The firm in the media
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, construction law in Paris
Construction lawyer in Paris: contracts, subcontracting and payment
A works contract to draft or to get paid under, an unpaid subcontractor, disputed delay penalties, a refusal to accept the works, a ten-year liability claim, an inspection by URSSAF (the social security contributions agency) or an accident on site: as a construction lawyer in Paris, the firm advises and defends building and civil engineering contractors (entreprises du BTP), and also the project owners (maîtres d'ouvrage) who hire them. Everything turns on the signed contract, the site documents and the time limits, which are short.
The firm can be reached 24/7. An unpaid subcontractor must first give the main contractor formal notice to pay: its direct action against the project owner only becomes available one month later (Article 12 of the Law of 31 December 1975), and it only covers what the project owner still owes the main contractor on the date it receives the copy of that formal notice (Article 13).
4,9/5
Average Google rating270 reviews
I received very high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective defence in criminal law.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer. He got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution found for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with great empathy and a strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen carefully and to fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Urgent matters 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, works contracts, subcontracting, recovery of construction debts, builders' liability and employment and social security law for building companies.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
A private works contract is a contract for work (louage d'ouvrage) under Article 1779 of the French Civil Code (Code civil). Above €12,000 excl. VAT, the project owner (maître d'ouvrage) under a private contract must guarantee payment to the contractor; failing that, the contractor, unless the contract was concluded for non-professional purposes, may suspend work on site fifteen days after a formal notice that has gone unheeded (Article 1799-1 of the Civil Code and the Decree of 30 July 1999). The retention (retenue de garantie) is capped at 5% and must be held in escrow or replaced by a guarantee (Law of 16 July 1971). The subcontractor must be accepted, and its payment terms approved, by the project owner, failing which the main contractor cannot rely on the subcontract against it (Article 3 of the Law of 31 December 1975), and its payment must be secured by a guarantee or a delegation of payment, on pain of nullity of the subcontract (Article 14). After acceptance of the works (réception), the contractor owes the guarantee of perfect completion (garantie de parfait achèvement) for one year, the guarantee of proper functioning (garantie de bon fonctionnement) for at least two years and the ten-year liability (responsabilité décennale), for which insurance is compulsory (Articles 1792 to 1792-6 of the Civil Code, L. 241-1 of the Insurance Code). A principal (donneur d'ordre) that does not check its contracting partner's social security position is jointly and severally liable for its debts in the event of undeclared work (Articles L. 8222-1 and L. 8222-2 of the Labour Code). Kohen Avocats, in Paris (16th arrondissement), acts for contractors, subcontractors and project owners. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
Unpaid works, a subcontractor demanding payment, acceptance of the works held up?
Understanding your situation
Construction contracts and disputes in Paris, explained
A works contract (marché de travaux) is a contract for work, or louage d'ouvrage (Article 1779 of the Civil Code). This section covers how it is paid and secured, how subcontracting is handled, what acceptance of the works triggers, what employment and social security law requires on site, and where to find the firm's detailed pages.
The contract
Private construction contracts: four clauses that decide payment
The price, the payment guarantee, the retention and the penalties, read alongside the texts that govern them.
The fixed price: a contractor who has undertaken to build a building for a fixed price (à forfait), on the basis of a plan settled with the owner, cannot claim any price increase for changes to or extensions of the plan unless they were authorised in writing and the price agreed with the owner (Article 1793 of the Civil Code).
The payment guarantee: the project owner under a private works contract must guarantee payment to the contractor where the sums due exceed €12,000 excl. VAT, after deducting deposits and advance payments made when the contract was concluded (Article 1799-1 of the Civil Code and Article 1 of Decree No. 99-658 of 30 July 1999). The guarantee (cautionnement) and the right to suspend the works do not apply where the project owner enters into the contract on its own account and for purposes unrelated to a professional activity connected with the contract.
The retention: it is at most 5% of the interim payments, the project owner must deposit an equal sum with an escrow agent (consignataire), and no retention is made if the contractor provides a joint and several personal guarantee for the same amount (Article 1 of the Law of 16 July 1971). One year after acceptance of the works, the guarantee is released or the sums paid over, unless a reasoned objection is notified by registered letter (Article 2 of the Law of 16 July 1971).
Delay penalties: the judge may reduce the agreed penalty, even of the judge's own motion, if it is manifestly excessive, and, save in the case of definitive non-performance, it is only incurred once the debtor has been given formal notice (Article 1231-5 of the Civil Code). The project owner may also terminate a fixed-price contract unilaterally, provided it compensates the contractor for its expenses, its work and the profit it could have made (Article 1794 of the Civil Code).
Extra works are the leading cause of disputes. Under a fixed-price contract, the French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) holds that the contractor “may claim payment for extra works only if those works were authorised in advance in writing and their price agreed in advance with the project owner, or if the latter accepted them expressly and unequivocally once they had been carried out” (our translation). In that case, which went against the contractor, the contract referred to the final-account procedure of the NF P 03-001 standard, and the court of appeal had inferred from the project owner's silence that it had accepted the balance claimed; the judgment was quashed, as that silence, or failure to follow the procedure for closing the accounts, does not amount to acceptance of the extra works (Cass. 3e civ., 8 June 2023, No. 22-10.393). Written, priced instructions (ordres de service) therefore protect the contractor better than any final statement of account.
The payment guarantee, by contrast, works in the contractor's favour. As long as no guarantee has been provided and the contractor remains unpaid, it may suspend performance of the contract after a formal notice that has gone unheeded for fifteen days (Article 1799-1 of the Civil Code); the formal notice is sent by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt (Article 1 of Decree No. 99-658 of 30 July 1999). The guarantee provided must be capable of being called on: the Cour de cassation holds that the guarantee securing payment of the sums due under the contract must not be subject to any condition that limits its enforcement, and it overturned a judgment that had accepted a guarantee conditional on notification of the final account (Cass. 3e civ., 4 March 2021, No. 19-25.964). Even insolvency proceedings (procédure collective) against the project owner do not undo a lawful suspension: “the opening of insolvency proceedings cannot have the effect of forcing a contractor who, before those proceedings were opened, duly gave notice that it was suspending performance of its works, to resume them without obtaining the financial guarantee laid down by Article 1799-1 of the Civil Code” (Cass. com., 10 October 2018, No. 17-18.547, our translation).
The retention benefits the project owner, as the case law confirms. The retention and the guarantee that replaces it “are intended to protect the project owner against the risks of non-performance or defective performance of the work to lift the reservations made at acceptance” (our translation), and the one-year period at the end of which the guarantor is released “cannot start to run before the date of acceptance” (our translation), whether acceptance is by agreement, tacit or ordered by the court. In that case, which went against the contractor, the Cour de cassation upheld the court of appeal's decision granting the project owner's claim for payment against the guarantor bank, as the cost of lifting the reservations exceeded the amount of the guarantee (Cass. 3e civ., 11 January 2023, No. 21-11.053).
Public works contracts. The public buyer (acheteur) pays within thirty days when it is a contracting authority (Article R. 2192-10 of the Public Procurement Code (Code de la commande publique)), subject to exceptions: fifty days for public health establishments and those of the armed forces health service, sixty days for certain public undertakings (Article R. 2192-11 of the Public Procurement Code). The retention only covers the reservations made at acceptance and, where applicable, during the guarantee period (Article R. 2191-32 of the Public Procurement Code); it may not exceed 5% of the initial contract value plus any amendments, or 3% for a small or medium-sized enterprise holding a contract with the State or with certain large local authorities and large public bodies (Article R. 2191-33 of the Public Procurement Code), and it is repaid within thirty days of the end of the guarantee period or of the lifting of the reservations notified during that period (Article R. 2191-35 of the Public Procurement Code). A direct subcontractor that has been accepted and approved is paid directly by the public buyer, and any waiver of this direct payment is deemed unwritten (Article L. 2193-11 of the Public Procurement Code).
Subcontracting
Subcontracting: what the Law of 31 December 1975 requires of each party
A mandatory law (loi d'ordre public) that protects the subcontractor and places obligations on the project owner.
Definition
Subcontracting is the arrangement by which a contractor entrusts to another person, by a subcontract and under its own responsibility, the performance of all or part of the works contract, or of part of the public contract, concluded with the project owner (Article 1 of the Law of 31 December 1975).
Acceptance
The contractor must have each subcontractor accepted, and the payment terms of each subcontract approved, by the project owner, when the contract is concluded and throughout its term; otherwise, it remains bound towards the subcontractor but cannot rely on the subcontract against it (Article 3 of the Law of 31 December 1975).
Guarantee
On pain of nullity of the subcontract, payments due to the subcontractor are secured by a joint and several personal guarantee from a qualified institution, unless payment by the project owner is arranged through a delegation of payment up to the value of the work performed (Article 14 of the Law of 31 December 1975).
Direct action
The subcontractor has a direct action (action directe) against the project owner if the main contractor fails to pay one month after being given formal notice; a copy of the formal notice is sent to the project owner, and any waiver of the direct action is deemed unwritten (Article 12 of the Law of 31 December 1975).
Limit
The direct action only covers work provided for in the subcontract from which the project owner actually benefits, and only up to what it still owes the main contractor when it receives the copy of the formal notice (Article 13 of the Law of 31 December 1975).
Project owner
In building and public works, a project owner that is aware that a subcontractor who has not been presented is working on site must give the main contractor or the subcontractor formal notice to regularise the position, and must require proof of the guarantee where the approved subcontractor does not benefit from a delegation of payment, unless the owner is an individual building their own home (Article 14-1 of the Law of 31 December 1975).
These obligations come at a price for a project owner that neglects them. For the Cour de cassation, its failure to act when it knows the subcontractor is present has a precise consequence: “The failure of a project owner who, having become aware of a subcontractor's presence on a site, refrained from giving the main contractor formal notice to fulfil its obligations by presenting the subcontractor to it, deprives the subcontractor of the benefit of the direct action” (our translation). The loss suffered by such an unpresented subcontractor “is assessed in the light of what the project owner still owed the main contractor on the date on which it became aware of the subcontractor's presence on the site, or of the sums paid to the main contractor after that date” (our translation). Where the subcontractor has been approved but has no guarantee, the measure is different: “the recoverable loss is then equal to the difference between the sums the subcontractor should have received had it been granted a delegation of payment or had a financial institution guaranteed its contract, and the sums actually received” (Cass. 3e civ., 7 March 2024, No. 22-23.309, our translation). The Court restated this in September 2026 in relation to extra works, overturning a judgment given “without ascertaining, as it was required to do, whether the extra works had been entrusted to the subcontractor for the performance of the main contract” (Cass. 3e civ., 3 September 2026, No. 24-15.620, our translation).
The main contractor, for its part, must provide the guarantee in time. The Cour de cassation holds that it “must provide the guarantee before the subcontract is concluded and, if performance of the works starts earlier, before it starts” (our translation); a guarantee provided after signature did not prevent the subcontract from being declared void (Cass. 3e civ., 21 January 2021, No. 19-22.219). Clauses that would defeat the Law are void (Article 15 of the Law of 31 December 1975).
The direct action is calculated on the balance of the main contract. The Montpellier Court of Appeal points out that “the subcontractor's direct action against the project owner is strictly limited to the sums the latter still owes the main contractor on the date the formal notice is received” (our translation), but that the subcontractor “may obtain payment of its claim out of the sums the project owner still owes the main contractor under the main contract, even if those sums relate to work other than that carried out by the subcontractor” (our translation); ruling on an urgent application (référé), it upheld an order for an interim payment of €22,380.79 (CA Montpellier, 3e ch. civ., 8 October 2026, No. 25/05905). A project owner that paid the contractor before receiving the formal notice is therefore liable only for the remaining balance.
In public contracts, direct payment follows a procedure: the subcontractor sends its request to the contract holder (titulaire), which has fifteen days to accept or refuse it, failing which it is deemed to have accepted (Articles R. 2193-11 to R. 2193-13 of the Public Procurement Code). The Council of State (Conseil d'État) held, under the former public procurement code (code des marchés publics), whose procedure these articles carry over, that this procedure allows the contract holder to check the documents and to object to payment: “Failure by the subcontractor to comply with it thus prevents it from asserting a right to that payment against the project owner” (our translation). A reasoned refusal by the contract holder, notified within the fifteen days, has the same effect; in the case decided, it was this refusal that deprived of direct payment a subcontractor that had nonetheless sent its request to the contract holder (CE, 17 October 2023, No. 469071). See also our article on the VAT reverse charge in construction subcontracting.
After the works
Acceptance of the works and ten-year liability insurance: what the contractor must obtain and prove
For the contractor, acceptance starts the period for release of the retention and triggers the statutory guarantees; ten-year liability insurance must be evidenced as soon as the site opens.
Acceptance of the works (réception) is the act by which the project owner declares that it accepts the work, with or without reservations; it takes place at the request of the more diligent party, by agreement or, failing that, by court order (Article 1792-6 of the Civil Code). The contractor therefore has an interest in initiating it: one year after acceptance, the guarantee replacing the retention is released, or the sums held in escrow are paid to it, unless the project owner notifies a reasoned objection by registered letter (Article 2 of the Law of 16 July 1971). Acceptance also starts the guarantee of perfect completion (Article 1792-6 of the Civil Code), the guarantee of proper functioning (Article 1792-3 of the Civil Code) and the ten-year liability (Article 1792 of the Civil Code and Article 1792-4-1 of the Civil Code), whose rules are set out on the pages dedicated to those subjects.
You are the contractor
- Request acceptance in writing and obtain a dated acceptance report (procès-verbal de réception), to start the time limits running and release the retention.
- Lift the reservations within the agreed time, and have this formally recorded.
- Keep the ten-year liability insurance certificate up to date and hand it over when each site opens.
You are the project owner
- Record precise reservations in the acceptance report, then give written notice of any defects that appear within the year.
- Check each contractor's ten-year liability insurance certificate before the site opens.
- Notify any objection to the release of the retention within the year following acceptance.
Ten-year liability insurance (assurance décennale) is compulsory for anyone whose ten-year liability may be incurred, and they must prove they hold it when any site opens (Article L. 241-1 of the French Insurance Code (Code des assurances)). The lack of insurance can expose the company's director personally: in a case where the manager had failed both to enter into an individual house-building contract (contrat de construction de maison individuelle) and to take out the insurance, the Cour de cassation overturned the judgment that had not examined whether he had committed “faults separable from his duties as a company officer, engaging his personal liability, by failing to enter into an individual house-building contract and to take out ten-year liability insurance” (Cass. 3e civ., 7 June 2018, No. 16-27.680, our translation).
What the firm checks for the contractor:
Defective work, expert assessments and builders' liability are covered on our construction law and building defects page; acceptance and ten-year liability claims have their own detailed pages: acceptance of the works and ten-year builder's liability (garantie décennale). See also our article on claiming under building damage insurance (assurance dommages-ouvrage).
Employment law on site
Undeclared work, hiring-out of labour, safety: the contractor's risks
A site brings several companies together; the law makes the principal answer for some of its contracting partners' failings.
Undeclared work
Undeclared work (travail dissimulé), whether by concealment of an activity or of salaried employment, is prohibited, as is knowingly using the services of anyone who engages in it (Article L. 8221-1 of the French Labour Code (Code du travail), L. 8221-3 and L. 8221-5). The penalty is three years' imprisonment and a €45,000 fine (Article L. 8224-1 of the Labour Code).
Duty of vigilance
For any contract worth at least €5,000 excl. VAT, the principal (donneur d'ordre) checks, when the contract is concluded and then periodically, that its contracting partner is registered and is filing its social security returns (Article L. 8222-1 of the Labour Code and Article R. 8222-1 of the Labour Code); it is deemed to have done so if it obtains, at the outset and then every six months, a certificate from the contributions collection body that is less than six months old, whose authenticity it checks with that body, together with, where required, one of the registration or professional activity documents specified by the provision (Article D. 8222-5 of the Labour Code).
Joint liability
Anyone who fails in this duty of vigilance is jointly and severally liable, with the contracting partner against whom an official report has been drawn up for undeclared work, for taxes, contributions, penalties and surcharges, and for wages due (Article L. 8222-2 of the Labour Code), in proportion to the value of the work carried out (Article L. 8222-3 of the Labour Code). A new version of Article L. 8222-2, which also refers to Article L. 8222-1-1, will come into force on 26 December 2026.
Project owner on notice
A project owner informed in writing, in particular by an inspector (agent de contrôle), of the irregular situation of its contracting partner, a subcontractor or a sub-delegate must immediately require its contracting partner to put an end to it, failing which it becomes jointly liable (Article L. 8222-5 of the Labour Code).
Hiring-out and unlawful supply of labour
Both profit-making arrangements whose sole purpose is the hiring-out of labour and the unlawful supply of labour (délit de marchandage) are prohibited (Article L. 8241-1 of the Labour Code and Article L. 8231-1 of the Labour Code). Unlawful hiring-out of labour is punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €30,000 fine, with heavier penalties in certain cases, and a possible ban on subcontracting labour for two to ten years (Article L. 8243-1 of the Labour Code, in the version in force since 27 June 2026).
Safety
The employer takes the measures necessary to ensure workers' safety (Article L. 4121-1 of the Labour Code), and safety coordination is organised on any site where several companies work (Article L. 4532-2 of the Labour Code). An accident caused by the employer's inexcusable fault (faute inexcusable) gives entitlement to additional compensation (Article L. 452-1 of the French Social Security Code (Code de la sécurité sociale)).
The duty of vigilance has limits, which the Cour de cassation has spelt out in the project owner's favour: “for the purposes of Article L. 8222-1 of the Labour Code, the project owner is not subject to a duty of vigilance with regard to its contracting partner's subcontractor” (our translation). It quashed the judgment that had upheld URSSAF's formal notices, since the main contractor, the project owner's only contracting partner, had not been the subject of an official report for undeclared work (Cass. 2e civ., 4 September 2025, No. 23-14.121). The ruling is specific to that configuration: towards its own contracting partner, the duty of vigilance still applies.
Sham subcontracting is costly for the company that organises it. In a construction site case, the trial judges had found that the subcontractors' employees worked under the authority of the principal's site management, which thereby made savings, in particular by avoiding the use of temporary agency work. The Criminal Division quashed the judgment only as regards the conviction for the offence under Article L. 8271-1-1 of the Labour Code, found on the basis that the project owner had not accepted the subcontractors, on the ground that this offence “cannot be made out in a situation of fictitious subcontracting” (our translation), and as regards the sentences, which were sent back to the court of appeal; the convictions for undeclared work, unlawful hiring-out of labour and marchandage were maintained (Cass. crim., 5 September 2023, No. 22-84.400).
Inexcusable fault is found “where the employer was or should have been aware of the danger to which the worker was exposed and did not take the measures necessary to protect the worker from it” (our translation); the Cour de cassation so held in the case of an employee who fell while reaching a terrace, when the building's safety plan “did not provide for the means of access to the terraces” (our translation). The court of appeal had found that the employee had chosen a dangerous means of access of his own accord; its judgment was quashed (Cass. 2e civ., 9 January 2025, No. 22-24.167).
Related pages of the firm: URSSAF reassessments for undeclared work, the principal's joint financial liability, criminal defence in undeclared work cases and the employer's inexcusable fault. See also our article on the vigilance certificate and joint financial liability.
Going further
The firm's construction pages, and companies in financial difficulty
Each subject has its own detailed page; insolvency proceedings against a client or a contractor also change the rules on debt recovery.
Construction law and building defects lawyer: defective work, delays, court-appointed expert assessments and builders' liability, for project owners and professionals alike.
Abandoned works lawyer: official findings (constat), formal notice, termination and completion of the works by another contractor when the original one stops turning up.
Lawyer for unlawful supply of labour cases: defence of companies prosecuted for unlawful supply of labour (marchandage) or unlawful hiring-out of labour, and the rights of the employee concerned.
Legal assistance with acceptance of the works and ten-year builder's liability (garantie décennale): acceptance report, reservations, court-ordered acceptance, claims and insurance.
Lawyer for companies in difficulty and judicial reorganisation lawyer: for a building company that can no longer meet its debts, or for the creditor of a defaulting client.
The judgment opening insolvency proceedings interrupts or prohibits claims for payment by prior creditors (Article L. 622-21 of the French Commercial Code (Code de commerce)), who must file a proof of claim with the creditors' representative (mandataire judiciaire) within the time limits set by regulation, even if they hold no enforceable title and, where the amount has not been fixed, on the basis of an estimate (Article L. 622-24 of the Commercial Code). Proceedings already under way can then only seek a finding that the claim exists and a determination of its amount (Article L. 622-22 of the Commercial Code): in the 2018 judgment on the payment guarantee, the Cour de cassation quashed the order for payment made in favour of the architect, whose action was pending on the date of the opening judgment, and entered the architect's claim in the debtor's liabilities (Cass. com., 10 October 2018, No. 17-18.547). See our page on filing a proof of claim (déclaration de créance).
The subcontractor keeps a route of its own. Article 12 of the Law of 31 December 1975, drafted with names of procedures that the Commercial Code no longer uses, provides that “This direct action remains available even if the main contractor is in liquidation of assets (liquidation des biens), judicial settlement (règlement judiciaire) or provisional stay of proceedings (suspension provisoire des poursuites)” (Article 12, our translation): the subcontractor claims from the project owner, up to what the latter still owes, what the main contractor can no longer pay. See also our page on judicial liquidation.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What does a construction lawyer do for a building contractor?
The lawyer acts before, during and after the works. Beforehand, they review or draft the works contract, a contract for work within the meaning of Article 1779 of the Civil Code, and the subcontracts: fixed price or price on estimate, written instructions, payment guarantee, retention, penalties, termination. They check that each subcontractor can be accepted and that its payment will be secured by a guarantee or a delegation of payment, on pain of nullity of the subcontract (Article 14 of the Law of 31 December 1975); the Cour de cassation requires the guarantee to be provided before the subcontract is concluded, or before performance starts if that happens first (Cass. 3e civ., 21 January 2021, No. 19-22.219).
During the works, they deal with unpaid progress invoices (situations de travaux), requests for a payment guarantee and suspension of the works (Article 1799-1 of the Civil Code), extra works, delays and penalties, and inspections by the labour inspectorate or URSSAF. Afterwards, they organise acceptance, the lifting of reservations, the release of the retention and the defence against a claim falling under the ten-year liability (Article 1792 of the Civil Code).
The firm acts in the same way for project owners, whether professionals or private individuals, and for subcontractors. It decides with the client between negotiation, formal notice, an urgent application (référé) and an action on the merits, before the court determined by the contract and the status of the parties.
Our client is not paying our progress invoices: what can we do?
Start with the payment guarantee. Under a private works contract, the project owner must guarantee payment to the contractor where the sums due exceed €12,000 excl. VAT, after deducting deposits and advance payments made when the contract was concluded (Article 1799-1 of the Civil Code and Article 1 of Decree No. 99-658 of 30 July 1999). As long as no guarantee has been provided and the contractor remains unpaid, it may suspend performance of the contract after a formal notice, sent by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt, that has gone unheeded for fifteen days. The guarantee and this right to suspend do not apply where the project owner enters into the contract on its own account and for purposes unrelated to a professional activity connected with the contract.
The guarantee must be capable of being called on: the Cour de cassation holds that the guarantee securing payment of the sums due under the contract must not be subject to any condition that limits its enforcement (Cass. 3e civ., 4 March 2021, No. 19-25.964). The Commercial Code also caps the payment period agreed between the parties at sixty days after the invoice is issued, or forty-five days end of month if the contract expressly so provides without manifest abuse towards the creditor, and makes late-payment penalties payable from the day after the payment date shown on the invoice (Article L. 441-10 of the Commercial Code, in force on 31 October 2026, with a deferred repeal on 1 January 2027 recorded on Légifrance).
The time limit for bringing a claim depends on the client: five years from the day on which the creditor knew or should have known the facts enabling it to act, as a general rule (Article 2224 of the Civil Code), but two years where the contractor claims the price of its services from a consumer (Article L. 218-2 of the French Consumer Code (Code de la consommation)). The firm sends the formal notice, requests the guarantee, then brings the claim for payment best suited to the amount and the documents.
Retention money in France: how much, and when is it released?
Under a private works contract, interim payments may be reduced by a retention of at most 5% of their amount, which guarantees performance of the works needed to satisfy the reservations made at acceptance. The project owner must deposit an equal sum with an escrow agent accepted by both parties or appointed by the president of the court, and no retention is made if the contractor provides a joint and several personal guarantee from a financial institution for the same amount (Article 1 of the Law of 16 July 1971).
When one year has passed from acceptance, with or without reservations, the guarantor is released or the sums held in escrow are paid to the contractor, even without a formal release (mainlevée), if the project owner has not notified, by registered letter, its objection on the ground that the contractor has failed to perform its obligations; an abusive objection exposes the owner to damages (Article 2 of the Law of 16 July 1971).
The rule also works for the project owner. The Cour de cassation holds that this period “cannot start to run before the date of acceptance” (our translation), whether acceptance is by agreement, tacit or ordered by the court, and it upheld the court of appeal's decision granting the project owner's claim for payment against a contractor's guarantor bank, as the cost of lifting the reservations exceeded the amount of the guarantee (Cass. 3e civ., 11 January 2023, No. 21-11.053). In public contracts, the retention may not exceed 5%, or 3% for certain small and medium-sized enterprises, and is repaid within thirty days of the end of the guarantee period (Article R. 2191-33 of the Public Procurement Code and Article R. 2191-35 of the Public Procurement Code).
Unpaid subcontractor: how do you get paid by the project owner?
Through the direct action. The subcontractor has a direct action against the project owner if the main contractor fails to pay, one month after being given formal notice, the sums due under the subcontract; a copy of the formal notice is sent to the project owner, and any waiver of the direct action is deemed unwritten (Article 12 of the Law of 31 December 1975). It only covers work provided for in the subcontract from which the project owner benefits, up to what it still owes the main contractor when it receives the copy of the formal notice (Article 13 of the Law of 31 December 1975).
The Montpellier Court of Appeal points out that the subcontractor “may obtain payment of its claim out of the sums the project owner still owes the main contractor under the main contract, even if those sums relate to work other than that carried out by the subcontractor” (CA Montpellier, 3e ch. civ., 8 October 2026, No. 25/05905, our translation). The formal notice and its copy must therefore be sent without delay: every payment made to the main contractor before the copy is received reduces the amount the claim can reach.
If the project owner knew you were on site without giving the main contractor formal notice to present you, or did not require the guarantee, its liability may be engaged (Article 14-1 of the Law of 31 December 1975), but the loss is not measured in the same way in the two cases. For an unpresented subcontractor, the Cour de cassation holds that it “is assessed in the light of what the project owner still owed the main contractor on the date on which it became aware of the subcontractor's presence on the site, or of the sums paid to the main contractor after that date” (our translation). For an approved subcontractor deprived of a guarantee, it equals the difference between what it should have received with a guarantee or a delegation of payment and what it actually received (Cass. 3e civ., 7 March 2024, No. 22-23.309).
As a project owner, what are your obligations towards the contractor's subcontractors?
In building and public works, the project owner has two obligations. If it becomes aware that a subcontractor who has not been presented is working on site, it must give the main contractor or the subcontractor formal notice to fulfil their obligations. If the accepted and approved subcontractor does not benefit from a delegation of payment, it must require the main contractor to prove that it has provided the guarantee (Article 14-1 of the Law of 31 December 1975). These rules do not apply to an individual who builds a home to live in themselves or to house their family.
Failure carries a cost. For the Cour de cassation, a project owner that knew of the subcontractor and refrained from giving the main contractor formal notice to present it deprives the subcontractor of the benefit of the direct action; it is liable up to what it still owed the main contractor on the day it learned of the subcontractor's presence, or for the sums paid afterwards. Where the approved subcontractor has no guarantee, “the recoverable loss is then equal to the difference between the sums the subcontractor should have received had it been granted a delegation of payment or had a financial institution guaranteed its contract, and the sums actually received” (Cass. 3e civ., 7 March 2024, No. 22-23.309, our translation). In September 2026, it overturned a judgment that had limited a subcontractor's compensation without ascertaining whether the extra works had been entrusted to it for the performance of the main contract (Cass. 3e civ., 3 September 2026, No. 24-15.620).
The firm helps project owners keep a register of the subcontractors on site, require the special acceptance forms (actes spéciaux) and guarantees, and defend themselves when a subcontractor brings a claim against them after the main contractor defaults.
Can delay penalties be challenged?
Yes, on several grounds. A delay penalty in a works contract is a clause under which the party that fails to perform will pay a certain sum; the judge may, even of their own motion, reduce it if it is manifestly excessive, or reduce it in proportion to the benefit that partial performance has brought the creditor, and any stipulation to the contrary is deemed unwritten (Article 1231-5 of the Civil Code). The same article adds that, save in the case of definitive non-performance, the penalty is only incurred once the debtor has been given formal notice: a penalty applied without formal notice can be challenged.
The challenge then turns on the facts: the contractual completion date, written instructions that pushed it back, bad weather, extra works ordered during the works, delay attributable to another contractor or to the project owner itself. The number of days of delay is reconstructed from the site meeting minutes and the correspondence.
For the project owner, the penalty remains the simplest tool, provided the clause is clear and formal notice is given. It may also terminate the fixed-price contract unilaterally, but must then compensate the contractor for all its expenses, its work and the profit it could have made (Article 1794 of the Civil Code). See our page on abandoned works when the contractor stops turning up.
Are extra works payable under a fixed-price contract?
Not without agreement. A contractor who has undertaken to build a building for a fixed price, on the basis of a plan settled and agreed with the owner, cannot claim any price increase for changes to or extensions of that plan unless they were authorised in writing and the price agreed with the owner (Article 1793 of the Civil Code).
The Cour de cassation applies this text strictly, to the contractor's detriment: the contractor “may claim payment for extra works only if those works were authorised in advance in writing and their price agreed in advance with the project owner, or if the latter accepted them expressly and unequivocally once they had been carried out” (our translation). It adds that “in a fixed-price contract, the project owner's silence on receiving the contractor's final statement of account, or its failure to follow the procedure for closing the accounts, does not amount to express and unequivocal acceptance of the extra works for which the contractor claims payment” (our translation), even where the contract refers to the final-account procedure of the NF P 03-001 standard (Cass. 3e civ., 8 June 2023, No. 22-10.393).
The contractor should therefore have a priced written instruction or contract amendment signed before carrying out the work. Failing that, it remains to be shown that the contract was not a fixed-price contract, or that the project owner accepted the works, once carried out, expressly and unequivocally. The firm analyses how the contract is classified before any costing.
Why should a contractor ask for acceptance of the works?
Because the final balance of the job depends on it. Acceptance is the act by which the project owner declares that it accepts the work, with or without reservations; it takes place at the request of the more diligent party, by agreement or, failing that, by court order, and both parties must always be given the opportunity to participate (Article 1792-6 of the Civil Code). The contractor can therefore initiate it. One year after acceptance, with or without reservations, the guarantee replacing the retention is released, or the sums held in escrow are paid to the contractor, if the project owner has not notified a reasoned objection by registered letter (Article 2 of the Law of 16 July 1971).
It can be tacit. The Cour de cassation holds that “taking possession of the work and paying for the works create a presumption of the project owner's unequivocal intention to accept it, with or without reservations” (Cass. 3e civ., 1 April 2021, No. 19-25.563, our translation). The date then depends on the evidence: in that case, since the handing over of the cheque for the balance could not be dated, acceptance was fixed on the day it was cashed. A dated and signed acceptance report, with the list of reservations, avoids this debate.
Acceptance also starts the statutory guarantees, including the ten-year liability, which expires ten years after it (Article 1792-4-1 of the Civil Code). Their rules, defective work and expert assessments are covered on our acceptance of the works and construction law pages.
Ten-year (decennial) liability insurance: what must a building contractor prove?
Any natural or legal person whose ten-year liability may be incurred under Article 1792 et seq. of the Civil Code must be covered by insurance, and must prove they hold it when any site opens; a bidder for a public contract must be able to provide that proof (Article L. 241-1 of the Insurance Code). The following are deemed builders: the architect, contractor, technician or any other person bound to the project owner by a contract for work, anyone who sells, after completion, a structure they built or had built, and the owner's agent who performs a task comparable to that of a contractor (Article 1792-1 of the Civil Code).
Failure to take out insurance may expose the company's director to personal civil liability. In a case where the manager had failed both to enter into an individual house-building contract and to take out the insurance, the Cour de cassation overturned the judgment that had not examined whether he had committed “faults separable from his duties as a company officer, engaging his personal liability, by failing to enter into an individual house-building contract and to take out ten-year liability insurance” (Cass. 3e civ., 7 June 2018, No. 16-27.680, our translation).
Classification of the defects, calling on the guarantees and claims against the insurer are covered on our ten-year builder's liability (garantie décennale) and construction law pages, and in our article on the tradesman's ten-year liability insurance certificate.
Our subcontractor used undeclared workers: are we liable?
That depends on the checks you made. For any contract worth at least €5,000 excl. VAT, the principal must check, when the contract is concluded and then periodically until performance ends, that its contracting partner is registered and is filing its social security and tax returns (Article L. 8222-1 of the Labour Code and Article R. 8222-1 of the Labour Code). It is deemed to have done so if it obtains, at the outset and then every six months, a certificate from the contributions collection body that is less than six months old, whose authenticity it checks, and an extract from the business register (Article D. 8222-5 of the Labour Code).
Otherwise, and if an official report for undeclared work is drawn up against the contracting partner, the principal is jointly and severally liable for taxes, contributions, penalties and surcharges, the repayment of public aid and the wages due (Article L. 8222-2 of the Labour Code), in proportion to the value of the work (Article L. 8222-3 of the Labour Code). Knowingly using the services of someone engaged in undeclared work is also a criminal offence (Article L. 8221-1 of the Labour Code and Article L. 8224-1 of the Labour Code).
The duty of vigilance under Article L. 8222-1 does not extend to your contracting partner's subcontractor: the Cour de cassation holds that “for the purposes of Article L. 8222-1 of the Labour Code, the project owner is not subject to a duty of vigilance with regard to its contracting partner's subcontractor” (Cass. 2e civ., 4 September 2025, No. 23-14.121, our translation). On the other hand, a project owner informed in writing, in particular by an inspector, of the irregular situation of a subcontractor or a sub-delegate must immediately require its contracting partner to put an end to it, failing which it becomes jointly liable (Article L. 8222-5 of the Labour Code). The firm challenges the reassessment where the conditions are not met. See our page on joint financial liability towards URSSAF.
A worker was injured on site: what does the company risk?
A workplace accident is first covered by the social security system. But where it is due to the inexcusable fault of the employer or of those to whom it has delegated management authority, the victim or their dependants are entitled to additional compensation (Article L. 452-1 of the Social Security Code), which is borne by the company. The employer must take the measures necessary to ensure workers' safety, through prevention, information and appropriate organisation (Article L. 4121-1 of the Labour Code), and safety coordination is required as soon as several companies work on the site (Article L. 4532-2 of the Labour Code).
The Cour de cassation finds inexcusable fault “where the employer was or should have been aware of the danger to which the worker was exposed and did not take the measures necessary to protect the worker from it” (our translation). It quashed, to the employer's detriment, a judgment that had ruled it out for an employee who fell while reaching a terrace from outside the building, when the building's safety plan “did not provide for the means of access to the terraces” (Cass. 2e civ., 9 January 2025, No. 22-24.167, our translation).
The victim's rights to the benefits and compensation in Book IV of the Social Security Code, which contains Article L. 452-1, are time-barred after two years from, in particular, the day of the accident or the end of the payment of daily allowances (Article L. 431-2 of the Social Security Code). The firm assists the company during the investigation, before the social security division of the court (pôle social) and, where necessary, before the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel). See our page on the employer's inexcusable fault.
The client or the main contractor is in judicial reorganisation or liquidation: what happens to the debt?
The opening judgment interrupts or prohibits any action by prior creditors seeking an order for the debtor to pay a sum of money or the termination of a contract for non-payment, and it halts enforcement proceedings (Article L. 622-21 of the Commercial Code). The creditor company must file a proof of claim with the creditors' representative within the time limits set by decree, even if it holds no enforceable title, and on the basis of an estimate if the amount has not yet been fixed (Article L. 622-24 of the Commercial Code). Proceedings already under way on the date of the opening judgment are interrupted until the claim has been filed, then resumed solely to establish the claim and fix its amount (Article L. 622-22 of the Commercial Code): applying that provision, the Cour de cassation quashed the order to pay made against an association in judicial reorganisation and entered its architect's claim in the liabilities (Cass. com., 10 October 2018, No. 17-18.547).
The same judgment protects the contractor that had suspended work before the proceedings opened, for lack of a payment guarantee: “the opening of insolvency proceedings cannot have the effect of forcing a contractor who, before those proceedings were opened, duly gave notice that it was suspending performance of its works, to resume them without obtaining the financial guarantee laid down by Article 1799-1 of the Civil Code” (our translation).
The defaulting contractor's subcontractor keeps its direct action against the project owner: Article 12 of the 1975 Law maintains it where the main contractor is in “liquidation of assets (liquidation des biens), judicial settlement (règlement judiciaire) or provisional stay of proceedings (suspension provisoire des poursuites)” (our translation), names of procedures that the Commercial Code no longer uses (Article 12 of the Law of 31 December 1975), up to what the project owner still owes (Article 13 of the Law of 31 December 1975). See our pages on filing a proof of claim and judicial reorganisation.
Public works contracts: what are the payment rules?
The Public Procurement Code sets the payment period at thirty days for contracting authorities (Article R. 2192-10 of the Public Procurement Code), subject to exceptions: fifty days for public health establishments and those of the armed forces health service, sixty days for certain public undertakings (Article R. 2192-11 of the Public Procurement Code). The retention only covers the reservations made at acceptance and, where applicable, during the guarantee period (Article R. 2191-32 of the Public Procurement Code); it may not exceed 5% of the initial value plus any amendments, or 3% for certain small and medium-sized enterprises (Article R. 2191-33 of the Public Procurement Code), and it is repaid within thirty days of the end of the guarantee period (Article R. 2191-35 of the Public Procurement Code).
The contract holder's direct subcontractor, once accepted and with its payment terms approved by the public buyer, is paid directly by the buyer for the part of the contract it performs (Article L. 2193-11 of the Public Procurement Code); the subcontracting declaration submitted with the bid states, among other things, the maximum amount and the payment terms (Article R. 2193-1 of the Public Procurement Code). The payment request first goes through the contract holder, which has fifteen days to accept or refuse it (Article R. 2193-12 of the Public Procurement Code).
The Council of State, ruling under the former public procurement code, whose procedure the Public Procurement Code carries over, holds that “Failure by the subcontractor to comply with it thus prevents it from asserting a right to that payment against the project owner” (our translation). The contract holder's reasoned refusal, notified within the fifteen-day period, “likewise prevents the subcontractor from asserting a right to that payment against the project owner” (our translation): that is what was decided, against a subcontractor that had nonetheless applied to the contract holder (CE, 17 October 2023, No. 469071). The firm prepares payment requests and claims, and brings the matter before the administrative court when the public buyer does not pay.
How much does a construction lawyer charge?
Fees are set out in a written fee agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours a fixed fee per stage: review or drafting of a works contract or subcontract, formal notice and request for a payment guarantee, a subcontractor's direct action, challenge to penalties, assistance at acceptance, defence before URSSAF or the social security division of the court, proof of claim, proceedings on the merits, appeal. Expert fees, judicial officer (commissaire de justice) fees and court costs are added to the fees. Any new engagement is covered by an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected invoicing.
For a company with a continuous flow of sites, an ongoing support engagement can cover reviewing works contracts and subcontracts, monitoring retentions and guarantees, and the first formal notices, for a fixed fee set in advance in the agreement.
For a first opinion on the documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, requested through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. For a first conversation: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related practice areas.
Official texts
- Articles 1779, 1793, 1794 and 1799-1 of the Civil Code: contract for work, fixed price, termination, payment guarantee
- Article 1 of Decree No. 99-658 of 30 July 1999: €12,000 threshold and the formal notice under Article 1799-1
- Articles 1231-5, 2224 of the Civil Code and L. 218-2 of the Consumer Code: penalty clause, limitation periods
- Articles 1792, 1792-1, 1792-2, 1792-3, 1792-4-1, 1792-4-3 and 1792-6 of the Civil Code: builders' liability, guarantees, acceptance
- Articles 1, 3, 12, 13, 14, 14-1 and 15 of Law No. 75-1334 of 31 December 1975: subcontracting
- Articles 1 and 2 of Law No. 71-584 of 16 July 1971: retention
- Articles L. 241-1 and L. 242-1 of the Insurance Code: ten-year liability insurance, building damage insurance (dommages-ouvrage)
- Articles L. 8221-1, L. 8221-3, L. 8221-5 and L. 8224-1 of the Labour Code: undeclared work
- Articles L. 8222-1, L. 8222-2, L. 8222-3, L. 8222-5, R. 8222-1 and D. 8222-5 of the Labour Code: duty of vigilance and joint financial liability
- Articles L. 8231-1, L. 8241-1 and L. 8243-1 of the Labour Code: marchandage, unlawful hiring-out of labour
- Articles L. 4121-1 and L. 4532-2 of the Labour Code, L. 452-1 and L. 431-2 of the Social Security Code: safety, inexcusable fault, limitation period
- Articles L. 2193-2, L. 2193-11, R. 2191-32, R. 2191-33, R. 2191-35, R. 2192-10, R. 2192-11, R. 2193-1, R. 2193-11, R. 2193-12 and R. 2193-13 of the Public Procurement Code: public contracts
- Articles L. 441-10, L. 622-21, L. 622-22 and L. 622-24 of the Commercial Code: payment periods, insolvency proceedings
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. 3e civ., 8 June 2023, No. 22-10.393: extra works under a fixed-price contract
- Cass. 3e civ., 4 March 2021, No. 19-25.964: guarantee under Article 1799-1 without conditions
- Cass. com., 10 October 2018, No. 17-18.547: suspension of works and insolvency proceedings against the project owner
- Cass. 3e civ., 11 January 2023, No. 21-11.053: starting point for the release of the retention
- Cass. 3e civ., 7 March 2024, No. 22-23.309: project owner's failings towards the subcontractor
- Cass. 3e civ., 3 September 2026, No. 24-15.620: subcontractor and extra works
- Cass. 3e civ., 21 January 2021, No. 19-22.219: guarantee provided after the subcontract
- CA Montpellier, 3e ch. civ., 8 October 2026, No. 25/05905: basis of the direct action
- CE, 17 October 2023, No. 469071: direct payment procedure in public contracts
- Cass. 3e civ., 1 April 2021, No. 19-25.563: tacit acceptance
- Cass. 3e civ., 7 June 2018, No. 16-27.680: company director and failure to take out ten-year liability insurance
- Cass. 2e civ., 4 September 2025, No. 23-14.121: project owner's duty of vigilance
- Cass. crim., 5 September 2023, No. 22-84.400: sham subcontracting, unlawful hiring-out of labour and marchandage
- Cass. 2e civ., 9 January 2025, No. 22-24.167: inexcusable fault, fall on a construction site
Further reading
A construction dispute: unpaid works, a subcontractor to pay, a defect to remedy?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the contract or subcontract, the progress invoices and bills, the written instructions, the acceptance report and the relevant correspondence. Hassan Kohen examines the clauses, guarantees and time limits, then tells you the appropriate route: formal notice, request for a payment guarantee, direct action, challenge to penalties, court-ordered acceptance, defence before URSSAF or proceedings before the court.