They talk about us
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, shareholder disputes in Paris
Shareholder dispute lawyer in Paris, France: deadlock, challenge, exit
A general meeting that no longer takes place, accounts rejected, a resolution passed against the company's interest, a minority shareholder who blocks, a 50/50 shareholder who paralyses the business, a director to be removed, a shareholder who wants to leave or whom the others want to expel: in any shareholder dispute in France, the firm acts for majority and minority shareholders alike, for directors and for the company itself, in SARLs, SASs, SAs, SCIs and non-trading companies (sociétés civiles). Everything starts with the articles of association, the minutes and the time limits.
The firm can be reached 24/7. An action to annul a company decision is time-barred after two years from the day on which the nullity arises (Article 1844-14 of the French Civil Code (Code civil), in the version in force since 1 October 2025); for a decision taken before that date, the applicable time limit must be checked, as transitional law is not covered here. An action for compensation of the loss caused by an abuse of majority is time-barred after five years.
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order (ordonnance de protection) case abusively requested by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution provided for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, shows great empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete mastery of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, and who knows how to guide his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Urgent help 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, company law, shareholder disputes, challenges to company decisions and shareholder exits.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 31 October 2026.
Quick answer
Every company must be formed in the common interest of its shareholders and managed in its own corporate interest (Article 1833 of the French Civil Code). A shareholder dispute is settled first by the articles of association and the law: each shareholder's right to take part in collective decisions (Article 1844), the right to information, voting majorities, removal of directors. Where a shareholder uses their vote against the company's interest and for their sole advantage, the case law sanctions abuse of majority, abuse of minority or abuse of equality; the burden of proving the abuse lies on the party who alleges it. The court may appoint an agent to convene the general meeting, order a management audit (expertise de gestion), appoint a provisional administrator where the company is in peril, remove a manager for legitimate cause, and order dissolution where discord paralyses the functioning of the company (Article 1844-7, 5°). An exit is achieved through a transfer of shares, withdrawal from a non-trading company (Article 1869) or the exclusion clause of an SAS (Article L. 227-16 of the French Commercial Code (Code de commerce)), with the value set, in the event of disagreement and where the law or the articles so provide, by an expert (Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code). Kohen Avocats, in the 16th arrondissement of Paris, acts for majority and minority shareholders alike, and for directors. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A deadlocked general meeting, a decision to challenge, an exit to negotiate?
Understanding your situation
Shareholder disputes in Paris, explained
A company is formed "in the common interest of the shareholders" (Article 1833 of the French Civil Code). What to gather before acting, how the court characterises abuses, which measures unblock the company, and how a shareholder leaves, or is led to leave, without losing the value of their shares.
Key points
Before acting: four checks in any shareholder dispute
The articles of association, information rights, voting majorities and time limits shape the strategy before personalities do.
The company form and the articles of association: in an SAS (simplified joint-stock company), the articles set the conditions under which the company is managed (Article L. 227-5 of the French Commercial Code) and determine which decisions are taken collectively (Article L. 227-9); in an SARL (private limited company), the law itself sets the majorities and most of the shareholders' rights. A shareholders' agreement (pacte d'associés), where one exists, supplements the articles between its signatories: it is covered on our page shareholders' agreement lawyer.
The shareholder's right to information: in an SARL, the accounts and the management report are communicated before the general meeting, written questions may be put, and at any time the company documents for the last three financial years may be obtained (Article L. 223-26); in a non-trading company, the books and company documents may be consulted at least once a year and written questions must be answered within one month (Article 1855 of the Civil Code).
Voting majorities: in an SARL, ordinary decisions are taken by shareholders representing more than half of the shares, then, failing that and unless the articles provide otherwise, on a second consultation by a majority of the votes cast (Article L. 223-29 of the Commercial Code); amendments to the articles require a qualified majority (Article L. 223-30). Every shareholder has the right to take part in collective decisions (Article 1844 of the Civil Code).
Time limits: an action to annul a company decision is time-barred after two years from the day on which the nullity arises, subject to the specific rules on mergers, demergers and changes to share capital (Article 1844-14 of the Civil Code, in force since 1 October 2025; for an earlier decision, the applicable time limit must be checked, as transitional law is not covered here); a personal action for compensation is time-barred after five years from the day on which the holder of the right knew or should have known the facts enabling them to bring it (Article 2224).
The competent court depends on the company form. SARLs and joint-stock companies are commercial by virtue of their form, whatever their purpose (Article L. 210-1 of the Commercial Code), and the commercial courts hear disputes relating to commercial companies (Article L. 721-3). According to the Cour de cassation, "a dispute relating to a private limited company falls within the exclusive jurisdiction of the commercial courts" (our translation), even where the company carries on a non-commercial activity (Cass. com., 28 May 2025, No. 24-14.148). Only companies formed under Ordinance No. 2023-77 of 8 February 2023 on the practice of regulated liberal professions through companies fall within the civil courts, which also hear disputes between their shareholders (Article L. 721-5). Paris is one of the twelve courts designated as economic activity courts (tribunaux des activités économiques) for the pilot scheme under Article 26 of Law No. 2023-1059 of 20 November 2023, which began on 1 January 2025 for four years (Order of 5 July 2024 on the pilot scheme of the economic activity court, Articles 1 and 2): during this period, disputes within commercial jurisdiction are brought before the Paris economic activity court.
The file is built from the first signs of the dispute: up-to-date articles of association, shareholders' agreement, minutes of general meetings, annual accounts, management reports, written exchanges between shareholders, requests for documents left unanswered. If the shareholder cannot obtain the documents referred to in Article L. 238-1 of the Commercial Code, in particular those of Article L. 223-26 in an SARL, they may ask the president of the court, ruling in urgent proceedings (référé), to order the managers or directors, subject to a daily penalty (astreinte), to provide them, or to appoint an agent to do so; Article 1855 of the Civil Code, which is specific to non-trading companies, does not appear in the list in that provision.
A shareholder dispute may also have a criminal dimension where company funds have been misappropriated: see our article on shareholder disputes and criminal risk. For the overall strategy in company law, see our page company law lawyer.
Abuses
Abuse of majority, minority and equality: what the court requires
Each shareholder votes as they see fit, but the vote cannot be used to sacrifice the company's interest to the interest of a single camp.
Abuse of majority
A decision taken for the sole purpose of favouring the majority shareholders to the detriment of the minority, and not in line with the company's interest. The Cour de cassation upheld this characterisation for a transaction provided for in a conciliation agreement approved by the court, that agreement having been concluded, according to the court of appeal's sovereign assessment, on the basis of a inaccurate presentation of the company's financial situation.
Abuse of minority
A refusal by the minority shareholder that prevents a transaction essential to the company, for the sole purpose of favouring their own interests to the detriment of the other shareholders. Both conditions must be proved.
Abuse of equality
The negative vote of a 50/50 shareholder that prevents an essential transaction, for the sole purpose of favouring their own interests to the detriment of the other shareholder. It gives rise to the liability of its author (Article 1240 of the Civil Code).
Nullity
A company decision can only be annulled if the claimant shows that they have suffered prejudice, if the irregularity influenced the outcome of the decision and if its consequences for the corporate interest are not excessive (Article 1844-12-1 of the Civil Code). The action is time-barred after two years (Article 1844-14).
Compensation
The aggrieved shareholder may claim damages. An action for compensation of the loss caused by an abuse of majority is time-barred after five years, a time limit distinct from that of the action for nullity (Cass. com., 30 May 2018, No. 16-21.022).
The case law assesses abuse in light of the company's interest, not merely a shareholder's disappointment. The Cour de cassation upheld a court of appeal which had held that "the disputed transaction, which had been decided for the sole purpose of favouring the majority shareholders to the detriment of the minority shareholders, was not in line with the company's interest and consequently constituted an abuse of majority" (our translation), and this "notwithstanding the court's approval of the conciliation agreement" (our translation) (Cass. com., 26 November 2025, No. 24-15.730). The burden of proof, however, lies on the claimant: the Cour de cassation quashed a judgment which had criticised the company for failing to show that the removal of a co-manager was in the corporate interest, because "the burden of proving an abuse of majority lies on the party who alleges it" (our translation) (Cass. com., 7 May 2025, No. 23-21.508).
For abuse of minority, the Cour de cassation requires two elements: that "the minority shareholder's conduct is contrary to the general interest of the company in that it prevents a transaction essential to it" (our translation) and that it "stems from the sole purpose of favouring their own interests to the detriment of the other shareholders" (our translation) (Cass. com., 13 March 2024, No. 22-13.764). In the same case, it accepts that "a minority shareholder's refusal to amend the corporate purpose may be contrary to the general interest of the company" (our translation) (Cass. com., 13 March 2024, No. 22-13.764), but it quashed the judgment which had instructed an ad hoc agent (mandataire ad hoc) to vote for that amendment on behalf of the minority shareholder, as the judges had failed to draw the legal consequences of their own findings. For a 50/50 shareholder, it holds that "it constitutes an abuse of equality for a shareholder holding an equal share to prevent, through their negative vote, a transaction essential to the company, for the sole purpose of favouring their own interests to the detriment of the other shareholder" (our translation), and that a unanimity rule in the articles of association is not enough to exclude it (Cass. com., 21 June 2023, No. 21-23.298).
Since 1 October 2025, the Civil Code has provided that the nullity of company decisions can only result from a breach of a mandatory provision of company law, other than the last paragraph of Article 1833, or from a ground of nullity applicable to contracts in general, and that "unless the law provides otherwise, a breach of the articles of association does not constitute a ground of nullity" (our translation) (Article 1844-10). Under former Article L. 235-1 of the Commercial Code, in the version applicable in French Polynesia, the Cour de cassation held, subject to contractual arrangements permitted by a mandatory provision, that "failure to comply with the provisions of the articles of association is not sanctioned by nullity" (our translation) (Cass. com., 7 May 2025, No. 23-21.508). See also our articles on abuse of majority in an SAS and on abuse of minority and the ad hoc agent.
Both sides
You are a majority shareholder, or you are a minority shareholder
The same provisions read differently depending on the share of the capital you hold.
You are a majority shareholder or a director
- Document the corporate interest of each decision: reports, figures, complete minutes.
- Respect the shareholders' rights to information and to be convened, so as not to offer any ground for nullity.
- When faced with a deadlock, establish the essential nature of the transaction and the minority shareholder's personal purpose.
- In defence, require the claimant to prove the abuse they allege.
You are a minority or 50/50 shareholder
- Exercise your rights to documents and to ask questions in writing, and keep the answers or the silences.
- Request that a general meeting be held, or that the court appoint an agent to convene it.
- Apply for a management audit on a specific transaction before bringing proceedings on the merits.
- Challenge a decision within the two-year time limit, and quantify your personal loss.
In an SARL, one or more shareholders holding half of the shares, or one tenth of the shares if they represent at least one tenth of the shareholders, may request that a general meeting be held, and any shareholder may ask the court to appoint an agent to convene it and set its agenda (Article L. 223-27 of the Commercial Code). A minority shareholder who wishes to act on behalf of the company against a manager at fault has the derivative action (action sociale), the damages from which are awarded to the company (Article L. 223-22 of the Commercial Code and Article 1843-5 of the Civil Code). A decision taken by the majority remains valid until its author is shown to have committed an abuse: the Cour de cassation points out that "the burden of proving an abuse of majority lies on the party who alleges it" (our translation) (Cass. com., 7 May 2025, No. 23-21.508).
The points the firm examines in every case:
The court
Unblocking the company: the measures the court can order
From a simple order to disclose documents to a provisional administrator, each measure has its own conditions.
General meeting and accounts
In an SARL, the accounts are submitted to the shareholders within six months of the year end; failing that, any interested person may apply to the president of the court in urgent proceedings (référé) for an order requiring the managers to convene the general meeting, or for the appointment of an agent to do so (Article L. 223-26 of the Commercial Code).
Ad hoc agent
The court may appoint an agent (mandataire ad hoc) with a specific task, for example convening the general meeting and having the accounts approved: for an SCI whose shareholder could obtain neither a general meeting nor the accounting documents, the Cour de cassation did not require proof of imminent danger.
Management audit
In an SARL, shareholders representing at least one tenth of the share capital may ask the court for an expert report on one or more management transactions (Article L. 223-37); in an SA (public limited company), the threshold is 5% of the capital, after written questions have gone without a satisfactory answer for one month (Article L. 225-231).
Provisional administrator
An exceptional measure that removes management powers from the directors: according to the Paris Court of Appeal, it requires proof that the normal functioning of the company is impossible and that it faces imminent danger.
Removal
The manager of an SARL may be removed by the shareholders, a removal decided without just cause possibly giving rise to damages, and by the courts for legitimate cause at the request of any shareholder (Article L. 223-25); the same rule applies to the manager of a non-trading company (Article 1851 of the Civil Code).
Dissolution
A last resort: early dissolution ordered by the court at the request of a shareholder for just cause, in particular in the event of "discord between shareholders paralysing the functioning of the company" (our translation) (Article 1844-7, 5°, of the Civil Code).
An ad hoc agent does not require the same seriousness as a provisional administrator. The Cour de cassation upheld a court of appeal which, having found discord, the absence of any general meeting despite a shareholder's request and her lack of access to the accounting documents, appointed an ad hoc agent for six months "without being required to carry out an irrelevant inquiry into circumstances making the normal functioning of the company impossible and threatening it with imminent danger" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 21 June 2018, No. 17-13.212). For a provisional administrator, by contrast, the Paris Court of Appeal points out that the appointment "is an exceptional measure which requires proof of circumstances making the normal functioning of the company impossible and threatening it with imminent danger" (our translation); it upheld such an appointment for an SCI whose property was subject to a seizure, a situation it held to be "the direct consequence of a deep discord that had set in between the shareholders" (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 2, 16 May 2024, No. 24/00543). In that case, the court ruled on the basis of Article 835 of the French Code of Civil Procedure (Code de procédure civile); before the commercial court, the president has a similar power (Article 873 of the same code).
A management audit is not the same as a pre-action measure of inquiry under Article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The Cour de cassation quashed a judgment which had ordered, on the latter basis, an expert assessment whose measures "were in reality aimed only at providing the claimant minority shareholders with information on management transactions, which as such fall within the mechanism provided for in Article L. 225-231 of the Commercial Code" (our translation) (Cass. com., 11 September 2024, No. 22-24.160). The legal basis must therefore be chosen before the application is filed.
In an SAS, removal is governed by the articles of association. The Cour de cassation holds that the articles set "in particular the terms for removing its directors" (our translation) and that "while a decision of the shareholders may supplement the articles on this point, it cannot derogate from them, even if it was taken unanimously" (our translation) (Cass. com., 9 July 2025, No. 24-10.428): in that case, the managing director (directeur général) lost his claim for compensation based on a collective decision contrary to the articles, but kept the €30,000 awarded for a removal held to be humiliating and abrupt.
The firm applies to the judge hearing urgent applications (juge des référés) or to the court ruling on the merits depending on the measure sought, and at each stage proposes the narrowest remit that will unblock the company. See our articles on the ousted shareholder of a deadlocked company, on management audits in an SARL, on Article 145 and the management audit and on removal of the president of an SAS.
The exit
Leaving the company, or making a shareholder leave
Withdrawal, buy-back, exclusion, dissolution or negotiated agreement: the value of the shares remains the central issue.
In a non-trading company, a shareholder may withdraw under the conditions set by the articles or, failing that, with the unanimous consent of the other shareholders, and withdrawal may also be authorised for just cause by a court decision; the shareholder is entitled to reimbursement of the value of their shares (Article 1869 of the Civil Code).
Where the law refers to Article 1843-4, for example when approval of a transferee is refused in an SARL or on withdrawal from a non-trading company, or where the articles of association provide for a transfer or buy-back without the value being determined or determinable, the value of the shares is set, in the event of disagreement, by an expert appointed by the parties or, failing agreement, by the president of the competent judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) or commercial court, ruling under the accelerated procedure on the merits with no right of appeal; the expert applies the valuation rules provided for in the articles or in any agreement binding the parties (Article 1843-4).
In an SARL, if the company refuses to approve a third-party transferee, the shareholders must, within three months, buy the shares or have them bought at a price set in accordance with Article 1843-4, unless the transferor withdraws, and this period may be extended by the court by no more than six months; the transferor may rely on this only if they have held the shares for at least two years, except in the case of succession, liquidation of the marital community or a gift to a spouse, ascendant or descendant (Article L. 223-14 of the Commercial Code).
In an SAS, the articles of association may provide that a shareholder can be required to transfer their shares, and suspend their non-financial rights until the transfer has taken place (Article L. 227-16).
Mediation may be agreed by mutual consent, outside or during proceedings (Article 1536 of the Code of Civil Procedure); it does not prevent the court from ordering a measure of inquiry or a provisional or protective measure (Article 1537).
Judicial dissolution for discord requires discord that paralyses the functioning of the company: a disagreement, however deep, is not enough. Article 1844-7, 5°, of the Civil Code covers other just causes, including a shareholder's failure to perform their obligations.
The SAS exclusion clause has its limits. According to the Cour de cassation, while the articles of association may provide for the exclusion of a shareholder by a collective decision, "any provision of the exclusion clause whose purpose or effect is to deprive the shareholder whose exclusion is proposed of the right to vote on that proposal is deemed unwritten" (our translation) (Cass. com., 29 May 2024, No. 22-13.158). Withdrawal from a non-trading company, for its part, "is distinct from the compulsory withdrawal provided for in Article 1860 of the Civil Code" (our translation), and the rule that a withdrawing shareholder only loses that status upon reimbursement of their shares "is merely a default rule subject to the shareholders' intention" (our translation) and may be set aside by the articles (Cass. 3e civ., 24 September 2026, No. 24-17.185). The date on which shareholder status is lost is therefore to be found first in the articles.
Dissolution remains exceptional. It was upheld for a professional resource-sharing company (société civile de moyens), the court of appeal having "in its sovereign assessment inferred that the discord between the shareholders and the loss of any affectio societatis caused the paralysis of the company's functioning" (our translation) (Cass. com., 28 May 2026, No. 25-14.596). It was refused for a non-trading company whose capital was split into two equal blocks, the manager holding half of the shares, because "the provisions of the articles of association of the company HFP made it possible to adopt the resolutions necessary for its proper functioning" (our translation), in particular through the manager's casting vote, and because the shareholders had a right of withdrawal: the judges were entitled to infer "that the discord between the shareholders did not paralyse its functioning" (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 18 January 2023, No. 19-24.671).
A negotiated transfer of shares often remains the quickest exit: see our page share transfer lawyer. See also our articles on the exclusion clause in an SAS, on excluding a shareholder from an SARL or a non-trading company, on the Article 1843-4 expert and on affectio societatis and dissolution.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the provisions in force and on verified decisions.
What does a lawyer do in a shareholder dispute in France?
First, the lawyer characterises the dispute on the basis of the documents: company form, articles of association, shareholders' agreement, minutes, accounts, exchanges between shareholders. The same quarrel does not open up the same rights depending on whether the company is an SARL, an SAS or a non-trading company. In an SAS, the articles set the conditions under which the company is managed (Article L. 227-5 of the Commercial Code); in an SARL, the law sets the majorities, the removal of the manager and the right to information (Articles L. 223-25, L. 223-26 and L. 223-29).
The lawyer then chooses the narrowest route that solves the problem. A written request for documents, an order obtained in urgent proceedings, the appointment of an agent to convene the general meeting or a management audit is often enough to restore the functioning of the company. Where the decision has already been taken, it must be challenged within the two-year time limit of Article 1844-14 of the Civil Code, and damages must be claimed within the five-year time limit of Article 2224.
Finally, the lawyer prepares the exit, which is often the real outcome of the dispute: negotiated transfer, withdrawal, buy-back at a value set by an expert, or, failing that, dissolution. The firm acts for majority and minority shareholders alike, for directors and for the company, and can propose mediation where dialogue remains possible.
Which court has jurisdiction over a shareholder dispute in France?
For a commercial company, the commercial court, and in Paris, during the pilot scheme that began on 1 January 2025, the economic activity court (tribunal des activités économiques). The commercial courts hear disputes relating to commercial companies (Article L. 721-3 of the Commercial Code), and SARLs and joint-stock companies are commercial by virtue of their form, whatever their purpose (Article L. 210-1).
The Cour de cassation infers from this an exclusive jurisdiction: "a dispute relating to a private limited company falls within the exclusive jurisdiction of the commercial courts" (our translation), even where the company carries on a non-commercial activity and the claimant shareholder is not a trader (Cass. com., 28 May 2025, No. 24-14.148). In that case, a veterinary surgeon who was a shareholder was challenging her removal as manager: the court of appeal had found the judicial court competent, and the Cour de cassation declared the commercial court competent.
The same decision recalls the exception for regulated liberal professions: disputes involving a company formed as a professional practice company (société d'exercice libéral) fall, "pursuant to Article L. 721-5 of the Commercial Code, within the jurisdiction of the civil courts alone" (our translation) (Cass. com., 28 May 2025, No. 24-14.148). The exception only applies to a company formed under Ordinance No. 2023-77 of 8 February 2023, for which Article L. 721-5 also reserves disputes between shareholders to the civil courts, unless the articles contain an arbitration clause; an ordinary SARL carrying on a liberal profession remains within commercial jurisdiction, as in the case cited. In Paris, disputes within commercial jurisdiction are brought before the economic activity court, the Paris court having been designated for the pilot scheme which began on 1 January 2025 for four years (Order of 5 July 2024 on the pilot scheme of the economic activity court). For non-trading companies, the court is not determined by Article L. 721-3, and this page does not cover that point.
Urgent measures are sought from the president of the competent court, ruling in urgent proceedings (référé): order to disclose documents (Article L. 238-1 of the Commercial Code), protective measures (Articles 835 and 873 of the Code of Civil Procedure).
What is abuse of majority in France, and how do you prove it?
It is the use of the majority vote against the company's interest, for the sole purpose of favouring the majority shareholders to the detriment of the minority. A company must be formed in the common interest of its shareholders and managed in its corporate interest (Article 1833 of the Civil Code): a decision that sacrifices that interest for the benefit of one camp is wrongful.
The Cour de cassation upheld a court of appeal which had found that "the disputed transaction, which had been decided for the sole purpose of favouring the majority shareholders to the detriment of the minority shareholders, was not in line with the company's interest and consequently constituted an abuse of majority" (our translation); the conciliation agreement providing for the transaction, a capital reduction followed by a capital increase partly reserved to certain parties, had been concluded on the basis of a inaccurate presentation of the company's financial situation, and its approval by the court made no difference (Cass. com., 26 November 2025, No. 24-15.730).
The burden of proof lies on the minority shareholder. The Cour de cassation said so when quashing a judgment which had annulled the general meeting that removed a co-manager, on the ground that the company had not shown that the removal was in the corporate interest: "the burden of proving an abuse of majority lies on the party who alleges it" (our translation) (Cass. com., 7 May 2025, No. 23-21.508). The case is therefore built on documents: accounts, trends in dividends and remuneration, agreements with the majority shareholder's companies, chronology of votes.
The aggrieved shareholder may seek annulment of the decision, if the ground relied on falls within Article 1844-10 of the Civil Code and under the conditions of Article 1844-12-1, a point which the sources reviewed here do not yet clarify for abuse of majority since the reform, and compensation for their loss, the action for which is time-barred after five years (Cass. com., 30 May 2018, No. 16-21.022). See our article on abuse of majority in an SAS.
A minority shareholder is blocking a decision: what can be done?
First check that the minority shareholder really has a blocking right. In an SARL, amendments to the articles of association require a qualified majority: three quarters of the shares or, for companies formed after the publication of the Law of 2 August 2005, two thirds of the shares held by the shareholders present or represented, with a quorum (Article L. 223-30 of the Commercial Code). In an SAS, the articles set the majorities (Article L. 227-9). A sufficient minority can therefore prevent a capital increase or a change to the corporate purpose.
A refusal is only wrongful if it is abusive. According to the Cour de cassation, abuse of minority requires proof that "the minority shareholder's conduct is contrary to the general interest of the company in that it prevents a transaction essential to it" (our translation) and that it "stems from the sole purpose of favouring their own interests to the detriment of the other shareholders" (our translation) (Cass. com., 13 March 2024, No. 22-13.764). In that case, the Court accepted that a refusal to amend the corporate purpose could be contrary to the company's interest, but partially quashed the judgment which had instructed an ad hoc agent to vote for that amendment on behalf of the minority shareholder, as the judges had failed to draw the consequences of their own finding that the termination of the contracts by the managers required an amendment to the articles falling outside their powers.
The response lies in a file that demonstrates the essential nature of the transaction and the minority shareholder's personal purpose: financing plan, alternatives proposed, exchanges, reasons given. The firm also attempts negotiation, as a blocking minority shareholder is often looking for an exit at a price. See our article on abuse of minority and the ad hoc agent.
Deadlocked 50/50 company: what are the solutions?
A company owned in equal shares is the most exposed to deadlock, since no shareholder holds a majority alone. Several levers exist before dissolution.
The first is abuse of equality. The Cour de cassation holds that "it constitutes an abuse of equality for a shareholder holding an equal share to prevent, through their negative vote, a transaction essential to the company, for the sole purpose of favouring their own interests to the detriment of the other shareholder" (our translation); it quashed a court of appeal decision which had ruled out abuse "on grounds drawn from the unanimity rule which were not capable of excluding the existence of an abuse of equality" (our translation) (Cass. com., 21 June 2023, No. 21-23.298). The abuse gives rise to the liability of its author under Article 1240 of the Civil Code.
The second lies in the court's measures: an agent to convene the general meeting (Article L. 223-27 of the Commercial Code for an SARL), an ad hoc agent, a provisional administrator where the company is in peril. The third lies in the articles of association themselves: in an equally held company, the Cour de cassation upheld the refusal to dissolve because the articles gave the manager a casting vote at general meetings and provided for a right of withdrawal, so that "the discord between the shareholders did not paralyse its functioning" (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 18 January 2023, No. 19-24.671).
Dissolution for just cause (Article 1844-7, 5°, of the Civil Code) remains the last resort. Before that, the firm seeks a negotiated exit for one of the two shareholders, made easier by the exit clauses of the shareholders' agreement where they exist. See our article on deadlock clauses in shareholders' agreements.
Can a general meeting resolution be annulled in France, and within what time limit?
Yes, but since 1 October 2025 the Civil Code has strictly limited nullity. The nullity of company decisions can only result from a breach of a mandatory provision of company law, with the exception of the last paragraph of Article 1833, or from one of the grounds of nullity applicable to contracts in general; "unless the law provides otherwise, a breach of the articles of association does not constitute a ground of nullity" (our translation) (Article 1844-10 of the Civil Code). Under former Article L. 235-1 of the Commercial Code, in the version applicable in French Polynesia, the Cour de cassation held, subject to contractual arrangements permitted by a mandatory provision, that "failure to comply with the provisions of the articles of association is not sanctioned by nullity" (our translation) (Cass. com., 7 May 2025, No. 23-21.508).
Even where a ground of nullity exists, the court will only annul the decision if the claimant shows that they have suffered prejudice resulting from an infringement of the interest protected by the rule relied on, if the irregularity influenced the outcome of the decision, and if the consequences of nullity for the corporate interest are not excessive (Article 1844-12-1). The action is extinguished if the ground of nullity has ceased to exist on the day the court rules at first instance (Article 1844-11), and the court may set a time limit for the nullity to be cured (Article 1844-13).
The time limit is short: an action to annul a company decision is time-barred after two years from the day on which the nullity arises, subject to the specific rules on mergers, demergers and changes to share capital (Article 1844-14). For a decision taken before the reform, the law applicable in time must be checked case by case. See our article on annulment of an SCI general meeting for failure to convene.
The manager refuses to disclose the accounts: what remedies are available?
In an SARL, the articles of association cannot restrict the right to information. The annual accounts and the management report are sent to the shareholders before the general meeting, which must rule within six months of the year end, and a shareholder may at any time obtain the company documents for the last three financial years; any clause to the contrary is deemed unwritten (Article L. 223-26 of the Commercial Code). A shareholder who is not a manager may also, twice per financial year, ask written questions about any fact likely to jeopardise the continuity of the business (Article L. 223-36). In a non-trading company, a shareholder may consult the books and company documents at least once a year, and ask written questions which must be answered within one month (Article 1855 of the Civil Code).
Faced with a refusal, a shareholder in an SARL may ask the president of the court, ruling in urgent proceedings, to order the managers, subject to a daily penalty, to provide the documents, or to appoint an agent to do so (Article L. 238-1 of the Commercial Code); that provision covers in particular the documents of Article L. 223-26, not those of Article 1855 of the Civil Code, and a shareholder in a non-trading company relies on the latter article and on the managers' obligation to account for their management at least once a year (Article 1856). If the general meeting has not been held within six months, any interested person may obtain an order requiring the managers to convene it or have an agent appointed to do so (Article L. 223-26).
Where the deadlock has lasted for years, the court can go further. The Cour de cassation upheld the appointment of an ad hoc agent tasked with obtaining the company documents, drawing up the reports and convening the general meeting to approve several financial years, for the benefit of a shareholder who had had no access to any accounting document, the court of appeal having ruled "without being required to carry out an irrelevant inquiry into circumstances making the normal functioning of the company impossible and threatening it with imminent danger" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 21 June 2018, No. 17-13.212).
How do you obtain a management audit in France?
A management audit allows minority shareholders to obtain an expert's report on one or more specific management transactions: an agreement with a company owned by the director, a disposal of assets, invoicing for services. It does not cover management as a whole.
In an SARL, one or more shareholders representing at least one tenth of the share capital may apply to the court for it; the decision sets the scope of the experts' task and powers, and may order the company to bear their fees (Article L. 223-37 of the Commercial Code). In an SA, the threshold is 5% of the capital, and the shareholders must first put written questions to the chairman of the board of directors or to the management board; only if no answer, or no satisfactory answer, is given within one month may they apply for the audit in urgent proceedings (Article L. 225-231). Article L. 227-1 applies the rules governing public limited companies to the SAS, insofar as they are compatible with its own provisions, apart from a list of exceptions which does not include Article L. 225-231.
The legal basis must be chosen carefully. The Cour de cassation quashed a judgment which had ordered, on the basis of Article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure, measures that "were in reality aimed only at providing the claimant minority shareholders with information on management transactions, which as such fall within the mechanism provided for in Article L. 225-231 of the Commercial Code" (our translation) (Cass. com., 11 September 2024, No. 22-24.160). Article 145 remains available where the aim is to preserve or establish evidence of facts on which the outcome of a future dispute may depend. See our article on management audits in an SARL.
How do you remove the manager of an SARL or the president of an SAS?
In an SARL, the manager is removed by a decision of the shareholders representing more than half of the shares or, failing that and unless the articles provide otherwise, on a second consultation by a majority of the votes cast, and the articles may provide for a higher majority; if the removal is decided without just cause, it may give rise to damages. The manager may also be removed by the courts for legitimate cause at the request of any shareholder (Articles L. 223-25 and L. 223-29 of the Commercial Code). The manager of a non-trading company is subject to similar rules, unless the articles provide otherwise (Article 1851 of the Civil Code). In an SA, the managing director may be removed at any time by the board of directors, and a removal decided without just cause may give rise to damages, unless they also chair the board (Article L. 225-55 of the Commercial Code).
In an SAS, everything depends on the articles of association, which set the conditions under which the company is managed (Article L. 227-5). The Cour de cassation holds that "while a decision of the shareholders may supplement the articles on this point, it cannot derogate from them, even if it was taken unanimously" (our translation) (Cass. com., 9 July 2025, No. 24-10.428). The removed managing director therefore did not obtain the compensation provided for by a collective decision contrary to the articles; he did, however, keep €30,000 in damages for a removal held to be humiliating and abrupt.
A removal must be prepared: reasons set out in writing, proper notice of the meeting, a discussion allowing the director to explain themselves where the articles or the law require it. Conversely, a director who has been removed examines the conditions of the removal and the just cause relied on. See our article on removal of the president of an SAS.
Can a shareholder be excluded from a French company?
In an SAS, yes, if the articles of association provide for it. The articles may provide, under the conditions they set, that a shareholder can be required to transfer their shares, and suspend their non-financial rights until the transfer has taken place (Article L. 227-16 of the Commercial Code). They may also provide for the exclusion of a corporate shareholder whose control changes (Article L. 227-17).
The clause must respect the voting right of the shareholder concerned. According to the Cour de cassation, while the articles of an SAS may provide for the exclusion of a shareholder by a collective decision of the shareholders, "any provision of the exclusion clause whose purpose or effect is to deprive the shareholder whose exclusion is proposed of the right to vote on that proposal is deemed unwritten" (our translation) (Cass. com., 29 May 2024, No. 22-13.158). It thus quashed the judgment which had refused to annul the exclusion of a shareholder deprived of that vote, citing Articles 1844 and 1844-10 of the Civil Code and L. 227-16 of the Commercial Code. An excluded shareholder may also challenge the price of their shares: where the articles provide for a transfer without the value being determined or determinable, it is set, in the event of disagreement, by an expert (Article 1843-4, II, of the Civil Code).
For SARLs and non-trading companies, the provisions cited on this page do not organise any comparable exclusion; the firm examines the articles of association before taking any step, and the exit is most often achieved through negotiation, a transfer of shares or, in extreme cases, dissolution. See our articles on the exclusion clause in an SAS and on exclusion from an SARL or a non-trading company.
How do you leave a company when you are in dispute with the other shareholders?
First, by transferring your shares. In an SARL, a transfer to a third party requires the approval of a majority of the shareholders representing at least half of the shares; if the company refuses, the shareholders must, within three months, buy the shares or have them bought at a price set in accordance with Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code, unless the transferor withdraws, provided that the transferor has held the shares for at least two years, except in the case of succession, liquidation of the marital community or a gift to a spouse, ascendant or descendant (Article L. 223-14 of the Commercial Code). In a non-trading company, shares may only be transferred with the approval of all the shareholders, unless the articles provide otherwise, and transfers to the transferor's ascendants or descendants are not subject to this requirement unless the articles so provide (Article 1861 of the Civil Code).
Next, by withdrawal, which is specific to non-trading companies. A shareholder may withdraw under the conditions set by the articles or, failing that, with the unanimous consent of the others, or for just cause by a court decision, and is entitled to reimbursement of the value of their shares, set, failing agreement, in accordance with Article 1843-4 (Article 1869). The Cour de cassation stresses that this voluntary withdrawal "is distinct from the compulsory withdrawal provided for in Article 1860 of the Civil Code" (our translation), and that the rule that a shareholder only loses that status upon reimbursement "is merely a default rule subject to the shareholders' intention" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 24 September 2026, No. 24-17.185).
Finally, the price is open to discussion. The Article 1843-4 expert is appointed by the parties or, failing agreement, by the president of the competent judicial court or commercial court, who rules with no right of appeal; the expert applies the valuation rules set out in the articles or in agreements between the parties. See our page share transfer lawyer and our article on the Article 1843-4 expert.
When will a French court dissolve a company for shareholder discord?
When the discord paralyses the functioning of the company. A company comes to an end through early dissolution ordered by the court at the request of a shareholder for just cause, in particular where a shareholder fails to perform their obligations, or in the event of "discord between shareholders paralysing the functioning of the company" (our translation) (Article 1844-7, 5°, of the Civil Code). Discord alone is not enough: it is the paralysis that must be proved.
The Cour de cassation upheld the dissolution of a professional resource-sharing company in which general meetings could no longer be held normally and a shareholder had been blocked for five years in his plan to leave, the court of appeal having "in its sovereign assessment inferred that the discord between the shareholders and the loss of any affectio societatis caused the paralysis of the company's functioning" (our translation) (Cass. com., 28 May 2026, No. 25-14.596).
By contrast, it upheld the refusal to dissolve a non-trading company whose capital was split into two equal blocks, the manager holding 50% of the shares and two other shareholders 25% each, because "the provisions of the articles of association of the company HFP made it possible to adopt the resolutions necessary for its proper functioning" (our translation), thanks to the manager's casting vote, and because the shareholders had a right of withdrawal: the court of appeal was entitled to infer "that the discord between the shareholders did not paralyse its functioning and to dismiss the application for dissolution" (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 18 January 2023, No. 19-24.671).
Dissolution leads to liquidation and, often, the sale of the assets. The firm assesses its consequences before applying for it, and opposes it where the client has an interest in the company continuing. See our article on dissolving a family SCI.
Is mediation possible between shareholders in France?
Yes, at any time. Outside or during proceedings, persons in dispute may, by mutual agreement, attempt to settle it amicably with the help of a mediator (Article 1536 of the Code of Civil Procedure). The court hearing the dispute may also, even in urgent proceedings and after obtaining the parties' agreement, order mediation, which may cover all or part of the dispute (Article 1534).
Mediation does not disarm the shareholder: recourse to a contractual amicable dispute resolution method does not prevent the court from ordering a measure of inquiry or a provisional or protective measure (Article 1537). The limitation period is suspended from the day on which, after the dispute has arisen, the parties agree to use mediation or, failing a written agreement, from the first meeting, and the period starts running again for a duration which cannot be less than six months once the mediation has ended (Article 2238 of the Civil Code).
The agreement reached can be made enforceable through approval by the court (Article 1543 of the Code of Civil Procedure). In a shareholder dispute, mediation most often concerns the exit of one of the shareholders and the price of their shares: the firm prepares the valuation, assists the client at the meetings and drafts the settlement agreement. Mediation and exit clauses in shareholders' agreements are covered on our page shareholders' agreement lawyer.
What are a lawyer's fees in a shareholder dispute in France?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs. The agreement specifies the amount or the method of calculating the fees for the foreseeable work, as well as the expected costs and disbursements. The fixed fee is set after reading the relevant documents: articles of association, shareholders' agreement, minutes, accounts, exchanges between shareholders.
The firm prefers a fixed fee per stage: analysis of the articles and the situation, request for documents or formal notice, urgent application to obtain documents or the appointment of an agent, application for a management audit, challenge to a general meeting decision, liability action, exit negotiation or mediation, proceedings on the merits, appeal. Expert fees and judicial officer (commissaire de justice) costs are added to the fees. Any new engagement is covered by an amendment, with no unexpected invoicing.
For a first opinion on the documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, via the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 31 October 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles 1832, 1833 and 1844 of the French Civil Code: company contract, common interest and corporate interest, participation in collective decisions
- Articles 1844-10, 1844-11, 1844-12-1, 1844-13 and 1844-14 of the Civil Code: nullity of company decisions, conditions, regularisation, two-year limitation period
- Articles 1240 and 2224 of the Civil Code: liability, limitation period for the action for compensation
- Articles 1843-5, 1851, 1855 and 1856 of the Civil Code: derivative action, manager of a non-trading company, shareholders' right to information
- Article 1844-7 of the Civil Code: dissolution for just cause and discord
- Articles 1843-4, 1861 and 1869 of the Civil Code: expert valuation of shares, approval of transferees, withdrawal of a shareholder from a non-trading company
- Article 2238 of the Civil Code: suspension of the limitation period during mediation
- Articles L. 210-1, L. 721-3 and L. 721-5 of the French Commercial Code: commercial nature by form, jurisdiction of the commercial court, professional practice companies
- Order of 5 July 2024 on the pilot scheme of the economic activity court: Paris economic activity court, pilot scheme from 1 January 2025
- Articles L. 223-14, L. 223-22, L. 223-25, L. 223-26, L. 223-27, L. 223-29, L. 223-30, L. 223-36 and L. 223-37 of the Commercial Code: SARL: approval of transferees, liability and removal of the manager, information, general meetings, majorities, management audit
- Articles L. 225-55 and L. 225-231 of the Commercial Code: SA: removal of the managing director, management audit
- Articles L. 227-1, L. 227-5, L. 227-9, L. 227-16 and L. 227-17 of the Commercial Code: SAS: application of the SA rules, management, collective decisions, exclusion
- Article L. 238-1 of the Commercial Code: order to disclose documents in urgent proceedings
- Articles 145, 835 and 873 of the French Code of Civil Procedure: pre-action measure of inquiry, urgent proceedings
- Articles 1534, 1536, 1537 and 1543 of the Code of Civil Procedure: court-ordered and contractual mediation, approval of the agreement
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. com., 26 November 2025, No. 24-15.730: abuse of majority despite a court-approved conciliation agreement
- Cass. com., 7 May 2025, No. 23-21.508: burden of proving abuse of majority, breach of the articles without nullity
- Cass. com., 30 May 2018, No. 16-21.022: five-year limitation period for the action for compensation
- Cass. com., 13 March 2024, No. 22-13.764: conditions for abuse of minority
- Cass. com., 21 June 2023, No. 21-23.298: abuse of equality
- Cass. 3e civ., 21 June 2018, No. 17-13.212: ad hoc agent without imminent danger (SCI)
- CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 2, 16 May 2024, No. 24/00543: provisional administrator, an exceptional measure
- Cass. com., 11 September 2024, No. 22-24.160: management audit and the Article 145 measure of inquiry
- Cass. com., 9 July 2025, No. 24-10.428: removal of SAS directors according to the articles
- Cass. com., 29 May 2024, No. 22-13.158: SAS exclusion clause and the voting right of the shareholder concerned
- Cass. 3e civ., 24 September 2026, No. 24-17.185: withdrawal of a shareholder from a non-trading company
- Cass. com., 28 May 2026, No. 25-14.596: dissolution for discord paralysing the company
- Cass. 1re civ., 18 January 2023, No. 19-24.671: dissolution refused, functioning ensured by the articles
- Cass. com., 28 May 2025, No. 24-14.148: exclusive jurisdiction of the commercial court, exception for liberal professions
Further reading
A deadlocked company, a decision to challenge, an exit to negotiate?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the articles of association, the shareholders' agreement if there is one, the latest minutes and accounts, and your exchanges with your fellow shareholders: Hassan Kohen, lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, examines the rights, majorities and time limits, then tells you the appropriate route: request for documents, urgent application, management audit, challenge to a decision, removal, negotiated exit or dissolution.