In the media
Watch the videos and their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, blockchain and tokenisation lawyers in Paris
Blockchain lawyer in Paris: smart contracts, tokens, proof, disputes
Classifying a token, drafting and legally auditing smart contracts, tokenising financial securities, governing a DAO, proving prior existence on a distributed ledger, ownership of code, GDPR compliance, a frozen wallet or withheld keys: as blockchain lawyers in Paris, the firm assists blockchain project founders, their developers, investors and users, both in advisory work and before the courts. Everything starts from what the ledger actually contains, and from who is answerable for it.
The firm can be reached 24/7. A contractual claim arising from a defective smart contract is in principle time-barred after five years from the day on which the holder knew or should have known the facts enabling them to bring it (Article 2224 of the French Civil Code (Code civil), and Article L. 110-4 of the French Commercial Code (Code de commerce) for obligations arising between traders or between traders and non-traders); where tokens or access rights are withheld, the urgent applications judge (juge des référés) may order the performance of an obligation to do something that is not seriously disputable (Articles 835 and 873 of the French Code of Civil Procedure (Code de procédure civile)).
4,9/5
Average Google review rating270 reviews
I received very high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice adapted to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective criminal defence.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer, he got me out of trouble in a protection order (ordonnance de protection) that my ex had sought abusively
Very satisfied with the outcome achieved in my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, shows great empathy and strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen to me carefully and to understand my situation properly. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, and who knows how to point his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Emergencies 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Avocat at the Paris Bar, blockchain projects: smart contracts, tokenisation, ownership of code, personal data and token disputes.
Official profile in the national directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
Blockchain is a distributed ledger, which Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 defines as an information repository shared and synchronised between nodes by means of a consensus mechanism. The applicable law depends on what is recorded on it. A token representing a financial security remains subject to the French Monetary and Financial Code (Code monétaire et financier), which allows securities that are not admitted to the operations of a central securities depository to be registered using distributed ledger technology (Articles L. 211-3 and L. 211-7). An ordinary crypto-asset falls under the MiCA Regulation, but a unique, non-fungible token does not. A smart contract is a program: the contract is the agreement of the parties, governed by the French Civil Code (Articles 1101 and 1128), and a bug can make liable the party who was supposed to deliver reliable code (Article 1231-1). An unregistered DAO has no legal personality (Articles 1842 and 1871). A blockchain record is admissible evidence, except where the law requires a written document (Article 1358 of the Civil Code; Article 45 duodecies of the amended eIDAS Regulation); it dates a file without proving its originality. Protocol code is software protected by copyright if it is original (Article L. 112-2 of the French Intellectual Property Code (Code de la propriété intellectuelle)); if written by an outside contractor, it remains the contractor's property unless assigned in writing. Kohen Avocats, in Paris 16th arrondissement, acts for project founders as well as investors and users. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A smart contract to audit, tokens to issue, a frozen wallet?
Understanding your situation
Blockchain law in Paris, explained
A distributed ledger does not create a separate body of law: it carries contracts, securities, evidence and data, each of which follows its own rules, to the point where it can stand in for a securities account (Article L. 211-3 of the French Monetary and Financial Code). How to classify the project, secure the smart contract, tokenise an asset, structure a DAO, prove facts through the blockchain, protect the code and comply with the GDPR.
Key points
Classify the project before writing a line of code
The technology is the same; the legal regime depends on what the token represents.
Identify the ledger. The MiCA Regulation defines a distributed ledger as "an information repository that keeps records of transactions and that is shared across, and synchronised between, a set of DLT network nodes using a consensus mechanism" (Article 3(1), point 2), of Regulation (EU) 2023/1114). Public, permissioned or private blockchain: the choice affects governance, liability and personal data.
Is the token a financial instrument? Equity securities issued by joint-stock companies, debt securities and units in collective investment undertakings are financial securities (Article L. 211-1 of the French Monetary and Financial Code). A token with those characteristics remains subject to that regime, and MiCA does not apply to crypto-assets that qualify as financial instruments (Article 2(4)(a) of the MiCA Regulation).
Is the token unique? MiCA "does not apply to crypto-assets that are unique and not fungible with other crypto-assets" (Article 2(3)). According to recital 11 of the Regulation, issuance in a large series or collection is, on the contrary, an indicator of fungibility; classification is checked token by token. NFTs have their own page: NFT lawyer.
Outside these cases, and subject to the other exclusions in Article 2 of the Regulation, it is a crypto-asset within the meaning of MiCA, to which the French Monetary and Financial Code refers (Article L. 54-10-1). If it is neither an asset-referenced token nor an e-money token, its offer to the public or admission to trading follows Title II of the Regulation, with notification to the AMF, the French financial markets authority (Articles L. 552-1 and L. 552-2): white papers and token offerings are covered on our MiCA lawyer page.
This classification governs everything else: the applicable law, the competent authority, the form of the contracts, taxation and the competent court. The firm carries it out on the basis of the white paper, the articles of association, the code and the terms and conditions, not the name given to the token. For crypto-asset service provider authorisation, disputes with a platform and taxation of capital gains, see our crypto and fintech lawyer page.
The user's status also matters. The Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) upheld a court of appeal that kept consumer status for an individual who had opened a cryptocurrency wallet, even though he had sat on a foundation dedicated to blockchain technology and carried out some 200 transactions in nine months: "the profit made falls within the management of a private estate" (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 28 June 2023, No. 22-12.424). He could therefore sue the foreign provider before the court of his place of residence.
The transparency of the ledger works both ways. In criminal proceedings, the investigating chamber (chambre de l'instruction) found that "the blockchain transaction involving the Coinbase account of Mr [J] [E] established that approximately 5.54 bitcoins had been received by that account" (our translation) from a suspect identifier, and the Court of Cassation upheld the seizure of the assets (Cass. crim., 15 February 2023, No. 22-81.326). Criminal matters are covered on our page on cryptocurrency theft and in our article on cryptocurrency money laundering.
Contracts
Smart contracts: the code executes, the contract binds
A self-executing program does not replace the parties' agreement; it applies it.
Agreement
A contract is a meeting of minds intended to create, modify, transfer or extinguish obligations (Article 1101 of the French Civil Code). Its validity requires the consent of the parties, their capacity and lawful and certain content (Article 1128). The smart contract is the instrument by which it is performed, not its source.
Terms
The terms and conditions of a protocol or platform are binding on the user only if they were brought to the user's attention and accepted (Article 1119). In a standard-form contract (contrat d'adhésion), a non-negotiable clause that creates a significant imbalance is deemed unwritten (Article 1171). However, the Court of Cassation, in the light of the parliamentary debates, concludes that this provision does not apply "to contracts concluded by a person carrying out production, distribution or service activities" (our translation): it is then Article L. 442-1 of the French Commercial Code that sanctions the significant imbalance, unless another provision excludes its application (Cass. com., 13 May 2026, No. 24-17.137). Where a consumer is involved, unfair terms fall under Article L. 212-1 of the French Consumer Code.
Information
A party who knows information that is decisive for the other party's consent must disclose it where the other party is legitimately unaware of it or relies on its contracting partner; a breach can lead to the contract being annulled (Article 1112-1). The white paper and the technical documentation fall within this scope.
Interpretation
A contract is interpreted according to the common intention of the parties rather than the literal meaning of its terms (Article 1188). Where the code does something other than what the parties intended, the agreement prevails.
Non-performance
The creditor of an unperformed obligation may refuse to perform its own, seek specific performance, obtain a price reduction, terminate the contract or claim damages (Article 1217); the debtor owes damages unless there is force majeure (Article 1231-1).
Time limit
Five years from the day on which the holder knew or should have known the facts enabling them to act (Article 2224), and also five years for obligations arising between traders or between traders and non-traders (Article L. 110-4 of the French Commercial Code).
The Tours commercial court (tribunal de commerce) ruled on a dispute arising from a bug during the launch of an NFT collection. The development studio, responsible for the smart contract, had had to suspend the sale for nearly two hours. The court found that "the error in the computer program of the smart contract is therefore obvious, acknowledged by its developers" (our translation). It added that, for this type of service, "if the obligation to achieve a result is not addressed in the contract, it is implicit for this activity" (our translation). But the client was not exonerated: in the absence of contract review, testing and audit, "the parties were led to set aside checks, tests and in particular the audit of the smart contract" (our translation), and liability was split equally (TC Tours, 21 February 2025, No. J2024000005).
The lesson is contractual. A blockchain project needs a written agreement describing the deliverable, testing, the security audit, the timetable, acceptance, the allocation of risk and ownership of the code. The firm drafts and negotiates these development, audit and partnership agreements, and reviews the protocol's terms and conditions.
Ordinary IT contracts (licence, SaaS, maintenance, integration) have their own page: IT contracts lawyer. Disputes over the non-performance of a software project are covered on our IT disputes lawyer page.
Structuring
Tokenising an asset, organising a DAO
A distributed ledger can stand in for a securities account; it does not create a legal entity.
Financial securities issued in France are registered in a securities account or, in the cases provided for by Article L. 211-7, by means of distributed ledger technology: "Registration by means of distributed ledger technology takes the place of registration in an account" (Article L. 211-3 of the French Monetary and Financial Code).
Securities that are not admitted to the operations of a central securities depository are registered in the owner's name in an account kept by the issuer or, if the issuer so decides, on a distributed ledger (Article L. 211-7). They then take registered form (Article R. 211-2).
The system must be designed to "guarantee the recording and integrity of the entries" and to make it possible to identify the owners, the nature and the number of securities, with a business continuity plan and periodic external storage of the data (Article R. 211-9-7).
Securities are transferred by entry in the ledger (Article L. 211-15), and the transfer of ownership results "from the registration of these securities in favour of the acquirer by means of distributed ledger technology" (Article L. 211-17).
Securities admitted to the operations of a DLT market infrastructure are recorded on a distributed ledger either under the ordinary conditions of Article L. 211-7 or under those of the pilot regime of Regulation (EU) 2022/858.
Tokenising an asset other than a financial security (a receivable, a right of use, a physical asset) is classified separately: a crypto-asset within the meaning of MiCA, a unique non-fungible token, or a mere contractual right.
A DAO, a decentralised autonomous organisation, has no specific status in French law. Companies, other than undisclosed partnerships (sociétés en participation), "have legal personality from the date of their registration" (Article 1842 of the French Civil Code). Without registration, an undisclosed partnership "is not a legal person" and may be proved by any means (Article 1871), and "Each partner contracts in their own name and is alone bound towards third parties"; if the participants act as partners in full view of third parties, each is bound by the acts of the others, jointly and severally if the partnership is commercial (Article 1872-1).
The courts apply these rules to unregistered groupings, provided the elements of a company are present: persons who agree to allocate property or their work to a common undertaking with a view to sharing the profit or benefiting from any savings that may result (Article 1832 of the French Civil Code). The Court of Cassation holds that an unregistered grouping of this kind (in that case, an AARPI, an association of lawyers) is a de facto company (société créée de fait) governed by the rules on undisclosed partnerships, and that, "since the AARPI is not a legal person, no claim could be brought against it" (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 8 March 2023, No. 20-16.475). The Tours commercial court held that a blockchain studio not yet registered, presented publicly as a business, "is indeed a de facto company and its partners are, to all appearances, its contacts" (our translation), and declared its four partners jointly and severally liable (TC Tours, 21 February 2025, No. J2024000005).
For a DAO, the issue is therefore to back the community with a legal structure: a company, association or foundation, depending on its purpose and funding, with articles of association and a shareholders' agreement that link on-chain votes with corporate decisions. Persons acting on behalf of a company being formed are bound by the acts performed, unless the company takes them over after registration (Article L. 210-6 of the French Commercial Code), and the Court of Cassation now leaves it to the court to determine whether the act was concluded in the name or on behalf of the company being formed (Cass. com., 29 November 2023, No. 22-12.865). See our pages company formation lawyer, shareholders' agreement lawyer and startup lawyer.
Evidence and creation
Proving through the blockchain, protecting the code
The ledger dates and freezes; it does not say who the author is, nor whether the work is original.
Proving through the blockchain
- Except where the law provides otherwise, evidence may be adduced by any means (Article 1358 of the French Civil Code), and between traders, commercial acts may be proved by any means (Article L. 110-3 of the French Commercial Code).
- An electronic ledger may not be rejected as evidence solely because it is in electronic form; records in a qualified electronic ledger enjoy a presumption of their unique and accurate sequential chronological ordering and of their integrity (Article 45 duodecies of the amended eIDAS Regulation).
- A legal act above the threshold set by decree must be proved in writing (Article 1359); an electronic document has the same value as a paper one if its author can be identified and its integrity is guaranteed (Article 1366).
Protecting the code
- Software, including preparatory design material, is a work of the mind (Article L. 112-2, 13°, of the French Intellectual Property Code).
- The economic rights in software created by an employee in the course of their duties vest in the employer (Article L. 113-9); those of an outside contractor pass to the client only through a detailed written assignment (Articles L. 131-2 and L. 131-3).
- Reproducing, modifying or placing software on the market without authorisation is infringement (Articles L. 122-6 and L. 335-3).
An electronic time stamp may not be denied legal effect solely because of its form, and a qualified time stamp "shall enjoy the presumption of the accuracy of the date and the time it indicates" (Article 41 of Regulation (EU) No 910/2014 as amended). Time stamping also helps establish the date and attribution of an electronic signature: the Aix-en-Provence court of appeal, applying the presumption of reliability under Article 1367 of the French Civil Code and the decree of 28 September 2017 implementing it, noted that "the dates and time of validation are indeed time-stamped with a time-stamping certificate" and that "no evidence contradicts the presumption of reliability of the electronic signature process used" (our translation) (CA Aix-en-Provence, ch. 1-7, 17 September 2026, No. 24/00084). The hash of a file recorded on a public blockchain dates that file, but it falls primarily under the principle that evidence is open (preuve libre), and its weight depends on the technical explanation provided.
Dating is not enough to protect. The Bordeaux court of appeal points out that "it is for the party relying on the originality of software to prove the existence of an intellectual contribution and a personalised effort by the person who developed it" (our translation); it found infringement of software whose prior existence was evidenced by "the deposit of the source code on a USB key with a commissaire de justice (judicial officer) two years before its assignment" (our translation) (CA Bordeaux, 1re ch. civ., 18 November 2025, No. 22/04592). Conversely, the Paris judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) dismissed the claim of a publisher that produced a registration certificate without explaining the originality of its program: "As nothing allows this software to be described as original, it therefore enjoys no copyright protection" (our translation) (TJ Paris, 3e ch. 1re sect., 25 September 2025, No. 24/00326).
A developer who documents their work is better placed to defend it. The Paris court of appeal declared admissible the claim of a developer who explained the infrastructure of his software, "the dating and time traceability of the changes made and their author" (our translation) (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 1, 18 October 2023, No. 22/07097). Version history, dated deposits and hashes recorded on a ledger together form a body of evidence. See also our copyright lawyer page and our article on breached open source licences.
Compliance and disputes
Personal data on the blockchain, withheld tokens and access
An immutable ledger has to accommodate the GDPR; a frozen wallet is unfrozen before the court.
Identify the controller, who "alone or jointly with others, determines the purposes and means of the processing" (Article 4(7) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679). According to the CNIL, the French data protection authority, the participant who decides to record data on the blockchain "could be considered a data controller" (our translation) (CNIL, 20 September 2018).
Where several actors jointly determine the purposes and means, they are joint controllers, set out their obligations in an arrangement, and the data subject may exercise their rights against each of them (Article 26 of the GDPR).
Design the processing so that, by default, "only personal data which are necessary for each specific purpose of the processing are processed" (Article 25(2)), keeping identifying data off-chain.
Carry out an impact assessment before the processing where the use of a new technology is likely to result in a high risk to the rights and freedoms of individuals (Article 35 of the GDPR).
Organise the right to erasure (Article 17): the CNIL notes that solutions such as cryptographic commitment or encryption, while not having strictly identical effects, "make it possible to move closer to the GDPR compliance requirements" (our translation).
Token disputes are first and foremost contractual. The urgent applications judge of the Bordeaux commercial court, seized by the subscriber to a SAFT whose issuer had frozen his wallet citing a breach of confidentiality, held that "the sole condition for delivery of the AVIA tokens is the undertaking of Mr [N] [F] to pay KEPLER DIGITALS SAS the sum of USD 10,000" (our translation), then ordered the issuer, subject to a daily penalty (astreinte), to restore access and distribute the remaining tokens (TC Bordeaux, réf., 2 September 2025, No. 2025R00362). Technical access follows the same logic: "It is established that the logins, passwords, access codes and authentication keys relating to a company's applications form part of its assets and belong to it" (our translation) (TJ Blois, réf., 13 August 2026, No. 26/01906).
The points the firm examines in every blockchain matter:
The GDPR outside blockchain (records of processing, processors, CNIL inspections) is covered on our GDPR lawyer page. Cryptocurrency fraud or theft is first a matter for a criminal complaint: see cryptocurrency theft lawyer.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the legislation in force and on verified decisions.
What does a blockchain lawyer do?
A blockchain lawyer turns a technical project into legal instruments that hold up. The first step is classification: does the token represent a financial security, a crypto-asset within the meaning of the MiCA Regulation, a unique and non-fungible asset or a mere contractual right? MiCA applies neither to unique and non-fungible crypto-assets nor to those that qualify as financial instruments (Article 2(3) and (4) of Regulation (EU) 2023/1114), the latter, being financial instruments, remaining subject to the French Monetary and Financial Code (Article L. 211-1).
Next come the contracts. The smart contract performs an agreement that must exist and be valid: consent, capacity, lawful and certain content (Article 1128 of the French Civil Code). The firm drafts development and audit agreements, the protocol's terms and conditions, the articles of association of the entity behind the DAO, assignments of rights in the code, and GDPR documentation.
Finally, disputes: a smart contract bug, tokens not delivered, a frozen wallet, withheld keys, infringement of the code. The Tours commercial court thus held that the error in the smart contract program made the developer liable, while sharing liability with a client that had not had the audit carried out (TC Tours, 21 February 2025, No. J2024000005).
Is a smart contract legally binding?
A smart contract is a program. It is not in itself a contract: a contract is "a meeting of minds between two or more persons intended to create, modify, transfer or extinguish obligations" (Article 1101 of the French Civil Code). Where such an agreement exists, the code ensures its automatic performance, and a lawfully formed contract has the force of law between those who made it (Article 1103).
The practical question is how to prove the agreement and its content. An electronic document "has the same evidential value as a paper document", provided its author can be identified and its integrity is guaranteed (Article 1366). Between traders, commercial acts may be proved by any means (Article L. 110-3 of the French Commercial Code). The exchanges before deployment matter: the Tours commercial court found that a smart contract development agreement existed on the basis of messages setting out the subject matter, the price and the deadline, and of a deposit paid in ether (TC Tours, 21 February 2025, No. J2024000005).
If the code does something other than what the parties intended, the contract is interpreted according to their common intention rather than the literal meaning of its terms (Article 1188). The firm therefore drafts a written agreement that describes in plain language what the program must do, the circumstances in which it stops, updates and liability in the event of an error.
A smart contract bug ruined our launch: who is liable?
The developer is liable for proven non-performance, except in cases of force majeure: the debtor is ordered, where appropriate, to pay damages for non-performance or delay (Article 1231-1 of the French Civil Code). The extent of the developer's liability depends on the nature of the obligation, an obligation of means or an obligation to achieve a result, as set by the contract or, failing that, as determined by the court in the light of the service promised. The creditor may also suspend its own performance, seek a price reduction or termination (Article 1217).
The Tours commercial court applied these rules to the launch of a collection of 5,555 NFTs, interrupted for nearly two hours by a bug. It found that "the error in the computer program of the smart contract is therefore obvious, acknowledged by its developers" (our translation) and, in the absence of a written document specifying the nature of the obligation, that "if the obligation to achieve a result is not addressed in the contract, it is implicit for this activity" (our translation). The decision is not, however, entirely favourable to the client: the court noted that the checks, tests and audit of the smart contract had been set aside, found the amount of lost sales uncertain, halved the client's estimate and split liability equally (TC Tours, 21 February 2025, No. J2024000005). The studio was ordered to pay €77,833.28, far from the amounts claimed.
The case is therefore prepared from the moment of the incident: preserving transactions and logs, dated screenshots, exchanges with the developer, quantifying the loss on verifiable evidence. The claim is time-barred after five years (Article 2224, and Article L. 110-4 of the French Commercial Code for obligations arising between traders or between traders and non-traders). The firm acts for clients as well as for developers whose liability is challenged.
Can a company's shares be tokenised?
Yes, where the shares are not admitted to the operations of a central securities depository. These securities are registered in their owner's name in an account kept by the issuer or, if the issuer so decides, by means of distributed ledger technology (Article L. 211-7 of the French Monetary and Financial Code). The law is explicit: "Registration by means of distributed ledger technology takes the place of registration in an account" (Article L. 211-3).
The ledger must meet precise requirements. It is designed to "guarantee the recording and integrity of the entries", to make it possible to identify the owners, the nature and the number of securities, and to be covered by a business continuity plan including periodic external storage of the data (Article R. 211-9-7). Securities recorded by the issuer on such a ledger take registered form (Article R. 211-2), are transferred by entry in the ledger (Article L. 211-15), and ownership passes to the acquirer upon registration in its favour (Article L. 211-17).
The token remains a share: articles of association, approval clauses, shareholders' agreements, the law on public offerings and taxation apply as they do to a security recorded in an account, and MiCA does not apply (Article 2(4)(a) of the MiCA Regulation). The firm reviews the articles of association, drafts the issuer's decision and aligns the rules of the smart contract with those of the shareholders' agreement.
Does a DAO have legal personality in France?
No, under French law as it stands, unless it is backed by an entity with legal personality. Companies, other than undisclosed partnerships, "have legal personality from the date of their registration" (Article 1842 of the French Civil Code). A community that carries on a joint activity without registration may be classified as an undisclosed partnership if its members have agreed to allocate property or their work to a common undertaking with a view to sharing the profit or savings (Article 1832), a partnership which "is not a legal person and is not subject to public disclosure" (Article 1871).
The consequences for members are serious. Each partner alone is bound towards third parties by the acts it concludes, but if the participants act as partners in full view of third parties, each is bound by the acts performed by the others, jointly and severally if the partnership is commercial (Article 1872-1). The Court of Cassation concludes that no claim can be brought against such a grouping, since it lacks legal personality, and it ruled out joint and several liability between the partners of a non-commercial grouping (Cass. 1re civ., 8 March 2023, No. 20-16.475). The Tours commercial court, for its part, found a de facto company between four developers who publicly presented themselves as co-founders of a blockchain studio, and declared them jointly and severally liable (TC Tours, 21 February 2025, No. J2024000005).
The firm therefore backs the DAO with a company, association or foundation, and drafts articles of association that give effect to the community's votes. Acts performed before registration bind those who acted, unless taken over by the company (Article L. 210-6 of the French Commercial Code); the Court of Cassation allows the court to determine, in the light of all the circumstances, whether the act was concluded in the name or on behalf of the company being formed (Cass. com., 29 November 2023, No. 22-12.865).
Can the blockchain prove the date of a creation or a document?
It can help. Except where the law requires a written document, "evidence may be adduced by any means" (Article 1358 of the French Civil Code). The eIDAS Regulation, amended in 2024, adds that an electronic ledger may not be denied admissibility as evidence in legal proceedings solely because it is in electronic form, and that records in a qualified electronic ledger enjoy a presumption as to their chronological ordering and their integrity (Article 45 duodecies of Regulation (EU) No 910/2014 as amended). A qualified ledger is created and managed by one or more qualified trust service providers (Article 45 terdecies): a public blockchain that is not operated by such a provider does not benefit from this presumption.
In practice, the hash of the file is recorded on the blockchain, not the file itself. When a dispute arises, the file must be produced, the hash recalculated, the transaction shown and the process explained. The court assesses all of this freely, as it assesses other evidence of prior existence: the Bordeaux court of appeal took into account source code deposited with a commissaire de justice (judicial officer) two years before the software was assigned (CA Bordeaux, 1re ch. civ., 18 November 2025, No. 22/04592).
The date proves neither authorship nor originality. The Paris judicial court dismissed the claim of a publisher that produced a registration certificate for its software without explaining its originality, pointing out that originality "must be explained by the person claiming to be its author" (our translation) (TJ Paris, 3e ch. 1re sect., 25 September 2025, No. 24/00326). The firm builds the evidence file before any dispute: time stamping, deposit, development history and a description of the creative choices.
What is an electronically signed, time-stamped contract worth?
It is worth the same as a paper document, on two conditions: the author must be identifiable and the document must be drawn up and kept in conditions that guarantee its integrity (Article 1366 of the French Civil Code). An electronic signature consists of a reliable identification process guaranteeing its link with the document, and "The reliability of this process is presumed, until proven otherwise" where the conditions laid down by decree are met (Article 1367).
Time stamping helps establish the date and attribution of the signature. Applying the presumption under Article 1367 and the decree of 28 September 2017 implementing it, the Aix-en-Provence court of appeal overturned a judgment that had refused to attribute an electronic signature to the borrower, after noting that "the dates and time of validation are indeed time-stamped with a time-stamping certificate" (our translation) and that nothing contradicted the presumption of reliability of the process (CA Aix-en-Provence, ch. 1-7, 17 September 2026, No. 24/00084). Separately from that presumption, a qualified time stamp itself enjoys a presumption of the accuracy of the date and time (Article 41 of the amended eIDAS Regulation).
The signature date can also work against the party relying on it. The Paris judicial court held that "the date of the deed must correspond to the date on which the parties affixed their electronic signature" (our translation), and rejected the request for discharge of penalties for late registration of a transfer, the time limit running from that date (TJ Paris, 9e ch. 2e sect., 14 January 2026, No. 24/10818). Where written documents conflict, the court retains the most plausible one (Article 1368). See our article on disputed electronic signatures.
Who owns the smart contract code: the developer or the client?
It all depends on the developer's status. If the developer is an employee and creates the software in the course of their duties or on the employer's instructions, the economic rights "vest in the employer, who alone is entitled to exercise them", unless otherwise agreed (Article L. 113-9 of the French Intellectual Property Code).
If the developer is an independent contractor, they remain the owner of the rights until they have assigned them in writing. Contracts transferring copyright must be recorded in writing (Article L. 131-2), and each of the rights assigned must be mentioned separately, with the scope of exploitation defined as to its extent, purpose, place and duration (Article L. 131-3). The Colmar court of appeal upheld a contractor's claim against the client company, noting that "no deed of assignment has been shown, it being specified that a deed of assignment cannot be implicit" (our translation), payment of the invoices not being sufficient to transfer the rights (CA Colmar, 1re ch. A, 9 April 2025, No. 24/01625). The outcome is unfavourable to a client who paid without a contract.
The development agreement must therefore provide for the assignment of rights in the code, the documentation and the preparatory material, delivery of the source code, the treatment of open source components and of the deployment keys. A developer who wants to assert their rights documents their work: the Paris court of appeal declared admissible the claim of a developer who traced the dating of the changes and their author (CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 1, 18 October 2023, No. 22/07097). See our article on an agency that refuses to hand over the source code.
Is blockchain protocol code protected by copyright?
Yes, if it is original. Software, including preparatory design material, is a work of the mind (Article L. 112-2, 13°, of the French Intellectual Property Code). The author has the right to authorise the reproduction, modification and placing on the market of the software (Article L. 122-6), and infringement of these rights is the criminal offence of counterfeiting (contrefaçon) (Article L. 335-3).
Protection covers the expression, not the idea. According to the Bordeaux court of appeal, "the source code corresponding to the development of the software in computer language is protectable under copyright, unlike the idea or the functionality" (our translation), and the party relying on originality must prove an intellectual contribution and a personalised effort. It found infringement, prohibited the sale of products using the infringing files and set a claim of €80,000 against the liabilities of the infringing company (CA Bordeaux, 1re ch. civ., 18 November 2025, No. 22/04592). It follows that the idea of a protocol or of a consensus mechanism is not protected as such; only the code that expresses it can be, if it is original.
The burden of proof is real: the Paris judicial court dismissed the claim of a publisher that did not explain the originality of its software (TJ Paris, 3e ch. 1re sect., 25 September 2025, No. 24/00326). The Bordeaux court of appeal also holds that open source or open access software is protectable under copyright, "infringement being characterised in this area by failure to comply with the terms of the licence agreement that sets the conditions of access to open source software" (our translation) (CA Bordeaux, 1re ch. civ., 18 November 2025, No. 22/04592). See our copyright lawyer page and our article on breaches of the GPL licence.
Blockchain and the GDPR: how can an immutable ledger be reconciled with the right to erasure?
The GDPR applies as soon as the blockchain contains personal data, including participants' public keys where they make it possible to identify a person. The data subject has the right to obtain "the erasure of personal data concerning him or her without undue delay" in the cases provided for, subject in particular to freedom of expression and legal obligations (Article 17 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679).
The answer is built in at the design stage. The controller implements appropriate measures, such as pseudonymisation, and ensures that only the data that are necessary are processed (Article 25). According to the CNIL, the participant who decides to record data on the blockchain "could be considered a data controller" (our translation); it notes that solutions such as cryptographic commitment or encryption, while not having strictly identical effects, "make it possible to move closer to the GDPR compliance requirements" (our translation) (CNIL, Blockchain and the GDPR, 20 September 2018). The firm recommends keeping the data off-chain and recording only a hash, which limits the impact of an erasure request.
Where several actors jointly determine the purposes and means, they are joint controllers and the data subject may take action against each of them (Article 26). An impact assessment precedes the processing where the new technology gives rise to a high risk (Article 35). No published French court decision on the erasure of data recorded on a blockchain has been identified. See our GDPR lawyer page.
The issuer has frozen our tokens or our wallet: what can we do?
First, reread the contract. A SAFT, a token subscription or terms and conditions set the conditions for delivery of the tokens, and a lawfully formed contract is binding on the parties (Article 1103 of the French Civil Code). The creditor may seek specific performance in kind (Article 1217).
Urgent proceedings (référé) make it possible to act quickly. The president of the judicial court, or of the commercial court in a commercial dispute, may order performance of the obligation, even an obligation to do something, where its existence is not seriously disputable (Articles 835 and 873 of the French Code of Civil Procedure). Seized by the subscriber to a SAFT whose issuer had frozen his wallet, accusing him of a breach of confidentiality, the urgent applications judge of the Bordeaux commercial court held that this disagreement "has no bearing on the contractual undertaking" (our translation) to deliver the tokens, the sole condition for their delivery being payment, which had been made. The judge ordered the wallet to be unfrozen and the remaining 130,207.06 tokens to be distributed according to the schedule, subject to a daily penalty of 100 euros (TC Bordeaux, réf., 2 September 2025, No. 2025R00362).
The file brings together the contract, the public address of the wallet, proof of payment, the distribution history and the formal notice that went unanswered. Where the freeze comes from an authorised exchange platform, the route is a complaint and the provider's liability: see our crypto and fintech lawyer page.
A former partner or contractor is holding on to the project's keys and access: what can we do?
Bring urgent proceedings to put an end to the disturbance. The urgent applications judge may order the protective or restorative measures needed to put an end to a manifestly unlawful disturbance, and order the performance of an obligation to do something that is not seriously disputable (Article 835 of the French Code of Civil Procedure).
The urgent applications judge in Blois ruled on dismissed directors who had kept a company's administrator access. The judge stated that "It is established that the logins, passwords, access codes and authentication keys relating to a company's applications form part of its assets and belong to it" (our translation). The judge ordered them to hand over the logins, codes, authentication keys and administration rights for ten services, including hosting, the code repository and payments, subject to a daily penalty of 250 euros, and rejected the broader requests (TJ Blois, réf., 13 August 2026, No. 26/01906).
For a blockchain project, the request covers deployment keys, contract administration rights, multisignature wallets, the code repository and the domain name. It must be precise, tool by tool, and supported by the articles of association, the contracts and proof that access was entrusted for the purposes of a role or an assignment. The development agreement should provide from the outset for the handover of keys and source code at the end of the assignment.
I am an individual user in a dispute with a foreign provider: which court should I go to?
An individual who enters into a contract for a purpose outside their trade or profession benefits from the protective regime of Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 where the other party pursues its activities in France or, by any means, directs its activities to France, and the contract falls within the scope of those activities (Article 17(1)(c) of the Regulation). The Court of Cassation points out that "proceedings brought by a consumer against the other party to the contract may be brought either in the courts of the Member State in which that party is domiciled or, regardless of the domicile of the other party, in the courts for the place where the consumer is domiciled" (Cass. 1re civ., 28 June 2023, No. 22-12.424).
Consumer status withstands sustained activity. In that case, the user had received a gift of tokens, carried out some 200 transactions in nine months, sat temporarily on a foundation dedicated to blockchain technology and taken part in projects linked to the protocol. The court of appeal held that these factors were not sufficient to establish that the contract was a professional one, and the Court of Cassation upheld that ruling: "the profit made falls within the management of a private estate" (our translation). The appeal brought by the foreign companies was dismissed (Cass. 1re civ., 28 June 2023, No. 22-12.424).
The outcome is unfavourable to the foreign provider. If French law applies, its terms and conditions must also have been brought to the user's attention and accepted by the user to be enforceable against them (Article 1119 of the French Civil Code). The firm checks the user's status, the jurisdiction clause and the applicable law before taking any action.
How much does a blockchain lawyer cost?
Fees are set out in a written fee agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the assignment covers and what it costs. The agreement specifies in particular the amount or the method for determining the fees covering the foreseeable work, as well as the expected costs and disbursements.
The firm prefers a fixed fee per stage: a token classification memo, drafting a development or audit agreement, a protocol's terms and conditions, the articles of association and shareholders' agreement of the entity behind a DAO, a decision to issue securities recorded on a distributed ledger, an assignment of rights in the code, GDPR compliance, a formal notice, urgent proceedings, proceedings on the merits, an appeal. Technical audit, commissaire de justice (judicial officer) or expert fees are added to the lawyer's fees. Any new assignment is covered by an amendment, with no unexpected billing.
For a first opinion on documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. For an initial conversation: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 31 October and 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on markets in crypto-assets (MiCA): exclusions (Article 2(3) and (4)), definitions of distributed ledger technology and distributed ledger (Article 3)
- Regulation (EU) No 910/2014 (eIDAS), as amended by Regulation (EU) 2024/1183: electronic ledger (Article 3), electronic time stamps (Article 41), electronic ledgers and qualified electronic ledgers (Articles 45 duodecies and 45 terdecies)
- Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (Brussels I bis): jurisdiction over consumer contracts (Articles 17 and 18)
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR): controller (Article 4), erasure (Article 17), data protection by design (Article 25), joint controllers (Article 26), impact assessment (Article 35)
- Articles L. 211-1, L. 211-3 and L. 211-7 of the French Monetary and Financial Code: financial securities, registration by means of distributed ledger technology
- Articles L. 211-15, L. 211-17, R. 211-2 and R. 211-9-7: transfer, transfer of ownership, registered form, requirements for the shared electronic recording system
- Articles L. 54-10-1, L. 552-1 and L. 552-2: reference to MiCA, public offerings of crypto-assets
- Articles 1101, 1103, 1112-1, 1119 and 1128 of the French Civil Code: contract, binding force, duty to inform, terms and conditions, validity
- Articles 1171, 1188, 1217, 1231-1 and 2224: unfair terms, interpretation, non-performance, damages, limitation period
- Articles 1358, 1359, 1366, 1367 and 1368: open evidence, written evidence, electronic documents and signatures, conflicting evidence
- Articles 1832, 1842, 1871 and 1872-1: company agreement, legal personality, undisclosed partnership, partners' liability
- Articles L. 110-3, L. 110-4, L. 210-6 and L. 442-1 of the French Commercial Code: evidence between traders, limitation period, company being formed, significant imbalance
- Article L. 212-1 of the French Consumer Code: unfair terms in contracts concluded with a consumer
- Articles L. 112-2, L. 113-9, L. 122-6, L. 131-2, L. 131-3 and L. 335-3 of the French Intellectual Property Code: software, employee-created software, rights of the software author, assignment, infringement
- Articles 835 and 873 of the French Code of Civil Procedure: urgent proceedings before the judicial court and the commercial court
- CNIL, "Blockchain and the GDPR: what solutions for responsible use in the presence of personal data?", 20 September 2018: classification of the actors, exercise of rights
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- Cass. 1re civ., 28 June 2023, No. 22-12.424: crypto wallet user, consumer status
- Cass. crim., 15 February 2023, No. 22-81.326: blockchain transaction, criminal seizure of bitcoins
- Cass. 1re civ., 8 March 2023, No. 20-16.475: grouping without legal personality, undisclosed partnership
- Cass. com., 29 November 2023, No. 22-12.865: acts performed for a company being formed
- Cass. com., 13 May 2026, No. 24-17.137: Article 1171 excluded for a professional covered by Article L. 442-1
- TC Tours, 21 February 2025, No. J2024000005: smart contract bug, de facto company
- TC Bordeaux, réf., 2 September 2025, No. 2025R00362: frozen SAFT tokens, release ordered in urgent proceedings
- CA Bordeaux, 1re ch. civ., 18 November 2025, No. 22/04592: originality and infringement of software
- CA Colmar, 1re ch. A, 9 April 2025, No. 24/01625: contractor's software, no assignment
- CA Paris, pôle 5, ch. 1, 18 October 2023, No. 22/07097: proof of authorship of software
- CA Aix-en-Provence, ch. 1-7, 17 September 2026, No. 24/00084: time-stamped electronic signature
- TJ Paris, 3e ch. 1re sect., 25 September 2025, No. 24/00326: originality not explained, software not protected
- TJ Paris, 9e ch. 2e sect., 14 January 2026, No. 24/10818: date of an electronically signed deed
- TJ Blois, réf., 13 August 2026, No. 26/01906: keys and access withheld by former directors
A smart contract to secure, tokens to issue, access to recover? Speak to a blockchain lawyer
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send us the white paper, the contract or terms and conditions, the address of the deployed contract or wallet, your exchanges with the developer or issuer and any documents you have: Hassan Kohen reviews the classification, the evidence and the time limits, then tells you the appropriate course of action, whether drafting or legal audit, structuring, compliance, formal notice, urgent proceedings or an action on the merits.