Civil European Court of Human Rights
GÜMÜŞ AND OTHERS v. TURKEY
SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 43362/04
Hidayet GÜMÜŞ against Turkey
and 10 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 11 October 2016 as a Committee composed of:
Nebojša Vučinić, President,
Valeriu Griţco,
Stéphanie Mourou-Vikström, judges,
and Hasan Bakırcı, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,
Having regard to the observations submitted by the respondent Government and the observations in reply submitted by the applicants,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
1. The applicants are Turkish nationals. Their names and birth dates, as well as the names of their representatives, appear in the appendix.
2. The Turkish Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent.
A. The circumstances of the case
3. The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.
4. Certain plots of land belonging to the applicants were designated as part of the public forest area. Subsequently, the applicants and/or the administrative authorities initiated proceedings before the domestic courts. Consequently, title deeds of the applicants were annulled and the plots of land in dispute were registered in the name of the Treasury because the domestic courts found that they were part of the public forest estate or had been formerly, pursuant to Section 2(B) of Law no. 6831. No compensation was awarded to the applicants.
5. The details of the applications are indicated in the table below.
|
Application no. and case name |
Introduction date |
Details of the land in dispute |
Date on which the proceedings were initiated |
Date and no. of the first instance court decision that annulled the title deed to the land |
Date and no. of the Court of Cassation’s final decision and notification date |
Articles invoked |
|
43362/04 Gümüş |
01/11/2004 |
Istanbul, Pendik, Emirli Village, Ağılaltı District, Plot No. 10, Parcel No. 738, 4.080 m2 |
21/09/2000 |
16/04/2003 Pendik Civil Court, E: 2000/573 K: 2003/252 |
02/03/2004 E: 2004/13235 K: 2004/2070 and 06/05/2004 |
Article 1 of Protocol no. 1 |
|
4517/06 Özdemir |
21/01/2006 |
a) Balıkesir, Ayvalık, Bağyüzü Village, Parcel No. 2, 62.400 m2
b) Balıkesir, Ayvalık, Hacıveliler Village, Parcel No. 129, 237.000 m2 |
17/09/2003
06/08/2003 |
14/07/2004 Ayvalık Civil Court, E: 2003/471 K: 2004/533
14/07/2004 Ayvalık Civil Court, E: 2003/373 K: 2004/520 |
23/06/2005 E: 2005/5158 K: 2005/8459 and 23/07/2005
23/06/2005 E: 2005/5159 K: 2005/8458 and 23/07/2005 |
Article 1 of Protocol no. 1; Article 6 § 1; Article 8; Article 13; Article 17
Article 1 of Protocol no. 1 ; Article 6 § 1; Article 8; Article 13; Article 17 |
|
25878/07 Öztok |
15/06/2007 |
Çanakkale, Sarıcaeli Village, Köycivarı District Parcel no.772, 16500 m2 |
10/05/2006 |
11/07/2006 Çanakkale Civil Court, E : 2006/334 K : 2006/369 |
20/04/2007 E: 2007/4173 K: 2007/5312 |
Article 1 of Protocol no. 1; Article 6 § 1; Article 13 |
|
48475/07 Anıltaş İthalat İhracat Pazarlama ve Ambalaj Sanayi A.Ş. |
15/10/2007 |
Yalova, Çınarcık, Esenköy Village, Çeşme District, Block No. 4, Parcel No. 2492, 77.077, 26 m2 |
26/07/1999 |
21/06/2005 Yalova Civil Court, E: 2004/37 K: 2005/1426 |
09/06/2006 E: 2006/5279 K: 2006/8124 and 20/09/2007 |
Article 1 of Protocol no. 1 |
|
54553/07 Gülsün |
03/12/2007 |
Sinop, Durağan, Ötegeçedüzlük District, Block No. 155, Plot No. 46-47 D-A, Parcel No. 1, 172 m2 |
28/11/2005 |
23/06/2006, Durağan Civil Court, E: 2005/97 K: 2006/77 |
12/06/2007 E: 2007/6677 K: 2007/8023 and 26/09/2007 |
Article 1 of Protocol no. 1; Article 6 § 1 |
|
23258/08 Genç |
08/05/2008 |
Trabzon, Maçka, Ormanüstü Village, Block No. 137, Parcel No. 2, 3.654, 95 m2 |
20/11/2002 |
17/10/2006, Maçka Civil Court, E: 2002/352 K: 2006/258 |
23/11/2007 E: 2007/13469 K: 2007/15063 and 17/12/2007 |
Article 1 of Protocol no. 1 |
|
36580/08 Kunter |
28/07/2008 |
İstanbul, Silivri, 1. Bölge, Büyükçavuşlu Village, Ahmet Faki District, Parcel no.803, 4900 m2 |
24/10/2005 |
27/12/2006 Silivri Civil Court, E : 2006/420 K : 2006/87
|
25/03/2008 E: 2008/1474 K: 2008/4667 |
Article 1 of Protocol No. 1; Article 6 |
|
47356/08 Tuğtepe and Others |
22/09/2008 |
Kocaeli, Gebze, Pelitli Village, Plot no.77 Parcel no.1692, 10460 m2 |
06/10/2004 |
09/03/2007 Gebze Civil Court, E : 2007/29 K : 2007/55 |
12/02/2008 E: 2007/18424 K: 2008/2078 and 31/03/2008 |
Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 |
|
52368/08 Konuklu |
16/10/2008 |
İstanbul, Silivri, 1. Bölge, Büyükçavuşlu Village, Sırameşeler District
I- Plot no.3 Parcel nos./m2 671/ 4081 m2 672/ 2950 m2 673/ 2950 m2
II- Plot no.4 Parcel no.684, 3750 m2 |
24/10/2005 |
28/06/2007 Silivri Civil Court, E : 2006/287 K : 2007/332 |
07/04/2008 E: 2008/3166 K: 2008/5352 and 05/05/2008 |
Article 1 of Protocol No. 1; Article 6 |
|
54187/08 Öztürkcan |
04/11/2008 |
İstanbul, Ümraniye, Ömerli, Plot no.6 Block no.35 Parcel no.19, 4449 m2 |
19/01/2004 |
22/11/2005 Ümraniye Civil Court, E: 2004/54 K: 2005/495 |
09/04/2008 E: 2008/3303 K: 2008/5690 and 06/05/2008 |
Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 |
|
5400/09 Küçükşen |
17/12/2008 |
İstanbul, Pendik, Emirli Village, Kokoğlu District, Plot No. 5, Parcel No. 825, 4.361,46 m2 |
26/03/2004 |
14/12/2006 Pendik Civil Court, E: 2004/157 K: 2006/527 |
14/05/2008 E: 2008/3322 K: 2008/7376 and 20/06/2008 |
Article 1 of Protocol no. 1; Article 6 § 1; Article 14: Article 17 |
B. Relevant domestic law and practice
6. A description of the domestic law and practice with respect to the Compensation Commission mentioned below (paragraph 10) may be found in Savaşçın and Others v. Turkey (dec.), no. 15661/07, 7 June 2016.
COMPLAINTS
7. The applicants complained under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention that they were deprived of their property without receiving any compensation.
8. In some cases, the applicants raised further complaints relying on Articles 6, 8, 13, 14 and 17 of the Convention.
THE LAW
9. The Court considers that, in accordance with Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal background.
A. Alleged violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention
10. The applicants complained under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention that the annulment of their title deeds without any compensation constituted a disproportionate burden and thus breached their right to the peaceful enjoyment of their possessions.
11. The Government noted that pursuant to Law no. 6384 a new Compensation Commission had been established in Turkey to deal with applications concerning the length of proceedings, the delayed execution of judgments and the non-execution of judgments. They further noted that the competence of the Compensation Commission was subsequently enlarged by decrees adopted on 16 March 2014 and 9 March 2016 to examine complaints relating to, among other things, the alleged breaches of the right to peaceful enjoyment of possessions on account of the annulment of applicants’ title deeds where the land at issue is classified as part of the public forest. Accordingly, they maintained that the applicants had not exhausted domestic remedies, as they had not made any application to the Compensation Commission.
12. The Court observes that, as pointed out by the Government, a new domestic remedy has been established in Turkey following the application of the pilot judgment procedure in the case of Ümmühan Kaplan v. Turkey (no. 24240/07, 20 March 2012). Subsequently, in its decision in the case of Savaşçın and Others v. Turkey ((dec.), no. 15661/07, 7 June 2016), the Court declared the application inadmissible on the ground that the applicants had failed to exhaust domestic remedies, that is to say the new remedy. In so doing, the Court considered in particular that this new remedy was a priori accessible and capable of offering a reasonable prospect of redress for complaints concerning the annulment of the applicants’ title deeds because their land was classified as part of the public forest area.
13. The Court notes that in its decision in the case of Ümmühan Kaplan (cited above, § 77), it stressed that it could nevertheless examine, under its normal procedure, applications of that type which had already been communicated to the Government.
14. However, taking into account the Government’s preliminary objection with regard to the applicants’ failure to make use of the new domestic remedy established by Law no. 6384, the Court reiterates its conclusion in the case of Savaşçın and Others, cited above.
15. In view of the above, the Court concludes that the applicants’ complaints regarding the annulment of their title deeds should be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non‑exhaustion of domestic remedies.
B. Other Alleged Violations of the Convention
16. In the applications nos. 4517/06, 25878/07, 54553/07, 36580/08, 52368/08 and 5400/09, the applicants also raised other complaints under various articles of the Convention. However, in the light of all the material in its possession and in so far as the matters complained of are within its competence, the Court concludes that these complaints do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols. Accordingly, the Court rejects them as manifestly ill-founded, pursuant to Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Declares inadmissible the applications.
Done in English and notified in writing on 17 November 2016.
Hasan Bakırcı Nebojša Vučinić
Deputy Registrar President
APPENDIX
|
No |
Application No |
Applicant’s name, Date of birth and Place of residence |
Represented by |
|
|
43362/04 |
Hidayet GÜMÜŞ 1929 Istanbul |
Bilal DAĞTEKİN |
|
|
4517/06 |
Önder ÖZDEMİR 15/07/1954 Balıkesir |
Vincent İŞİTMEZ |
|
|
25878/07 |
Mustafa ÖZTOK 10/10/1966 Çanakkale |
– |
|
|
48475/07 |
ANILTAŞ İTHALAT İHRACAT PAZARLAMA VE AMBALAJ SAN A.Ş. Yalova |
Saadet AYHAN |
|
|
54553/07 |
Mahmut GÜLSÜN 3/04/1955 Sinop |
Zeynel KADAYIFCI |
|
|
23258/08 |
Ali Fahri GENÇ 1/02/1928 Trabzon |
Ahmet Metin GENÇ |
|
|
36580/08 |
Ahmet Mithat KUNTER 1/09/1951 İstanbul |
Ahmet BEKAR |
|
|
47356/08 |
Vildan TUĞTEPE 13/03/1951 Kocaeli
Nimet ALPASLAN 25/03/1938 Kocaeli
Huriye GÜLÜMSER 25/12/1919 Kocaeli
Kıymet TUNA 27/11/1944 Kocaeli
|
Ayten GÜRLEYEN |
|
|
52368/08 |
Hasibe KONUKLU 19/04/1942 Diyarbakır |
Nazif YAVUZ |
|
|
54187/08 |
Nahit ÖZTÜRKCAN 5/09/1951 Istanbul |
Faruk ÖKSÜZ |
|
|
5400/09 |
Yusuf KÜÇÜKŞEN 1/1/1933 Leiderdorp |
Türkan YILMAZ |
Official sources: view the source page · Official PDF
HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.