Tax European Court of Human Rights

LUNINA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA

ECLI ECLI:CE:ECHR:2011:0113DEC000712003

FIRST SECTION

DECISION

This version was rectified on 21 March 2011
under Rule 81 of the Rules of Court

AS TO THE ADMISSIBILITY OF

Application no. 7120/03
Lidiya Sergeyevna LUNINA and Others
against Russia
(see annex for other applications)

The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 13 January 2011 as a Committee composed of:

 Sverre Erik Jebens, President,
 Anatoly Kovler,
 George Nicolaou, judges,
and André Wampach, Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to the above applications,

Having regard to the decision to apply the pilot-judgment procedure taken in the case of Burdov (no. 2) v. Russia (no. 33509/04, ECHR 2009‑…),

Having regard to the declarations submitted by the respondent Government requesting the Court to strike the applications out of the list of cases and the applicants’ replies to those declarations,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

THE FACTS

The applicants are Russian nationals. Their names and dates of birth are tabulated below.

Ms A. Issayeva, Ms M. Khabarova, Ms T. Yakovleva and Mr K. Mokhnatkin died after lodging their applications under Article 34 of the Convention. Their successors Mr I. Zhukov, Ms N. Khabarova, Ms N. Sokolova and Ms N. Makhnatkina, respectively, indicated their interest in pursuing the proceedings.

The Russian Government (“the Government”) were represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, the Representative of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.

The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.

The applicants sued the State authorities in domestic courts for payment of various monetary sums due under the Russian law. The courts held for the applicants and ordered the authorities to pay various amounts in the form of lump sums and/or of periodic payments to be upgraded in line with the inflation in the country. These judgments became binding but the authorities delayed their enforcement.

In particular, on 27 November 2000 the Sovetskiy District Court of Voronezh awarded Ms Grigorenko’s mother, who had died in September 2000, a certain amount for indexation of her pension (application no. 14218/06). The Government stated that Ms Grigorenko had obtained her inheritance certificate on 23 November 2005 and submitted it together with the writ of execution shortly thereafter. The judgment was enforced on 20 December 2005.

COMPLAINTS

The applicants complained about the delayed enforcement of the judgments in their favour and, in certain cases, of assorted faults that allegedly accompanied the judicial or enforcement proceedings.

THE LAW

I. LOCUS STANDI

The Court takes note of certain applicants’ death and of the interest of their successors in pursuing the proceedings.

The Court reiterates that where an applicant dies during the examination of a case his or her heirs may in principle pursue the application on his or her behalf (see Ječius v. Lithuania, no. 34578/97, § 41, ECHR 2000-IX). Furthermore, in some cases concerning non-enforcement of court judgments, the Court recognised the right of the relatives of the deceased applicant to pursue the application (see Shiryayeva v. Russia, no. 21417/04, §§ 8-9, 13 July 2006).

The Court notes that the rights at stake in the present case are very similar to those at the heart of the cases referred to above. Nothing suggests that the rights the applicants sought to protect through the Convention mechanism were eminently personal and non-transferable (see Malhous v. the Czech Republic [GC], no. 33071/96, § 1, 12 July 2001). The Government did not contend that any of the successors mentioned above had no standing to pursue the cases. Therefore, the Court considers that the applicants’ successors have a legitimate interest in pursuing the applications.

II. COMPLAINTS OF NON-ENFORCEMENT

Regarding Ms Grigorenko’s complaint of delayed enforcement of the judgment of 27 November 2000, the Court takes cognisance of the Government’s submissions and is satisfied that it was the applicant’s responsibility to inform the State of her status as heir to the deceased claimant with an award against the State. The Court considers that in this situation the State cannot bear responsibility for the delay in the payment of the award (see Ziabreva v. Russia, no. 23567/06, § 21, 18 December 2008). Accordingly, this complaint should be rejected as manifestly ill-founded under Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.

As to the other applications, following the Burdov (no. 2) pilot judgment cited above the Government informed the Court of the payment of the domestic court awards in the applicants’ favour and submitted unilateral declarations aimed at resolving the issues raised by the applications. By these declarations the Russian authorities acknowledged in various but very similar terms that judgments in the applicants’ favour were not enforced in a timely manner (e.g. “the excessive duration of the enforcement”, “the delay in the enforcement” or “the lengthy enforcement”). They also declared that they were ready to pay the applicants ex gratia the sums tabulated below. The remainder of the declarations read as follows:

“The authorities therefore invite the Court to strike [the applications] out of the list of cases. They suggest that the present declaration might be accepted by the Court as “any other reason” justifying the striking out of the case of the Court’s list of cases, as referred to in Article 37 § 1 (c) of the Convention.

The [sums tabulated below], which [are] to cover any pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage as well as costs and expenses, will be free of any taxes that may be applicable. [They] will be payable within three months from the date of notification of the decision taken by the Court pursuant to Article 37 § 1 of the European Convention on Human Rights. In the event of failure to pay [these sums] within the said three-month period, the Government undertake to pay simple interest on [them] from expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points.

This payment will constitute the final resolution of the case.”

Some applicants agreed to the terms of the Government’s declarations. Others failed to reply. A majority disagreed on various grounds, considering most often that the compensation amounts offered by the Government were insufficient.

The Court reiterates that under Article 37 of the Convention it may at any stage of the proceedings strike an application out of its list of cases where the circumstances lead to the conclusions specified under (a), (b), or (c) of that Article.

Article 37 § 1 (c) enables the Court in particular to strike a case out of its list if:

“for any other reason established by the Court, it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the application.”

Article 37 § 1 in fine states:

“However, the Court shall continue the examination of the application if respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the protocols thereto so requires.”

The Court recalls that in its pilot judgment (Burdov v. Russia (no. 2), cited above) it ordered the Russian Federation to

“grant [adequate and sufficient] redress, within one year from the date on which the judgment [became] final, to all victims of non-payment or unreasonably delayed payment by State authorities of a judgment debt in their favour who [had] lodged their applications with the Court before the delivery of the present judgment and whose applications [had been] communicated to the Government under Rule 54 § 2 (b) of the Rules of the Court.”

In the same judgment the Court also held that:

“pending the adoption of the above measures, the Court [would] adjourn, for one year from the date on which the judgment [became] final, the proceedings in all cases concerning solely the non-enforcement and/or delayed enforcement of domestic judgments ordering monetary payments by the State authorities, without prejudice to the Court’s power at any moment to declare inadmissible any such case or to strike it out of its list following a friendly settlement between the parties or the resolution of the matter by other means in accordance with Articles 37 or 39 of the Convention.”

Having examined the terms of the Government’s declarations, the Court understands them as intending to give the applicants redress in line with the pilot judgment (see Burdov (no. 2), cited above, §§ 127 and 145 and point 7 of the operative part).

The Court is satisfied that the excessive length of the execution of judgments in the applicants’ favour is acknowledged by the Government either explicitly or in substance. The Court also notes that the compensations offered are comparable with Court awards in similar cases, taking account, inter alia, of the specific delays in each particular case (see Burdov (no. 2), cited above, §§ 99 and 154).

The Court therefore considers that it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the applications. It is also satisfied that respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the protocols thereto does not require it to continue the examination of the applications.

Accordingly, in so far as the complaints about delayed enforcement of the judgments in the applicants’ favour are concerned, the applications should be struck out of the list.

As regards the question of implementation of the Government’s undertakings, the Committee of Ministers remains competent to supervise this matter in accordance with Article 46 of the Convention (see the Committee’s decisions of 14-15 September 2009 (CM/Del/Dec(2009)1065) and Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2009)1 58 concerning the implementation of the Burdov (no. 2) judgment). In any event the Court’s present ruling is without prejudice to any decision it might take to restore, pursuant to Article 37 § 2 of the Convention, the present applications to the list of cases (see E.G. v. Poland (dec.), no. 50425/99, § 29, ECHR 2008‑… (extracts)).

III. OTHER COMPLAINTS

Some applicants made accessory complaints referring to assorted Articles of the Convention. However, in the light of all the material in its possession, and in so far as the matters complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols. It follows that the applications in this part are manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.

For these reasons, the Court unanimously:

Decides to join the applications;

 

Declares the complaint of non-enforcement made by Ms L. Grigorenko inadmissible;

Takes note of the terms of the respondent Government’s declarations;

Decides to strike the applications in respect of non-enforcement of the judgments in the applicants’ favour out of its list of cases;

Declares the remainder of the applications inadmissible.

André Wampach Sverre Erik Jebens
Deputy Registrar President

ANNEX

 

No

Application No

Last name

Forename

Born

Compensation offered (euros)

  1.  

7120/03

LUNINA

 

BARKALOVA

 

CHERNYSHOVA

 

DAMARAD

 

DAVYDOVA

 

GLADILOVA

 

ISSAYEVA

 

KALAYEVA

 

KHABAROVA

 

KHVOSTOVA

 

MALKHOVA

 

MAMONOVA

 

PLOTNIKOVA

 

SAMSONOVA

 

SELIVANOVA

 

SHUMILINA

 

SVIRIDOV

 

YERINA

 

ZABALUYEVA

 

LIDIYA SERGEYEVNA

 

LIDIYA MITROFANOVNA

 

OLGA MIKHAYLOVNA

 

BORIS ALEKSANDROVICH

 

ANASTASIYA IVANOVNA

 

GALINA SERGEYEVNA

 

ALEKSANDRA PAVLOVNA

 

RAISA ILYINICHNA

 

MARIYA ILYINICHNA

 

ANNA SEMENOVNA

 

ZOYA NIKOLAYEVNA

 

TAMARA ANDREYEVNA

 

LIDIYA VYACHESLAVOVNA

 

VALENTINA GRIGORYEVNA

 

MARIYA VASILYEVNA

 

TATYANA VASILYEVNA

 

GENNADIY MIKHAYLOVICH

 

YELENA PETROVNA

 

NATALYA SERGEYEVNA

 

1958

 

1940

 

1952

 

1957

 

1940

 

1944

 

1929

 

1949

 

1933

 

1940

 

1938

 

1944

 

1960

 

1943

 

1939

 

1945

 

1932

 

1955

 

1953

1,800

 

2,100

 

2,000

 

1,500

 

2,150

 

850

 

1900

 

1,700

 

2,300

 

2,150

 

1,800

 

1,800

 

2,300

 

2,000

 

2,000

 

2,100

 

1,980

 

1,900

 

1,600

  1.  

34436/04

MOROZ

 

YAKOVLEVA

 

SELEZNEV

 

RAIDA VIKTOROVNA

 

TATYANA PETROVNA

 

YURIY IVANOVICH

1936

 

1934

 

1940

2,500

 

2,600

 

2,500

  1.  

39945/04

KRAVCHENKO

 

ALEKSANDR ANTONOVICH

1941[1]

 

3,000

  1.  

2107/05

KURZHALOV

 

OLEG PETROVICH

1954

610

  1.  

3453/05

TURMANOV

 

TARIYEL NIKOLAYEVICH

1949[2]

2,456

  1.  

4249/05

MAKSIM

 

ANDREY ANDREYEVICH

1981

1,100

  1.  

4523/05

PETUKHOV

 

ANATOLIY ALEKSANDROVICH

1949

2,905

  1.  

4943/05

SANIN

 

VIKTOR ALEKSANDROVICH

1956

1,584

  1.  

12254/05

 

KOSYGIN

VYACHESLAV FEDOROVICH

1948

785

  1.             

13094/05

DUBRAVIN

NIKOLAY GRIGORYEVICH

 

1949

2,904

  1.             

18611/05

GERASIMENKO

 

GALINA VASILYEVNA

1945

1,760

  1.             

22256/05

NOSKOV

 

ROMAN VIKTOROVICH

1961

2,670

  1.             

22668/05

MILKEVICH

 

YURIY STANISLAVOVICH

1957

1,640

  1.             

31957/05

MARTIROSYAN

 

EDVART NAPOLEONOVICH

1956

766

  1.             

33595/05

KUNDYUSOV

 

ANDREY IVANOVICH

1962

966

  1.             

36458/05

PUSTOVAROV

ANDREY VLADIMIROVICH

1972

2,970

  1.             

38083/05

ANDREYTSEVA

 

CHERNENKO

 

GALINA ALEKSANDROVNA

 

GALINA GRIGORYEVNA

1955

 

1955

1,087

 

1,087

  1.             

42513/05

VOBLIKOV

 

VLADIMIR NIKOLAYEVICH

1948

620

  1.             

2060/06

FEDOREY

 

ALEKSANDR VLADIMIROVICH

1958

2,430

  1.             

4138/06

USHAKOVA

 

NADEZHDA NIKOLAYEVNA

1957

3,925

  1.             

4158/06

SALMENKOVA

 

GALINA RUFOVNA

1960

1,572

  1.             

14218/06

GUBINA

 

NOVIKOVA

 

ZHIGULINA

 

KARPOVA

 

GRIGORENKO

 

TAMARA AFANASYEVNA

 

VALENTINA VASILYEVNA

 

PELAGEYA ALEKSEYEVNA

 

LIDIYA IVANOVNA

 

LIDIYA NIKOLAYEVNA

1934

 

1931

 

1935

 

1941

 

1934

1,500

 

1,500

 

1,500

 

1,500

 

Declared inadmissible

  1.             

15400/06

GREKOVA

 

OLGA PAVLOVNA

1968

2,609

  1.             

18363/06

SAZONOV

 

SERGEY ANATOLYEVICH

1958

3,955

  1.             

28225/06

GADZHIYEV

 

OMAR DZHABRAILOVICH

1961

2,000

  1.             

31401/06

YERMOLAYEV

 

VLADIMIR SEMENOVICH

1953

990

  1.             

42611/06

 ZAO LIZINGOVAYA KOMPANIYA ‘GEOLIZING’

 

 

 

1,628

  1.             

44973/06

SEMITKOVSKIY

 

LAPIK

 

SOKOLENKO

KRAMARENKO

 

SHCHEGELSKIY

 

ALCHINSKIY

 

VITALIY GRIGORYEVICH

 

ALEKSEY LEONIDOVICH

 

IGOR VLADIMIROVICH

DMITRIY ANATOLYEVICH

 

NIKOLAY NIKOLAYEVICH

 

NIKOLAY ANATOLYEVICH

1957

 

1953

 

1964

1967

 

1962

 

1960

1,553

 

2,096

 

1,778

1,743

 

1,447

 

1,592

  1.             

45414/06

TSAPENKO

 

GEORGIY GEORGIYEVICH

1950

 

650

  1.             

2258/07

ANTOSHKIV

 

NADEZHDA ALEKSANDROVNA

1937

835

  1.             

5669/07

KONSTANTINOV

 

MIKHAIL VASILYEVICH

1956

5,000

  1.             

5672/07

LOSEVA

 

LYUBOV YAKOVLEVNA

1950

700

  1.             

11344/07

YEVSENOCHKIN

 

VLADIMIR PAVLOVICH

1946

804

  1.             

14538/07

MAKHNATKINA

NINA YEVGENYEVNA

1935

 

1,610

  1.             

19514/07

PRIKHODCHENKO

 

NIKOLAY GRIGORYEVICH

1951

 

857

  1.             

19651/07

GORSKAYA

 

NATALIYA MIKHAYLOVNA

1946

 

927

  1.             

25181/07

BAZAYEVA

 

BARSEGYANTS

 

DOROKHOV

 

GAZZAYEV

 

KIRICHENKO

 

KOBLOV

 

KOLIYEV

 

KORAYEV

 

KRAVCHENKO

 

KULUMBEKOV

 

PAVLIOSHVILI

 

POSYAKIN

 

SAFIBEKOV

 

TIGIYEV

 

TOMAYEV

 

ZHITNIK

 

SVETLANA FEDOROVNA

 

AVETIS SARKISOVICH

 

SERGEY NIKOLAYEVICH

 

VIKTOR KAZBEKOVICH

 

IGOR STANISLAVOVICH

 

FELIKS CHERMENOVICH

 

ALAN KHASANBEKOVICH

 

ANATOLIY PAVLOVICH

 

SERGEY NIKOLAYEVICH

 

VALERIY GAVRILOVICH

 

GELA SHAVLOVICH

 

DMITRIY VALENTINOVICH

 

ZANGIR KHALIDDIN-OGLY

 

RUSLAN ANDREYEVICH

 

OLEG IRAKLIYEVICH

 

SOSLAN YEVGENYEVICH

1957

 

1959

 

1956

 

1970

 

1973

 

1966

 

1967

 

1955

 

1965

 

1963

 

1967

 

1955

 

1969

 

1961

 

1953

 

1969

1,460

 

1,370

 

1,600

 

1,750

 

1,450

 

1,600

 

1,320

 

1,780

 

1,350

 

1,650

 

1,350

 

3,000

 

1,670

 

1,470

 

1,550

 

1,600

  1.             

30260/07

BUGLEYEV

 

OLEG ALEKSEYEVICH

1952

2,200

  1.             

35007/07

TATARSHAO

 

AMIR KHADZHIBIYEVICH

1952

1,394

  1.             

36894/07

RESIN

 

ANDREY IGOREVICH

1974

2,467

  1.             

37004/07

BELYANIN

 

ANATOLIY VASILYEVICH

1948

820

  1.             

44866/07

BULATOV

 

NIKOLAY ILYICH

1939

 

835

  1.             

56480/07

YERIN

 

SERGEY VASILYEVICH

1963

900

  1.             

10318/08

ROZHKOV

 

VLADIMIR VASILYEVICH

1955

3,600

  1.             

12376/08

KALOYEV

 

TAYMURAZ MAISEYEVICH

1981

2,800

  1.             

16247/08

LISITSKAYA

 

ANNA MIKHAYLOVNA

1931

5,000

  1.             

20802/08

LEDENTSOV

 

GENNADIY YEVGENYEVICH

1939

500

  1.             

20806/08

SHAYEKHOV

 

YANAGAYEV

 

ISKANDER MINNEKHANOVICH

 

ALEKSEY DMITRIYEVICH

1953

 

1987

1,150

 

1,150

  1.             

22165/08

KOLKHITOVA

 

ANDZELINA KAZBEKOVNA

1969

3,400

  1.             

30626/08

KOCHKINA

 

IDEYA IVANOVNA

1936

1,020

  1.             

30632/08

SOKOL

 

BORIS MIRONOVICH

1944

870

  1.             

32219/08

KOPCHENKO

 

ZINAIDA IVANOVNA

1943

860

  1.             

32221/08

MITROFANOVA

 

NADEZHDA IVANOVNA

1950

880

  1.             

32225/08

KOCHKIN

 

VLADIMIR FEDOROVICH

1936

1,050

  1.             

40332/08

PETRAKI

 

VLADIMIR NIKOLAYEVICH

1982

3,000

  1.             

59373/08

SHERIYEV

 

KHABAS MUKHAMEDOVICH

1975

3,900

  1.             

8421/09

SHAMANAYEVA

 

TATYANA YEVGENYEVNA

1950

3,010

 

[1] Rectified on 21 March 2011 : the text was “1954”

[2] Rectified on 21 March 2011 : the text was “1954”


HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.