Administrative United Kingdom
EA & Ors v The Entry Clearance Officer
First-tier Tribunal(Immigration and Asylum Chamber)Appeal Number: HU/63291/2024 HU/63293/2024 HU/63294/2024 THE IMMIGRATION ACTS Heard at Hatton Cross (Hybrid Hearing)On 18 August 2026 Before FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL JUDGE Seelhoff Between EA WA TA(ANONYMITY ORDER MADE) Appellants and THE ENTRY CLEARANCE OFFICER Respondent Representation: For the Appellant:Dr Rashimi, Counsel instructed by Allied Law Chambers Solicitors (joined by video link) For the Respondent:Ms Skinner, Home Office Presenting Officer DECISION AND REASONS
1. This is the decision of the Tribunal in the appeal of the Appellants against the decisions of the Respondent made on 18 September 2024 to refuse the Appellants’ entry clearance applications to join FA in the UK. FA is a refugee and is the adult son of EA and the older brother of WA and TA. WA and TA were minors at the date of application but WA turned 18 this year. The applications were made as family reunion applications and the refusals constitute Human Rights decisions and accordingly attract rights of appeal. Anonymity
2. In making this decision I have considered that justice being administered openly and in public is a fundamental tenet of the justice system but it may be qualified by the interests of the parties and family members. I have decided to make an anonymity direction because FA is a recognised refugee and there may be risks associated with publicising his identity as well as identifying the Appellants one of whom is a minor still. Background
3. The family consisted of EA’s husband, 4 sons (including FA, WA and TA) and a daughter (AA). EA’s husband, the father of the remaining Appellants and FA is said to have been missing since 2018. FA fled Syria in 2021 fearing military service and came to the UK where he was recognised as a Refugee.
4. On the 6th February 2024 the Appellants all applied for family reunion to join FA in the UK along with AA. The applications were refused with the Respondent noting that none of the Appellants were related to the Sponsor in a way that was recognised under Appendix Family Reunion of the Immigration Rules.
5. The Respondent went on to consider if there were compelling or compassionate factors which meant that the applications ought to be allowed and concluded that there were not.
6. The Sponsor lodged appeals for the Appellants. He believed he had appealed for AA but no appeal has been received by the tribunal and accordingly the tribunal has no jurisdiction to consider an appeal for her.
7. No evidence was filed in support of the appeal prior to August 2026. On the 11th of August 2026 Allied Law Chambers put themselves on record as acting having apparently been instructed on the 1st of August 2026.
8. On the 11th August 2026 Allied Law Chambers contacted the tribunal seeking clarification in respect of whether there was an appeal for AA or if there was a record of an attempted appeal. I note that the tribunal’s system deletes unsubmitted appeals after a short period of time for reasons of data protection so there would be no records at this time if the appeal was started but never completed. I have found no records of any live appeal for AA.
9. On the 17th August 2026 Allied Law Chambers uploaded a bundle of evidence including a statement for FA and a skeleton argument. There was a request for these to be admitted but no reference was made to the Practice Direction of November 2024 which provides that evidence should be submitted 5 working days before the hearing. New Material
10. FA’s statement discloses significant new information. FA asserts that on or around 10 June 2026 the family had found out that FA’s father had been detained by an extremist armed group and had been implicated in land fraud relating to land being taken from a mosque where he had been a trustee. FA asserts that a Fatwa was declared against his family in June 2026 and they were excluded from the community which has forced them to go to a Refugee camp on the border where they are said to be living in a tent.
11. FA asserts he has lost all contact with his family but that he is pursuing the appeal.
12. FA also asserts that his mother has had significant poor health for many years.
13. The papers now submitted include a document declaring EA’s husband missing from 2018, a family registration certificate, a medical letter in respect of EA, a letter declaring EA was living without a “breadwinner”, a page of FA’s council tenancy book, photographs of the Appellants apparently in a tent in the camp, and messages between FA and the Appellants. The Hearing
14. On the morning of the hearing counsel contacted the hearing centre care of her clerks to note that the hearing notices she had been provided indicated that the hearing was to be heard remotely and that she had just been advised it was listed face to face which caused difficulties as she was 3 hours away. I confirmed that a number of the notices of hearing had been issued with incorrect details and agreed that she should be allowed to attend remotely.
15. The hearing took place face to face. It was recorded using the Cloud Video Platform. That recording is the record of proceedings and should be consulted in the event of any dispute about what was said at the hearing.
16. At the outset of the hearing I made the parties aware that the decision in the appeal might be published.
17. I clarified the issue with late service of the evidence and Dr Rashimi indicated that it was due to solicitors being instructed late and applied for the new documents to be admitted.
18. Ms Skinner confirmed that she had reviewed the documents and was happy for them to be admitted. I asked her to confirm that that meant she was consenting to any “new matter” arising being considered by me in the appeal and she confirmed that she was.
19. I confirmed for Dr Rashimi’s benefit that there was no appeal for AA and that the tribunal did not have the power to make a decision with reference to her in those circumstances.
20. I reviewed the issues and asked if the Appellants accepted that they did not meet the Immigration Rules and Dr Rashimi confirmed that it was accepted that they did not meet the rules and that the case was being argued “outside” the rules only. Issues
21. The parties agreed that the issues the Tribunal must decide are (a) Is there protected family life between the Appellant’s in accordance with IA [2025] EWCA Civ 1516. (b) Would the appellant's removal give rise to unjustifiably harsh consequences such that it is disproportionate and therefore unlawful under section 6 of the Human Rights Act 1998? Evidence
22. The Sponsor was the sole witness and gave evidence with the assistance of an Arabic interpreter. He adopted the evidence of his statement and was asked some supplementary evidence before being cross examined and re-examined. Legal Framework
23. The relevant provisions of the Immigration Rules in this appeal are appendix Family Reunion, save that it is accepted that those requirements are not met. It is not suggested that the requirements of Appendix Adult Dependent Relative are met in respect of EA or WA.
24. In so far as they rely on article 8 outside the Rules it is for the appellant to show that article 8(1) of the ECHR is engaged and if so, it is for the respondent to show that the decision was in accordance with the law, made in pursuance of a legitimate aim and that it was proportionate to the legitimate aim. The standard of proof is the balance of probabilities. Sections 117A to 117D of the 2002 Act are relevant to any assessment under article 8 of the ECHR outside the Rules. Findings
25. I address credibility briefly first. In terms of the Appellants change in circumstances I note that it is extremely recent.
26. In his statement FA said that he had last had contact with his mother on the 9th June 2026. That would be difficult to reconcile with his apparent knowledge of a Fatwa which was allegedly issued on the 10th June 2026 and his possession of photographs of the camp she is said to have fled to on the 10th June 2026.
27. Before me FA said he had paid a lawyer with access to the Israeli controlled territory where the camp is to track his family down and that he had spoken to his mother on the 20th July 2026 on the lawyer’s phone. I do not accept his claim that he only thought he needed to mention contact with his mother on her own phone when talking about his last contact with her. I consider that this is a significant inconsistency in the evidence.
28. There is no apparent mention of medical problems in the original application despite the letter from January 2024 now served suggesting that the problems are long standing. It was suggested before me that this was with the original application but there is no evidence of that before me.
29. There is a “ground of appeal” documents submitted in March 2025 which asserts that medical evidence was submitted but this appears to have been copied from another appeal as it refers to numerous paragraphs and reasons which are not in the decisions.
30. The medical letter does not appear to have been properly translated. The original document contains medical terms in English and as Ms Skinner noted some of those words do not appear in the translation such as a reference to “cognitive behavioural therapy”. The letter also mentions quite extreme conditions including multiple sclerosis, significant sight loss, and an inability to wash, cook, clean or shop. Ms Skinner noted that it is entirely unclear how EA could have coped over the last few years if her conditions are this extreme. I also note that the letter was apparently issued by a specialist hospital in Damascus and says she had visited the hospital several times. If EA had visited the hospital on a number of occasions up until January 2024 it is entirely unclear why that simply stopped and why there is no evidence of any further treatment. I note in particular that Asad’s regime was in place until December 2024 and so the change of regime would not explain this.
31. The grounds of appeal document does not mention the specific medical problems EA is now said to suffer from which is an inconsistency.
32. It is also appropriate to consider the timing of the new evidence being provided. It is hard to see how the appeal could have succeeded prior to this all being served and so it being provided just the day before the hearing is very convenient.
33. I do not find that FA and the Appellant’s have proven that their claims are true on the balance of probabilities. That will inform my assessment of the issues below. Issue (i) – Is there Family Life
34. As confirmed by the Court of Appeal in IA, family life is normally limited to the core family and there will be no family life between parents and adult children or adult siblings unless they can demonstrate additional elements of dependence involving more than the normal emotional ties.
35. To assess whether there is family life I must consider all the circumstances of the case. In terms of FA’s history it is accepted that he was a child and part of the family unit with his mother and siblings when he left Syria. He is however now 22 years old and has lived away from her for five years. In that time WA has also turned 18 and is an adult himself although he remains part of the family unit with the other Appellants.
36. I am told that FA provides emotional support as evidenced by call records. The call records I have provided show snapshots of videochat and call records that cover to 9th November 2023 to 19th July 2025 which means that I have nothing in the last year. The 37 messages shown are mostly short and the record shows just one completed call in 18 months. I do not consider that this shows meaningful or significant contact and support. The sponsor suggested these were just extracts, but that does not add to the limited value of the evidence before me especially given that the Appellants bear the burden of proof.
37. The Sponsor suggested that he sent roughly £1000 a year to his family as a lump sum and had most recently sent money in December 2025. There is no documentary evidence of his ever having had this much money available to send, never mind of his having sent this to Syria.
38. I do not find that the Appellants have proven that there is genuine effective or committed support from the sponsor. I do not find that they have demonstrated that there are currently more than normal emotional ties nor any element of dependency.
39. It follows that I do not find that there is family life between the Appellants and their Sponsor applying the guidance in IA. It follows that the appeal cannot succeed. Issue (ii) – Proportionality
40. I have considered the alternate situation in case I am wrong about the existence of family life.
41. In the first instance I note that I have not accepted that the circumstances have been proven to be as claimed. However even if I had accepted that EA were ill and the family were living in a Refugee camp there would still be issues.
42. It is in the public interest to preserve immigration control. Parliament has determined that adult parents and siblings are not entitled to benefit from family reunion. Adult Dependents need to establish significant health needs with reference to Appendix Adult Dependent Relative of the Rules. Even if there are such high care needs, it also needs to be established that adequate care is not available in the country and EA does have another adult to support her and her minor children in WA who has now turned
18.
43. Comparable to the situation in IA there is no resettlement scheme for Syria. In IA the Court of Appeal noted that; “the positive factors “ did not outweigh the public interest because “the creation in effect of resettlement policies for conflict zones is for the government and parliament”” and the “public interest was to respect the policy decision not to create a resettlement scheme”.” (175)
44. There is one minor Appellant and I acknowledge his best interests might be better served in the UK with the opportunities here than in remaining in Syria but that is not determinative of the appeal given the weight to be given to the public interest. It would not currently be in AA’s best interests to allow the appeals as she does not have an appeal and would face being left behind.
45. The Appellants do not speak English which I am bound to weigh against them. The Sponsor is on Universal Credit and is not currently working. He lives in a one bedroom council flat. I am bound to find that there is neither sufficient means to support the Appellants nor sufficient accommodation available for them. Accordingly allowing these appeals would be likely to result in significant cost to the public purse.
46. In the circumstances of the case even if I had found the Sponsor and the Appellants credible, and accepted that the circumstances of the case were as claimed, I consider that the decision would not have been disproportionate and that the circumstances would not have been sufficiently exceptional or compassionate as to justify my allowing the appeal. I note that even if AA had a valid appeal before me I would have reached the same decision on proportionality. Determination of the Issues
47. There is no basis on which the appeal can succeed. Notice of Decision
48. The appeal is dismissed on all grounds. ANONYMITY ORDER
49. Unless and until the Tribunal, the Upper Tribunal, or, a Court orders otherwise, pursuant To rule 13(1)(b) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Rules 2014, the appellants, AA and FA, are granted anonymity. No-one shall publish or reveal either directly or indirectly any information, including their names or their addresses, that is likely to lead members of the public to identify them. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court. To the Respondent – Fee Award I have dismissed the appeal and therefore there can be no fee award. Signature SignedA.SeelhoffDate 26th August 2026 First-tier Tribunal Judge Seelhoff
For advice on a matter of this kind in France, contact our immigration lawyer in Paris.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).