Featured in the media
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, hidden defects lawyers in Paris
Hidden defects lawyer in Paris, France: invoke or contest the warranty
Water infiltration, dry rot (mérule), termites, cracks or a non-compliant installation discovered after buying a house or a flat, a serious breakdown in a used car: in France, these may amount to hidden defects (vices cachés). The firm advises buyers who want to cancel the sale or obtain a price reduction, and defends sellers against whom the warranty is invoked. Everything turns on proof of the defect, the clause in the deed of sale and the two-year time limit.
The firm can be reached 24/7. A claim under the warranty against hidden defects must be brought within two years of discovering the defect (Article 1648 of the French Civil Code); a court claim, even an urgent application (référé), interrupts this period (Article 2241), and an expert assessment ordered before any trial suspends it (Article 2239).
4,9/5
Average Google rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
An excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the outcome of my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young yet seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with great empathy and a strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen gave us sound advice and support. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Urgent matters 24/7
Preliminary review of your file
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer at the Paris Bar: warranty against hidden defects, litigation over property sales and vehicle sales, court-ordered expert assessments.
Official profile in the national directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 31 October 2026.
Quick answer
The seller is bound by the warranty against hidden defects in the thing sold that make it unfit for its intended use, or that so diminish that use that the buyer would not have acquired it, or would have paid a lower price for it (Article 1641 of the French Civil Code). The seller is not liable for apparent defects (Article 1642). The buyer chooses between returning the thing against a refund of the price and keeping it against a refund of part of the price (Article 1644); a seller who knew of the defects also owes full damages (Article 1645). A non-warranty clause only protects a seller who was unaware of the defect (Article 1643), and the courts set it aside for a professional seller or a seller who personally carried out the works in question, except against a professional buyer in the same field. The action must be brought within two years of discovering the defect (Article 1648), and no later than twenty years after the sale (Article 2232, according to the Cour de cassation, France's highest court). Kohen Avocats, in the 16th arrondissement of Paris, acts for buyers and sellers alike, in property and vehicle cases. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A defect discovered after the purchase, or a claim received after the sale?
Understanding your situation
Hidden defects (vices cachés) in Paris: the warranty explained
The seller must protect the buyer against hidden defects in the thing sold (Article 1641 of the Civil Code). What counts as a hidden defect, what the clause in the deed is worth, the time limits to meet, the role of the expert assessment, and what the buyer can obtain, or what the seller can argue in defence.
Key points
A hidden defect: four conditions to meet
What the buyer must prove, and what the seller will contest first.
A defect in the thing sold itself, not mere disappointment on the buyer's part: the warranty covers defects in the thing (Article 1641 of the Civil Code).
A serious defect, which makes the thing unfit for its intended use, or so diminishes that use that the buyer would not have acquired it, or would have paid a lower price, had they known of it (Article 1641).
A hidden defect: the seller is not liable for apparent defects which the buyer could have seen for themselves (Article 1642).
A defect that existed before the sale; the burden of proving this defect and the other conditions lies with the buyer, who is claiming performance of the obligation (Article 1353).
According to the Cour de cassation, “an apparent defect is one whose full extent and consequences the buyer was able to ascertain” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-16.847). In that case, a survey report annexed to the deed mentioned house longhorn beetles (capricornes) in the attic, and the court of appeal had dismissed the buyer's claims. Its judgment was quashed, because “the buyer had not grasped the extent of the infestation and its consequences” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-16.847). A sign visible during viewings is therefore not enough to rule out the warranty if the extent of the damage could not be measured.
Seriousness, on the other hand, has to be proved. The Paris Judicial Court (tribunal judiciaire) dismissed the claims of the buyers of a flat whose waste water outlet was connected to the rainwater downpipe. The seriousness required by Article 1641 had not been established, “the mere non-compliance of the connection being insufficient to establish it” (our translation; TJ Paris, 2e ch. 2e sect., 28 October 2025, No. 23/12894). In that case, the court held that non-compliance alone was not enough to establish seriousness.
Two related regimes follow other rules. The seller of a building to be constructed (off-plan sale) is liable for apparent defects within specific time limits, and bears the builders' warranties from acceptance of the works (Articles 1642-1, 1646-1 and 1648, paragraph 2); a person who sells, after completion, a building they built or had built is deemed to be a builder (Article 1792-1). The warranty does not apply to sales made by order of the court (Article 1649). See also our article on water infiltration discovered after buying a flat in Paris.
The deed of sale
The non-warranty clause: when it protects the seller, and when it falls away
Its scope depends on who the seller is and what they knew.
The principle: the seller is liable for hidden defects even if unaware of them, unless, in that case, the seller has stipulated that they will not be bound by any warranty (Article 1643 of the Civil Code). The clause therefore only covers a seller who was unaware of the defect.
The seller in bad faith: if they knew of the defect, the clause does not apply, and they owe, in addition to refunding the price, full damages (Article 1645). The burden of proving that knowledge lies with the buyer (Article 1353).
The professional seller: they are irrebuttably presumed to know the defects in what they sell, and cannot rely on the clause, except against a professional buyer in the same field. The Paris Court of Appeal treated as such a property dealer (marchand de biens) whose articles of association also covered renovation works.
The seller who personally carried out the works that caused the defect: they are treated as a professional seller, even if they are not a construction professional.
Missing diagnostic reports: if, when the authentic deed of sale (acte authentique) is signed, one of the valid lead, asbestos, termite, gas, electricity or non-mains drainage (assainissement non collectif) reports is missing, the seller cannot exclude the corresponding warranty against hidden defects (Article L. 271-4 of the French Construction and Housing Code).
The Cour de cassation recently restated this: “a seller who, without being a construction professional, personally carried out the works that caused the defects in the thing sold is treated as a professional seller” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-11.221). The sellers had carried out major works over twelve to thirteen years, some of them on the structure; they could not rely on the clause. For professional sellers, the commercial chamber applies “an irrebuttable presumption that the professional seller knows of the defect in the thing sold, which obliges it to make good all the damage resulting from it” (our translation; Cass. com., 5 July 2023, No. 22-11.621).
The Paris Court of Appeal treated as a professional a property dealer company whose articles of association also covered renovation works. Ruling on that company's claim against its own seller, it noted that “as a professional seller, it was incumbent on it to have all necessary checks carried out on the compliance of the works” (our translation; CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 10 July 2026, No. 24/02204). The company was ordered to pay, among other sums, €56,591.17 excl. VAT for repairs and €11,340 for loss of enjoyment.
The clause remains effective in the ordinary case. Faced with a non-professional seller whose knowledge of the defect had not been shown, the Paris Judicial Court held, in any event, “so that the exclusion of warranty clause must apply” (our translation), and ordered the buyers to pay the costs of the proceedings (TJ Paris, 2e ch. 2e sect., 28 October 2025, No. 23/12894). Before taking action, the firm therefore looks for proof of what the seller knew: works carried out, insurance claims made, minutes of co-ownership general meetings, exchanges before the sale. See our articles on the de facto professional seller and on the exemption clause in property sales.
The timetable
Time limits, expert assessment, procedure: the stages of a hidden defects claim
The two-year period runs fast; a court-ordered expert assessment protects it, provided it is requested in time.
Discovery
The two-year period runs from discovery of the defect (Article 1648, paragraph 1, of the Civil Code). The date of discovery has to be proved: report, quote, official record of findings (constat), written exchanges.
Recording the defect and claiming
Dated photographs, a report drawn up by a judicial officer (commissaire de justice), preservation of the damaged items, then formal notice to the seller. Repairs carried out before an expert assessment can destroy the evidence.
Urgent application for an expert
If there is a legitimate reason to establish, before any trial, evidence of facts on which the outcome of a dispute may depend, an expert assessment can be ordered on an urgent application; where it concerns a building, the court for the place where the building is located has sole jurisdiction (Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure).
Interruption
A court claim, even an urgent application, interrupts the limitation period (Article 2241), and the interruption has effect until the proceedings end (Article 2242).
Suspension
Where the court grants a request for an investigative measure made before any trial, the limitation period is suspended; it starts running again, for a period that cannot be less than six months, from the day the measure was carried out (Article 2239).
Long-stop period
Postponing the starting point or suspending the period cannot extend it beyond twenty years from the day the right arose; interruption by a court claim is not subject to this cap (Article 2232, paragraphs 1 and 2).
The nature of this period long divided the Cour de cassation. Sitting as a mixed chamber, it settled the question: “the two-year period provided for in Article 1648, paragraph 1, of the Civil Code is a limitation period” (our translation), because “the buyer must be able to act against the seller within a period capable of interruption and suspension” (our translation; Cass. ch. mixte, 21 July 2023, No. 21-15.809). The same formation set the outer limit: the action cannot go beyond “the twenty-year long-stop period running from the day the right arose” (our translation), that is to say “the day of the sale concluded by the party against whom the warranty is sought” (our translation; Cass. ch. mixte, 21 July 2023, No. 21-17.789).
Suspension changes the outcome of cases. In a case where the buyer had brought proceedings on the merits almost six years after the order appointing the expert, the court of appeal had held the claim time-barred. The Cour de cassation quashed that judgment: “the two-year limitation period had been suspended between the order of 30 July 2014 and the filing of the expert's report on 30 November 2018” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 11 December 2025, No. 23-19.474). The period then starts running again: proceedings on the merits should not be delayed once the report has been filed.
The mixed chamber points out that “the court cannot base its decision exclusively on a non-judicial expert report produced at the request of one of the parties” (our translation; Cass. ch. mixte, 21 July 2023, No. 21-15.809). A private expert report helps decide whether to act and supports the application for a court-appointed expert, but does not replace one. See our article on preparing a court-ordered expert assessment under Article 145, and our analysis of litigation strategy, evidence and time limits.
Both sides
You are the buyer, or you are the seller facing a claim
The same articles read differently depending on where you stand.
You are the buyer
- Date the discovery of the defect and apply for a court-appointed expert (référé-expertise) within two years.
- Gather evidence of what the seller knew: works they carried out, previous insurance claims, exchanges, diagnostic reports.
- Choose between a refund of the price and a price reduction, and quantify the damages.
You are the seller
- Check the two-year period, its starting point and the twenty-year long-stop period.
- Challenge whether the defect was apparent, how serious it is and whether it predates the sale.
- Rely on the non-warranty clause if you are a non-professional seller acting in good faith, with up-to-date diagnostic reports.
A damages claim does not escape the two-year period. A co-owners' association (syndicat des copropriétaires) had persuaded the Paris Court of Appeal to apply the five-year period of Article 2224. The Cour de cassation quashed that judgment: a damages claim based on a hidden defect can be brought on its own, but “it nonetheless remains subject to the provisions of Article 1648 of the Civil Code” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 19 February 2026, No. 23-22.295). For the seller, checking the dates therefore comes before any argument on the merits. For the buyer, a claim based on fraudulent misrepresentation (dol) remains available alongside the warranty (see the next panel).
The points the firm examines in every case:
Remedies
Cancelling the sale, reducing the price, obtaining compensation
The buyer chooses the route; the amount depends on what the seller knew.
Rescission claim
The buyer returns the thing and obtains a refund of the price (Article 1644 of the Civil Code). A seller who was unaware of the defect also reimburses the costs occasioned by the sale (Article 1646).
Price reduction claim
The buyer keeps the thing and obtains a refund of part of the price (Article 1644), the amount of which is argued on the basis of the expert's findings.
Damages
A seller who knew of the defects is liable, in addition to refunding the price, for all damages owed to the buyer (Article 1645).
Loss of the thing
If the thing perished because of its poor quality, the loss falls on the seller; a loss caused by a fortuitous event remains with the buyer (Article 1647).
Fraudulent misrepresentation
A seller who obtains consent through scheming, lies or the intentional concealment of decisive information commits fraudulent misrepresentation (Article 1137); if it was decisive, it vitiates consent (Article 1130), which opens the way to annulment of the contract and compensation for the loss (Article 1178).
The choice belongs to the buyer, and the case law protects it. “The buyer, who alone has the choice of the actions provided for by law” (our translation), can obtain a price reduction up to the cost of the works left for them to bear, even if a third party has repaired the defect (Cass. 3e civ., 8 February 2023, No. 22-10.743). Such a repair, the Cour de cassation holds, cannot remove “the price-reduction claim allowing the buyer to obtain a refund of the price up to the cost of the works they had to bear to remedy the defect” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 8 February 2023, No. 22-10.743). In that case, heard on appeal in Paris, the co-owners' association had carried out the works. Compensation can also be claimed on its own, since the buyer “may bring the claim for compensation independently of the rescission or price-reduction claim” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 30 January 2020, No. 19-10.176). Buyers who kept a house that had to be demolished thus obtained from the seller in bad faith “damages equivalent to the cost of its demolition and reconstruction” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 30 January 2020, No. 19-10.176).
Other parties may be held liable. The diagnostic surveyor instructed only to produce the termite report “commits a tort that renders it liable to the buyer if it fails to report the visible presence of other wood-boring insects” (our translation; CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 10 October 2025, No. 24/08015). The Paris Court of Appeal ordered it to pay €4,800 and €172.50, and rejected the claim for loss of the chance to negotiate a lower price. Lastly, fraudulent misrepresentation remains available: the warranty claim “does not exclude a claim in tort based on fraud or fraudulent concealment committed before or at the time the contract was concluded” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 23 September 2020, No. 19-18.104).
Vehicles are governed by the same articles of the Civil Code. Where a consumer buys a vehicle from a professional seller, it is also covered by the legal guarantee of conformity (Articles L. 217-1 and L. 217-3 of the French Consumer Code), which does not deprive the buyer of the claim under the warranty against hidden defects (Article L. 217-30). See our articles on hidden defects in a car bought from a private seller and on the annulment of a property sale for fraudulent misrepresentation.
FAQ
Hidden defects in France: frequently asked questions
Thirteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What is a hidden defect (vice caché) in a French property sale?
It is a defect in the house or flat, existing on the day of the sale, that the buyer could not detect. It must be serious enough to make the property unfit for its intended use, or to diminish that use so much that the buyer would not have bought it, or would have paid a lower price, had they known of it (Article 1641 of the Civil Code). Recurrent water infiltration, roof timbers attacked by insects, unstable foundations or a dangerous installation are examples, subject to proof in each case.
The seller is not liable for apparent defects which the buyer could have seen for themselves (Article 1642). But a visible sign is not enough, on its own, to make the defect apparent: everything depends on what the buyer could gauge of its extent. According to the Cour de cassation, “an apparent defect is one whose full extent and consequences the buyer was able to ascertain” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-16.847). The judgment that held against a buyer a survey report mentioning house longhorn beetles in the attic was therefore quashed, since the extent of the infestation could only be discovered through major works.
Seriousness, for its part, must be proved by the buyer (Article 1353). The Paris Judicial Court refused to find a hidden defect in a non-compliant waste water connection in a flat, repaired for just over €5,000, as seriousness had not been shown (TJ Paris, 2e ch. 2e sect., 28 October 2025, No. 23/12894). The firm checks these conditions before any proceedings, on the basis of the documents and, in most cases, an initial technical opinion.
What is the time limit for a hidden defects claim in France?
Two years from discovery of the defect (Article 1648, paragraph 1, of the Civil Code). What counts is not the date of the sale but the date on which the buyer became aware of the defect, which is proved by dated documents: report, quote, official record of findings, email from a professional. The seller may argue for an earlier date; it is better to act without waiting for the end of the period.
This period is a limitation period: “the two-year period provided for in Article 1648, paragraph 1, of the Civil Code is a limitation period” (our translation; Cass. ch. mixte, 21 July 2023, No. 21-15.809). It can therefore be interrupted by a court claim, even an urgent application (Article 2241), and suspended during an expert assessment ordered before any trial (Article 2239).
There is also an absolute limit. The mixed chamber of the Cour de cassation holds that the action cannot go beyond “the twenty-year long-stop period running from the day the right arose” (our translation), that is to say “the day of the sale concluded by the party against whom the warranty is sought” (our translation; Cass. ch. mixte, 21 July 2023, No. 21-17.789). This period derives from Article 2232, which prevents postponement of the starting point and suspension from extending the limitation period beyond twenty years, interruption by a court claim being excepted (paragraph 2).
For the sale of a building to be constructed, the time limit for claims relating to apparent defects is shorter and is a foreclosure period (délai de forclusion) (Article 1648, paragraph 2). The firm calculates the time limits from the first appointment, on the basis of the documents.
Can the two-year time limit for hidden defects be interrupted or suspended?
Yes. A court claim, even an urgent application, interrupts the limitation period (Article 2241 of the Civil Code); the interruption has effect until the proceedings end (Article 2242). Where the court grants a request for an expert assessment made before any trial, the limitation period is also suspended and only starts running again, for a period that cannot be less than six months, from the day the measure was carried out (Article 2239).
The Cour de cassation applies these texts to the Article 1648 period. In a case where the expert's report had been filed more than four years after the order, it quashed the judgment holding the buyer time-barred: “the two-year limitation period had been suspended between the order of 30 July 2014 and the filing of the expert's report on 30 November 2018” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 11 December 2025, No. 23-19.474). The same judgment holds that the urgent application also interrupts the claim based on fraudulent misrepresentation, because the buyer's claim “pursues the same ends whether it is based on the warranty against hidden defects or on fraud” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 11 December 2025, No. 23-19.474).
Two precautions are essential. The application for an expert assessment should describe all the defects observed, and proceedings on the merits must follow the filing of the report without letting the period, which then starts running again, expire. The expert assessment is requested from the court for the place where the building is located, which has sole jurisdiction when the measure concerns a building (Article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure).
The deed of sale contains a non-warranty clause: can I still bring a claim?
Often, yes. The seller is liable for hidden defects even if unaware of them, “unless, in that case, he has stipulated that he will not be bound by any warranty” (our translation; Article 1643 of the Civil Code). The clause therefore only protects a seller who was unaware of the defect; if they knew of it, the clause falls away and they owe full damages (Article 1645).
It also falls away against a professional seller, who is presumed to know of the defect, and against a seller who carried out the works personally. There is one qualification: “a clause limiting or excluding the warranty against hidden defects may be relied on against a professional buyer in the same field as the seller of the thing” (our translation), unless the seller's bad faith is proved (Cass. 3e civ., 23 October 2025, No. 23-18.469). According to the Cour de cassation, “a seller who, without being a construction professional, personally carried out the works that caused the defects in the thing sold is treated as a professional seller” (our translation), so that they cannot rely on a non-warranty clause (Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-11.221). Lastly, if one of the lead, asbestos, termite, gas, electricity or non-mains drainage reports is missing when the authentic deed is signed, the seller cannot exclude the corresponding warranty (Article L. 271-4 of the Construction and Housing Code).
Outside these cases, the clause takes effect. The Paris Judicial Court applied it, in any event, to a non-professional seller whose knowledge of the defect had not been proved, “so that the exclusion of warranty clause must apply” (our translation; TJ Paris, 2e ch. 2e sect., 28 October 2025, No. 23/12894). Before issuing proceedings, the firm therefore looks for evidence of what the seller knew: invoices for works, insurance claim declarations, minutes of general meetings, listings and messages. See our article on proving that the seller knew about dry rot (mérule).
The seller is a professional or did the works themselves: what difference does it make?
A seller who was unaware of the defect is only liable to refund the price and reimburse the costs occasioned by the sale (Article 1646 of the Civil Code). A seller who knew of it also owes full damages (Article 1645). And a professional seller is deemed to know of it. The commercial chamber of the Cour de cassation applies “an irrebuttable presumption that the professional seller knows of the defect in the thing sold, which obliges it to make good all the damage resulting from it” (our translation), a presumption “which applies even where the buyer is itself a professional” (our translation; Cass. com., 5 July 2023, No. 22-11.621).
The rule extends to a seller who personally carried out the works that caused the defect (Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-11.221), and the Paris Court of Appeal treated as a professional a property dealer company whose articles of association also covered renovation works. Ruling on that company's claim against its own seller, the court noted that “as a professional seller, it was incumbent on it to have all necessary checks carried out on the compliance of the works” (our translation; CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 10 July 2026, No. 24/02204). The attic had been converted by the previous owner without a contractor or insurance.
If the seller sold, after completion, a building they built or had built, they are also deemed to be a builder (Article 1792-1) and are strictly liable, for ten years from acceptance of the works (Article 1792-4-1), for damage that compromises the structural soundness of the building or that, affecting one of its constituent elements or items of equipment, makes it unfit for its purpose (Article 1792). The firm therefore checks the seller's articles of association, the history of the works and the permits obtained.
Cancelling the sale or getting a price reduction: how do I choose?
The law leaves the choice to the buyer: return the thing and obtain a refund of the price, or keep the thing and obtain a refund of part of the price (Article 1644 of the Civil Code). The Cour de cassation stresses that it is the buyer “who alone has the choice of the actions provided for by law” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 8 February 2023, No. 22-10.743).
The rescission claim, which unwinds the sale, is suitable where the property is unusable or trust has broken down. It leads to a refund of the price and, if the seller was unaware of the defect, reimbursement of the costs occasioned by the sale (Article 1646); if they knew of it, full damages are added (Article 1645). It requires returning the property, which weighs heavily where a loan financed the purchase or the family lives there.
The price reduction claim leaves the property with the buyer and refunds part of the price, the amount of which is argued on the basis of the works costed by the expert. It survives repair by a third party: such a repair cannot remove “the price-reduction claim allowing the buyer to obtain a refund of the price up to the cost of the works they had to bear to remedy the defect” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 8 February 2023, No. 22-10.743). On the other hand, a buyer who agrees to the seller repairing the defect themselves can no longer bring a warranty claim once the defect has disappeared, according to the same judgment.
The firm compares the two routes with you: the amount at stake, the seller's solvency, financing, your plans, the length of the proceedings. See our article on the two-year time limit and the first steps.
What damages can be obtained for a hidden defect?
It all depends on what the seller knew. If they knew of the defects, they are liable, in addition to refunding the price, for all damages owed to the buyer (Article 1645 of the Civil Code). If they were unaware of them, they owe only a refund of the price and the costs occasioned by the sale (Article 1646). A professional seller, presumed to know of the defect, falls into the first category.
These damages can be claimed on their own. According to the Cour de cassation, the buyer “may bring the claim for compensation independently of the rescission or price-reduction claim” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 30 January 2020, No. 19-10.176). Buyers who had chosen to keep a house with defects requiring its demolition thus obtained from the seller in bad faith “damages equivalent to the cost of its demolition and reconstruction” (our translation), namely €129,931 incl. VAT with indexation (Cass. 3e civ., 30 January 2020, No. 19-10.176). Loss of enjoyment is also compensated: €11,340 in the property dealer case decided by the Paris Court of Appeal (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 10 July 2026, No. 24/02204).
This stand-alone claim does not escape the time limit. The Cour de cassation quashed a judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal that had applied the five-year period of Article 2224 to a co-owners' association. The damages claim, it held, “nonetheless remains subject to the provisions of Article 1648 of the Civil Code” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 19 February 2026, No. 23-22.295). The firm quantifies each head of loss, with supporting documents, and has it included in the expert's terms of reference.
How do you prove a hidden defect? Is a court-appointed expert needed?
The burden of proof lies with the buyer, who is claiming performance of the warranty obligation (Article 1353 of the Civil Code): they must establish the existence of the defect, its seriousness, its hidden nature and that it predates the sale. Dated photographs, a judicial officer's report, contractors' quotes and reports, the diagnostic reports annexed to the deed, listings and exchanges with the seller form the initial basis of the file.
A court-appointed expert assessment is requested before any trial, if there is a legitimate reason to establish evidence of facts on which the outcome of the dispute may depend; for a building, only the court for the place where it is located has jurisdiction (Article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure). It has a twofold advantage: it is adversarial, and the application interrupts and then suspends the two-year period (Articles 2241 and 2239).
A private expert report is not always enough. The mixed chamber of the Cour de cassation points out that “the court cannot base its decision exclusively on a non-judicial expert report produced at the request of one of the parties” (our translation; Cass. ch. mixte, 21 July 2023, No. 21-15.809). It remains useful for deciding whether to act and for persuading the urgent applications judge to order an expert assessment.
The firm drafts the application for an expert assessment, proposes the expert's terms of reference, attends the meetings and sends the expert written observations. See our article on preparing a court-ordered expert assessment.
Negative termite report, asbestos not reported: what can I do?
The technical diagnostic file is annexed to the preliminary sale agreement (promesse de vente) or, failing that, to the authentic deed of sale; it includes in particular the reports on lead, asbestos, termites, gas, electricity and non-mains drainage (Article L. 271-4 of the Construction and Housing Code). If one of these documents, still valid, is missing when the authentic deed is signed, the seller cannot exclude the corresponding warranty against hidden defects. Under the same article, if the natural and technological risk report (état des risques) is missing, the buyer can seek rescission of the contract or a price reduction.
A diagnostic report being present does not close the discussion. A report that mentions a problem does not always reveal its extent. The Cour de cassation quashed the judgment that held against the buyer a report mentioning house longhorn beetles, because an apparent defect is one whose full extent and consequences the buyer was able to ascertain (Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-16.847).
The diagnostic surveyor may also be liable for omissions. The Paris Court of Appeal holds that a surveyor whose assignment is limited to termites “commits a tort that renders it liable to the buyer if it fails to report the visible presence of other wood-boring insects” (our translation; CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 10 October 2025, No. 24/08015). Compensation remained limited to the cost of repairs and a few days' rent, the loss of a chance to negotiate a lower price being rejected. See our articles on termites despite a negative report and on the diagnostic surveyor's liability.
Hidden defect or fraud (dol): what is the difference, and can both claims be combined?
The warranty against hidden defects does not require any fault: the seller owes it even if unaware of the defect (Article 1643 of the Civil Code). Fraudulent misrepresentation (dol), on the other hand, consists in obtaining the other party's consent through scheming or lies, or through the intentional concealment of information one knows to be decisive for them (Article 1137). It allows the contract to be annulled and, independently of annulment, compensation for the loss suffered (Article 1178). In cases of fraud, the time limit for an annulment claim only runs from the day the fraud was discovered (Article 1144).
The two routes are not mutually exclusive. The Cour de cassation holds that the warranty claim “does not exclude a claim in tort based on fraud or fraudulent concealment committed before or at the time the contract was concluded” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 23 September 2020, No. 19-18.104). In that case, the warranty claim was time-barred according to the court of appeal, and the judgment that shut the buyer out of a fraud claim was quashed. A breach of the duty to inform, which the parties can neither limit nor exclude, also renders the party bound by it liable and may lead to annulment of the contract (Article 1112-1).
The two claims are protected together. An urgent application interrupts the claim based on fraud, because the buyer's claim “pursues the same ends whether it is based on the warranty against hidden defects or on fraud” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 11 December 2025, No. 23-19.474). Fraud, however, requires proof of an intention to deceive, which is harder to establish. See our article on the annulment of a property sale for fraudulent misrepresentation.
The buyer is claiming under the warranty after the sale: how can I defend myself?
By starting with the time limits. The action must be brought within two years of discovering the defect (Article 1648 of the Civil Code), and no later than twenty years after the sale (Article 2232). A buyer claiming damages alone remains subject to the two-year period. The Cour de cassation so held when quashing a judgment that applied the five-year period, because the damages claim “nonetheless remains subject to the provisions of Article 1648 of the Civil Code” (our translation; Cass. 3e civ., 19 February 2026, No. 23-22.295).
Then come the substantive conditions: an apparent defect, which the buyer could have seen for themselves, is not covered (Article 1642); nor is a defect that is not serious enough or that arose after the sale (Article 1641). The burden of proving these conditions lies with the buyer (Article 1353).
Finally, the non-warranty clause protects a non-professional seller who was unaware of the defect (Article 1643). The Paris Judicial Court dismissed buyers' claims, holding that seriousness had not been established and, in any event, that since the seller's knowledge of the defect had not been shown, the exclusion of warranty clause had to apply (TJ Paris, 2e ch. 2e sect., 28 October 2025, No. 23/12894). The buyers were also ordered to pay €4,000 towards the costs of the proceedings. This defence is not available to a seller who personally carried out the works that caused the defect, who is treated as a professional (Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-11.221).
The firm analyses the claim, responds to the formal notice, takes part in the expert assessment to argue about the cause of the damage and when it arose and, where appropriate, brings third-party claims against the contractor or diagnostic surveyor concerned.
Hidden defect in a used car: what are my options?
Articles 1641 to 1648 of the Civil Code apply to the sale of a vehicle just as to the sale of a building, including between private individuals: a hidden, serious defect that existed before the sale, action within two years of discovery (Article 1648), choice between a refund and a price reduction (Article 1644). An adversarial expert assessment, first private and then court-ordered if necessary, establishes the cause of the breakdown.
Against a garage or a professional seller, the buyer is in a stronger position, as the seller is presumed to know of the defect. In a case concerning the sale of a tractor, the Cour de cassation applies “an irrebuttable presumption that the professional seller knows of the defect in the thing sold, which obliges it to make good all the damage resulting from it” (our translation; Cass. com., 5 July 2023, No. 22-11.621). A consumer also has the legal guarantee of conformity (Articles L. 217-1 and L. 217-3 of the Consumer Code); for second-hand goods, a lack of conformity appearing within twelve months of delivery is presumed, unless proven otherwise, to have existed at that date (Article L. 217-7). This presumption, specific to the guarantee of conformity, does not apply to the hidden defects claim, where the buyer still has to prove that the defect predates the sale (Article 1353 of the Civil Code). This guarantee does not deprive the buyer of the claim under the warranty against hidden defects (Article L. 217-30).
A subsequent buyer can act against the original seller, but within a limit. According to the Cour de cassation, “the warranty against hidden defects accompanies the thing sold, as an accessory” (our translation; Cass. 1re civ., 3 September 2025, No. 24-11.383). But knowledge of a defect predating the first sale “is assessed at the date of that sale in the person of the first buyer who, if a professional, is presumed to know of the defect” (our translation; Cass. 1re civ., 3 September 2025, No. 24-11.383). On this basis, the Cour de cassation quashed an order against an original seller in favour of subsequent buyers, because the court of appeal had not examined whether the first buyer knew of the defect. See our article on the legal guarantee of conformity for a used vehicle.
What are the fees for a hidden defects lawyer?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971, save for the exceptions provided for in that text: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee for each stage: analysis of the file and the time limits, formal notice or reply to a claim, urgent application for an expert, assistance during the expert assessment, proceedings on the merits, appeal. Expert fees and the costs of judicial officers' acts are separate from the fees. Any new assignment is covered by an addendum, with no unexpected invoicing. The firm applies the same method whether you are the buyer or the seller.
For a first opinion on the documents, the preliminary review of your file at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. It covers the time limits, the non-warranty clause, the status of the seller and the documents available, and indicates whether to send a formal notice first, apply for an expert assessment or gather further evidence. First contact on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 31 October 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles 1625, 1641, 1642 and 1643 of the Civil Code: purpose of the warranty, hidden and apparent defects, non-warranty clause
- Articles 1644, 1645, 1646 and 1647: rescission and price reduction claims, damages, costs of the sale, loss of the thing
- Articles 1648 and 1649: two-year period, sales by order of the court
- Articles 1642-1, 1646-1, 1792, 1792-1 and 1792-4-1: sale of a building to be constructed, seller deemed to be a builder, duration of the ten-year builder's liability (garantie décennale)
- Articles 1112-1, 1130, 1137, 1144 and 1178: duty to inform, defects of consent, fraudulent misrepresentation, time limit and effects of annulment
- Article 1353: burden of proof
- Articles 2224, 2232, 2239, 2241 and 2242: limitation, long-stop period, suspension, interruption
- Article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure: investigative measures before any trial
- Article L. 271-4 of the Construction and Housing Code: technical diagnostic file and warranty against hidden defects
- Articles L. 217-1, L. 217-3, L. 217-7 and L. 217-30 of the Consumer Code: legal guarantee of conformity, second-hand goods, combination with the warranty against hidden defects
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. ch. mixte, 21 July 2023, No. 21-15.809: two-year period, limitation period, non-judicial expert report
- Cass. ch. mixte, 21 July 2023, No. 21-17.789: twenty-year long-stop period running from the sale
- Cass. 3e civ., 11 December 2025, No. 23-19.474: suspension during the expert assessment, interruption extending to the fraud claim
- Cass. 3e civ., 19 February 2026, No. 23-22.295: damages claim subject to the two-year period
- Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-11.221: seller who carried out the works, clause set aside
- Cass. com., 5 July 2023, No. 22-11.621: irrebuttable presumption against the professional seller
- Cass. 3e civ., 23 October 2025, No. 23-18.469: clause enforceable against a professional buyer in the same field
- Cass. 3e civ., 13 November 2025, No. 24-16.847: apparent defect assessed in its full extent
- Cass. 3e civ., 30 January 2020, No. 19-10.176: stand-alone damages, demolition and reconstruction
- Cass. 3e civ., 8 February 2023, No. 22-10.743: buyer's choice, repair by a third party
- Cass. 3e civ., 23 September 2020, No. 19-18.104: warranty against hidden defects and fraud
- Cass. 1re civ., 3 September 2025, No. 24-11.383: subsequent buyer of a vehicle, first buyer's knowledge
- CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 10 July 2026, No. 24/02204: property dealer, professional seller
- CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 10 October 2025, No. 24/08015: diagnostic surveyor's liability
- TJ Paris, 2e ch. 2e sect., 28 October 2025, No. 23/12894: seriousness not established, clause applied
Further reading
A hidden defect discovered after buying property in France, or a claim received?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the deed of sale, the annexed diagnostic reports, photographs, quotes and your exchanges with the other party: Hassan Kohen reviews the time limits, the clause and the seller's status, then tells you which route suits your case: formal notice, urgent application for an expert, claim for a refund or a price reduction, or the seller's defence.