Civil European Court of Human Rights
ÇAKIR AND OTHERS v. TURKEY
SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 51274/07
Saime ÇAKIR against Turkey
and 100 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 25 June 2013 as a Chamber composed of:
Guido Raimondi, President,
Danutė Jočienė,
Peer Lorenzen,
András Sajó,
Işıl Karakaş,
Nebojša Vučinić,
Helen Keller, judges,
and Stanley Naismith, Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications, listed in the Appendix,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
A list of the applicants is set out in the Appendix. Additionally, the case and decision numbers of the impugned proceedings appear in the Appendix.
A. The circumstances of the case
The facts of the case, as submitted by the applicants, may be summarised as follows.
On various dates, the applicants initiated actions before the civil courts or proceedings were brought against them before the civil or criminal courts. The procedures lasted several years.
B. Relevant domestic law
A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in Müdür Turgut and Others ((dec.), no 4860/09, §§ 19-26, 26 March 2013).
COMPLAINTS
The applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time.
Certain applicants also alleged violations of Article 13 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention.
THE LAW
A. Joinder of the applications
The Court first considers that in accordance with Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their common legal background.
B. Alleged violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention
The applicants complained that the length of the proceedings had been incompatible with the “reasonable time” requirement, laid down in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention, which reads as follows:
“In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a … hearing within a reasonable time by a … tribunal…”
The Court observes that the applicants asserted that the length of the proceedings had been incompatible with the principle of the “reasonable time” requirement in accordance with Article 6 § 1 of the Convention. The Court found in Müdür Turgut and Others ((dec.), cited above, §§ 58 and 60) that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384, insofar as it is a priori accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 § 1 of the Convention. In the present cases the Court sees no reasons to come to a different conclusion.
It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
C. Alleged violation of Article 13 of the Convention
Some applicants also complained that there had been no effective remedy under Turkish law. They rely in this regard to Article 13 of the Convention, which provides:
“Everyone whose rights and freedoms as set forth in this Convention are violated shall have an effective remedy before a national authority notwithstanding that the violation has been committed by persons acting in an official capacity.”
The Court recalls that it has also held that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384 provides for a remedy to the applicants within the meaning of Article 13 of the Convention to complain about the length of proceedings for the purposes of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention, relating to all applications pending before the Court submitted before 23 September 2012, and not yet communicated to the respondent Government (Müdür Turgut and Others (dec.), cited above, § 59).
It follows that these parts of the applications are manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.
D. Alleged violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention
Having carefully examined the applicants’ complaints in the light of all the material in its possession, and in so far as the matter complained of is within its competence, the Court finds that it does not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.
It follows that these parts of the applications are manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Stanley Naismith Guido Raimondi
Registrar President
Appendix
|
No |
Application No. |
Lodged on |
Applicant Date of birth Place of residence |
Represented by |
Notes |
|
|
51274/07 |
14/11/2007 |
Saime ÇAKIR 01/05/1945 Marmaris |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Court of Cassation E2007/1968 K2007/1884 |
|
|
53915/07 |
28/11/2007 |
Duran ERTUĞRUL 01/01/1947 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Court of Cassation E2005/10700 K2006/5135 |
|
|
10830/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Sultan TOK 01/03/1954 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1978/129 K2009/374 |
|
|
10836/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Fatmana ERGÜN 15/07/1942 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1999/598 |
|
|
10841/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Orhan ŞİMŞEK 20/05/1932 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court. E1988/360 |
|
|
10846/10 |
05/02/2010 |
Mehmet ÇELİKALP 01/10/1948 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court. E1995/486 |
|
|
10851/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Mehmet ERGÜN 01/07/1922 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court. E1995/356 |
|
|
11904/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Mehmet TOK 23/05/1946 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court. E1978/129 K2009/374 |
|
|
11906/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Dündar ERGÜN 03/01/1975 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1999/598 |
|
|
13540/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Yıldız TAŞTEKIN 10/03/1986 Muğla Nermin TARIM 20/03/1970 Marmaris |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1999/586 |
|
|
13551/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Ayser TOK TURGUT 01/08/1956 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court. E1978/127 K2003/130 |
|
|
13557/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Nihat ÖZER 26/01/1938 Marmaris |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court. E1995/315 |
|
|
13559/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Mustafa SAVAŞ 06/11/1950 Marmaris |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court. E1991/214 |
|
|
16243/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Sevginaz ERGÜN ARMUTLU 21/06/1972 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1910 K2010/491 |
|
|
19823/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Fatmana ÇELİKALP 03/07/1956 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Court of Cassation E2010/1979 K2010/3291 |
|
|
37986/10 |
26/03/2010 |
Ali Ulaş AKGÜN 10/02/1977 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Court of Cassation E2007/9300 K2009/2653 |
|
|
41862/10 |
02/07/2010 |
Yaşar TARIM 04/04/1933 Muğla Musa TARIM 06/04/1956 Muğla Tamer TARIM 01/07/1961 Muğla Nazmiye GÜRCAN 04/08/1965 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1996/11 K2001/16 |
|
|
42168/10 |
02/07/2010 |
Mürüvvet TANRIVER 01/01/1952 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1567 K2010/196 |
|
|
42369/10 |
24/05/2010 |
Mehmet ERGÜN 01/07/1922 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1978/54 K2009/25 |
|
|
42431/10 |
24/05/2010 |
Fatmana ERGÜN 15/07/1942 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1978/54 K2009/25 |
|
|
52756/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Sultan TOK 01/03/1954 Mugla Akkadın YAVAŞ 16/10/1958 Muğla Mehmet TOK 23/05/1946 Muğla Ayser TOK TURGUT 01/08/1956 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1984/42 |
|
|
54360/10 |
16/08/2010 |
Ramazan ŞEN 01/07/1928 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2007/243 E2009/970K |
|
|
55231/10 |
24/05/2010 |
Hüseyin Cahit ERGÜN 01/01/1962 Marmaris |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1978/54 K2009/25 |
|
|
55763/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Ali Nihat TARIM 05/06/1930 Muğla Ayfer TARIM 01/02/1935 Muğla Gönül Söyler BİLDİK 01/01/1958 Muğla Emel BALCI 01/04/1963 Muğla Arzu BULUT 06/04/1972 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Court of Cassation E2010/3446 K2010/3638 |
|
|
55938/10 |
25/08/2010 |
İbrahim Kemal EVCAN 16/05/1941 Marmaris |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1544 K2010/194 |
|
|
55943/10 |
25/08/2010 |
İskender TÜRKMENOĞLU 15/01/1946 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1809 K2010/423 |
|
|
55962/10 |
25/08/2010 |
Sinan KOZAN 17/08/1945 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1481 K2010/234 |
|
|
55997/10 |
25/08/2010 |
Nurhayat KORKMAZ 03/01/1944 Ankara Hatice EROL 11/03/1954 Ankara Filiz TAYLAN 11/09/1952 Ankara Hamdi Murat EFEOĞLU 09/04/1960 Ankara |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1908 K2010/494 |
|
|
56464/10 |
25/08/2010 |
Şaban YÜCEL 05/11/1943 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1547 K2010/170 |
|
|
56638/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Nimet Sibel CANATAN 02/05/1990 Muğla Ahmet Günan CANATAN 05/12/1946 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1902 2010/651 |
|
|
58466/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Güllü YALÇIN 25/06/1943 Muğla Fatmana ŞİMŞEK 01/09/1930 Muğla Dürdane ŞİMŞEK 01/03/1936 Muğla Sadıka YILDIRIM 09/09/1939 Muğla Zeynep İŞLER 20/09/1947 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1991/173 E1991/245 E1988/59 E1991/355 E1991/294 E1996/13 |
|
|
59089/10 |
30/07/2010 |
Selahattin TOMBUL 01/06/1963 Marmaris |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2008/238 K2009/769 |
|
|
59097/10 |
25/08/2010 |
Nezahat KURNAZ 27/07/1964 Muğla Sevcan BOZKURT 20/01/1968 Muğla Mehmet SARI 29/07/1971 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1973/70 K2011/2 |
|
|
59252/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Ali Nihat TARIM 05/06/1930 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1978/93 |
|
|
59260/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Mehmet EVCAN 10/01/1937 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/71 K2010/460 |
|
|
59354/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Sabahattin ŞİMŞEK 14/05/1942 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/89 |
|
|
59378/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Yusuf AL 01/02/1943 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/257 K2010/648 |
|
|
59463/10 |
16/06/2010 |
Nursen TARIM 29/10/1963 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1475 K2010/94 |
|
|
59479/10 |
16/06/2010 |
Kadriye ÖZER 23/03/1933 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1475 K2010/94 |
|
|
59490/10 |
16/06/2010 |
Gülsen ACAR 08/01/1960 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1475 K2010/94 |
|
|
59500/10 |
16/06/2010 |
İsmet ESEN 25/03/1939 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2008/226 K2009/985 |
|
|
59505/10 |
16/06/2010 |
İbrahim ÖZER 16/06/1967 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1475 K2010/94 |
|
|
59508/10 |
16/06/2010 |
Mustafa ERGÜN 12/01/1979 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1978/99 K2003/309 |
|
|
59510/10 |
16/06/2010 |
Dursen EVCAN 20/10/1958 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1475 K2010/94 |
|
|
59513/10 |
16/06/2010 |
Coşkun ZEYTİNOĞLU 08/02/1936 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1831 |
|
|
59514/10 |
16/06/2010 |
Nurkan YAĞCI 02/02/1970 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1529 K2010/201 |
|
|
59580/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Ramazan ÇELİK 01/04/1952 Muğla Fatma ÖZDEMİR 01/08/1955 Muğla Gülfer AKKUŞ 10/02/1958 Muğla Gülnaz ACAR 02/08/1960 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1978/82 K2009/69 |
|
|
59785/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Şerife Defne GÜRÜNLÜ 20/01/1959 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1846 K2010/774 |
|
|
59786/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Gülsüm ERDAL 27/11/1952 Muğla Gülayşe ÖZTEKİN 12/03/1956 Muğla Ayser GÖKBAKAR 01/07/1957 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1840 K2010/856 |
|
|
59858/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Sultan UYSALCAN 26/12/1943 Muğla Ali UYSALCAN 20/01/1957 Muğla Bayram UYSALCAN 27/05/1965 Muğla Adil UYSALCAN 17/02/1968 Muğla Nahit UYSALCAN 01/07/1970 Muğla Necibe YILDIRIM 04/10/1960 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1991/156 K2008/891 |
|
|
60026/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Sebahattin TARIM 21/01/1939 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2010/366 |
|
|
60153/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Mehmet Salih ÖZTEKİN 01/01/1926 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1825 |
|
|
60219/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Turan ÇELEBİOĞLU 01/01/1927 İstanbul |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
60308/10 |
08/09/2010 |
RUTO TAAHHÜT VE İNŞAAT LTD ŞTİ Ankara |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
60346/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Übeyde Barbara ELLİ 18/05/1960 Muğla Nihat Eralp ELLİ 23/12/1965 Muğla Mine ELLİ 20/06/1963 Muğla Payzın ELLİ 23/07/1976 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
60419/10 |
03/09/2010 |
İsmail Kudret UNUTMAZ 28/07/1955 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/582 K2010/657 |
|
|
60861/10 |
13/09/2010 |
Fatmana ŞİMŞEK 01/09/1930 Muğla Dürdane ŞİMŞEK 01/03/1936 Muğla Sadıka YILDIRIM 09/09/1939 Muğla Güllü YALÇIN 25/06/1943 Muğla Zeynep İŞLER 20/09/1947 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1991/245 |
|
|
61202/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Nilgün YENİCİOĞLU 11/08/1950 Ankara |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
61283/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Ayşe Zeynep KATNAŞ 20/01/1957 Edirne |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
61642/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Zeynep Bilge GÜZ 22/01/1939 Ankara |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
62109/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Sumru BEDER 01/01/1941 Ankara |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
62112/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Tamer SUNGAR 29/02/1936 Ankara |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
62116/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Halit KORKMAZ 28/07/1951 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1991/209 |
|
|
62118/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Aksın GENCE 14/08/1946 Ankara |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
62122/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Çidem ERGÜVENÇ 22/06/1947 Ankara |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
62534/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Fatmana ŞİMŞEK 01/09/1930 Muğla Dürdane ŞİMŞEK 01/03/1936 Muğla Sadıka YILDIRIM 09/09/1939 Muğla Güllü YALÇIN 25/06/1943 Muğla Zeynep İŞLER 20/09/1947 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1988/59 K2009/905 |
|
|
63704/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Bekir TARIM 20/09/1956 Muğla Muhammet TARIM 01/02/1952 Muğla İbrahim TARIM 21/07/1954 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1978/77 |
|
|
63708/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Bekir TARIM 20/09/1956 Muğla Muhammet TARIM 01/02/1952 Muğla İbrahim TARIM 21/07/1954 Muğla Hasan GÖKGÖZ 26/10/1941 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1978/278 |
|
|
63831/10 |
08/09/2010 |
İbrahim YALÇINOĞLU 20/12/1933 Ankara |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
63855/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Erten ALKAN 08/09/1944 Ankara |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
63866/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Fatmana ŞİMŞEK 01/09/1930 Muğla Dürdane ŞİMŞEK 01/03/1936 Muğla Sadıka YILDIRIM 09/09/1939 Muğla Güllü YALÇIN 25/06/1943 Muğla Zeynep İŞLER 20/09/1947 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1996/13 K2009/994 |
|
|
63869/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Fatmana ŞİMŞEK 01/09/1930 Muğla Dürdane ŞİMŞEK 01/03/1936 Muğla Sadıka YILDIRIM 09/09/1939 Muğla Güllü YALÇIN 25/06/1943Muğla Zeynep İŞLER 20/09/1947 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Court of Cassation E2010/9381 K2010/10790 |
|
|
64381/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Özer ÇELİK 10/08/1973 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1718 |
|
|
64507/10 |
02/07/2010 |
Yaşar TARIM 04/04/1933 Marmaris Musa TARIM 06/04/1956 Muğla Tamer TARIM 01/07/1961 Muğla Nazmiye GÜRCAN 04/08/1965 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Court of Cassation E2011/3319 K2011/2120 |
|
|
64540/10 |
16/08/2010 |
Orhan ŞİMŞEK 20/05/1932 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Court of Cassation E2009/20015 K2010/2162 |
|
|
65155/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Fatmana YILDIRIM 01/01/1944 Muğla Selma ARSLAN (YILDIRIM) 01/01/1967 Muğla Mehmet Ali YILDIRIM 01/01/1965 Muğla Sabahattin YILDIRIM 01/01/1971 Muğla Mehmet YILDIRIM 01/01/1945 Muğla Hasan YILDIRIM 01/01/1944 Muğla Mustafa YILDIRIM 01/01/1941 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Court of Cassation E2010/9799 2010/10798 |
|
|
65168/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Melek YALÇIN 16/04/1946 İstanbul |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1994/64 |
|
|
65178/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Halil DEMİRTAŞ 01/01/1956 Muğla Semiha GÖNEN (DEMİRTAŞ) 01/01/1963 Muğla Gülden UYGUN (DEMİRTAŞ) 01/01/1975 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1974/27 |
|
|
65255/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Emine ADALI 01/07/1928 Muğla Dürdane YANIK 06/09/1953 Muğla Turhan YÜCEL 27/11/1955 Muğla Tazettin ADALI 20/03/1958 Muğla Adlen ADALI 26/10/1960 Muğla Mehmet ADALI 04/03/1966 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1973/91 K2009/1160 |
|
|
70949/10 |
03/09/2010 |
Sebahattin TARIM 21/01/1939 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2010/367 |
|
|
71466/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Kutlu BURSA 15/12/1936 İstanbul |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1983/146 |
|
|
74542/10 |
12/11/2010 |
Halil KORKMAZ 10/03/1948 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1991/209 K2010/790 |
|
|
74810/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Ferhan EVİRGEN 05/01/1929 Muğla Utarit EVİRGEN 12/04/1953 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1525 K2010/381 |
|
|
74821/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Rıfat DİKER 01/01/1944 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1983/146 |
|
|
74826/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Mualla HİÇŞAŞMAZ 19/03/1926 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1983/146 |
|
|
74875/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Uğur TARHAN 29/06/1940 Eskişehir |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1983/146 |
|
|
74878/10 |
08/09/2010 |
Cemal DİKER 01/01/1926 Eskişehir |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1983/146 |
|
|
75439/10 |
12/11/2010 |
Melek AYAYDIN ÖZTEKİN 01/01/1952 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1984/42 |
|
|
75457/10 |
27/11/2010 |
Mehmet Engin SEYHAN 28/01/1949 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1808 K2010/424 |
|
|
2940/11 |
28/10/2010 |
Nadir KORKMAZ 02/01/1961 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1991/209 K2010/790 |
|
|
4441/11 |
02/07/2010 |
Ayfer TARIM 01/02/1935 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Court of Cassation E2010/8998 K2010/11838 |
|
|
13735/11 |
16/12/2010 |
Rıza ÖZZEYBEK 19/04/1951 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1464 K2010/779 |
|
|
15493/11 |
27/11/2010 |
Ramazan ÇELİK 01/04/1952 Muğla Fatma ÖZDEMİR 01/08/1955 Muğla Gülfer AKKUŞ 10/02/1958 Muğla Gülnaz ACAR 02/08/1960 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Civil Court of General Jurisdiction E2008/434 K2010/458 |
|
|
18239/11 |
28/01/2011 |
Turgut SAVAŞ 15/01/1948 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1734 K2010/705 Court of Cassation E2012/8187 |
|
|
41715/11 |
28/06/2011 |
Ali Nihat TARIM 05/06/1930 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1978/10 K2009/954 |
|
|
43412/11 |
20/05/2011 |
Orhan TURUT 28/02/1957 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Court of Cassation E2011/76 K2011/459 |
|
|
47599/11 |
19/05/2011 |
Ramazan ERTUĞRUL 26/09/1938 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2008/247 K2009/770 |
|
|
47613/11 |
19/05/2011 |
Gazanfer KOCAYİĞİT 10/05/1963 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1991/233 K2008/892 |
|
|
47622/11 |
19/05/2011 |
Mehmet KOCAYİĞİT 01/01/1926 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E1995/367 |
|
|
53489/11 |
11/07/2011 |
Pamirhan OBAOĞLU 11/09/1985 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2010/365 (First number 1995/365) K2010/304 |
|
|
63587/11 |
25/08/2010 |
Bayram KOCAYİĞİT 01/01/1950 Muğla |
Aydın TORAMAN |
Marmaris Cadastral Court E2009/1478 K2010/274 |
Official sources: view the source page · Official PDF
HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.