Kohen Avocats, challenges against CROUS decisions in Paris
CROUS Lawyer in Paris: Grant (Bourse) Refused or Repayable, Housing
Means-tested CROUS grant (bourse CROUS) refused, grant level disputed, repayment order, refusal of readmission or eviction from a university residence: as a CROUS lawyer in Paris, the firm challenges decisions of the CROUS and the rectorate, from the request for reconsideration (recours gracieux) to the administrative court.
Available 24/7. A decision of the CROUS or of the rector (recteur) can be challenged before the administrative court within two months of its notification (Article R. 421-1 of the French Code of Administrative Justice, code de justice administrative): send it to us as soon as you receive it, with proof of its date.
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received outstanding support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order (ordonnance de protection) case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the outcome of my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with a great deal of empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, kind and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Avocat at the Paris Bar — challenges against decisions of the CROUS and the rectorate before the administrative court.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 12 October 2026.
Quick answer
A CROUS lawyer in Paris deals with three types of decision: the refusal or reduction of a means-tested grant (bourse sur critères sociaux), suspension followed by a repayment order (ordre de reversement), meaning repayment of the grant, and disputes over housing in a university residence, from refusal of readmission to eviction. These decisions are taken by the rector or by the CROUS, a public administrative body (établissement public administratif): they are challenged before the administrative court within two months of their notification (Article R. 421-1 of the French Code of Administrative Justice). A request for reconsideration (recours gracieux) or a hierarchical appeal (recours hiérarchique) lodged within that time limit interrupts it. The challenge is prepared from documents: tax assessment notices, the judgment setting maintenance (pension alimentaire), attendance records, medical certificates. Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th, reviews your case on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A refusal notice, a repayment order or a letter from the residence to send us?
Understanding your situation
CROUS disputes in Paris, explained
Means-tested higher education grants are governed by Article D. 821-1 of the French Education Code (code de l’éducation) and by an annual circular (circulaire); the 2026-2027 circular was published in the Bulletin officiel of 26 February 2026. Housing in a university residence is a matter for the CROUS, a public administrative body. In both cases, the competent court is the administrative court. Here is what you need to know, step by step.
Key points
CROUS grant and housing: who decides, which court reviews
The rules that govern any challenge to a CROUS decision.
The means-tested grant is awarded according to conditions of study, age, qualifications, nationality and resources set by the minister (Article D. 821-1 of the French Education Code). The CROUS processes the application; under the circular of 26 February 2026, the final decision is taken by the rector of the host academic region (région académique).
The refusal of a grant, its withdrawal or the reduction of its amount must state reasons and indicate the available remedies and time limits (Article L. 211-2 of the French Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration (code des relations entre le public et l’administration) and the 2026-2027 circular).
The CROUS is a public administrative body that allocates its accommodation by unilateral decision: a dispute arising from a request to evict a student from a university residence falls within the jurisdiction of the administrative courts.
The administrative court must be seised within two months of notification (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice). A request for reconsideration or a hierarchical appeal lodged within that time limit interrupts it (Article L. 411-2 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration).
The Jurisdiction Disputes Tribunal (Tribunal des conflits), ruling on accommodation in the « Fontaine au Roi » residence in Paris 11th, held « that even where the university residence cannot be regarded as part of the public domain, any request by the CROUS for eviction seeks to ensure the normal functioning and continuity of the public administrative service for which it is responsible » (our translation) (Tribunal des conflits, 12 February 2018, No. C4112). For a grant, the decision is taken by the rectoral authority; for housing, by the director of the CROUS. The firm first identifies the exact author of the decision, because it determines who receives the request for reconsideration and which court has jurisdiction.
Grant
CROUS grant refused or to be repaid: two distinct situations
An initial refusal and a repayment order are not challenged with the same arguments or the same documents.
Refusal or disputed grant level
- Resources: eligibility is assessed by reference to the resources of the parent or parents supporting the student; a single parent, a separation or maintenance set by the court changes the basis of assessment.
- Grant entitlements: seven at most over the whole course of studies; the 3rd entitlement requires 60 validated ECTS credits, the 4th and 5th 120 credits, the 6th and 7th 180 credits.
- Review: possible if resources for year N-1 fell by at least 15% compared with N-2, on a request sent no later than 1 March.
Suspension and repayment order
- Grounds: course enrolment (inscription pédagogique) not completed by 31 October, dropping out, work-study (alternance), switching to a programme not approved for grants, lack of attendance or absence from examinations.
- Safeguards: suspension notified, the month already begun is paid, prior adversarial procedure, reasoned repayment order stating the available remedies and time limits.
- Exceptions: interruption for serious medical reasons reported to the student records office, exemption from attendance for studies abroad or for an internship forming part of the course.
The court reviews whether the circular has been applied correctly. It annulled a refusal calculated on the income of both parents when the father was directly paying expenses set by an agreement approved by the family court judge (JAF) (CAA Nantes, 7 January 2022, No. 20NT01367).
Each safeguard can ground a challenge:
Method
CROUS grant appeal: the procedure step by step
From notification to judgment, each step has its own recipient and time limit.
Read the notification
Identify the author of the decision, the CROUS or the rector, its exact ground, the date of receipt and the remedies indicated. The two-month time limit runs from notification.
Write to the rector
For a grant from the Ministry of Higher Education, Service-Public advises sending the request for reconsideration to the rector of the academy (recteur d'académie) and then, if it fails, a hierarchical appeal to the minister, which must be sent through the rector.
Seek annulment
The application targets the initial decision and the rejection of the administrative appeal. The court may annul the decision and order the administration to re-examine the application within a time limit it sets (Article L. 911-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
Urgent suspension application
If the decision deprives the student of the resources on which their housing or studies depend, the urgent applications judge (juge des référés) may suspend it where urgency justifies it and a ground raises serious doubt as to its lawfulness (Article L. 521-1).
A procedural trap: a procedural ground that was not raised before the administrative court can no longer be raised on appeal if it belongs to a distinct legal cause. The Bordeaux Administrative Court of Appeal so held for a student who relied too late on the absence of a reminder: « such a ground, relating to the regularity of the procedure at the end of which the recovery order was issued, belongs to a legal cause distinct from the sole ground relating to the merits of the debt that he had raised before the first-instance judges » (our translation) (CAA Bordeaux, 18 April 2024, No. 22BX01391). All grounds must therefore be argued at first instance.
Housing
CROUS housing and eviction: the process and the time limits
From admission to a university residence to the enforcement of an eviction.
Admission and occupancy agreement
Accommodation is allocated by decision of the CROUS; an occupancy agreement (convention d'occupation) and the residence's internal rules set out the resident's obligations, starting with payment of the occupancy fee (redevance).
Alleged breaches
Debt, disturbances, breaches of the internal rules: where the measure envisaged is a sanction, it may only be taken after the student has been given the opportunity to submit observations (Article L. 122-1 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration).
Refusal of readmission or end of the right of occupancy
The decision is challenged by a request for reconsideration to its author, then before the administrative court, within two months. In Paris, the Administrative Court of Appeal annulled a refusal of readmission issued without the student having been able to submit observations (CAA Paris, 16 October 2024, No. 23PA00340).
Occupation without title
A student who stays on after their right of occupancy ends becomes an occupier without right or title (occupant sans droit ni titre); the CROUS may then apply to the urgent applications judge of the administrative court.
« Useful measures » urgent application
On the basis of Article L. 521-3 of the Code of Administrative Justice, which is admissible even without a prior decision, the judge may order the student to vacate the premises and authorise eviction if they have not left within the time limit set.
Enforcement and the winter truce
Article L. 412-6 of the French Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures (code des procédures civiles d’exécution) stays the enforcement of evictions from 1 November to 31 March, unless rehousing is ensured; according to the Council of State (Conseil d'État), it does not prevent the court from ordering eviction during that period.
In a case concerning the « Delphine Seyrig » residence in Paris, the Council of State upheld an order holding that « the urgency and usefulness of the measure sought were established by the need to ensure the proper functioning of the public service entrusted to the CROUS of Paris, which was prevented from using the accommodation to meet the demand of other students, who were moreover numerous » (our translation) (CE, 21 March 2018, No. 407386). The student's defence must therefore be prepared before the urgent hearing, and first of all by challenging in time the decision that ended their right of occupancy.
Preparing the case
Documents to gather for a CROUS appeal
The court rules on the documents: those missing from the file do not count.
The notification being challenged, with proof of its date of receipt: envelope, email, screenshot of the Mes services étudiant portal.
The tax assessment notices used, the judgment or approved agreement setting maintenance, the notice bearing the single-parent mention.
Evidence of a drop in resources, a death, a separation or a family breakdown.
Transcripts of marks and ECTS credits, enrolment certificates, proof of course enrolment.
For attendance: exam notices, attendance records, medical certificates, exemptions from attendance granted by the institution.
For housing: admission decision, occupancy agreement, internal rules, correspondence with the residence, statement of the debt and proof of payment.
The Bordeaux Administrative Court of Appeal rejected the appeal of a student who relied on an enrolment certificate and a transcript of marks against the attendance records produced by the rectorate: those documents said nothing about his presence in class. Send us what you have, even if incomplete: the firm will prioritise it with you on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions about CROUS appeals
Thirteen answers based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
Do I need a lawyer to challenge a CROUS decision?
Not always. Before the administrative court, Article R. 431-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice requires representation by a lawyer where the claims seek payment of a sum of money, discharge from or reduction of sums claimed from the applicant, or the resolution of a dispute arising from the performance of a contract. Article R. 431-3 lifts this requirement for several types of dispute, including those concerning benefits, allowances or rights granted under social assistance or social welfare and housing.
An application that only seeks the annulment of a grant refusal does not fall within any of the cases in Article R. 431-2. A challenge to a repayment order, which seeks discharge from a sum claimed, calls for a careful review of these two articles before filing.
A lawyer is mainly useful on the substance: identifying the author of the decision, choosing between a request for reconsideration and applying directly to the court, raising every procedural and substantive ground at first instance, and gathering the documents the court expects.
What is the time limit to challenge a CROUS grant refusal?
Two months from notification of the decision, under Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice. Service-Public points out that the administrative court with jurisdiction over the academy may be seised within two months following the initial notification of refusal.
Before going to court, a request for reconsideration may be sent to the rector of the academy, then a hierarchical appeal to the Minister of Higher Education, which must be sent through the rector. If lodged within the time limit, these appeals interrupt it: under Article L. 411-2 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration, where both are lodged, time only starts running again once both have been rejected.
The administration's silence also counts: where it amounts to a rejection, the two-month time limit runs from the date on which the implied decision arises (Article R. 421-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice). Keep proof of the date on which each appeal was sent, by registered post or by hand delivery against a receipt.
My parents are separated: can the CROUS take both parents' income into account?
The 2026-2027 circular states that eligibility for the grant is assessed by reference to the resources of the parent or parents supporting the student, the grant remaining complementary to the maintenance obligation under Articles 203 and 371-2 of the French Civil Code (code civil). Everything therefore depends on proof of who supports the student and, where relevant, of the maintenance paid by the other parent.
The administrative courts review this application closely. The Nantes Administrative Court of Appeal annulled a refusal based on the income of both parents: the father was directly paying school, transport or health expenses under an approved agreement, and the court held that these sums « are representative of maintenance within the meaning of the provisions of the circular of 11 April 2017 set out in point 4, whatever the tax treatment otherwise given to the sums concerned » (our translation) (CAA Nantes, 7 January 2022, No. 20NT01367).
The Nancy Administrative Court of Appeal likewise required that only the income of the mother be taken into account, as her tax assessment notice bore the single-parent mention. It relied on the paragraph of the circular then applicable dealing with single parents, « which, contrary to what the Minister of National Education argues, does not reserve that status solely to recipients of the earned income supplement (revenu de solidarité active) receiving an increase in the basic allowance » (our translation) (CAA Nancy, 17 April 2018, No. 16NC02887). See also our analysis of the CROUS grant for students whose parents are separated.
The CROUS is asking me to repay my grant: is that lawful?
The principle is set out in Article D. 821-1 of the French Education Code: a student who does not meet the general conditions of study and attendance on which their entitlement to the grant depends must repay the sums unduly received. Article L. 612-1-1 of the same code links continued entitlement to student aid to those conditions.
The 2026-2027 circular governs the procedure. Suspension takes effect when the triggering event is recorded by the institution, any month already begun remains due, a prior adversarial procedure is organised under Article L. 121-1 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration, and the repayment order, signed by the rector, must state reasons and mention the available remedies and time limits.
The court checks whether the absences are real and whether the procedure was regular, but it accepts that suspension and repayment can be combined, because « the sole purpose of suspension is to prevent the future receipt of undue sums, whereas the issuing of the recovery order seeks the return of sums already received » (our translation) (CAA Paris, 31 January 2022, No. 20PA02566). The challenge therefore concerns the evidence, the period claimed and the procedural safeguards. See our article on a CROUS grant refused, withdrawn or to be repaid.
My absences were justified: can I keep my CROUS grant?
Yes, in the cases provided for by the 2026-2027 circular. A student who interrupts their studies for serious medical reasons, treatment or hospitalisation, must inform the student records office of their institution and send it the supporting documents: the interruption then does not suspend payment of the grant during the period concerned.
A student who is also studying abroad or doing an internship forming part of their course must obtain from the academic authorities an exemption from attendance and permission to sit the examinations. Being a working student is not enough in itself: under an earlier circular, the Paris Administrative Court of Appeal noted that « the circular of 11 April 2017 provides only that students, in particular employed students, who benefit from special teaching arrangements and are reported by the institution as exempt from attendance, cannot be subject to an order to repay the grant for lack of attendance » (our translation) (CAA Paris, 4 June 2021, No. 21PA00666).
The right reflex is to document everything: report the situation to the student records office when it arises, keep the certificates and request the exemption in writing. The circular links continued payment of the grant to this information being given to the institution.
My parents' income has fallen: can I ask for my grant to be reviewed?
The 2026-2027 circular allows a review, at the student's request, where resources for year N-1 have fallen by 15% or more compared with those for year N-2. The drop is shown on the tax assessment notice issued in year N for income in N-1.
A review is also possible in the event of a death at the end of year N-1 or during the current year: only the income of the person who still actually supports the student is then taken into account. The request must be sent no later than 1 March of the academic year concerned.
The right to make a mistake (droit à l'erreur) under Article L. 123-1 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration, which the circular states may be relied on, protects a person who corrects a mistake made for the first time, except in cases of bad faith or fraud; the circular specifies that it does not cover late or omitted declarations. See our article on a lower CROUS grant level.
Can I apply to the court urgently against a CROUS decision?
Yes, through an urgent suspension application (référé-suspension). Under Article L. 521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice, where an administrative decision, even a rejection, is the subject of an application for annulment, the urgent applications judge may suspend its enforcement if urgency justifies it and if a ground raises, at that stage of the proceedings, serious doubt as to its lawfulness.
The urgent application is therefore never on its own: it accompanies an application on the merits. Urgency is shown through documents: bank statements, rent to pay, risk of dropping out, the academic calendar. Serious doubt is built on an identifiable defect: lack of reasons, no adversarial procedure, wrong basis of resources, absences not established.
Where suspension is ordered, the court rules on the application on the merits as soon as possible, and the suspension ends at the latest when that judgment is delivered, under the same article.
The CROUS refuses to readmit me to my university residence: can I challenge it?
Yes. A refusal of readmission decided on account of breaches is an administrative decision that can be challenged before the administrative court within two months. Where it penalises conduct, it is one of the decisions that must state reasons (Article L. 211-2 of the Code of Relations between the Public and the Administration) and may only be taken after the person concerned has been given the opportunity to submit observations (Article L. 122-1).
The Paris Administrative Court of Appeal annulled the refusal to readmit a student of the Lepaute residence, in the 13th arrondissement, decided on account of a rent debt and breaches of the internal rules, on the ground that he « was not invited to submit written observations and, where appropriate, at his request, oral observations before the contested decision was issued, which constituted a sanction under the aforementioned Article 18 of the internal rules of the university residences » (our translation) (CAA Paris, 16 October 2024, No. 23PA00340). The court rejected the argument based on urgency, as the decision was a refusal of readmission and not an eviction.
The challenge is prepared with the internal rules, the decision, the correspondence with the residence and the statement of the debt. See our article on CROUS housing refused or readmission denied.
The CROUS is seeking my eviction from the residence: which court, which procedure?
The administrative court. The Jurisdiction Disputes Tribunal held that the CROUS, as public administrative bodies, allocate their accommodation by unilateral decision and that any request for eviction seeks to ensure the normal functioning and continuity of their public service, even where the residence is not part of the public domain (Tribunal des conflits, 12 February 2018, No. C4112).
The usual route is the « useful measures » urgent application under Article L. 521-3 of the Code of Administrative Justice, admissible even in the absence of a prior administrative decision. The Council of State upheld an order requiring an occupier without title to vacate his accommodation and authorising the CROUS of Paris to have him evicted if he had not left within one month of its notification (CE, 21 March 2018, No. 407386).
In that case, the Council of State held that the urgent applications judge did not have to take into account the occupier's interest in remaining in the premises, an interest he had not in fact relied on, since he had no right to remain. Relevant personal circumstances must therefore be put before the court, and the decision ending the right of occupancy must be challenged in time.
Does the winter truce (trêve hivernale) protect a student housed by the CROUS?
Article L. 412-6 of the French Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures provides that any eviction measure not enforced by 1 November is stayed until 31 March of the following year, unless the rehousing of the persons concerned is ensured in adequate conditions that respect the unity and needs of the family.
The Council of State clarified its scope in a dispute concerning a Paris university residence: these provisions only provide for a stay of eviction measures not yet enforced and do not prevent the court from ordering eviction, even during the truce (CE, 21 March 2018, No. 407386). An order can therefore be made in winter; it is its enforcement that is deferred, unless rehousing is provided.
The text provides for exceptions, in particular where eviction was ordered because of entry without right or title into another person's home by means of trickery, threats, assault or coercion. Each occupier's situation is examined in the light of these provisions and of the planned date of enforcement.
My student residence is not run by the CROUS: do the rules change?
Often, yes. Not all residences that house students come under the CROUS. Where a private body or a landlord runs the residence, even under an agreement with the State or the CROUS, the dispute may fall within the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts and the regime for residential hostels (logements-foyers) defined in Article L. 633-1 of the French Construction and Housing Code (code de la construction et de l’habitation), which expressly covers housing for students.
The Paris Judicial Court (tribunal judiciaire) thus held, for a furnished sub-letting agreement reserved for grant-holding students, that « it follows from all these elements that the letting concerns a residential hostel (logement-foyer) » (our translation), the Law of 6 July 1989 being set aside (TJ Paris, 13 June 2024, No. 23/09228). Under this regime, Article L. 633-2 of the same code limits termination by the manager to failure to perform an obligation under the agreement or a serious or repeated breach of the internal rules, total cessation of the establishment's activity and loss of the conditions of admission.
Before taking any step, the firm checks who signed your agreement and what their status is: the competent court and the applicable texts depend on this.
Which administrative court should I apply to in Paris?
Article R. 312-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice designates the administrative court within whose territorial jurisdiction the authority that took the contested decision, under its own powers or by delegation, has its legal seat. Where there has been a prior administrative appeal, the relevant decision is the one that was the subject of that appeal.
In practice, a decision of the Paris rectorate or of the CROUS of Paris falls within the jurisdiction of the Paris Administrative Court. For a student enrolled in another academy in the Paris region (Île-de-France), the notification states the signing authority: that authority determines the competent court.
The firm checks the signing authority and any delegation before filing, so as not to lose time where an urgent application is being considered and to target correctly both the initial decision and the rejection of the administrative appeal.
What are the fees for a challenge against the CROUS?
Fees are agreed with the client and set out in a written fee agreement, except in cases of urgency, force majeure or full legal aid, in accordance with Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: request for reconsideration and hierarchical appeal, application to the administrative court, urgent application, appeal. Any new engagement is covered by an amendment to the agreement. The preliminary case review, offered through the form on this page, costs €80 incl. VAT and results in a written analysis, within 24 working hours as indicated on the form.
Legal aid (aide juridictionnelle) is available subject to means; the firm will tell you whether you are eligible. First conversation on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts and decisions
- Article D. 821-1 of the Education Code, conditions for awarding grants and repayment
- Article L. 612-1-1 of the Education Code, study, attendance and continued entitlement to student aid
- circular of 26 February 2026 (BO No. 9), rules for awarding grants for 2026-2027
- Article L. 211-2 of the CRPA, statement of reasons; Article L. 121-1 and Article L. 122-1, adversarial procedure
- Article L. 411-2 of the CRPA, administrative appeals and time limit; Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice, two-month time limit
- Articles L. 521-1 and L. 521-3 of the Code of Administrative Justice, urgent applications; Article L. 412-6 of the Code of Civil Enforcement Procedures, winter truce
- Tribunal des conflits, 12 February 2018, No. C4112; CE, 21 March 2018, No. 407386; CAA Paris, 16 October 2024, No. 23PA00340
- CAA Nantes, 7 January 2022, No. 20NT01367; CAA Nancy, 17 April 2018, No. 16NC02887; CAA Paris, 31 January 2022, No. 20PA02566; CAA Bordeaux, 18 April 2024, No. 22BX01391; CAA Paris, 4 June 2021, No. 21PA00666; TJ Paris, 13 June 2024, No. 23/09228
A CROUS decision to challenge?
The firm is available 24/7. Send us the notification and the documents you have: the time limit for a court challenge is two months, and a request for reconsideration lodged in time interrupts it. Grant refused, grant level disputed, repayment order, refusal of readmission or eviction from a university residence: each case is examined on the documents, before the deadline.