Family United Kingdom

AB v CD

Official source

Neutral Citation Number: [2026] EWFC 314

Case No: ZC27/26

IN THE FAMILY COURT

Royal Courts of Justice

Strand, London, WC2A 2LL

Date: 30 October 2026

Before:

MRS JUSTICE THEIS DBE

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

Between:

AB Applicant
-and-
CD
-and-
First Respondent
WX (through his Children’s Guardian) Second Respondent

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

Andrew Powell KC (instructed by Keystone Law) for the Applicant

The First Respondent did not appear and was not represented

Eva Holland (Cafcass Legal) for the Second Respondent

Hearing date: 21 October 2026

Judgment: 30 October 2026

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

Approved Judgment

………………………..

This judgment was delivered in private. The judge has given leave for this version of the judgment to be published on condition that (irrespective of what is contained in the judgment) in any published version of the judgment the anonymity of the child and members of their family must be strictly preserved. All persons, including representatives of the media and legal bloggers, must ensure that this condition is strictly complied with. Failure to do so may be a contempt of court.

Mrs Justice Theis:

Introduction

1. This matter concerns an application by AB for an adoption order pursuant to s 51(1) Adoption and Children Act 2002 (ACA 2002) in respect of W, age 6. WX was born following a gestational surrogacy arrangement in the US. The surrogate, CD, who carried W is a respondent to this application and consents to the adoption order being made.

2. W’s biological father, EF, is AB’s former partner. They were in a relationship at the time of the surrogacy arrangement, his gametes were used to create the embryo even though he signed a US sperm donor agreement with AB prior to W’s conception. As a result, he is not named as the father on WX’s US birth certificate. AB and EF separated in 2023, WX still continues to see EF monthly and speaks to him in between visits. EF is WX’s legal father in this jurisdiction albeit he does not have parental responsibility, as he was not married to CD at the time of the embryo transfer and not recorded as the father on WX’s birth certificate.

3. WX has lived with AB throughout his life. AB is WX’s sole legal parent under the law in California as a result of pre-birth orders made in that jurisdiction. AB is not recognised as WX’s legal parent in this jurisdiction as s 33 Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 (HFEA 2008) provides that “The woman who is carrying or has carried a child as a result of the placing in her of an embryo or of sperm and eggs, and no other woman, is to be treated as the mother of the child.” As a consequence, AB is not WX’s legal mother and does not have parental responsibility for him. Even though AB is WX’s de facto mother she is a legal stranger to him in this jurisdiction. The surrogate, CD, who gave birth to WX in the US, is currently treated as his legal mother in this jurisdiction and she has parental responsibility even though she has played no part in WX’s life following his birth.

4. AB is not eligible to seek a parental order under section 54A HFEA 2008 because WX was conceived with donated rather than AB’s gametes. AB therefore seeks an adoption order to become WX’s legal parent in this jurisdiction.

5. This application was listed for final hearing on 21October 2026. Having considered the bundle and the written and oral submissions on behalf of AB and WX, through his Children’s Guardian, I made an adoption order. The reasons for making that order are set out below.

6. The court has had the benefit of detailed skeleton arguments from both Mr Powell KC and Ms Holland. The court has benefitted from their respective written and oral advocacy and their expertise in this area of the law.

Relevant background

7. AB was born in Country X. She moved to France in the 1980’s and then to this jurisdiction in 1995. AB acquired British citizenship in 2003 and is also a French citizen. AB has lived with WX in London since August 2024.

8. Prior to WX’s conception AB and EF lived together in the UK. EF had been married, was separated from his wife and has two adult children.

9. AB and EF wanted to have children. Following a long IVF journey together which was unsuccessful, they explored embarking on a surrogacy arrangement in the US in 2018. At an early stage of the process, although supportive of a surrogacy arrangement, EF informed AB that he did not wish to be a legal parent or to have financial responsibility for any child conceived. This was due to AB’s independent financial circumstances and EF’s wish not to cause complications regarding inheritance for his children from his marriage.

10. AB took legal advice from her attorney in the US who advised her that she could be a sole legal parent in California and that EF could act as a known donor to her. At the time, AB and EF remained in a relationship and intended to co-parent, albeit that EF would not have legal or financial responsibility for the child born following the surrogacy arrangement.

11. Embryos were created at California Fertility Partners using eggs from a donor and EF’s gametes. All parties had legal advice and the US donor agreements were signed, both between AB and the egg donor and between AB and EF.

12. AB engaged a surrogacy agency, the Center for Surrogate Parenting (CSP), in California. CSP subsequently introduced AB and EF to the surrogate, CD, who was living with her long-term partner in California. She was not married. Following introductions, CD agreed to proceed on the understanding that AB and EF were a couple but that AB would have sole legal responsibility for any child conceived.

13. AB and CD entered a gestational carrier agreement (which did not include EF) in 2019, having each had independent legal advice.

14. WX was conceived at California Fertility Partners in California, USA, following the transfer of an embryo to CD which had been created with donor eggs and EF’s gametes. CD subsequently gave birth to WX in California in 2020.

15. AB was present at the birth and EF arrived a week later. AB had obtained a pre-birth court order in California and was recorded on the US birth certificate as WX’s sole legal parent. A US passport was obtained for WX, and he was brought home to the UK when he was only a few weeks old, in early 2020.

16. AB was alerted by UK Border Control to the fact that steps needed to be taken in the UK to resolve WX’s legal status in the UK.

17. AB instructed Wesley Gryk solicitors to apply for British nationality registration and a UK passport for WX was granted later in 2020. AB also took legal advice and was advised to apply for a parental order together with EF. Although EF was reluctant, a joint application was made in June 2020.

18. AB was offered a work opportunity in France and she and EF decided to move there with WX in December 2020. As a result of the move (but also reflecting EF’s reluctance to make a parental order application), permission was granted to withdraw the parental order application in December 2020. AB and WX gained French citizenship and AB is recognised there as WX’s sole legal parent. EF did not wish to be recorded as WX’s legal father in France.

19. While in France the relationship between AB and EF broke down and they separated in 2023.

20. Since their separation EF has had regular contact with WX, which has been encouraged by AB.

21. In August 2024, AB decided to return to live in the UK with WX. They have lived together continuously in London since then, and WX has started school here. Their family life is anchored here.

22. AB sought further legal advice about her position as a parent and subsequently instructed her current solicitors to represent her in an adoption application to secure her legal status as WX’s parent for the purposes of UK law.

23. AB gave notice of her intention to adopt to the relevant local authority in November 2025. The local authority commenced their enquiries and completed the report as required under rule 14.11 Family Procedure Rules 2010 (the Annex A report) in February 2026.

24. AB’s application to adopt is dated 25 March 2026, issued on 1 April 2026. The matter was allocated to High Court Judge level in the Family Court and Judd J gave directions on 22 April 2026, listing the matter on 7 July 2026.

25. AB filed a statement in support and the local authority Annex A report had been filed. The hearing on 7 July 2026 was listed for directions and consideration whether to join the child.

26. On 7 July 2026 I made a child arrangements order providing for WX to live with AB and directions that included joining WX as a party, through his Children’s Guardian, and directed the filing of further evidence and a report from the Children’s Guardian. That order listed the application for final hearing on 21 October 2026. At that hearing the adoption application was supported by the local authority and the Children’s Guardian.

27. The court has had the benefit of detailed skeleton arguments from Mr Powell KC, on behalf of AB, and Ms Holland, on behalf of WX, as well as their oral submissions. Their respective expertise in this area of the law has been of great assistance.

Legal framework

28. A parental order under s 54 or s54A HFEA 2008 is recognised as the legal framework that provides a bespoke order for children born following a surrogacy arrangement. In circumstances where the criteria for a parental order are not capable of being satisfied (in this case the lack of a biological connection) an adoption order is the only other legal order available that achieves legal parenthood and extinguishes the legal parenthood of any other individual(s).

29. An adoption order has been made in relation to a child born following a surrogacy arrangement in differing factual circumstances (see Re B (adoption: surrogacy and parental responsibility) [2018] EWFC 86; J v K (adoption) [2021] EWFC 155; Re H (surrogacy: step parent adoption) [ 2023] EWFC 214 and C & Anor v E (international surrogacy and domestic adoption) [2025] EWFC 68).

30. The legal requirements in respect of an adoption application are set out in the Adoption and Children Act 2002 (ACA 2002). They can be summarised as follows:

(1) S 42 the child to live with the adopter(s) before adoption. Relevant to this case s42(5) provides that the child must have had his home with the applicant for 3 years during the period of five years preceding the application. That requirement has been met.

(2) S 42(7) the court must be satisfied that the relevant local authority has had sufficient opportunity to see the subject child with the applicant in their home environment. That has been met in this case through the preparation by the local authority of the Annex A report. The author of the report saw AB on three occasions, WX on two occasions and had a video meeting with EF.

(3) S 44 notice of intention to adopt. This applies where the proposed adopter(s) wish to adopt a child who is not placed for adoption with them by an adoption agency. In such circumstances the court cannot make an adoption order unless the proposed adopter(s) have given notice to the appropriate local authority of their intention to apply for an adoption order. The notice must be given not more than two years, or less than three months, before the date on which the application for the adoption order is made. By s 44(5) once a local authority is in receipt of the notice of intention to adopt, they must arrange for the investigation of the matter and submit a report (an Annex A report) to the court. In this case the applicant gave notice to the local authority on 12 November 2025 and made the adoption application on 25 March 2026, after the three month period had expired.

(4) S 49 provides that the applicant(s) must be either domiciled in this jurisdiction or been habitually resident for a period of not less than one year ending with the date of the application. Both of those conditions are satisfied in this case.

(5) S 51permits an application for an adoption order by a single applicant. AB is not married or in a civil partnership and is over the age of 21 years.

(6) S 47 provides that the court must be satisfied that any parent with parental responsibility consents to the making of an adoption order, unless their consent is dispensed with pursuant to s52. S 51 (6) defines parent as any individual who holds parental responsibility. CD gave her formal consent to the making of an adoption order by signing form A104 and providing her statement confirming her consent dated 23 January 2026. EF is a legal parent as CD was not married. EF does not have parental responsibility as he was not married to CD and is not registered as WX’s father under any of the specified enactments (s 4(1) Children Act 1989). EF was given notice of this application and his position in not opposing the order being made, even though his formal consent is not required, is set out in the Annex A report and re-affirmed in the Children’s Guardian’s report.

31. It is clear from the matters set out above that the statutory criteria for an adoption order are met.

32. In deciding whether an adoption order should be made the lifelong welfare needs of the child concerned is the court’s paramount consideration in accordance with s 1 ACA 2002 having regard, in particular, to the matters set out in s 1 (4). Section 1(6) ACA 2002 requires the court to consider the whole range of powers under the ACA 2002 and CA 1989 and prohibits the court from making an adoption order unless the court considered that making it would be better for the child than not making it.

Submissions

33. Mr Powell submits that in accordance with the principles set out In the matter of X and Y (Children: Adoption Order: Setting Aside) [2026] UKSC 13 on the facts of this case the court needs to consider the following.

34. First, the court must consider the legal consequences of adoption before making such an order. He submits it requires a careful examination of the proposed order and its consequences for the child’s legal relationship with the biological father and the surrogate. The statutory effect of an adoption order is to establish a new legal relationship of parenthood where, in accordance with s 67(1) ACA 2002, the adopted person ‘is to be treated in law as if born as the child of the adopters’. In Re J (Loss of Parental Responsibility) [2026] EWCA Civ 344 the Court of Appeal recognised both the distinct legal status created by adoption under s 67 ACA 2002 and the distinction between biological, gestational and social or psychological parenthood. Mr Powell submits AB does not suggest that EF’s relationship with WX is not significant but it is distinct from the preservation of EF’s legal status.

35. Second, EF’s position must be considered as part of the court’s overall welfare assessment. EF does not wish to remain a legal parent to WX. That is the position he occupies in relation to WX in the US and France. The court needs to carefully examine whether WX’s best interests are best served in preserving EF’s legal parenthood despite his stated wishes.

36. Third, the court needs to recognise in considering whether to make an adoption order that it is a welfare determination that will have enduring and profound consequences for WX’s legal identity and family relations.

37. Mr Powell submits that as part of that welfare determination the court needs to consider what other orders are available. It is accepted that an application for a step parent adoption could not be made in this case as s 51(2) ACA 2002 requires AB to be the partner of EF. A partner is defined in s 144 (4) ACA 2002 as including ‘two people living as partners in an enduring family relationship’. On the facts of this case EF has made his position clear that he does not wish to be WX’s legal parent. The factors that found family life as in Re E (Adoption by One Parent) [2022] 1 FLR 804 are not present in this case. AB and EF are not co-parenting and EF’s position regarding his legal parent relationship regarding WX has been clear. The only other orders that could made under the CA 1989 would be a child arrangements order through which AB would acquire parental responsibility but WX’s legal parent relationship with both CD and EF would remain. A child arrangements order only remains in force until WX is 18 years. Such an order would require additional provisions to limit CD’s ability to exercise her parental responsibility in relation to WX. It would also be open to the court to make a Special Guardianship order, which has the benefit of giving AB enhanced parental responsibility but, like the child arrangements order, it would only last until WX is 18 years and the legal parent relationship of both CD and EF would be retained.

38. In undertaking its welfare assessment Mr Powell submits the following considerations are important:

(1) An adoption order reflects the lived reality for WX, who has been cared for by AB since birth and is likely to remain cared for by her for the rest of his minority, and beyond. EF has made his position clear he does not wish to retain a legal parental role. If the adoption order was not made EF’s legal status in relation to WX would be retained against his wishes and would be inconsistent with his legal status in the US and France.

(2) WX’s continuing relationship with EF does not necessarily require him to remain a legal parent and there is no suggestion that making an adoption order will change their de facto relationship. There is no suggestion that AB does other than support the continuance of that relationship and WX recognises EF as his father. If the position changed and EF needed to make an application to the court he would need to apply for leave under s 10(9) CA 1989. Clearly any application would need to be considered on its merits at the time, it is accepted that as matters currently stand EF would likely satisfy the s 10(9) CA 1989 criteria.

(3) No harm has been identified that WX would be occasioned if an adoption order is made. Such an order would reflect the lived reality for WX and would reflect his legal status in both the US and France.

(4) For the reasons set out in the report from the Children’s Guardian’s report AB recognises the importance of life story work and age appropriate conversations with WX about his birth story.

39. Ms Holland, on behalf of WX’s Children’s Guardian, makes the following points in addition to supporting those made on behalf of AB. In EF’s discussions with the Children’s Guardian he confirmed his position regarding the adoption application and considered that extinguishing his legal parenthood would not alter his relationship with WX. EF recognised that WX may in the future feel hurt or rejected upon learning that EF never intended to be his legal parents and, as a consequence, may question his relationship with EF. In her assessment the Children’s Guardian considers that whilst WX identifies with EF as his father and values that relationship, his understanding of family life is centred upon AB as his primary parent and care giver. An adoption order would ensure that AB is recognised as WX’s legal parent throughout his life. The alternatives of a Child Arrangements order or a Special Guardianship Order would continue only until WX is 18 years which would not meet his lifelong welfare needs.

40. In supporting the adoption order being made the Children’s Guardian recognises the effect on WX’s legal relationship with AB and EF, but does not consider it would alter WX’s lived experience and, importantly, it would more accurately reflect the circumstances of his birth and family arrangements.

41. In her perceptive welfare analysis the Children’s Guardian has carefully considered that WX may have feelings of rejection, confusion and unfairness when considering his legal relationship with EF, as compared to EF’s other children, but considers this can be managed through on-going age appropriate conversations about WX’s birth story.

Discussion and decision

42. The legal requirement to make an adoption order having been established the focus of the court has been on the welfare determination. When the application came before me in July 2026 I was concerned that the Annex A report had not properly considered, as it is required to do under s 1 (4) (c ) and (f) ACA 2002, the likely effect on WX of the loss of his legal relationship with EF if an adoption order was made. That issue has now been carefully considered by the Children’s Guardian and her conclusions are supported by the author of the Annex A report.

43. Due to his young age WX has limited understanding of these proceedings. He is aware he was carried by another woman before he was born, however he does not understand the legal status of his important adults and caregivers. By virtue of the fact he has had his home with AB since his birth, and been in her sole care since 2023, his primary attachment is with her. I agree with the assessment of the Children’s Guardian that if WX was able to understand the issues before the court he would wish for his family arrangements to reflect what he has known all his life. The making of an adoption order will not change that but does provide legal recognition to secure the fact that AB is his primary carer and would more accurately reflect both the circumstances of his birth and the family relationships that exist in his daily life.

44. This is reflected in the conclusions of the Annex A report regarding the author’s assessment of AB and is supported by the Children’s Guardian, who states in her report ‘[WX] is thriving in [AB’s] care and presents as a happy, secure and well-cared for child. He has a warm and loving relationship with [AB], who has consistently met his needs and has demonstrated a clear ability and willingness to continue doing so throughout this childhood’.

45. Due to the fact that WX was born via a surrogacy arrangement he has a particular need to be provided with an understanding of the circumstances of his conception and birth. He already has some understanding about that and AB is committed to support his continued understanding. WX recognises EF as his father and both AB and EF are united in ensuring WX understands the circumstances of his birth, parentage and identity as he matures.

46. When considering the consequences of a sole adoption order being made the Children’s Guardian states she has had ‘particular regard to the ceasing of [EF’s] legal parenthood. Whilst this is a significant legal consequence, the evidence before the Court indicates that it is unlikely to alter [WX’s] day-to-day experience of family life. {WX} knows [EF] is his father and values their relationship, and this would reflect the original intention of the surrogacy agreement and [AB’s] legal status as [WX’s] sole legal parent in the USA and France. The principal impact of the proposed Adoption Order is however likely to be felt in his future understanding of his identity and family history. As [WX] matures, he may seek to understand why the person he knows and identifies as his father did not wish to acquire or retain parental status’.

47. The Children’s Guardian’s assessment in supporting the adoption order carefully weighs in the balance the impact on WX’s future understanding of his identity and family history concluding they can be managed through ongoing, age-appropriate conversations about his birth story, surrogacy journey and family history, together with therapeutic support, should this become necessary.

48. I agree and accept the recommendations following the detailed and careful assessments undertaken by the author of the Annex A report and the Children’s Guardian. For the reasons set out above, making an adoption order will undoubtedly meet WX’s lifelong welfare needs.

At Kohen Avocats, our family law attorney in Paris can review your situation.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.