Criminal European Court of Human Rights

ARSLANOĞLU AND OTHERS v. TURKEY

ECLI ECLI:CE:ECHR:2016:1011DEC001404605

 

 

SECOND SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 14046/05
Murat ARSLANOĞLU against Turkey
and 124 other applications
(see list appended)

The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 11 October 2016 as a Committee composed of:

 Nebojša Vučinić, President,
 Valeriu Griţco,
 Stéphanie Mourou-Vikström, judges,
and Hasan Bakırcı, Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

THE FACTS

1.  A list of the applicants and their representatives are set out in the appendix. The Turkish Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent.

A.  The circumstances of the case

2.  The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.

3.  The applicants were all serving their prison sentences or were in pre-trial detention when the present applications were lodged. Disciplinary boards of respective prisons decided to impose on the applicants’ correspondence several types of monitoring measures such as stopping, destroying or censoring their private letters.

4.  The applicants challenged the prison authorities’ decisions before the enforcement judges and the assize courts respectively. The domestic courts dismissed the applicants’ objections and ruled that the impugned restrictions were consistent with the domestic laws and regulations and were justified by reasons of order and security in the prisons, prevention of offences and protection of third parties.

B.  Relevant domestic law

5.  A description of the domestic law regarding the new remedy introduced by Law no. 6384 can be found in Sayan v. Turkey (dec.), no. 49460/11, §§ 6-12, 14 June 2016).

COMPLAINTS

6.  The applicants invoked Articles 8, 9, 10 and/or 14 of the Convention and complained that the restrictions imposed on their correspondence breached, in a discriminatory manner, their right to respect for their correspondence solely or together with their right to freedom of thought and their right to free expression. Some of the applicants also invoked Articles 6 and 13 of the Convention and complained about the ineffectiveness and unfairness of the procedures before the national courts. Finally, based on the same facts some of the applicants invoked Articles 1, 3, 5, 7, 17 and 18 of the Convention, Article 1 of Protocol No. 12 and Protocols nos. 4, 6, 7 and 13.

THE LAW

7.  Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, at the outset the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.

8.  The Court will examine the applications solely from the standpoint of Article 8 of the Convention (see Asan v. Turkey (dec.), no. 38453/09, 30 August 2016).

9.  The Government noted that pursuant to Law no. 6384 a new Compensation Commission had been established to deal with applications concerning the length of proceedings and the non-execution of judgments. They further noted that the competence of the Compensation Commission was subsequently enlarged by a decree adopted on 9 March 2016 to examine complaints relating to, among other things, the alleged breach of the right to respect for correspondence of detainees or convicted persons, on account of the prison administration’s refusal to receive or send letters or similar correspondence that are drafted in Turkish. Accordingly, they maintained that the applicants had not exhausted domestic remedies, as they had not made any application to the Compensation Commission.

10.  The Court has examined similar applications against Turkey on several occasions and found a violation of Article 8 of the Convention on the grounds that the interference was not “in accordance with the law” (see Tan v. Turkey, no. 9460/03, §§ 24-26, 3 July 2007, and Tur v. Turkey, no. 13692/03, §§ 23-25, 11 June 2013) or was not “necessary in a democratic society” (see Fazıl Ahmet Tamer v. Turkey, no. 6289/02, §§ 54-56, 5 December 2006, and Mehmet Nuri Özen v. Turkey, no. 37619/05, §§ 18-19, 2 February 2010).

11.  Furthermore, the Court also notes that in its decision in the case of Ümmühan Kaplan (no. 24240/07, § 77, 20 March 2012), it stressed that it could nevertheless examine, under its normal procedure, applications of that type which had already been communicated to the Government. However, taking into account the Government’s objection with regard to the applicants’ failure to make use of the new domestic remedy established by Law no. 6384, the Court reiterates its conclusion in the cases of Turgut and Others v. Turkey ((dec.), no. 4860/09, §§ 47-59, 26 March 2013); Çakır and Others v. Turkey ((dec.), no. 51274/07, § 6, 25 June 2013); Yöyler and Others v. Turkey ((dec.), no. 10783/07, §§ 11-13, 16 December 2014); Yıldız and Yanak ((dec.), no. 44013/07, § 29-38, 27 May 2014); and Sayan v. Turkey ((dec.), no. 49460/11, 14 June 2016).

12.  In view of the above, the Court concludes that the applications should be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non‑exhaustion of domestic remedies.

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Decides to join the applications;

Declares the applications inadmissible.

 

Done in English and notified in writing on 17 November 2016.

 Hasan Bakırcı Nebojša Vučinić
Deputy Registrar President

APPENDIX

No.

Application No.

Lodged on

Applicant

Date of birth

Place of residence

Represented by

  1.  

14046/05

05/04/2005

Murat ARSLANOĞLU

18/05/1968

Karaman

 

  1.  

27932/05

25/02/2005

Suat DUMAN

28/07/1970

İzmir

Mehmet ERBİL

  1.  

49196/06

21/11/2006

Muhittin ALTIN

30/03/1974

Kırıkkale

 

  1.  

16487/07

03/04/2007

Recep BEKİK

15/09/1969

Ankara

 

  1.  

20926/07

15/03/2007

Erhan KAYA

16/10/1970

Erzurum

 

  1.  

22255/07

21/05/2007

Erdener DEMİREL

21/11/1980

Tekirdağ

Metin FİLORİNALI

  1.  

26251/07

21/05/2007

Vahdettin BUDAK

03/04/1977

İzmir

 

  1.  

27105/07

15/06/2007

Mehmet Şerif ÖNER

01/01/1975

İzmir

Türkan ASLAN

  1.  

27672/07

20/06/2007

Ahmet KAYA

02/03/1957

Kars

 

  1.            

34450/07

09/07/2007

Mehmet Reşit ARSLAN

01/06/1966

Ankara

 

 

 

  1.            

39135/07

23/08/2007

Diyadin AKDEMİR

01/01/1974

Kocaeli

İnan AKMEŞE

  1.            

40904/07

06/09/2007

Abdullah KANAT

22/07/1956

Diyarbakır

Abdullah AKIN

  1.            

43819/07

25/09/2007

Kenan KARAASLAN

18/12/1966

Bolu

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

52333/07

30/10/2007

Metin YAMALAK

10/06/1980

Bolu

Mehmet ERBİL

  1.            

56448/07

27/11/2007

Ahmet KAYA

02/03/1957

Kars

 

  1.            

6560/08

23/01/2008

Abdi CANGI

17/07/1971

Tekirdağ

Oya ASLAN

  1.            

8267/08

07/02/2008

Mehmet DESDE

05/01/1959

Berlin

Çetin BİNGÖLBALI

  1.            

11135/08

07/02/2008

Hüseyin Habip TAŞKIN

17/11/1960

İzmir

Çetin BİNGÖLBALI

  1.            

13042/08

04/03/2008

Eyüp TURĞAY

22/04/1972

Ankara

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

13693/08

07/02/2008

Serhat ÇETİNER

23/10/1972

Kırıkkale

Sertaç ÇETİNER

  1.            

13713/08

07/02/2008

Serhat ÇETİNER

23/10/1972

Kırıkkale

 

 

Sertaç ÇETİNER

  1.            

13715/08

07/02/2008

Serhat ÇETİNER

23/10/1972

Kırıkkale

Sertaç ÇETİNER

  1.            

13724/08

07/02/2008

Serhat ÇETİNER

23/10/1972

Kırıkkale

Sertaç ÇETİNER

  1.            

13726/08

07/02/2008

Serhat ÇETİNER

23/10/1972

Kırıkkale

Sertaç ÇETİNER

  1.            

13730/08

07/02/2008

Serhat ÇETİNER

23/10/1972

Kırıkkale

Sertaç ÇETİNER

  1.            

14014/08

28/02/2008

Abdullah AYDIN

01/03/1971

Şanlıurfa

 

  1.            

14814/08

07/03/2008

Ali Rıza KALAN

25/10/1973

Bolu

Mehmet ERBİL

  1.            

14949/08

12/03/2008

Murat KARAYEL

10/05/1971

Kırıkkale

Fazıl Ahmet TAMER

  1.            

15647/08

04/03/2008

Turgut KOYUNCU

10/10/1974

İzmir

Hesin DURSUN

  1.            

15952/08

04/03/2008

Gültekin AYDEMİR

03/04/1973

İzmir

 

  1.            

16331/08

21/03/2008

Mehmet Sabri YAKUT

02/03/1974

Erzincan

 

  1.            

16614/08

14/03/2008

Hüseyin BİLGE

01/01/1968

Şanlıurfa

 

 

 

  1.            

17441/08

06/03/2008

Soncan GEDİK

14/08/1967

Antalya

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

17442/08

06/03/2008

Soncan GEDİK

14/08/1967

Antalya

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

17443/08

25/03/2008

Soncan GEDİK

14/08/1967

Antalya

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

19430/08

05/12/2005

Musa ŞANAK

11/12/1964

Ankara

Sinem COŞKUN

  1.            

19437/08

21/06/2005

Fethi OKTAY

01/01/1968

Bolu

 

  1.            

19627/08

25/03/2008

Kemal YİĞİT

20/10/1982

İzmir

Esin ASLAN

  1.            

19636/08

01/04/2008

Hayati KAYTAN

01/05/1968

Ankara

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

19641/08

01/04/2008

Süleyman TATAR

02/04/1970

Ankara

Fazıl Ahmet TAMER

  1.            

20551/08

17/03/2008

Turgut KOYUNCU

10/10/1974

İzmir

Hesin DURSUN

  1.            

25947/08

01/05/2008

Sinan TÜRKMAN

01/01/1966

Bolu

 

  1.            

26967/08

15/05/2008

Mehmet Nuri ÖZEN

10/05/1976

İzmir

 

  1.            

27164/08

02/04/2008

Abdullah AYDIN

01/03/1971

Şanlıurfa

 

  1.            

28234/08

27/05/2008

Mesut YURTSEVER

12/02/1974

Bolu

Faik Özgür EROL

  1.            

28403/08

13/05/2008

Serhat ÇETİNER

23/10/1972

Kırıkkale

Sertaç ÇETİNER

  1.            

28407/08

13/05/2008

Serhat ÇETİNER

23/10/1972

Kırıkkale

Sertaç ÇETİNER

  1.            

29210/08

07/04/2008

Hüseyin BİLGE

01/01/1968

Şanlıurfa

 

  1.            

29327/08

26/05/2008

Turgut KOYUNCU

10/10/1974

İzmir

Hesin DURSUN

  1.            

30532/08

16/06/2008

Fevzi ABO

01/01/1985

Tekirdağ

Mehmet ERBİL

  1.            

31951/08

02/04/2008

Hasan OZAN

02/01/1961

Antalya

Ercan KANAR

  1.            

32534/08

18/06/2008

Mehmet Emin EKİNCİ

20/04/1986

Tekirdağ

İnan AKMEŞE

  1.            

32631/08

07/07/2008

Hasan OZAN

02/01/1961

Edirne

Ercan KANAR

  1.            

32727/08

27/05/2008

Ali BALIN

15/11/1980

İzmir

 

  1.            

36811/08

15/04/2008

Mehmet Çelebi ÇALAN

01/09/1967

Ankara

 

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

36823/08

15/04/2008

Mehmet Çelebi ÇALAN

01/09/1967

Ankara

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

36863/08

07/04/2008

Hüseyin BİLGE

01/01/1968

Şanlıurfa

 

  1.            

36864/08

07/04/2008

Hüseyin BİLGE

01/01/1968

Şanlıurfa

 

  1.            

36893/08

15/04/2008

Mehmet Çelebi ÇALAN

01/09/1967

Ankara

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

36921/08

15/04/2008

Mehmet Çelebi ÇALAN

01/09/1967

Ankara

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

36932/08

24/06/2008

Mehmet Çelebi ÇALAN

01/09/1967

Ankara

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

36944/08

24/06/2008

Mehmet Çelebi ÇALAN

01/09/1967

Ankara

Murat VARGÜN

  1.            

37938/08

31/07/2008

Şehmus YILDIZ

01/05/1974

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37939/08

31/07/2008

Kutsi ÇAĞIŞ

03/03/1968

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37940/08

31/07/2008

İbrahim ATEŞ

01/01/1975

Balıkesir

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37941/08

31/07/2008

Veysel AVCI

10/05/1970

Karabük

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37942/08

31/07/2008

Ahmet MUSTAFA

24/06/1975

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37943/08

31/07/2008

Aydın KUDAT

01/01/1969

Adıyaman

 

  1.            

37944/08

31/07/2008

Yusuf KARANLIK

12/04/1969

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37945/08

31/07/2008

Faik ÇİRİK

29/10/1965

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37946/08

31/07/2008

Yılmaz DEMİR

10/02/1971

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37947/08

31/07/2008

Mehmet ATEŞ

01/01/1970

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37948/08

31/07/2008

İbrahim AKSOY

04/04/1958

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37950/08

31/07/2008

Ramazan ATEŞ

01/02/1967

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37951/08

31/07/2008

Hamdin DEMİRKIRAN

15/03/1971

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37953/08

31/07/2008

Sinan GÜL

10/12/1975

Adıyaman

Umut GÜL

  1.            

37954/08

31/07/2008

İsmail TAŞAR

09/07/1976

Bolu

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37955/08

31/07/2008

Abdulselam SÜSİN

10/06/1969

Karabük

 

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37956/08

31/07/2008

Nimet DEGİŞ

10/04/1957

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37957/08

31/07/2008

Cengiz AYAR

05/01/1973

Kocaeli

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37958/08

31/07/2008

İsmail BİÇEN

04/02/1973

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37959/08

31/07/2008

İlyas DOĞAN

29/08/1975

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37960/08

31/07/2008

Mehmet Emin SIRÇA

05/06/1976

Eskişehir

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37961/08

31/07/2008

Abdurrahman GÜNER

20/12/1970

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37962/08

31/07/2008

Mehmet Şirin İVRENDİ

01/01/1970

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37963/08

31/07/2008

Şükrü AKBAŞ

01/01/1967

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37965/08

31/07/2008

Cemal ÇAKIR

20/09/1965

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37966/08

31/07/2008

Mehmet Ali KAYADAĞ

31/01/1973

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37967/08

31/07/2008

Abdullatif SÖNMEZ

02/02/1972

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37968/08

31/07/2008

Kazım ÇALIŞIR

01/10/1966

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37969/08

31/07/2008

Abdulvahap YILMAZ

01/06/1967

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37970/08

31/07/2008

Hüseyin BİLECAN

20/09/1974

Tekirdağ

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37971/08

31/07/2008

Ali Ejder ELYAKUT

04/03/1978

Karabük

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

37972/08

31/07/2008

Nihat ŞAHİN

03/03/1972

Tekirdağ

 

  1.            

38072/08

30/07/2008

Ufuk KESKİN

08/05/1976

İzmir

 

  1.            

38140/08

31/07/2008

Halil ARSLAN

02/08/1975

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

38276/08

30/07/2008

Abdulmenaf OSMAN

14/04/1965

Kocaeli

 

  1.            

38291/08

31/07/2008

Mehmet ÇELİK

31/07/1975

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.            

38297/08

28/07/2008

Remzi ALMAZ

06/06/1973

Eskişehir

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.       

38299/08

31/07/2008

Ahmet İBRAHİM

01/09/1972

Adıyaman

 

 

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.       

38304/08

01/04/2008

Ramazan NAZLIER

21/12/1973

Diyarbakır

 

  1.       

38308/08

31/07/2008

Barış KILIÇ

01/03/1976

Eskişehir

 

  1.       

38314/08

31/07/2008

Nevzat BAHADIR

10/07/1978

Adıyaman

Ünsal TANRIVERDİ

  1.       

38810/08

16/06/2008

Mahmut CENGİZ

20/03/1983

Tekirdağ

Mehmet ERBİL

  1.       

39330/08

01/08/2008

Diyadin AKDEMİR

01/01/1974

Kocaeli

İnan AKMEŞE

  1.       

39706/08

31/07/2008

Önder BİTİRGİÇ

01/06/1984

Kocaeli

Mehmet ERBİL

  1.       

39949/08

28/07/2008

Refik SÜNKÜR

03/02/1975

Bolu

Engin BABAYİĞİT

01/01/1983

Bolu

Mehmet ERBİL

  1.       

42340/08

19/08/2008

Ramazan VURAL

05/01/1975

Bolu

Mehmet ERBİL

  1.       

45787/08

13/09/2008

Faruk YILDIZ

25/02/1973

Tekirdağ

Mehmet ERBİL

  1.       

47891/08

23/09/2008

Sertaç KILIÇARSLAN

01/02/1976

İzmir

 

 

  1.       

47976/08

22/09/2008

Selçuk ESİN

23/01/1978

İzmir

 

  1.       

48078/08

24/09/2008

Mehmet Enes TUNÇ

03/11/1972

Erzurum

 

  1.       

48133/08

22/09/2008

Nizamettin MAHMUTOĞLU

01/01/1973

Siirt

Rehşan BATARAY SAMAN

  1.       

48137/08

24/09/2008

Kemal YİĞİT

20/10/1982

İzmir

Esin ASLAN

  1.       

48141/08

25/09/2009

Ferhat YİLDENİZ

12/04/1980

İzmir

Nezahat PAŞA BAYRAKTAR

  1.       

51259/08

07/10/2008

Cuma DAĞDÖĞEN

15/05/1979

İzmir

 

  1.       

52114/08

31/07/2008

Davut AKGÜL

02/05/1973

Adıyaman

 

  1.       

52167/08

14/10/2008

Hüseyin TUNÇ

01/01/1968

İzmir

 

  1.       

53824/08

21/10/2008

Vahdettin BUDAK

03/04/1977

İzmir

 

  1.       

54371/08

17/10/2008

Tamer TUNCER

25/10/1971

Kocaeli

Sevim AKAT EŞKİ

  1.       

56362/08

30/10/2008

Turgut KOYUNCU

10/10/1974

İzmir

 

Hesin DURSUN

  1.       

58460/08

18/11/2008

Ahmet ÇAKAL

13/01/1953

İzmir

 

  1.       

61532/08

04/12/2008

Mehmet Şerif ÖNER

01/01/1975

İzmir

 

  1.       

61663/08

01/12/2008

Abdülbari YILDIRIM

01/01/1964

İzmir

 

  1.       

62073/08

04/12/2008

Bozo AÇLAN

27/04/1971

Edirne

 

 


HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.