Civil European Court of Human Rights
DŁUGOSZ AND OTHERS v. POLAND
FIRST SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 5791/11
Katarzyna DŁUGOSZ against Poland
and 59 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 12 December 2017 as a Committee composed of:
Aleš Pejchal, President,
Krzysztof Wojtyczek,
Armen Harutyunyan, judges,
and Renata Degener, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,
Having regard to the declarations submitted by the respondent Government on 3 March 2016 and 28 February and 13 July 2017 requesting the Court to strike the applications out of the list of cases and the applicants’ reply to that declarations,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
FACTS AND PROCEDURE
1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.
2. The Polish Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent, Ms J. Chrzanowska, of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
3. All the applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention about the excessive length of proceedings in their cases and under Article 13 of the Convention about the lack of, or insufficient, redress for the excessive length of proceedings granted to them by the national courts.
4. On 7 July 2015 the applications were communicated to the Polish Government pursuant to Rule 54 § 2 (b) of the Rules of Court, by virtue of the ninth operative provision of the pilot-judgment given in the case of Rutkowski and Others v. Poland (see Rutkowski and Others v. Poland, nos. 72287/10 and 2 others, §§ 223-228 and the ninth operative provision, 7 July 2015).
5. By letters dated 3 March 2016 and 28 February and 13 July 2017 the Government informed the Court that they proposed to make declarations with a view to resolving the issues raised by the applications. In each case the Government acknowledged a violation of Article 6 § 1 on account of the excessive length of proceedings and violation of Article 13 on account of the lack of an effective remedy, securing sufficient redress for a violation of Article 6 § 1. They offered payment of sums specified in respect of each applicant in a table appended to their declarations. The Government further undertook to adopt a range of general measures in respect of other persons who were victims of similar violations or might be affected by similar violations in the future. The sums referred to above, which are specified in the appendix to the decision, are to cover any pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage as well as costs and expenses, will be free of any taxes that may be applicable. They will be payable within three months from the date of notification of the decision taken by the Court pursuant to Article 37 § 1 of the Convention. In the event of failure to pay these sums within the said three-month period, the Government undertook to pay simple interest on each of them, from expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default periods plus three percentage points. In addition, the Government made a declaration on general measures to be adopted in implementation of the Rutkowski and Others pilot judgment (see Załuska and Rogalska v. Poland and 398 other applications (dec.), nos. 53491/10 and 72286/10, §§ 23-25, 20 June 2017). They further requested the Court to strike out the applications in accordance with Article 37 of the Convention.
THE LAW
6. Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.
7. On various dates in 2017 all applicants informed the Court that they had agreed to the terms of the Government’s declarations.
8. The Court finds that following the applicants’ express agreements to the terms of the declarations made by the Government the cases should be treated as friendly settlements between them and the Government.
9. Article 39 of the Convention, conferring on the Court the power to strike a case out of its list of cases in the event of a friendly settlement, provides:
“If a friendly settlement is effected, the Court shall strike the case out of its list by means of a decision which shall be confined to a brief statement of the facts and of the solution reached.”
10. The Court has already examined the first group of 400 unilateral declarations submitted by the Government in the pilot-judgment procedure in the case Rutkowski and Others, cited above. It found that, in view of the amounts proposed by the Government in their unilateral declarations on the individual measures of redress, there have been no circumstances regarding respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols which would require the continued examination of the cases where a friendly settlement has been concluded (see Załuska and Rogalska (dec.), cited above, § 37). It has also been satisfied that, having regard to the general measures taken or to be taken in the future by the respondent Government, the settlement was based on “respect for human rights” as interpreted in the context of the pilot-judgment procedure (see ibid, § 45).
11. The same conclusions apply to the instant cases. The Court therefore takes note of the friendly settlements reached between the parties. It is satisfied that the settlements are based on respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols and finds no reasons to justify a continued examination of the application.
12. In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the cases out of the list.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Decides to strike the applications out of its list of cases pursuant to Article 39 of the Convention.
Done in English and notified in writing on 11 January 2018.
Renata Degener Aleš Pejchal
Deputy Registrar President
APPENDIX
|
No. |
Application no. |
Lodged on |
Applicant Date of birth Place of residence |
Represented by |
Introduced by |
Amount proposed in Unilateral Declaration |
|
|
5791/11 |
13/01/2011 |
Katarzyna DŁUGOSZ 09/08/1972 Rzeszów
|
|
Katarzyna Długosz |
PLN 12,920 |
|
|
6102/11 |
20/01/2011 |
Sławomir KOGUT 13/05/1964 Rzeszów
|
|
Sławomir Kogut |
PLN 12,480 |
|
|
44805/11 |
22/06/2011 |
Janusz MIERNICKI 26/01/1937 Warsaw
|
|
Janusz Miernicki |
PLN 23,120 |
|
|
77330/11 |
29/11/2011 |
Janusz MIERNICKI 26/01/1937 Warsaw |
|
Janusz Miernicki |
PLN 43,680 |
|
|
26224/12 |
25/04/2012 |
Wiesław WAKULIŃSKI 28/02/1959 Warsaw
|
|
Wiesław Wakuliński |
PLN 4,240 |
|
|
33343/12 |
21/05/2012 |
Jacek KOMOROWSKI 20/09/1976 Marki
|
|
Jacek Komorowski |
PLN 12,560 |
|
|
38582/12 |
04/06/2012 |
Sławomir WYSOCKI 15/02/1969 Kamińsk
|
|
Sławomir Wysocki |
PLN 14,380 |
|
|
42422/12 |
21/06/2012 |
Dariusz BŁASZCZYK 09/11/1976 Włocławek |
|
Dariusz Błaszczyk |
PLN 7,920 |
|
|
43421/12 |
28/05/2012 |
Tadeusz SOKOŁOWSKI 27/07/1956 Nowogród Bobrzański |
|
Tadeusz Sokołowski |
PLN 19,380 |
|
|
43510/12 |
27/06/2012 |
Andrzej WLASTELICZ 26/01/1964 Warsaw
|
|
Andrzej Wlastelicz |
PLN 4,510 |
|
|
46716/12 |
10/07/2012 |
Włodzimierz CELEJEWSKI 20/12/1963 Psary
|
|
Włodzimierz Celejewski |
PLN 19,370 |
|
|
50461/12 |
02/08/2012 |
Artur PYRZANOWSKI-KLUCZYŃSKI 03/11/1976 Czerwony Bór
|
|
Artur Pyrzanowski-Kluczyński |
PLN 7,360 |
|
|
54027/12 |
08/08/2012 |
Mariusz ROZENCWAJG 05/08/1961 Gdańsk |
Marcin KRAKOWSKI |
Mariusz Rozencwajg |
PLN 16,550 for the first set of proceedings and PLN 21,840 for the second set of proceedings |
|
|
60258/12 |
21/11/2012 |
Jerzy GÓRECKI 13/10/1974 Gdańsk
|
|
Jerzy Górecki |
PLN 21,700 |
|
|
61012/12 |
30/08/2012 |
Tomasz MAŚLANKA Cracow
|
Monika SAWARSKA |
Tomasz Maślanka |
PLN 24,220 |
|
|
61024/12 |
04/09/2012 |
Sławomir MALINOWSKI 14/06/1974 Marki
|
|
Sławomir Malinowski |
PLN 16,045 |
|
|
62459/12 |
06/09/2012 |
Paweł CZYŻ 09/01/1978 Bielsko-Biała
|
|
Paweł Czyż |
PLN 15,920 |
|
|
63776/12 |
13/09/2012 |
Wojciech KUCHARCZYK 11/10/1958 Dobczyn
|
|
Wojciech Kucharczyk |
PLN 6,040 |
|
|
65503/12 |
30/11/2012 |
Leszek FISZER 03/02/1963 Legnica
|
|
Leszek Fiszer |
PLN 7,800 |
|
|
66711/12 |
01/10/2012 |
Tomasz KACZMARSKI 18/07/1982 Warsaw
|
|
Tomasz Kaczmarski |
PLN 30,730 |
|
|
66858/12 |
11/10/2012 |
Mariusz SŁABOSZ 16/04/1975 Sosnowiec
|
Mirosława SŁABOSZ |
Mariusz Słabosz |
PLN 9,660 |
|
|
68398/12 |
11/10/2012 |
Damian OBREMSKI 31/10/1972 Krzywaniec
|
|
Damian Obremski |
PLN 13,510 |
|
|
69056/12 |
24/09/2012 |
Krzysztof RACIS 08/10/1975 Warsaw
|
|
Krzysztof Racis |
PLN 26,080 |
|
|
69128/12 |
10/10/2012 |
Krzysztof KRYŃSKI 25/07/1982 Radziejowice
|
|
Krzysztof Kryński |
PLN 4,240 |
|
|
32823/13 |
17/05/2013 |
Jarosław JANKOWSKI 05/10/1968 Poznań
|
Damian NOWICKI |
Jarosław Jankowski |
PLN 8,724 |
|
|
44451/13 |
10/06/2013 |
Remigiusz KACZMAREK 07/07/1976 Racibórz
|
|
Remigiusz Kaczmarek |
PLN 6,240 |
|
|
61490/13 |
16/09/2013 |
Janusz TRELA 13/09/1963 Wołów
|
|
Janusz Trela |
PLN 36,810 |
|
|
67187/13 |
18/10/2013 |
Tadeusz Antoni STACHYRA 05/07/1954 Warsaw |
|
Tadeusz Antoni Stachyra |
PLN 41,980 |
|
|
68660/13 |
25/10/2013 |
Michał WALICKI 20/06/1986 Warsaw
|
Marcin MAZUR |
Michał Walicki |
PLN 12,920 |
|
|
68744/13 |
15/10/2013 |
Marek GOŁAWSKI 02/05/1966 Michałki
|
|
Marek Goławski |
PLN 12,510 |
|
|
76685/13 |
26/11/2013 |
Innocente SCATTOLIN 06/06/1956 Dąbrówno
|
Maciej ŁAPUĆ |
Innocente Scattolin |
PLN 12,920 |
|
|
54/14 |
06/12/2013 |
Mariusz GRABIEC 28/08/1977 Lubsko
|
|
Mariusz Grabiec |
PLN 22,960 |
|
|
1450/14 |
10/12/2013 |
Marek MASZKIEWICZ 05/01/1955 Warsaw
|
|
Marek Maszkiewicz |
PLN 33,720 |
|
|
7916/14 |
09/01/2014 |
Daniel Bolesław WICZANOWSKI 27/07/1981 Bielsko-Biała
|
|
Daniel Bolesław Wiczanowski |
PLN 16,650 |
|
|
10582/14 |
09/09/2014 |
Robert ZAGALSKI 10/03/1982 Warsaw
|
|
Robert Zagalski |
PLN 9,360 |
|
|
12760/14 |
24/01/2014 |
Wojciech FALKIEWICZ 19/04/1988 Bielsko – Biała
|
|
Wojciech Falkiewicz |
PLN 7,800 |
|
|
16754/14 |
10/02/2014 |
Mariusz Robert BERGER 24/09/1976 Warsaw |
|
Mariusz Robert Berger |
PLN 37,920 |
|
|
18218/14 |
12/02/2014 |
Konrad Łukasz IZDEBSKI 01/08/1990 Opole Lubelskie |
|
Konrad Łukasz Izdebski |
PLN 6,240 |
|
|
18907/14 |
14/05/2014 |
Sylwester Robert WÓJCIK 16/07/1960 Bydgoszcz
|
|
Sylwester Robert Wójcik |
PLN 7,290 |
|
|
33782/14 |
11/06/2014 |
Piotr RODACKI 08/04/1983 Cracow
|
|
Piotr Rodacki |
PLN 6,380 |
|
|
33807/14 |
16/04/2014 |
Sebastian PADZIK 15/05/1981 Żytkowice
|
|
Sebastian Padzik |
PLN 3,290 |
|
|
33820/14 |
16/06/2014 |
Edgar ZALINYAN 03/06/1974 Września
|
Robert DUDKOWIAK |
Edgar Zalinyan |
PLN 8,020 |
|
|
59204/14 |
20/08/2014 |
Waldemar KOŁB 09/12/1948 Gdańsk
|
Wiktor SZEWCZYK |
Waldemar Kołb |
PLN 17,260 |
|
|
59596/14 |
02/10/2014 |
Piotr MICHAŁOWSKI 30/04/1959 Koronowo
|
|
Piotr Michałowski |
PLN 9,360 |
|
|
64072/14 |
19/09/2014 |
Andrzej WYCECH 02/05/1966 Węgrów
|
|
Andrzej Wycech |
PLN 10,480 |
|
|
65509/14 |
15/09/2014 |
Tomasz KWAŚNY 02/02/1985 Bytom
|
|
Tomasz Kwaśny |
PLN 7,800 |
|
|
65529/14 |
18/11/2014 |
Arkadiusz KULIBERDA 15/04/1971 Bydgoszcz
|
|
Arkadiusz Kuliberda |
PLN 11,300 |
|
|
65620/14 |
21/09/2014 |
Jolanta GÓRECKA 14/09/1956 Wrocław |
|
Jolanta Górecka |
PLN 21,200 |
|
|
66730/14 |
26/09/2014 |
Mariusz KRUŻMANOWSKI 14/04/1981 Pułtusk |
|
Mariusz Krużmanowski |
PLN 6,240 |
|
|
68262/14 |
04/11/2014 |
Rafał KOWALIK 12/01/1976 Częstochowa |
Marta KOWALIK |
Rafał Kowalik |
PLN 8,480 |
|
|
70806/14 |
09/01/2015 |
Mariusz NOWAK 11/09/1979 Dąbrowa Górnicza
|
|
Mariusz Nowak |
PLN 16,200 |
|
|
74613/14 |
23/10/2014 |
Robert Zdzisław SZAMBOROWSKI 03/09/1974 Warsaw |
|
Robert Zdzisław Szamborowski |
PLN 5,800 |
|
|
75273/14 |
18/11/2014 |
Grzegorz NICIA 08/06/1970 Cracow |
|
Grzegorz Nicia |
PLN 28,900 |
|
|
8702/15 |
09/02/2015 |
Małgorzata GAŃKO 29/10/1987 Sulejówek |
|
Małgorzata Gańko |
PLN 8,040 |
|
|
12001/15 |
03/03/2015 |
Michał PIETRAS 12/12/1984 Włodawa
|
|
Michał Pietras |
PLN 7,660 |
|
|
12010/15 |
03/03/2015 |
Bartłomiej KURIAN 03/02/1983 Zielona Góra |
|
Bartłomiej Kurian |
PLN 9,600 |
|
|
17745/15 |
03/04/2015 |
Olga OLSZEWSKA 07/02/1950 Warsaw |
|
Olga Olszewska |
PLN 23,980 |
|
|
20191/15 |
20/04/2015 |
Sylwia BĄCZEK 07/07/1976 Nowa Sól |
|
Sylwia Bączek |
PLN 18,720 |
|
|
25280/15 |
18/05/2015 |
Marek RASIŃSKI 29/10/1956 Warsaw |
|
Marek Rasiński |
PLN 9,870 |
|
|
25940/15 |
23/05/2015 |
Roman Krzysztof BURZYŃSKI 09/08/1955 Bobrowiec |
|
Roman Krzysztof Burzyński |
PLN 2,800 |
Official sources: view the source page · Official PDF
HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.