Featured in the media
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, pre-emption right lawyers in Paris
Pre-emption right lawyer in Paris, France: DIA, price, appeals, SAFER
Declaration of intention to sell (déclaration d'intention d'aliéner, DIA), the municipality's two-month time limit, pre-emption at the asking price or at a lower price, price-setting by the court, challenges before the administrative court, retrocession, notice to quit in order to sell (congé pour vendre), sale after division of a building and SAFER pre-emption of farmland in France: the firm assists sellers, ousted buyers (acquéreurs évincés) and tenants. Everything turns on short time limits, counted from the DIA or from the decision.
The firm can be reached 24/7. If the municipality remains silent for two months from receipt of the DIA, it is deemed to have waived its right, unless the time limit has been suspended (Article L. 213-2 of the French Planning Code, Code de l'urbanisme); a pre-emption decision can be challenged within two months of its notification or publication (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice, Code de justice administrative).
4,9/5
Average Google rating270 reviews
I received high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his thorough command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him to you without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the outcome obtained for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with a great deal of empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, kind and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Urgent matters 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Get a French property lawyer's analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer at the Paris Bar: urban pre-emption rights, challenges to pre-emption decisions, price-setting by the court and tenants' pre-emption rights.
Official profile in the national directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 31 October 2026.
Quick answer
In areas where the municipality has introduced the urban pre-emption right (droit de préemption urbain), any sale of a property subject to it requires, on pain of nullity, a declaration of intention to sell sent to the town hall (mairie), stating the price and terms of the sale (Article L. 213-2 of the French Planning Code, Code de l'urbanisme). The holder of the right has two months to waive it, buy at the proposed price or offer another price, and its silence counts as a waiver; failing agreement, the price is set by the court with jurisdiction over expropriation (Articles L. 213-4 and R. 213-8). A pre-emption is lawful only if the public authority shows, at the date of its decision, that a planned development action or operation genuinely exists and if the decision states its purpose (Article L. 210-1, as interpreted by the Council of State, Conseil d'État); it can be challenged before the administrative court, if necessary through an urgent application for suspension (référé-suspension). Tenants have their own rights when they receive a notice to sell or when their home is sold after the division of the building. Kohen Avocats, in the 16th arrondissement of Paris, acts for sellers, ousted buyers and tenants. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A DIA to file, a pre-emption decision received, a notice to sell?
Understanding your situation
Pre-emption rights in Paris, including SAFER pre-emption, explained
Every pre-emption decision must state the purpose for which the right is exercised (Article L. 210-1 of the French Planning Code). How the DIA and the two-month time limit work, how the price is set, how to challenge the decision, what the seller and the ousted buyer can obtain, and which pre-emption rights belong to the tenant.
Key points
The declaration of intention to sell: the document that starts the municipality's time limit
Four points to check before signing, then during the two months after filing.
A property subject to the right: municipalities with an approved local urban development plan (plan local d'urbanisme) may, by council resolution, introduce an urban pre-emption right over all or part of their urban areas and future development areas (Article L. 211-1 of the French Planning Code). It covers real property transferred for consideration, transfers of undivided rights and certain transfers of shares in property-holding non-trading companies (sociétés civiles immobilières) (Article L. 213-1).
A prior declaration: any transfer subject to the right requires, “on pain of nullity”, a declaration by the owner to the town hall stating the price and terms of the sale (Article L. 213-2). It is sent by registered post with acknowledgement of receipt, handed in against a receipt or filed electronically (Article R. 213-5).
A two-month time limit: if the holder of the right remains silent for two months from receipt of the declaration, it is deemed to have waived the pre-emption right (Article L. 213-2); this period runs from the postal acknowledgement of receipt, the acknowledgement of registration or the receipt given on filing (Article R. 213-7).
A single request for documents: within this period, the holder may send the owner one single request for documents, taken from an exhaustive list set by decree, and ask to visit the property. The time limit is then suspended and later resumes; if less than one month remains, the holder has one month to decide (Article L. 213-2).
Calculating the time limit is often decisive. In a case decided by the Council of State, the municipality had requested documents and a visit on the last possible day; once the documents had been sent and the visit tacitly refused, “the time available to the holder of the pre-emption right after receipt of the declaration of intention to sell started running again on 5 May 2023, for a period of one month, that is until 5 June 2023” (our translation) (CE, 17 October 2024, No. 489707). The argument that the decision of 23 June 2023 was out of time was held capable of raising serious doubt and, urgency being established, its enforcement was suspended at the request of the sellers and the ousted buyer.
Some properties fall outside the ordinary urban pre-emption right (droit de préemption urbain simple), such as a unit consisting of a single residential, professional or mixed-use premises, with its ancillary premises, in a building that has been under the co-ownership regime (copropriété) for at least ten years from the publication of the co-ownership rules, or a building during the four years following its completion, unless the municipality adopts a reasoned resolution extending the right to such property (Article L. 211-4). The holder's decision is published and notified to the seller, to the notary and, where applicable, to the buyer named in the declaration (Article L. 213-2).
The holder may delegate its right, in particular to a public body whose remit covers it (Article L. 213-3): the decision must come from a competent authority. See also our articles on the town hall's silence after the DIA and on clearing the pre-emption right before the sale.
The price
Pre-emption at the asking price, a lower offer, a price set by the court: the seller's timetable
Each response opens a time limit, and each silence has a consequence laid down by law.
The response
For a private sale with no payment in kind, the holder notifies either its waiver, or its decision to buy at the price and on the terms proposed, or an offer at a price of its own, together with its intention to have the price set by the court if the offer is not accepted (Article R. 213-8 of the French Planning Code).
Two months
Faced with a lower offer, the owner either accepts it, maintains the asking price and agrees to have the price set by the court, or withdraws from the sale; silence for two months counts as a withdrawal from the sale (Article R. 213-10).
Fifteen days
If the owner maintains the asking price, a holder that considers the price excessive refers the matter to the expropriation court within fifteen days of receiving the owner's reply, failing which it is deemed to have waived its right (Article R. 213-11).
Deposit
The holder deposits 15% of the valuation made by the departmental director of public finances; if the deposit receipt is not notified within three months of the referral to the court, it is deemed to have waived its right (Article L. 213-4-1).
After the judgment
For two months after the decision has become final, each party may accept the price set or withdraw; silence counts as acceptance and as transfer of ownership to the holder (Article L. 213-7).
Four months
The price is paid or, if there is an obstacle to payment, deposited within four months of the decision to buy or of the court's final decision; failing that, the seller may sell the property freely (Article L. 213-14).
Pre-emption at the DIA price binds the seller. The Paris Court of Appeal held in a recent judgment that “once the holder of the pre-emption right has notified its decision to buy at the price and on the terms proposed by the seller, agreement on the property and on the price is reached and the sale is complete, with all the consequences that follow” (our translation), the signing of the notarial deed (acte authentique) “affecting only the transfer of ownership and not the formation of the sale” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 9 October 2026, No. 25/04544). The seller, who had failed to attend the signing at the notary's office, was ordered to execute the deed. The estate agent's fee also follows the sale: the holder “is required to pay the intermediary's fee that was payable by the intended buyer” (our translation), provided its amount and the party liable for it are stated in the parties' agreement and in the declaration (Cass. 3e civ., 12 May 2021, No. 19-25.226).
Failing agreement, the price is set by the court with jurisdiction over expropriation, without any ancillary compensation, in particular no reinvestment allowance (indemnité de réemploi), and by reference to a reference date specific to pre-emption (Article L. 213-4), the property being valued at the date of the first-instance decision according to its actual use at that reference date (Article L. 322-2 of the French Expropriation Code, Code de l'expropriation pour cause d'utilité publique). According to the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation), where the property is subject to the pre-emption right, that date “is the date on which the most recent of the acts making public, approving, revising or amending the land use plan (plan d'occupation des sols) or the local urban development plan and delimiting the zone in which the property is located became enforceable against third parties” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 1 March 2023, No. 22-11.467). In that expropriation case, the owner's appeal was dismissed.
Before the Law of 24 March 2014, the holder had six months to pay or deposit the price, and the former owner could only ask for the property to be handed back (rétrocession) (former Article L. 213-14). Under that regime, the Court of Cassation dismissed a seller's appeal: the court of appeal had found, in the exercise of its own assessment of the facts, a proven risk that the price would not be repaid if the pre-emption were annulled, amounting to an obstacle to payment that justified the deposit, and had held that a time limit expiring on a Sunday was extended to the next working day (Cass. 3e civ., 23 September 2020, No. 19-14.261). See our article on pre-emption at a lower price and the expropriation judge, and our expropriation lawyer page.
Challenging the decision
Challenging a pre-emption decision before the administrative court
What the court checks, the time limit for bringing proceedings, and when to seek a suspension.
A development purpose: pre-emption rights are exercised with a view to carrying out, in the general interest, actions or operations meeting the purposes listed in Article L. 300-1, or to build up land reserves, and “Every pre-emption decision must state the purpose for which this right is exercised.” (Article L. 210-1 of the French Planning Code).
Purposes defined by law: implementing an urban project or a local housing policy, accommodating economic activities, building public facilities, tackling unfit housing, enabling urban renewal or safeguarding heritage, among others (Article L. 300-1).
A decision taken in time, by a competent authority or a duly appointed delegate, after a complete DIA (Articles L. 213-2 and L. 213-3).
An application within two months of the notification or publication of the contested decision (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
An urgent application for suspension (référé-suspension), where urgency justifies it and an argument raises serious doubt as to the lawfulness of the decision (Article L. 521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
The court reviews whether the project is genuine and whether there is a general interest. The Council of State requires the public authority to show, “at the date on which they exercise it, that a planned development action or operation meeting the purposes set out in Article L. 300-1 of the Planning Code genuinely exists, even if the precise features of that project had not been defined at that date” (our translation), “it being irrelevant that the date on which the planned action or operation will actually be carried out cannot yet be determined” (our translation) (CE, 25 March 2026, No. 504317). That decision of 25 March 2026 set aside the judgment that had found in favour of the ousted buyers of a property in Vincennes.
The general interest is assessed in the same way: exercising the right must, “having regard in particular to the characteristics of the property concerned by the operation or to its foreseeable cost, meet a sufficient general interest” (our translation), but the lawfulness of the decision “is not, however, subject to the requirement that the public authority be unable to carry out the operation on equivalent terms without exercising this right” (our translation) (CE, 13 March 2019, No. 419259). Here again, the judgment in favour of the ousted buyers was set aside. A challenge therefore requires a close examination of the public authority's file, not a general criticism of the expediency of the pre-emption.
In urgent proceedings, the ousted buyer benefits from a presumption of urgency, which the public authority can rebut by showing particular circumstances (CE, 30 January 2019, No. 421740). See our article on challenging a pre-emption by the City of Paris and our public law lawyer page.
Both sides
You are selling, or you were due to buy: what each party can obtain
Waiver, annulment, retrocession, damages: the consequences of pre-emption.
You are the seller
- File a complete and accurate DIA, then monitor the two-month time limit and any suspensions.
- Respond to a lower offer within two months: accept, maintain the price before the court or withdraw from the sale.
- Demand payment within four months, then sell freely if it is not made.
You are the ousted buyer
- Challenge the decision within two months and seek its suspension in urgent proceedings.
- After annulment, if the transfer has taken place, assert the priority right to buy granted to the buyer named in the DIA, after the former owners.
- Claim damages if the public authority fails to meet its obligations.
Annulment has different effects depending on whether or not the sale has gone through. If ownership has not been transferred, the holder may not pre-empt the same property again for one year, and the owner is no longer bound by the price and terms in its declaration (Article L. 213-8 of the French Planning Code). If ownership has been transferred, the holder must first offer to sell the property to the former owners, then to the buyer named in the DIA, at a price intended to restore the terms of the transaction that was prevented (Article L. 213-11-1). The administrative court may order it to do so, provided the holder has not in the meantime sold the property to a third party, and only “after verifying, in the light of all the interests at stake, that restoring the initial situation does not cause excessive harm to the general interest” (our translation) (CE, 28 September 2020, No. 436978). For a building in the eighteenth arrondissement of Paris converted into social housing, the ousted buyer's claim was rejected.
Accepting retrocession closes off other routes. According to the Court of Cassation, where the holder offers the property to the ousted buyer after the former owner has declined, and the buyer accepts, the buyer “may no longer seek annulment of the sale concluded with the former owner as from the date on which the preliminary sale agreement is concluded” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 7 September 2022, No. 21-12.114). The Court notes that the municipality had “remained the owner despite the annulment of the pre-emption decision” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 7 September 2022, No. 21-12.114). Failure to comply with the obligations to offer the property to the former owners and then to the buyer gives rise to a claim for damages before the ordinary courts, which is time-barred five years after the entry recording the use or sale of the property in the register of pre-empted property or, in the event of annulment, five years after the administrative court's decision has become final (Article L. 213-12).
The points the firm examines in every case:
A sale concluded without a DIA may be annulled, and that action is time-barred five years after publication of the deed transferring ownership (Article L. 213-2). Questions about the sale agreement (compromis), conditions precedent and defects in the sale are covered on our property sale lawyer page. See also our articles on the ousted buyer and on retrocession after annulment.
Other rights
Tenants and the SAFER: pre-emption rights separate from the municipality's
Notice to sell, sale after division of the building, farmland: their own rules and time limits.
Notice to sell
A notice based on the decision to sell the home must, on pain of nullity, state the price and terms of the planned sale; it counts as an offer to sell to the tenant, valid for the first two months of the notice period (Article 15 of the Law of 6 July 1989).
Completion
A tenant who accepts has two months to complete the sale, extended to four months if a loan is needed; otherwise the acceptance is automatically void (Article 15).
Secondary right
If the landlord then sells on terms or at a price more favourable to the buyer, the notary must notify them to the tenant, on pain of nullity of the sale; this offer is valid for one month (Article 15).
Sale after division
Before any sale of a home following the initial division or the subdivision of the building into units, the landlord must notify the tenant of the price and terms, on pain of nullity of the sale; the offer is valid for two months (Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1975).
SAFER
SAFERs (sociétés d'aménagement foncier et d'établissement rural, the rural land agencies) have a pre-emption right over agricultural property and bare land intended for agriculture sold for consideration, subject to the statutory exceptions (Article L. 143-1 of the French Rural and Maritime Fishing Code, Code rural et de la pêche maritime), and must give reasons for each pre-emption by reference to the statutory objectives (Article L. 143-3).
Six months
Claims challenging a SAFER pre-emption are inadmissible after six months from publication of the reasoned decision (Article L. 143-13); where compliance with the statutory objectives is in issue, the six-month period runs from publication of the decision to resell (rétrocession) (Article L. 143-14).
In an unpublished judgment, the Court of Cassation, recalling that the notice counts as an offer to sell, quashed for lack of legal basis the judgment that had upheld a notice “without finding that each joint owner had consented to the service of a notice to sell on the tenant” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 23 January 2025, No. 23-21.610). The secondary right also protects the price: “a tenant who exercises the secondary pre-emption right by accepting the offer notified by the notary, which did not have to be presented by the estate agent instructed by the owner to find a buyer, cannot be required to pay a commission that increases the price of the property” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 1 March 2023, No. 21-22.073).
The right under Article 10 of the 1975 Law applies only after division. The Court of Cassation, refusing to refer a priority preliminary ruling on constitutionality (QPC), adopts the analysis of the Constitutional Council: Parliament provided for this right “only where that unit is put up for sale following the division or subdivision of the building that contains it, whether the sale is by agreement or by auction” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 20 November 2025, No. 25-14.382). The occupant who contested this condition did not obtain the referral. For the SAFER, the six-month period “cannot run against that ousted buyer” (our translation) where the notification was made on the basis of inaccurate or incomplete information that prevented it from being delivered to the ousted buyer (Cass. 3e civ., 9 July 2026, No. 25-15.423).
The commercial tenant's right of first refusal (droit de préférence) is covered on our commercial lease lawyer page. See our articles on the notice to sell and the offer to the tenant, on a changed price and the secondary right and on the tenant's pre-emption right.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the legislation in force and on verified decisions.
When do you need a pre-emption right lawyer in France?
Before signing the preliminary sale agreement, as soon as a pre-emption decision is received and as soon as a notice to sell arrives. Before the sale, the lawyer checks whether the property lies in an area subject to the urban pre-emption right, introduced by resolution of the municipal council over all or part of the urban and future development areas (Article L. 211-1 of the French Planning Code), reviews the preliminary agreement and prepares an accurate declaration of intention to sell, since any transfer subject to the right requires that declaration “on pain of nullity” (Article L. 213-2).
After the decision, everything depends on the time limits. A seller who receives a lower offer has two months to reply, failing which the seller is deemed to have withdrawn from the sale (Article R. 213-10). The ousted buyer and the seller have two months to bring proceedings before the administrative court (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice), and the judge hearing urgent applications can suspend the decision. The ousted buyer in principle benefits from a presumption of urgency, which the public authority can rebut by showing particular circumstances (CE, 30 January 2019, No. 421740).
The firm acts for sellers, whether individuals or companies, for ousted buyers and for tenants who receive a notice to sell or an offer after division of the building. Planning questions that determine the zone or the project are also covered on our planning lawyer page.
Is my property in France subject to the urban pre-emption right?
First, there must be a council resolution. In particular, municipalities with an approved local urban development plan may introduce an urban pre-emption right over all or part of the urban areas and future development areas delimited by that plan (Article L. 211-1 of the French Planning Code). Checking the local urban development plan and the resolution shows where the property stands.
Next, there must be a transfer covered by the law. The right applies to any building or land, or any set of company rights giving entitlement to a building, when transferred for consideration in any form whatsoever; to transfers of undivided rights, except when made to a co-owner in the joint ownership (indivision); and to transfers of the majority of the shares in a property-holding non-trading company (société civile immobilière) whose assets consist of a single land holding, or transfers giving a buyer a majority of those shares, except for companies formed exclusively between relatives by blood or marriage up to and including the fourth degree; all subject to the exclusions provided for in the text (Article L. 213-1).
Some sales fall outside the ordinary right: the transfer of one or more units consisting of a single residential, professional or mixed-use premises, with its ancillary premises, in a building that has been under the co-ownership regime for at least ten years from the publication of the co-ownership rules, or following the division of a company allocating units to its members (société d'attribution); a commercial unit or an entire building is therefore not covered by this exemption; the transfer of shares in certain such companies; and the transfer of a building within four years of its completion. The municipality may, however, by reasoned resolution, apply the pre-emption right to these sales over all or part of its territory (Article L. 211-4). The firm checks these points before signature, to avoid a sale that could be annulled. See our article on the planning certificate (certificat d'urbanisme) and clearing the pre-emption right.
What must a DIA contain, and how long does the town hall have to respond?
The declaration is made by the owner to the town hall of the municipality where the property is located. It must state the price and terms of the planned transfer or, in the case of an auction, the estimated value of the property or its reserve price, together with certain environmental information (Article L. 213-2 of the French Planning Code). It is drawn up on the official form and sent by registered post with acknowledgement of receipt, handed in against a receipt or filed electronically (Article R. 213-5). The estate agent's fee and the party liable for it should be stated: a holder that pre-empts must bear the fee where its amount and the party liable for it are stated in the parties' agreement and in the declaration (Cass. 3e civ., 12 May 2021, No. 19-25.226).
The holder has two months from receipt; its silence counts as a waiver. It may send a single request for documents, from an exhaustive list, and ask to visit the property: the time limit is suspended, then resumes on receipt of the documents, on refusal of the visit or after the visit, with at least one month remaining (Article L. 213-2 and Article R. 213-7).
The Council of State applied this calculation to the letter: after a request for documents and a visit made on the last day, “the time available to the holder of the pre-emption right after receipt of the declaration of intention to sell started running again on 5 May 2023, for a period of one month, that is until 5 June 2023” (our translation) (CE, 17 October 2024, No. 489707). The argument that the pre-emption of 23 June was out of time was held to be serious, and its enforcement was suspended. The firm reconstructs this timetable as soon as the decision is received. See our article on the town hall's silence after the DIA.
If the town hall pre-empts at the DIA price, can I still refuse to sell?
In principle, no. When the holder notifies its decision to buy at the price and on the terms proposed (Article R. 213-8 of the French Planning Code), the declaration, which is an offer, meets its acceptance. The law allows the offer to be withdrawn only “failing agreement on the price” (Article L. 213-7). The Paris Court of Appeal draws the consequence: “once the holder of the pre-emption right has notified its decision to buy at the price and on the terms proposed by the seller, agreement on the property and on the price is reached and the sale is complete, with all the consequences that follow” (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 9 October 2026, No. 25/04544).
In that case, the seller had not attended the signing appointment. The court held that signing the notarial deed affected only the transfer of ownership, not the formation of the sale, and ordered the seller to execute the deed within two months. The rules do provide that a notarial deed is to be drawn up within three months of the agreement (Article R. 213-12): the court noted that this time limit carried no sanction and that the delay was due to the seller's conduct and to a charge registered against the property that had not been lifted in time.
The seller does, however, keep three safeguards. Ownership passes only on the later of the dates of payment and of the notarial deed, and if the price is neither paid nor deposited within four months, the seller may sell the property freely (Article L. 213-14). The seller keeps the use and enjoyment of the property until the price has been paid in full (Article L. 213-15). On the merits, challenging the pre-emption decision before the administrative court remains the main route, without prejudice to the right to sell freely under Article L. 213-14 if the price is not paid or deposited within four months. The firm checks these time limits and the lawfulness of the decision.
What can I do if the town hall offers a lower price?
Three responses are possible, within two months of receiving the offer: accept the proposed price, maintain the price in the declaration and agree to have it set by the expropriation court, or withdraw from the sale. The owner's silence counts as a withdrawal from the sale (Article R. 213-10 of the French Planning Code). Withdrawing releases the property, but ends the planned sale.
If the owner maintains the price, the burden of the procedure shifts to the holder: if it considers the price excessive, it must refer the matter to the court within fifteen days of receiving the owner's reply, failing which it is deemed to have waived its right (Article R. 213-11). It must also deposit a sum equal to 15% of the valuation made by the departmental director of public finances and notify the deposit receipt within three months of the referral, failing which it is deemed to have waived its right (Article L. 213-4-1).
Once the price has been set and the decision has become final, each party has two months to accept it or to withdraw from the transfer, silence counting as acceptance (Article L. 213-7). If the holder withdraws after the price has been set by the court, it may not pre-empt the same property again for five years from the date the court decision became final, as against the same owner, if the owner sells within that period at the price set by the court, revised in line with the construction cost index (Article L. 213-8). In parallel, the decision can be challenged before the administrative court within two months. The firm values the property, drafts the reply and prepares the written submissions to the court. See our article on pre-emption at a lower price.
How does the expropriation judge set the price of a pre-empted property in France?
According to the rules of expropriation, with adaptations specific to pre-emption. The price set by the court with jurisdiction over expropriation excludes any ancillary compensation, in particular the reinvestment allowance. For a property outside a deferred development zone (zone d'aménagement différé), the reference date is the date on which the most recent of the acts approving, revising or amending the local urban development plan and delimiting the property's zone became enforceable against third parties; later improvements are not presumed to be speculative; if there are not enough comparable sales in the same zone, transactions in comparable zones may be taken into account (Article L. 213-4 of the French Planning Code).
The property is valued at the date of the first-instance decision, only its actual use at the reference date being taken into account (Article L. 322-2 of the French Expropriation Code). In expropriation cases, the Court of Cassation applies this reference date to property subject to the pre-emption right, on the basis of Articles L. 213-4 a) and L. 213-6: it “is the date on which the most recent of the acts making public, approving, revising or amending the land use plan or the local urban development plan and delimiting the zone in which the property is located became enforceable against third parties” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 1 March 2023, No. 22-11.467). In that expropriation case, it dismissed the owner's appeal.
In practice, the debate turns on comparable sales, floor area, the condition of the property and the classification of the land. Where the pre-emption covers only part of a single land holding (unité foncière), the price takes into account the loss in value of the remaining part (Article L. 213-4), and the owner may require the whole holding to be acquired (Article L. 213-2-1). The firm gathers comparable sales, challenges the holder's valuation and argues the case before the expropriation court. See our expropriation lawyer page.
How do you challenge a town hall's pre-emption decision in France?
By an application for annulment (recours pour excès de pouvoir) before the administrative court, lodged within two months of the notification or publication of the decision (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice), possibly together with an urgent application for suspension where urgency justifies it and an argument raises serious doubt (Article L. 521-1).
The grounds concern both procedure and substance. The decision must come from a competent authority, be taken within the two-month time limit, as suspended where applicable, and state its purpose: “Every pre-emption decision must state the purpose for which this right is exercised.” (Article L. 210-1 of the French Planning Code). On the substance, the public authority must show, at the date of the decision, that a planned development action or operation meeting the purposes of Article L. 300-1 genuinely exists, “even if the precise features of that project had not been defined at that date” (our translation) (CE, 25 March 2026, No. 504317).
These requirements are not always enough for the applicant. On 25 March 2026, the Council of State set aside the judgment that required the public land agency (établissement public foncier) to show a project that could be carried out “with certainty and within a reasonable time” (our translation) (CE, 25 March 2026, No. 504317), remitting the case to the court of appeal, and, in 2019, the judgment that required the municipality to prove it could not act other than through pre-emption, also with remittal (CE, 13 March 2019, No. 419259). A challenge must therefore rely on the public authority's actual file, which the firm obtains and analyses before choosing the grounds. See our article on challenging a pre-emption by the City of Paris.
What are my remedies as the ousted buyer after a pre-emption?
The buyer named in the DIA is notified of the decision (Article L. 213-2 of the French Planning Code) and may challenge it within two months. In urgent proceedings, the buyer's position is favourable: “Given the purpose of a pre-emption decision and its effects on the ousted buyer, the urgency requirement must in principle be regarded as met where the ousted buyer seeks suspension of such a decision.” (our translation) (CE, 30 January 2019, No. 421740). In that case, however, the application was rejected for want of a serious argument: urgency does not remove the need to show unlawfulness (Article L. 521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
If the decision is annulled after the sale, the holder offers to sell the property to the former owners and then, if they decline, to the buyer whose name appeared in the declaration (Article L. 213-11-1). Accepting that offer comes at a procedural cost: an ousted buyer who accepts it “may no longer seek annulment of the sale concluded with the former owner as from the date on which the preliminary sale agreement is concluded” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 7 September 2022, No. 21-12.114).
A similar priority applies where the holder decides to use or sell a property pre-empted less than five years earlier for purposes other than those of Article L. 210-1: it benefits first the former owners and then, if they decline, the buyer whose name appeared in the declaration (Article L. 213-11). Where these obligations are not met, the ousted buyer may claim damages before the ordinary courts; the claim is time-barred five years after the entry recording the use or sale of the property in the register of pre-empted property or, in the event of annulment, five years after the administrative court's decision has become final (Article L. 213-12). The firm assesses the costs incurred and the loss resulting from the lost transaction. See our article on the ousted buyer facing the town hall.
Can you get the property back after a pre-emption is annulled?
It all depends on when the annulment occurs. If the decision is annulled before any transfer of ownership, the holder may not exercise its right over the property for one year from the date the decision became final, and the owner is no longer bound by the price and terms in its declaration (Article L. 213-8 of the French Planning Code). The original sale can then go ahead, if the parties still wish.
If the transfer has taken place, the holder must first offer to sell the property to the former owners, then to the buyer named in the DIA. The price offered aims to restore, without unjust enrichment, the terms of the transaction that was prevented; failing agreement, it is set by the expropriation court. Former owners who do not accept within three months of notification of the final court decision are deemed to have declined (Article L. 213-11-1).
The administrative court can order the holder to make this offer, that is, “to offer the former owner and then, where appropriate, the ousted buyer the opportunity to acquire the property, at a price intended to restore, without unjust enrichment of either party, the terms of the transaction that the exercise of the pre-emption right prevented” (our translation), after verifying that restoring the initial situation does not cause excessive harm to the general interest (CE, 28 September 2020, No. 436978). For a Paris building that had become a social housing complex, the Council of State refused the order and rejected the ousted buyer's claim. The firm assesses this risk before starting proceedings. See our article on retrocession after annulment.
What is the risk of selling without a declaration of intention to sell (DIA)?
Annulment. Any transfer of a property subject to the pre-emption right requires, “on pain of nullity”, the owner's prior declaration to the town hall, and “The action for annulment provided for in the first paragraph is time-barred five years after publication of the deed transferring ownership.” (Article L. 213-2 of the French Planning Code). During that period, the buyer's title remains open to challenge.
The scope of Article L. 213-1 is broad: the law covers real property transferred for consideration “in any form whatsoever”, transfers of undivided rights to a third party and certain transfers of a majority of the shares in a property-holding non-trading company (Article L. 213-1). The declaration must also state the price and terms of the planned transfer (Article L. 213-2), and the firm checks that it matches the signed preliminary agreement.
The same requirement applies to craft businesses, businesses (fonds de commerce) and commercial leases located in a local shops and crafts protection area (périmètre de sauvegarde du commerce et de l'artisanat de proximité): each transfer requires, on pain of nullity, a prior declaration by the transferor to the municipality, whose silence for two months counts as a waiver (Article L. 214-1). The firm audits the deeds and, if a problem arises, defends the seller or the buyer. See our article on the notary's liability and clearing the pre-emption right.
What pre-emption right does a tenant have after a notice to sell?
When the landlord serves notice in order to sell the home, the notice must, on pain of nullity, state the price and terms of the planned sale, and it counts as an offer to sell to the tenant, valid for the first two months of the notice period, which is six months. A tenant who accepts has two months to complete the sale, or four if a loan is needed (Article 15 of the Law of 6 July 1989).
If the landlord then sells on terms or at a price more favourable to the buyer, the notary must notify those terms to the tenant, on pain of nullity of the sale, and this notification counts as an offer for one month (Article 15, II). This secondary right protects the tenant against a price reduction reserved for a third party. The Court of Cassation has held that a tenant who exercises it “cannot be required to pay a commission that increases the price of the property” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 1 March 2023, No. 21-22.073).
The notice itself may be vulnerable. Where the home is held in joint ownership (indivision), the Court of Cassation requires the consent of each joint owner: it set aside the judgment that had upheld a notice “without finding that each joint owner had consented to the service of a notice to sell on the tenant” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 23 January 2025, No. 23-21.610). A fraudulent notice is also punishable by a criminal fine of up to €6,000 for an individual and €30,000 for a legal entity (Article 15, V). The firm checks the notice, the price and any later sales. See our articles on the notice to sell and on the secondary pre-emption right.
Break-up sale (vente à la découpe): can a tenant buy their home first?
Yes, where the sale follows the division of the building. Before concluding any sale of residential or mixed-use premises following the initial division or the subdivision of all or part of a building into units, the landlord must, on pain of nullity of the sale, inform the tenant or occupant in good faith, by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt, of the price and terms of the planned sale. This notification counts as an offer to sell for two months (Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1975).
A tenant who accepts has two months to complete the sale, or four if a loan is needed. If the owner then sells on more favourable terms, the notary must notify them, on pain of nullity, and the offer is valid for one month. The provision does not apply to sales of an entire building or of all its residential units, nor to transactions between relatives by blood or marriage up to and including the fourth degree (Article 10, III).
The division requirement is strict. The Court of Cassation points out that Parliament provided for this right “only where that unit is put up for sale following the division or subdivision of the building that contains it, whether the sale is by agreement or by auction” (our translation), in order to protect the occupant “following a speculative transaction made easier by the division of the building” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 20 November 2025, No. 25-14.382). It refused to refer to the Constitutional Council the question raised by the occupant who contested this condition. The firm checks the chronology of the division and of the sales before bringing an action for annulment. See our article on the tenant's pre-emption right.
How do you challenge a SAFER pre-emption of farmland in France?
SAFERs (rural land agencies) have a pre-emption right when agricultural property, the movable property attached to it or bare land intended for agriculture is sold for consideration (Article L. 143-1 of the French Rural and Maritime Fishing Code). On pain of nullity, the decision must be justified “by explicit and reasoned reference” to one or more of the objectives set by law, and brought to the attention of the persons concerned (Article L. 143-3).
The time limit is short: unless compliance with the statutory objectives is in issue, claims challenging SAFER pre-emption decisions are inadmissible after six months from the day on which the reasoned decisions were made public (Article L. 143-13). Challenging those objectives does not open an unlimited period: the claim is then inadmissible after six months from publication of the reasoned decision to resell (rétrocession) (Article L. 143-14).
This time limit presupposes proper notification. On 9 July 2026, the Court of Cassation held that a letter sent on the basis of inaccurate or incomplete information that prevented it from being delivered to the ousted buyer is not proper notification, so that the six-month period “cannot run against that ousted buyer, notwithstanding the buyer's knowledge of the existence of a pre-emption decision by other means” (our translation) (Cass. 3e civ., 9 July 2026, No. 25-15.423). The judgment that had declared the ousted buyers' claim inadmissible was quashed. The firm checks the reasons for the decision, the notifications and the timetable before issuing proceedings.
What fees does a pre-emption right lawyer charge?
Fees are set out in a written fee agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before you commit, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs. The agreement specifies the amount of the fees, or how they are calculated, for the foreseeable work, as well as the expected costs and disbursements. The fixed fee is set after reading the relevant documents: preliminary sale agreement, declaration of intention to sell, pre-emption decision, the public authority's offer, notice to sell or offer notified to the tenant.
The firm prefers a fixed fee for each stage: review of a preliminary agreement and a DIA, reply to the public authority's offer, request for reconsideration (recours gracieux), application for annulment and urgent application for suspension, proceedings before the expropriation court, request for retrocession, action for annulment or damages, appeal. Service and expert fees are added to the fees. Any new work is covered by an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected billing.
For an initial opinion based on your documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. First contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 31 October 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles L. 210-1 and L. 300-1 of the French Planning Code: purpose of pre-emption, development actions and operations
- Articles L. 211-1, L. 211-4 and L. 213-1 of the French Planning Code: introduction of the urban pre-emption right, excluded property, transfers covered
- Articles L. 213-2, R. 213-5 and R. 213-7 of the French Planning Code: declaration of intention to sell, two-month time limit, documents and visit, nullity
- Article L. 213-3 of the French Planning Code: delegation of the pre-emption right
- Articles R. 213-8, R. 213-10, R. 213-11 and L. 213-4-1 of the French Planning Code: the holder's response, the owner's options, referral to the court, deposit
- Articles L. 213-4, L. 213-2-1, L. 213-6, L. 213-7 and L. 213-8 of the French Planning Code: price set by the court, partial pre-emption, withdrawal
- Articles L. 213-14, L. 213-15 and R. 213-12 of the French Planning Code: payment, transfer of ownership, notarial deed
- Articles L. 213-11, L. 213-11-1 and L. 213-12 of the French Planning Code: use of the property, retrocession after annulment, damages
- Article L. 214-1 of the French Planning Code: pre-emption of businesses and commercial leases
- Article L. 322-2 of the French Expropriation Code: reference date and actual use
- Articles R. 421-1 and L. 521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice: time limit for challenges, urgent application for suspension
- Articles L. 143-1, L. 143-3, L. 143-13 and L. 143-14 of the French Rural and Maritime Fishing Code: SAFER pre-emption right, statement of reasons, six-month time limit
- Article 15 of Law No. 89-462 of 6 July 1989: notice to sell and the tenant's pre-emption right
- Article 10 of Law No. 75-1351 of 31 December 1975: the tenant's pre-emption right after division of the building
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- CE, 25 March 2026, No. 504317: a genuine project at the date of the pre-emption
- CE, 13 March 2019, No. 419259: sufficient general interest for the pre-emption
- CE, 30 January 2019, No. 421740: presumption of urgency for the ousted buyer in urgent proceedings
- CE, 17 October 2024, No. 489707: request for documents, visit and the two-month time limit
- CE, 28 September 2020, No. 436978: order to offer the property back after annulment
- CA Paris, pôle 4, ch. 1, 9 October 2026, No. 25/04544: pre-emption at the DIA price and a completed sale
- Cass. 3e civ., 12 May 2021, No. 19-25.226: estate agent's fee borne by the holder of the right
- Cass. 3e civ., 23 September 2020, No. 19-14.261: obstacle to payment and deposit of the price, former six-month time limit
- Cass. 3e civ., 1 March 2023, No. 22-11.467: reference date for property subject to the pre-emption right
- Cass. 3e civ., 7 September 2022, No. 21-12.114: ousted buyer who accepted the retrocession
- Cass. 3e civ., 23 January 2025, No. 23-21.610: notice to sell and consent of the joint owners
- Cass. 3e civ., 1 March 2023, No. 21-22.073: the tenant's secondary pre-emption right without commission
- Cass. 3e civ., 20 November 2025, No. 25-14.382: the tenant's pre-emption right after division of the building
- Cass. 3e civ., 9 July 2026, No. 25-15.423: SAFER, defective notification and the six-month time limit
Further reading
A DIA to file, a pre-emption to challenge, a notice to sell received?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the preliminary sale agreement, the declaration of intention to sell, the pre-emption decision or the public authority's offer, the notice or offer you received and your correspondence with the notary: Hassan Kohen reviews the time limits, the lawfulness of the decision and the price, then tells you which route suits your case: a reply to the public authority, a challenge and urgent application, price-setting proceedings, retrocession or an action for annulment.