The firm in the media
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, constitutional law and QPC in Paris
Constitutional lawyer in Paris: challenge a law during your case (QPC)
Priority preliminary ruling on constitutionality (question prioritaire de constitutionnalité, QPC), separate and reasoned written submission, transmission, referral to the French Constitutional Council (Conseil constitutionnel), hearing and effects of the decision: at Kohen Avocats, a constitutional lawyer in Paris assesses whether the question is worth raising and can act before the court hearing the case and before the Constitutional Council, for the party challenging the law as well as for the party defending it. Constitutional litigation turns first on the form of the written submission and on the moment it is filed.
The firm can be reached 24/7. The judge does not raise the question of their own motion: it must be presented in a separate and reasoned written submission (Article 23-1 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958). Once transmission has been refused, it can only be argued again in an appeal against the decision settling all or part of the dispute (Article 23-2). Before the administrative courts, the party bringing the appeal presents the challenge before the time limit for appealing expires, and the respondent to the appeal may bring it with no time limit, in every case by a separate and reasoned submission.
4,9/5
Average Google rating270 reviews
I received very high-quality support from this criminal defence lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective defence in criminal law.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer. He got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution found for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with great empathy and a strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen carefully and to fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Urgent matters 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar: priority preliminary rulings on constitutionality (QPC), constitutional litigation, and how they fit with treaty-compatibility review.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 1 November 2026.
Quick answer
The priority preliminary ruling on constitutionality (QPC) allows a party to argue, during their case, that a legislative provision infringes the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution (Article 61-1 of the French Constitution). It must be presented in a separate and reasoned written submission, failing which it is inadmissible, and the judge cannot raise it of their own motion (Article 23-1 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958). The court transmits it if the provision applies to the dispute, if it has not already been declared constitutional, barring a change in circumstances, and if the question is not devoid of seriousness (Article 23-2). The Council of State (Conseil d'État) or the Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) rules within three months, then the Constitutional Council decides within three months of the referral (Articles 23-4 and 23-10). A provision declared unconstitutional is repealed when the decision is published or at a later date set by the decision (Article 62 of the Constitution). Kohen Avocats, in Paris (16th arrondissement), assesses whether the question is worth raising and can draft the submission and argue it before the court hearing the case; before the Court of Cassation and the Council of State, the signature of a lawyer admitted to the Council of State and the Court of Cassation (avocat au Conseil d'État et à la Cour de cassation) is required in the cases provided for by law. Contact: +33 6 89 11 34 45.
A law to challenge during your case, a refusal to transmit, a question to defend?
Understanding your situation
Constitutional challenges and the QPC in France, explained
During proceedings, a case can be brought before the French Constitutional Council on referral from the Council of State or the Court of Cassation (Article 61-1 of the Constitution). What can be challenged, how and before whom, what the Constitutional Council decides, and what it changes for your case.
Key points
An admissible QPC: four checks before drafting
What the judge looks at first, and what makes the question fail without any examination of the merits.
A pending case: the question arises in a dispute before a court (Article 61-1 of the Constitution). No one can refer a law they object to directly to the Constitutional Council.
A legislative provision: a statute, an institutional act (loi organique), a ratified government ordinance. Decrees and administrative orders (décrets, arrêtés) are excluded (Nouveaux Cahiers du Conseil constitutionnel, No. 29); their lawfulness is challenged before the administrative courts or, where the outcome of the criminal trial depends on it, before the criminal court (Article 111-5 of the French Criminal Code).
A right or freedom guaranteed by the Constitution: the 1958 Constitution, the 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, the Preamble to the 1946 Constitution, the fundamental principles recognised by the laws of the Republic and the Charter for the Environment (same source).
A separate and reasoned written submission: the plea must be set out in it, failing which it is inadmissible, and the judge cannot raise it of their own motion (Article 23-1 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958).
Case law can be targeted through the provision it interprets. The Constitutional Council holds that “any litigant has the right to challenge the constitutionality of the actual scope that a settled case-law interpretation gives to this provision” (decision No. 2010-39 QPC of 6 October 2010, our translation). The interpretation must, however, exist and be settled: the social chamber of the Court of Cassation refused to refer a question, noting that there was, as matters stood, no “settled case-law interpretation of the contested legislative provisions” (Cass. soc., 9 May 2018, No. 18-40.007, our translation).
The line between statute and regulation needs watching. The criminal chamber declared inadmissible a question which, behind statutory articles, in fact targeted an article of a regulatory nature: it identified provisions “of a regulatory nature, which cannot be the subject of a QPC” (Cass. crim., 25 February 2025, No. 24-86.402, our translation). For an unratified ordinance, the answer depends on the date: once the enabling period has expired, in matters falling within the scope of statute law, its provisions “must be regarded as legislative provisions” (decision No. 2020-843 QPC of 28 May 2020, our translation).
Not every ground is a constitutional one. The legislature's failure to exercise its own powers “can be relied on in support of a QPC only where a right or freedom guaranteed by the Constitution is affected” (decision No. 2010-5 QPC of 18 June 2010, our translation). Likewise, a statute's incompatibility with an international commitment “cannot be regarded as a ground of unconstitutionality” (decision No. 2010-605 DC of 12 May 2010, our translation): the European Convention on Human Rights is relied on through a different plea.
The procedure
From the separate submission to referral: conditions, time limits, refusal
Each step has its own rule, and inadmissibility can turn on a detail of form.
Timing
The question may be raised for the first time on appeal (Article 23-1), and even for the first time at the cassation stage (Article 23-5).
Written submission
A separate and reasoned written submission before the civil courts (Article 126-2 of the Code of Civil Procedure) and the criminal courts (Article R.* 49-21 of the Code of Criminal Procedure); before the administrative courts, a separate submission bearing the words “question prioritaire de constitutionnalité” (Article R.* 771-3 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
Judicial investigation and assize court
During a judicial investigation, the question goes to the investigating chamber (chambre de l'instruction) (Article R.* 49-22 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The plea cannot be raised before the assize court (cour d'assises); if its judgment is appealed, the plea is raised in a written submission accompanying the notice of appeal, which is immediately transmitted to the Court of Cassation (Article 23-1).
Three conditions
The provision applies to the dispute or the proceedings, or forms the basis of the prosecution; it has not been declared constitutional in the grounds and operative part of a Constitutional Council decision, barring a change in circumstances; the question is not devoid of seriousness. The court rules without delay (Article 23-2).
Transmission
The decision to transmit is sent to the Council of State or the Court of Cassation within eight days of being delivered and is not open to any appeal (Article 23-2).
Second filter
The Council of State or the Court of Cassation has three months. Referral requires the first two conditions and a question that is new or serious (Article 23-4). If no decision is made within that period, the question is sent to the Constitutional Council (Article 23-7).
Constitutional Council
It rules within three months of the referral, after adversarial submissions and a public hearing, save in exceptional cases (Article 23-10).
A refusal to transmit has immediate effects. It divests the court of the plea (Article 126-6 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Article R.* 49-27 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Article R.* 771-10 of the Code of Administrative Justice). There is one exception: where the refusal rests solely on the provision being inapplicable, or in criminal matters on its not forming the basis of the prosecution, the court that ultimately intends to apply it may revoke the refusal or, before the administrative courts, declare it void, and transmit the question. Otherwise, the refusal “can be challenged only in an appeal against the decision settling all or part of the dispute” (Article 23-2, our translation). An immediate appeal fails: the Paris Court of Appeal held that the texts do not provide “for an appeal to be brought against a decision taken by a first-instance court on a QPC filed before it” (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 16 May 2025, No. 20/05553, our translation). The criminal chamber takes the same approach for an appeal to the Court of Cassation, the challenge having to take the form of a written submission “raising the question again” (Cass. crim., 9 January 2018, No. 17-86.231, our translation).
Before the administrative courts, the party bringing the appeal presents the challenge “within the time limit for bringing proceedings and by a separate and reasoned submission” (CE, 21 June 2021, No. 445346, our translation), accompanied by a copy of the refusal decision (Article R.* 771-12, Article R.* 771-16). The respondent to the appeal may bring it “with no time limit”, including in electoral matters, where a cross-appeal is not available, but always in a separate and reasoned submission (CE, 21 June 2021, No. 445346, our translation). A party who did not challenge the refusal before the administrative court of appeal cannot make up for it at the cassation stage: the Council of State dismissed a question “based on the same grounds, concerning the same provisions as those submitted to the administrative court”, without referring it (CE, 30 November 2020, No. 443970, our translation).
The judge must answer and follow the procedure. A court of appeal that did not rule on the transmission of a question put before it had its judgment quashed, the Court of Cassation holding that “In so ruling, the court of appeal exceeded its powers.” (Cass. 2e civ., 2 March 2023, No. 21-11.499, our translation). Conversely, obtaining a transmission does not ensure that the question will be examined: before a court of the ordinary court system (juridiction judiciaire), the case is communicated to the public prosecution service (ministère public) as soon as the plea is raised, where it is not a party to the proceedings (Article 23-1), and the social chamber declared inadmissible a question transmitted by an employment tribunal (conseil de prud'hommes) without that communication (Cass. soc., 17 December 2025, No. 25-40.032).
The participants
Who raises the question, who signs, who pleads
The party attacking the law and the party defending it need to take different approaches, and each court has its own rules on representation.
You are challenging the provision
- Identify the exact applicable text and its version, then the right or freedom infringed.
- Check that the Constitutional Council has not already declared it constitutional, or establish the change in circumstances.
- File the separate submission in time, and prepare the challenge to any refusal.
You are defending the provision
- Dispute admissibility: separate submission, standing as a party, signature, time of filing.
- Show that the text does not apply to the dispute, or that the question is not serious.
- Submit written observations at each level, and anticipate the effects of a repeal on the dispute.
Before the court hearing the case, the rules on representation are those of the court seised. Where representation by a lawyer is mandatory, the question “can only be raised by a lawyer”; elsewhere, the party may file the written submission personally, and it must still be separate and reasoned (Nouveaux Cahiers du Conseil constitutionnel, No. 29, our translation).
Before the Court of Cassation, in civil matters, the parties must, unless otherwise provided, instruct a lawyer admitted to the Council of State and the Court of Cassation (Article 973 of the Code of Civil Procedure), and observations on a transmitted question are signed by that lawyer in matters where representation is mandatory (Article 126-9). The sanction is clear: “In the absence of an admissible appeal, the QPC raised in connection with that appeal before the Court of Cassation is not admissible.” (Cass. 2e civ., 13 March 2025, No. 24-50.042, our translation). In criminal matters, observations are also signed by such a lawyer, except where they come from the convicted person, from the civil party in press matters or from the appellant in the cases provided for in Articles 567-2, 574-1 and 574-2 (Article R.* 49-30 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The criminal chamber rejected a submission which “was not signed by the applicant herself but by her lawyer, who is not a lawyer admitted to the Council of State and the Court of Cassation” (Cass. crim., 20 October 2026, No. 26-84.940, our translation).
Before the Council of State, the application and submissions are, as a rule, presented by a lawyer admitted to the Council of State, failing which they are inadmissible (Article R. 432-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice), subject to exemptions, in particular for applications for judicial review (recours pour excès de pouvoir) and electoral disputes (Article R. 432-2). For a transmitted question, the exemption from representation before the court that transmitted it also applies to the observations; otherwise, they are presented by a lawyer admitted to the Council of State and the Court of Cassation (Article R.* 771-20). The firm is not an avocat aux Conseils (a member of the specialist bar of the Council of State and the Court of Cassation): in these cases, it can prepare the file for the avocat aux Conseils instructed in the case and does not sign in their place.
Before the Constitutional Council, the procedure is written and adversarial, with notifications sent electronically and a deadline for filing observations that “cannot be postponed” (internal rules of procedure, Articles 1 and 3, our translation). At the hearing, the representatives of the parties and of admitted interveners present their oral observations “if they are lawyers admitted to the Council of State and the Court of Cassation or lawyers” (Article 10, our translation). The firm can therefore act there for a party or for an admitted intervener, after reviewing the file.
The points the firm reviews in every case:
The consequences
Effects of a French Constitutional Council decision, a priori review, the ECHR and EU law
A favourable decision does not always have an effect on your case: everything depends on what the Constitutional Council decides about its effects over time.
Repeal
The unconstitutional provision is repealed from the publication of the decision or from a later date that the decision sets, and the Constitutional Council determines the conditions and limits within which the effects the provision has produced may be called into question (Article 62 of the Constitution).
Pending cases
“As a rule, the declaration of unconstitutionality must benefit the person who raised the QPC, and the provision declared unconstitutional cannot be applied in proceedings pending on the date of publication of the Constitutional Council's decision.” (decision No. 2026-1203 QPC of 5 June 2026, our translation).
Postponement
The repeal may be postponed. For police custody (garde à vue), it was postponed to 1 July 2011, and “measures taken before that date under the provisions declared unconstitutional cannot be challenged on the basis of that unconstitutionality” (decision No. 2010-14/22 QPC of 30 July 2010, our translation).
Reservation
The text may remain in force, declared constitutional subject to an interpretative reservation. The Constitutional Council thus held that the rules on compensation for accidents at work could not, in the event of the employer's inexcusable fault, “prevent those same persons, before the same courts, from claiming from the employer compensation for all the damage not covered by Book IV of the Social Security Code” (decision No. 2010-8 QPC of 18 June 2010, our translation).
Binding force
Decisions of the Constitutional Council are not open to any appeal and are binding on the public authorities and on all administrative and judicial authorities (Article 62). A clerical error can only be the subject of a request for rectification within twenty days of publication in the Official Journal (Journal officiel) (internal rules of procedure, Article 13).
Repeal does not in itself give rise to compensation. The Council of State accepts that the State may be liable for a statute contrary to the Constitution “only if the Constitutional Council has declared that provision unconstitutional on the basis of Article 61-1” or, in certain cases, in the course of a review under Article 61, provided that the Constitutional Council's decision does not rule it out, and “it is for the victim to establish the reality of their loss and the existence of a direct causal link between the unconstitutionality of the statute and that loss” (CE, Ass., 24 December 2019, No. 425983, our translation). In that case, the company's appeal was dismissed. The Constitutional Council also recognises that it has the power “to preclude the State's liability from being incurred” (decision No. 2026-1203 QPC of 5 June 2026, our translation).
A priori review follows a different logic. Institutional acts and the rules of procedure of the parliamentary assemblies are submitted to the Constitutional Council before they are promulgated or applied; ordinary statutes may be referred to it before promulgation by the President of the Republic, the Prime Minister, the presidents of the two assemblies or sixty members of the National Assembly or sixty senators, and it rules within one month, reduced to eight days in an emergency at the Government's request (Article 61 of the Constitution). A person affected by the statute cannot refer it to the Constitutional Council, but may send it an external contribution. Since 2019, the Constitutional Council has published the text of these contributions, which “do not have the status of procedural documents” and do not oblige it to respond (press release of 24 May 2019, our translation); its 2022 rules codified this practice (decision No. 2022-152 ORGA, press release). See our article on referral to the Constitutional Council under Article 61.
Treaty compatibility and constitutionality are not the same thing. When both pleas are raised, the judge rules first on the transmission of the question (Article 23-2), but the authority of the Constitutional Council's decisions “does not limit the jurisdiction of the administrative and ordinary courts to give precedence to those commitments over a legislative provision incompatible with them, even where the latter has been declared consistent with the Constitution” (decision No. 2010-605 DC of 12 May 2010, our translation). The Court of Justice of the European Union accepts this mechanism on condition that the national courts remain at liberty, in particular, “to refer to the Court, at whatever stage of the proceedings they consider appropriate, and even at the end of the incidental procedure for the review of constitutionality, any question for a preliminary ruling that they consider necessary” (CJEU, Grand Chamber, 22 June 2010, Melki and Abdeli, C-188/10 and C-189/10, our translation).
Strategy and related pages
QPCs by area of law and the firm's other legal options
A few decisions show what a question can change in each type of litigation. They do not prejudge any other case.
Criminal law: the text defining the offence, the penalty and procedural safeguards. Several articles of the Code of Criminal Procedure on police custody were declared unconstitutional (decision No. 2010-14/22 QPC of 30 July 2010), and a detained person may hand the written submission to the head of the prison, in support of an application that may be made by that route (Article R.* 49-24 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
Tax: penalties and collection. The commercial chamber referred a question on the order against a garnishee (tiers saisi) to pay, which “could be regarded as a sanction having the character of a punishment” (Cass. com., 11 March 2026, No. 25-40.034, our translation); the Constitutional Council struck down the text, its decision being “applicable to all cases not finally decided on the date of publication of this decision” (decision No. 2026-1203 QPC of 5 June 2026, our translation). For tax fraud, an interpretative reservation limits to the most serious cases the combined application of the tax penalties of Article 1729 and the criminal penalties of Article 1741 of the General Tax Code (decision No. 2016-545 QPC of 24 June 2016).
Employment and social security: compensation, freedom of enterprise, worker participation. The reservation on the employer's inexcusable fault widened the types of loss recoverable before the social security courts (decision No. 2010-8 QPC of 18 June 2010).
Business: penalties and parallel proceedings. The Constitutional Council held that the articles punishing both the criminal offence of insider dealing and the administrative breach of insider dealing “disregard the principle that offences and penalties must be necessary” for the persons it identifies, with repeal postponed to 1 September 2016 (decision No. 2014-453/454 QPC and 2015-462 QPC of 18 March 2015, our translation).
Foreign nationals: residence, humanitarian assistance, immigration detention. “The freedom to help others, for a humanitarian purpose, regardless of whether their stay on national territory is lawful, follows from the principle of fraternity.” (decision No. 2018-717/718 QPC of 6 July 2018, our translation).
For the relevant areas of law, see the firm's other pages:
Public law lawyer in Paris: the page for the area of law to which constitutional litigation belongs.
European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) lawyer: where the complaint falls under the European Convention on Human Rights rather than the Constitution.
Court of appeal lawyer: the question may be raised for the first time on appeal, and the refusal to transmit is challenged there.
Criminal defence for elected officials: for elected officials facing prosecution, in particular for unlawful taking of interest (prise illégale d'intérêts), whose defence may include challenging the text applied.
White-collar crime lawyer: for economic and financial prosecutions, where the question of cumulative penalties also arises.
FAQ
QPC in France: frequently asked questions
Fourteen detailed answers, based on the texts in force and on verified decisions.
What is a QPC (priority preliminary ruling on constitutionality) and what is it for?
It is the right of a party to proceedings to argue that a legislative provision infringes the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution (Article 61-1 of the Constitution). The Constitutional Council hears it on referral from the Council of State or the Court of Cassation, never directly. Before this procedure existed, a statute in force escaped any such review; today, litigants can obtain it in the course of their own dispute.
The question serves two purposes. It can remove the text on which the prosecution or the claim is based, since a provision declared unconstitutional is repealed (Article 62 of the Constitution), and it can fix the meaning of that text through an interpretative reservation. As a rule, the declaration of unconstitutionality “must benefit the person who raised the QPC”, subject to the Constitutional Council's power to decide otherwise as to its effects over time (decision No. 2026-1203 QPC of 5 June 2026, our translation).
It is called a priority question because a judge faced with both a constitutionality plea and a treaty-compatibility plea rules first on whether to transmit the former (Article 23-2 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958). Finally, once the Constitutional Council has been seised, the termination of the original proceedings has no effect on the examination of the question (Article 23-9). A single litigant's case can therefore lead to a ruling on a rule that reaches beyond their own dispute.
What does a constitutional lawyer do in a QPC?
First, the lawyer decides whether the question makes sense in the case. The provision must apply to the dispute or the proceedings, or form the basis of the prosecution, and the Constitutional Council must not already have declared it constitutional, barring a change in circumstances (Article 23-2 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958). The lawyer then researches the Constitutional Council's decisions on the right relied on, the version of the text and the effect that repeal would have on the dispute.
The lawyer drafts the separate written submission, specifies the provision and the right or freedom infringed, and argues the question at the hearing before the court dealing with the case. The lawyer also prepares the next steps: challenging any refusal, passing the file to the avocat aux Conseils when that lawyer's signature is required, written observations and oral argument before the Constitutional Council, where lawyers may present oral observations (internal rules of procedure, Article 10).
Drafting matters, because the judge examines the question as it was put. A question that targets the wrong text fails: the criminal chamber declared inadmissible one that in fact concerned a regulatory article (Cass. crim., 25 February 2025, No. 24-86.402). The firm can act for the party challenging the provision as well as for the party defending it, or for a third party wishing to intervene, after reviewing the file. A question may also be advised against, for example where another plea meets the client's needs more quickly.
Which provisions can be challenged, and on the basis of which rights and freedoms?
A legislative provision (Article 61-1 of the Constitution): a statute, an institutional act, a ratified ordinance, a New Caledonian “loi du pays”. Decrees, administrative orders and individual decisions do not go through this route (Nouveaux Cahiers du Conseil constitutionnel, No. 29): their lawfulness is challenged before the competent court, including the criminal court where the outcome of the criminal trial depends on it (Article 111-5 of the Criminal Code). The criminal chamber accordingly rules out provisions “of a regulatory nature, which cannot be the subject of a QPC” (Cass. crim., 25 February 2025, No. 24-86.402, our translation). An unratified ordinance may be targeted once the enabling period has expired, for matters within the scope of statute law (decision No. 2020-843 QPC of 28 May 2020).
Case law can be criticised through the text, provided it is settled. The Constitutional Council recognises the right of every litigant to challenge “the actual scope that a settled case-law interpretation gives to this provision” (decision No. 2010-39 QPC of 6 October 2010, our translation). In that decision, however, the provision was declared constitutional. Referral may also fail for lack of an established interpretation, as the social chamber held (Cass. soc., 9 May 2018, No. 18-40.007).
The rights that can be relied on are found in the 1958 Constitution, the 1789 Declaration, the 1946 Preamble, the fundamental principles recognised by the laws of the Republic and the Charter for the Environment. A ground based on a treaty is not one of them: it “cannot be regarded as a ground of unconstitutionality” (decision No. 2010-605 DC of 12 May 2010, our translation). The legislature's failure to exercise its own powers is only useful if it affects a right or freedom (decision No. 2010-5 QPC of 18 June 2010).
When and before which courts can a QPC be raised, including at the assize court?
Before any court under the Council of State or the Court of Cassation, at first instance, for the first time on appeal (Article 23-1 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958), and even for the first time at the cassation stage (Article 23-5). Since the judge cannot raise it of their own motion, it depends on the party's initiative.
Criminal proceedings have their own rules. During a judicial investigation, the question goes to the investigating chamber, and the written submission may also be filed with the registry of the investigating judge, the liberty and custody judge (JLD) or the juvenile judge (Article R.* 49-22 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The criminal chamber declared inadmissible a question transmitted directly to the Court of Cassation by a liberty and custody judge, “without the investigating chamber having been seised of it” (Cass. crim., 7 May 2019, No. 19-90.011, our translation).
The plea cannot be raised before the assize court. If a judgment delivered at first instance is appealed, it is raised in a written submission accompanying the notice of appeal, which is immediately transmitted to the Court of Cassation (Article 23-1). This route is specific to the assize court. For the departmental criminal court, “no exception is provided to the principle that such a plea may be raised before any trial court under the Court of Cassation”: the question is raised before that court, not directly with the Court of Cassation on appeal (Cass. crim., 9 September 2026, No. 26-90.015, our translation).
On an appeal to the Court of Cassation, the brief itself must be admissible: the question “is admissible only if the brief setting out the grounds of appeal is” (Cass. crim., 20 October 2026, No. 26-84.940, our translation).
How do you draft the separate, reasoned submission?
As a stand-alone document, separate from the main pleadings (conclusions) and devoted entirely to the question. The plea must be set out in it, failing which it is inadmissible (Article 23-1 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958), and both civil and criminal courts must raise of their own motion the absence of a separate and reasoned submission (Article 126-2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Article R.* 49-21 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). In criminal proceedings, a detained person may hand the written submission to the head of the prison, in the case provided for by the text (Article R.* 49-24).
Before the administrative courts, the submission and, where applicable, the envelope containing it bear the words “question prioritaire de constitutionnalité” (Article R.* 771-3 of the Code of Administrative Justice). On an appeal to the Court of Cassation, the separate submission bears the same words (Article 126-10 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Article R.* 49-31 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The criminal chamber points out that “where the QPC is raised in the course of an appeal to the Court of Cassation, it must be presented in a separate submission”, and declares the question inadmissible otherwise (Cass. crim., 19 November 2025, No. 25-84.362, our translation).
On the substance, the written submission identifies the provision and its version, states the right or freedom infringed and addresses the three conditions for transmission. It shows why the provision applies to the dispute, says whether it has already been examined and explains why the question is serious. An email address must be provided for the proceedings before the Constitutional Council, whose notifications are sent electronically (internal rules of procedure, Article 3).
What are the three conditions for a QPC to be transmitted?
The first is that the contested provision applies to the dispute or the proceedings, or forms the basis of the prosecution. The second is that it has not already been declared constitutional in the grounds and operative part of a Constitutional Council decision, “save where there has been a change in circumstances” (our translation). The third is that the question is not devoid of seriousness (Article 23-2 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958).
A change in circumstances allows a fresh review where it is “justified by changes that have occurred, since the previous decision, in the applicable constitutional standards or in the circumstances, of law or of fact, that affect the scope of the contested legislative provision” (decision No. 2009-595 DC of 3 December 2009, our translation). Settled case law may amount to such a change, but “only on condition that this case-law interpretation arose after the declaration of conformity” (Cass. crim., 5 April 2022, No. 22-80.434, our translation). In that case, referral was refused because the interpretation predated the declaration.
The Council of State and the Court of Cassation apply a second filter: they re-examine the first two conditions and refer the question if it is new or serious (Article 23-4). The court hearing the case is not required to transmit a question challenging, on the same grounds, a provision that is already before the Constitutional Council or the supreme court concerned; it then stays its ruling or defers its decision (Article 126-5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Article R.* 771-6 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
What are the time limits, and are the proceedings suspended?
The court hearing the case rules without delay, and its decision to transmit is sent within eight days of being delivered (Article 23-2 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958). The Council of State or the Court of Cassation has three months from receipt of the transmission (Article 23-4), or from the presentation of the plea where the question is raised before it (Article 23-5). If no decision is made within that period, the question goes to the Constitutional Council (Article 23-7), which rules within three months of the referral (Article 23-10).
For the parties, the time limit for observations before the Court of Cassation is one month from the decision to transmit (Article 126-9 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Article R.* 49-30 of the Code of Criminal Procedure), and it may be shortened in urgent cases (Article 126-11, Article R.* 49-32). Before the Council of State, it is one month from notification of the decision to transmit, or the period set for the parties (Article R.* 771-20 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
When the question is transmitted, the court stays its ruling, but the preparation of the case continues and the court may order the necessary interim or protective measures. There is no stay where a person is deprived of liberty because of the proceedings, nor where the purpose of the proceedings is to end a measure depriving a person of liberty. The judge may also rule without waiting if the law or regulations require a ruling within a set time or as a matter of urgency, and the transmitting court may decide what must be decided immediately where a stay could have irreversible or manifestly excessive consequences (Article 23-3). The question therefore does not always suspend the proceedings.
Do you need a lawyer admitted to the Council of State and the Court of Cassation?
Not before the court hearing the case: the rules are those of the court seised, and the question “can only be raised by a lawyer” only where representation is mandatory there (Nouveaux Cahiers du Conseil constitutionnel, No. 29, our translation). The firm can therefore argue the question before first-instance courts and courts of appeal on that basis.
Before the Court of Cassation, in civil matters, the parties must, unless otherwise provided, instruct an avocat aux Conseils (Article 973 of the Code of Civil Procedure), who also signs the observations on a transmitted question in matters where representation is mandatory (Article 126-9). “As it was not lodged by a lawyer admitted to the Council of State and the Court of Cassation, the appeal is not admissible”, and the question falls with it (Cass. 2e civ., 13 March 2025, No. 24-50.042, our translation).
In criminal matters, observations are signed by such a lawyer, except for the convicted person, the civil party in press matters and the appellant in the cases referred to in the text (Article R.* 49-30 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which refers to Article 585). A submission signed by a lawyer who is not an avocat aux Conseils is inadmissible (Cass. crim., 20 October 2026, No. 26-84.940).
Before the Council of State, the exemption from representation before the court that transmitted the question also applies to the observations; otherwise, they are presented by an avocat aux Conseils (Article R.* 771-20 of the Code of Administrative Justice), as, in principle, are the application and submissions (Article R. 432-1), subject to the exemptions in Article R. 432-2. The firm is not an avocat aux Conseils and does not sign in that lawyer's place; it can prepare the file for the avocat aux Conseils instructed in the case. Before the Constitutional Council, lawyers present their oral observations themselves (internal rules of procedure, Article 10).
What can you do if the judge refuses to transmit the QPC?
There is no immediate remedy. The refusal “can be challenged only in an appeal against the decision settling all or part of the dispute” (Article 23-2 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958, our translation). An appeal or a cassation appeal directed against the refusal alone fails: “the appeal to the Court of Cassation against the judgment refusing to transmit a QPC is inadmissible” (Cass. crim., 9 January 2018, No. 17-86.231, our translation), and the Paris Court of Appeal takes the same view for an appeal (CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 16 May 2025, No. 20/05553).
The refusal divests the court of the plea, although it may be revoked where it rests solely on the text being inapplicable and the judge ultimately intends to apply it (Article 126-6 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Article R.* 771-10 of the Code of Administrative Justice). The challenge is then made in a new separate and reasoned written submission, in the appeal on the merits (Article 126-2, Article R.* 49-29 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
The administrative courts set a timetable: in support of the main appeal, the challenge is presented before the time limit for appealing or bringing proceedings expires, together with a copy of the refusal decision (Article R.* 771-12, Article R.* 771-16). The respondent to the appeal may bring it “with no time limit”, always by a separate and reasoned submission (CE, 30 November 2020, No. 443970, our translation). The Council of State declared a challenge inadmissible for lack of a separate submission (CE, 21 June 2021, No. 445346), and refused to refer a question taken up again at the cassation stage by a company that had not challenged the refusal on appeal (CE, 30 November 2020, No. 443970).
A refusal by the Council of State or the Court of Cassation to refer the matter to the Constitutional Council “is not open to any appeal” (Nouveaux Cahiers du Conseil constitutionnel, No. 29, our translation): the argument on the merits of the dispute and, where relevant, the treaty-compatibility plea then remain available.
Can you intervene before the French Constitutional Council without being a party, and how does the hearing work?
A person “showing a special interest” may submit observations in intervention before the date set by the notice of referral and stated on the Constitutional Council's website (internal rules of procedure, Articles 1 and 6, our translation). Missing that deadline cannot be held against a party whose identical question was not transmitted for that reason. If the intervention is not admitted, the person concerned is informed: the Constitutional Council, for example, refused that of the French Anti-Doping Agency (Agence française de lutte contre le dopage) (decision No. 2014-453/454 QPC and 2015-462 QPC of 18 March 2015).
Before the Council of State, the filter is narrower: an intervention in support of a submission seeking referral is admissible “only on condition that its author has also intervened in the main action” (CE, 12 November 2018, No. 423892, our translation).
The written procedure comes before the hearing. The parties and the authorities submit observations before a date that cannot be postponed, then a reply: “These second observations may have no purpose other than to reply to the first.” (Article 1, our translation). The President of the Republic, the Prime Minister and the presidents of the two assemblies are notified and may also submit observations (Article 23-8 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958).
The hearing is public, save in exceptional cases (Article 23-10), and its broadcast is “shown live in a room open to the public” (Article 8, our translation). After the question has been read out and the procedure summarised, the lawyers present their oral observations (Article 10). The reasoned decision is notified to the parties and published in the Official Journal (Article 23-11).
What does the Constitutional Council's decision change for my case?
There are three possible outcomes. The provision may be declared constitutional: it continues to apply, the dispute resumes, and the question can only come back if there is a change in circumstances. It may be declared constitutional subject to a reservation: the judge then applies it in the meaning laid down. For tax fraud, where the tax penalties of Article 1729 and the criminal penalties of Article 1741 of the General Tax Code are combined, the provisions of the latter article, under the reservation adopted, “apply only to the most serious cases of fraudulent concealment of sums subject to tax” (decision No. 2016-545 QPC of 24 June 2016, our translation).
Finally, it may be declared unconstitutional. It is then repealed on publication or at a later date, and the Constitutional Council determines the conditions and limits within which past effects may be called into question (Article 62 of the Constitution). It has the “power both to set the date of repeal and to defer its effects over time, and to provide for the effects that the provision produced before that declaration to be called into question” (decision No. 2026-1203 QPC of 5 June 2026, our translation).
The outcome therefore varies from one decision to another. In 2026, the declaration was held “applicable to all cases not finally decided on the date of publication of this decision” (decision No. 2026-1203 QPC of 5 June 2026, our translation). In 2010, by contrast, the postponement to 1 July 2011 precluded challenges on the ground of that unconstitutionality to police custody measures already taken under the provisions concerned (decision No. 2010-14/22 QPC of 30 July 2010). A decision that is favourable in principle may therefore have no immediate effect on the case of the person who obtained it.
Compensation also requires the conditions set by the Council of State, including proof of the loss and of the causal link (CE, Ass., 24 December 2019, No. 425983).
When should you raise a QPC rather than another plea?
When the applicable text really is the source of the problem, and no other plea is enough to set it aside. If the procedure is irregular, if the text does not apply to the facts or if evidence is lacking, those pleas can succeed directly, and they must still be set out in the main pleadings. A question added to those pleas does not replace them.
The comparison with treaty-compatibility review deserves separate examination. The judge hearing the dispute can set aside a statute contrary to a treaty, even one declared constitutional (decision No. 2010-605 DC of 12 May 2010), and EU law allows the judge to disapply the text or to refer a question to the Court of Justice (CJEU, Melki and Abdeli). The court seised may also “immediately suspend any possible effect of the statute that is incompatible with EU law” (decision No. 2010-605 DC of 12 May 2010, our translation). The example of police custody shows what is at stake: the Constitutional Council had postponed the repeal (decision No. 2010-14/22 QPC of 30 July 2010), whereas the full court (assemblée plénière) of the Court of Cassation applied Article 6 of the Convention, holding that the States party to it “are bound to respect the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights, without waiting to be challenged before it or to have amended their legislation” (Cass. ass. plén., 15 April 2011, No. 10-17.049, our translation).
The question does, however, have an advantage of its own: the repealed provision disappears from the legal order (Nouveaux Cahiers du Conseil constitutionnel, No. 29). It does depend on successive filters, though, and the statistics call for caution. According to the Constitutional Council's statistical report, from 1 March 2010 to 30 June 2026 it received 676 referrals from the Court of Cassation and 558 from the Council of State, and it counts 697 decisions of conformity, 269 of total non-conformity, 79 of partial non-conformity and 46 other outcomes. These figures say nothing about any given case. Both pleas can be presented in the same proceedings, each in its own form, with the judge ruling first on the transmission of the question (Article 23-2 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958). The firm examines how they fit together before anything is filed.
Can my lawyer ask another lawyer to prepare the QPC?
Yes. The texts governing the question do not reserve the drafting of the written submission to the lawyer who has handled the case from the start. What matters is that the submission is separate, reasoned and presented in the proceedings by a person entitled to do so before that court (Article 23-1 of the Ordinance of 7 November 1958, Article 126-2 of the Code of Civil Procedure).
The division of work is agreed in advance. The lawyer in charge of the dispute keeps control of the case on the merits and of the consistency between the main pleadings and the submission; the colleague consulted assesses whether the question is worth raising, proposes the wording and, where appropriate, prepares the hearing before the Constitutional Council, where lawyers present oral observations (internal rules of procedure, Article 10). Since Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971 requires, as a rule, a written fee agreement, the colleague's involvement and its cost are agreed in writing with the client.
The signature remains a point to check at every stage. Before the Court of Cassation, a submission signed by a lawyer who is not an avocat aux Conseils, in a matter where that signature is required, makes the question inadmissible (Cass. crim., 20 October 2026, No. 26-84.940). The firm reviews a colleague's request on the documents, then says what it can take on. A refusal to transmit calls for the same coordination, since the challenge to it must accompany the appeal on the merits.
What are the fees of a constitutional and QPC lawyer?
Fees are set out in a written agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of the Law of 31 December 1971: before committing, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours fixed fees per stage: assessing whether a question is worth raising, drafting the separate submission, the hearing before the court dealing with the case, challenging a refusal to transmit, written observations and oral argument before the Constitutional Council, intervention by a third party, external contribution. Where the signature of a lawyer admitted to the Council of State and the Court of Cassation is required, that lawyer's fees are agreed with them. Any new engagement is covered by an amendment to the agreement, with no unexpected billing.
For a first opinion on the documents, the preliminary case review at €80 incl. VAT, requested through the form on this page, leads to a written analysis within 24 working hours. It covers the provision at issue, the procedural timetable and the plea that appears best suited. For a first conversation, call +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page, checked on 1 November 2026, and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Articles 61, 61-1 and 62 of the Constitution: a priori review, priority preliminary ruling, effects of decisions
- Articles 23-1, 23-2, 23-3, 23-4, 23-5, 23-7, 23-8, 23-9, 23-10 and 23-11 of Ordinance No. 58-1067 of 7 November 1958: rules governing the QPC
- Internal rules on the procedure followed before the Constitutional Council for priority preliminary rulings on constitutionality: observations, intervention, hearing, rectification
- Articles 126-2, 126-3, 126-5, 126-6, 126-7, 126-9, 126-10, 126-11, 126-12 and 973 of the Code of Civil Procedure: separate submission, transmission, representation
- Articles R.* 49-21, R.* 49-22, R.* 49-24, R.* 49-25, R.* 49-27, R.* 49-29, R.* 49-30, R.* 49-31, R.* 49-32 and 585 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: separate submission, judicial investigation, signature. Articles R.* 49-22 and 585, in force on the date of this page, are shown on Légifrance as repealed with effect from 1 January 2029
- Articles R.* 771-3, R.* 771-5, R.* 771-6, R.* 771-9, R.* 771-10, R.* 771-12, R.* 771-16, R.* 771-17, R.* 771-20, R. 432-1 and R. 432-2 of the Code of Administrative Justice: separate submission, refusal, observations, lawyer
- Article 111-5 of the Criminal Code: review by the criminal courts of the lawfulness of administrative acts
- Twelve questions and answers on the priority preliminary ruling on constitutionality, Nouveaux Cahiers du Conseil constitutionnel, No. 29, October 2010, to be read with decision No. 2020-843 QPC on unratified ordinances
- Press release of 24 May 2019 and press release on decision No. 2022-152 ORGA of 11 March 2022: external contributions, rules of procedure for a priori review
- Statistical report of the Constitutional Council, data as at 30 June 2026
- CJEU, Grand Chamber, 22 June 2010, Melki and Abdeli, C-188/10 and C-189/10: priority mechanism and EU law
- Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: fee agreement
Decisions cited
- decision No. 2009-595 DC of 3 December 2009: change in circumstances
- decision No. 2010-605 DC of 12 May 2010: constitutionality and treaty compatibility
- decision No. 2010-5 QPC of 18 June 2010: the legislature's failure to exercise its own powers (incompétence négative)
- decision No. 2010-8 QPC of 18 June 2010: reservation on inexcusable fault
- decision No. 2010-14/22 QPC of 30 July 2010: police custody, postponed repeal
- decision No. 2010-39 QPC of 6 October 2010: settled case-law interpretation
- decision No. 2014-453/454 QPC and 2015-462 QPC of 18 March 2015: insider dealing offence and breach, intervention not admitted
- decision No. 2016-545 QPC of 24 June 2016: tax fraud, reservations
- decision No. 2018-717/718 QPC of 6 July 2018: principle of fraternity, effects over time
- decision No. 2020-843 QPC of 28 May 2020: unratified ordinance
- decision No. 2026-1203 QPC of 5 June 2026: garnishee, effects on pending cases
- Cass. ass. plén., 15 April 2011, No. 10-17.049: applying the Convention without waiting
- Cass. 2e civ., 2 March 2023, No. 21-11.499: a judge who does not rule on transmission
- Cass. crim., 9 January 2018, No. 17-86.231: no cassation appeal against the refusal alone
- Cass. crim., 7 May 2019, No. 19-90.011: question raised during a judicial investigation
- Cass. soc., 9 May 2018, No. 18-40.007: no settled interpretation
- Cass. crim., 5 April 2022, No. 22-80.434: settled interpretation and change in circumstances
- Cass. 2e civ., 13 March 2025, No. 24-50.042: cassation appeal not lodged by a lawyer admitted to the Council of State and the Court of Cassation (avocat aux Conseils)
- Cass. crim., 20 October 2026, No. 26-84.940: submission not signed by a lawyer admitted to the Council of State and the Court of Cassation (avocat aux Conseils)
- Cass. crim., 19 November 2025, No. 25-84.362: no separate submission
- Cass. soc., 17 December 2025, No. 25-40.032: case not communicated to the public prosecution service
- Cass. crim., 9 September 2026, No. 26-90.015: departmental criminal court and the procedure specific to the assize court
- Cass. crim., 25 February 2025, No. 24-86.402: text of a regulatory nature
- Cass. com., 11 March 2026, No. 25-40.034: referral, penalty on the garnishee
- CA Paris, pôle 6, ch. 12, 16 May 2025, No. 20/05553: no appeal against the refusal alone
- CE, 21 June 2021, No. 445346: challenging the refusal to transmit
- CE, 30 November 2020, No. 443970: refusal not challenged on appeal
- CE, 12 November 2018, No. 423892: intervention in support of a question
- CE, Ass., 24 December 2019, No. 425983: State liability for an unconstitutional statute
A law to challenge during your case, or a QPC to defend?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send the decision or document applying the text, the pleadings exchanged, the procedural timetable and, if there is one, the refusal to transmit: Hassan Kohen reviews the provision, the decisions already handed down and the possible effect on your dispute, then tells you the appropriate route, whether a separate submission, a challenge to the refusal, an intervention before the Constitutional Council or another plea.