They talk about us
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, involuntary psychiatric hospitalisation in Paris
Involuntary commitment lawyer in Paris: challenging compulsory care
Kohen Avocats acts as an involuntary commitment lawyer in Paris (hospitalisation sous contrainte) for patients and their families. Admission at the request of a third party, imminent danger or a prefect's order: the firm assists the patient and their relatives before the judge of the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) who reviews the measure, then on appeal before the first president of the court of appeal, including on seclusion and restraint. The hearing is prepared on the basis of the medical certificates and the time limits.
Reachable 24/7. The judge must be seised within eight days of admission and must rule before the twelfth day. An appeal against the judge's order must be lodged within ten days of notification, and within twenty-four hours when the order concerns seclusion or restraint.
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution provided for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, shows great empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen carefully and to fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar — psychiatric care without consent, before the judicial court and the court of appeal.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 12 October 2026.
Quick answer
Involuntary hospitalisation (hospitalisation sous contrainte), or psychiatric care without consent (soins psychiatriques sans consentement), is ordered by the director of the hospital, at the request of a third party or in the event of imminent danger, or by the prefect. It is always reviewed by a judge: the judge of the judicial court (magistrat du siège du tribunal judiciaire), formerly the liberty and custody judge (JLD), must be seised within eight days of admission and must rule before the twelfth day, then every six months. At the hearing, the patient is assisted or represented by a lawyer, whom they may choose. A relative may also apply for the measure to be lifted at any time. Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th arrondissement, acts before the judge and on appeal: lawfulness of the procedure, certificates, time limits, seclusion and restraint. Reachable on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A hearing before the judge, a seclusion measure, a decision to challenge?
Understanding your situation
Involuntary psychiatric hospitalisation in Paris, explained
Psychiatric care without consent is governed by Articles L. 3211-1 et seq. of the French Public Health Code (Code de la santé publique). The law sets a principle, consent to care, and frames its exceptions under the review of the ordinary courts. This review is systematic: no full-time hospitalisation continues beyond twelve days without a judge having ruled. The firm's health law practice is organised around these safeguards. What you need to know, step by step.
Key points
Three routes to admission, one judicial review
What the Public Health Code requires before any measure, and who reviews it.
The principle: no one may receive psychiatric care without their consent, except in the cases provided for by law (Article L. 3211-1 of the Public Health Code).
At the request of a third party: mental disorders that make consent impossible, a condition requiring immediate care, and two medical certificates less than fifteen days old (Article L. 3212-1).
For imminent danger: where no third party is available, a certificate from a doctor who does not work at the hospital, and notification of the family within twenty-four hours, save in particular difficulties.
By decision of the prefect: mental disorders that endanger people's safety or seriously breach public order, and a reasoned order (Article L. 3213-1).
In all cases, restrictions on liberties must remain appropriate, necessary and proportionate to the person's mental state (Article L. 3211-3). Review lies with the judge of the judicial court within whose jurisdiction the receiving hospital is located, that is, the Paris judicial court for a hospital in Paris. Since 1 September 2024, the articles that organise this review refer to this judge (magistrat du siège du tribunal judiciaire) and no longer to the liberty and custody judge (JLD); the former term remains common in decisions and in hospital departments.
Two situations
You are hospitalised, or a relative is
What the law guarantees the patient, and what a relative can do on their side.
If you are the patient
- To be informed of the admission decision, its grounds, your rights and the available remedies, in a manner suited to your condition (Article L. 3211-3).
- To seek advice from a lawyer or a doctor of your choice, to send and receive mail, and to refer the matter to the departmental commission for psychiatric care.
- To be heard by the judge, assisted or represented by a lawyer of your choice, appointed under legal aid or assigned by the court (Article L. 3211-12-2).
If you are a relative
- To apply to the judge yourself, at any time, for the measure to be lifted, as a spouse, civil partner, cohabiting partner, relative or person acting in the patient's interest (Article L. 3211-12).
- To bring useful information to the judge's attention, since the judge may act of their own motion.
- To exercise, at the patient's request, most of their rights: contacting the authorities, referring the matter to the commission, consulting a lawyer.
The judge reviews the lawfulness of the procedure and the merits of the measure in the light of the medical evidence. The judge does not make a new diagnosis: the defence is built on the documents, the time limits and the consistency of the certificates.
At each stage, a legal safeguard can be checked:
Step by step
Challenging the measure before the judge
From the first certificate to the court order, what the lawyer does at each stage.
Gathering the decisions and certificates
Director's decision or prefect's order, third-party request, initial certificates, then the twenty-four-hour and seventy-two-hour certificates (Article L. 3211-2-2): each document is dated, signed and reasoned, or it is not.
Automatic judicial review
The director or the prefect refers the case to the judge within eight days of admission, and the judge rules before the twelfth day (Article L. 3211-12-1). The patient may also apply to the judge directly, at any time.
An adversarial hearing
The judge normally sits in a dedicated courtroom within the hospital. The patient is heard, unless a reasoned medical opinion advises otherwise; their lawyer consults the file and argues both the lawfulness of the procedure and the merits.
Release or continuation
The judge orders the measure to be lifted, if necessary with effect deferred by no more than twenty-four hours so that a care programme can be drawn up, or maintains full-time hospitalisation (Article L. 3211-12-1, III).
An irregularity leads to the measure being lifted only if it has infringed the person's rights (Article L. 3216-1). The lawyer demonstrates this infringement document by document and, where possible, proposes care outside the hospital.
Timeline
The time limits that govern the measure
The deadlines set by the Public Health Code, from admission to the six-monthly review.
Twenty-four hours
Full physical examination and a certificate from a psychiatrist of the hospital who did not write the admission certificates (Article L. 3211-2-2).
Seventy-two hours
A new certificate. If both certificates conclude that care must continue, the psychiatrist proposes the form of care: full-time hospitalisation or a care programme.
Eighth day
Deadline for the director or the prefect to refer the case to the judge. A late referral leads the judge to find that the measure is lifted, save in exceptional circumstances.
Twelfth day
The judge must have ruled. Failing that, the full-time hospitalisation is lifted by operation of law (Article L. 3211-12-1, V).
Every month
For care at the request of a third party or for imminent danger, continuation for periods of one month, on the basis of a certificate drawn up in the last three days of each period (Article L. 3212-7).
Six months
A new mandatory review if full-time hospitalisation continues without interruption; the judge is seised at least fifteen days before the deadline.
After the court order
Appeal within ten days of notification before the first president of the court of appeal (Article R. 3211-18), who rules within twelve days of the appeal being lodged (Article R. 3211-22).
Preparing for the hearing
Documents to gather
What makes it possible to check the procedure and to offer the judge a credible alternative.
The director's admission decision or the prefect's order, and each decision to continue the measure.
The third party's request, with their identity and the nature of their relationship with the patient.
All medical certificates and opinions: initial, twenty-four-hour, seventy-two-hour and monthly.
The document notifying the patient of their rights and remedies, with its date.
Where applicable, the seclusion or restraint decisions and their renewals.
The elements for discharge: accommodation, follow-up by a community psychiatrist, available family and friends, a protection judgment if one exists.
Send what you have, even if incomplete. A hospitalised patient may consult the documents at the hospital, and the court registry provides a copy to any lawyer who requests one (Article R. 3211-13). The firm sets priorities with you on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen answers based on the Public Health Code currently in force and on verified judgments of the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation).
Do I need a lawyer before the judge who reviews an involuntary commitment in France?
Yes. Before the judge of the judicial court, as before the first president of the court of appeal, the hospitalised person is assisted or represented by a lawyer (Article R. 3211-8 of the Public Health Code). They may choose the lawyer themselves. Otherwise, a lawyer is appointed under legal aid or assigned by the court (Article L. 3211-12-2 of the same code). If a reasoned medical opinion stands in the way of their being heard, they are represented by their lawyer. The other parties, the hospital director, the prefect or the third party who requested the care, are not required to have one.
Choosing a lawyer early leaves time to read the certificates, check every date and prepare a concrete discharge plan before the review hearing, which takes place within the first twelve days. A relative may contact the firm on the patient's behalf. It is then the patient who confirms the choice of counsel, because the lawyer defends the patient's liberty and voice, not those of the family.
What is the difference between admission at a third party's request, for imminent danger and by order of the prefect?
Care at the request of a third party is decided by the hospital director, on an application by a family member or by a person who can show a prior relationship with the patient. Two medical certificates less than fifteen days old are required, the first from a doctor who does not work at the hospital (Article L. 3212-1 of the Public Health Code). In an emergency, where there is a serious risk to the patient's integrity, a single certificate may suffice (Article L. 3212-3).
Imminent danger allows admission without a third-party request, where it proves impossible to obtain one, on the basis of a certificate from a doctor from outside the hospital. The director must then inform the family within twenty-four hours, save in particular difficulties.
The prefect's decision concerns people whose mental disorders require care and endanger people's safety or seriously breach public order. The order must be reasoned and state the circumstances precisely (Article L. 3213-1). In Paris, in the event of imminent danger attested by a medical opinion, the police commissioners (commissaires de police) take the provisional measures, which lapse after forty-eight hours without a decision by the prefect (Article L. 3213-2).
How long can involuntary psychiatric hospitalisation last in France?
The law sets no maximum duration. It requires regular reviews. After admission, a seventy-two-hour observation period takes place in full-time hospitalisation, with a certificate at twenty-four hours and another at seventy-two hours (Article L. 3211-2-2 of the Public Health Code). If either of them concludes that the person's condition no longer justifies the measure, the director lifts it immediately (Article L. 3212-4).
For care at the request of a third party or for imminent danger, the director may then maintain the care for one month, then for renewable periods of one month, on the basis of a certificate drawn up in the last three days of each period. Beyond one year, continuation requires an in-depth assessment by a panel (collège), renewed every year. Failure to produce a certificate results in the measure being lifted (Article L. 3212-7).
The judge, for their part, reviews full-time hospitalisation before the twelfth day, then before the end of each six-month period if it continues without interruption (Article L. 3211-12-1).
What happens if the judge is not seised or does not rule in time?
The time limits are strict. Where the judge has not ruled before the twelfth day, or before the end of the six-month period, the full-time hospitalisation is lifted by operation of law (Article L. 3211-12-1, V, of the Public Health Code). Where the judge is seised after the eighth day, they find without a hearing that the measure is lifted, save in exceptional circumstances that caused the delay.
The Court of Cassation restated this in the case of a patient readmitted after running away: “if the judge is seised after this time limit has expired, the judge finds without a hearing that the release from full-time hospitalisation has taken effect, unless exceptional circumstances causing the late referral are shown” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 24 May 2018, No. 17-21.056, decision on courdecassation.fr). The judgment refers to the former numbering of the text and to the liberty and custody judge; the rule has remained the same.
A release obtained because of a delay does not rule out all care: if the medical conditions are still met, a care programme outside full-time hospitalisation may be put in place (Article L. 3211-12-5). The lawyer therefore checks the dates to the day, then discusses what happens next.
Is a procedural error enough to be released?
Not on its own. An irregularity in an admission or continuation decision leads to the measure being lifted only if it has infringed the person's rights (Article L. 3216-1 of the Public Health Code). An unreasoned decision, a certificate drawn up by a doctor who was not authorised to do so, or late or missing information on rights are therefore argued in the light of their concrete effect on the patient.
The irregularity must still be raised. The Court of Cassation holds that the judge seised “is never required to raise of its own motion the plea based on the irregularity of the procedure under the provisions of this code” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 5 March 2020, No. 19-24.080, decision on courdecassation.fr). In that case, the patient had not criticised the prefect's order on appeal on the point he later relied on, and his appeal to the Court of Cassation was dismissed.
This is one of the reasons why the file is read in full before the hearing: what the lawyer does not raise, the judge does not have to look for.
Can the judge order release if the psychiatrists ask for the measure to continue?
The judge reviews whether the measure is justified, but does not replace the doctor. The Court of Cassation states that, when ruling on the continuation of full-time hospitalisation, “the judge must examine whether the measure is justified in the light of the medical evidence, provided by the parties or obtained at the judge's request, without being able to make an assessment of a medical nature” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 8 February 2023, No. 22-10.852, decision on courdecassation.fr). It quashed an order that had lifted the measure even though all the certificates, regular and detailed, concluded that it should continue.
The defence therefore does not consist in setting the patient's opinion against that of the psychiatrists. It focuses on what the judge can check: are the two legal conditions actually described, are the certificates detailed or copied from one day to the next, is the proposed form of care reasoned? The judge may also order an expert assessment, entrusted to psychiatrists who do not work at the hospital (Article R. 3211-14); the time limit for ruling is then extended by no more than fourteen days (Article L. 3211-12-1).
Admission for imminent danger: must the family be informed?
In principle, yes. When the director orders an admission for imminent danger, they inform within twenty-four hours, save in particular difficulties, the person's family, the person responsible for their legal protection or, failing that, a person who can show a prior relationship with them (Article L. 3212-1, II, 2°, of the Public Health Code). This information allows a relative to apply to the judge and to share what they know.
The patient nevertheless retains the right to the confidentiality of information concerning them. The Court of Cassation has held that “the fact that the person receiving psychiatric care without consent refuses to have their family informed of this measure constitutes a particular difficulty within the meaning of this text” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 26 October 2022, No. 20-23.333, decision on courdecassation.fr).
A failure to inform is therefore not argued in the same way depending on whether or not the patient refused to have their relatives informed. The lawyer looks in the file for what the hospital recorded on this point.
Can the patient be denied a hearing by the judge?
Being heard is the rule. At the hearing, the person is heard, assisted or represented by a lawyer; they are exempted from appearing only if a reasoned medical opinion establishes that medical reasons, in their interest, stand in the way of their being heard (Article L. 3211-12-2 of the Public Health Code). Hearings are public, but they are held in chambers (chambre du conseil) if the patient so requests.
The Court of Cassation ensures this safeguard on appeal. It holds that “the first president may dispense with hearing the person admitted for psychiatric care only if a doctor's opinion shows medical reasons which, in that person's interest, stand in the way of their being heard” (our translation), or in the event of an insurmountable circumstance (Cass. 1re civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-18.095, decision on courdecassation.fr). The order that merely noted the patient's absence was quashed.
A patient who wishes to speak to the judge should tell their lawyer and the care team, so that their attendance can be arranged.
Seclusion and restraint: what time limits and what review by the judge?
Seclusion and restraint are measures of last resort, reserved for patients in full-time hospitalisation without consent, to prevent immediate or imminent harm, on the reasoned decision of a psychiatrist (Article L. 3222-5-1 of the Public Health Code). Seclusion is ordered for no more than twelve hours, renewable up to a total of forty-eight hours; restraint, applied in the context of seclusion, for no more than six hours, renewable up to a total of twenty-four hours.
Beyond that, renewal is exceptional: the director informs the judicial court, the doctor informs a relative, and the judge must be seised before the seventy-second hour of seclusion or the forty-eighth hour of restraint. The judge rules within twenty-four hours. The patient or a relative may also apply at any time for the measure to be lifted (Article L. 3211-12).
This procedure is in writing, without a hearing, but the patient is entitled to be heard if they request it (Article L. 3211-12-2, III). An appeal against the order must be lodged within twenty-four hours of its notification (Article R. 3211-42).
How do I appeal against the judge's decision?
The order of the judge of the judicial court may be appealed before the first president of the court of appeal or their delegate, within ten days of its notification (Article R. 3211-18 of the Public Health Code). The judge states this time limit orally when notifying the decision at the hearing (Article R. 3211-16). The appeal is lodged by a reasoned declaration sent by any means to the registry of the court of appeal (Article R. 3211-19).
An appeal does not have suspensive effect. Where the judge orders the measure to be lifted, only the public prosecutor (procureur de la République) may ask for the appeal to be given suspensive effect, within six hours of notification, by relying on a serious risk to the integrity of the patient or of others (Article L. 3211-12-4). The first president then rules on this request without delay.
Unless the appeal has suspensive effect, the first president rules within twelve days of the appeal being lodged, or twenty-five days if an expert assessment is ordered (Article R. 3211-22). The declaration must state reasons: the appeal is prepared as soon as the order is read.
What rights does a patient have during involuntary hospitalisation?
Restrictions on liberties must be appropriate, necessary and proportionate to the person's mental state and to the treatment required; their dignity must be respected in all circumstances (Article L. 3211-3 of the Public Health Code). Before each decision to continue the measure, the person is informed of the proposed decision and given the opportunity to submit observations, insofar as their condition allows.
The person is informed of the admission decision and its grounds, of their legal situation, their rights and the available remedies. They have the right to communicate with the authorities, to refer the matter to the departmental commission for psychiatric care and to the users' committee, to alert the Inspector General of Places of Deprivation of Liberty (Contrôleur général des lieux de privation de liberté), to seek advice from a doctor or lawyer of their choice, to send and receive mail, to consult the hospital's internal rules, to vote and to practise their religion.
Most of these rights may be exercised, at the person's request, by their relatives or by a person able to act in their interest. They also retain the right to choose their practitioner or mental health team (Article L. 3211-1).
Can a relative apply to end the hospitalisation?
Yes, and at any time. The judge may be asked to order, at short notice, the immediate lifting of a care measure, whatever its form (Article L. 3211-12 of the Public Health Code). The application may be made by the patient, the holders of parental authority or the guardian of a minor, the person in charge of a protection measure, the spouse, cohabiting partner or civil partner (PACS), the person who requested the care, a relative or a person able to act in the patient's interest, or the public prosecutor.
The application is dated and signed. It states the identity of the applicant, that of the patient and the hospital where the patient is staying, and sets out the facts (Article R. 3211-10). The judge may also act of their own motion, and any interested person may send them useful information.
The relative is not, however, the patient's lawyer: if their positions differ, each may be advised separately. The firm starts by hearing what the patient wants.
Can you obtain compensation after an unlawful involuntary hospitalisation?
The lawfulness of administrative admission and continuation decisions can be challenged only before the ordinary courts (Article L. 3216-1 of the Public Health Code). The same text provides that, when the judicial court rules on claims for compensation for the harmful consequences of these decisions, it may examine any irregularities affecting them.
A compensation claim requires gathering the whole file: decisions, certificates, the judge's orders, the duration of the measure, personal and professional consequences. A release ordered for irregularity, or an order finding an infringement of rights, is often the starting point.
The firm also handles the assessment of losses within its personal injury practice. For a failure in supervision or care during the hospitalisation, other rules and other courts may apply depending on the status of the hospital: the route is chosen case by case, after reading the documents.
What are the fees for an involuntary hospitalisation case?
Fees are set in agreement with the client. Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971 requires a written fee agreement, save in cases of urgency, force majeure or work under full legal aid: the client knows what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: review hearing before the judge, application for release, challenge to seclusion or restraint, appeal before the first president. Any new engagement is covered by an amendment to the agreement.
The patient may also be assisted by a lawyer appointed under legal aid or assigned by the court (Article L. 3211-12-2 of the Public Health Code). For a first written opinion, the preliminary case review, at €80 incl. VAT through the form on this page, allows you to send the admission decision and the certificates. First contact on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, in the version in force on 12 October 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts and decisions
- Article L. 3211-1 of the Public Health Code: principle of consent to psychiatric care
- Article L. 3211-3 of the Public Health Code: patient's rights and proportionality
- Article L. 3211-2-2 of the Public Health Code: observation period and certificates
- Article L. 3211-12 of the Public Health Code: application for release at any time
- Article L. 3211-12-1 of the Public Health Code: systematic judicial review
- Article L. 3211-12-2 of the Public Health Code: hearing, being heard and lawyer
- Article L. 3211-12-4 of the Public Health Code: appeal before the first president
- Article L. 3212-1 of the Public Health Code: third-party request and imminent danger
- Article L. 3213-1 of the Public Health Code: admission by decision of the prefect
- Article L. 3216-1 of the Public Health Code: irregularities and infringement of rights
- Article L. 3222-5-1 of the Public Health Code: seclusion and restraint
- Article R. 3211-8 of the Public Health Code: assistance or representation by a lawyer
- Article R. 3211-18 of the Public Health Code: ten-day time limit for appeal
- Cass. 1re civ., 24 May 2018, No. 17-21.056: late referral to the judge
- Cass. 1re civ., 5 March 2020, No. 19-24.080: irregularity not raised by the court of its own motion
- Cass. 1re civ., 26 October 2022, No. 20-23.333: informing the family and confidentiality
- Cass. 1re civ., 8 February 2023, No. 22-10.852: role of the judge and medical opinions
- Cass. 1re civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-18.095: hearing the patient on appeal
An involuntary commitment to challenge?
The firm is reachable 24/7. Send the admission decision, the certificates and the hearing date: the lawyer checks the procedure, prepares the patient's hearing and argues the case before the judge of the judicial court, then, if necessary, before the first president of the court of appeal. For an end-of-life question in intensive care, see also our page on withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment.