Civil European Court of Human Rights

AYSULOV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA

ECLI ECLI:CE:ECHR:2021:1005DEC002085105

 

 

THIRD SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 20851/05
Buranbay Abdullovich AYSULOV against Russia
and 14 other applications
(see list appended)

 

The European Court of Human Rights (Third Section), sitting on 5 October 2021 as a Committee composed of:

 María Elósegui, President,
 Darian Pavli,
 Frédéric Krenc, judges,
and Olga Chernishova, Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,

Having regard to the observations submitted by the respondent Government and the observations in reply submitted by the applicants,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

THE FACTS

1.  A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.

2.  The Russian Government (“the Government”) were represented initially by Mr G. Matyushkin, the Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights, then by his successor in that office, Mr M. Galperin, and lately by Mr M. Vinogradov, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.

3.  The applicants alleged that the national authorities had failed to provide them with the necessary assistance in enforcement of the final court decisions against private parties.

  1. The circumstances of the case

4.  The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.

5.  The applicants had final decisions in their favour against private parties rendered by national courts, on various dates, to be enforced. They submitted the writs of execution for these decisions to the bailiffs’ service and enforcement proceedings were initiated, which brought no or insufficient results. The applicants lodged civil actions against the bailiffs’ service, seeking compensation for non-pecuniary damage by the lengthy non‑enforcement of the judgments. The particulars of the relevant domestic proceedings are presented in the appended table.

  1. Relevant domestic law

6.  The provisions of domestic law concerning execution of judgments were previously set out in the case Kunashko v. Russia (no. 36337/03, §§ 27-30, 17 December 2009) and, concerning compensation for damage caused by public authorities and their officials, in the case Smagilov v. Russia ((dec.), no. 24324/05, §§ 17-31, 13 November 2014).

COMPLAINTS

7.  The applicants complained under Article 6 of the Convention that the national authorities had failed to assist them in the enforcement of the final judgments against private parties. Certain applicants also alleged that the above failure to provide them requisite legal assistance resulted in a violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1. Some applicants also lodged an accessory complaint under Article 13 of the Convention.

THE LAW

8.  Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly.

9.  The applicants referring to Article 6 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 alleged that the Russian authorities had failed to assist them in the enforcement of the judgments in their favour. The Government contested that argument.

10.  The Court notes that the applicable general principles are well‑established in the case-law. Notably, when final judgments are issued against “private” defendants, the State’s positive obligation consists of providing a legal arsenal allowing individuals to obtain, from their evading debtors, payment of sums awarded by those judgments. However this positive obligation is not that of result, but one of means (see, among many other authorities, Dachar v. France (dec.), no. 42338/98, 6 June 2000; Fuklev v. Ukraine, no. 71186/01, § 84, 7 June 2005; and Kunashko, cited above, §§ 38‑39, 17 December 2009).

11.  The Court, having carefully examined the applications listed in the appended table and having regard to its case-law, concludes that, in the light of aforementioned and the material in its possession, the State authorities have provided requisite assistance to the applicants in the enforcement of the judgments in their favour, and impossibility of further enforcement cannot be attributed to them. In view of the above, the applications are manifestly ill-founded, and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Decides to join the applications;

Declares the applications inadmissible.

Done in English and notified in writing on 4 November 2021.

 {signature_p_2}

 Olga Chernishova María Elósegui
 Deputy Registrar President

 

Appendix

(non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic judgments against private parties)

 

 

Application

no.

 

Applicant name

Year of birth

Place of residence

Nationality

Represented by

Domestic judgment in applicant’s favour (court, date, award)

Start date of enforcement/submission of the writ to bailiff

Article 1069 proceedings (final decision – court, date, award/reason to refuse)

Reasons for inadmissibility

 

1.  

20851/05

Buranbay Abdullovich AYSULOV

 

1951

 

Krasnodar

 

Russian

 

Self-representation

 

Prikubanskiy District Court of Krasnodar

 

20/08/2002

 

RUB 251,900

Issued and sent to the bailiffs:

 

02/09/2002

 

Initiated:

 

10/10/2002

Unlawful omission recognized:

 

Kanavinskiy District Court of Nizhniy Novgorod

 

17/03/2005 (not sending copies of documents)

 

Moskovskiy District Court of Nizhniy Novgorod

 

28/09/2007

 

22/11/2007

 

03/10/2008

 

Compensation proceeding:

 

Declined

 

Sormovskiy District Court of Nizhniy Novgorod

 

19/04/2006

 

No causal link

 

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in his favour, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them.

 

Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 – manifestly ill-founded, impossibility of further enforcement cannot be attributed to the actions of the authorities. The State cannot be held responsible for the lack of funds on the side of the debtor.

 

 

2.  

8521/07

Valentina Mikhaylovna GANIMAN

 

1946

 

Troitsk, Chelyabinsk Region

 

Russian

Troitsk Town Court

 

28/02/2000

 

RUB 33,215.50

 

Indexation of the award

 

Troitsk Town Court

 

22/09/2005

 

RUB 72,775.87

 

Troitsk Town Court

 

24/08/2007

 

RUB 83,189.97

 

Troitsk Town Court

 

20/04/2009

 

RUB 101,599.91

 

 

Initiated:

 

07/03/2000

Unlawful omission recognized:

 

Troitsk Town Court

 

05/12/2005

 

Compensation claim:

 

Dismissed

 

Chelyabinsk Regional Court

 

14/09/2006

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in her favour, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them.

 

Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 – manifestly ill-founded, the applicant maintains the possibility to further pursue the enforcement proceedings. The State cannot be held responsible for the lack of funds on the side of the debtor.

 

3.  

53213/08

Vladimir Fedorovich KUDRYAVTSEV

 

1950

 

Ufa, Republic of Bashkortostan

 

Russian

 

Aleksey Nikolayevich LAPTEV

 Kirovskiy District Court of Ufa

 

15/12/1997

 

RUB 221,055

 

Initiated:

 

12/11/1998

Unlawful omission recognised and compensation proceedings:

 

Supreme Court of the Republic of Bashkortostan

 

25/03/2008

 

RUB 50,000 of non-pecuniary damages

 

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in his favour, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them.

 

Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 – manifestly ill-founded, the applicant maintains the possibility to further pursue the enforcement proceedings. The State cannot be held responsible for the lack of funds on the side of the debtor.

 

4.  

40289/10

Aleksandr Vasilyevich YERMOLAYEV

 

1949

 

Rtischevo, Saratov Region

 

Russian

 

Self-Representation

Commercial Court of the Saratov Region

 

01/12/1999

 

RUB 250,000

 

Initiated:

 

11/12/2000

Unlawful omission recognised:

 

Commercial Court of Saratov Region

 

12/10/2005

 

Commercial Court of Saratov Region

 

22/11/2006

 

Compensation proceedings:

 

Federal Commercial Court of the Volga Circuit

 

26/07/2010

 

Declined

 

The judgment is against a private party, and thus, falls out of scope of the Compensation Act 2010

 

Saratov Regional Court

 

04/05/2011

 

Declined

 

No causal link

 

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in his favour, enforcement is still possible. Anyway, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them.

 

Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 – manifestly ill-founded, the applicant maintains the possibility to further pursue the enforcement proceedings. The State cannot be held responsible for the lack of funds on the side of the debtor.

 

Article 13 – no need to examine separately.

 

5.  

20536/11

Marina Aleksandrovna MAKSIMOVA

 

14/04/1969

 

Volgograd

 

Russian

 

Tsentralniy District Court of Volgograd

 

16/12/1999

 

Alimony equal to 25% of the income + additional maintenance equal to 25% of the income

 

Issued:

 

16/12/1999

 

 

Unlawful omission recognized and compensation proceeding:

 

Krasnooktyabrskiy District Court of Volgograd

 

20/07/2010

 

RUB 5,000

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in her favour, enforcement is still possible. Anyway, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them.

 

Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 – manifestly ill-founded, the applicant maintains the possibility to further pursue the enforcement proceedings. The State cannot be held responsible for the lack of funds on the side of the debtor.

 

6.  

35043/11

Tatyana Yuryevna ANDREYEVA

 

1960

 

Irina Yuryevna

ANDREYEVA

 

1992

 

Olga Yuryevna

ANDREYEVA

 

1994

 

Nizhniy Novgorod

 

Russian

 

Kanavinskiy District Court of Nizhniy Novgorod

 

07/12/1995

 

Alimony equal to 1/3 of the income in respect of children + additional maintenance equal to RUR 60,500/month between 31/01/1995 and 21/02/1996 in respect of the first applicant

Unknown, the case file was destroyed due to the expiry of the statutory time-limit for its storage

 

Duplicates issued:

 

02/04/2002

 

Initiated:

 

07/07/2004

Unlawful omission recognised:

 

Priokskiy District Court of Nizhniy Novgorod

 

06/07/2006

 

25/04/2008

 

03/11/2010

 

Compensation proceedings:

 

Sormovskiy District Court of Nizhniy Novgorod

 

30/09/2010

 

RUB 26,164.20

 

Nizhniy Novgorod Regional Court

 

17/11/2011

 

Dismissed

 

 

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in her favour, the latter was fully enforced.

7.  

55474/12

Farida Radikovna BIKAYEVA

 

1963

 

Perm

 

Russian

 

Industrialniy District Court of Perm

 

30/03/2009

 

RUB 2,706,018

 

30/07/2010

 

RUB 1,283,120

 

05/08/2011

 

RUB 1,014,391.43

Interim measure

 

05/03/2009

 

Main enforcement proceedings

 

27/05/2009

 

22/11/2010

 

09/11/2011

Unlawful omission recognised:

 

Perm District Court of the Perm Region

 

03/02/2011

 

07/06/2011

 

17/10/2011

 

Compensation proceedings:

 

Industrialnyy District Court of Perm

 

11/04/2012

 

RUB 100,200

 

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in her favour, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them

 

Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 – manifestly ill-founded, impossibility of further enforcement cannot be attributed to the actions of the authorities. The State cannot be held responsible for the lack of funds on the side of the debtor.

 

Article 13 – no need to examine separately.

8.  

59958/13

 

Maksim Grigoryevich GORLOV

 

1939

 

Moscow

 

Russian

 

Self-Representation

 

Basmannyy District Court of Moscow

 

22/03/2006

 

RUB 244,907

Initiated:

 

17/04/2006

Unlawful omission recognised:

 

Basmannyy District Court of Moscow

 

10/03/2009

 

20/04/2009

 

29/06/2009

 

Compensation proceedings:

 

Supreme Court

 

19/06/2013

 

RUB 5,000

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in his favour, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them

 

Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 – manifestly ill-founded, impossibility of further enforcement cannot be attributed to the actions of the authorities. The State cannot be held responsible for the lack of funds on the side of the debtor.

 

9.  

18862/14

Ivan Iosifovich

TYAGLO

 

1943

 

Yessentuki, Stavropol Region

 

Russian

 

Viktor Vladimirovich POLYAKOV

 

Yessentuki Town Court

 

23/10/2008

 

RUB 1,813,100

 

Indexation of the award:

 

Yessentuki Town Court

 

18/06/2009

 

RUB 136,060

 

Yessentuki Town Court

 

22/03/2010

 

RUB 135,419.76

 

Yessentuki Town Court

 

15/02/2011

 

RUB 132,766.74

 

Yessentuki Town Court

 

26/03/2012

 

RUB 159,075

 

Yessentuki Town Court

 

24/04/2013

 

RUB 156,897.22

 

Initiated

 

02/12/2008

Unlawful omission recognised:

 

Stavropol Regional Court

 

19/01/2010

 

Compensation proceedings:

 

 

Supreme Court

 

07/04/2014

 

Declined

 

No causal link

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in his favour, enforcement is still possible. Anyway, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them.

 

10.  

55310/14

Yuriy Iosifovich MIKHAYLOVSKIY

 

1974

 

Moscow

 

Russian

 

Self-Representation

 

Izmaylovskiy District Court of Moscow

 

05/11/2008

 

RUB 1,495,103.30

 

Indexation of the award:

 

Izmaylovskiy District Court of Moscow

 

09/06/2011

 

RUB 343,020.70

Initiated:

 

19/02/2009

Unlawful omission recognised:

 

Izmaylovskiy District Court of Moscow

 

24/12/2009

 

Moscow City Court

 

08/11/2009

 

Compensation proceedings:

 

Supreme Court

 

02/04/2014

 

RUB 3,000

 

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in his favour, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them.

11.  

18827/17

Elena Mikhaylovna KUZNETSOVA

 

1966

 

Tver

 

Russian

 

Artem Yuryevich BRANNTSKIY

Sovetskiy District Court of Vladivostok

 

28/02/2007

 

RUB 749,408

 

 

Initiated:

 

 01/06/2007

 

 

Unlawful omission recognised:

 

Sovetskiy District Court of Vladivostok

 

28/04/2012

 

Compensation proceedings:

 

Primorskiy Regional Court

 

08/02/2016

 

RUB 50,000

non-pecuniary damage

 

Leninskiy Distrivt Court of Vladivostok

 

RUB 107,167,88

legal costs

 

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in her favour, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them

 

Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 – manifestly ill-founded, impossibility of further enforcement cannot be attributed to the actions of the authorities. The State cannot be held responsible for the lack of funds on the side of the debtor.

 

Article 13 – no need to examine separately.

12.  

26352/17

Valeriy Mikhaylovich TOKUNOV

 

1954

 

Anapa

 

Russian

 

Susanna Ilyinichna ARUTYUNYAN

 

Interim measure:

 

Anapa Town Court

 

14/01/2011

 

RUB 3,025,919

 

Main proceedings:

 

Krasnodar Regional Court

 

05/11/2013

 

RUB 2,413,012.40

 

Initiated:

 

07/03/2013

Compensation awarded:

 

Supreme Court

 

21/09/2016

 

RUB 1,300,000 of pecuniary damage and RUB 100,000 of non-pecuniary damage

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in his favour, enforcement is still possible. Anyway, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them.

13.  

42552/17

Aleksandr Aleksandrovich BARSUKOV

 

06/06/1978

 

Kursk

 

Russian

 

Andrey Nikolayevich

GOLOVACHEV

 

Novoanninskiy District Court of Volgograd

 

28/01/2003

 

RUB 169,530

 

Indexation of the award:

 

Novoanninskiy District Court of Volgograd

 

10/07/2008

 

RUB 80,018,18

 

Novoanninskiy District Court of Volgograd

 

11/02/2011

 

RUB 59,165,33

 

Novoanninskiy District Court of Volgograd

 

30/04/2014

 

RUB 26,288,12

 

Initiated:

 

03/04/2003

Supreme Court

 

15/02/2017

 

Declined

 

No direct causal link

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in his favour, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them

 

Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 – manifestly ill-founded, impossibility of further enforcement cannot be attributed to the actions of the authorities. The State cannot be held responsible for the lack of funds on the side of the debtor.

 

Article 13 – no need to examine separately.

14.  

19709/18

Yelena Nikolayevna MUSKATINA

 

1978

 

Moscow

 

Russian

 

Self-Representation

 

Khoroshevskiy Intermunicipal People’s Court of the North-Western Administrative Circuit of Moscow

 

10/04/1996

 

Monthly alimony payments equal to 1/4 of the income in respect of a child (1995 y.o.b.)

 

Penalty for failure to pay alimony payments

 

Savelovskiy District Court of Moscow

 

22/04/2015

 

RUB 8,643,371

 (substitution of the applicant in the domestic proceedings, the sum was awarded to the applicant’s son who by that time was an adult)

Initiated:

 

27/08/2013

Unlawful omission recognised

 

Savelovskiy District Court of Moscow

 

18/08/2016

 

Compensation proceedings:

 

Supreme Court

 

09/02/2018

 

Declined

 

No causal link

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in her favour, enforcement is still possible. Anyway, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them.

15.  

29409/18

Sergey Petrovich FILIPPOV

 

1958

 

Mikhaylovka, Volgograd Region

 

Russian

 

Anton Valeryevich GAVRILOV

 

Mikhaylovskiy District Court of the Volgograd Region

 

13/12/2010

 

RUB 1,230,957

Interim measure:

 

16/12/2010

 

Main proceedings:

 

07/04/2011

Unlawful omission recognised:

 

Mikhaylovskiy District Court of the Volgograd Region

 

25/12/2015

 

Compensation proceedings:

 

Supreme Court

 

30/01/2018

 

Declined

 

No causal link

Article 6 – manifestly ill‑founded, the State authorities provided requisite assistance to the applicant in the enforcement of the judgment in his favour, impossibility of full enforcement cannot be attributed to them

 

Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 – manifestly ill-founded, impossibility of further enforcement cannot be attributed to the actions of the authorities. The State cannot be held responsible for the lack of funds on the side of the debtor.

 

 


HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.