Tax European Court of Human Rights
ĆALDOVIĆ v. SERBIA AND OTHER APPLICATIONS
SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 1/10
Milenko ĆALDOVIĆ against Serbia
and 40 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 13 November 2012 as a Committee composed of:
Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque, President,
Dragoljub Popović,
Helen Keller, judges,
and Françoise Elens-Passos, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the applications below (see table appended) lodged between 6 November 2009 and 26 February 2010,
Having regard to the formal declarations accepting a friendly settlement of the cases,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
The applicants are Serbian nationals (for additional personal details see the appended table). They were represented before the Court by Mr M. Jevtović, a lawyer practising in Užice. The Serbian Government (”the Government”) were represented by their Agent, Mr S. Carić.
Relying on Article 6 of the Convention, the applicants complained about the respondent State’s failure to fully enforce final court decisions rendered in their favour against the same “socially-owned” company. The essential information as to the domestic proceedings in respect of each application is indicated in the appended table.
Between 5 April 2012 and 25 April 2012 the Court received friendly settlement declarations signed by the parties under which the applicants agreed to waive any further claims against Serbia in respect of the facts giving rise to these applications against an undertaking by the Government to pay each of them the amounts specified in the appended table to cover any non-pecuniary damage as well as costs and expenses, which will be converted into local currency at the rate applicable on the date of payment, and will be free of any taxes that may be applicable. These sums will be payable within three months from the date of notification of the decision taken by the Court. In the event of failure to pay these sums within the said three-month period, the Government undertook to pay simple interest on them, from expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points.
The parties, furthermore, agreed that within the said three-month period the Government will pay, from their own funds, the sums awarded in the domestic decisions under consideration in the present cases (see table appended), less any amounts which may have already been paid on the basis of the said decisions, plus the costs of the domestic enforcement proceedings. These payments will constitute the final resolution of the cases pending before the European Court of Human Rights.
THE LAW
The Court considers that, in accordance with Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal background.
The Court takes note of the friendly settlement reached between the parties. It is satisfied that the settlement is based on respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols and finds no reasons to justify a continued examination of the applications.
In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the cases out of the list pursuant to Article 39 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Decides to strike the applications out of its list of cases.
Françoise Elens-Passos Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque
Deputy Registrar President
APPENDIX
|
No. |
Application no. |
Lodged on |
Applicant’s name date of birth place of residence |
Final domestic decision (issuing authority / case no. and date of issuance) |
Enforcement order (enforcement authority, case no., date of order and / or other information) |
Friendly settlement amount |
|
|
1/10 |
11/11/2009 |
Milenko ĆALDOVIĆ 24/01/1958 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.103/03 of 21 February 2003 |
Municipal Court in Užice I.1210/2003 of 11 April 2003 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
55/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Ljubiša BRALOVIĆ 25/03/1956 Sevojno
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.152/03 of 11 March 2003 |
Municipal Court in Užice I.1237/03 of 23 April 2003 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
60/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Milomir VIDIĆ 04/04/1960 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.143/03 of 27 March 2003 |
Municipal Court in Užice I.1256/03 of 5 May 2003 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
62/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Ljubinko FILIPOVIĆ 15/02/1960 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I. 203/03 of 16 April 2003 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.1247/02 of 18 May 2004 3. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.863/04 of 24 November 2004 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice I.1965/2003 of 30 May 2003 2. Municipal Court in Užice I.1333/04 of 12 December 2004 3. Request for enforcement of P.I.863/04 filed on 15 December 2004 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made) |
2,100 euros |
|
|
65/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Vojislav BAKOVIĆ 02/01/1979 Mečkat
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I. 145/03 of 10 July 2003 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.924/04 of 24 December 2004 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice I.2663/03 of 11 August 2003 2. Municipal Court in Užice I. 495/05 of 7 March 2005 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
75/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Željko TANASKOVIĆ 30/03/1979 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.231/03 of 8 July 2003 |
Municipal Court in Užice I.2665/03 of 11 August 2003 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
77/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Radomir ALEKSIĆ 13/05/1935 Bajina Bašta
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.105/03 of 17 June 2003 |
Municipal Court in Užice I.2666/03 of 11 August 2003 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
106/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Grozdomir GRADINČEVIĆ 05/09/1956 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.752/02 of 16 January 2003 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.12/04 of 26 January 2004 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice I.3187/03 of 4 December 2003 2. Municipal Court in Užice I.663/04 of 16 April 2004 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
110/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Petronije PERIĆ 18/08/1953 Bajina Bašta
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.102/99 of 21 July 1999 2. Municipal Court in Užice 1247/02 of 18 May 2004 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice I.227/04 of 17 February 2004 2. Municipal Court in Užice I.1333/02 of 12 December 2004 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
112/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Milenko ŠABOTOVIĆ 16/06/1957 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.7/04 of 26 January 2004 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.725/04 of 20 October 2004 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice I.277/04 of 23 February 2004 2. Request for enforcement of P.I.725/04 filed on 2 December 2004 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made) |
2,100 euros |
|
|
113/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Zdravko RAKIĆ 12/01/1950 Sevojno
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.9/04 of 26 January 2004 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.26/04 of 18 May 2006 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice I. 278/04 of 23 February 2004 2. Request for enforcement of P.I.26/04 filed on 23 June 2006 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made) |
2,100 euros |
|
|
115/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Drago JANKOVIĆ 15/04/1950 Užice |
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.436 of 28 January 2004 |
Municipal Court in Užice I.279/04 of 23 February 2004 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
128/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Mirko STIKOVIĆ 21/04/1951 Prijepolje
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.114/04 of 19 February 2004 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.100/04 of 3 December 2004 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice I. 509/04 of 29 March 2004 2. Request for enforcement P.I.100/04 filed on 12 April 2006 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made) |
2,100 euros |
|
|
133/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Zorica VIRIJEVIĆ 11/10/1947 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.375/98 of 9 February 2000 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.79/2003 of 26 June 2003 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice I. 512/04 of 29 March 2004 2. Request for enforcement of P.I.79/2003 filed on 25 March 2004 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made) |
2,100 euros |
|
|
138/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Milena TUCOVIĆ 30/05/1947 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.375/98 of 17 March 1999 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.375/98 of 9 February 2000 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice I.511/04 of 29 March 2004 2. Municipal Court in Užice I.511/04 of 29 March 2004 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
150/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Milan SIMIĆ 13/08/1947 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.26/04 of 18 May 2006 |
Request for enforcement of P.I.26/04 filed on 23 June 2006 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made) |
2,100 euros |
|
|
152/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Aleksandar ŽUNIĆ 27/09/1969 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.26/04 of 18 May 2006 |
Request for enforcement of P.I.26/04 filed on 23 June 2006 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made) |
2,100 euros |
|
|
208/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Mladena SUPUROVIĆ 22/03/1947 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.375/98 of 17 March 1999 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.375/98 of 9 February 2000 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice I.513/04 of 29 March 2004 2. Municipal Court in Užice I.513/04 of 29 March 2004 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
212/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Ilija STARČEVIĆ 02/08/1950 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.298/98 of 8 October 1998 |
Municipal Court in Užice Certificate of enforceability of 27 January 1999 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
219/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Miodrag MARKOVIĆ 14/08/1952 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.291/97 of 1 June 1998 |
Municipal Court in Užice I.564/05 of 21 March 2005 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
224/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Tomislav ĐUROVIĆ 04/02/1954 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.267/04 of 27 September 2004 |
Request for enforcement of P.I.267/04 filed on 3 December 2004 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made)
|
1,100 euros |
|
|
228/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Miloš ŽUNIĆ 04/03/1953 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.267/04 of 27 September 2004 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.690/03 of 3 December 2004 |
1. Request for enforcement of P.I.267/04 filed on 3 December 2004 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made) 2. Request for enforcement of P.I.690/03 filed on 19 January 2005 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made)
|
2,100 euros |
|
|
259/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Nikola VIDIĆ 12/05/1951 Sirogojno
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.711/06 of 5 February 2007 |
Request for enforcement of P.I.711/06 filed on 13 March 2008 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made)
|
1,100 euros |
|
|
260/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Sredoje RAKOVIĆ 15/03/1953 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.178/06 of 8 May 2006 |
Request for enforcement of P.I.178/06 filed on 6 June 2008 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made) |
2,100 euros |
|
|
277/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Nadežda VIDIĆ 25/10/1950 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.298/98 of 8 October 1998 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 3. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.879/05 of 17 November 2005 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice Certificate of enforceability of 27 January 1999 2. Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised) 3. Municipal Court in Užice Certificate of enforceability of 3 October 2006 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
280/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Danica SAVIĆ 24/10/1952 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.879/05 of 17 November 2005 |
1. Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised) 2. Municipal Court in Užice Certificate of enforceability of 3 October 2006 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
282/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Slađana RAKIĆ 16/09/1952 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.298/98 of 8 October 1998 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 3. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.879/05 of 17 November 2005 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice Certificate of enforceability of 27 January 1999 2. Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised) 3. Municipal Court in Užice Certificate of enforceability of 3 October 2006 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
283/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Mihailo NJEGOŠEVIĆ 03/06/1943 Bela Zemlja
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 |
Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised)
|
2,100 euros |
|
|
288/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Radmila STARČEVIĆ 18/12/1950 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 |
Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised)
|
2,100 euros |
|
|
415/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Radmila MIRKOVIĆ 04/03/1962 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 |
Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised)
|
2,100 euros |
|
|
419/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Snežana RISTOVIĆ 15/10/1965 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 |
Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised)
|
2,100 euros |
|
|
420/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Ana MAJIĆ 17/05/1953 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.298/98 of 8 October 1998 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice Certificate of enforceability of 27 January 1999 2. Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised)
|
2,100 euros |
|
|
421/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Vera NIKOLIĆ 28/10/1950 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.298/98 of 8 October 1998 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 |
1. Municipal Court in Užice Certificate of enforceability of 27 January 1999 2. Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised) |
2,100 euros |
|
|
422/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Miroslav PIŠČEVIĆ 15/11/1940 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 |
Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised)
|
2,100 euros |
|
|
424/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Sanja PAPIĆ 04/07/1972 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 |
Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised)
|
2,100 euros |
|
|
426/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Milena PETROVIĆ 15/09/1952 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 |
Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised)
|
2,100 euros |
|
|
427/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Mirjana TRIFUNOVIĆ 14/08/1952 Beograd
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.76/04 of 5 March 2004 |
Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised)
|
2,100 euros |
|
|
491/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Marko PEJIĆ 03/06/1994 Užice
Marija PEJIĆ 01/04/1993 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.496/04 of 15 June 2004 |
Municipal Court in Užice I.1150/04 of 8 August 2004 |
2,100 euros |
|
|
1033/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Ljubiša ALEKSIĆ 10/01/1945 Užice
|
1. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.34/2000 of 22 June 2000 2. Municipal Court in Užice P.I.131/2001 of 17 April 2001 |
1. Commercial Court in Užice St.7/08 of 9 November 2008 (claim recognised) 2. Request for enforcement of P.I.131/2001 filed on 18 May 2006 with Municipal Court in Užice (no decision made) |
2,100 euros |
|
|
1531/10 |
06/11/2009 |
Milenko TOŠIĆ 07/05/1973 Užice
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.319/2003 of 9 September 2003 |
Municipal Court in Užice I.3079/03 of 10 November 2003 |
1,100 euros |
|
|
12510/10 |
26/02/2010 |
Dobrisav BUČIĆ 15/08/1953 Zlatibor
|
Municipal Court in Užice P.I.1182/02 of 19 June 2007 |
Municipal Court in Užice I.201/07 of 12 November 2007 |
2,100 euros |
Official sources: view the source page · Official PDF
HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.