Civil European Court of Human Rights
FEDRIGON AND OTHERS v. ITALY
FIRST SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 32728/02
Sara FEDRIGON and Others against Italy
and 43 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 3 November 2016 as a Committee composed of:
Robert Spano, President,
Pauliine Koskelo,
Tim Eicke, judges,
and Hasan Bakırcı, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the dates indicated in the appended table,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
FACTS AND PROCEDURE
A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.
The applicants’ complaints under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention concerning the excessive length of civil proceedings were communicated to the Italian Government (“the Government”), who submitted observations on the admissibility and merits. The observations were forwarded to the applicants, who were invited to submit their own observations.
By a letter sent to the applicants on 4 May 2016, the Registry requested an update on the status of the respective domestic proceedings.
No reply was received to the Registry’s letters.
By a second letter sent to the applicants by registered post on 29 June 2016, the Registry indicated that no reply had been received to the letter of 4 May 2016 and requested the applicants to provide the updates referred to in its previous letter. The applicants’ attention was drawn to Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention and to the fact that, in case of no reply, the Court might assume that the applicants do not intend to pursue the application before the Court and strike their case out of its list of cases. The applicants received this letter on different dates. However, no answer has been received.
THE LAW
Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.
In the light of the foregoing, the Court concludes that the applicants may be regarded as no longer wishing to pursue the application (Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention). Furthermore, in accordance with Article 37 § 1 in fine, the Court finds no special circumstances regarding respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto which require the continued examination of the applications.
Accordingly, the cases should be struck out of the list.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Decides to strike the applications out of its list of cases.
Done in English and notified in writing on 24 November 2016.
Hasan Bakırcı Robert Spano
Deputy Registrar President
APPENDIX
|
No |
Application No |
Lodged on |
Applicant Date of birth Place of residence |
Represented by |
|
|
32728/02 |
11/07/1998 |
Sara FEDRIGON 03/08/1924 Imola Lucia FEDRIGON 22/11/1928 Vado-Monzuno Giuseppe FEDRIGON 28/10/1930 Vado-Monzuno Stefano FEDRIGON 07/09/1938 Vado-Monzuno Paolo FEDRIGON 16/09/1944 Monzuno |
Nicoletta MACCAFERRI |
|
|
5492/03 |
20/10/1999 |
Luigia DI GIUSEPPE 02/06/1913 Santa Croce del Sannio |
Sebastiano DE NIGRIS DE MARIA |
|
|
12180/03 |
07/03/2003 |
Renato TRENTO 23/01/1947 Pescara |
Gabriello VIGLIOTTI |
|
|
17696/03 |
26/05/2003 |
Giampiero LOTTINI 13/03/1934 Livorno |
Tullio CONTU |
|
|
25289/03 |
22/07/2000 |
Rocco MOCCIA 09/04/1956 Cimitile Fabrizio MOCCIA 03/04/1971 Nola Anna Maria MOCCIA 03/10/1957 Nola Carmela LUCREZIO 10/06/1936 Nola |
Pietrantonio CICCONE |
|
|
25896/03 |
23/07/2003 |
Renato BONIARDI 25/02/1951 Milan |
Salvatore BOTTARI |
|
|
26042/03 |
25/07/2003 |
EVEREST DI BORCHI OLIMPIA E C. S.A.S. Carmignano |
|
|
|
30833/03 |
11/09/2003 |
Giulio RUBINO 07/02/1967 Telese Terme (Benevento) |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
38759/03 |
22/11/2003 |
Antonio CAMPANILE 14/01/1942 Grumo Nevano |
Gennaro MALINCONICO |
|
|
38808/03 |
18/11/2003 |
Luigi IZZO 24/06/1923 Sessa Aurunca |
Claudio STRONATI |
|
|
39235/03 |
31/03/2000 |
Maria VISCIONE 09/02/1921 Roccabascerana |
Fabrizio GIORDANO |
|
|
39253/03 |
03/01/2001 |
Giuseppe GIANGRANDE 09/11/1920 S. Arcangelo Trimonte |
Fabrizio GIORDANO |
|
|
39300/03 |
17/04/2000 |
Alfredo PALMA 25/09/1941 Benevento |
Fabrizio GIORDANO |
|
|
39302/03 |
31/03/2000 |
Mennato FORGIONE 12/05/1959 Benevento |
Fabrizio GIORDANO |
|
|
39311/03 |
25/11/1998 |
Vincenza VANNETIELLO 13/10/1948 Avellino |
Fabrizio GIORDANO |
|
|
88/04 |
01/12/2003 |
Maria Luigia MANCINO 24/11/1958 Melizzano |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
89/04 |
01/12/2003 |
Maria Luigia MANCINO 24/11/1958 Melizzano (Benevento) |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
93/04 |
15/12/2003 |
Giuseppina RENZI 02/12/1933 Melizzano |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
4531/04 |
05/12/2003 |
Carmela DE LUCIA 26/09/1967 Durazzano |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
4535/04 |
05/12/2003 |
Maria Grazia BUFFOLINO 12/02/1968 Sant’Agata dei Goti |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
4540/04 |
05/12/2003 |
Lucia Gerarda MONTEFORTE 01/10/1969 Sant’Agata dei Goti |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
4584/04 |
07/01/2004 |
Giuseppe DE CICCO 12/01/1952 Melizzano |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
4735/04 |
29/12/2003 |
Filomena GRASSO 22/06/1928 |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
5783/04 |
20/01/2004 |
Eufemia SALERNO 30/10/1933 Sant’Angelo a Cupulo |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
11049/04 |
13/03/2004 |
Maria MAZZANTI 03/04/1943 Carnea di Follo |
|
|
|
13347/04 |
20/01/2004 |
Vincenzo VALORE 18/09/1925 Palazzo Adriano Antonio VALORE 16/02/1923 Palazzo Adriano |
Antonio PETRONIO |
|
|
13407/04 |
22/03/2004 |
Anna Maria FOTI 29/12/1928 Rome |
Nicola SANITATE |
|
|
14816/04 |
05/04/2004 |
Lea PERAZZITTI 03/11/1942 Pescara Manuela RAPATTONI 04/08/1973 Pescara Alessandro RAPATTONI 19/02/1976 Pescara |
Raffaella DE VICO |
|
|
18267/04 |
05/04/2004 |
Lea PERAZZITTI 03/11/1942 Pescara Manuela RAPATTONI 04/08/1973 Pescara Alessandro RAPATTONI 19/02/1976 Pescara |
Raffaella DE VICO |
|
|
20612/04 |
14/05/2004 |
Sergio MAIRA 22/01/1970 San Giovanni Gemini Salvatore MAIRA 30/03/1935 San Giovanni Gemini |
Salvatore MANGIAPANE |
|
|
21881/04 |
04/06/2004 |
Francesco ABENAVOLI 25/09/1938 Reggio Calabria |
|
|
|
22101/04 |
04/06/2004 |
Domenico TRIPEPI 02/05/1931 Reggio Calabria |
Francesco ABENAVOLI |
|
|
24313/04 |
22/06/2004 |
Flora BECAGLI 14/09/1941 Scandicci |
Francesco ATZENI |
|
|
25010/04 |
29/06/2004 |
TECNOCLIMA S.P.A. Pergine Valsugana |
Gabriele TADDEI |
|
|
26642/04 |
21/07/2004 |
Giulia SCIALLA 26/07/1947 Solopaca |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
26648/04 |
21/07/2004 |
Gloria SCIALLA 06/02/1940 Solopaca |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
26679/04 |
20/07/2004 |
Marianna IANNUCCI 26/11/1968 Limatola |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
35227/04 |
14/09/2004 |
Erminia DI GIOIA 06/12/1953 Telese Terme |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
43322/04 |
10/11/1999 |
Emilio BIONDI 20/03/1933 Faicchio |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
44659/04 |
29/10/2001 |
Domizia DI CROCCO 11/11/1966 Itri |
|
|
|
1162/05 |
19/04/2001 |
Luciana D’ANGELIS 30/01/1954 Paduli |
Fabrizio GIORDANO |
|
|
3762/05 |
01/12/2003 |
Maria Luigia MANCINO 24/11/1958 Melizzano |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
10380/05 |
01/03/2005 |
Giuseppina RENZI 02/12/1933 Melizzano |
Giulio DI GIOIA |
|
|
40985/06 |
05/10/2006 |
Paolo VITELLO 03/09/1964 Riesi |
Pierluigi ZODA |
Official sources: view the source page · Official PDF
HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.