Miscellaneous Etats-Unis

State v. Martin

Official source
[Cite as State v. Martin, 

2026-Ohio-4289

.]


                               COURT OF APPEALS OF OHIO

                              EIGHTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
                                 COUNTY OF CUYAHOGA


STATE OF OHIO,                                     :

                 Plaintiff-Appellee,               :
                                                            No. 116249
                 v.                                :

TRAMAINE E. MARTIN,                                :

                 Defendant-Appellant.              :


                                JOURNAL ENTRY AND OPINION

                 JUDGMENT: AFFIRMED
                 RELEASED AND JOURNALIZED: October 29, 2026


            Civil Appeal from the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas
                               Case No. CR-16-612220-A


                                             Appearances:

                 Michael C. O’Malley, Cuyahoga County Prosecuting
                 Attorney, and Anthony T. Miranda, Assistant Prosecuting
                 Attorney, for appellee.

                 Tramaine E. Martin, pro se.


EILEEN A. GALLAGHER, J.:

                Tramaine Martin (“Martin”) appeals the trial court’s denial of his

successive petition for postconviction relief. For the reasons that follow, we affirm.
Facts and Procedural History

            This is Martin’s fifth appeal to this court concerning his underlying

criminal convictions in the same case. In December 2016, Martin was charged in a

five-count indictment from allegations that he sexually assaulted his ex-girlfriend’s

ten-year-old niece. Martin was tried and found guilty of attempted rape, gross

sexual imposition and kidnapping with a sexual-motivation specification. Martin

was sentenced to an indefinite prison term of ten years to life. In July 2017, Martin

appealed his sentence. Martin’s sentence and convictions were affirmed by this

court in State v. Martin, 

2018-Ohio-1843

 (8th Dist.) (“Martin I”).

            The same day that Martin filed his notice of appeal for Martin I, he filed

a petition for postconviction relief in the trial court, which the trial court denied.

Martin did not appeal this denial.

             In January 2019, Martin filed a second petition for postconviction relief

on different grounds. The trial court denied that motion and this court affirmed that

denial in State v. Martin, 

2019-Ohio-4463, ¶ 19

 (8th Dist.) (“Martin II”).

            In June 2022, Martin filed an application for postconviction DNA

testing in the trial court in which he requested that the victim’s underwear be

retested. The trial court denied the motion. This court affirmed that denial in State

v. Martin, 

2023-Ohio-3153

, ¶ 19 (8th Dist.) (“Martin III”).

             In May 2024, Martin filed a pro se motion to correct an illegal sentence.

The trial court denied that motion and this court affirmed that denial in State v.

Martin, 

2024-Ohio-5486, ¶ 22

 (8th Dist.) (“Martin IV”).
              Also in May 2024, Martin filed a successive petition for postconviction

relief in which he argued that the State failed to disclose at trial the name of the

author for the Cuyahoga County Division of Children and Family Services

(“CCDCFS”) report and the laboratory notes for the Bureau of Criminal

Investigations (“BCI”) item No. 1.7.2B, which was the consumed swab from the back

panel of the victim’s underwear. The trial court denied Martin’s successive petition

on March 27, 2025.

               Martin appeals that denial raising the following three assignments of

error:

         Assignment of Error I: The trial court erred in not properly
         journalizing its rulings and violating the “one-document” rule.

         Assignment of Error II: The trial court erred, as a matter of law, in
         denying post-conviction relief without first determining the threshold
         question of jurisdiction.

         Assignment of Error III: The trial court erred in not filing findings
         of fact and conclusions of law when Martin raised new ground(s) for
         relief.

Law and Analysis

               R.C. 2953.21(A)(2)(a) provides that a petition for postconviction relief

must be filed within 365 days from the filing of the trial transcripts in the petitioner’s

direct appeal. Martin’s transcript was filed in Martin I on September 5, 2017.

Martin’s petition for postconviction relief in this case was filed on May 6, 2024. As

such, Martin’s petition is facially untimely.

                “Because       the   timeliness    requirement     of   R.C.    2953.23    is

jurisdictional,    a   trial    court   does      not   have   jurisdiction    to   entertain
an untimely petition for postconviction relief unless the exceptions set forth under

R.C. 2953.23 are satisfied.” State v. Atahiya, 

2021-Ohio-1488, ¶ 21

 (8th Dist.).

       R.C. 2953.23(A)(1)(a) permits a trial court to entertain an untimely
       petition only if:

       (1) the petitioner was unavoidably prevented from discovering the facts
       on which the petition is predicated, or

       (2) the United States Supreme Court has recognized a new federal or
       state right that applies retroactively to the petitioner and the petition
       asserts a claim based on that new right.

Id.

   Martin alleges in his petition that he was unavoidably prevented from

discovering the facts on which his petition is predicated pursuant to R.C.

2953.23(A)(1)(a).

              “If the petitioner can satisfy one of these threshold conditions, he or

she must then demonstrate by clear and convincing evidence that, but for the

constitutional error at trial, no reasonable factfinder would have found him or her

guilty of the offenses of which he or she was convicted. R.C. 2953.23(A)(1)(b).” Id.

at ¶ 22.

              Our standard of review in this case was set forth in Atahiya:

       Typically, a reviewing court reviews a trial court’s decision granting or
       denying a petition for postconviction relief for an abuse of discretion.
       Gondor, 

112 Ohio St.3d 377

, 

2006-Ohio-6679

, 

860 N.E.2d 77, at ¶ 58

.
       However, whether the trial court possessed subject matter jurisdiction
       to entertain an untimely petition for postconviction relief is a question
       of law, which we review de novo. State v. Apanovitch, 

155 Ohio St.3d
358

, 

2018-Ohio-4744

, 

121 N.E.3d 351, ¶ 24

.
      Assignment of Error I

              In his first assignment of error, Martin argues that the trial court’s

judgment entry denying his petition violates the “one-document” rule as stated in

State v. Baker, 

2008-Ohio-3330

, ¶ 17. He also argues in his brief that the trial

court’s judgment entry here is flawed because it does not “bare a judge’s signature”

and the accompanying order does not “bare a label or a time-stamp of the clerk.”

              Baker establishes the four requirements for a judgment of conviction

to be a final appealable order under R.C. 2505.02. Id. at ¶ 18. This case and its rule

are not applicable here because Martin is taking issue with the judgment entry

denying his petition, not his judgment of conviction, with which he raises no issues.

              Furthermore, while the trial court’s judgment entry does not have the

judge’s signature it is time stamped by the clerk’s office. The order ends with “OSJ.”

As previously explained by this court, “OSJ” means to “order see journal” or “order

see judgment.” Moore v. Russo, 

2017-Ohio-9166

, ¶ 13 (8th Dist.). “OSJ” means that

the signed judgment is attached to the order, which was the case here since the

attached order did contain the judge’s signature. 

Id.

 In Moore this court held that

a judgment entry that contains the clerk’s time-stamp and has “OSJ” written with

an attached and signed order is proper. 

Id.

 Just as in Moore, here the judgment

entry did contain both the clerk’s time-stamp with “OSJ” written and had an

attached order with the judge’s signature. This judgment entry is therefore proper.

              Martin’s first assignment of error is overruled.
      Assignment of Error II

              Martin’s second assignment of error alleges that the trial court erred

by denying the petition without determining if it had jurisdiction. Again, we review

whether a trial court possessed subject matter jurisdiction de novo. State v. Bethel,

2022-Ohio-783, ¶ 20

.

              In this case, the trial court would not have jurisdiction to hear Martin’s

successive postconviction petition if he was unable to satisfy R.C. 2953.23(A)(1)(a)

by establishing he was “unavoidably prevented from discovery of the facts.” “R.C.

2953.23 puts the onus on the petitioner to show that he was unavoidably prevented

from discovering the facts on which his petition relies.” State v. Johnson, 2024-

Ohio-134, ¶ 13. The petitioner has a duty to present sufficient evidence to carry this

burden at the time the petition is filed. Id. at ¶ 26.

              “Unavoidably prevented from discovery of the facts” means the

postconviction relief petitioner was (1) unaware of those facts; and (2) unable “‘to

learn of them through reasonable diligence.’” State v. Harrison, 

2018-Ohio-1396,

¶ 6

 (8th Dist.), quoting State v. Short, 

2003-Ohio-3538

, ¶ 9 (8th Dist.).

               “In Brady [v. Maryland, 

373 U.S. 83

 (1963)] the Supreme Court of

the United States held that a state violates the Fourteenth Amendment to the United

States Constitution when it ‘withholds evidence that is favorable to the defense and

material to the defendant’s guilt or punishment.’” Bethel, 

2022-Ohio-783, at ¶ 19

,

quoting Smith v. Cain, 

565 U.S. 73, 75

 (2012) (summarizing Brady’s holding).

“‘There are three components of a true Brady violation: The evidence at issue must
be favorable to the accused, either because it is exculpatory, or because it is

impeaching; that evidence must have been suppressed by the State, either willfully

or inadvertently; and prejudice must have ensued.’” 

Bethel at ¶ 19

, quoting Strickler

v. Greene, 

527 U.S. 263, 281-282

 (1999).

              The Ohio Supreme Court has held that “when a defendant seeks to

assert a Brady claim in an untimely or successive petition for postconviction relief,

the defendant satisfies the unavoidably prevented requirement contained in R.C.

2953.23(A)(1)(a) by establishing that the prosecution suppressed the evidence on

which the defendant relies.” 

Bethel at ¶ 25

. “There is no Brady violation where

evidence is disclosed or introduced during trial.” State v. Collins, 

2020-Ohio-4136,

¶ 14

 (8th Dist.); See State v. Iacona, 

93 Ohio St.3d 83, 100

 (2001).

              Martin alleges in his petition that the State withheld evidence in

violation of Brady. The allegedly withheld evidence is the name of the author of the

CCDCFS report and the BCI laboratory notes for item No. 1.7.2.B. The exhibits

attached to Martin’s petition to support these allegations include (1) a journal entry

ordering CCDCFS to produce records to the court for an in camera inspection and

transcript pages from a hearing in Martin’s case showing the State had produced

“CFS records” and that Martin’s counsel had not yet reviewed them; (2) BCI

Laboratory Reports; (3) a journal entry from the trial court in CR-14-587110-B; and

(4) a couple of transcript pages from Martin’s trial from the testimonies of Andrea

Dennis, a forensic scientist, and Lindsay Pruneski, a forensic biologist, both of whom

conducted DNA testing at the BCI for the State.
              Regarding the CCDCFS report, Martin alleges that if he had known

the author of the CCDCFS report he would have been able to call the author to the

stand to question him regarding his conclusions. Martin alleges that the copy of the

report he received prior to trial was redacted to conform to confidentiality

requirements.

              Martin, however, failed to attach a copy of this report to his petition

and his allegation in his petition that the report was redacted to conform to

confidentiality requirements does not firmly establish that the report’s author was

redacted and unknown to him. Furthermore, if Martin received the report, even if

redacted, then the report was not suppressed as it was disclosed and provided to him

and he provides no reasons why he would have been unable to call the author of a

report that was ordered by the trial court for an in camera inspection before being

provided to the parties. No affidavit was attached to his petition to verify any

statements made in his petition. None of the exhibits attached to the petition

establish that the author of the report was kept from him by the State or even at all.

This is not sufficient to establish that this evidence was suppressed in violation of

Brady.

              Regarding the BCI laboratory notes for item No 1.7.2.B, Martin alleges

the results from the swab of the back panel of underwear were exculpatory and the

notes were “favorable” to him because they “disclosed the weakness of the amylase

found[.]” Martin then argues that the attached exhibit testimony shows the forensic

scientists admitted to manipulating the swab to concentrate the sample.
                  Again, Martin fails to support his allegation that this evidence was

suppressed, i.e., withheld from him by the State. Martin does not provide an

affidavit stating that he never received the report in discovery and the State’s

response to defendant’s request for discovery filed on January 30, 2017, lists the

provided discovery materials and included there is “DNA Report.” While the report

is not attached, such that this court cannot confirm with 100 percent certainty that

it is the same BCI report Martin alleges was suppressed, Martin at no point states

this DNA report was not the BCI report. The mere fact that the BCI report was

disclosed and provided to Martin establishes that this evidence was not suppressed

and no Brady violation occurred. Because Martin had the report, if he wanted

additional documentation such as laboratory notes, he was more than capable of

requesting the additional documentation in discovery. His failure to do so does not

amount to suppressed evidence.

                  Because these reports were disclosed to Martin, he fails to establish a

Brady violation because the evidence was never suppressed by the State. Collins,

2020-Ohio-4136, at ¶ 14

. Failure to establish a Brady violation also means Martin

has failed to establish that he was “unavoidably prevented from discovery of the

facts” because the evidence was not suppressed. Bethel, 

2022-Ohio-783, at ¶ 25

. He

presents no other evidence establishing how he was unavoidably prevented from the

discovery of facts related to the two reports which he does not dispute he received

prior to trial.
               ‘“[A] petitioner’s failure to satisfy R.C. 2953.23(A) deprives a trial

court of jurisdiction to adjudicate the merits of an untimely or successive

postconviction petition.”’   State v. Kenney, 

2025-Ohio-4841, ¶ 17

 (8th Dist.),

quoting Apanovitch, 

2018-Ohio-4744, at ¶ 36

. A trial court properly denies an

untimely and successive petition when it lacks authority to entertain it pursuant to

R.C. 2953.23(A). State v. Little, 

2021-Ohio-1446, ¶ 9

 (9th Dist.).

              Wherefore, because Martin is unable to satisfy the requirements of

R.C. 2953.23(A)(1)(a), the trial court was without jurisdiction to entertain his

untimely and successive petition as a matter of law and properly denied it.

              Martin’s second assignment of error is overruled.

      Assignment of Error III

              In his third, and last, assignment of error Martin alleges the trial court

erred by not issuing findings of fact and conclusions of law when it denied Martin’s

petition despite him raising new grounds for relief.

              “A trial court has no duty to issue findings of fact and conclusions of

law when it dismisses untimely or successive petitions for postconviction relief.”

Kenney, 

2025-Ohio-4841, at ¶ 17

. Technically, the trial court in this case denied

Martin’s petition rather than dismissing it for lack of jurisdiction. Courts have

“previously advised that trial courts should dismiss a petition for postconviction

relief when jurisdiction is lacking rather than denying the petition on some other

grounds.” State v. Jones, 

2019-Ohio-1014

, ¶ 17 (10th Dist.). Nevertheless, we may

conclude the trial court did not err in its disposition of Martin’s petition and affirm
its judgment. Id. at ¶ 18; see State v. Ali, 

2021-Ohio-4303, ¶ 13

 (8th Dist.) (Because

the trial court lacked jurisdiction to hear the untimely and successive petition for

postconviction relief, the trial court did not err by summarily denying it.).

              As such, because the trial court lacked jurisdiction to hear Martin’s

untimely and successive petition, the trial court did not err in summarily denying

Martin’s petition without issuing findings of fact and conclusions of law.

              Martin’s third assignment of error is overruled.

      Vexatious Litigator

              This is Martin’s fifth unsuccessful appeal regarding his underlying

criminal convictions in the same case. Martin is hereby forewarned that if he

continues to file frivolous appeals, this may result in him being declared a vexatious

litigator by this court and be subjected to future appellate filing requirements under

Loc.App.R. 23(B)-(C).

              Judgment affirmed.

      It is ordered that appellee recover from appellant costs herein taxed.

      The court finds there were reasonable grounds for this appeal.

      It is ordered that a special mandate issue out of this court directing the

common pleas court to carry this judgment into execution.
      A certified copy of this entry shall constitute the mandate pursuant to Rule 27

of the Rules of Appellate Procedure.


________________________
EILEEN A. GALLAGHER, JUDGE

MICHAEL JOHN RYAN, P.J., and
TIMOTHY W. CLARY, J., CONCUR

For advice on a matter of this kind in France, contact our criminal law attorney in Paris.


Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.