The firm in the media
Watch the videos and read their transcriptsVideos
Kohen Avocats, health law in Paris
Medical negligence lawyer in Paris: patients, families and health law
Access to medical records refused, a medical error, a no-fault medical accident, an infection caught in hospital, hospitalisation without consent, an end-of-life decision: our medical negligence lawyer in Paris defends patients and their relatives before the ordinary courts (juge judiciaire), the administrative courts and the conciliation and compensation commission (commission de conciliation et d'indemnisation, CCI).
The firm can be reached 24/7. Two situations cannot wait: inpatient psychiatric care without consent, which a judge must review before the twelve-day period expires, and a decision to withdraw treatment, which can be brought before the judge hearing urgent applications (juge des référés).
4,9/5
Average Google rating270 reviews
I received very high-quality support from this criminal lawyer. His professionalism, his complete command of the case and his constant involvement at every stage of the proceedings deserve to be highlighted. Communication was clear, structured and responsive, with precise advice suited to my situation. I recommend this lawyer to anyone looking for a rigorous and effective defence in criminal law.
Mr Kohen handled my criminal case. I am very satisfied with the work he did and I recommend him without any hesitation.
Excellent criminal defence lawyer. He got me out of trouble in a protection order case brought abusively by my ex
Very satisfied with the solution found for my defence before the court. All the best
Hassan Kohen is a young, seasoned and highly competent lawyer. He is an excellent listener, with great empathy and a strong human sensitivity. Available and responsive, he has complete command of his profession.
I had a very good experience with Hassan Kohen. He took the time to listen carefully and to fully understand my situation. He is a lawyer who gives sound advice, caring and available, and who knows how to steer his clients in the right direction. I recommend him without hesitation to anyone looking for an attentive and competent professional.
Mr Kohen advised and supported us well. I thank him for everything he did.
Paris Bar
Urgent matters 24/7
Preliminary case review
Send your documents. Receive an analysis.
Hassan Kohen
Lawyer (avocat) at the Paris Bar, patients' rights, medical and hospital liability.
Official profile in the directory of French lawyers (CNB) · 4.9/5 on Google (270 reviews)
Page updated on 12 October 2026.
Our health law practice areas
Medical malpractice lawyer: help for your situation
Pharmacy owners (pharmaciens titulaires), pharmacies and laboratories: see how we assist in pharmaceutical law to prepare your project or your defence.
Quick answer
A health lawyer defends the patient or their family against a doctor, a private clinic, a public hospital or ONIAM, the French national office that compensates medical accidents. The competent court depends on where the care was given: the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire) for a doctor in private practice or a clinic, the administrative court for a public hospital, after a prior claim. Liability in principle requires fault; however, the healthcare facility is strictly liable for hospital-acquired (nosocomial) infections, and serious no-fault medical accidents are compensated through national solidarity. The limitation period is ten years from the stabilisation of the injury (consolidation). The firm also acts on access to medical records, psychiatric care without consent and end-of-life decisions. For a first conversation, call +33 6 89 11 34 45.
Medical records refused, an expert assessment to prepare, an urgent medical decision?
Understanding your situation
Medical negligence compensation and health law, explained
Health law brings together the rules of the French Public Health Code (Code de la santé publique), the rules of civil liability and those of administrative litigation. It protects patients before, during and after treatment: information, consent, access to records, compensation for harm, review of deprivations of liberty, respect for their wishes at the end of life. This page presents the subject and the common procedures; two urgent situations have their own page, compulsory hospitalisation and withdrawal of treatment. The firm's other areas of practice are listed on the practice areas page.
Key points
Patients' rights, the foundation of health law
What the Public Health Code guarantees to everyone receiving care.
To be informed about your state of health, the treatments proposed, their frequent or serious risks that are normally foreseeable, and the other possible options (Article L. 1111-2).
To undergo no procedure without freely given and informed consent, which can be withdrawn at any time, and to be able to refuse treatment (Article L. 1111-4).
To access your medical records within eight days of the request at the latest, or within two months for information more than five years old (Article L. 1111-7).
To appoint a trusted person (personne de confiance) and to draw up advance directives, which are binding on the doctor except in the cases provided for by law (Article L. 1111-6 and Article L. 1111-11).
To have any inpatient psychiatric care without consent reviewed by a judge of the judicial court before the twelve-day period expires (Article L. 3211-12-1).
These rights are not merely theoretical. A breach opens specific remedies: a court order to disclose the records, compensation for a failure to inform, the lifting of an irregular measure (mainlevée), suspension of a medical decision by the urgent applications judge (juge des référés). The first appointment serves to identify the remedy that fits your situation and the court before which it is brought.
Two courts
Public hospital or private clinic: which court?
The place of treatment takes precedence over the seriousness of the harm in determining the procedure.
Care in a public hospital
- The hospital's liability is decided by the administrative court (tribunal administratif).
- A prior compensation claim is sent to the hospital before any application to the court (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice).
- Referral to the conciliation and compensation commission naming the hospital counts as a prior claim (CE, 7 June 2023).
Care in a private clinic or private practice
- The liability of the practitioner, the clinic and their insurers is decided by the judicial court (tribunal judiciaire).
- An expert assessment may be ordered before any trial if there is a legitimate reason to establish evidence of the facts (Article 145 of the Code of Civil Procedure).
- The urgent applications judge may award an interim payment where the obligation is not seriously disputable (Article 835 of the same code).
Where several parties are involved, for example a doctor in private practice and a public hospital, two separate procedures may be needed. The status of each one is analysed before any claim is filed.
Whichever route applies, the conciliation and compensation commission remains open:
Compensation
Obtaining compensation: fault, infection and no-fault medical accidents
Several regimes coexist; the right legal basis determines the compensation.
Fault-based liability
Healthcare professionals and facilities are liable for the consequences of preventive, diagnostic or treatment procedures only in the event of fault: misdiagnosis, a poorly performed procedure, inadequate monitoring (Article L. 1142-1, I).
Hospital-acquired infections
The facility is liable unless it proves an external cause (cause étrangère); where permanent impairment exceeds 25%, or in the event of death, national solidarity takes over (Article L. 1142-1-1).
No-fault medical accidents
Where there is no fault, ONIAM compensates abnormal harm that reaches the severity threshold: permanent impairment above 24%, or six months off work or with a temporary functional impairment of at least 50% (Article D. 1142-1).
Failure to inform
A patient who was not warned of a risk that then materialised can claim a loss of chance of refusing the procedure and harm arising from lack of preparation (préjudice d'impréparation), distinct from the bodily injury.
These regimes can be combined. Where a fault only caused the loss of a chance to avoid a medical accident, ONIAM tops up the compensation, after deducting what the liable party owes (Cass. 1re civ., 24 April 2024, No. 23-11.059).
Timeline
From injury to compensation: how a claim unfolds
The typical stages of a medical liability claim, with their time limits.
Request for the medical records
Disclosure within eight days at the latest, or two months for information more than five years old, after a forty-eight-hour reflection period.
Medico-legal review
Review of the file with a doctor who advises victims (médecin conseil de victimes): possible breach, causation, severity, applicable regime.
Choice of route
Conciliation and compensation commission, prior claim to the public hospital or expert assessment through urgent proceedings (référé) before the judicial court, depending on where the care was given.
Expert assessment
The expert assessment describes the care, finds or rules out fault, sets the date when the injury stabilises (consolidation) and assesses each head of loss.
Opinion, offer or judgment
The commission gives its opinion within six months of the referral; the insurer or ONIAM makes an offer within four months of the opinion. Failing agreement, the court decides.
Limitation period
Ten years from the consolidation of the injury, against professionals and public or private facilities as well as before ONIAM (Article L. 1142-28).
Preparing the case
Documents to gather
What makes it possible to assess a situation from the first review.
The medical records: operation and hospitalisation reports, monitoring charts, prescriptions, test results.
The information and consent documents given or signed before the procedure.
Later medical certificates describing the lasting effects and how they have developed.
Sick notes, health insurance statements and proof of income before and after the events.
Invoices and out-of-pocket expenses: treatment, travel, personal assistance and home adaptations.
For a relative hospitalised without consent or approaching the end of life: admission decisions, certificates, advance directives and the appointment of a trusted person.
Send what you have, even if incomplete: the firm helps you obtain the missing documents from the facility, through the courts if necessary. For a first conversation, call +33 6 89 11 34 45.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Thirteen answers based on the legislation in force, checked on Légifrance, and on decisions of the French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) and the Council of State (Conseil d'État).
When should I consult a health lawyer in France?
As early as possible, and always before signing anything with an insurer or a healthcare facility. The situations that call for advice are fairly clear: harm after a procedure, a delayed diagnosis, an infection acquired during a hospital stay, refusal to disclose medical records, a relative admitted to psychiatric care against their wishes, or a decision to limit or withdraw treatment that the family does not understand.
The first task is to identify the legal nature of the situation: fault, a no-fault medical accident, a hospital-acquired infection, failure to inform or an irregularity in a measure imposing care without consent. Each is governed by a specific provision of the French Public Health Code, in particular Article L. 1142-1 on medical liability, and comes before a different court depending on whether the care was provided in a public hospital or a private clinic.
Serious personal injury cases follow the approach described on our personal injury lawyer page; abuse in care homes for older people is covered on our abuse in care homes (EHPAD) page. For an initial review, the preliminary case review requested through the form costs €80 incl. VAT.
Public hospital or private clinic: which court hears my claim?
Where the care was given determines which court hears the case. Harm caused in a public healthcare facility falls within the administrative court's jurisdiction; harm attributed to a doctor in private practice, a private clinic or their insurers falls within the judicial court's jurisdiction. Where several parties are involved, two sets of proceedings may be necessary.
Before the administrative court, a monetary claim is admissible only after the administration has decided on a prior claim (Article R. 421-1 of the French Code of Administrative Justice). The Council of State accepts that referral to the conciliation and compensation commission, where it names the facility concerned, serves as that prior claim: it “must be regarded, within the meaning and for the purposes of the second paragraph of Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice, as a prior claim submitted to the healthcare facility” (our translation) (CE, 7 June 2023, No. 464883).
Before the judicial court, the usual route begins with an expert assessment ordered in urgent proceedings, before any trial on the merits. The court is therefore chosen at the first appointment, based on the medical reports and each practitioner's status.
How do I obtain my medical records, and what if access is refused?
Article L. 1111-7 of the French Public Health Code gives everyone access to all information about their health held by professionals and facilities: test results, consultation, operation and hospitalisation reports, prescriptions, monitoring charts and correspondence between healthcare professionals. Disclosure must take place within eight days of the request at the latest, after a forty-eight-hour reflection period; the time limit extends to two months where the information is more than five years old.
This right extends beyond the hospital. The Cour de cassation applied it to information gathered by an insurer's medical adviser during an expert assessment, holding that the victim “had a right of access to the health data concerning him and consequently had a legitimate interest in obtaining it” (our translation) (Cass. 2e civ., 30 September 2021, No. 19-25.045).
In practice, make the request in writing and keep a copy. If no response arrives within the time limit, the remedies differ depending on whether the facility is public or private; in all cases, a court can order disclosure. Our article on refusal to disclose medical records explains these steps.
My doctor did not warn me of a risk that materialised: can I claim compensation?
Yes, subject to conditions. Article L. 1111-2 of the French Public Health Code requires patients to be informed about proposed treatments, their usefulness, their consequences, the frequent or serious risks that are normally foreseeable and the other possible options. Only urgency or an inability to provide information dispenses with this duty. In a dispute, the professional or facility must prove, by any means, that the information was given.
The breach gives rise to two distinct heads of loss. The first is the loss of a chance to refuse the procedure had the information been given. The second is non-pecuniary: the Cour de cassation holds that, where the risk materialises, the breach causes the patient “non-pecuniary harm distinct from the bodily injuries suffered, resulting from a lack of preparation for the possibility of that risk materialising” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 23 January 2019, No. 18-10.706).
The case is built from the documents signed before the procedure, consultation reports and exchanges with the medical team. A generic consent form does not always establish that the specific risk was explained.
What is the conciliation and compensation commission (CCI)?
The conciliation and compensation commission, usually called the CCI, offers an out-of-court route to anyone who considers that they have suffered harm attributable to preventive care, diagnosis or treatment, and to those entitled to claim following a death (Article L. 1142-7 of the French Public Health Code). Referral suspends limitation periods and time limits for court proceedings until the procedure ends.
Where the harm reaches the statutory severity threshold, the commission gives an opinion on the circumstances, causes, extent of the harm and applicable compensation regime within six months of referral (Article L. 1142-8). If it finds fault, the liable party's insurer must make an offer within four months of the opinion; if it finds a no-fault accident, ONIAM must do so.
The opinion can only be challenged in the course of a compensation claim brought before a court. The procedure remains useful because it produces, without a trial, a reasoned opinion on the causes and extent of the harm. The firm prepares the referral, assists the victim at every stage and negotiates the offer under each head of loss.
Can ONIAM compensate me for a no-fault medical accident?
Yes, where three conditions are met: the harm is directly attributable to treatment, its consequences are abnormal in relation to the patient's state of health and its foreseeable development, and it reaches the severity threshold set by decree (Article L. 1142-1, II). That threshold is permanent impairment above 24%, or an interruption of work or temporary functional impairment of at least 50% for six consecutive months or six non-consecutive months over twelve months (Article D. 1142-1).
Abnormality is assessed using two criteria that the Cour de cassation keeps distinct. It is established, in particular, “where the medical procedure has had consequences markedly more serious than those to which the patient was exposed with sufficient probability in the absence of treatment” (our translation) or, failing that, where the harm had a low probability of occurring (Cass. 1re civ., 15 October 2025, No. 24-14.186).
Compensation through national solidarity remains subsidiary: “compensation through national solidarity is subsidiary and is excluded where fault is the cause of the bodily injury suffered by the patient” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 24 April 2024, No. 23-11.059). The same judgment allows supplementary compensation from ONIAM where the fault only caused the loss of a chance to avoid the accident.
I caught an infection in a hospital or clinic: do I have to prove fault?
No. Article L. 1142-1 of the French Public Health Code makes healthcare facilities, services and organisations liable for harm resulting from hospital-acquired infections unless they prove an external cause. The victim establishes the infection and its connection with the care received; they do not have to prove a failure in hygiene.
This strict liability extends beyond hospitals. The Cour de cassation applied it to a stand-alone cosmetic surgery facility, reiterating that such facilities “are liable for harm resulting from hospital-acquired infections unless they prove an external cause” (our translation) (Cass. 1re civ., 8 December 2021, No. 19-26.191).
For the most serious infections, a different body pays compensation: Article L. 1142-1-1 provides for compensation through national solidarity for hospital-acquired infections causing permanent impairment above 25%, and for deaths caused by such infections. Identifying who must pay at the outset avoids bringing proceedings against the wrong party.
What is the time limit for a medical negligence claim in France?
Liability claims against healthcare professionals and public or private facilities, and compensation claims submitted to ONIAM, are time-barred ten years after the injury stabilises (consolidation) (Article L. 1142-28 of the French Public Health Code). Consolidation is the point at which the victim's condition stops changing; the expert determines this date.
This long period is no reason to wait. Medical records become harder to complete over time, witnesses forget, and certain routes have their own requirements: before the administrative court, an application follows a decision by the hospital on the prior claim; in urgent proceedings, an expert assessment requires a legitimate reason.
Referral to the conciliation and compensation commission suspends the limitation period until its procedure ends. Before taking any step, the firm reconstructs the treatment timeline and checks the consolidation date already set or still to be determined.
What is loss of chance in a French medical liability claim?
Loss of chance is the harm compensated where fault did not cause the entire injury but deprived the patient of a real opportunity to avoid it or reduce its severity: a delayed diagnosis, inadequate monitoring or a late referral. The award is calculated as a proportion of the compensation for the bodily injury.
The Council of State defines it as follows: “the harm resulting directly from the facility's fault, which must be fully compensated, is not the bodily injury established but the loss of a chance to avoid that injury occurring” (our translation) (CE, 18 March 2019, No. 417635). In that case, however, it held that the injury, which would not have occurred without the fault, had to be compensated in full.
This point is decisive: presenting a case as a mere loss of chance when the fault directly caused the injury means accepting partial compensation. Our article on loss of chance in medical liability reviews recent decisions.
A relative is in psychiatric care without consent: what can a lawyer do?
Inpatient psychiatric care without consent cannot continue unless a judge of the judicial court has ruled before twelve days have elapsed since admission (Article L. 3211-12-1 of the French Public Health Code). An application to lift the measure can also be made at any time, notably by the hospitalised person, their spouse, a relative or someone able to act in their interests (Article L. 3211-12).
The review concerns the necessity and lawfulness of the measure: medical certificates, time limits and notification of rights. However, an irregularity only leads to the measure being lifted if it has infringed the person's rights (Article L. 3216-1). The Cour de cassation reiterated this when quashing a decision made although “the lifting of the measure could not be ordered without establishing a concrete infringement of the rights” (our translation) of the patient (Cass. 1re civ., 15 September 2021, No. 20-15.610).
The lawyer's role is therefore to demonstrate that concrete infringement. Our compulsory hospitalisation lawyer page explains the hearing and remedies.
Can the family challenge a decision to withdraw treatment?
Treatment amounting to unreasonable persistence (obstination déraisonnable), because it appears futile, disproportionate or serves only to sustain life artificially, may be withdrawn or withheld (Article L. 1110-5-1 of the French Public Health Code). Where the patient cannot express their wishes, the decision follows a collective medical decision-making procedure, respects advance directives or, in their absence, requires consultation of the trusted person or, failing that, the family or relatives (Article L. 1111-4).
The decision can be challenged before the urgent applications judge under Article L. 521-2 of the French Code of Administrative Justice. The Council of State then carries out a particular review, “balancing the fundamental rights at issue, namely the right to respect for life and the patient's right to consent to medical treatment and not to undergo treatment resulting from unreasonable persistence” (our translation) (CE, juge des référés, 30 June 2026, No. 516675).
These cases are handled within days and with restraint. Our withdrawal of treatment lawyer page explains the collective medical decision-making procedure and urgent proceedings.
What does the French assisted dying law of 18 August 2026 provide?
Law No. 2026-794 of 18 August 2026 created a right to assisted dying, incorporated into the French Public Health Code and in force since 20 August 2026. To qualify, a person must, among other conditions, be at least eighteen years old, have a serious and incurable life-threatening condition at an advanced or terminal stage, experience suffering that is resistant to treatment or that they consider unbearable, and be able to express a freely given and informed choice; psychological suffering alone is insufficient (Article L. 1111-12-2).
The doctor decides after a collective medical decision-making procedure and notifies their reasoned decision within fifteen days of the request being formalised. Only the person who made the request may challenge that decision before the administrative courts, including through an urgent application to protect a fundamental right (référé-liberté); the person responsible for a protective measure may challenge an authorisation within two days (Article L. 1111-12-10).
The firm answers patients' and families' questions about this new legislation, keeping to its wording: case law has not yet had time to develop.
How much does a health lawyer charge in France?
Fees are set out in a written fee agreement, in accordance with Article 10 of Law No. 71-1130 of 31 December 1971: before you commit, you know what the engagement covers and what it costs.
The firm favours fees per stage: review of the medical records, a prior claim or referral to the conciliation and compensation commission, assistance at the expert assessment, proceedings on the merits and negotiation of the offer. Any new engagement is covered by an amendment.
The preliminary case review requested through the form on this page costs €80 incl. VAT and results in a written analysis. Legal aid (aide juridictionnelle) is available subject to means testing; the firm tells you whether you qualify. For a first conversation, call +33 6 89 11 34 45.
References
Official texts and related pages
The sources for this page and the firm's related areas of practice.
Official texts
- Article L. 1111-2 of the French Public Health Code, patient information
- Article L. 1111-4 of the French Public Health Code, consent and refusal of treatment
- Article L. 1111-7 of the French Public Health Code, access to medical records
- Article L. 1142-1 of the French Public Health Code, medical liability and national solidarity
- Article L. 1142-7 of the French Public Health Code, referral to the conciliation and compensation commission
- Article L. 1142-28 of the French Public Health Code, ten-year limitation period
- Article L. 3211-12-1 of the French Public Health Code, review of hospitalisation without consent
- Article L. 1110-5-1 of the French Public Health Code, unreasonable persistence in treatment
- Article L. 1111-12-10 of the French Public Health Code, remedies concerning assisted dying
- Article R. 421-1 of the French Code of Administrative Justice, prior claim
A question about health law?
The firm can be reached 24/7. Send your medical records, the correspondence exchanged and the decisions received: Hassan Kohen tells you which route to take, before which court and within what time limit, whether you are the patient or a relative.



