Tax United Kingdom

Take 3.9 TV Partnership & Ors v The Commissioners for HMRC

Official source

Neutral Citation: [2026] UKFTT 01461 (TC)

Case Number: TC10061

FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL

TAX CHAMBER

Location: Decided on the papers

Appeal reference: TC/2025/01802

TC/2025/01803

TC/2025/01805

TC/2025/01806

TC/2025/01807

INCOME TAX – as a result of an earlier decision in the above appeals, under reference [2026] UKFTT 696 (TC), the appeals were allowed in part and it was left to the parties to agree on the amounts by which the closure notices to which the appeals related should be amended, failing which those amounts would be determined by the First-tier Tribunal – the Respondents reached an agreement with one of the Appellants as to the amounts by which the closure notices issued to that Appellant should be amended but have been unable to reach an agreement to a similar effect with the other Appellants – accordingly, the amounts in question have been determined by the First-tier Tribunal in this decision

Judgment date: 15 October 2026

Decided by:

TRIBUNAL JUDGE TONY BEARE

MR JULIAN STAFFORD

Between

(1) TAKE 3.9 TV PARTNERSHIP

(2) TAKE 3.10 TV PARTNERSHIP

(3) TAKE 3.12 TV PARTNERSHIP

(4) TAKE 3.13 TV PARTNERSHIP

(5) TAKE 3.14 TV PARTNERSHIP

Appellants

and

THE COMMISSIONERS FOR HIS MAJESTY’S REVENUE AND CUSTOMS

Respondents

DECISION

Introduction

1. On 12 May 2026, we issued a decision in principle, under reference [2026] UKFTT 696 (TC) (the “Decision”), in relation to the closure notices issued by the Respondents which had led to the above appeals. Words defined in the Decision bear the same meanings in this decision.

2. So far as relevant to this decision, the conclusions which we reached in the Decision were as follows:

(1) the appeals made by Take 3.11 against the closure notices issued to that partnership had been finally determined and were not relevant to the Decision – see paragraph 9(3) of the Decision;

(2) as regards the closure notices issued to each of the other five Appellants:

(a) to the extent that they related to the Peakviewing transactions, the appeals against those closure notices were upheld – see paragraph 6(1) of the Decision; and

(b) to the extent that they related to the non-Peakviewing transactions, the T3 Equity component of each T3 Advance was wholly and exclusively incurred for the purposes of the relevant Appellant’s trade and, therefore, the relevant Appellant was entitled to relief for that component – see paragraph 217 of the Decision; and

(3) consequently, the appeals by each of the other five Appellants should be allowed in part and the closure notices should be amended to reflect the conclusions set out in paragraph 2(2) above – see paragraph 219 of the Decision.

3. At the time of issuing the Decision, we expressed the view that it should not be difficult for the parties to reach agreement in relation to the precise figures reflecting those conclusions given that:

(1) as regards the amendments to the closure notices to the extent that they related to the Peakviewing transactions, the relevant figures were those set out in the Appellants’ partnership returns and were set out in the penultimate column of the table set out in paragraph 5 of the Decision; and

(2) as regards the amendments to the closure notices to the extent that they related to the non-Peakviewing transactions, the relevant components of each T3 Advance should be readily-identifiable for the reasons set out in paragraphs 214 to 216 of the Decision

– see paragraph 219 of the Decision.

4. Since issuing the Decision, the Respondents and Take 3.14 TV Partnership (“Take 3.14”) have reached agreement on the amounts by which the closure notices issued to Take 3.14 should be amended. Accordingly, the appeals by Take 3.14 have now been finally determined and are not the subject of this decision.

5. However, the parties have been unable to reach agreement on the amounts by which the closure notices issued to each the other four partnerships – Take 3.9 TV Partnership (“Take 3.9”), Take 3.10 TV Partnership (“Take 3.10”), Take 3.12 TV Partnership (“Take 3.12”) and Take 3.13 TV Partnership (“Take 3.13”) – should be amended. This is largely because Mr Rawlinson, who represented the Appellants at the hearing, did not have the authority to agree the figures on behalf of the remaining four Appellants.

6. The parties have therefore requested that we determine the figures based on their respective written submissions but without the need for a further hearing.

the respondents’ submissions

7. The position advanced by the Respondents in that regard is as follows.

8. The starting point in the process is the table set out in paragraph 5 of the Decision, which, subject to one minor typographical correction, is duplicated below for ease of reference (“Table 1”):

Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4 Column 5
Partnership and tax year Position recorded in amended partnership return – trading profit/(loss) (£) Position recorded in closure notice – non-trading profit/(loss) (£) Outcome now sought by the Respondents Outcome now sought by the Respondents
Trading profit/(loss) (from the Peakviewing transactions) (£) Non-trading profit/(loss) (from the non-Peakviewing transactions) (£)
Take 3.9 – the 2001/2002 tax year (4,679,517) (2,076,112) (3,375,644) (1,303,873)
Take 3.9 – the 2002/2003 tax year 3,270,377 163,008 3,107,369 163,008
Take 3.10 – the 2001/2002 tax year (3,622,736) (1,621,045) (2,612,833) (1,009,853)
Take 3.10 – the 2002/2003 tax year 2,531,190 125,963 2,405,227 125,963
Take 3.12 – the 2001/2002 tax year (3,997,313) (1,787,156) (2,887,033) (1,110,280)
Take 3.12 – the 2002/2003 tax year 2,796,936 139,246 2,657,690 139,246
Take 3.13 – the 2001/2002 tax year (1,649,967) (751,550) (1,189,172) (460,975)
Take 3.13 – the 2002/2003 tax year 1,152,018 57,354 1,094,664 57,354

9. The amounts set out in Column 4 of Table 1 reflect the agreed position of the parties throughout the hearing in relation to the tax consequences of the Peakviewing transactions. In short, they reflect the Respondents’ acceptance of the amended partnership returns of the relevant Appellants to the extent that those returns related to the Peakviewing transactions. It is therefore only the amounts set out in Column 5 of Table 1 – those which relate to the non-Peakviewing transactions – which need to be addressed in this decision.

10. The amounts set out in Column 5 of Table 1 reflect the Respondents’ position at the start of the hearing to the effect that none of the profits or losses arising as a result of the non-Peakviewing transactions were trading profits or losses. Given our conclusion in the Decision that some of those profits and losses were trading profits and losses – specifically, those profits and losses which were attributable to the T3 Equity component of each T3 Advance – it is necessary to determine how much of each amount in Column 5 of Table 1 can properly be said to be attributable to the T3 Equity component of each T3 Advance and, conversely, how much of each amount in Column 5 of Table 1 can properly be said to be attributable to the T3 Debt component of the relevant T3 Advance.

11. The Respondents submitted that that apportionment should be as set out in the table which follows (“Table 2”):

Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4
Partnership and tax year Non-trading profit/(loss) alleged to arise at the start of the hearing by the Respondents (£) Trading profit/(loss) attributable to the portion of the amount in Column 2 which reflects the T3 Equity component of each T3 Advance (£) Non-trading profit/(loss) attributable to the portion of the amount in Column 2 which reflects the T3 Debt component of each T3 Advance (£)
Take 3.9 – the 2001/2002 tax year (1,303,873) (501,991.11) (801,881.89)
Take 3.9 – the 2002/2003 tax year 163,008 61,780.03 101,227.97
Take 3.10 – the 2001/2002 tax year (1,009,853) (388,793.41) (621,059.59)
Take 3.10 – the 2002/2003 tax year 125,963 47,739.98 78,223.02
Take 3.12 – the 2001/2002 tax year (1,110,280) (427,457.80) (682,822.20)
Take 3.12 – the 2002/2003 tax year 139,246 52,774.23 86,471.77
Take 3.13 – the 2001/2002 tax year (460,975) (177,406.08) (283,388.92)
Take 3.13 – the 2002/2003 tax year 57,354 21,737.17 35,616.83

12. They explained that the split set out in Table 2 was calculated by reference to the production schedules set out on pages 414 to 418 of the bundle produced for the hearing (the “Production Schedules”) and in the following manner:

(1) in relation to each Appellant in respect of the 2001/2002 tax year:

(a) the amounts contributed to the relevant Appellant by its partners in respect of the non-Peakviewing transactions as a whole, expressed as a percentage of the total expenditure incurred by the relevant Appellant in respect of those transactions, was calculated; and

(b) that percentage was then applied to the amount appearing in Column 2 of Table 2 to produce the amount appearing in Column 3 of Table 2, with the balance appearing in Column 4 of Table 2; and

(2) in relation to each Appellant in respect of the 2002/2003 tax year, the position was more complicated because:

(a) the amounts contributed by the partners to the relevant Appellant in respect of the non-Peakviewing transactions in the relevant tax years as a whole varied from non-Peakviewing transaction to non-Peakviewing transaction;

(b) in the 2002/2003 tax year, two of the non-Peakviewing transactions – ICTC and “Inquisition” – generated income; and

(c) the amount appearing in Column 2 of Table 2 in relation to the relevant Appellant in respect of the 2002/2003 tax year was a net figure reflecting both the income from those two transactions and the expenditure attributable to another non-Peakviewing transaction – “Big Kiss” – in the 2002/2003 tax year;

(3) the Respondents recognised that the above features gave rise to a number of alternative methods for calculating the extent to which the amount appearing in Column 2 of Table 2 in relation to each Appellant in respect of the 2002/2003 tax year was attributable to the T3 Equity component of each T3 Advance in respect of the non-Peakviewing transactions;

(4) however, they considered that the best way of determining how much of the amount set out in Column 2 of Table 2 in relation to each Appellant in respect of the 2002/2003 tax year was attributable the T3 Equity component of each T3 Advance in respect of the non-Peakviewing transactions was by reference to the income generated by the non-Peakviewing transactions in the 2002/2003 tax year; and

(5) to that end, they suggested the following three-stage process which took account of the fact that the amounts contributed by the partners to the relevant Appellant in respect of the non-Peakviewing transactions in the relevant tax years as a whole varied from non-Peakviewing transaction to non-Peakviewing transaction:

(a) first, they determined how much of the income generated by each non-Peakviewing transaction in the relevant Appellant in respect of the 2002/2003 tax year was attributable to the amounts contributed by the partners in respect of that non-Peakviewing transaction. This was done in the following manner:

(i) they calculated the percentage of the total expenditure incurred by the relevant Appellant in respect of the relevant non-Peakviewing transaction represented by the amounts contributed to the relevant Appellant by its partners in respect of the relevant non-Peakviewing transaction; and

(ii) then, they applied that percentage to the income generated by the relevant non-Peakviewing transaction in the 2002/2003 tax year to produce an amount of income generated by the relevant non-Peakviewing transaction which could be seen as being attributable to the amounts contributed by the partners to the relevant Appellant in respect of the relevant non-Peakviewing transaction;

(b) secondly, they calculated the percentage of the aggregate income generated by the non-Peakviewing transactions as a whole in the 2002/2003 tax year represented by the amounts of income calculated in respect of each non-Peakviewing transaction in accordance with paragraph 12(5)(a) above; and

(c) finally, they applied that percentage to the amounts appearing in Column 2 of Table 2 to produce the amounts appearing in Column 3 of Table 2, with the balance appearing in Column 4 of Table 2.

13. The final stage in the process of determining how much of the overall profit or loss set out in the amended partnership return in respect of both the Peakviewing transactions and the non-Peakviewing transactions was a trading profit or loss was to aggregate the amounts set out in Column 4 of Table 1 – which we have replicated in Column 2 below – with the amounts set out in Column 3 of Table 2 – which we have replicated in Column 3 below – as set out in the table which follows (“Table 3”):

Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4
Partnership and tax year Trading profit/(loss) (from the Peakviewing transactions) (£) Trading profit/((loss) (from the non-Peakviewing transactions) (£) Aggregate trading profit/(loss) (£)
Take 3.9 – the 2001/2002 tax year (3,375,644) (501,991.11) (3,877,635.11)
Take 3.9 – the 2002/2003 tax year 3,107,369 61,780.03 3,169,149.03
Take 3.10 – the 2001/2002 tax year (2,612,833) (388,793.41) (3,001,676.41)
Take 3.10 – the 2002/2003 tax year 2,405,227 47,739.98 2,452,967.98
Take 3.12 – the 2001/2002 tax year (2,887,033) (427,457.80) (3,314,491.80)
Take 3.12 – the 2002/2003 tax year 2,657,690 52,774.23 2,710,464.23
Take 3.13 – the 2001/2002 tax year (1,189,172) (177,406.08) (1,366,578.08)
Take 3.13 – the 2002/2003 tax year 1,094,664 21,737.17 1,116,401.17

14. The balance of the overall profit or loss set out in the amended partnership returns in respect of both the Peakviewing transactions and the non-Peakviewing transactions was a non-trading profit or loss, as set out in the table which follows (“Table 4”):

Column 1 Column 2
Partnership and tax year Non-trading profit/loss attributable to the portion of the amount in Column 2 of Table 2 which reflects the T3 Debt component of each T3 Advance (£)
Take 3.9 – the 2001/2002 tax year (801,881.89)
Take 3.9 – the 2002/2003 tax year 101,227.97
Take 3.10 – the 2001/2002 tax year (621,059.59)
Take 3.10 – the 2002/2003 tax year 78,223.02
Take 3.12 – the 2001/2002 tax year (682,822.20)
Take 3.12 – the 2002/2003 tax year 86,471.77
Take 3.13 – the 2001/2002 tax year (283,388.92)
Take 3.13 – the 2002/2003 tax year 35,616.83

mr rawlinson’s submissions

15. Although Mr Rawlinson made it clear that he did not have the authority to agree the figures with the Respondents, he did make some submissions in relation to the Respondents’ proposal as described above.

16. First, while saying that he did not dispute the information set out in paragraph 5 of the Decision – which is to say the information in Table 1 above:

(1) he noted that there were differences between the expenditure shown in the Production Schedules in respect of the non-Peakviewing transactions in the 2001/2002 tax year and the trading losses claimed in respect of the non-Peakviewing transactions in the 2001/2002 tax year and that there was now no-one available to explain why that difference existed; and

(2) he suggested that some non-Peakviewing transactions may already have been taken into account in the adjustments to the partnership returns made by the Appellants in relation to the Peakviewing transactions in November 2003.

17. Secondly, although he did not himself suggest a method for calculating the part of the profits and losses arising in respect of the non-Peakviewing transactions in the relevant tax years which should be treated as being attributable to the T3 Equity component of the T3 Advances, he said that the Respondents’ proposed approach might not be the only basis for calculating those amounts.

discussion

18. We are not inclined to reject the method of calculation proposed by the Respondents on the basis of Mr Rawlinson’s submissions.

19. That is because:

(1) it seems to us that the submissions described in paragraph 16(2) above involve calling into question the figures set out in paragraph 5 of the Decision and paragraph 8 above and those figures were agreed by all of the parties at the commencement of the hearing. In our view, it is now too late to re-visit those figures, particularly given the time that has elapsed since the relevant tax years and the absence of evidence that that necessarily entails; and

(2) the submission described in paragraph 17 above is not a concrete and detailed suggestion as to an alternative viable method for making the calculations but is simply a broad statement to the effect that other methods of calculation might be available, something which the Respondents themselves acknowledged in their submissions in relation to the 2002/2003 tax year – see paragraph 12(3) above.

20. Our view is that, so far as the 2001/2002 tax year is concerned, the method of calculating the trading profits and losses and the non-trading profits and losses of each the remaining four Appellants suggested by the Respondents is entirely reasonable. This is because the Appellants received no income in respect of the non-Peakviewing transactions in that relevant tax year. It is therefore simply a case of determining what proportion of the aggregate expenditure on the relevant non-Peakviewing transactions as a whole was attributable to the monies provided by the partners and the method proposed by the Respondents seems unexceptionable to us. Accordingly, we agree with the figures set out in Table 2, Table 3 and Table 4 above insofar as they relate to the 2001/2002 tax year.

21. However, we are less convinced by the Respondents’ proposed method for dealing with the 2002/2003 tax year because the non-Peakviewing transactions as a whole gave rise to both income and expenses in that relevant tax year and it seems to us that the method proposed by the Respondents involves taking no account of the extent to which the expenditure incurred by each Appellant on “Big Kiss” in the 2002/2003 tax year was funded by the partners.

22. Our conclusion is therefore that the calculation of the trading profit for each partnership in respect of the 2002/2003 tax year in respect of the non-Peakviewing transactions needs to slightly different so that it reflects the fact that the net profit made by each partnership in the relevant tax year in respect of those transactions was an amalgam of gross income and gross expenses and that different debt/equity ratios applied to each of those gross figures.

23. Accordingly, in our view, a more appropriate approach to that relevant tax year would be the following:

(1) break down the net profit for that relevant tax year in respect of the non-Peakviewing transactions which appears in the relevant partnership return for that tax year into its constituent gross parts – the gross income arising on ICTC and “Inquisition” and the gross expenditure incurred on “Big Kiss”;

(2) apportion the gross income arising on ICTC and “Inquisition” as shown in the partnership returns between the partner-funded gross income and the debt-funded gross income in the same manner as the Respondents have proposed for apportioning the net profit in the 2002/2003 tax year – ie by reference to the extent to which, in accordance with the Production Schedules, the expenditure on those productions in the previous tax year – the 2001/2002 tax year – was partner-funded. That part of the gross income for the 2002/2003 tax year as shown in the partnership returns would be “A";

(3) apportion the gross expenditure incurred on “Big Kiss” as shown in the partnership returns between the partner-funded gross expenditure and the debt-funded gross expenditure on the same basis as the Respondents have proposed for apportioning the expenditure incurred on ICTC and “Inquisition” in the 2001/2002 tax year – ie by applying the equity percentage shown in the Production Schedules for “Big Kiss” in the 2002/2003 tax year and applying that equity percentage to the gross expenditure incurred on “Big Kiss” as shown in the partnership returns for that tax year. That part of the gross expenditure for 2002/2003 as shown in the partnership returns would be "B"; and

(4) treat A minus B as the portion of the net profit for the 2002/2003 tax year which represents the equity contributed by the partners.

24. In our view, the approach described above would better reflect the portion of the net profit in the 2002/2003 tax year which was attributable to the equity provided by the partners to each partnership.

25. Unfortunately, however, there are two difficulties in pursuing this approach.

26. First, the figures for gross income and gross expenditure for each partnership in respect of the relevant tax year as shown in the partnership returns are not exactly the same as the figures for gross income and gross expenditure for each partnership in respect of the relevant tax year as shown in the Production Schedules and, at this point in time, it is impossible to determine why those differences exist.

27. Secondly, whereas the Production Schedules contain a breakdown of gross income and gross expenditure between each non-Peakviewing transaction, there is no such breakdown in the partnership returns themselves. The only breakdown between the various non-Peakviewing transactions that exists is the one set out in the Production Schedules.

28. Despite these difficulties, we consider that, as a matter of principle, the method of calculation described in paragraph 23 above is a fairer template for the calculation of the portion of the net profit in the 2002/2003 tax year that was attributable to the equity provided by the partners to each partnership than the one proposed by the Respondents and that it is possible to apply that template, despite the difficulty described in paragraph 27 above, by using the figures for gross income and gross expenditure for each production which appear in the Production Schedules in respect of that relevant tax year. We recognise that this does not cure the difficulty described in paragraph 26 above but, even so, it at least gives effect to the breakdown of the expenditure on “Big Kiss” between the part which was funded by the partners and the part which was not.

29. Applying that method gives rise to the following revisions to Column 3 in Table 2 insofar as that table relates to the 2002/2003 tax year (“Table 5”):

Column 1 Column 2 Column 3
Partnership Figures proposed by the Respondents in Column 3 of Table 2 (£) Revised figures using the methodology described above (£)
Take 3.9 61,780.03 59,595.53
Take 3.10 47,739.98 46,129.54
Take 3.12 52,774.23 50,969.05
Take 3.13 21,737.17 20,994.42

30. That, in turn, then gives rise to the following revised version of Table 3 (“Table 6”):

Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4
Partnership and tax year Trading profit/(loss) (from the Peakviewing transactions) (£) Trading profit/((loss) (from the non-Peakviewing transactions) (£) Aggregate trading profit/(loss) (£)
Take 3.9 – the 2001/2002 tax year (3,375,644) (501,991.11) (3,877,635.11)
Take 3.9 – the 2002/2003 tax year 3,107,369 59,595.53 3,166,964.53
Take 3.10 – the 2001/2002 tax year (2,612,833) (388,793.41) (3,001,676.41)
Take 3.10 – the 2002/2003 tax year 2,405,227 46,129.54 2,451,356.54
Take 3.12 – the 2001/2002 tax year (2,887,033) (427,457.80) (3,314,491.80)
Take 3.12 – the 2002/2003 tax year 2,657,690 50,969.05 2,708,659.05
Take 3.13 – the 2001/2002 tax year (1,189,172) (177,406.08) (1,366,578.08)
Take 3.13 – the 2002/2003 tax year 1,094,664 20,994.42 1,115,658.42

31. It also gives rise to the following revised version of Table 4 (“Table 7”):

Column 1 Column 2
Partnership and tax year Non-trading profit/loss attributable to the portion of the amount in Column 2 of Table 2 which reflects the T3 Debt component of each T3 Advance (£)
Take 3.9 – the 2001/2002 tax year (801,881.89)
Take 3.9 – the 2002/2003 tax year 103,412.47
Take 3.10 – the 2001/2002 tax year (621,059.59)
Take 3.10 – the 2002/2003 tax year 79,833.46
Take 3.12 – the 2001/2002 tax year (682,822.20)
Take 3.12 – the 2002/2003 tax year 88,276.95
Take 3.13 – the 2001/2002 tax year (283,388.92)
Take 3.13 – the 2002/2003 tax year 36,959.58

conclusion

32. It follows from the above that, in our view, the portion of the aggregate profit or loss arising in each partnership in respect of each tax year as shown in the partnership returns which was a trading profit or loss was as set out in Column 4 of Table 6 and that the balance of the aggregate profit or loss arising in each partnership in respect of each tax year as shown in the partnership returns was a non-trading profit or loss as set out in Column 2 of Table 7.

Right to apply for permission to appeal

33. This document contains full findings of fact and reasons for the decision. Any party dissatisfied with this decision has a right to apply for permission to appeal against it pursuant to Rule 39 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009. The application must be received by this Tribunal not later than 56 days after this decision is sent to that party. The parties are referred to “Guidance to accompany a Decision from the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber)” which accompanies and forms part of this decision notice.

Release Date: 15th OCTOBER 2026

If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our tax lawyer in Paris.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.