Featured in the media
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, property development and off-plan (VEFA) lawyers in Paris
Off-plan property lawyer in Paris, France: VEFA, delivery, warranties
Buying off-plan property in France (vente en l'état futur d'achèvement, VEFA): reservation contract and security deposit, stage payments (appels de fonds), completion guarantee, late delivery, snags (réserves) and non-conformities, property development contract (contrat de promotion immobilière): the firm assists off-plan buyers, investors and project owners, as well as developers and sellers of buildings under construction facing claims. Each stage has its own time limits and formalities.
The firm can be reached 24/7. A claim against the seller for visible defects and non-conformities must be brought, on pain of being time-barred (forclusion), within one year of the date on which the seller can be released from them (Article 1648 of the French Civil Code, Code civil); a non-professional buyer has ten days to withdraw (Article L. 271-1 of the French Construction and Housing Code, Code de la construction et de l'habitation).
4,9/5
Average Google rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his thorough command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the outcome obtained for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with a great deal of empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, kind and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Urgent matters 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Get a French property lawyer's analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer at the Paris Bar: property development, off-plan sales (VEFA), property development contracts and disputes over delivery.
Official profile in the national directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 31 October 2026.
Quick answer
An off-plan sale (vente en l'état futur d'achèvement, VEFA) immediately transfers to the buyer the seller's rights over the land and ownership of the existing structures, the future works becoming the buyer's property as they are carried out (Article 1601-3 of the French Civil Code). For a home, it must be made by notarial deed, with a delivery date and proof of a financial guarantee of completion or of repayment (Articles L. 261-10, L. 261-10-1 and L. 261-11 of the French Construction and Housing Code). Payments follow the progress of the works, up to 35% of the price when the foundations are completed, 70% when the building is weathertight (mise hors d'eau) and 95% on completion, and the balance may be paid into a deposit account if conformity is disputed (Article R. 261-14). For visible defects, the buyer must act within one year of the date on which the seller can be released from them, and the seller is liable under the ten-year and two-year warranties (Articles 1642-1, 1646-1 and 1648 of the French Civil Code). Under a property development contract, a mandate in the common interest, the developer guarantees the performance of the contractors it deals with (Article 1831-1). Kohen Avocats, in the 16th arrondissement of Paris, acts for buyers as well as for developers and project owners. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A reservation contract to sign, a late delivery, snags not yet cleared?
Understanding your situation
Property development and off-plan sales (VEFA) in Paris, explained
The off-plan seller keeps the powers of project owner until the works are accepted (Article 1601-3 of the French Civil Code), but the buyer pays as the works progress. How the reservation is signed, what the staged payments and the completion guarantee protect, what each party can demand on delivery and in the event of delay, and what the developer owes the project owner.
Before the deed
Reservation and VEFA contract: mandatory formalities
Four rules to check before signing, whether you are buying or selling.
The protected sector: any contract that transfers ownership of a residential or mixed-use building and requires payments before completion must, on pain of nullity, take the form of a forward sale (vente à terme) or an off-plan sale (Article L. 261-10 of the French Construction and Housing Code).
The preliminary contract: the reservation specifies the nature of the building, the quality of construction, the time frame for the works, and the location and price of the unit, in return for a security deposit paid into a special account (Article L. 261-15); “Any other promise to buy or sell is void.”
A capped deposit: 5% of the estimated price if the sale is to be completed within one year, 2% if within two years, and no deposit may be required beyond that (Article R. 261-28); the funds are deposited in the name of the reservation holder with a bank, an authorised institution or a notary (Article R. 261-29).
A complete notarial deed: description of the property, price and payment terms, delivery date and attached certificate of the financial guarantee, on pain of nullity, which only the buyer may invoke before the works are completed (Article L. 261-11).
Management as a serviced residence (résidence hôtelière) does not exclude the protective regime where the deed provides for residential use. In a case where the reservation concerned a two-room duplex and the notarial deed residential premises, the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) held, regardless of the management of the property as a serviced residence, that “the court of appeal rightly concluded that the protective regime for off-plan sales provided for by Article L. 261-10 of the Construction and Housing Code applied” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 23 May 2019, No. 17-17.908). Clauses contrary to Articles L. 261-11 to L. 261-15 are deemed unwritten (Article L. 261-16).
A non-professional buyer may withdraw within ten days from the day after the letter notifying the contract is first presented; where the sale is preceded by a preliminary contract, this period applies to that contract only (Article L. 271-1). The seller must then notify the draft deed of sale at least one month before signature (Article R. 261-30). The security deposit is refunded without deduction or penalty in the cases listed in Article R. 261-31, in particular if the sale is not concluded within the agreed period through the seller's doing, if the price exceeds the revised estimated price by more than 5%, or if the planned loans are not obtained. The Paris Court of Appeal upheld this refund for reservation holders who had received no offer of sale within the eight months stipulated, noting that the estimated construction period relied on by the developer “concerns completion of the works and not the conclusion of the sale” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 20 February 2026, No. 24/11718). It did, however, reject their claim for loss of opportunity.
Outside the cases provided for by Articles L. 261-15, I, and R. 261-31, what happens to the deposit depends on the terms of the reservation contract: they should be read before signing. See also our articles on the mortgage condition precedent in an off-plan purchase and on the buyer's withdrawal period.
Payments
Stage payments, deposit of the balance and the completion guarantee
The buyer is paying for a building that does not yet exist: the law sets caps and requires a guarantor.
Before the sale
Apart from the security deposit under the reservation contract (Article L. 261-15), the seller may neither demand nor accept any payment before the contract of sale is signed, or before the date on which the sum falls due (Article L. 261-12).
35 %, 70 %, 95 %
Total payments may not exceed 35% of the price when the foundations are completed, 70% when the building is weathertight and 95% on completion of the building; any penalty for late payment may not exceed 1% per month (Article R. 261-14).
The balance
It is payable when the unit is made available to the buyer, but it may be paid into a deposit account if conformity with the contract is disputed (Article R. 261-14).
Price revision
Where provided for, it follows a national building cost index, within a limit of between 60% and 80% of the change in that index (Article L. 261-11-1).
The guarantee
Before contracting, the seller takes out a financial guarantee of completion or of repayment; the buyer can call on the completion guarantee if the seller fails financially, which is defined as “a lack of the funds needed to complete the building” (Article L. 261-10-1).
The guarantor
A bank, an authorised financial institution, an approved insurance company or a mutual guarantee society (Article R. 261-17), it advances or pays the sums needed for completion (Article R. 261-21); its guarantee ends once completion has been formally recorded (Article R. 261-24).
Paying the balance into a deposit account protects a buyer who disputes the delivery. The Court of Cassation quashed a judgment that had refused to hand over the keys to buyers authorised to deposit the balance, “whereas a deposit counts as payment” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 15 December 2010, No. 09-67.232). The Paris Court of Appeal, hearing an appeal against an interim order, holds that the provisions of Article R. 261-14, “which protect the buyer, must be interpreted broadly, so that a deposit is permitted for non-conformities but also for defects and disorders” (our translation), and that “a mere dispute is enough to make the deposit, and the seller's consent is not required” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 8, 3 March 2023, No. 22/11125). The same decision shows the limit: once the snags had for the most part been cleared, “given the minor nature of the finishing works still to be carried out, the obligation to pay the balance of the price is not seriously disputable” (our translation), and the buyer was ordered to pay the €14,950 balance on an interim basis, while the seller was ordered to pay the buyer €5,000 in interim damages (CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 8, 3 March 2023, No. 22/11125).
The completion guarantee has a precise purpose. According to the Paris Court of Appeal, the guarantor “is only required to provide the financing needed to complete the building if the seller defaults, and does not have to take part in carrying out the construction or to take the place of the seller as project owner” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 6, 24 November 2023, No. 21/02986); the court accepts that the guarantor may be held liable for fault if it fails to act diligently in implementing the guarantee, but it dismissed the claims of the buyers who blamed it for the lapse of the building permit, since the guarantor had alerted them more than six months before the lapse. The notary, for its part, must inform the buyer about the guarantee offered. In sales made in 2006 and 2007 with an intrinsic completion guarantee (garantie intrinsèque d'achèvement), where the selling company had been unable to obtain a bank guarantee, the Court of Cassation held that “Where the intrinsic guarantee offered by the seller proves unsuited to the risks of the operation, of which the notary is or should be aware, the notary must draw the buyer's attention to the fragility of the protection provided by such a guarantee.” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 21 January 2026, No. 23-22.937). The rules now in force require a financial guarantee given by one of the bodies listed in Article R. 261-17.
When its guarantee is called, the guarantor alone is entitled to demand the balance of the price from the buyer, even if the seller is subject to insolvency proceedings (Article L. 261-10-1). See our articles on the completion guarantee when the developer defaults and on enforcing the guarantee against the guarantor.
Delivery
Completion, snags, visible defects and the seller's warranties
Delivery starts short time limits: snags are recorded, then the claim must be brought within the year.
The building is deemed complete when the works have been carried out and the equipment essential for its use in accordance with its intended purpose has been installed; for this assessment, “non-conformities with the contract are not taken into account where they are not substantial” (Article R. 261-1).
Recording completion is neither an acknowledgement that the building conforms to the contract nor a waiver of the buyer's rights under Article 1642-1 of the French Civil Code (Article R. 261-1).
The seller cannot be released from visible construction defects or non-conformities either before the works are accepted or before one month has elapsed after the buyer takes possession; the seller avoids rescission or a price reduction by undertaking to carry out repairs (Article 1642-1 of the French Civil Code).
The claim must be brought, on pain of being time-barred, within one year of the date on which the seller can be released from those visible defects or non-conformities (Article 1648, paragraph 2).
From acceptance of the works, the seller is liable under the warranties owed by builders under Articles 1792 to 1792-3, for the benefit of successive owners (Article 1646-1).
The contract cannot exclude them: any clause contrary to Articles 1642-1 and 1646-1 is deemed unwritten (Article L. 261-16 of the French Construction and Housing Code).
The one-year period must be calculated carefully. Since the seller cannot be released either before acceptance of the works or before the month following the taking of possession has expired, it is the later of these two events that counts (Article 1642-1). The Court of Cassation holds that “the buyer may, for one year from acceptance of the works or from the expiry of one month after taking possession of the works, bring an action against the seller under the warranty for visible defects, even if the defects were reported after that one-month period had expired” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 13 February 2025, No. 23-17.755). This period can be interrupted by a court claim, even an application for interim relief (Article 2241 of the French Civil Code), but it then starts running again for one year only. Buyers who had obtained interim orders requiring the snags to be cleared, subject to a daily penalty, and then an expert assessment, and who had issued proceedings on the merits more than a year after the last order, were time-barred according to the Court of Cassation, because “a new one-year period had run from that interruption” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 11 July 2019, No. 18-17.856).
The action under the warranty for visible defects does not exclude the ten-year builder's liability (garantie décennale). According to the Court of Cassation, “the buyer may bring both the action under the ten-year liability and the action for repair of visible defects” (our translation), and where the buyer relies on the ten-year liability, “whether the defect was visible is assessed from the standpoint of the project owner and as at the date of acceptance of the works” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 14 January 2021, No. 19-21.130), the judgment specifying that it does not matter whether the defect was visible when the buyer took possession. Finally, floor area is checked against the regulatory definition: in an off-plan deed, “the stipulated area means a habitable area within the meaning of Article R. 111-2 of the same Code, excluding parts of premises less than 1.80 metres high” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 18 March 2021, No. 19-24.994). That definition is now found in Article R. 156-1 of the French Construction and Housing Code.
The builders' warranties (one-year completion warranty, two-year warranty on equipment, ten-year liability) are explained on our construction law lawyer page. See also our articles on non-conformity and visible defects in an off-plan purchase, on non-conformity at delivery and on the ten-year liability in an off-plan purchase.
Delay
Late delivery: legitimate grounds, penalties and losses
The delivery date is stated in the deed; everything turns on the grounds for postponement and on proof of the loss.
You are the buyer
- Note the delivery date stipulated in the deed and the grounds for postponement provided for.
- Demand supporting evidence for each ground relied on, including the project manager's (maître d'œuvre) certificate.
- Calculate the contractual penalties and prove each loss: rent, interim loan interest (intérêts intercalaires), rental value.
You are the developer or seller
- Draft precise and verifiable legitimate grounds for suspension.
- Keep buyers informed as the works progress, with the certificates provided for in the contract.
- Argue the starting point, the period attributable to you and the amount of the losses claimed.
The seller undertakes to construct the building within a period set by the contract (Article 1601-1 of the French Civil Code), and the deed must state that period (Article L. 261-11 of the French Construction and Housing Code). A party in default owes damages unless it shows force majeure (Article 1231-1 of the French Civil Code), defined as an event beyond its control, which could not reasonably have been foreseen and whose effects cannot be avoided (Article 1218). Contracts add legitimate grounds for suspension. In a contract with a non-professional or a consumer, the Court of Cassation held not to be unfair the clause providing that, where a legitimate ground for suspension is evidenced by the seller with a letter from the project manager, “the delivery of the property sold will be delayed by a period equal to twice the period actually recorded, because of their impact on the general organisation of the site, has neither the object nor the effect of creating, to the detriment of the non-professional or consumer, a significant imbalance between the parties' rights and obligations under the contract and is therefore not unfair” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 23 May 2019, No. 18-14.212); the judgment awarding €10,000 to the buyers was quashed on that point, and the case was remitted to the same court of appeal sitting with different judges.
The ground relied on must nevertheless be proved in the manner required by the contract. According to the Paris Court of Appeal, bad weather, delays in obtaining authorisations or the withdrawal of a contractor “are contingencies that may amount to legitimate grounds for suspending the delivery deadline insofar as the seller, who owes the obligation to deliver, has no control over them” (our translation), provided they are certified and substantiated (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 2 October 2026, No. 23/02860). The Rennes Court of Appeal disregarded the 146 days of bad weather announced in a mere letter from the developer, because “That letter was not, however, accompanied by a letter from the project manager, so that it is insufficient to prove the alleged delay” (our translation) (CA Rennes, 4e ch., 28 August 2025, No. 24/00575); it did, however, accept 73 days of bad weather substantiated by a table certified by the project management firm, and 58 days of force majeure, which were doubled under the contract, reducing the delay attributable to the developer from 350 to 161 days, and then awarded compensation for the extra rent and the interim loan interest on that basis.
The stipulated penalties are a penalty clause that the court may reduce or increase if it is manifestly excessive or derisory (Article 1231-5 of the French Civil Code). In a case decided by the Court of Cassation, the stipulated penalties were held to be due until the completion date found by the lower courts: it upheld a court of appeal that had held that “16 March 2018 had to be taken as the date of completion of the works, so that the late-delivery penalties were due until that date” (our translation), since there were no compliance certificates allowing the property to be lived in earlier (Cass. 3e civ., 13 February 2025, No. 23-17.755). Lastly, rental loss must be proved: the Paris Court of Appeal refused any compensation for loss of rental income to buyers whose situation “is not enough to substantiate the loss they claim without at the very least an estimate of the property's rental value by a property professional” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 2 October 2026, No. 23/02860).
The points the firm examines in every late-delivery case:
Abandoned sites are covered on a separate page. See our article on late delivery of an off-plan property and the developer's legitimate grounds.
The developer
Property development contract and the developer's liability
As agent of the project owner, the developer is answerable for the contractors it chooses.
A mandate in the common interest
The developer undertakes to the project owner to have a construction programme carried out, for an agreed price and by means of construction contracts (contrats de louage d'ouvrage), and to carry out all or part of the legal, administrative and financial operations (Article 1831-1 of the French Civil Code).
Guarantor of the contractors
“The developer guarantees the performance of the obligations of the persons with whom it has contracted on behalf of the project owner.” It is bound by the obligations under Articles 1792 to 1792-3, and by those of a building contractor for any work it carries out itself (Article 1831-1).
Its powers
It concludes contracts, accepts the works and settles the contracts on behalf of the project owner, within the limit of the overall price; borrowing and acts of disposal require a special mandate (Article 1831-2).
A mandatory written contract
For a residential building, the contract must be recorded in writing before it is performed, stating in particular the land, the building, the price, the financing, the developer's remuneration, the time frame and the developer's guarantee, on pain of nullity, which only the project owner may invoke until the works are completed (Article L. 222-3 of the French Construction and Housing Code), subject to the exceptions provided for in Article L. 222-1.
End of the engagement
The engagement ends on delivery only if the construction accounts have been finally settled, without prejudice to any liability claims (Article 1831-4); “Court-supervised arrangement or liquidation does not automatically terminate the property development contract.” (Article 1831-5).
Payments by the project owner
Clauses providing for automatic termination if the project owner fails to make a payment take effect only one month after formal notice has gone unheeded (Article L. 222-4).
The developer's guarantee does not make it an insurer against every defect. On 11 June 2026 the Court of Cassation held that, although the developer is bound by the builders' statutory warranties, “its contractual liability for intermediate defects is subject to proof of personal fault” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 11 June 2026, No. 23-22.360). The project owner did not, however, lose everything: the judgment was quashed for failing to answer its submissions relying on a clause of the contract making the developer responsible for the choice of contractors and the conformity of the works, and because “a property developer that does not undertake to carry out part of the programme itself is not a contractor for works within the meaning of Article 1779, 3°, of the Civil Code” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 11 June 2026, No. 23-22.360), so that the retention guarantee scheme for building contracts did not apply to it.
A developer that itself sells off-plan falls under a different framework: “The seller retains the powers of project owner until the works are accepted.” (Article 1601-3 of the French Civil Code). In that capacity, save for the exceptions provided by law, it takes out building damage insurance (assurance dommages-ouvrage) before the works begin (Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code), and is then liable to buyers under the warranties of Article 1646-1 of the Civil Code. The firm advises developers on drafting reservation contracts, deeds of sale and property development contracts, and defends them before the court-appointed expert and the court; it assists buyers and project owners in the same way.
See our article on the property development contract, intermediate defects and the judgment of 11 June 2026.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the legislation in force and on verified decisions.
When do you need an off-plan property lawyer in France?
Before signing, during construction and from delivery onwards. For the buyer, the lawyer reviews the reservation contract and the draft deed, which the seller must notify at least one month before signature (Article R. 261-30 of the French Construction and Housing Code). The lawyer checks the description of the property, the price and payment terms, the delivery date and the certificate of the financial guarantee, without which the off-plan deed of sale is void at the buyer's request, before the works are completed (Article L. 261-11). The lawyer also examines the grounds for postponing the delivery date stipulated in the contract, and then checks stage payments against the actual progress of the works.
On delivery, the lawyer helps draft the snags and organises the claim within the one-year period of Article 1648 of the French Civil Code, a period whose expiry the Court of Cassation strictly enforces (Cass. 3e civ., 11 July 2019, No. 18-17.856). In the event of delay, the lawyer examines the grounds for postponement relied on and calculates the losses.
For professionals, the firm drafts and negotiates reservation contracts, deeds of sale, property development contracts and legitimate-grounds clauses, and defends developers and sellers facing claims. It also acts for project owners who have entrusted their programme to a developer. The builders' warranties are covered on our construction law page.
Off-plan reservation contract in France: how much is the deposit, and when is it refunded?
The reservation is a preliminary contract by which the seller undertakes to reserve a home in return for a security deposit paid into a special account. It must state the nature of the building, the quality of construction, the time frame for the works, and the location and price of the unit, and the funds remain frozen until the sale (Article L. 261-15 of the French Construction and Housing Code). It also states the approximate habitable area and includes a brief technical specification (Article R. 261-25).
The deposit may not exceed 5% of the estimated price if the sale is to be completed within one year, 2% if within two years, and no deposit may be required beyond that (Article R. 261-28). It is refunded without deduction or penalty if the sale is not concluded within the agreed period through the seller's doing, if the price exceeds the revised estimated price by more than 5%, if the planned loans are not obtained or are 10% lower than expected, if a planned item of equipment is not provided, or if the value of the property is reduced by more than 10%. The request is made by registered letter to the seller and the depositary, and the refund is made within three months (Article R. 261-31).
The Paris Court of Appeal thus upheld the refund ordered for reservation holders who had received no offer of sale within the eight months stipulated, holding that “it was indeed through the seller's doing that the sale was not concluded” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 20 February 2026, No. 24/11718). Outside the statutory cases, what happens to the deposit depends on the terms of the contract. See our article on the mortgage condition precedent in an off-plan purchase.
Can you withdraw after signing an off-plan (VEFA) reservation in France?
Yes, if you are buying as a non-professional. For any contract for the sale of a building to be constructed, a non-professional buyer may withdraw within ten days from the day after the letter notifying the contract is first presented. Notification is made by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt or by any means offering equivalent guarantees, and withdrawal is exercised in the same way (Article L. 271-1 of the French Construction and Housing Code).
Where the sale is preceded by a preliminary contract, as is the case with a reservation, the right of withdrawal applies only to that preliminary contract (Article L. 271-1). Withdrawal therefore takes place at the reservation stage, not when the notarial deed is signed. Where the notarial deed is not preceded by any preliminary contract or promise, the buyer has a ten-day cooling-off period from notification of the draft deed, during which the deed cannot be signed.
The period runs from the day after the letter is first presented, not from the day the buyer collects it. The contract must state clearly the conditions for exercising this right, and failure to provide this information exposes the professional to an administrative fine (Article L. 271-1). After that period, the deposit is refunded in the cases provided for by Articles L. 261-15, I, and R. 261-31, or by the contract. The firm checks that notification was properly made and the exact date on which the period expires. See our article on the buyer's withdrawal period.
How are stage payments scheduled in an off-plan (VEFA) purchase?
According to a statutory cap linked to the actual progress of the works. Total payments or deposits may not exceed 35% of the price when the foundations are completed, 70% when the building is weathertight and 95% on completion of the building. The balance is payable when the unit is made available to the buyer. If the sale is subject to a condition precedent, no payment may be made before the condition is fulfilled, and the penalty for late payment may not exceed 1% per month (Article R. 261-14 of the French Construction and Housing Code).
Apart from the security deposit under the reservation (Article L. 261-15), the seller may neither demand nor accept any payment before the contract of sale is signed, or before the date on which the sum falls due (Article L. 261-12). The buyer must pay the price as the works progress (Article 1601-3 of the French Civil Code), which means that each stage must actually have been reached. The contract may provide for price revision, but only in line with a national building cost index and within a limit of between 60% and 80% of the change in that index (Article L. 261-11-1).
Completion is often disputed when the 95% call for funds is made. The building is deemed complete when the works and equipment essential for its use are in place, disregarding non-substantial non-conformities and defects that do not make the works unfit for use (Article R. 261-1). For the calculation of late-delivery penalties, and not for whether the 95% call was due, the Court of Cassation upheld a court of appeal that had taken as the completion date the date on which the compliance certificates were handed over, before which the building could not be lived in (Cass. 3e civ., 13 February 2025, No. 23-17.755). The firm compares each call for funds with the progress certificates and challenges premature calls.
Can you hold back the final 5% balance on delivery of an off-plan property?
Yes, if conformity is disputed. The 5% balance is payable when the unit is made available to the buyer, but it may be paid into a deposit account if conformity with the contract is disputed (Article R. 261-14 of the French Construction and Housing Code). The deposit protects the buyer without depriving them of the keys: the Court of Cassation quashed the judgment of the court of appeal that allowed the seller to keep the keys until actual payment, “whereas a deposit counts as payment” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 15 December 2010, No. 09-67.232).
The Paris Court of Appeal, hearing an appeal against an interim order, reads the text broadly: a deposit is allowed for non-conformities as well as for defects and disorders, and “a mere dispute is enough to make the deposit, and the seller's consent is not required” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 8, 3 March 2023, No. 22/11125). In that case, the buyer had noted twenty-three snags on delivery. The same court nevertheless ordered the buyer to pay the €14,950 balance on an interim basis once the snags had for the most part been cleared, finding that, “given the minor nature of the finishing works still to be carried out, the obligation to pay the balance of the price is not seriously disputable” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 8, 3 March 2023, No. 22/11125).
A deposit presupposes a dispute over conformity, which it is prudent to put in writing, although the Paris Court of Appeal holds that a mere dispute is enough, and the balance may fall due again once the seller has remedied the defects. It does not replace a court claim, which is what interrupts the one-year period under Article 1648, paragraph 2, of the Civil Code (Article 2241). The firm drafts the snag list, arranges the deposit with a third party and monitors the clearing of snags. See our article on non-conformity at delivery.
The developer has defaulted: how do you call on the completion guarantee?
Before concluding an off-plan sale of a home, the seller must take out a financial guarantee of completion of the building or of repayment of the sums paid. The completion guarantee can be called on by the buyer if the seller fails financially, which is defined as a lack of the funds needed for completion. The guarantor may have an ad hoc administrator appointed, who has the powers of project owner to have the building completed and to accept the works (Article L. 261-10-1 of the French Construction and Housing Code).
The guarantee is given by a bank, an authorised financial institution, an approved insurance company or a mutual guarantee society (Article R. 261-17), in the form of a credit facility or a guarantee given to the buyer jointly and severally with the seller (Article R. 261-21). It ends on completion as recorded by a qualified professional or an independent inspection body, the latter being mandatory where the seller acts as its own project manager (Article R. 261-24). When the guarantee is called, the guarantor alone is entitled to demand the balance of the price, even if the seller is subject to insolvency proceedings (Article L. 261-10-1).
Its purpose is limited, without ruling out all liability. According to the Paris Court of Appeal, the guarantor “is only required to provide the financing needed to complete the building if the seller defaults, and does not have to take part in carrying out the construction or to take the place of the seller as project owner” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 6, 24 November 2023, No. 21/02986). The guarantor may be held liable for fault if it fails to act diligently, but the court found that it had been diligent and dismissed the buyers' claims. The notary may also be held liable for failing to warn the buyer about an unsuitable guarantee (Cass. 1re civ., 21 January 2026, No. 23-22.937). The firm serves formal notice on the guarantor and brings proceedings against those responsible. See our article on the completion guarantee when the developer defaults.
Late delivery of an off-plan property in France: what compensation can you claim?
The seller of a building to be constructed undertakes to build it within a period set by the contract (Article 1601-1 of the French Civil Code). In the event of delay, it owes damages unless it shows force majeure (Article 1231-1 of the French Civil Code). Where the deed provides for penalties per day of delay, this is a penalty clause that the court may reduce or increase if it is manifestly excessive or derisory; except in the case of definitive non-performance, the penalty is incurred only after formal notice (Article 1231-5 of the French Civil Code).
In a case decided by the Court of Cassation, the stipulated penalties were held to be due until the completion date found by the lower courts. The Court upheld the court of appeal, which had held that “16 March 2018 had to be taken as the date of completion of the works, so that the late-delivery penalties were due until that date” (our translation), since there were no earlier compliance certificates (Cass. 3e civ., 13 February 2025, No. 23-17.755).
Other losses must be proved item by item. The Rennes Court of Appeal awarded €5,025.50 for extra rent and €2,171.40 for interim loan interest, calculated on 161 days of delay attributable to the developer, after rejecting some of the grounds for postponement relied on and accepting others (CA Rennes, 4e ch., 28 August 2025, No. 24/00575). Conversely, the Paris Court of Appeal rejected a claim for loss of rental income by buyers who produced only a price per square metre taken from a website, whereas a zero-interest loan (prêt à taux zéro) presupposed a main residence: the mere fact that they did not live in the property “is not enough to substantiate the loss they claim without at the very least an estimate of the property's rental value by a property professional” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 2 October 2026, No. 23/02860). The firm gathers the evidence for each item before serving formal notice. See our article on late delivery of an off-plan property.
Bad weather, a failed contractor: can the developer justify the delay?
Yes, if it proves force majeure or a legitimate ground provided for in the contract. Force majeure requires an event beyond the debtor's control, which could not reasonably have been foreseen when the contract was concluded and whose effects cannot be avoided by appropriate measures (Article 1218 of the French Civil Code). Off-plan deeds of sale also provide for legitimate grounds for suspending the deadline, such as bad weather or the failure of a contractor.
The Court of Cassation has held not to be unfair a clause which, for a legitimate ground for suspension evidenced by a letter from the project manager, doubles the length of the recorded suspensions because of their impact on the organisation of the site: it “is not unfair” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 23 May 2019, No. 18-14.212). According to the Paris Court of Appeal, such events “are contingencies that may amount to legitimate grounds for suspending the delivery deadline insofar as the seller, who owes the obligation to deliver, has no control over them” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 2 October 2026, No. 23/02860), provided they are clearly defined and certified.
The burden of proof remains on the seller. The Rennes Court of Appeal disregarded the 146 days of bad weather announced in a mere letter from the developer, on the ground that “That letter was not, however, accompanied by a letter from the project manager, so that it is insufficient to prove the alleged delay” (our translation) (CA Rennes, 4e ch., 28 August 2025, No. 24/00575), but it accepted 73 of them on the strength of a table certified by a company in the project management team, as well as 58 days of force majeure linked to the health crisis, which were doubled under the contract, reducing the delay attributable to the seller from 350 to 161 days. The checks cover the project manager's certificate, the weather records of the station named in the contract, the period actually affected and the information given to buyers. For developers, the firm drafts precise clauses and builds this file as the works progress; for buyers, it disputes each day of postponement.
How do you record snags at handover of an off-plan property, and when must you act?
By noting precisely in the handover report each visible defect and each discrepancy with the specification or the plans. The seller cannot be released from visible construction defects or non-conformities either before the works are accepted or before one month has elapsed after the buyer takes possession (Article 1642-1 of the French Civil Code). The claim must then be brought, on pain of being time-barred, within one year of the date on which the seller can be released (Article 1648, paragraph 2).
Defects discovered after delivery are still covered if they are reported in time: the Court of Cassation holds that the buyer may act against the seller for one year in respect of visible defects, “even if the defects were reported after that one-month period had expired” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 13 February 2025, No. 23-17.755). Recording completion is not an acknowledgement that the building conforms to the contract (Article R. 261-1 of the French Construction and Housing Code).
The one-year period is strict. An application for interim relief interrupts it (Article 2241 of the French Civil Code), but only a new one-year period then runs: buyers who had obtained orders requiring the snags to be cleared, subject to a daily penalty, and then an expert assessment, and who had issued proceedings on the merits more than a year after the last order, “were time-barred in their action” (our translation) according to the Court of Cassation (Cass. 3e civ., 11 July 2019, No. 18-17.856). The seller avoids rescission or a price reduction by undertaking to carry out repairs (Article 1642-1). The firm attends the handover, drafts the snag list and then sets the timetable for the steps that interrupt the period. See our article on visible defects in an off-plan purchase.
The floor area delivered is smaller than in the contract: what remedy?
The off-plan deed of sale must describe the property sold and contain the relevant information on its nature (Article L. 261-11 of the French Construction and Housing Code), and the reservation already states an approximate habitable area (Article R. 261-25). A shortfall in area is therefore first and foremost a failure to conform to the contract.
The area is measured according to the regulatory definition, not according to an implied agreement. The Court of Cassation quashed the judgment of a court of appeal that had required the buyers to prove a common intention to exclude the low-ceilinged parts: in an off-plan deed, “the stipulated area means a habitable area within the meaning of Article R. 111-2 of the same Code, excluding parts of premises less than 1.80 metres high” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 18 March 2021, No. 19-24.994). The definition is now found in Article R. 156-1, which deducts the areas taken up by walls, partitions, steps, stairwells, ducts and door and window openings, and excludes in particular unconverted attics, cellars, garages, terraces, loggias and balconies, as well as parts less than 1.80 metres high.
Where the shortfall is visible on delivery, it falls under the regime for visible non-conformities: snags, then a claim within the year (Article 1648 of the French Civil Code), the seller being able to avoid a price reduction by undertaking to carry out repairs (Article 1642-1). The firm has the unit measured by a professional, compares the result with the attached plans and calculates the price reduction to be claimed.
Defects after delivery: what warranties apply against the developer-seller?
From acceptance of the works, the seller of a building to be constructed is bound by the obligations for which architects, contractors and other builders are liable under Articles 1792 to 1792-3 of the French Civil Code. These warranties benefit successive owners of the building (Article 1646-1 of the French Civil Code). The seller is thus strictly liable for damage that compromises the soundness of the works or makes them unfit for their intended purpose, unless an external cause is shown (Article 1792).
These warranties are in addition to the action for visible defects. According to the Court of Cassation, “the buyer may bring both the action under the ten-year liability and the action for repair of visible defects” (our translation), and for the ten-year liability, “whether the defect was visible is assessed from the standpoint of the project owner and as at the date of acceptance of the works” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 14 January 2021, No. 19-21.130). A defect visible to the buyer on delivery, but hidden for the seller when the works were accepted, may therefore still fall under the ten-year liability. In that case, the co-owners' association (syndicat des copropriétaires) obtained partial cassation of the judgment that had held it time-barred for several defects.
The seller must also, save for the exceptions provided by law and before the works begin, have taken out building damage insurance (assurance dommages-ouvrage), which pre-finances repairs of a ten-year nature without any need to establish liability (Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code). The detailed rules on the builders' warranties are set out on our construction law lawyer page. See also our article on the ten-year liability in an off-plan purchase.
Property development contract: what does the developer owe the project owner?
A property development contract is a mandate in the common interest by which the developer undertakes to have a construction programme carried out, for an agreed price, by means of construction contracts, and to carry out all or part of the legal, administrative and financial operations. The developer guarantees the performance of the obligations of the contractors with which it has dealt on behalf of the project owner and is bound by the obligations under Articles 1792 to 1792-3 of the French Civil Code (Article 1831-1 of the French Civil Code).
For a residential building, the contract must be recorded in writing before it is performed, stating the land, the characteristics of the building, the specifications, the price and its revision, the financing, the developer's remuneration, the time frame and its guarantee of proper performance, on pain of nullity, which only the project owner may invoke until the works are completed (Article L. 222-3 of the French Construction and Housing Code). The engagement ends on delivery only if the construction accounts have been finally settled (Article 1831-4 of the French Civil Code).
The developer's contractual liability has a limit. On 11 June 2026 the Court of Cassation held that “its contractual liability for intermediate defects is subject to proof of personal fault” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 11 June 2026, No. 23-22.360). The same judgment nevertheless partly quashed the decision of the lower court, which had not answered the argument based on a clause making the developer responsible for the choice of contractors and the conformity of the works. The terms of the contract therefore matter as much as the law. The firm drafts these contracts and conducts claims between developers and project owners. See our article on the judgment of 11 June 2026.
Developer or seller facing a claim: how do you defend yourself?
By checking the time limits first. A claim for visible defects and non-conformities is time-barred one year after the date on which the seller can be released from them (Article 1648 of the French Civil Code), and an interruption only starts a new one-year period: the Court of Cassation found that buyers who had issued proceedings on the merits too late “were time-barred in their action” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 11 July 2019, No. 18-17.856). The seller also avoids rescission or a price reduction by undertaking to carry out repairs (Article 1642-1 of the French Civil Code).
On delay, the Court of Cassation has held not to be unfair a clause on legitimate grounds for suspension evidenced by a letter from the project manager (Cass. 3e civ., 23 May 2019, No. 18-14.212), each ground still having to be proved. The losses claimed must be proved: the Paris Court of Appeal rejected a claim for lost rent that was not supported by a professional estimate of the rental value (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 2 October 2026, No. 23/02860). The contractual penalty may be reduced if it is manifestly excessive (Article 1231-5 of the French Civil Code).
On delivery, a balance paid into a deposit account may fall due again on an interim basis once the snags have for the most part been cleared and the obligation to pay is no longer seriously disputable (CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 8, 3 March 2023, No. 22/11125). The completion guarantor is bound to finance completion, its liability for fault requiring a lack of diligence in implementing the guarantee (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 6, 24 November 2023, No. 21/02986). Lastly, under a property development contract, intermediate defects require proof of personal fault on the developer's part, subject to contract clauses extending its liability (Cass. 3e civ., 11 June 2026, No. 23-22.360), and nullity for lack of a written contract can be invoked only by the project owner, until the works are completed (Article L. 222-3 of the French Construction and Housing Code). The firm defends developers, sellers and delegated project owners before the court-appointed expert and the court.
What fees does an off-plan property and development lawyer charge?
Fees are set out in a written fee agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971, save for the exceptions provided for in that text: before you commit, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs. The agreement specifies the amount of the fees, or how they are calculated, for the foreseeable work, as well as the expected costs and disbursements. The fixed fee is set after reading the relevant documents: reservation contract, deed of sale and specification, calls for funds, handover report, correspondence with the developer or the guarantor.
The firm prefers a fixed fee for each stage: review of a reservation contract or a deed of sale, drafting of a property development contract, assistance at handover, formal notice or reply, calling on the completion guarantee, urgent proceedings (référé), proceedings on the merits, appeal. Expert and bailiff's report costs are added to the fees. Any new work is covered by an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected billing.
For an initial opinion based on your documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 31 October 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles 1601-1 and 1601-3 of the French Civil Code: sale of a building to be constructed, off-plan sale
- Articles 1642-1, 1646-1 and 1648 of the French Civil Code: visible defects and non-conformities, the seller's warranties, time limit for bringing a claim
- Articles 1792, 1792-1 and 1792-6 of the French Civil Code: builders' liability, acceptance of the works
- Articles 1831-1, 1831-2, 1831-4 and 1831-5 of the French Civil Code: property development contract
- Articles 1217, 1218, 1231-1, 1231-5 and 2241 of the French Civil Code: non-performance, force majeure, damages, penalty clause, interruption
- Articles L261-10, L261-11, L261-11-1, L261-12 and L261-16 of the French Construction and Housing Code: protected sector, content of the deed, price revision, payments, clauses deemed unwritten
- Articles L261-10-1, R261-17, R261-21 and R261-24 of the French Construction and Housing Code: financial guarantee of completion
- Articles L261-15, R261-25, R261-28, R261-29, R261-30 and R261-31 of the French Construction and Housing Code: reservation contract, security deposit, refund
- Articles R261-1 and R261-14 of the French Construction and Housing Code: completion, staged payments, deposit of the balance
- Article L271-1 of the French Construction and Housing Code: withdrawal and cooling-off period for non-professional buyers
- Articles L222-1, L222-3 and L222-4 of the French Construction and Housing Code: property development contract for a residential building
- Article R156-1 of the French Construction and Housing Code: habitable area
- Article L242-1 of the French Insurance Code: building damage insurance (dommages-ouvrage)
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. 3e civ., 23 May 2019, No. 17-17.908: application of the protected off-plan sector
- CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 20 February 2026, No. 24/11718: refund of the security deposit, sale not concluded through the seller's doing
- Cass. 3e civ., 15 December 2010, No. 09-67.232: deposit of the balance counts as payment
- CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 8, 3 March 2023, No. 22/11125: deposit without the seller's consent, balance due once snags are cleared
- CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 6, 24 November 2023, No. 21/02986: scope of the completion guarantor's obligation
- Cass. 1re civ., 21 January 2026, No. 23-22.937: the notary's duty to advise on the completion guarantee
- Cass. 3e civ., 13 February 2025, No. 23-17.755: visible defects reported after the one-month period, completion date and penalties
- Cass. 3e civ., 11 July 2019, No. 18-17.856: one-year time bar after interruption
- Cass. 3e civ., 14 January 2021, No. 19-21.130: ten-year liability and the action for visible defects may both be brought
- Cass. 3e civ., 18 March 2021, No. 19-24.994: habitable area stipulated in the off-plan deed
- Cass. 3e civ., 23 May 2019, No. 18-14.212: legitimate grounds for suspension clause not unfair
- CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 2 October 2026, No. 23/02860: legitimate grounds for postponement, proof of lost rent
- CA Rennes, 4e ch., 28 August 2025, No. 24/00575: proof of grounds for postponement, bad weather partly accepted, losses caused by the delay
- Cass. 3e civ., 11 June 2026, No. 23-22.360: property developer, intermediate defects and personal fault
Further reading
An off-plan reservation, a late delivery, snags still outstanding?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the reservation contract, the deed of sale and the specification, the calls for funds, the handover report and your correspondence with the developer or the buyer: Hassan Kohen reviews the time limits, the guarantees and the grounds for postponement relied on, then tells you which route suits your case: formal notice, deposit of the balance, calling on the guarantee, urgent proceedings, or bringing or defending a claim in court.