They talk about us
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, CARSAT lawyer in Paris
CARSAT Lawyer in Paris: Pensions, Quarters, Overpayments, AT/MP Rates
Miscalculated pension, quarters (trimestres) missing from the career statement, early retirement for a long career refused, repayment of an overpayment (trop-perçu) demanded, workplace accident contribution rate disputed: as a CARSAT lawyer in Paris, the firm assists insured persons, retirees and employers against the general-scheme pension funds, from the initial complaint to the court. In Paris, the French state pension is handled by the Assurance retraite Île-de-France, not by a CARSAT; the rules and the remedies are the same.
The firm can be reached 24/7. The amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable) must be referred to within two months of notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code); for employers, the AT/MP contribution rate and the risk classification are challenged within two months of their notification, directly before the Amiens Court of Appeal. An enforcement order (contrainte) issued for an overpayment is challenged by objection (opposition) within fifteen days of its notification (Article R. 133-3).
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received a very high standard of support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order that my ex had applied for abusively
Very satisfied with the solution provided for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with a great deal of empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has a complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer of sound advice, kind and available, who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, social security litigation, general-scheme pensions and occupational risk pricing.
Official profile in the French national directory of lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
The regional retirement and occupational health insurance funds (caisses d'assurance retraite et de la santé au travail, CARSAT) record and check the data that determine the pension rights of insured persons in the general scheme (régime général), calculate and pay pensions, and contribute to the pricing of workplace accidents and occupational diseases (Article L. 215-1 of the French Social Security Code). In the Paris region (Île-de-France), the regional fund does not carry out the pension function (Article L. 215-3): Parisians deal with the Assurance retraite Île-de-France, while pricing remains with the regional health insurance fund for Île-de-France (caisse régionale d'assurance maladie d'Île-de-France). A decision is first challenged before the amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable), within two months (Article R. 142-1), then before the social division of the judicial court (pôle social du tribunal judiciaire); a medical or incapacity-related challenge goes before the medical amicable appeals board (commission médicale de recours amiable) (Article R. 142-8). An enforcement order (contrainte) issued for an overpayment is challenged directly, by a reasoned objection before the court, within fifteen days of its notification (Articles L. 161-1-5 and R. 133-3). An employer's AT/MP rate is brought before the Amiens Court of Appeal (Article D. 311-12 of the Code of Judicial Organisation). A pension overpayment becomes time-barred after two years, except in cases of fraud or false declaration (Article L. 355-3). Kohen Avocats, in the 16th arrondissement of Paris, acts for insured persons, retirees, surviving spouses and employers. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A pension to check, an overpayment claimed, an AT/MP rate to challenge?
Understanding your situation
CARSAT and your French state pension rights, explained
The regional retirement and occupational health insurance funds “calculate and pay the pensions resulting from these rights” (Article L. 215-1 of the French Social Security Code). Who decides in Paris, how the pension is calculated and proven, what the fund can claim back, how employers challenge their rate, and which route to take to challenge a decision.
Key points
What CARSAT does, and who replaces it in Paris
Two functions, pensions and occupational risks, and an organisation specific to the Paris region.
General-scheme pensions: the fund records and checks the data needed to determine entitlements, calculates and pays pensions, and informs and advises insured persons and their employers on old-age insurance legislation (Article L. 215-1, 1°).
Occupational risks: it develops the prevention of workplace accidents and occupational diseases and contributes to applying the pricing rules and setting the rates (Article L. 215-1, 2°). The AT/MP contribution rate is set each year by the fund for each risk category (Article L. 242-5).
The Paris-region exception: for the Île-de-France region, the competent fund does not carry out the pension functions under 1° of Article L. 215-1 (Article L. 215-3). Paris and the seven other departments of the region come under the Assurance retraite Île-de-France (contacts page of the Assurance retraite).
The competent fund: the pension application is sent to the fund for the insured person's place of residence, or for their last place of work if they live abroad; an application sent to another fund remains admissible, and that fund then calculates the entitlements, except for residents of the Haut-Rhin, Bas-Rhin and Moselle, whose application falls exclusively to CARSAT Alsace-Moselle (Article R. 351-34).
For an insured person in Paris, the name changes but the law stays the same. In court, the pension disputes of Paris-region residents set the insured person against the National Old-Age Insurance Fund (Caisse nationale d'assurance vieillesse, CNAV): it was a party to the plenary assembly judgment of 17 May 2023 on overpayments, arising from a case decided in the Val-d'Oise (Cass. ass. plén., 17 May 2023, No. 20-20.559), and to the judgment of 25 January 2018 given on an appeal against a judgment of the Paris Court of Appeal (Cass. 2e civ., 25 January 2018, No. 16-27.854). Pricing challenges by Paris-region employers are directed against the regional health insurance fund for Île-de-France, a party to the judgment of 25 June 2026 on risk classification (Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-20.587). Outside the Paris region, the regional CARSATs are involved, for example Rhône-Alpes, Sud-Est, Normandie, Bourgogne Franche-Comté or Alsace-Moselle in the decisions cited on this page.
Many decisions can be challenged: pension award notice, refusal of early retirement, refusal to validate quarters, pension effective date, request for repayment of an overpayment, survivor's pension (pension de réversion) reduced or withdrawn, contribution rate, classification of an establishment, charging of an occupational disease to the employer's account. Silence kept by the fund for four months on a pension application itself amounts to a decision of rejection (Article R. 351-34).
The legal retirement age, the full rate (taux plein) and the required insurance period by year of birth are set out on our page French pension and social protection lawyer in Paris. This page deals with the fund's decisions and how to challenge them.
The pension
Quarters, long careers, calculation and effective date
The pension is decided on the career statement long before the award notice.
Career statement
Everyone has the right to obtain a statement of their individual position regarding the entitlements built up in the compulsory schemes, and has access to an online service giving their updated statement (Article L. 161-17, III). This is where missing quarters are spotted.
Quarters
An insurance period is only counted if a minimum level of contributions was paid for it; in cases of force majeure or manifest impossibility of proving payment, proof may come from probative documents or consistent presumptions (Article L. 351-2).
Long career
The retirement age is lowered for insured persons who started work before one of four ages set by decree and who have a sufficient contributory insurance period (Article L. 351-1-1); the starting-age thresholds are sixteen, eighteen, twenty and twenty-one (Article D. 351-1-1).
Calculation
The amount results from applying to the basic annual salary (salaire annuel de base) a rate that rises with the insurance period, up to the full rate (Article L. 351-1). Entitlements take account of contributions recorded up to the last day of the calendar quarter preceding the pension start date (Article R. 351-1).
Application and effective date
The pension is not paid automatically: it must be applied for from the competent fund, which issues a receipt (Article R. 351-34). The insured person chooses the start date, which must be the first day of a month and can never precede the filing of the application; failing this, the pension takes effect on the first day of the month following receipt of the application (Article R. 351-37, I).
Notification
A pension that is notified and not challenged in time becomes final. It should therefore be checked as soon as it is received, line by line, before the two-month period expires.
Proof of quarters is the leading source of pension litigation. The Cour de cassation requires a finding, “for each of the disputed periods, of the deduction at source of the contributions due for general-scheme old-age insurance” (our translation), and quashed a judgment that had validated quarters on indications that were too general (Cass. 2e civ., 12 July 2018, No. 17-17.830). For the Toulouse Court of Appeal, proof “is, in principle, provided by producing either payslips or an employer's certificate certified as consistent with the accounting records” (our translation). In that case, CARSAT credited five quarters during the proceedings on the basis of the payslips produced, but the remainder was rejected for lack of proof (CA Toulouse, 6 February 2025, No. 23/03113).
Long-career refusals are argued quarter by quarter. The Cour de cassation upheld the validation of three quarters of civilian service by a conscientious objector “as quarters deemed contributed to be taken into account in an application for early retirement for a long career” (our translation), against CARSAT Rhône-Alpes (Cass. 2e civ., 20 September 2018, No. 17-21.576). More recently, the Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal held that an insured person covered by three schemes “may claim early retirement for a long career from 1 January 2018” (our translation), after recalculating the remaining days (CA Aix-en-Provence, 11 September 2026, No. 24/09990).
Quarters for studies or incomplete years can be bought back, up to a total of twelve quarters and against contributions set on an actuarially neutral basis (Article L. 351-14-1). See our articles (in French) on missing quarters on the career statement and on refused long-career certificates.
Sums claimed back
Overpayments, pension revision and fault by the fund
What the fund can recover, what it can no longer change, and what it must compensate.
Overpayment without fraud
- Two-year limitation period from the payment of each instalment (Article L. 355-3).
- Where the fund made an error, no repayment is claimed from an insured person acting in good faith whose resources are below the ceiling for the old-age allowance for salaried workers (allocation aux vieux travailleurs salariés).
- Between that ceiling and twice that amount, no automatic deduction: the amicable appeals board may grant full or partial remission and set up a payment schedule.
Alleged fraud or false declaration
- The two-year limitation period does not apply: the action is time-barred five years after discovery (Article 2224 of the Civil Code and Article L. 355-3).
- The fund can then go back as far as twenty years of benefits (Article 2232 of the Civil Code).
- A surcharge equal to 10% of the sums claimed is added where the overpayment results from fraud by the beneficiary (Article L. 355-3).
The stakes of this classification are considerable. The plenary assembly of the Cour de cassation holds that in cases of fraud or false declaration, the action “becomes time-barred five years from the day the fraud or false declaration is discovered” (our translation) and that the action thus “brought within five years of its discovery, allows the fund to recover the whole of the overpayment relating to benefits paid during the twenty years preceding the action” (our translation). In that case, the survivor's pension beneficiary was ordered to repay €23,984.91 (Cass. ass. plén., 17 May 2023, No. 20-20.559). The false declaration is therefore the first point to argue: without it, the fund remains confined to two years.
A notified pension cannot be reopened at will. For the Cour de cassation, it “becomes final when its award has been the subject of a decision by the fund duly notified to the insured person and not challenged by them in good time” (our translation); the judgment was quashed because the judges had not examined whether the time limit for challenging the first notification had expired (Cass. 2e civ., 25 January 2018, No. 16-27.854). The principle protects retirees against a late reduction, but it also bars them from challenging out of time. And a pension once awarded is not revised to take account of payments relating to a period after the date on which the account was closed (Article R. 351-10; Cass. 2e civ., 10 October 2019, No. 18-20.849).
A fund that fails in its duty to inform is liable: the Cour de cassation upheld an order against a CARSAT that had “committed a fault causing the insured person to lose a chance of having her personal pension awarded” (our translation) earlier (Cass. 2e civ., 8 April 2021, No. 19-24.135). See our articles (in French) on enforcement orders for pension overpayments and on reduced or reclaimed survivor's pensions.
Employers
AT/MP contribution rate, risk classification and employer account
Technical litigation, brought before a single court for the whole country, with short time limits.
Rate
The AT/MP contribution rate is set each year by the fund for each risk category, according to rules laid down by decree (Article L. 242-5). It is calculated per establishment, except where a single rate applies, under individual or mixed pricing, to the company's establishments belonging to the same risk category (Article D. 242-6-1).
Ranking
An establishment is classified in a risk category according to the activity carried on, under a nomenclature set by ministerial order (Article D. 242-6-1); the classification can be changed at any time (Article L. 242-5).
Notification
Rate and classification decisions are notified electronically; once the employer has completed the steps needed for them to be made available, they are deemed notified on the date they are consulted and at the latest fifteen days after being made available (Article L. 242-5).
Surcharges
The fund may grant rebates for prevention measures, or impose additional contributions for exceptional risks, in particular after failure to comply with prescribed prevention measures (Article L. 242-7).
Appeals
No amicable appeals board: the prior appeal requirement does not apply to this type of litigation (Article L. 142-4). The Amiens Court of Appeal hears these cases (Article D. 311-12 of the Code of Judicial Organisation), at first and last instance (Article L. 242-5), within two months of notification (Article R. 142-1-A, III).
Referral
The appeal is brought by a writ of summons (assignation) to a hearing set by the first president of the court, with a copy of the contested decision; a copy of the writ is filed with the court registry before the hearing, failing which the appeal lapses (Article R. 142-13-1).
The two-month time limit is strict. The Cour de cassation holds that the classification of the establishment “is a decision adversely affecting the employer, which the employer must, if it disagrees, challenge within two months of its notification” (our translation); a Paris-region employer that had challenged only its rate was held to be time-barred as regards its classification (Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-20.587).
The employer account follows a more flexible rule. The employer “is entitled to challenge the charging of the consequences of an occupational disease to its employer account without being met with the time bar on challenging the last contribution rate notified” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 7 April 2022, No. 20-18.310). The limit was set in 2025: the time limit “may be raised against the employer where that request, which cannot have the effect of altering a rate that has become final, is made in the course of proceedings challenging that rate” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 15 May 2025, No. 22-24.655). The order of the steps therefore matters as much as the substance.
A disease contracted while working for several successive employers can be entered in the special account (compte spécial), which removes it from the company's account. The Amiens Court of Appeal points out that the employer must prove that the employee “was exposed to the risk successively in several establishments of different companies” (our translation) and that it is impossible to identify the company responsible; it ordered the entry on the basis of statements from former colleagues (CA Amiens, 24 January 2025, No. 24/01650). Upstream, the challenge to the local health insurance fund's recognition of the disease is handled separately: see our pages (in French) on CPAM disputes and on the employer's inexcusable fault.
Appeals
Challenging a CARSAT decision, step by step
A mandatory prior complaint, an optional mediator, then the court.
The fund's amicable appeals board must be referred to within two months of notification of the contested decision (Article R. 142-1). This prior appeal is a precondition for court proceedings (Article L. 142-4).
Time limits can only be raised if they were stated, together with the available remedies, in the notification of the decision or, for an implicit decision, in the acknowledgement of receipt of the application (Article R. 142-1-A, III).
If the board has not decided within two months of receiving the complaint, the complaint may be treated as rejected; the period only runs from receipt of any documents produced later (Article R. 142-6).
The fund's mediator can be approached after a prior request to its departments and before any court proceedings; mediation interrupts the time limits for appeal, from notification that the complaint is admissible until the mediator's recommendations (Article L. 217-7-1).
The specially designated social division of the judicial court (pôle social du tribunal judiciaire) is seised by an application lodged with or sent to the registry by recorded delivery with acknowledgement of receipt, with a brief statement of the grounds, the supporting documents and the contested decision (Article R. 142-10-1; Article L. 211-16 of the Code of Judicial Organisation).
An appeal must be lodged within one month (Article 538 of the Code of Civil Procedure); representation by a lawyer is not compulsory on appeal (Article R. 142-11).
The prior appeal is not a formality. The Paris Court of Appeal holds that “The failure to refer the matter first to the amicable appeals board therefore makes the application to the court inadmissible, the burden of proving that prior referral lying on the party alleging it.” (our translation) A widow challenging her survivor's pension thus lost on appeal, for lack of proof of her complaint (CA Paris, 21 February 2025, No. 21/02782). The firm therefore keeps proof of every item sent: recorded-delivery letter, acknowledgement of receipt, copy of the complaint and of the documents.
The points the firm checks in every case:
The procedure before the board and before the court is detailed on our pages (in French) on amicable appeals board proceedings and social division (pôle social) litigation.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified court decisions.
I live in Paris: does CARSAT manage my French state pension?
No. The regional retirement and occupational health insurance funds (CARSAT) record the pension rights of insured persons in the general scheme, and calculate and pay pensions (Article L. 215-1 of the French Social Security Code). But for the Île-de-France region, the competent fund within the meaning of that article does not carry out these pension functions (Article L. 215-3). Paris, Seine-et-Marne, Yvelines, Essonne, Hauts-de-Seine, Seine-Saint-Denis, Val-de-Marne and Val-d'Oise come under the Assurance retraite Île-de-France, according to the contacts page of the Assurance retraite.
The pension application is sent to the fund for the insured person's place of residence, or for their last place of work if they live abroad. An application sent to another fund remains admissible: the fund that received it then examines it and calculates the entitlements, except for residents of the Haut-Rhin, Bas-Rhin and Moselle, whose application falls exclusively to CARSAT Alsace-Moselle (Article R. 351-34). An insured person who worked in another region and retires in Paris therefore does not need to track down the former CARSAT of that region.
For employers, workplace accident pricing for establishments in the Paris region falls to the regional health insurance fund for Île-de-France, a party for example to the Cour de cassation judgment of 25 June 2026 on risk classification (Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-20.587). Apart from the exclusive jurisdiction of CARSAT Alsace-Moselle, the substantive rules, time limits and remedies are the same throughout France: the firm acts in Paris as well as before the regional funds.
What does a lawyer do in a dispute with CARSAT?
The lawyer checks the decision, chooses the remedy and prepares the evidence. The fund decides alone, on the data it holds: a quarter missing from the statement, an application received later than expected or a misunderstood source of income is enough to reduce a pension for the whole of retirement. Yet the notification must be challenged within a short time: the amicable appeals board must be referred to within two months of notification (Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code), and this prior appeal is a precondition for access to the court (Article L. 142-4).
The firm reconstructs the career from the individual statement of entitlements (relevé de situation individuelle) (Article L. 161-17), payslips and certificates, drafts the reasoned complaint, approaches the mediator where the case lends itself to it (Article L. 217-7-1), then brings the dispute before the social division of the judicial court. It also defends retirees from whom the fund claims an overpayment, and employers challenging their AT/MP contribution rate before the Amiens Court of Appeal.
Sometimes more than the pension itself is at stake. The Cour de cassation upheld an order against a CARSAT that had not fulfilled its duty to inform and had thus “committed a fault causing the insured person to lose a chance of having her personal pension awarded” (our translation) earlier (Cass. 2e civ., 8 April 2021, No. 19-24.135). The firm then quantifies the loss and claims it.
Quarters are missing from my French career statement: how can I get them validated?
By proving that contributions were paid for the period. An insurance period is only counted if a minimum level of contributions was paid for the calendar year concerned; in cases of force majeure or manifest impossibility for the insured person to provide that proof, it may be provided by probative documents or consistent presumptions (Article L. 351-2 of the French Social Security Code).
The case law is demanding. The Cour de cassation quashed a judgment that validated quarters “on grounds unable to establish, for each of the disputed periods, the deduction at source of the contributions due for general-scheme old-age insurance” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 12 July 2018, No. 17-17.830). The Toulouse Court of Appeal states that proof is in principle provided by payslips or an employer's certificate certified as consistent with the accounting records, and that “statements giving no detail as to the size, date or amount of the deductions made” (our translation) are not sufficient. In that case, CARSAT credited five quarters during the proceedings on the basis of the payslips produced, and the court rejected the remainder for lack of proof (CA Toulouse, 6 February 2025, No. 23/03113).
The firm therefore lists, period by period, what can be produced: payslips, certificates of employment, employer certificates, supplementary pension statements, unemployment or daily sickness benefit decisions. See our article (in French) on employers that no longer exist and lost payslips.
The fund refuses my early retirement for a long career: what can I do?
Go back over the count of quarters. The retirement age is lowered for insured persons who started work before one of four ages set by decree and who have an insurance period of which all or part gave rise to contributions paid by them (Article L. 351-1-1 of the French Social Security Code). The starting-age thresholds are sixteen, eighteen, twenty and twenty-one, and the corresponding retirement age varies with the year of birth (Article D. 351-1-1). The decree specifies which periods are deemed contributed.
A refusal often turns on a single quarter. The Cour de cassation upheld the validation of three quarters of civilian service “as quarters deemed contributed to be taken into account in an application for early retirement for a long career” (our translation), setting aside a regulatory restriction held to be incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights (Cass. 2e civ., 20 September 2018, No. 17-21.576). The Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal, for its part, recalculated the record of an insured person covered by three schemes and held that he “may claim early retirement for a long career from 1 January 2018” (our translation); it also awarded €1,500 for non-pecuniary loss because the fund had failed to respond (CA Aix-en-Provence, 11 September 2026, No. 24/09990).
The firm checks the quarters contributed before each age threshold, the periods deemed contributed and the remaining periods in other schemes, then files the complaint with the amicable appeals board within two months. See our article (in French) on refused long-career certificates.
My French pension seems miscalculated: how can I check it?
By going back over its three components. The amount of the pension results from applying to the basic annual salary a rate that rises, up to the full rate, according to the insurance period across all schemes or the age at which the pension is claimed; if the period completed in the general scheme is below the limit, the pension is then reduced proportionately (Article L. 351-1 of the French Social Security Code). Entitlements are determined taking account of contributions recorded up to the last day of the calendar quarter preceding the pension start date, the age reached on that date and the number of qualifying quarters (Article R. 351-1).
Each element is checked against the documents: the salaries recorded year by year, the quarters validated, contributed or treated as equivalent, the rate applied and the pro rata reduction. An error in a single salary entry or a single quarter can change the result for the whole of retirement.
The check must be done quickly. The Cour de cassation holds that the pension “becomes final when its award has been the subject of a decision by the fund duly notified to the insured person and not challenged by them in good time” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 25 January 2018, No. 16-27.854). The complaint to the amicable appeals board must therefore be filed within two months of notification (Article R. 142-1). The legal retirement age and the period required for the full rate are set out on our page French pension and social protection lawyer in Paris.
Can a French pension already awarded be revised?
Sometimes, but within narrow limits. A pension once awarded cannot be revised to take account of payments relating to a period after the date on which the insured person's account was closed (Article R. 351-10 of the French Social Security Code). The Cour de cassation applies this provision strictly: “a retirement pension once awarded cannot be revised to take account of payments relating to a period after the date on which the insured person's account was closed” (our translation), and the insured person who sought to have contributions after his pension start date taken into account lost (Cass. 2e civ., 10 October 2019, No. 18-20.849).
Finality also works in the retiree's favour. A pension notified and not challenged in good time becomes final; the Cour de cassation quashed the judgment that had allowed the fund to go back on a first notification without examining whether the time limit for challenging it had expired (Cass. 2e civ., 25 January 2018, No. 16-27.854). A fund that reduces a pension after the event must therefore justify its right to do so, and the reduction is challenged before the amicable appeals board within two months (Article R. 142-1).
A revision requested by the insured person, for a period before the closing of the account that the fund overlooked, is prepared like an application to validate quarters, with supporting evidence. The firm first distinguishes what stems from an error by the fund from what concerns a later period. See our article (in French) on revising a pension after it has been awarded.
My pension started later than expected: can I obtain back payments?
Only if the application really was filed earlier. The pension application is sent to the competent fund, in the form and with the supporting documents required by the regulations, and the fund issues a receipt (Article R. 351-34 of the French Social Security Code). The effective date depends on that application: it is the first day of a month and cannot precede the filing of the application (Article R. 351-37, I).
The Paris Court of Appeal drew the consequences against an insured person who relied on a form completed more than a year before the application recorded by the fund: “the start date of a retirement pension cannot precede the date on which an application is filed in the form and with the supporting documents laid down by order of the Minister for Social Security” (our translation). Email exchanges referring to the application were held insufficient: “these items are insufficient to prove the filing of his application” (our translation), and the claim for damages was dismissed (CA Paris, 20 December 2024, No. 22/07000). Proof of sending, whether a receipt, an acknowledgement of receipt or an online confirmation, therefore decides the dispute.
Another avenue is fault by the fund. Where the delay results from a failure to inform, the insured person can obtain compensation for the lost chance of retiring earlier (Cass. 2e civ., 8 April 2021, No. 19-24.135). Silence kept by the fund for four months on a pension application amounts to rejection (Article R. 351-34) and opens the way to an appeal. See our article (in French) on a postponed effective date and back payments of pension.
The fund is claiming back a pension overpayment: how long does it have to act?
Two years, in principle. Any claim for repayment of an overpayment of old-age and invalidity benefits is time-barred after two years from the payment of those benefits to the beneficiary, except in cases of fraud or false declaration (Article L. 355-3 of the French Social Security Code). The period runs from each payment, instalment by instalment.
Fraud or false declaration changes everything. The plenary assembly of the Cour de cassation holds that the action then becomes time-barred “five years from the day the fraud or false declaration is discovered” (our translation), and that it allows the fund to recover the overpayment over the twenty years preceding the action. The survivor's pension beneficiary was ordered to repay €23,984.91 (Cass. ass. plén., 17 May 2023, No. 20-20.559). The debate therefore focuses first on whether an inaccurate declaration was actually made and on the date it was discovered.
Without fraud, the law also protects modest incomes: where the fund made an error, no repayment is claimed from an insured person acting in good faith whose resources are below the ceiling for the old-age allowance for salaried workers; between that ceiling and twice that amount, the repayment cannot be deducted automatically and the amicable appeals board may grant full or partial remission and a payment schedule (Article L. 355-3). See our article (in French) on enforcement orders for pension overpayments.
My survivor's pension has been reduced or reclaimed: how should I respond?
By checking the resources taken into account. The surviving spouse is entitled to a survivor's pension (pension de réversion) from an age and under conditions set by decree, if their personal resources or those of the household do not exceed ceilings set by decree (Article L. 353-1 of the French Social Security Code). The survivor's pension can be revised if resources change, but the last revision cannot take place more than three months after the start date of all personal basic and supplementary pensions or, for those who cannot claim them, after the age provided for in Article L. 161-17-2 (Article R. 353-1-1). A late revision is challenged first on this ground.
The time the fund has depends on how the case is characterised. Without fraud or false declaration, the repayment claim is time-barred after two years from each payment (Article L. 355-3). With a false declaration, the Cour de cassation applies a five-year limitation period from its discovery and allows the fund to go back twenty years of benefits; the case decided by the plenary assembly concerned precisely a survivor's pension (Cass. ass. plén., 17 May 2023, No. 20-20.559). The characterisation as a “false declaration” is therefore challenged document by document: signed forms, questions asked by the fund, information already in its possession.
The challenge follows the ordinary route: amicable appeals board within two months of notification (Article R. 142-1), then the social division of the judicial court. The Paris Court of Appeal declared inadmissible the appeal of a widow who could not prove that she had referred the matter to the board (CA Paris, 21 February 2025, No. 21/02782). See our article (in French) on refused, reduced or reclaimed survivor's pensions.
The fund does not reply or gave me wrong information: can I obtain compensation?
Yes, if fault and loss are established. Insured persons have a right to information on the pension system at no cost to them: an interview from the age of forty-five, an individual statement of entitlements, an overall indicative estimate of their pensions (Article L. 161-17 of the French Social Security Code). The fund informs and advises insured persons on old-age insurance legislation (Article L. 215-1, 1°).
The Cour de cassation upheld an order against a CARSAT that had not fulfilled its duty to inform an insured person, holding that it had “committed a fault causing the insured person to lose a chance of having her personal pension awarded before 1 January 2013” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 8 April 2021, No. 19-24.135). The Aix-en-Provence Court of Appeal, for its part, held that the “lack of information and response in a complex matter that is vital for insured persons” (our translation) amounted to a fault and awarded €1,500 in damages (CA Aix-en-Provence, 11 September 2026, No. 24/09990). Conversely, the Paris Court of Appeal dismissed the claim of an insured person whose fund had paid the pension from the month following the first valid application (CA Paris, 20 December 2024, No. 22/07000).
Before going to court, the fund's mediator can be approached, after a prior request to its departments and before any court proceedings; mediation interrupts the time limits for appeal from notification that the complaint is admissible until the mediator's recommendations (Article L. 217-7-1). Merely approaching the mediator therefore does not suspend the two-month period. The firm gathers the reminders, replies and dates. See our article (in French) on pension files left unanswered.
How do I challenge a CARSAT decision, and within what time limit?
By a complaint to the amicable appeals board, within two months of notification of the decision (Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code). This prior appeal is mandatory before any court proceedings (Article L. 142-4). There are two exceptions: a medical challenge goes before the medical amicable appeals board (Article R. 142-8), and an enforcement order (contrainte) issued for an overpayment is challenged by objection before the court within fifteen days of its notification (Articles L. 161-1-5 and R. 133-3). Time limits can only be raised if they were stated, together with the available remedies, in the notification of the decision or, for an implicit decision, in the acknowledgement of receipt of the application (Article R. 142-1-A, III). An incomplete notification therefore does not start the time limit running.
If the board has not decided within two months of receiving the complaint, the complaint may be treated as rejected; if documents are produced later, that period only runs from their receipt (Article R. 142-6). The insured person then applies to the social division of the judicial court, within two months (Article R. 142-1-A, III), by an application lodged with or sent to the registry by recorded delivery with acknowledgement of receipt, together with the supporting documents and the contested decision (Article R. 142-10-1); the judgment can be appealed within one month (Article 538 of the Code of Civil Procedure).
Failing to go to the board first carries a sanction. For the Paris Court of Appeal, “The failure to refer the matter first to the amicable appeals board therefore makes the application to the court inadmissible, the burden of proving that prior referral lying on the party alleging it.” (our translation) (CA Paris, 21 February 2025, No. 21/02782). The complaint is therefore sent with its supporting documents, in a way that keeps proof of it. The mediator can be approached in parallel; the mediator does not replace the board, and mediation only interrupts the time limits for appeal from notification that the complaint is admissible until the mediator's recommendations (Article L. 217-7-1). See our page (in French) on amicable appeals board proceedings.
Employers: how do I challenge the AT/MP rate or risk classification notified by CARSAT?
Directly before the Amiens Court of Appeal, without going to the amicable appeals board. The AT/MP contribution rate is set each year by the fund for each risk category, and risks are classified by the fund subject to an appeal by the employer to the court with jurisdiction over pricing, which rules at first and last instance (Article L. 242-5 of the French Social Security Code). The prior appeal requirement does not apply to this type of litigation (Article L. 142-4); the Amiens Court of Appeal has jurisdiction (Article L. 311-16 and Article D. 311-12 of the Code of Judicial Organisation).
The time limit is two months from notification (Article R. 142-1-A, III). Decisions are notified electronically; once the employer has completed the steps needed for them to be made available, they are deemed notified on the date they are consulted, at the latest fifteen days after being made available (Article L. 242-5). The Cour de cassation holds that the classification “is a decision adversely affecting the employer, which the employer must, if it disagrees, challenge within two months of its notification” (our translation); the employer that had challenged only its rate was held to be time-barred as regards its classification (Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-20.587).
The appeal is brought by a writ of summons to a hearing set by the first president of the court, with a copy of the contested decision, and a copy of the writ must be filed with the court registry before the hearing, failing which the appeal lapses (Article R. 142-13-1). The classification is argued on the basis of the activity actually carried on, under the risk nomenclature (Article D. 242-6-1); additional contributions and rebates come before the same court (Article L. 242-7). The firm checks the nomenclature, the claims charged and the timetable of notifications.
Employers: how do I remove an occupational disease from the employer account?
By challenging the charging of the cost, or by applying for its entry in the special account (compte spécial). The Cour de cassation holds that the employer “is entitled to challenge the charging of the consequences of an occupational disease to its employer account without being met with the time bar on challenging the last contribution rate notified and without having to wait for notification of future rates” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 7 April 2022, No. 20-18.310).
The rule has a limit. In 2025, the Cour de cassation specified that the two-month time limit “may be raised against the employer where that request, which cannot have the effect of altering a rate that has become final, is made in the course of proceedings challenging that rate” (our translation), and quashed the judgment that had ordered the recalculation of rates properly notified (Cass. 2e civ., 15 May 2025, No. 22-24.655). Removal from the employer account should therefore be requested without delay, and the rates for the years concerned challenged within their own time limits (Article R. 142-1-A, III).
The special account covers in particular diseases contracted while working for several successive employers. The Amiens Court of Appeal points out that “the employer must prove that the conditions laid down by this provision are met” (our translation), namely exposure to the risk in several companies and the impossibility of identifying the one that caused the disease; it ordered the entry on the basis of statements from former colleagues (CA Amiens, 24 January 2025, No. 24/01650). The challenge to the recognition of the disease itself falls to the local health insurance fund (CPAM) and the social division: see our page (in French) on CPAM disputes.
What are a lawyer's fees in a dispute with CARSAT?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: review of the notification and the career statement, complaint to the amicable appeals board, referral to the mediator, application to the social division of the judicial court, defence against a claim for repayment of an overpayment, employer appeal before the Amiens Court of Appeal, appeal. The amount depends on the number of decisions challenged and the stage of the proceedings; it is set after reading the documents, whether the notification, the career statement, letters from the fund or rate notices. Any new engagement is covered by an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected invoicing.
For a first opinion on your documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, via the form on this page, results in a first written analysis within 24 working hours. First discussion on +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles L. 215-1 and L. 215-3 of the French Social Security Code: functions of the regional retirement and occupational health insurance funds, Île-de-France exception
- Articles L. 351-1, R. 351-1 and R. 351-10 of the French Social Security Code: pension calculation, closing of the account, no revision for a later period
- Articles L. 351-2 and L. 351-14-1 of the French Social Security Code: validation of quarters, proof of contributions, buy-back
- Articles L. 351-1-1 and D. 351-1-1 of the French Social Security Code: early retirement for a long career
- Article L. 161-17 of the French Social Security Code: right to information, individual statement of entitlements
- Articles R. 351-34 and R. 351-37 of the French Social Security Code: pension application, competent fund, pension start date, implicit rejection
- Articles L. 353-1 and R. 353-1-1 of the French Social Security Code: survivor's pension, revision and its limit
- Articles L. 355-3, L. 161-1-5 and R. 133-3 of the French Social Security Code: limitation and remission of pension overpayments, enforcement order and objection
- Articles L. 242-5, L. 242-7 and D. 242-6-1 of the French Social Security Code: AT/MP contribution rate, classification, rebates and additional contributions
- Articles L. 142-4, R. 142-1, R. 142-1-A, R. 142-6 and R. 142-8 of the French Social Security Code: prior appeal, amicable appeals board, medical board, time limits
- Article L. 217-7-1 of the French Social Security Code: mediator of the social security bodies
- Articles R. 142-10-1, R. 142-11 and R. 142-13-1 of the French Social Security Code: application to the court, appeal, appeal before the court of appeal with jurisdiction over pricing
- Articles L. 211-16, L. 311-16 and D. 311-12 of the Code of Judicial Organisation: social division, Amiens Court of Appeal for pricing
- Articles 2224 and 2232 of the Civil Code: five-year limitation period, twenty-year long-stop period
- Article 538 of the Code of Civil Procedure: time limit for appeal
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. ass. plén., 17 May 2023, No. 20-20.559: overpayment, fraud, five years and twenty years
- Cass. 2e civ., 12 July 2018, No. 17-17.830: proof of deduction of contributions at source
- Cass. 2e civ., 20 September 2018, No. 17-21.576: quarters deemed contributed, long career
- Cass. 2e civ., 8 April 2021, No. 19-24.135: failure to inform and loss of a chance
- Cass. 2e civ., 25 January 2018, No. 16-27.854: finality of the notified pension
- Cass. 2e civ., 10 October 2019, No. 18-20.849: no revision for a later period
- Cass. 2e civ., 7 April 2022, No. 20-18.310: challenge to the employer account without time bar
- Cass. 2e civ., 15 May 2025, No. 22-24.655: time bar where the rate has become final
- Cass. 2e civ., 25 June 2026, No. 23-20.587: risk classification, two-month time limit
- CA Aix-en-Provence, 11 September 2026, No. 24/09990: long career and failure of the fund to respond
- CA Toulouse, 6 February 2025, No. 23/03113: quarters and payslips
- CA Paris, 20 December 2024, No. 22/07000: effective date and proof of the application
- CA Paris, 21 February 2025, No. 21/02782: mandatory prior appeal
- CA Amiens, 24 January 2025, No. 24/01650: entry in the special account
Further reading
A French state pension, an overpayment or an AT/MP rate to challenge?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the notification you received, your career statement, and any payslips or rate notices you have: Hassan Kohen reviews the time limits, the quarters and the calculations, then tells you the appropriate route, whether a complaint to the amicable appeals board, the mediator, the social division of the judicial court or the Amiens Court of Appeal.