Miscellaneous Mauritius
Supreme Court of Mauritius, 12 May 2026, 2026 SAV 66 – POLICE v C MATOO
Page 1 POLICE v C MATOO
2026 SAV 66
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF SAVANNE
Cause No.: 2340/24 Police
v/s
Chitralall Matoo
Judgment
The accused stands charged with the offence of « Blows » in breach of Section 230(1) of the Criminal Code. As per the information dated 2nd September 2024, the accused stands charged with having on or about the 13th October 2021, willfully and unlawfully inflicted blows on and upon the person of Mr Mahanankumar Matoo.
The accused pleaded not guilty and was represented by Mr Bissoonauthsing of Counsel. The case for the Prosecution was conducted by PS Mattan.
Case for the Prosecution
Two witnesses deponed on behalf of the Prosecution, namely the recording officer PS Nugessur and the complainant Mr M Matoo.
Witness no. 1, PS Nugessur, was the recording officer and he gave evidence to the effect that on the 20th March 2023 at 10.34 hours, he had recorded a statement from the accused at Grand Bois Police Station (Doc B). He was duly cross-examined.
Witness no. 2, Mr M Matoo, is the complainant and he gave evidence to the effect that the accused is his uncle and on the material date, he had approached the accused to ask him to return his concrete blocks. According to the complainant, the accused refused to return his concrete blocks and while they were conversing the accused had
Page 2 an object in his hand. The complainant stated that the accused slapped him with the said object on his left cheek causing him a bleeding injury near his lips.
The complainant was duly cross-examined and revealed that the accused had also kicked him.
The PF 58 issued to the complainant on the material date was produced by the Prosecution (Doc A).
Case for the Defence
The accused deponed under oath and stated that the complainant is his nephew with whom he is not on goods terms as he had entrusted the construction of a greenhouse to the complainant but the latter did not complete the works and brought him to his knees. According to the accused on the material date, the complainant came up to him while they were in their respective vehicles and asked him whether he will return his concrete blocks. The accused further stated that the complainant kicked him twice on his left foot. The accused produced his medical certificate (Doc C).
The accused was duly cross-examined.
In his out of court statement (Doc B), the accused had denied the evidence against him.
Submissions by Learned Counsel for the accused
Learned Defence Counsel submitted that the bad blood between the complainant and the accused could have led the complainant to level a false allegation against the accused. He further submitted that in the present case there is the word of one against the denial of the other and as such the presumption of innocence prevails.
The Law
The offence of assault is provided in Section 228(1) of the Criminal Code in the following terms:
Page 3 Any person who wilfully inflicts any wound or blow, or is the author of any other violence or assault shall if such act of violence has caused any sickness or incapacity for personal labour for more than 20 days, be punished by imprisonment and a fine not exceeding 100,000 rupees.
The accused, in the present case has been charged under Section 230(1) of the Criminal Code which provides that: Where such wound, blow or other violence or assault has not caused any sickness or incapacity from personal labour of the description mentioned in section 228 the offender shall be punished by imprisonment for a term not exceeding 2 years, and by a fine not exceeding 50,000 rupees.
Analysis
The presumption of innocence established by Section 10(2)(a) of the Constitution places a burden upon the Prosecution to prove each element of the offence with which the accused has been charged. In fact, the burden rests on the Prosecution to prove all the elements of the offence beyond reasonable doubt 1 . When at the close of the case for the Prosecution, a prima facie case has been clearly established against the accused, the burden then shifts on him to satisfy the Court why it should not act on the evidence adduced by the Prosecution 2 .
It was therefore incumbent upon the Prosecution to prove that on the material date the accused assaulted the complainant in the manner as averred in the information.
While on the one hand, the case for the Prosecution rests mainly on the testimony of the complainant, the evidence before me, on the other hand, is highly indicative of bad blood between the complainant and the accused. I find that I must therefore treat the evidence of the complainant with caution. Having had the opportunity of seeing both the complainant and the accused depone under oath, I have accordingly assessed their respective demeanours.
1 Boodhoo A. v The State [2004 SCJ 235] 2 Andoo M vs The Queen [1989 SCJ 257]
Page 4 The complainant, I find, has deponed in a clear and straightforward manner. I find that he has explained in detail the circumstances in which and the subject matter in respect of which he had approached the accused on the material date. I have also found the complainant’s testimony of the injury which he states he has sustained on the material date to be consistent with the contents of the independent PF 58 issued to him on the same day. I have however noted certain inconsistencies and shortcomings in the complainant’s testimony on the manner in which he states he was assaulted by the accused. Indeed, in his complaint to the police, the complainant had related that the accused had dealt him with a fisticuff blow on his left cheek and kicked him on his right foot. In Court however, the complainant stated that the accused had struck him with an object which he was holding in his hand. I consider that there is a marked difference between being dealt with a fisticuff blow, that is with a clenched fist, and being struck with an object.
In addition, during the course of examination in chief, the complainant maintained the sequence of events which had taken place at the material time, namely that the accused struck him with an object, he pushed the accused and left for the police station. The complainant also denied having been struck on any other part of his body. However during the course of cross-examination when he was confronted with the averment which he had made in his statement to the police to the effect that the accused had also kicked him, the complainant for the first time came up with the version that the accused had pushed him and kicked him leaving marks of his foot on his trousers.
I do bear in mind that the complainant has deponed in Court some four and a half years after the material date and was not being called upon to undergo a memory test. However at no point in time did he give the impression that his memory was failing him. I in fact consider that it is with vivid details that the complainant had related the incident which had occurred on the material date to the extent of even repeating the words which the accused had spoken to him at the material time. In the circumstances, I find that the inconsistency in his version regarding the manner in which he states the accused had struck him on his cheek, his initial denial of having been struck elsewhere on his body and his inability to depone in respect of the kick to his foot negatively affect the complainant’s credibility.
Be that as it may, I find that the accused, for his part, has deponed under oath in a coherent, clear and straightforward manner. He has been able to explain in detail the
Page 5 reason for which there is bad blood between the complainant and him, how the complainant had approached him on the material date and the sequence of events leading to the complainant kicking him on his foot. The accused has also produced a medical certificate in support of his version. Contrarily to the complainant, I find that the accused has been able to withstand the test of cross-examination for he has stood his ground all throughout and maintained his denial of the charge with force. In the circumstances, I find that the accused’s credibility has not been impeached and I find no reason not to rely upon his version. In the same vein, I consider that the accused’s testimony under oath is sufficient to rebut that of the complainant.
Conclusion
In light of the above, I give the accused the benefit of the doubt. The charge against the accused is consequently dismissed.
A Dhunnoo (Miss) District Magistrate This 12th May 2026
Our criminal law attorney in Paris assists clients in matters of this kind.
Official sources: view the source page · Official PDF
Supreme Court of Mauritius.