In the media
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, garantie décennale lawyer in Paris
Garantie décennale lawyer in Paris: defects, insurers, time limits
Cracks, water ingress, a leaking roof, failed insulation, an insurer that refuses or does not reply, a ten-year deadline drawing near: as garantie décennale lawyers (ten-year builder's liability), the firm acts for the project owner, the buyer and the co-owners' association (syndicat de copropriétaires) seeking compensation, and also for the builder and its insurer when a claim is brought against them. Everything turns on the date of acceptance of the works (réception), the nature of the defect and the steps that have interrupted the time limit.
The firm can be reached 24/7. The ten-year period runs from acceptance of the works (Article 1792-4-1 of the French Civil Code). It is not suspended during the court-ordered expert assessment. A court claim, even an urgent application (référé), interrupts it (Article 2241), but only for the defects it identifies; an acknowledgement of liability by the builder does not interrupt it.
4,9/5
Average Google rating270 reviews
I received first-rate support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order application brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the outcome he achieved for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, shows great empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar: builders' liability, garantie décennale, construction insurance and expert-assessment litigation.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
Every builder of a construction work (ouvrage) is liable as of right, towards the project owner or the buyer, for damage that compromises the solidity of the work or makes it unfit for its intended purpose, unless the builder proves an external cause (Article 1792 of the French Civil Code). This liability ends ten years after acceptance of the works (Article 1792-4-1), a time limit that the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) classes as a foreclosure period (forclusion): a summons for a court-ordered expert assessment in urgent proceedings (référé-expertise) interrupts it, and suspension during the expert assessment does not apply. The builder must be insured and must provide proof of that insurance when work starts on site (Article L. 241-1 of the French Insurance Code, Code des assurances); save for exceptions, the project owner takes out property damage insurance (dommages-ouvrage) that pre-finances the repairs and must give its position within sixty days (Article L. 242-1). Since 21 March 2024, equipment fitted to an existing building, such as a heat pump or a fireplace insert, no longer falls under the décennale unless it constitutes a construction work in itself. Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th arrondissement, acts for project owners and for builders alike. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A defect after building work, an insurer that refuses, a time limit running?
Understanding your situation
The garantie décennale in Paris, explained
The presumption in Article 1792 of the French Civil Code protects the project owner for ten years. What it covers, who is liable, how the decennial insurer and the dommages-ouvrage insurer come in, how to preserve the time limit, and how to bring a claim or defend one.
Scope
Decennial liability: the four conditions to be met
A construction work, damage hidden at acceptance, sufficient seriousness, revealed during the ten-year test period.
A construction work. "Every builder of a construction work is liable as of right" (our translation) for the damage defined in Article 1792 of the French Civil Code. A new building is one; work on an existing building is one only if it is substantial. The Nîmes Court of Appeal puts it this way: "To constitute a construction work, works on existing buildings must be substantial works carried out with new materials, matter or the use of building techniques, and amount to a transformation of the existing building and a genuine renovation, not a mere refurbishment." (our translation) (CA Nîmes, 2e ch., sect. A, 25 June 2026, No. 25/01458).
Damage not apparent at acceptance, or that appeared afterwards. Acceptance of the works (réception) is the act by which the project owner accepts the work, with or without reservations (Article 1792-6 of the French Civil Code). For the Court of Cassation, "Acceptance of the work covers any construction defect, disorder or non-conformity that was apparent and not made the subject of reservations." (our translation), and whether a defect was apparent is assessed on the day of acceptance and from the standpoint of the project owner (Cass. 3e civ., 8 October 2026, No. 24-16.523).
Decennial seriousness. The damage compromises the solidity of the work or, affecting one of its constituent elements or one of its items of equipment, makes it unfit for its intended purpose, even if it results from a defect in the ground (Article 1792 of the French Civil Code). Items of equipment that form an inseparable whole with the works of site servicing, foundations, structure, enclosure or roofing are covered as to their solidity, that is, where they cannot be removed, dismantled or replaced without damaging the work or removing material from it (Article 1792-2 of the French Civil Code).
Seriousness reached within ten years. The builder is discharged ten years after acceptance (Article 1792-4-1 of the French Civil Code). A risk that did not materialise during that period is not enough: the Court of Cassation upheld the dismissal of a claim, "in the absence of decennial damage established during the test period" (our translation), concerning a missing roof underlay that could cause tiles to fall (Cass. 3e civ., 11 May 2022, No. 21-15.608).
The reversal of 21 March 2024 narrowed the scope of the guarantee. After seven years of contrary case law, the Court of Cassation holds that "where items of equipment installed as a replacement or an addition on an existing construction work do not in themselves constitute a construction work, they fall neither under the ten-year guarantee nor under the two-year guarantee of proper functioning, whatever the seriousness of the defects, but under ordinary contractual liability, which is not subject to builders' compulsory insurance" (our translation). In that case, which went against the owners, the fireplace insert fitted in their house had caused a fire that destroyed it; the judgment holding the installer and its insurer liable under the décennale was quashed, and the Court specified that "The new case law applies to the pending proceedings, provided that it does not cause a disproportionate interference with legal certainty or with the right of access to a court." (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 21 March 2024, No. 22-18.694).
The lower courts apply this rule to energy-renovation equipment. The Nîmes Court of Appeal held that a heat pump installed in place of an oil-fired boiler, connected to the existing electrical panel and pipework, was not a construction work: the defects "do not fall under the ten-year guarantee, even where the seriousness of the defects is established, but under ordinary contractual liability" (our translation). The installer, in liquidation, was held contractually liable, and the owners' claims were merely entered as debts against its estate (CA Nîmes, 2e ch., sect. A, 25 June 2026, No. 25/01458). The practical issue is the insurer: without the décennale, the compulsory insurance does not apply.
Conversely, unfitness for purpose is construed broadly once it is established. The Paris Court of Appeal points out that "mere thermal discomfort is not enough to establish unfitness for purpose" (our translation), then applied the décennale to a house whose under-roof insulation had been badly installed: "It therefore appears established that the air-tightness defects, whose consequences can only be offset by excessive energy consumption, make the house unfit for its intended purpose." (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 5, 4 June 2025, No. 22/14479). The Court of Cassation likewise holds that a health risk linked to odours makes the work unfit for its intended purpose, and that dommages-ouvrage insurance covers it when it appears after acceptance (Cass. 3e civ., 11 May 2022, No. 21-15.608).
Two exclusions and two neighbouring guarantees. Items of equipment whose sole function is to enable a professional activity to be carried out in the work are not items of equipment within the meaning of these provisions (Article 1792-7 of the French Civil Code). There is no liability if the builder proves an external cause (Article 1792 of the French Civil Code). Other items of equipment fall under a guarantee of proper functioning of at least two years (Article 1792-3 of the French Civil Code), and defects reported at acceptance or within the year fall under the one-year completion guarantee (garantie de parfait achèvement) (Article 1792-6 of the French Civil Code): see our page on construction law, and our articles on defective thermal insulation and energy renovation.
Who is liable
Who owes the garantie décennale, and to whom
A presumption that bears on all builders, for the benefit of the project owner and successive buyers.
Builders
Any architect, contractor, technician or other person bound to the project owner by a works contract (contrat de louage d'ouvrage) is deemed a builder, as is anyone who, acting as the owner's agent, performs a task comparable to that of a works contractor (Article 1792-1 of the French Civil Code).
Seller
A person who sells, after completion, a work that they built or had built is also deemed a builder (Article 1792-1 of the French Civil Code). The seller of a building to be constructed (off-plan sale) is bound, from acceptance, by the same obligations as builders, and these guarantees benefit successive owners (Article 1646-1 of the French Civil Code).
Manufacturer
The manufacturer of a work, part of a work or item of equipment designed to meet, in service, precise requirements determined in advance is jointly and severally liable with the contractor who installed it without modification and in accordance with the manufacturer's rules (Article 1792-4 of the French Civil Code).
Subcontractor
The subcontractor is not bound to the project owner by a works contract: it is not a builder within the meaning of Article 1792-1 of the French Civil Code and does not owe the garantie décennale. The insurer subrogated to the project owner's rights, which therefore exercises those rights, can seek the subcontractor's liability "only on the basis of tort liability" (our translation) and must prove its fault and the causal link with the loss (Cass. 3e civ., 27 April 2017, No. 16-10.691). The action is nevertheless time-barred ten years after acceptance of the works (Article 1792-4-2 of the French Civil Code).
Contract clauses
Any clause that excludes or limits the liability under Articles 1792 to 1792-2, or that excludes or limits the manufacturer's joint and several liability, is deemed unwritten (Article 1792-5 of the French Civil Code).
The presumption relieves the project owner of having to prove fault: the owner establishes the damage, its seriousness and its link with the builder's work, and the builder is exonerated only by proving an external cause (Article 1792 of the French Civil Code). The statutory guarantee also excludes ordinary law. The Court of Cassation points out that "damage falling under a statutory guarantee cannot give rise, against the persons bound by that guarantee, to a claim for compensation based on ordinary contractual liability" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-22.376). The legal basis therefore cannot be chosen at will: a decennial defect is argued under Article 1792, within the time limit of Article 1792-4-1.
The claim follows the building. In the same decision, the Court holds that "while the action under the ten-year guarantee is in principle transferred to buyers together with ownership of the building, the project owner does not lose the right to bring it where it has a direct and certain interest in doing so" (our translation), for example where the owner has been ordered to pay damages to its own buyer. In that case, which went against the sellers who had had their house built, the judgment that had allowed their ordinary-law claim against the bricklayer's insurer was quashed (Cass. 3e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-22.376).
The manager of an uninsured company may be personally liable. The Court of Cassation set aside the judgment that had failed to examine whether the manager had committed "faults separable from his corporate functions, engaging his personal liability, by failing to enter into a contract for the construction of a detached house and to take out decennial liability insurance" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 7 June 2018, No. 16-27.680). This is often the only solvent route when the company has disappeared.
The liability of the architect and the project manager (maître d'œuvre), off-plan sales (VEFA) and the contract for the construction of a detached house (CCMI) have their own pages: see our articles on the architect's liability and the décennale in off-plan sales (VEFA), and our pages on contracts for the construction of a detached house and construction industry lawyers for building contractors.
The insurers
Decennial insurance and dommages-ouvrage insurance: who pays, and within what time limits
Two compulsory insurance policies, which apply neither to the same persons nor at the same time.
Decennial liability insurance is compulsory for anyone whose liability may be engaged under Articles 1792 et seq. of the Civil Code; they must provide proof of it when any work starts on site, and the policy is "deemed to include a clause maintaining cover for the duration of the decennial liability" (our translation) (Article L. 241-1 of the French Insurance Code). Anyone who has construction work carried out on behalf of others, or with a view to sale, must also be insured (Article L. 241-2 of the French Insurance Code). The insurance certificate is attached to quotes and invoices, and any deed transferring ownership within the ten years states whether or not insurance exists (Article L. 243-2 of the French Insurance Code). Failing to take out insurance is punishable by six months' imprisonment and a fine of 75,000 euros, or by one of these two penalties only, except for an individual who builds a home to live in themselves or for occupation by their spouse, ascendants, descendants or those of their spouse (Article L. 243-3 of the French Insurance Code).
Property damage insurance (assurance dommages-ouvrage) is taken out by the project owner before work starts on site, save for exceptions relating in particular to public-law entities. It pays for the repair of damage of a decennial nature "without any determination of liability" (our translation) (Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code); the insurer then brings its recourse claims against the builders and their insurers. It takes effect after the one-year completion period, except where the contract is terminated before acceptance or the contractor fails to perform after acceptance, in each case after formal notice has gone unheeded.
60 days
From receipt of the claim notification, the insurer notifies its decision on whether the cover applies in principle (Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code).
90 days
If it accepts, it makes a compensation offer, provisional where appropriate, within ninety days of the claim notification; an additional period of no more than one hundred and thirty-five days requires the insured's express agreement and technical grounds.
15 days
An accepted offer is paid within fifteen days.
Sanction
Missed deadline or manifestly insufficient offer: the insured, after notifying the insurer, incurs the repair costs, and the compensation is automatically increased by interest at twice the statutory interest rate (Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code).
The Court of Cassation applies these time limits strictly. The insurer "is required to respond within the sixty-day period to every claim notification, including where it considers that the defects are identical to those previously reported" (our translation), failing which it can no longer raise "the two-year limitation period that would have expired by the date of the second notification" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 30 September 2021, No. 20-18.883). An insurer that has accepted cover within that period "can no longer dispute it on the ground that the defects are not decennial in nature" (our translation), and must fund the work needed to remedy them (Cass. 3e civ., 3 April 2025, No. 23-16.055). Finally, while acceptance without reservations covers apparent defects, "dommages-ouvrage cover applies to defects of a decennial nature that appear after acceptance" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 11 May 2022, No. 21-15.608).
Against the builder's decennial insurer, the injured party has a direct action: "The injured third party has a right of direct action against the insurer covering the civil liability of the person responsible" (our translation) (Article L. 124-3 of the French Insurance Code). This insurer covers only the declared activities, but it is for the insurer to prove the exclusion it relies on: "where the insurer denies cover by relying on a clause in the special conditions of the insurance policy that excludes from the cover the activity carried out by the builder, it must prove that this clause was brought to the insured's attention and that the insured accepted it" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 17 November 2021, No. 20-16.771).
You have dommages-ouvrage insurance
- Notify the claim to the dommages-ouvrage insurer in writing, with the supporting documents, and note the date the notification was received.
- Count sixty and then ninety days, and give notice of any failure to act before starting the work.
- Challenge the report of the insurer's expert before accepting an offer.
You do not have it
- Gather the decennial insurance certificates attached to each contractor's quotes and invoices.
- Send the builder a formal notice and notify the claim to its insurer.
- Summon the builder and its insurer together in urgent proceedings for a court-ordered expert assessment (référé-expertise), before the ten years expire.
See our articles on the statutory time limits of the dommages-ouvrage insurer, how to activate dommages-ouvrage insurance, the tradesman's decennial insurance certificate and decennial cover refused by the insurer, and our page on insurance law.
The time limit
The ten-year time limit: starting point, interruption, pitfalls
A foreclosure period, governed by stricter rules than ordinary limitation.
Acceptance
The time limit runs from acceptance of the works (Article 1792-4-1 of the French Civil Code), whether by agreement or by the court, always in the presence of both parties (Article 1792-6 of the French Civil Code). Its date has to be proved: see our article on tacit acceptance of the works.
Nature of the time limit
"The ten-year period for bringing a claim against builders on the basis of Articles 1792-4-1 to 1792-4-3 of the Civil Code is a foreclosure period." (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 9 October 2025, No. 23-20.446). Foreclosure periods are not governed by the title on limitation, unless a text provides otherwise (Article 2220 of the French Civil Code).
Interruption
"A court claim, even in urgent proceedings, interrupts the limitation period as well as the foreclosure period" (our translation) (Article 2241 of the French Civil Code). The interruption has effect until the proceedings end (Article 2242 of the French Civil Code), and it is void if the claim is withdrawn, lapses or is finally dismissed (Article 2243 of the French Civil Code).
After the référé
The time limit "is interrupted by a summons for a court-ordered expert assessment in urgent proceedings, and starts running again for a full period of ten years from the order granting the investigative measure" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 22 October 2026, No. 24-22.203).
No suspension
Suspension during an investigative measure ordered before any trial (Article 2239 of the French Civil Code) does not apply to this time limit (Cass. 3e civ., 22 October 2026, No. 24-22.203).
What does not interrupt it
An acknowledgement of liability by the builder (Cass. 3e civ., 9 October 2025, No. 23-20.446); a summons, for the defects it does not identify (Cass. 3e civ., 2 May 2024, No. 22-23.004).
A judgment of 22 October 2026 applies this rule to a common situation. A court of appeal had applied the suspension under Article 2239, then the six-month period following the expert's report, and held time-barred a claim brought several years after that report. The Court of Cassation quashed the judgment: the ten-year period, interrupted by the summons in urgent proceedings, starts again for ten years from the order, and "secondly, Article 2239 of the Civil Code on the suspension of limitation during the investigative measure does not apply to it" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 22 October 2026, No. 24-22.203). The calculation is therefore made from the order, not from the filing of the report.
Two decisions, unfavourable to the claimant, show the limits of interruption. "The interruptive effect of a summons applies only to the defects expressly identified in it" (our translation), and a request to extend the expert assessment to other defects interrupts nothing for those already covered by the initial measure (Cass. 3e civ., 2 May 2024, No. 22-23.004). And the builder's acknowledgement of liability does not protect the project owner: "an acknowledgement of liability by the builder made after the date on which the aforementioned law came into force does not interrupt the ten-year foreclosure period" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 9 October 2025, No. 23-20.446). Expiry of the time limit also bars any recourse claim based on the ten-year guarantee itself: "no action, even a recourse action, based on this guarantee may be brought more than ten years after acceptance" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-22.376). Recourse claims between builders on another legal basis follow separate rules, which the firm checks case by case.
Insurers follow their own rules. Actions arising from an insurance contract are time-barred two years after the event giving rise to them, five years for drought damage recognised as a natural disaster; where the insured's action stems from a claim by a third party, time runs only from the day that third party sued the insured or was compensated (Article L. 114-1 of the French Insurance Code). This period is interrupted by the ordinary causes, by the appointment of experts following a loss and by the insured's registered letter concerning payment of the compensation (Article L. 114-2 of the French Insurance Code). For the injured party, the direct action is subject to the same time limit as the claim against the person liable, but "it may nevertheless be brought against the insurer for as long as the insurer remains exposed to a claim by its insured" (our translation); and "an action for a court-ordered expert assessment in urgent proceedings starts the two-year limitation period for the insured's action against the insurer" (our translation). In that case, which went against the project owner, the court of appeal that had allowed the direct action without finding that the insurer remained exposed to a claim by its insured was overturned (Cass. 3e civ., 14 September 2023, No. 22-21.493).
Sue early, sue all the builders and their insurers, and identify every defect: that is the practical rule the firm applies. Acceptance of the works, which sets the starting point, has its own page: lawyer for acceptance of building works, and our article on tacit acceptance. Cracks caused by drought often fall under another regime: see natural disaster claims lawyer. See also the two-year limitation period in insurance.
The procedure
Bringing or defending a decennial claim: from claim notification to judgment
The case is won on proof of the defect, on the date of acceptance and on the steps that preserved the time limit.
Gather the acceptance report (procès-verbal de réception) or proof of taking possession and payment, and the contracts, quotes, invoices and insurance certificates of each contractor involved (Article L. 243-2 of the French Insurance Code).
Have the defect and how it develops formally recorded before any permanent repair, so that its cause remains observable.
Notify the claim to the dommages-ouvrage insurer if there is one, and monitor the sixty-day and ninety-day time limits (Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code).
Send the builder a formal notice and notify the claim to its decennial insurer, against which the injured party has a direct action (Article L. 124-3 of the French Insurance Code).
Apply for a court-ordered expert assessment in urgent proceedings, which interrupts the ten-year period (Article 2241 of the French Civil Code): where the measure concerns a building, "the court of the place where the building is located has exclusive jurisdiction" (our translation) (Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure).
Attend the expert's meetings, submit written observations (dires), challenge the decennial classification and the costing, then sue all those liable and their insurers on the merits.
You are the project owner or a buyer
- Establish that the defect reached decennial seriousness within the ten years and its link with the work of each builder.
- Identify each defect in the summons, and join all the insurers to the proceedings.
- If the company has disappeared, act against its insurer and, if there is no insurance, pursue the manager.
You are a builder or an insurer
- Check foreclosure, the date of acceptance and the defects actually identified in the procedural documents.
- Challenge whether the defect was apparent at acceptance, its seriousness and the classification as a construction work.
- Rely on an external cause, and join the other contractors and their insurers as third parties.
The builder's defence is built on the same texts. A defect that was apparent and not reserved is cleared by acceptance, and whether it was apparent is assessed "on the day of acceptance and exclusively from the standpoint of the project owner" (our translation); where that owner is a legal entity, its expertise is measured by its corporate purpose and activities, not by those of its representative (Cass. 3e civ., 8 October 2026, No. 24-16.523). The damage must also have been visible in its full extent: for the Paris Court of Appeal, "damage can be apparent only if not only its manifestation but also its causes and consequences were apparent" (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 5, 4 June 2025, No. 22/14479). Equipment added to an existing building falls outside the scope of the guarantee (Cass. 3e civ., 21 March 2024, No. 22-18.694), and expiry of the test period bars any action based on it (Cass. 3e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-22.376).
A company in liquidation does not make the case disappear. If it was insured, the direct action against its insurer remains open on the conditions set out by the Court of Cassation (Cass. 3e civ., 14 September 2023, No. 22-21.493). If it was not, or if the defect falls outside the décennale, the claim is lodged in the insolvency proceedings and the court sets its amount, as the Nîmes Court of Appeal did for the installer of a heat pump (CA Nîmes, 2e ch., sect. A, 25 June 2026, No. 25/01458); the personal liability of the uninsured manager may then be pursued (Cass. 3e civ., 7 June 2018, No. 16-27.680).
See our articles on court-ordered expert assessments, recording defective workmanship and tradesmen without decennial insurance, and our pages on lodging a claim in insolvency proceedings and abandoned building sites.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What is the garantie décennale in France and how does it work?
It is liability as of right: "Every builder of a construction work is liable as of right" (our translation), towards the owner or buyer of the work, for damage that compromises its solidity or makes it unfit for its intended purpose, even if it results from a defect in the ground, unless an external cause is proved (Article 1792 of the French Civil Code). The project owner does not have to prove fault: the owner establishes the defect, its seriousness and the link with the builder's work.
It applies to the architect, the contractor, the technician, the seller who had the building built and the agent who acts like a works contractor (Article 1792-1 of the French Civil Code). It lasts ten years from acceptance of the works (Article 1792-4-1 of the French Civil Code), and any clause that excludes or limits it is deemed unwritten (Article 1792-5 of the French Civil Code).
It works with two insurance policies. The builder must be insured and provide proof of it when work starts on site (Article L. 241-1 of the French Insurance Code); save for exceptions, the project owner takes out dommages-ouvrage insurance, which pre-finances the repairs without waiting for liability to be determined (Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code). In practice, the project owner notifies the claim to that insurer, or to the builder and its insurer, then applies for an expert assessment if cover is disputed.
Acceptance of the works, which starts the time limit, clears apparent defects that were not reserved (Cass. 3e civ., 8 October 2026, No. 24-16.523). The firm therefore checks three points first: the date of acceptance, the seriousness of the defect and the steps already taken to preserve the time limit. See also our practical guide to the garantie décennale.
Cracks, water ingress, roofing: which defects are covered by decennial liability?
Those that reach the seriousness required by Article 1792 of the French Civil Code: damage to the solidity of the work, or unfitness for its intended purpose. Cracks that affect the structure, water ingress that makes a room uninhabitable or a roof that lets water through can reach that threshold; a purely cosmetic defect does not, since there is no harm to solidity or to intended use. The expert assessment decides the question case by case.
Items of equipment that are inseparable from the works of site servicing, foundations, structure, enclosure or roofing are covered when their solidity is affected: an item is inseparable when it cannot be removed, dismantled or replaced without damaging the work or removing material from it (Article 1792-2 of the French Civil Code).
The defect must reach that seriousness within the ten years. The Court of Cassation upheld the dismissal of a claim "in the absence of decennial damage established during the test period" (our translation), where the expert had only noted a risk of falling tiles due to the lack of a roof underlay; in the same case, it held that a real health risk, linked to odours, made the work unfit for its intended purpose (Cass. 3e civ., 11 May 2022, No. 21-15.608).
For roofing and roof structures, see our page on roofing and roof structure disputes, and our article on water ingress through expansion joints. The firm has the defect formally recorded before any repair, so that its cause remains observable.
Does defective thermal or sound insulation fall under the garantie décennale?
Yes, when it makes the work unfit for its intended purpose within the meaning of Article 1792 of the French Civil Code. Discomfort is not enough; a house that can only be heated at the cost of abnormal energy consumption may, on the other hand, fall under the guarantee. For defective sound insulation, the test is the same: unfitness for purpose, assessed case by case on the expert's measurements.
The Paris Court of Appeal sets the two boundaries. It points out that "mere thermal discomfort is not enough to establish unfitness for purpose" (our translation), then applied the décennale to badly installed under-roof insulation, with excess electricity consumption reaching 60% above the regulatory values according to the expert: "It therefore appears established that the air-tightness defects, whose consequences can only be offset by excessive energy consumption, make the house unfit for its intended purpose." (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 5, 4 June 2025, No. 22/14479).
The same decision rejects the argument based on acceptance without reservations, even though the buyers had made a general reservation about the loft insulation: "damage can be apparent only if not only its manifestation but also its causes and consequences were apparent" (our translation). The buyers had grasped the extent of the defect only after the first winter (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 5, 4 June 2025, No. 22/14479).
Proof rests on measurements: compared energy bills, thermal imaging, acoustic measurements, an expert's report. The firm has them prepared before opening discussions with the insurer. See our article on defective thermal insulation.
Heat pump, air conditioning, solar panels on an existing house: does the décennale apply?
In principle no, since the judgment of 21 March 2024. The Court of Cassation holds that "where items of equipment installed as a replacement or an addition on an existing construction work do not in themselves constitute a construction work, they fall neither under the ten-year guarantee nor under the two-year guarantee of proper functioning, whatever the seriousness of the defects, but under ordinary contractual liability, which is not subject to builders' compulsory insurance" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 21 March 2024, No. 22-18.694). It thus ruled out the décennale for a fireplace insert that had caused the house to burn down. This solution, unfavourable to the owner, applies to pending proceedings, provided that it does not cause a disproportionate interference with legal certainty or with the right of access to a court.
The Nîmes Court of Appeal applied it to a heat pump installed in place of a boiler: in the absence of substantial works, the installation was not a construction work, and the defects "do not fall under the ten-year guarantee, even where the seriousness of the defects is established, but under ordinary contractual liability" (our translation). As the installer was in liquidation, the owners obtained only the entry of their claims as debts against its estate (CA Nîmes, 2e ch., sect. A, 25 June 2026, No. 25/01458).
Two routes remain open. If the works themselves constitute a construction work, given their scale and the building techniques used, Article 1792 of the French Civil Code applies. Otherwise, the installer is liable for its contractual faults, and its civil liability insurer, if it has one, can be pursued through the direct action (Article L. 124-3 of the French Insurance Code). But that insurance is not compulsory, and its exclusions can be raised against the injured party: in the Nîmes case, the clauses excluding the cost of redoing the work and non-consequential intangible losses, "which can be raised against third parties since the insurance is not compulsory" (our translation), led to the dismissal of the claims against that insurer (CA Nîmes, 2e ch., sect. A, 25 June 2026, No. 25/01458). The firm first classifies the works, on the basis of the quote, the invoice and the expert's findings.
Is renovation work covered by the garantie décennale?
It is if it constitutes a construction work. Article 1792 of the French Civil Code refers to the builder "of a construction work" (our translation): a major renovation that transforms the building falls within the scope of the guarantee; mere decorative work or the fitting of equipment does not.
The Nîmes Court of Appeal sums up the test: "To constitute a construction work, works on existing buildings must be substantial works carried out with new materials, matter or the use of building techniques, and amount to a transformation of the existing building and a genuine renovation, not a mere refurbishment." (our translation) It refused that classification for a heat pump connected to the existing installation and removable without damage to the building (CA Nîmes, 2e ch., sect. A, 25 June 2026, No. 25/01458).
The Court of Cassation drew the same dividing line for equipment: items added or replaced on an existing building, without constituting a construction work in themselves, fall under contractual liability, whatever the seriousness of the defect (Cass. 3e civ., 21 March 2024, No. 22-18.694). Items of equipment inseparable from a construction work remain subject to Article 1792-2 of the French Civil Code.
The classification is proved by documents: nature and scale of the works in the quote, plans, invoices for materials, photographs of the site. The firm examines them before choosing the legal basis, because a classification error means losing the decennial insurer. See our article on the décennale in energy renovation.
The defect was visible at acceptance of the works: is it still covered?
Not if it was apparent and was not reserved. Acceptance is the act by which the project owner accepts the work, with or without reservations (Article 1792-6 of the French Civil Code), and the Court of Cassation holds that "Acceptance of the work covers any construction defect, disorder or non-conformity that was apparent and not made the subject of reservations." (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 8 October 2026, No. 24-16.523).
Whether a defect was apparent is assessed strictly. It is judged "on the day of acceptance and exclusively from the standpoint of the project owner" (our translation); for a company, in the light of its corporate purpose and activities, not of its manager's expertise (Cass. 3e civ., 8 October 2026, No. 24-16.523). For the Paris Court of Appeal, "damage can be apparent only if not only its manifestation but also its causes and consequences were apparent" (our translation): an insulation defect whose extent only came to light in the first winter was not apparent (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 5, 4 June 2025, No. 22/14479).
A reserved defect falls first under the one-year completion guarantee (garantie de parfait achèvement), which the contractor owes for one year for defects noted in the acceptance report or notified in writing (Article 1792-6 of the French Civil Code). Dommages-ouvrage insurance, for its part, covers defects of a decennial nature that appear after acceptance (Cass. 3e civ., 11 May 2022, No. 21-15.608).
The firm reads the acceptance report line by line: a precise reservation preserves rights that a vague one does not always secure. See our article on the one-year completion guarantee.
How long do I have to bring a decennial claim, and how do I interrupt the ten-year time limit?
Ten years from acceptance of the works (Article 1792-4-1 of the French Civil Code). The Court of Cassation classes this time limit as a foreclosure period: "The ten-year period for bringing a claim against builders on the basis of Articles 1792-4-1 to 1792-4-3 of the Civil Code is a foreclosure period." (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 9 October 2025, No. 23-20.446). The rules on limitation apply to it only where a text so provides (Article 2220 of the French Civil Code).
Such a text exists for court claims: "A court claim, even in urgent proceedings, interrupts the limitation period as well as the foreclosure period" (our translation) (Article 2241 of the French Civil Code). The judgment of 22 October 2026 specifies that the time limit "is interrupted by a summons for a court-ordered expert assessment in urgent proceedings, and starts running again for a full period of ten years from the order granting the investigative measure" (our translation), and that the suspension under Article 2239 of the French Civil Code does not apply to it (Cass. 3e civ., 22 October 2026, No. 24-22.203).
Three pitfalls are common. A summons interrupts the time limit only for the defects it expressly identifies (Cass. 3e civ., 2 May 2024, No. 22-23.004). An acknowledgement of liability by the builder does not interrupt the time limit (Cass. 3e civ., 9 October 2025, No. 23-20.446). And the interruption is void if the claim is withdrawn, lapses or is finally dismissed (Article 2243 of the French Civil Code).
The firm calculates the time limit at the first appointment, from the acceptance report, and sues all the builders and their insurers, identifying each defect.
The tradesman had no decennial insurance: what are my options?
The absence of insurance does not remove liability: the tradesman remains liable as of right under Article 1792 of the French Civil Code. The risk is solvency: without an insurer, a judgment is worth only what the business is worth.
The duty to insure is general: anyone whose decennial liability may be engaged must be insured and provide proof of it when work starts on site (Article L. 241-1 of the French Insurance Code), by means of a certificate attached to quotes and invoices (Article L. 243-2 of the French Insurance Code). Failure to do so is a criminal offence (délit) punishable by six months' imprisonment and a fine of 75,000 euros, or by one of these two penalties only, except for an individual who builds a home to live in themselves or for occupation by their spouse, ascendants, descendants or those of their spouse (Article L. 243-3 of the French Insurance Code).
The manager may be liable on their personal assets. The Court of Cassation set aside the judgment that had failed to examine whether the manager had committed "faults separable from his corporate functions, engaging his personal liability, by failing to enter into a contract for the construction of a detached house and to take out decennial liability insurance" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 7 June 2018, No. 16-27.680).
Before acting, the firm checks that no insurance existed on the date work started, for the activity actually carried out; it looks for the project owner's dommages-ouvrage insurance, if one was taken out (Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code), and for the other insured contractors. See our article on tradesmen without decennial insurance.
The company has disappeared or is in liquidation: can I claim against its insurer?
Yes. "The injured third party has a right of direct action against the insurer covering the civil liability of the person responsible" (our translation) (Article L. 124-3 of the French Insurance Code). The decennial insurance policy is deemed to maintain cover for the duration of the decennial liability, notwithstanding any provision to the contrary (Article L. 241-1 of the French Insurance Code): the disappearance of the company does not bring that cover to an end.
This action has a timetable. It is in principle subject to the same time limit as the claim against the person liable, but "it may nevertheless be brought against the insurer for as long as the insurer remains exposed to a claim by its insured" (our translation); and "an action for a court-ordered expert assessment in urgent proceedings starts the two-year limitation period for the insured's action against the insurer" (our translation). In that case, which went against the project owner, the Court of Cassation set aside the judgment that allowed the direct action without finding that the insurer remained exposed to a claim by its insured (Cass. 3e civ., 14 September 2023, No. 22-21.493).
If the company was not insured, or if the defect does not fall under the décennale, what remains is lodging the claim in the insolvency proceedings and having it entered against the estate. That is what the owner of a defective heat pump obtained, the installer being in liquidation (CA Nîmes, 2e ch., sect. A, 25 June 2026, No. 25/01458). The uninsured manager may then be pursued personally (Cass. 3e civ., 7 June 2018, No. 16-27.680).
The firm sues the insurer at the same time as the company and its liquidator. See our pages on lodging a claim in insolvency proceedings and compulsory liquidation.
The dommages-ouvrage insurer does not reply or refuses: what can I do?
Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code strictly regulates the insurer: sixty days from receipt of the claim notification to decide whether cover applies in principle, ninety days to make an offer if it accepts, fifteen days to pay the accepted offer. If it misses a deadline or makes a manifestly insufficient offer, the insured may, after notifying it, incur the repair costs, and the compensation is automatically increased by interest at twice the statutory interest rate.
The Court of Cassation draws consequences from this that favour the project owner. The insurer "is required to respond within the sixty-day period to every claim notification, including where it considers that the defects are identical to those previously reported" (our translation), failing which it loses the right to raise the two-year limitation period that would have expired by the date of that new notification (Cass. 3e civ., 30 September 2021, No. 20-18.883). An insurer that has accepted cover within that period "can no longer dispute it on the ground that the defects are not decennial in nature" (our translation) and must fund the work needed to remedy them (Cass. 3e civ., 3 April 2025, No. 23-16.055).
A reasoned refusal can be challenged: it often turns on whether the defect was apparent at acceptance or on its seriousness. Yet dommages-ouvrage insurance covers defects of a decennial nature that appear after acceptance (Cass. 3e civ., 11 May 2022, No. 21-15.608). The action against the insurer is time-barred after two years (Article L. 114-1 of the French Insurance Code), a period interrupted by the appointment of an expert or by a registered letter from the insured concerning the compensation (Article L. 114-2 of the French Insurance Code).
See our article on the statutory time limits of the dommages-ouvrage insurer.
The decennial insurer refuses cover: which grounds can be challenged?
The most common grounds for refusal are that the defect is not decennial, that it was apparent at acceptance, that the time limit has expired, that the equipment was fitted to an existing building and that the activity was not declared. Each is checked against the texts and the documents.
The declared activity is the most technical ground. The Court of Cassation accepts that cover extends only to the sector of activity declared by the builder, but "where the insurer denies cover by relying on a clause in the special conditions of the insurance policy that excludes from the cover the activity carried out by the builder, it must prove that this clause was brought to the insured's attention and that the insured accepted it" (our translation). The judgment that had upheld the refusal on inadequate and speculative grounds was quashed (Cass. 3e civ., 17 November 2021, No. 20-16.771).
The duration of cover is not negotiable: the policy is "deemed to include a clause maintaining cover for the duration of the decennial liability" (our translation), notwithstanding any provision to the contrary (Article L. 241-1 of the French Insurance Code). On the other hand, the refusal is well founded where equipment fitted to an existing building does not constitute a construction work (Cass. 3e civ., 21 March 2024, No. 22-18.694).
The insured builder also has a time limit against its insurer: two years, which, where a third party claims against the builder, run only from the day that third party sued it or was compensated (Article L. 114-1 of the French Insurance Code). The firm reviews the special conditions, the certificate given to the project owner and the chronology before responding. See our article on decennial cover refused by the insurer.
I bought a house less than ten years old: can I bring a garantie décennale claim?
Yes. The guarantee benefits the buyer of the work (Article 1792 of the French Civil Code), and the Court of Cassation holds that "while the action under the ten-year guarantee is in principle transferred to buyers together with ownership of the building, the project owner does not lose the right to bring it where it has a direct and certain interest in doing so" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-22.376). The buyer acts against the original builders and their insurers, within the ten-year period that runs from acceptance of the works, not from the sale.
The seller may itself be liable. A person who sells, after completion, a work that they built or had built is deemed a builder (Article 1792-1 of the French Civil Code). The seller of a building to be constructed is bound by the obligations of Articles 1792 to 1792-3 from acceptance, and these guarantees benefit successive owners (Article 1646-1 of the French Civil Code).
The deed of sale helps prepare the claim: where it is signed within the ten years, it states whether the compulsory insurance policies exist, and the insurance certificate is annexed to it (Article L. 243-2 of the French Insurance Code). The firm starts from these annexes to identify the contractors, their insurers and the date of acceptance.
The statutory guarantee excludes ordinary law for the same damage: "damage falling under a statutory guarantee cannot give rise, against the persons bound by that guarantee, to a claim for compensation based on ordinary contractual liability" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-22.376). For off-plan purchases, see our article on the décennale in off-plan sales (VEFA).
You are a builder facing a decennial claim: how can you defend yourself?
The presumption in Article 1792 of the French Civil Code is not irrebuttable. The builder is exonerated by proving an external cause, and first challenges the conditions of the guarantee: existence of a construction work, seriousness of the defect, whether it was apparent at acceptance, whether it is attributable to its work.
Whether the defect was apparent is argued from the standpoint of the project owner: acceptance covers apparent defects that were not reserved, assessed "on the day of acceptance and exclusively from the standpoint of the project owner" (our translation) and, for a legal entity, in the light of its corporate purpose and activities (Cass. 3e civ., 8 October 2026, No. 24-16.523). Equipment fitted to an existing building, if it does not constitute a construction work, falls under ordinary contractual liability, outside compulsory insurance (Cass. 3e civ., 21 March 2024, No. 22-18.694).
Time limits also protect the builder. The ten-year period is a foreclosure period, which the builder's own acknowledgement of liability does not interrupt (Cass. 3e civ., 9 October 2025, No. 23-20.446); a summons interrupts the time limit only for the defects it identifies (Cass. 3e civ., 2 May 2024, No. 22-23.004); and "no action, even a recourse action, based on this guarantee may be brought more than ten years after acceptance" (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-22.376).
The builder must also protect its recourse against its insurer: it has two years from the third party's summons or compensation (Article L. 114-1 of the French Insurance Code). The firm notifies the claim to the insurer, joins the other contractors and their insurers as third parties, and argues the apportionment between co-obligors before the expert. For building contractors, see our page on construction industry lawyers.
What are the fees of a garantie décennale lawyer?
Fees are set out in a written fee agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: review of the documents and calculation of the time limit, claim notification and challenge to an insurer's refusal, formal notice, référé-expertise, attendance at expert meetings and written observations, proceedings on the merits, appeal. Court expert fees, bailiff (commissaire de justice) fees and court costs are added to the fees. Any new task is covered by an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected invoicing.
For a builder or a company handling several claims, an ongoing support engagement can cover notifications to insurers, monitoring of expert assessments and third-party claims against other contractors, for a fixed fee set in advance in the agreement.
For a first opinion on the documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. First call on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles 1792, 1792-1, 1792-2, 1792-3, 1792-4, 1792-5, 1792-6 and 1792-7 of the French Civil Code: builders' liability, items of equipment, acceptance of the works
- Articles 1792-4-1, 1792-4-2 and 1792-4-3 of the French Civil Code: time limits for claims against builders and subcontractors
- Article 1646-1 of the French Civil Code: seller of a building to be constructed
- Articles 2220, 2239, 2241, 2242 and 2243 of the French Civil Code: foreclosure, suspension and interruption
- Articles L. 241-1, L. 241-2, L. 243-2 and L. 243-3 of the French Insurance Code: decennial liability insurance
- Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code: dommages-ouvrage (property damage) insurance
- Articles L. 124-3, L. 114-1 and L. 114-2 of the French Insurance Code: direct action, two-year limitation period
- Article 145 of the French Code of Civil Procedure: expert assessment before any trial
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. 3e civ., 21 March 2024, No. 22-18.694: equipment fitted to an existing construction work
- CA Nîmes, 2e ch., sect. A, 25 June 2026, No. 25/01458: heat pump on an existing building, classification as a construction work
- CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 5, 4 June 2025, No. 22/14479: defective thermal insulation and unfitness for purpose
- Cass. 3e civ., 11 May 2022, No. 21-15.608: seriousness within the test period, dommages-ouvrage
- Cass. 3e civ., 8 October 2026, No. 24-16.523: defect apparent at acceptance
- Cass. 3e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-22.376: transfer of the claim, test period, exclusion of ordinary law
- Cass. 3e civ., 7 June 2018, No. 16-27.680: company manager and lack of decennial insurance
- Cass. 3e civ., 30 September 2021, No. 20-18.883: sixty-day time limit of the dommages-ouvrage insurer
- Cass. 3e civ., 3 April 2025, No. 23-16.055: dommages-ouvrage cover accepted
- Cass. 3e civ., 17 November 2021, No. 20-16.771: declared activity and proof of the exclusion
- Cass. 3e civ., 14 September 2023, No. 22-21.493: direct action against the insurer and limitation
- Cass. 3e civ., 22 October 2026, No. 24-22.203: référé-expertise and the ten-year foreclosure period
- Cass. 3e civ., 2 May 2024, No. 22-23.004: interruption limited to the defects identified
- Cass. 3e civ., 9 October 2025, No. 23-20.446: acknowledgement of liability and foreclosure
- Cass. 3e civ., 27 April 2017, No. 16-10.691: subcontractor's tort liability, fault to be proved
Further reading
A defect to be repaired, an insurer to be made to pay?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the acceptance report, the quotes and invoices, the insurance certificates, photographs and your correspondence with the contractor or the insurer: Hassan Kohen examines the nature of the defect, the date of acceptance and the time limits, then tells you the appropriate route: claim notification, formal notice, référé-expertise, direct action against the insurer or defence of the builder before the court.