In the media
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, CIPAV disputes in Paris
CIPAV Lawyer in Paris: Contributions, Enforcement and Pensions
Disputed affiliation, formal notice or enforcement order (contrainte), contributions collected by URSSAF since 2023, missing pension points, an incorrect career statement, a pension wrongly calculated: as a CIPAV lawyer in Paris, the firm assists self-employed professionals (professions libérales), micro-entrepreneurs and their heirs against the CIPAV, from the out-of-court claim to the social division (pôle social) of the judicial court. Everything starts from the decision notified and its time limit.
The firm can be reached 24/7. An objection (opposition) to an enforcement order must be lodged within fifteen days of its notification or service (Article R. 133-3 of the French Social Security Code, Code de la sécurité sociale); the amicable appeals board (commission de recours amiable) must be referred to within two months of notification of the disputed decision (Article R. 142-1).
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice tailored to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution found for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with a great deal of empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer of sound advice, caring and available, who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he has done.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, social security litigation for self-employed professionals: affiliation, contributions, enforcement orders and pension rights.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
The CIPAV is the professional section of the National Old-Age Insurance Fund for the Liberal Professions (Caisse nationale d'assurance vieillesse des professions libérales) which manages, for the professions listed by law, the basic pension, the supplementary pension and invalidity-death cover (Articles L. 640-1 and R. 641-1 of the French Social Security Code). Since 1 January 2023, its members' contributions have been collected by URSSAF, including for earlier periods (Article L. 213-1, 2° bis, and Article 12 of the Act of 23 December 2021); the transfer concerns collection only, the rights still being managed by the professional section. The formal notice (mise en demeure) must state the cause, nature, amount and period of the sums claimed (Article R. 244-1); contributions of self-employed workers become time-barred after three years from 30 June of the following year (Article L. 244-3); an enforcement order (contrainte) is challenged within fifteen days (Article R. 133-3). The fund's other decisions, including the individual statement of entitlements (relevé de situation individuelle) where its entries reflect a decision, are challenged before the amicable appeals board within two months of their notification, provided the notification mentions this time limit and the means of appeal, and then before the social division of the judicial court (Articles R. 142-1 and R. 142-1-A). Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th, acts for the member, the contributor and their heirs. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
An enforcement order received, missing points, a pension wrongly calculated?
Understanding your situation
CIPAV disputes explained
The amount of the basic pension of the liberal professions is the number of points multiplied by the service value of the point (Article L. 643-1 of the French Social Security Code). Who falls under the CIPAV, who collects the contributions, how to defend yourself against an enforcement order, how to have points restored and which appeals to bring.
Key points
Who falls under the CIPAV, and who collects its contributions
Four checks before disputing a single amount.
A profession on the statutory list: psychologist, psychotherapist, psychomotor therapist, occupational therapist, osteopath, chiropractor, dietitian, court-appointed expert, motor vehicle expert, person holding the approval provided for in Article L. 472-1 of the Social Action and Families Code (code de l'action sociale et des familles), architect, interior architect, construction economist, surveyor, consulting engineer, project manager (maître d'œuvre), artist not covered by Article L. 382-1, tour guide, ski instructor, high-mountain guide, mid-mountain leader (Articles L. 640-1 and R. 641-1, 11°).
A start date of activity: since the Act of 30 December 2017, the list has been exhaustive for self-employed workers starting their activity on or after 1 January 2019 (1 January 2018 for micro-entrepreneurs starting their activity). Liberal professionals outside the list who were affiliated before 1 January 2019 remained with the CIPAV, with a right to opt for the general scheme open until 31 December 2023, provided they were up to date with their contributions; “This change of affiliation is final” (our translation) (Article 15 of Act No. 2017-1836 of 30 December 2017).
The right creditor: since 1 January 2023, URSSAF has collected the basic pension, supplementary pension and invalidity-death contributions of the members of this section (Article L. 213-1, 2° bis, and Article L. 640-2), including those for “earlier periods” (our translation) (Article 12 of Act No. 2021-1754 of 23 December 2021).
The calculation scheme: the micro-entrepreneur pays contributions on turnover or receipts, at a global rate (Article L. 613-7); other liberal professionals contribute by bands of earned income, each band giving entitlement to a number of points set by decree (Article L. 642-1).
The CIPAV is not a mere branch of the national fund. The autonomous old-age insurance organisation of the liberal professions comprises a national fund and professional sections “with legal personality and financial autonomy” (our translation) (Article L. 641-1). The CIPAV therefore sues and defends in its own name on affiliation, points and pensions, while collection is now a matter for URSSAF.
The transfer has practical effects on pending cases. The Poitiers Court of Appeal held that URSSAF Île-de-France “took the place of the CIPAV from 1 January 2023 to collect all social contributions and debts owed by self-employed liberal professionals affiliated to the CIPAV” (our translation), whatever the period concerned, and upheld an enforcement order issued by the fund in 2019 (CA Poitiers, ch. soc., 7 May 2026, No. 23/00523). The Paris Court of Appeal accepted the same standing to enforce a judgment delivered in favour of the CIPAV, even for an activity outside the statutory list (CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 10, 26 March 2026, No. 24/16933).
Challenging your affiliation requires showing that the activity falls under another scheme. The Versailles Court of Appeal dismissed the claim of a software author who “does not show that he would fall within a category other than that of the liberal professions” (our translation) and had not exercised the right of option before 31 December 2023 (CA Versailles, ch. protection sociale 4-7, 12 February 2026, No. 23/00856). See also our article on the self-employed liberal micro-entrepreneur who moved from the CIPAV to the general scheme, and our analysis of the transfer of CIPAV collection to URSSAF.
Collection
Contribution demands, formal notice, enforcement order
Each step has its conditions, and each time limit its starting point.
Formal notice
Any enforcement action is preceded by a formal notice sent by registered letter or by any means giving a certain date of receipt, whose content must be precise and reasoned (Article L. 244-2). It states the cause, nature and amount of the sums claimed, the surcharges and penalties, and the period to which they relate (Article R. 244-1).
One-month period
If the formal notice has no effect after one month from its notification, the director of the body may issue an enforcement order (contrainte) (Article R. 133-3).
Enforcement order
Failing an objection before the specially designated judicial court, the enforcement order has all the effects of a judgment and, in particular, confers the benefit of a judicial mortgage (Article L. 244-9).
Objection
It is lodged by registration with the court registry or by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt, within fifteen days of notification or service; it must state its grounds and be accompanied by a copy of the enforcement order. The notice must state, on pain of nullity, the reference and amount of the enforcement order, the time limit for objection, the address of the court and the formalities for referring the matter to it (Article R. 133-3).
Limitation periods
Contributions of self-employed workers become time-barred after three years from 30 June of the year following the year for which they are due (Article L. 244-3); the collection action, after three years from the expiry of the period set by the formal notice (Article L. 244-8-1); enforcement of an enforcement order that has become final, after three years (Article L. 244-9).
Judgment
The decision of the court ruling on the objection replaces the enforcement order and is provisionally enforceable as of right (Article R. 133-3).
A formal notice is not annulled on form alone. For the Court of Cassation, the formal notice “must enable the person to know the nature, cause and extent of their obligation” (our translation), but it set aside a judgment that had annulled one, because “the disputed formal notice mentioned identifiable acronyms to designate the nature of the contributions due” (our translation) (a dispute with another fund, the IRCEC, Cass. 2e civ., 20 March 2025, No. 22-24.609). The useful debate therefore concerns what the document actually makes it possible to understand: period, scheme, amount, surcharges, sums already paid.
Calculating limitation periods requires the same rigour. The Court of Cassation holds that the limitation period for the collection action “only starts to run on expiry of the period granted by the formal notice to the person liable for the contributions to regularise their situation” (our translation); in that case, the member who relied on limitation lost before the Court of Cassation, which, on the CIPAV's appeal, set aside the judgment that had annulled the enforcement order and remitted the case (Cass. 2e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-15.239). The period then applicable was five years; it is now three years (Article L. 244-8-1).
A judgment delivered in favour of the CIPAV, here on 23 June 2023 on a 2022 enforcement order, may be enforced by URSSAF (CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 10, 26 March 2026, No. 24/16933). Receiving a document from URSSAF for CIPAV contributions is therefore not, in itself, a ground for nullity. See our pages on URSSAF enforcement orders, on URSSAF formal notices and on URSSAF litigation.
The pension
Points, career statement, pension award: what can be corrected
The amount of the pension depends on the points recorded in the account; a missing point can be claimed.
Basic pension: the amount of the pension is obtained from “the total number of points recorded in the account of the person concerned multiplied by the service value of the point” (our translation) (Article L. 643-1).
Individual statement of entitlements: each scheme sends it periodically and the insured person may request it, with online access to their updated statement (Article L. 161-17, III).
Buy-back: periods of higher education, where this scheme is the first scheme of affiliation after the studies, and years counting fewer than four quarters may be taken into account, up to a limit of twelve quarters, in return for contributions set on an actuarially neutral basis (Article L. 643-2).
Invalidity-death: the compulsory scheme managed by the section includes “benefits for widows and orphans” (our translation) (Article L. 644-2).
Contributions paid late: former Article R. 643-10, which excluded periods whose contributions had not been paid within five years of falling due, was set aside by the Court of Cassation and then repealed on 5 March 2023.
Notified pension: the award decision is challenged within the time limits for appeal stated in the notification (Articles R. 142-1 and R. 142-1-A).
The five-year rule fell on the ground of the right of property. For the Court of Cassation, the right to a pension in a contributory scheme “constitutes a substantial proprietary interest” (our translation); “the points acquired in return for the payment of contributions must be regarded as acquired as and when they are paid” (our translation), so that refusing contributions paid after five years, but before the pension is awarded, “excessively infringes the guaranteed fundamental right” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 2 June 2022, No. 21-16.072). It confirmed this in 2024, recalling that it had decided “to set aside the application of Article R. 643-10 of the Social Security Code” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 11 January 2024, No. 21-23.823).
On supplementary pension points for micro-entrepreneurs, the Court of Cassation ruled in an unpublished judgment dismissing an appeal, delivered for the years 2010 to 2014: the number of points “derives directly from the member's contribution class, determined according to their earned income” (our translation), it held in dismissing the CIPAV's appeal (Cass. 2e civ., 23 January 2020, No. 18-15.542). For the years 2013 to 2019, after the end of State compensation on 1 January 2016, the Paris Court of Appeal held that, “whatever the period relied on, the Cipav wrongly based the calculation of supplementary pension points” (our translation) on that compensation and on its articles of association (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 12 January 2024, No. 22/09946).
The individual statement of entitlements is a gateway to litigation: the insured person may challenge the periods, contributions or points shown on it (Cass. 2e civ., 11 October 2018, No. 17-25.956). The limit lies in its content: a statement that merely reports an absence of data does not amount to a decision of the fund, and the appeal is then inadmissible (Cass. 2e civ., 1 December 2022, No. 21-12.784; CA Lyon, ch. soc. D, 28 January 2025, No. 22/08674). See also our articles on the CIPAV death benefit, on the micro-entrepreneur's invalidity pension and on invalidity pensions for the liberal professions.
Both sides
You challenge the fund, or the fund relies on its rules against you
The same texts read differently depending on where you stand.
You are the member or an heir
- Gather contribution demands, tax assessments, proof of payment, statements of entitlements and the fund's notifications.
- Check the affiliation, the contribution class, the points for each year and the regularity of the formal notice.
- Lodge the claim within the time limits, then refer the matter to the social division; quantify the pension arrears due.
What the fund or URSSAF argues against you
- Compulsory affiliation by operation of law, and no right of option exercised before 31 December 2023.
- Contributions payable by the debtor (portables), whose payment must be proved by the member.
- Time-barred appeal, final decision, no challengeable decision on an incomplete statement.
The fund's arguments are not mere formalities. The Paris Court of Appeal refused to validate years of self-employed activity in the 1980s and 1990s for a consultant who proved neither his affiliation nor his payments, recalling that “social security contributions, including pension scheme contributions, are payable by the debtor and not collectable by the creditor” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 3 May 2024, No. 21/02456). The firm therefore starts with the evidence: what was paid, to whom, and for which year.
The grounds the firm examines in every case:
Appeals
From the amicable appeals board to the appeal against the judgment
A mandatory order, short time limits, and documents to attach from the outset.
Prior appeal
Court proceedings are preceded by a prior appeal (Article L. 142-4): the body's amicable appeals board must be referred to within two months of notification of the disputed decision (Article R. 142-1).
Silence
If the board's decision is not brought to the applicant's attention within two months of receipt of the claim, the applicant may treat it as rejected (Article R. 142-6).
Social division
The time limit for court proceedings is two months from notification of the disputed decision, unless otherwise provided; these time limits can only be relied on if they were stated, together with the means of appeal, in the notification (Article R. 142-1-A, III).
Application
The court is seised by an application lodged with the registry or sent by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt, with a brief statement of the grounds, the documents listed in a schedule and a copy of the disputed decision or of the prior appeal (Article R. 142-10-1).
Enforcement order
A notable exception: an enforcement order is challenged directly before the court, by an objection lodged within fifteen days (Article R. 133-3).
Appeal or appeal on points of law
The time limit for appeal is one month in contentious matters (Article 538 of the French Code of Civil Procedure). Where a personal or movable-property action concerns a claim of 5,000 euros or less, the judicial court rules at last instance (Article R. 211-3-24 of the Code of Judicial Organisation): only an appeal on points of law to the Court of Cassation (pourvoi en cassation) is then available (Article 605 of the French Code of Civil Procedure), as in the case of the judgments of the Quimper judicial court challenged directly before the Court of Cassation (Cass. 2e civ., 20 March 2025, No. 22-24.609).
Compensation for a fault of the fund follows ordinary law: “Any act whatever by a person which causes damage to another obliges the person by whose fault it occurred to make reparation” (our translation) (Article 1240 of the French Civil Code). The right to information about one's pension is laid down by law (Article L. 161-17), but fault and loss must be proved: the Lyon Court of Appeal dismissed a claim for damages against the CIPAV, for lack of proof that the absence of data on the statement resulted from a failure by the fund (CA Lyon, ch. soc. D, 28 January 2025, No. 22/08674).
The firm drafts the claim, refers the matter to the social division of the competent judicial court, pleads the case and follows up the enforcement of the judgment, including the recalculation of the pension and the payment of arrears. See our pages on the amicable appeals board and on the social division of the judicial court, and, for employees and the general scheme, our page on the CARSAT.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What does a lawyer do in a CIPAV dispute?
They first identify the document at issue and the time limit that is running. An enforcement order (contrainte) is challenged by an objection within fifteen days of its notification or service (Article R. 133-3 of the French Social Security Code); the fund's other decisions, such as a refusal of points, a notified pension or a statement of entitlements whose entries reflect a decision of the fund, are challenged before the amicable appeals board within two months of their notification (Article R. 142-1), a time limit that can only be relied on if it is stated, together with the means of appeal, in the notification (Article R. 142-1-A, III), and then before the social division of the judicial court.
They then check the merits: does the profession appear on the list in Article L. 640-1, is the body taking action the right one since collection was transferred to URSSAF (Article L. 213-1, 2° bis), does the formal notice state the cause, nature, amount and period of the sums claimed (Article R. 244-1), are the contributions time-barred (Article L. 244-3), do the points for each year match the contributions paid.
Finally, they rely on the case law obtained against the fund, in particular on micro-entrepreneurs' points (Cass. 2e civ., 23 January 2020, No. 18-15.542) and on contributions paid more than five years after falling due (Cass. 2e civ., 2 June 2022, No. 21-16.072). The firm drafts the claim, refers the matter to the court, pleads the case and follows up the enforcement of the judgment, including the recalculation of the pension and arrears.
Does my activity still fall under the CIPAV?
Yes, if it appears on the statutory list. Article L. 640-1 of the French Social Security Code lists the professions affiliated to the old-age and invalidity-death insurance schemes of the liberal professions; the section in 11° of Article R. 641-1 covers, in particular, psychologists, psychotherapists, psychomotor therapists, occupational therapists, osteopaths, chiropractors, dietitians, court-appointed experts, motor vehicle experts, architects, interior architects, construction economists, chartered surveyors (géomètres-experts), consulting engineers, project managers (maîtres d'œuvre), tour guides, ski instructors, high-mountain guides and mid-mountain leaders.
For other liberal professionals, everything depends on the date of affiliation. Those who are not on this list and were affiliated before 1 January 2019 remained with the CIPAV; until 31 December 2023, and provided they were up to date with their contributions, they could ask to be transferred to the general scheme for the self-employed, and “This change of affiliation is final” (our translation) (Article 15 of Act No. 2017-1836 of 30 December 2017).
Challenging affiliation requires proof. The Versailles Court of Appeal dismissed the claim of a software author who “does not show that he would fall within a category other than that of the liberal professions” (our translation) and had not exercised the option before the deadline (CA Versailles, ch. protection sociale 4-7, 12 February 2026, No. 23/00856). The firm checks the profession actually practised, the registration dates and the steps taken, before arguing for deregistration or a new affiliation. See our article on the self-employed liberal micro-entrepreneur who moved to the general scheme.
Since 2023, who claims my contributions: the CIPAV or URSSAF?
URSSAF. Since 1 January 2023, it has collected the basic pension, supplementary pension and invalidity-death contributions owed by liberal professionals affiliated to the CIPAV professional section (Article L. 213-1, 2° bis, and Article L. 640-2 of the French Social Security Code). The transfer also applies to the past: URSSAF collects the contributions and settles the debts relating to “earlier periods” (our translation) (Article 12 of Act No. 2021-1754 of 23 December 2021). The transfer concerns collection only: pension rights remain those of the professional section.
The courts draw all the consequences. The Poitiers Court of Appeal held that URSSAF Île-de-France “took the place of the CIPAV from 1 January 2023” (our translation) for all contributions and debts of affiliated liberal professionals, whatever the period, and upheld a 2019 enforcement order (CA Poitiers, ch. soc., 7 May 2026, No. 23/00523). The Paris Court of Appeal recognised URSSAF's standing to enforce a judgment delivered in favour of the CIPAV, the legislature having intended to transfer to it “the collection of the contributions collected until then by the CIPAV itself” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 10, 26 March 2026, No. 24/16933).
Two courts of appeal have rejected the argument that URSSAF lacked standing, including, in Paris, for an activity outside the statutory list. The useful defence concerns affiliation, the amount, the formal notice and limitation. See our analysis of the transfer of collection.
I have received a formal notice (mise en demeure): what should I check?
How it was sent and what it contains. The formal notice must precede any enforcement action; it is sent by registered letter or by any means giving a certain date of receipt, and its content must be precise and reasoned (Article L. 244-2 of the French Social Security Code). It “states the cause, nature and amount of the sums claimed, the surcharges and penalties that apply to them and the period to which they relate” (our translation) (Article R. 244-1).
The Court of Cassation requires that it enable the debtor “to know the nature, cause and extent of their obligation” (our translation). It nevertheless takes a realistic approach: it set aside a judgment that had annulled a formal notice because it designated the contributions by abbreviations, these entries being “identifiable acronyms to designate the nature of the contributions due” (our translation) (a dispute with another fund, the IRCEC, Cass. 2e civ., 20 March 2025, No. 22-24.609). Annulment is therefore argued on a real gap: missing period, incomprehensible amount, sums already paid not deducted, scheme not identifiable.
The formal notice also starts time limits running. If it has no effect for one month, the body may issue an enforcement order (Article R. 133-3); and the collection action becomes time-barred three years after the expiry of the period it sets (Article L. 244-8-1). The firm checks every entry, compares the amounts with the income declared and the payments made, then prepares the claim or the forthcoming defence. See our page on URSSAF formal notices.
An enforcement order (contrainte) has been served on me: what should I do, and by when?
Lodge an objection within fifteen days. The debtor lodges an objection by registration with the registry of the competent court for their place of residence, or by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt sent to that registry, within fifteen days of notification or service; the objection must state its grounds and a copy of the enforcement order must be attached (Article R. 133-3 of the French Social Security Code). After that time limit, the enforcement order has all the effects of a judgment and, in particular, confers the benefit of a judicial mortgage (Article L. 244-9).
The document itself can be checked. On pain of nullity, the service or notification states the reference and amount of the enforcement order, the time limit for objection, the address of the competent court and the formalities for referring the matter to it (Article R. 133-3). The enforcement order must also have been preceded by a formal notice that remained without effect for one month.
On the merits, the objection disputes affiliation, the calculation of contributions, limitation and payments already made. The burden of proof weighs heavily on the objector: the Poitiers Court of Appeal upheld an enforcement order, for a reduced amount, relying on the income the member did not dispute and on the absence of any proven payment (CA Poitiers, ch. soc., 7 May 2026, No. 23/00523). The judgment on the objection replaces the enforcement order and is provisionally enforceable as of right (Article R. 133-3). The firm drafts the objection within the time limit, then develops it at the hearing. See our page on URSSAF enforcement orders.
Are my CIPAV contributions time-barred?
Three time limits combine. First, the contributions and levies of self-employed workers become time-barred after three years, from 30 June of the year following the year for which they are due (Article L. 244-3 of the French Social Security Code). Second, the civil collection action becomes time-barred after three years “from the expiry of the period set by the warnings or formal notices” (our translation) (Article L. 244-8-1). Finally, enforcement of an enforcement order that was not challenged and has become final becomes time-barred three years after its notification or service, or after an enforcement measure served under that order (Article L. 244-9).
The starting point must be calculated precisely. The Court of Cassation holds that the limitation period for the collection action “only starts to run on expiry of the period granted by the formal notice” (our translation) to the person liable to regularise their situation. In that case, the member lost before the Court of Cassation, which set aside the judgment and remitted the case: the enforcement order, served more than five years after the formal notice, had been served within the period counted from the expiry of the month granted (Cass. 2e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-15.239). The period, then five years, is now three years.
The firm reconstructs the chronology, contribution year, date of the formal notice, date of service of the enforcement order, enforcement measures, before raising limitation. A correctly calculated limitation period can wipe out part of the sums claimed.
My CIPAV career statement is wrong: can I challenge it?
Yes, where it reflects a decision of the fund. “Everyone has the right to obtain, under conditions specified by decree, a statement of their individual situation” (our translation), and pension schemes must send it periodically (Article L. 161-17, III, of the French Social Security Code). For the Court of Cassation, the insured person may, if they consider it incorrect, challenge “the recording of the periods of affiliation, amount of contributions or number of points shown on the individual statement of entitlements sent to them” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 11 October 2018, No. 17-25.956).
The Paris Court of Appeal applied this rule to the CIPAV: since the entries on the statement result from decisions of the body, the insured person “may challenge the entries on this statement before the amicable appeals board of the body concerned and then before the social security court” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 12 January 2024, No. 22/09946).
The limit is real. For a statement that merely indicated that career data at the CIPAV were not available, the Court of Cassation upheld the lower courts: “the judgment correctly inferred that the insured person's appeal was inadmissible” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 1 December 2022, No. 21-12.784). The Lyon Court of Appeal applied the same rule: such a statement “cannot amount to one or more decisions taken by the competent social security bodies” (our translation) (CA Lyon, ch. soc. D, 28 January 2025, No. 22/08674). In that case, you must first obtain a decision from the fund on the years concerned, then challenge it before the amicable appeals board. The firm drafts the request and the claim year by year.
Micro-entrepreneur: the CIPAV gave me too few points, what can I do?
Have the supplementary pension points recalculated according to the contribution class. The micro-entrepreneur pays a global rate on turnover or receipts (Article L. 613-7 of the French Social Security Code). The CIPAV has at times calculated their points on the basis of the financial compensation paid by the State or of its articles of association, rather than on the basis of the contribution class.
The Court of Cassation rejected this practice. It holds that the number of supplementary pension points awarded to affiliated self-employed entrepreneurs (auto-entrepreneurs) “derives directly from the member's contribution class, determined according to their earned income” (our translation), and it dismissed the fund's appeal against the judgment that had corrected an insured person's points, in an unpublished judgment delivered for the years 2010 to 2014 (Cass. 2e civ., 23 January 2020, No. 18-15.542). For the years 2013 to 2019, the Paris Court of Appeal upheld a judgment in favour of a micro-entrepreneur, holding that “the Cipav wrongly based the calculation of supplementary pension points” (our translation) on State compensation and on its articles of association, and that the fund could not substitute profit for turnover to determine the class (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 12 January 2024, No. 22/09946).
The process starts from the individual statement of entitlements, where its entries reflect a decision of the fund, or from the pension notification: they are challenged before the amicable appeals board within two months of their notification (Article R. 142-1), a time limit that can be relied on if it was stated together with the means of appeal (Article R. 142-1-A, III). The firm reconstructs, year by year, the turnover declared, the applicable class and the points due, then quantifies the arrears. See our article on the points of the self-employed liberal micro-entrepreneur.
I paid contributions late: can the CIPAV refuse the points?
Not for the basic pension, if they were paid before the pension was awarded. Former Article R. 643-10 of the French Social Security Code excluded from the calculation of the basic pension the periods whose arrears of contributions had not been paid within five years of falling due. The Court of Cassation set it aside in the light of the right to the peaceful enjoyment of possessions: the right to a pension in a contributory scheme “constitutes a substantial proprietary interest” (our translation), and “the points acquired in return for the payment of contributions must be regarded as acquired as and when they are paid” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 2 June 2022, No. 21-16.072).
Refusing to take into account contributions paid after five years but before the pension was awarded “excessively infringes the guaranteed fundamental right” (our translation), the Court held in 2022, before confirming in 2024 that it had decided “to set aside the application of Article R. 643-10 of the Social Security Code” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 11 January 2024, No. 21-23.823). The provision had in the meantime been repealed, on 5 March 2023 (last version of Article R. 643-10).
The basic pension remains the points recorded in the account multiplied by the service value of the point (Article L. 643-1): each point restored increases the pension. The firm gathers the proof of payment, identifies the years concerned and requests the regularisation of the points, then the revision of the pension and the payment of arrears.
The CIPAV cannot find my years of activity: what can I do?
Gather proof of affiliation and payments, because it is for the insured person to provide it. Anyone carrying on an activity falling under the autonomous old-age insurance organisation of the liberal professions must pay contributions (Article L. 642-1 of the French Social Security Code), and basic pension rights are counted in points acquired through these contributions (Article L. 643-1).
The case law is demanding. The Paris Court of Appeal dismissed the claim of a former consultant who sought validation of years of self-employed activity carried on between 1986 and 1996: his tax assessments, business tax notices and URSSAF documents proved the activity, not affiliation to the fund or payment of pension contributions, and the court recalled that “social security contributions, including pension scheme contributions, are payable by the debtor and not collectable by the creditor” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 3 May 2024, No. 21/02456).
The useful documents are therefore the fund's contribution demands, proof of payment, certificates of affiliation, old statements of entitlements and the correspondence exchanged. Where years are missing from the statement, you must ask the fund for a decision, then challenge it within two months before the amicable appeals board (Article R. 142-1). The firm rebuilds the file and assesses, before any appeal, what can be proved.
My CIPAV pension has already been awarded: can it still be revised?
It depends on the notification and the time limits. The decision awarding the pension is challenged before the amicable appeals board within two months of its notification (Article R. 142-1 of the French Social Security Code); these time limits can only be relied on if they were stated, together with the means of appeal, in the notification (Article R. 142-1-A, III). An incomplete notification therefore leaves the door open.
Conversely, a pension that was properly notified and not challenged becomes final. For the Court of Cassation, ruling on the general scheme, “the retirement pension becomes final when its award has been the subject of a decision of the body duly notified to the insured person and not challenged by them in good time” (our translation); it set aside the judgment that had not examined whether the time limit for appeal had expired (Cass. 2e civ., 25 January 2018, No. 16-27.854). In that case, finality worked in the insured person's favour, as the fund could not go back on a notification that had become final; whether this solution carries over to the liberal professions scheme has not been decided. Checking the date and content of the notification is therefore the first task.
Where the notification is regular and the time limit has expired, other routes remain to be checked: points not recorded for a given period, contributions paid before the pension was awarded and not taken into account, a buy-back accepted but not included. The firm examines the notification, the time limits still open and the points that can be disputed, then quantifies the revised pension and the arrears.
Can I buy back quarters from the CIPAV?
Yes, in the basic scheme of the liberal professions and within the statutory limits. Subject to payment of contributions set by decree on an actuarially neutral basis, and up to a total limit of twelve quarters, the following are taken into account: periods of higher education where this scheme is the first scheme of affiliation after the studies, and years of affiliation for which fewer than four quarters were credited (Article L. 643-2 of the French Social Security Code). For periods of initial education, the amount of the payment may be reduced by decree, in particular where the application is made within ten years of the end of the studies.
A buy-back is decided on a calculation: cost of the payment, number of quarters useful for the pension rate, expected pension gain, planned retirement age. The individual statement of entitlements, to which every insured person is entitled (Article L. 161-17), and the overall indicative estimate sent from a certain age make it possible to measure the gaps.
A refusal of a buy-back, a disputed payment amount or bought-back quarters not recorded are decisions of the fund: they are challenged before the amicable appeals board within two months of their notification (Article R. 142-1), then before the social division. The firm checks the application, the proposed calculation and the actual recording of the quarters.
The CIPAV made a mistake: can I claim damages?
Yes in principle, but the fault, the loss and the causal link must be proved. The fund's liability is governed by ordinary law: “Any act whatever by a person which causes damage to another obliges the person by whose fault it occurred to make reparation” (our translation) (Article 1240 of the French Civil Code). The right to information about one's pension is provided for by law, which in particular requires schemes to send an individual statement of entitlements periodically (Article L. 161-17 of the French Social Security Code); general information for insured persons is also a matter for the minister, with the assistance of the bodies (Article R. 112-2).
The courts review the evidence strictly. The Lyon Court of Appeal dismissed a member's claim for 3,000 euros against the CIPAV for missing data on her statement: the statement was issued by a third-party body, no failure by the fund to transmit data was established, and the non-pecuniary loss relied on was not made out (CA Lyon, ch. soc. D, 28 January 2025, No. 22/08674).
A claim for compensation is therefore prepared on the documents: requests left unanswered, incorrect information given in writing, quantified loss of points or arrears. It usefully accompanies the main claim for correction of rights, which remains the heart of the case. The firm assesses whether the loss can be demonstrated before claiming it.
What are a lawyer's fees in a CIPAV dispute?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Act of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The agreement specifies the amount or the method of determining the fees covering the foreseeable work, as well as the expected costs and disbursements; fees take into account, in particular, the difficulty of the case and the work carried out, and the law prohibits setting them solely according to the judicial outcome. The agreement may, however, provide, in addition to remuneration for the services performed, a supplementary fee based on the result obtained or the service rendered.
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: analysis of affiliation and contributions, claim before the amicable appeals board, objection to an enforcement order, proceedings before the social division, appeal, application for revision of the pension and follow-up of arrears. Any new engagement gives rise to an amendment, with no unexpected billing.
For a first opinion on the documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles L. 640-1 of the French Social Security Code, L. 641-1 and R. 641-1: affiliated professions, professional sections, the CIPAV section
- Articles L. 213-1 and L. 640-2: collection of contributions by URSSAF since 1 January 2023
- Articles L. 613-7 and L. 642-1: micro-entrepreneur contributions, contributions by bands and points
- Articles L. 643-1, L. 643-2 and L. 644-2: points-based basic pension, buy-back of quarters, invalidity-death scheme
- Article R. 643-10: former five-year rule, repealed on 5 March 2023 (last version, for information)
- Articles L. 161-17 and R. 112-2: right to pension information, individual statement of entitlements
- Articles L. 244-2 and R. 244-1: formal notice and its content
- Articles L. 244-3, L. 244-8-1 and L. 244-9: limitation of contributions, of the collection action and of the enforcement of an enforcement order
- Article R. 133-3: enforcement order and objection within fifteen days
- Articles L. 142-4, R. 142-1, R. 142-6, R. 142-1-A and R. 142-10-1: prior appeal, amicable appeals board, time limits, referral to the court
- Article 12 of Act No. 2021-1754 of 23 December 2021: entry into force of the transfer and earlier periods
- Article 15 of Act No. 2017-1836 of 30 December 2017: exhaustive list and right of option until 31 December 2023
- Article 538 of the French Code of Civil Procedure: time limit for appeal
- Article R. 211-3-24 of the Code of Judicial Organisation: judgment at last instance up to 5,000 euros
- Article 605 of the French Code of Civil Procedure: appeal on points of law against judgments at last instance
- Article 1240 of the French Civil Code: fault-based liability
- Article 10 of Act No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. 2e civ., 2 June 2022, No. 21-16.072: contributions paid more than five years after falling due
- Cass. 2e civ., 11 January 2024, No. 21-23.823: confirmation, Article R. 643-10 set aside
- Cass. 2e civ., 23 January 2020, No. 18-15.542: supplementary pension points of self-employed entrepreneurs (auto-entrepreneurs)
- Cass. 2e civ., 11 October 2018, No. 17-25.956: challenging the individual statement of entitlements
- Cass. 2e civ., 12 November 2020, No. 19-15.239: starting point of the limitation period for the collection action
- Cass. 2e civ., 20 March 2025, No. 22-24.609: content of the formal notice, identifiable acronyms
- Cass. 2e civ., 25 January 2018, No. 16-27.854: finality of the notified pension (general scheme)
- CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 12 January 2024, No. 22/09946: statement open to challenge and points calculation rejected
- CA Paris, pôle 1, ch. 10, 26 March 2026, No. 24/16933: enforcement by URSSAF of a judgment obtained by the CIPAV
- CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 13, 3 May 2024, No. 21/02456: affiliation and payments not proved
- Cass. 2e civ., 1 December 2022, No. 21-12.784: CIPAV statement without data, inadmissibility of the appeal upheld
- CA Lyon, ch. soc. D, 28 January 2025, No. 22/08674: statement without data, appeal inadmissible, compensation refused
- CA Versailles, ch. protection sociale 4-7, 12 February 2026, No. 23/00856: challenge to affiliation and right of option not exercised
- CA Poitiers, ch. soc., 7 May 2026, No. 23/00523: URSSAF substituted for the CIPAV, enforcement order upheld
Further reading
An enforcement order, missing points, a disputed pension?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the decision or document received, its date of notification, your contribution demands, your proof of payment and your individual statement of entitlements: Hassan Kohen reviews the affiliation, the amounts and the time limits, then tells you the appropriate route: a claim before the amicable appeals board, an objection to an enforcement order, proceedings before the social division or an appeal.