Kohen Avocats, withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment in Paris
Life Support Withdrawal Lawyer in Paris: contest end-of-life decisions
Intensive care, vegetative or minimally conscious state, limitation of active treatment: as life support withdrawal lawyers, the firm assists the trusted person (personne de confiance) and the family during the collegial procedure, then before the urgent applications judge of the administrative court and the Council of State (Conseil d'État). It also helps patients draft precise advance directives.
Reachable 24/7. When seised of an urgent application to protect a fundamental freedom (référé-liberté), the urgent applications judge of the administrative court rules within forty-eight hours under the Code; the order can be appealed to the Council of State within fifteen days of its notification.
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his thorough command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a case involving a protection order abusively requested by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution found for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with great empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar — end of life and withdrawal of treatment, before the administrative court and the Council of State.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 12 October 2026.
Quick answer
When a patient can no longer express their wishes, the withdrawal or limitation of their treatment is decided by the doctor in charge, on the ground that unreasonable obstinacy (obstination déraisonnable) must be avoided, after a collegial procedure, in accordance with the patient's advance directives or after consulting the trusted person, the family or those close to the patient. The decision is reasoned and communicated. A family that contests it can apply to the urgent applications judge of the administrative court, then appeal to the Council of State, and the doctor cannot carry out the decision before that challenge has been able to be brought and decided. Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th arrondissement, acts during the collegial procedure and before the court. Reachable on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A decision announced, a collegial meeting, a challenge to bring?
Understanding your situation
Withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment in Paris, explained
End-of-life care is governed by Articles L. 1110-5 et seq. and L. 1111-4 et seq. of the French Public Health Code (Code de la santé publique). Two laws amended them in 2026: the law of 26 May 2026 on support and palliative care, which redefines the collegial procedure, then the law of 18 August 2026 on the right to assisted dying (aide à mourir). Withdrawal of treatment (arrêt des traitements) on the ground of unreasonable obstinacy remains a medical decision, regulated and reviewed by the courts. It forms part of the firm's health law practice. What you need to know, step by step.
Key points
What the law allows, and on what conditions
The rules of the Public Health Code in force on 12 October 2026, and the court that reviews them.
No unreasonable obstinacy: treatments that are useless, disproportionate or that have no effect other than the mere artificial prolongation of life may be suspended or not started (Article L. 1110-5-1).
A conscious patient decides: anyone may refuse or discontinue a treatment, and the doctor respects their wishes after informing them of the consequences (Article L. 1111-4).
A patient unable to express their wishes: collegial procedure, respect for advance directives or, failing that, consultation of the trusted person, the family or those close to the patient.
Care continues: artificial nutrition and hydration are treatments, but support and palliative care remain due until the end (Article L. 1110-5-1).
In a public hospital, the medical decision can be brought before the urgent applications judge of the administrative court, then before the Council of State. The judge does not take the place of the care team; the judge checks that the decision falls within the cases provided for by law, with an expert assessment if necessary. Withdrawal of treatment must not be confused with assisted dying, a separate regime created in August 2026, which requires a request from the person themselves.
Two situations
When the patient can still express their wishes, or no longer can
Who decides in each case, and what role for relatives.
The patient can express their wishes
- They take the decisions about their health together with the doctor and may refuse any treatment; if they thereby put their life in danger, they must reiterate their decision within a reasonable time (Article L. 1111-4).
- They may request deep and continuous sedation in the cases provided for by Article L. 1110-5-2.
- They may appoint a trusted person and write or revise advance directives at any time.
The patient can no longer express their wishes
- The doctor in charge decides, after a collegial procedure (Article R. 4127-37-2).
- The doctor must respect the advance directives, except in a life-threatening emergency or where the directives are manifestly inappropriate and set aside collegially (Article L. 1111-11).
- In the absence of directives, the doctor gathers the testimony of the trusted person, which prevails, or that of the family and those close to the patient (Articles L. 1111-6 and L. 1111-12).
The family does not decide in the patient's place, but it is heard and informed. What it reports of the patient's wishes carries weight in the medical decision, and then before the court.
At each stage, a statutory safeguard can be checked:
Step by step
From the collegial procedure to the urgent applications judge
What the lawyer does before the decision, then when it is contested.
Making the patient's wishes heard
Written request to initiate the collegial procedure or for information about it, testimonies, advance directives, the patient's own writings: these are handed to the care team before the meeting.
Reading the reasons
The decision is reasoned and recorded in the medical file; the trusted person or the family is informed of its nature and of the reasons for it (Article R. 4127-37-2, IV). The lawyer checks the composition of the collegial panel and the consultant.
Applying to the urgent applications judge
Application for an urgent order to protect a fundamental freedom (référé-liberté) before the administrative court (Article L. 521-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice, Code de justice administrative), with the available medical documents and, where necessary, a request for an expert assessment.
The Council of State
Appeal within fifteen days of notification of the order (Article L. 523-1). The judge assesses the situation as it stands on the date of the ruling, including how it has evolved.
The doctor cannot carry out the decision before the persons consulted who may wish to apply to the court have been able to do so and obtain a ruling (CE, 21 December 2022, No. 463391). The court still has to be seised in time.
Timeline
How a challenge unfolds
The typical stages, from the start of the collegial procedure to the order of the Council of State.
Initiation of the collegial procedure
On the doctor's initiative or at the request of the trusted person, the family or someone close to the patient; they are informed as soon as it is initiated.
Meeting and decision
Consultation within the care team, reasoned opinion of at least one consultant, inquiry into the patient's wishes, then a reasoned decision by the doctor in charge.
Informing the family
Nature of and reasons for the decision, often with a date for implementation. This is the moment to state in writing the intention to apply to the court.
Urgent application before the administrative court
The judge rules within forty-eight hours under Article L. 521-2; if the judge orders an expert assessment, the decision may be suspended while the case is examined, as in the case decided on 3 November 2025.
Appeal before the Council of State
Within fifteen days of notification of the order, without the obligation to be represented by a lawyer (Article R. 523-3 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
After the order
If the patient's condition changes, a new collegial procedure may lead to a new decision, which can itself be challenged.
Preparing the file
Advance directives and documents to gather
What establishes the patient's wishes and makes it possible to discuss the medical decision.
The advance directives, written, dated and signed, or the attestation of the two witnesses (Article R. 1111-17).
The document appointing the trusted person, co-signed by that person (Article L. 1111-6).
The reasoned decision and the reports provided by the medical team, with their dates.
Writings, messages or testimonies reporting what the patient said about the end of their life.
Opinions of outside doctors consulted by the family, and exchanges about a possible transfer.
The guardianship or curatorship judgment, if the patient is under a protection measure.
Access to the medical file is governed by Article L. 1111-7 of the Public Health Code: for the patient or, if the patient is under a protection measure with representation relating to the person, for the person in charge of that measure, disclosure no later than eight days after the request, after a forty-eight-hour cooling-off period, or within two months for information more than five years old. Send what you have, even if incomplete, on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Thirteen answers based on the Public Health Code in force and on verified decisions of the Council of State.
What is unreasonable obstinacy in French end-of-life law?
The Public Health Code prohibits starting or continuing medical acts that amount to unreasonable obstinacy. Where they appear useless, disproportionate or have no effect other than the mere artificial prolongation of life, they may be suspended or not started, in accordance with the patient's wishes or, if the patient can no longer express them, after a collegial procedure (Article L. 1110-5-1). Artificial nutrition and hydration are treatments within the meaning of that provision.
The concept is not limited to how serious the patient's condition is. The Council of State points this out: “the mere fact that a person is in an irreversible state of unconsciousness or, a fortiori, of loss of autonomy making them dependent on such a means of supporting vital functions cannot, in itself, characterise a situation in which continuing that treatment would appear unjustified on the ground of refusing unreasonable obstinacy” (our translation) (CE, urgent applications judge, 3 November 2025, No. 508990, decision on Légifrance).
The doctor must rely on a set of medical and non-medical factors specific to each patient: their current condition, how it is evolving, their suffering, the prognosis and the wishes they may have expressed.
Who decides to withdraw treatment when the patient can no longer express their wishes?
The doctor in charge of the patient, after a collegial procedure (Article R. 4127-37-2 of the Public Health Code). The family and those close to the patient do not decide; they are informed and, in the absence of advance directives, consulted. The decision respects the advance directives; in their absence, it can only be taken after the testimony of the wishes expressed by the patient has been gathered from the trusted person or, failing that, from the family or someone close to the patient (Article L. 1111-4).
Where the decision concerns a minor or a protected adult with representation relating to the person, the doctor also gathers the opinion of the holders of parental authority or of the person in charge of the measure, unless an emergency makes that consultation impossible.
The decision is reasoned and recorded in the medical file. The trusted person, or failing that the family or someone close to the patient, is informed of its nature and of the reasons for it. These documents, meeting reports and written reasons, are what the lawyer reads first, because the judge will read them too.
How does the collegial procedure work?
Since the law of 26 May 2026 on support and palliative care, Article L. 1110-5-1 of the Public Health Code defines the collegial procedure as a multidisciplinary consultation between the available members of the care team and the doctor in charge of the patient, including as far as possible the patient's regular doctor, the referring doctor of the medico-social facility and a professional from the team supporting the patient at home or in a facility. How it operates is left to regulations.
The regulatory provision in force on 12 October 2026 remains Article R. 4127-37-2: consultation with the members of the care team present and a reasoned opinion from at least one consultant doctor with no hierarchical link to the doctor in charge. A second consultant is called in if one of them considers it useful. The trusted person, the family or someone close to the patient is informed as soon as the procedure is initiated.
In practice, the family can ask to be received, put forward what the patient said about the end of their life and hand over written material. The firm prepares these testimonies with the family, before the collegial meeting.
Can the family ask for the collegial procedure to be initiated?
Yes. The doctor in charge of the patient may initiate the collegial procedure on their own initiative, but is required to do so at the request of the trusted person or, failing that, the family or someone close to the patient (Article R. 4127-37-2, II, of the Public Health Code). This option is also open to a family that considers the treatments have become unreasonable: it can ask for the question to be examined collegially.
The request is preferably made in writing, addressed to the doctor in charge and to the head of department, and kept. It dates the exchange and secures, at the end of the procedure, a reasoned decision. Once the procedure is initiated, informing the trusted person or the family is mandatory.
In both cases, the decision taken remains a medical one. If it is contested, the urgent applications judge checks that it falls within the cases provided for by law.
Are advance directives binding on the doctor in France?
In principle, yes. Advance directives are binding on the doctor for any decision on investigation, intervention or treatment (Article L. 1111-11 of the Public Health Code). Two exceptions are provided for: a life-threatening emergency, for the time needed for a full assessment of the situation, and directives that appear manifestly inappropriate or not suited to the medical situation.
In the second case, the refusal to apply them can only be decided after a collegial procedure. The doctor gathers the opinion of the care team and that of at least one consultant doctor with no hierarchical link to them; the doctor may gather the testimony of the trusted person or of those close to the patient (Article R. 4127-37-1). The decision to refuse is reasoned, recorded in the file and brought to the attention of the trusted person or, failing that, the family.
Directives work both ways: they can ask for treatments to be withdrawn or for them to be continued. If several exist, the most recent prevail, whatever their medium.
How do you write valid advance directives in France?
Advance directives are a written document, dated and signed by their adult author, identified by surname, first name, date and place of birth (Article R. 1111-17 of the Public Health Code). A person who cannot write or sign, while still able to express their wishes, may ask two witnesses, including the trusted person if one has been appointed, to attest that the document expresses their will, freely formed and informed. An adult under a protection measure with representation relating to the person writes them with the authorisation of the judge or the family council.
An official template exists; it distinguishes the situation of a person who knows they have a serious illness from that of a person who does not (Article R. 1111-18). The directives can be stored in the shared medical record (dossier médical partagé), or entrusted to the regular doctor, the trusted person or someone close (Article R. 1111-19). They can be revised and revoked at any time.
A useful text states precisely which treatments the person accepts or refuses, and in which situations. The firm helps word it so that it is not found inappropriate for lack of precision.
What is the role of the trusted person (personne de confiance)?
Any adult may appoint a trusted person, a relative, someone close or their regular doctor, who will be consulted if they themselves can no longer express their wishes (Article L. 1111-6 of the Public Health Code). The trusted person reports the person's wishes, and their testimony prevails over any other testimony. The appointment is made in writing and co-signed by the person appointed; since the law of 26 May 2026, that person receives a guide setting out their role.
The judge checks in concrete terms that the trusted person was consulted. In a case decided in 2026, the Council of State noted that their testimony had been gathered throughout the hospital stay and on the day before the collegial meeting, so that “the argument that the trusted person provided for in Article L. 1111-6 of the Public Health Code was not consulted, whereas Article L. 1111-4 of the same code requires this where the patient is unable to express their wishes, is unfounded in fact” (our translation) (CE, urgent applications judge, 30 June 2026, No. 516675, decision on Légifrance).
The trusted person therefore has every reason to keep a record of each meeting with the medical team.
How can you urgently challenge a decision to withdraw life-sustaining treatment?
In a public hospital, the usual route is the référé-liberté before the urgent applications judge of the administrative court: the judge may order any measure needed to protect a fundamental freedom that is being seriously and manifestly unlawfully infringed, and rules within forty-eight hours (Article L. 521-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice). The Council of State describes a particular role: the judge “must then take the protective measures necessary to prevent its implementation where that decision might not fall within the cases provided for by law” (our translation) (CE, urgent applications judge, 3 November 2025, No. 508990, decision on Légifrance).
The application sets out, at least briefly, the facts and the legal arguments and shows the urgency (Article R. 522-1). It is exempt from the requirement to be represented by a lawyer (Article R. 522-5), but it is built on precise medical documents and testimonies. The judge may sit as a panel of three judges and order a medical expert assessment.
If the facility is private, the route of challenge depends on its status: it must be determined before any application to the court.
Can the doctor withdraw treatment before the judge has ruled?
No, where the persons consulted wish to apply to the court. The Council of State holds that a doctor who decides to withdraw treatment “cannot implement that decision before the persons they have consulted, who might wish to bring a challenge before the competent court, have been able to do so and obtain a decision from it” (our translation) (CE, 21 December 2022, No. 463391, decision on Légifrance).
In that case, decided on an application for suspension (référé-suspension), the Council of State set aside the order of an urgent applications judge who had rejected the family's application without further examination, although it was seriously argued that the decision might not fall within the cases provided for by law. The case was sent back to the administrative court.
In practical terms, a family considering a challenge must say so clearly to the medical team, in writing, and apply to the court without waiting for the date announced for the withdrawal. The time between the decision and its implementation is often only a few days.
Can the judge rule in the family's favour?
Yes, where the facility does not show that the legal conditions are met. In September 2026, the Council of State upheld the suspension of a decision limiting therapies taken for a tetraplegic patient whose condition had improved and for whom a rehabilitation stay had been proposed; it held that “the conditions for applying the provisions of Article L. 1110-5-1 of the Public Health Code are not, as of today, met” (our translation) (CE, urgent applications judge, 9 September 2026, No. 518545, decision on Légifrance).
The opposite outcome is common. In the orders of 3 November 2025 and 30 June 2026 cited on this page, the judge found, on the basis of expert assessments or medical evidence covering several months, that continuing the treatments amounted to unreasonable obstinacy.
The outcome depends on the medical facts, how they evolve and the patient's wishes. The lawyer does not promise a result: the lawyer checks the procedure, gathers the evidence pointing the other way, requests an expert assessment where it is useful and puts forward any new element.
What happens after the administrative court's order?
An order made on a référé-liberté can be appealed to the Council of State within fifteen days of its notification; the President of the Litigation Section or the delegated judge rules within forty-eight hours, according to the text (Article L. 523-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice). This appeal is exempt from the requirement to be represented by a lawyer (Article R. 523-3).
The situation is not frozen for all that. The patient's condition may change, and the medical team may reopen a collegial procedure and take a new decision. In the case decided on 3 November 2025, a new collegial meeting had been held while the appeal was pending. In the case of 9 September 2026, it was the improvement in the patient's condition that led the judge to maintain the suspension.
The firm ensures continuity in the case: collegial procedure, administrative court, Council of State, then follow-up of later medical decisions.
Withdrawal of treatment and assisted dying in France: what is the difference?
Withdrawal of treatment on the ground of refusing unreasonable obstinacy most often concerns a patient who can no longer express their wishes: the decision is medical, taken after a collegial procedure. When the doctor then withdraws a life-sustaining treatment, the doctor implements deep and continuous sedation combined with analgesia (Article L. 1110-5-2 of the Public Health Code), unless the patient objected to it in their advance directives (Article R. 4127-37-3).
Assisted dying, created by Law No. 2026-794 of 18 August 2026, rests, by contrast, on a request from the person themselves. It requires in particular a serious and incurable illness that is life-threatening, suffering that is refractory or unbearable, and the ability to express their will freely and in an informed way (Article L. 1111-12-2). The doctor's decision can only be challenged by the person who made the request, before the administrative courts; the only exception is that the person in charge of a protection measure may challenge, within two days of its notification, the decision authorising a protected adult to access it (Article L. 1111-12-10).
A relative therefore cannot request assisted dying in the patient's place. The two regimes are distinct, and a dispute over withdrawal of treatment is not argued under the rules on assisted dying.
What are the lawyer's fees for a withdrawal of treatment case?
Fees are set in agreement with the client. Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971 requires a written fee agreement, except in an emergency, in cases of force majeure or where the lawyer acts under full legal aid: the client knows what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee for each stage: support during the collegial procedure, urgent application before the administrative court, appeal before the Council of State, drafting advance directives or appointing a trusted person. Any new engagement is covered by an amendment to the agreement.
Legal aid (aide juridictionnelle) can be requested, subject to means testing. For a first written opinion, the preliminary case review, at €80 incl. VAT through the form on this page, lets you send the medical decision and the reports. First conversation on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, in the version in force on 12 October 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts and decisions
- Article L. 1110-5 of the Public Health Code: right to a dignified and supported end of life
- Article L. 1110-5-1 of the Public Health Code: unreasonable obstinacy and collegial procedure
- Article L. 1110-5-2 of the Public Health Code: deep and continuous sedation
- Article L. 1111-4 of the Public Health Code: consent, refusal of treatment, patient unable to express their wishes
- Article L. 1111-6 of the Public Health Code: trusted person
- Article L. 1111-11 of the Public Health Code: advance directives
- Article L. 1111-12-10 of the Public Health Code: challenges to a decision on assisted dying
- Article R. 4127-37-1 of the Public Health Code: refusal to apply advance directives
- Article R. 4127-37-2 of the Public Health Code: limitation or withdrawal of treatment
- Article R. 1111-17 of the Public Health Code: form of advance directives
- Article L. 521-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice: urgent application to protect a fundamental freedom (référé-liberté)
- Article L. 523-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice: appeal to the Council of State
- Law No. 2026-404 of 26 May 2026: support and palliative care
- Law No. 2026-794 of 18 August 2026: right to assisted dying
- CE, 21 December 2022, No. 463391: no implementation before the court has been able to rule
- CE, urgent applications judge, 3 November 2025, No. 508990: role of the judge and unreasonable obstinacy
- CE, urgent applications judge, 30 June 2026, No. 516675: consultation of the trusted person
- CE, urgent applications judge, 9 September 2026, No. 518545: suspension maintained after improvement
A life support withdrawal decision to challenge?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the announced decision, the reports and any advance directives: the lawyer checks the collegial procedure, prepares testimonies on the patient's wishes and, if necessary, applies to the urgent applications judge of the administrative court, then to the Council of State. For compulsory psychiatric care, see our page on involuntary psychiatric admission.