Kohen Avocats, medical malpractice and personal injury lawyers in Paris
Medical malpractice lawyer in Paris: proving fault, obtaining redress
An operation that went wrong, a diagnosis made too late, an infection caught in hospital, a risk nobody told you about, a relative who died after treatment: as medical malpractice lawyers in Paris, the firm assists patients and their families against doctors, private clinics, public hospitals and their insurers, before the CCI (regional conciliation and compensation commission), ONIAM (the national medical accident compensation office) and the courts.
The firm can be reached 24/7. The claim becomes time-barred ten years after consolidation (the date the injury stabilises), but a short time limit applies against a public hospital: where its rejection decision states the available remedies and time limits, the administrative court must be seised within two months of its notification.
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a case involving a protection order abusively sought by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution provided for my defence before the court. All the best
Mr Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He listens very well, shows great empathy and a strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Mr Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, kind and available, who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Avocat at the Paris Bar, medical liability and personal injury, before the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire), the administrative court, the CCI and ONIAM.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 26 October 2026.
Medical malpractice situations
Choose your situation
Quick answer
A medical malpractice lawyer establishes the fault, links it to the injury and has each head of loss quantified. A doctor, a private clinic or a hospital is liable for their acts only where there is fault (Article L. 1142-1 of the French Public Health Code (Code de la santé publique)); a clinic or a hospital, on the other hand, is strictly liable for hospital-acquired (nosocomial) infections, unless there is an external cause. Where there is no fault, ONIAM compensates a medical accident that is abnormal and sufficiently serious. The claim becomes time-barred ten years after consolidation. The dispute goes before the judicial court for a private clinic or a doctor in private practice, and before the administrative court for a public hospital, after the CCI has possibly been seised. Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th, acts from obtaining the medical records through to judgment. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
An operation that went wrong, a diagnosis made too late, a relative who died after treatment?
Understanding your situation
Medical malpractice in Paris, explained
French law does not speak of medical error (erreur médicale) but of fault, therapeutic hazard (aléa thérapeutique) and hospital-acquired infection: this distinction determines who pays, which court has jurisdiction and how fault is proved. This page sets out the common rules. Each frequent situation has its own detailed analysis, accessible from the carousel above, from the firm's medical law articles and from its personal injury page.
Key points
Fault, hazard or infection: who compensates, and on what conditions
Three separate regimes, one common time limit.
Health professionals and healthcare establishments are liable for the harmful consequences of acts of prevention, diagnosis or treatment only where there is fault (Article L. 1142-1, I, of the Public Health Code). The burden of proving fault lies in principle with the patient, but the Cour de cassation holds that harm caused by a surgeon, in performing the surgical procedure, "to an organ or tissue that the operation did not involve, is a fault" (our translation), unless an anomaly made the harm unavoidable or the risk was inherent and falls under therapeutic hazard (Cass. 1re civ., 25 May 2023, No. 22-16.848).
Healthcare establishments, services and organisations are liable for hospital-acquired infections unless they prove an external cause (same article, I, paragraph 2). A doctor in private practice, by contrast, is liable for them only where there is fault. The most serious infections, above 25 % permanent impairment or in the event of death, are compensated by ONIAM (Article L. 1142-1-1).
Where there is no fault, a medical accident gives a right to compensation under national solidarity if it is directly attributable to the treatment, if it had abnormal consequences in view of the patient's state of health and its foreseeable development, and if it reaches a severity threshold (Article L. 1142-1, II): permanent impairment above 24 %, or six months off work or of temporary functional deficit of at least 50 % (Article D. 1142-1). Abnormality is established where the procedure caused "consequences significantly more serious than those to which the patient was exposed with sufficient probability in the absence of treatment" or, failing that, where the occurrence of the harm "had a low probability" (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 15 October 2025, No. 24-14.186).
All these claims become time-barred ten years after the consolidation of the injury (Article L. 1142-28). Referral to the CCI suspends this time limit until the end of the amicable procedure (Article L. 1142-7).
The firm acts for patients and, in the event of death, for their relatives. The most frequent situations have their own analysis: misdiagnosis, surgical error, hospital-acquired infection, failure to inform the patient and death following medical fault.
Two courts
Private clinic or doctor, or public hospital
Where the treatment took place determines the court, the procedure and the time limits.
Private clinic or doctor in private practice
- The dispute falls within the jurisdiction of the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire). The opponents are the practitioner, the clinic and their insurers.
- Before any trial, a medical expert assessment can be requested by way of urgent application (référé) if there is a legitimate reason to establish evidence of the facts (Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure).
- The court then rules on fault, causation and each head of loss, on the basis of the expert report.
Public hospital, including the AP-HP
- The dispute falls within the jurisdiction of the administrative court. In principle, the opponent is the establishment, not the doctor working there.
- A claim for compensation must first be sent to the hospital: the court can be seised only after its decision (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
- The hospital's refusal opens a two-month period to bring the case before the court, enforceable if it was stated in the notification together with the available remedies (Article R. 421-5).
The Versailles administrative court of appeal points this out: the victim may ask the court, "within two months following notification of the decision rejecting the claim" (our translation), for compensation for any harm arising from the same event, and a claim filed after that period is out of time (CAA Versailles, 5e ch., 26 June 2025, No. 23VE00479). The CCI remains available in both cases, and referral to it suspends the limitation and litigation time limits (Article L. 1142-7 of the Public Health Code).
What the firm seeks, depending on the case:
Situations
Diagnosis, surgery, infection, information
The four areas in which the firm acts most often.
Misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis
A wrong diagnosis is not a fault in itself: the fault lies in tests that were not ordered or signs that were overlooked. Where it is not certain that the harm would have been avoided, the victim obtains compensation for a loss of chance, "corresponding to a fraction of the various heads of loss" (our translation), measured by the extent of the chance lost and not by the seriousness of the fault (Cass. 1re civ., 12 September 2018, No. 17-22.311). After a delayed diagnosis of a tumour, the Paris judicial court thus found a loss of chance of survival assessed at 58 % (TJ Paris, 19e ch., 24 June 2024, No. 21/14439). See our analysis of late cancer diagnosis.
Surgical procedure and complications
Injury to an organ that the operation did not target is presumed to be a fault, unless there is an anatomical anomaly or an inherent risk that could not be controlled (Cass. 1re civ., 25 May 2023, No. 22-16.848). Conversely, a known complication that occurs despite a correctly performed procedure falls under therapeutic hazard and, depending on its severity, under ONIAM. The expert assessment decides between the two. See our analysis of surgical error.
Hospital-acquired infection
The clinic or hospital is strictly liable for an infection contracted during treatment, unless there is an external cause. The Cour de cassation specifies that this regime applies to healthcare establishments, and not to a company of radiologists, which is not an establishment within the meaning of the text (Cass. 1re civ., 10 November 2021, No. 19-24.227). Above 25 % permanent impairment, ONIAM takes over (Article L. 1142-1-1 of the Public Health Code). See our analysis of hospital-acquired infection.
The risk nobody told you about
The patient must be informed of frequent or serious risks that are normally foreseeable, and it is for the professional or the establishment to prove that the information was given (Article L. 1111-2). The Paris Court of Appeal holds that, where the risk materialises, the failure causes "certain and separate non-pecuniary harm resulting from a lack of preparation for the consequences of such a risk" (our translation), and upheld the judgment that had awarded 10,000 euros on that basis (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 10, 4 July 2024, No. 21/09365). See our analysis of failure to inform the patient.
Medical fault may also constitute a criminal offence. Involuntary manslaughter is punishable by three years' imprisonment (Article 221-6 of the French Criminal Code), and unintentional injury causing more than three months' incapacity by two years (Article 222-19). Where the doctor did not directly cause the harm, a gross fault (faute caractérisée) or the manifestly deliberate breach of a safety obligation is required (Article 121-3).
Timeline
How a medical malpractice case unfolds
From the medical records to the judgment, with the time limits.
The medical records
The patient has access to them directly or through a doctor of their choice, within eight days of the request, or within two months if the information is more than five years old (Article L. 1111-7 of the Public Health Code).
The explanation owed
The professional or the establishment must inform the person who considers themselves a victim of the circumstances and causes of the harm, no later than fifteen days after its discovery or the request, at a meeting at which the person may be assisted (Article L. 1142-4).
The expert assessment
It is ordered by the CCI or by the court, by way of urgent application. It is the central document: the firm prepares the questions, assists the patient with a medical adviser and challenges the report where needed. See our analysis on challenging an unfavourable expert report.
The CCI
Seised in the area where the treatment took place (Article R. 1142-13), it gives its opinion within six months where the harm reaches the severity threshold. This opinion can only be challenged in the compensation claim before the court (Article L. 1142-8).
The offer
If the CCI finds a fault, the insurer of the liable party must make an offer within four months of the opinion (Article L. 1142-14); if it remains silent or refuses, ONIAM steps in instead (Article L. 1142-15). If it finds a therapeutic hazard, ONIAM makes the offer within the same time limit (Article L. 1142-17).
The court
Failing agreement, or if the offer is insufficient, the judicial court or the administrative court determines liability and quantifies each head of loss. Accepting an offer amounts to a settlement (transaction): it must be reviewed before it is signed.
Preparing the case
The documents to gather
What the expert and the court will examine, and what the firm reads first.
The complete medical records: operation and hospital stay reports, monitoring charts, test results, imaging.
Documents signed before the procedure: information sheets, consent form, quotes, referral letters.
Follow-up after the harm: medical certificates, sick notes, prescriptions, opinions of the doctors consulted afterwards.
Evidence of losses: payslips, tax notices, invoices for care, home help or adaptations.
Correspondence with the establishment: complaints, replies, minutes of the meeting at which the harm was explained.
Documents already received: CCI opinion, expert report, offer from the insurer or ONIAM, the hospital's rejection decision.
Send what you have, even if incomplete: the firm first identifies the time limits running and the competent court, then works with you to request the missing documents. Call +33 6 89 11 34 45.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Twelve answers based on the texts in force on 26 October 2026 and on case law.
What does a medical malpractice lawyer do in France?
They turn a suspicion into a case. They obtain the medical records, have them read by a medical adviser, characterise what happened (fault, therapeutic hazard or hospital-acquired infection) and choose the route: CCI, negotiation with the insurer, urgent application for an expert assessment or a claim on the merits. The choice depends on where the treatment took place, the severity of the harm and the time limits running.
They then assist the patient at the expert assessment, which most often decides the outcome, challenge the report where needed and quantify each head of loss. Finally, they argue the case before the judicial court or the administrative court when no offer is made or the offer remains insufficient. For the first steps, see our analysis of the first thirty days after a medical error.
How do I get my medical records in France?
By a written request to the establishment or the practitioner. Everyone has access to the information about their health held by professionals and establishments, directly or through a doctor they designate. The records must be provided no later than eight days after the request, and within two months where the information is more than five years old (Article L. 1111-7 of the Public Health Code).
After harm has occurred, a second obligation applies: the establishment must explain the circumstances and causes of the harm no later than fifteen days after its discovery or the express request, at a meeting at which the patient may be assisted (Article L. 1142-4). A refusal or silence should be noted and kept on record. See our analysis of the hospital that says nothing after an accident.
How do you prove medical negligence in France?
By expert assessment, in principle. The burden of proving fault lies with the patient, and the doctor's obligation is one of means (obligation de moyens): the harm alone is not enough. Causation between the fault and the harm may, however, be proved "by any means and in particular by presumptions, provided they are serious, precise and consistent" (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 8 September 2021, No. 20-13.773).
In the same judgment, the Cour de cassation overturned a court of appeal that had inferred causation from the mere sequence of medical acts: chronology does not replace proof. Some rules lighten the burden: injury to an organ that the operation did not target is presumed to be a fault (Cass. 1re civ., 25 May 2023, No. 22-16.848), and it is for the doctor to prove that they informed the patient (Article L. 1111-2 of the Public Health Code).
What is loss of chance in a medical negligence claim?
It is the harm compensated where it cannot be said that, without the fault, the harm would not have occurred. The Cour de cassation holds that the harm then consists of "a loss of the chance of escaping that harm or of suffering less serious harm, corresponding to a fraction of the various heads of loss, assessed by the trial judges by measuring the extent of the chance lost and not by assessing the nature or seriousness of the fault" (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 12 September 2018, No. 17-22.311).
In practice, the expert assessment sets a percentage, which is applied to each head of loss. The Paris judicial court found a 58 % loss of chance of survival after a delayed diagnosis (TJ Paris, 19e ch., 24 June 2024, No. 21/14439); the Paris administrative court of appeal found 50 % for a patient who had not been sufficiently informed before an operation (CAA Paris, 3e ch., 30 June 2025, No. 24PA01194). See our analysis of how loss of chance is calculated.
The doctor did not inform me of the risks: what can I claim?
The information covers the proposed investigations and treatments, their consequences, the frequent or serious risks that are normally foreseeable and the other possible options. In the event of a dispute, it is for the professional or the establishment to prove that it was given, by any means (Article L. 1111-2 of the Public Health Code). The known risks of the procedure must be disclosed where they "either have a significant statistical frequency, whatever their seriousness, or are serious risks, whatever their frequency" (our translation) (CAA Paris, 3e ch., 30 June 2025, No. 24PA01194).
Two types of harm may result. The first is the loss of the chance to have declined the operation: in the case decided in Paris, the AP-HP was ordered to pay 107,470 euros, an amount that also includes compensation for lack of preparation (CAA Paris, 3e ch., 30 June 2025, No. 24PA01194). The second is the harm caused by lack of preparation (préjudice d'impréparation), compensated even without any loss of chance, at 10,000 euros in a judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 10, 4 July 2024, No. 21/09365). See our analysis of failure to inform the patient.
I caught an infection in hospital: who is liable?
The establishment where the treatment was carried out, without you having to prove fault. Healthcare establishments, services and organisations are liable for harm resulting from hospital-acquired infections unless they prove an external cause (Article L. 1142-1, I of the Public Health Code). The Cour de cassation points out the difference between the regimes: "health professionals are liable only where there is fault, whereas the establishments, services and organisations in which acts of prevention, diagnosis or treatment are carried out are strictly liable, unless they prove an external cause" (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 10 November 2021, No. 19-24.227).
Where the infection causes permanent impairment above 25 % or death, compensation is paid by ONIAM under national solidarity (Article L. 1142-1-1). The firm first checks the exact place of treatment and whether the infection was hospital-acquired. See our analysis of hospital-acquired infection.
Can you file a criminal complaint against a doctor in France?
Yes, where the fault caused death or injury. Involuntary manslaughter is punishable by three years' imprisonment and a fine of 45,000 euros (Article 221-6 of the French Criminal Code); unintentional injury causing total incapacity for work of more than three months, by two years and 30,000 euros (Article 222-19).
The threshold is higher than in civil proceedings. Where the doctor did not directly cause the harm but created the situation that made it possible, criminal liability requires a manifestly deliberate breach of a duty of care or safety, or a gross fault (faute caractérisée) exposing others to a particularly serious risk that the doctor could not have been unaware of (Article 121-3). The criminal route is therefore not always the quickest way to obtain compensation: it is chosen case by case, alongside the civil or administrative route.
Do I have to go to the CCI before going to court?
It is not compulsory, but it is often useful. The commission may be seised by any person who considers themselves the victim of harm attributable to treatment, or by their heirs and dependants (Article L. 1142-7 of the Public Health Code), in the area where the treatment took place (Article R. 1142-13). It gives an opinion on the circumstances, causes and extent of the harm where it reaches the severity threshold, within six months of being seised (Article L. 1142-8).
Referral to it suspends the limitation period. The Cour de cassation points this out: "referral to the conciliation and compensation commission suspends the limitation and appeal time limits until the end of the amicable settlement procedure" (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 16 March 2022, No. 20-15.172). The opinion does not bind the court: it can only be challenged in the compensation claim. See our analysis of the CCI procedure.
The insurer makes no offer, or the offer is too low: what can I do?
Where the CCI considers the harm attributable to a fault, the insurer of the liable party must send an offer within four months of the opinion, aimed at full compensation of the losses (Article L. 1142-14 of the Public Health Code). In the event of silence or refusal, the victim may ask ONIAM to step in for the insurer; ONIAM then seeks recovery from the liable party (Article L. 1142-15).
The court seised by ONIAM may then order the insurer or the liable party to pay ONIAM a sum of up to 15 % of the compensation awarded; the Cour de cassation upheld a decision placing this sum on the clinic that had not joined its insurer to the proceedings (Cass. 1re civ., 16 February 2022, No. 20-19.333). An insufficient offer should not be accepted: accepting it amounts to a settlement. See our analysis of an insufficient ONIAM offer.
Medical negligence in a French public hospital: which court, which time limits?
The administrative court, against the establishment. A claim for compensation must first be sent to the hospital: an application seeking payment of a sum of money is admissible only after the administration has decided on that claim (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
The refusal opens a two-month period, enforceable if the notification states the available remedies and time limits (Article R. 421-5). The Versailles administrative court of appeal held out of time the claim of a patient who had brought the case before the court after that period: a new claim sent to the hospital years later had not reopened the time limit (CAA Versailles, 5e ch., 26 June 2025, No. 23VE00479). This is one of the first points the firm checks. See our analysis of medical errors in a public hospital or private clinic.
What is the time limit for a medical negligence claim in France?
Ten years from the consolidation of the injury, for claims against health professionals and healthcare establishments, public or private, as well as for claims brought before ONIAM (Article L. 1142-28 of the Public Health Code). Consolidation is the date from which the state of health has stabilised; it is set by the expert assessment, not by the date of the operation.
Referral to the CCI suspends this time limit (Article L. 1142-7). Where ONIAM has stepped in for the insurer and the victim has accepted its offer, the amicable procedure ends and the time limit starts running again from that acceptance (Cass. 1re civ., 16 March 2022, No. 20-15.172). Against a public hospital, the two-month period following a notified refusal applies in addition to the limitation period.
How much does a medical malpractice lawyer cost in France?
Fees are agreed with the client and set out in a written fee agreement, except in cases of urgency, force majeure or full legal aid (Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971): before committing, the patient knows what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm works in stages: analysis of the medical records, assistance at the expert assessment, the CCI procedure, court action. The law prohibits fees set solely on the basis of the court outcome, but it allows an additional fee linked to the result obtained, provided for in the fee agreement from the outset.
For a first written opinion, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT can be requested using the form on this page. First conversation on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page and the firm's pages dedicated to each situation.
Official texts and decisions
- Article L. 1142-1 of the Public Health Code, fault, hospital-acquired infection, national solidarity
- Article L. 1142-1-1, serious hospital-acquired infections
- Article D. 1142-1, severity thresholds
- Article L. 1111-2, patient information and proof
- Article L. 1111-7, access to medical records
- Article L. 1142-4, information about the harm
- Articles L. 1142-7 and L. 1142-8, referral to the CCI and its opinion
- Articles L. 1142-14, L. 1142-15 and L. 1142-17, offers from the insurer and ONIAM
- Article L. 1142-28, ten-year limitation period
- Articles R. 421-1 and R. 421-5 of the Code of Administrative Justice, prior claim and time limit
- Articles 121-3, 221-6 and 222-19 of the Criminal Code, unintentional offences
- Cass. 1re civ., 25 May 2023, No. 22-16.848, injury to an organ not targeted by the operation
- Cass. 1re civ., 12 September 2018, No. 17-22.311, loss of chance
- Cass. 1re civ., 8 September 2021, No. 20-13.773, proof of causation
- Cass. 1re civ., 10 November 2021, No. 19-24.227, hospital-acquired infection
- Cass. 1re civ., 15 October 2025, No. 24-14.186, abnormality of the harm, ONIAM
- Cass. 1re civ., 16 March 2022, No. 20-15.172, CCI and limitation
- Cass. 1re civ., 16 February 2022, No. 20-19.333, no offer, 15 % penalty
- CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 10, 4 July 2024, No. 21/09365, harm from lack of preparation
- CAA Paris, 3e ch., 30 June 2025, No. 24PA01194, failure to inform, AP-HP
- CAA Versailles, 5e ch., 26 June 2025, No. 23VE00479, time limit after the hospital's refusal
A medical error that needs to be recognised?
The firm reads the medical records and the documents you have received, assesses the time limits running and tells you the appropriate route: CCI, negotiation with the insurer, expert assessment by urgent application or a claim on the merits. It can be reached 24/7, and the preliminary case review can be requested using the form on this page.






