Civil European Court of Human Rights

AGATONOVIĆ AND OTHERS v. SERBIA

ECLI ECLI:CE:ECHR:2013:1217DEC005989311

 

SECOND SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 59893/11
Stojan AGATONOVIĆ against Serbia
and 101 other applications
(see list appended)

The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 17 December 2013 as a Committee composed of:

Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque, President,

 Dragoljub Popović,

 Helen Keller, judges,

and Stanley Naismith, Section Registrar.

Having regard to the above applications lodged on 12 September 2011,

Having regard to the formal declarations accepting a friendly settlement of the cases,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

FACTS AND PROCEDURE

A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix. They were all represented by the same attorney, Mr M. Moskovljević, a lawyer practising in Kruševac.

The Serbian Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent, Mr S. Carić.

All applicants are former employees of the same socially-owned company – Građevinsko preduzeće Jastrebac – from Kruševac (hereinafter: the debtor). In the course of insolvency proceedings against the debtor on 11 July 2003 the Kraljevo Commercial Court adopted decisions (domestic case no. St.2505/02) according to which the debtor was ordered to pay the applicants certain sums. The applicants complained about the respondent State’s failure to enforce the said decisions rendered in their favour.

After unsuccessful friendly settlement negotiations, by letter dated 9 September 2013 the Government informed the Court that they proposed to make a declaration with a view to resolving the issues raised by the application.

The declaration provided as follows:

“I declare that the Government of the Republic of Serbia is ready to accept that there had been a violation of the applicants’ right under Article 6 paragraph 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention.

I further declare that within three-month period the Government offer to pay to the applicants listed below, the sums awarded in the domestic decisions under consideration in this case, less any amounts which may have already been paid on the basis of the said decisions.

These sums shall be payable within three months from the date of delivery of the decision of the Court. This payment will constitute the final resolution of the case.

The Government regret the occurrence of the actions which have led to the bringing of the present applications.”

On 15 October 2013, the Court received a letter from the applicants’ representative informing the Court that they had agreed to the terms of the Government’s declaration.

THE LAW

The Court considers that, in accordance with Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal background.

The Court finds that following the applicants’ express agreement to the terms of the declaration made by the Government the case should be treated as a friendly settlement between the parties.

The Court takes note of the friendly settlement reached between the parties. It is satisfied that the settlement is based on respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols and finds no reasons to justify a continued examination of the applications. In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the case out of the list.

For these reasons, the Court unanimously

Decides to join the applications;

Decides to strike the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 39 of the Convention.

 Stanley Naismith  Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque
 Registrar President

 

Appendix

 

No

Application No

Applicant

Date of birth

Place of residence

Nationality

  1.  

59893/11

Stojan AGATONOVIĆ

03/03/1956

selo Žiljci,

Serbian

  1.  

25768/12

Radomir PAVLOVIĆ

13/04/1949

selo Čitluk

Serbian

  1.  

25786/12

Živorad MILOJEVIĆ

07/06/1957

selo Čitluk

Serbian

  1.  

25797/12

Milutin PAVLOVIĆ

20/03/1954

selo Šanac

Serbian

  1.  

25807/12

Nikola OJDANIĆ

24/09/1972

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.  

25809/12

Zorica PETRONIJEVIĆ

26/08/1948

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.  

25810/12

Nikolaj NIKOLOV

01/04/1945

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.  

25811/12

Nada NIKOLIĆ

19/01/1947

Kruševac

Serbian

 

  1.  

25812/12

Miroslav POPADIĆ

26/05/1956

selo Šavrane

Serbian

  1.            

25813/12

Milan PEŠIĆ

23/06/1965

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25814/12

Slaviša JEVGENIJEVIĆ

05/06/1974

selo Rosica

Serbian

 

  1.            

25815/12

Miloš BLAGOJEVIĆ

07/02/1951

selo Štitare

Serbian

  1.            

25816/12

Branislav BAJIĆ

26/10/1936

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25817/12

Slavko VOJINOVIĆ

18/05/1946

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25818/12

Boris VIDIĆ

23/02/1944

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25820/12

Jugoslav MATIĆ

28/01/1954

selo Šanac

Serbian

  1.            

25821/12

Mirko VASIĆ

23/10/1944

Kruševac

Serbian

 

  1.            

25822/12

Milivoje BUJIĆ

17/12/1960

Krusevac

Serbian

  1.            

25823/12

Milica BOŠKOVIĆ

10/07/1957

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25830/12

Ljubiša BOŠKOVIĆ

20/08/1960

Prnjavor

Serbian

  1.            

25839/12

Ružica BOGDANOVIĆ

01/02/1947

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25848/12

Nadica BOGDANOVIĆ

23/07/1954

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25851/12

Veroljub VUČKOVIĆ

25/03/1966

selo Prepeljevac

Serbian

  1.            

25857/12

Ankica ĐOKOVIĆ

14/09/1956

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25860/12

Slobodan DUBOVAC

02/04/1940

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25872/12

Miroslav DIŠLJENKOVIĆ

01/01/1961

Kruševac

Serbian

 

  1.            

25878/12

Minko DINOV

24/09/1970

selo Pepeljevac

Serbian

  1.            

25880/12

Ranko DIMITRIJEVIĆ

27/03/1960

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25883/12

Živorad ĐORĐEVIĆ

09/05/1950

selo Dedina

Serbian

  1.            

25904/12

Slobodan ĐORĐEVIĆ

14/04/1945

selo Zabare

Serbian

  1.            

25908/12

Milorad ĐORĐEVIĆ

30/09/1944

selo Lomnica

Serbian

  1.            

25919/12

Dragan ĐORĐEVIĆ

28/10/1955

selo Čitluk

Serbian

  1.            

25924/12

Miroslav NIKOLIĆ

21/06/1952

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25986/12

Slobodan STOJANOVIĆ

02/11/1948

selo Žabare

Serbian

  1.            

25987/12

Simeon STOJANOVIĆ

15/02/1946

selo V. Kruševica

Serbian

 

  1.            

25988/12

Radoslav DINIĆ

21/04/1947

selo Dobromir

Serbian

  1.            

25989/12

Milomir ILIĆ

17/11/1953

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

25991/12

Slobodan ILIĆ

28/10/1949

selo Čitluk

Serbian

  1.            

25992/12

Zoran NEŠIĆ

20/08/1966

selo Konjuh

Serbian

  1.            

25993/12

Mirjana MARIJANOVIĆ

08/09/1964

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26002/12

Ranđel MARINKOVIĆ

05/11/1944

selo V. Kruševica

Serbian

  1.            

26005/12

Božidar DAMNJANOVIĆ

10/10/1941

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26008/12

Veljko NIKOLIĆ

26/04/1962

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26010/12

Dragić ĐORĐEVIĆ

15/09/1955

selo Lepenac

Serbian

 

  1.            

26013/12

Jasmina JANKOVIĆ

31/12/1975

selo Rudjinci

Serbian

  1.            

26014/12

Milan POPOVIĆ

13/12/1954

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26019/12

Golub OJDANIĆ

10/03/1944

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26020/12

Srboljub ĐURĐEVIĆ

24/04/1947

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26026/12

Goran NIKOLIĆ

23/09/1973

selo Gornji Stepoš

Serbian

  1.            

26032/12

Dragan NIKOLIĆ

12/01/1950

selo Mali Šiljegovac

Serbian

  1.            

26034/12

Ružica NESTOROVIĆ

20/10/1951

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26036/12

Petar TRIFUNOVIĆ

21/04/1946

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26041/12

Dobrica MILOJEVIĆ

26/10/1950

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26044/12

Miladin TROŠIĆ

29/11/1962

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26049/12

Svetlana MILOJKOVIĆ

28/02/1949

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26050/12

Živorad ZDRAVKOVIĆ

23/12/1950

selo Zdravinje

Serbian

  1.            

26064/12

Milovan STOJKOVIĆ

02/08/1973

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26069/12

Svetislav IVANOVIĆ

29/03/1974

selo Crkvina

Serbian

  1.            

26073/12

Mirjana IVANOVIĆ

24/11/1959

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26080/12

Živorad IVANOVIĆ

10/08/1946

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26111/12

Zorica ZDRAVKOVIĆ

26/06/1968

selo Lomnica

Serbian

  1.            

26118/12

Saša MILOVANOVIĆ

28/11/1975

selo Vitanovac

Serbian

 

  1.            

26123/12

Milovan JAKOVLJEVIĆ

04/07/1958

selo V. Plana

Serbian

 

  1.            

26131/12

Slobodan ATANASKOVIĆ

05/11/1957

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26137/12

Radmila ANTIĆ

21/04/1946

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26139/12

Ljubomir ALIĆ

01/09/1944

selo Pločnik

Serbian

  1.            

26145/12

Miroljub JOVANOVIĆ

08/11/1972

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26154/12

Bratislav KNEŽEVIĆ

05/05/1957

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26156/12

Branislav KALEZIĆ

06/08/1950

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26160/12

Miodrag KADRIĆ

25/02/1948

selo Pločnik

Serbian

  1.            

26164/12

Ljubisav KOVAČEVIĆ

16/04/1939

Kruševac

Serbian

 

  1.            

26165/12

Slavka KNEŽEVIĆ

23/09/1950

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26166/12

Milomir ŽIVKOVIĆ

12/01/1949

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26167/12

Ljubiša ŽIVOJINOVIĆ

19/07/1942

selo V. Golovode

Serbian

  1.            

26169/12

Momčilo MILJKOVIĆ

23/01/1948

selo Grevci

Serbian

  1.            

26170/12

Boban LISINAC

24/11/1973

Kruševac                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       

Serbian

  1.            

26171/12

Dragan LAZAREVIĆ

14/05/1965

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26174/12

Slavica KUČ

29/05/1949

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26176/12

Branislav JOVANOVIĆ

19/06/1974

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26178/12

Milica STOJANOV

21/08/1948

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26181/12

Ivanca STANKOV

05/12/1952

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26186/12

Miroslav CIVIĆ

29/03/1943

selo Ribare

Serbian

 

  1.            

26188/12

Krstomir ĐORĐEVIĆ

28/02/1951

selo Dedina

Serbian

  1.            

26191/12

Zoran PETROVIĆ

05/06/1953

selo Dvorane

Serbian

  1.            

26194/12

Ljubiša PETRONIJEVIĆ

25/01/1950

selo Sušica

Serbian

  1.            

26198/12

Dušan PETROVIĆ

20/08/1948

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26200/12

Suzana ĆIRIĆ

01/11/1950

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26205/12

Srboljub ĐOKOVIĆ

04/03/1955

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26251/12

Veroljub PANIĆ

10/10/1963

selo Majdevo

Serbian

  1.            

26255/12

Snežana PANTELIĆ

16/11/1976

selo Dvorane

Serbian

  1.            

26276/12

Selena VUČKOVIĆ

20/11/1960

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.            

26278/12

Jovan TOŠIĆ

21/05/1942

selo Dedina

Serbian

  1.            

26281/12

Milomir VUKADINOVIĆ

09/04/1949

selo Sušica

Serbian

  1.            

26282/12

Tomislav PETROVIĆ

07/01/1963

selo Dvorane

Serbian

  1.            

26287/12

Srboljub PETROVIĆ

27/11/1956

Selo Igroš

Serbian

  1.            

26288/12

Miroljub OBRADOVIĆ

25/08/1952

selo Golubovac

Serbian

  1.            

26291/12

Stojadin IVIĆ

28/07/1943

selo Meševo

Serbian

  1.            

26293/12

Slađan STANOJLOVIĆ

20/02/1977

selo Boljevac, R. Banja

Serbian

 

  1.            

26295/12

Obrad CUCA

17/03/1948

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.       

26337/12

Jelica RAŠKOVIĆ

26/04/1957

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.       

26338/12

Dragan RISTIĆ

25/03/1951

Kruševac

Serbian

  1.       

26339/12

Vukoman ČOLOVEJIĆ

31/08/1956

Kruševac

Serbian

 

 


HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.