Administrative United Kingdom
Jonathan Lemi v THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
First-tier Tribunal
(Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Appeal Number: HU/55845/26
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
Heard at Manchester
on 4th November, 2026
Before
first-tier tribunal JUDGE jepson
Between
Jonathan Lemi
Appellant
and
THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent
Representation:
For the Appellant: Mr.Timson, counsel instructed by Medlock Law solicitors.
For the Respondent Mr.Scholes, Home Office Presenting Officer.
DECISION AND REASONS
1. The Appellant, a citizen of the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC hereinafter,) appeals the decision made on 10th April, 2026 to refuse their human rights claim. That was made in response to a deportation notice issued 12th December, 2025. The stage two order coincided with the refusal letter.
2. No anonymity direction is made. One has not been sought. I am, however, conscious that the Appellant’s family (which includes some children) are not in any way associated with his offending. I will therefore refer to them only by their initials or relation to the Appellant.
BACKGROUND
3. The Appellant entered the UK around the age of two. He is now twenty-seven. An asylum claim (presumably with the Appellant as a dependent of his mother) was refused in June 2001. Leave to remain was granted in August 2003. Indefinite leave followed in November 2004. That was extended in 2005, after which what is referred to by the Respondent as ‘no time leave’ was awarded in September 2019.
4. In October, 2025 the Appellant was sentenced to twenty-seven months’ custody by a Crown Court. The offences were two counts of possession of a class A drug with intent to supply, from the same date. Alongside the criminal proceedings, a referral had been made to the Single Competent Authority. Reasonable negative grounds were found before the date of sentence.
5. It is not claimed the second exception to deportation can be met (S.117C(5) Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 – NIAA hereinafter.) That is despite a suggestion in representations from the Appellant’s solicitor (24th February, 2026 – page 57 Respondent’s bundle) the exception might apply to his mother. The Appellant has no partner nor children.
6. Reliance is placed on the first exception (S.117C(6).) The Respondent accepts lawful residence in the UK for most of the Appellant’s life. Dispute arises as to whether he is integrated within the community and if very significant obstacles would arise on return to the DRC. Family ties – principally with the Appellant’s mother and siblings – are said to constitute very compelling circumstances (S.117C(6).) The Respondent asserts such circumstances do not arise. The public interest in removal is said to be strong.
HEARING
7. The hearing was recorded. That shall stand as the record of proceedings.
Preliminary issues
8. The Appellant attended with his mother. Both gave evidence. It had been anticipated the Appellant’s brother would also appear. Mr.Timson explained the brother had just started a job, was unable to take time away. The Appellant did not seek an adjournment. It was noted the brother’s statement says much that same as that of his mother.
9. No other issues arose. The hearing proceeded without incident.
Issues in dispute
10. The parties agree the issues for resolution are as follows:
(i) Whether the first exception to deportation is met.
(ii) If very compelling circumstances arise.
Evidence and submissions
11. I heard evidence from the Appellant and his mother. Neither required an interpreter. Following closing submissions from each advocate, judgment was reserved.
The Crown Court sentence – Mr.Recorder Thomas – 28th October, 2025
12. Each offence occurred on 2nd January 2022. The Appellant (defendant as was) had been pulled over by the police. Twenty-nine bags, a mix of heroin and crack cocaine, were found. The Judge found the case to be one of street-level supply. The Appellant was placed at the bottom end of a supply chain. Matters fell within category three of the applicable sentencing guideline. That provided a start point of four and a half years custody. A discount of 25% was given for pleas at the Crown Court, though the exact point that took place is not clear. It was, the Judge accepted, necessary for the National Referral Mechanism process to conclude before pleas could be entered. Charges were laid on 29th August, 2023. The fact of a significant delay was taken into account.
13. The Appellant was twenty-three at the time of offences, twenty-six when sentenced. He was considered immature for his age. There were no others convictions on the Appellant’s record when the offences were committed. Some had been amassed since, however. They comprised fail to provide, obstruct PC and associated documentary (motoring) offences in December 2022. An offence of drug-driving followed in May 2023. The respective sentences imposed were not mentioned. In August 2024, the Appellant was given a suspended sentence for possession of drugs and possess bladed article. Accompanying the latter was unpaid work and rehabilitation days.
14. The Judge noted despite being more than a year on from the suspended sentence being imposed, limited progress was made. What was termed ‘significant or unjustified breaches’ of the order had occurred. Although there is no suggestion of a conviction, at the end of the hearing an un-named probation officer in court referred to breach proceedings before the Magistrates Court. Whether they were pursued is not known. Irrespective of that, the Judge concluded it was unrealistic to impose a further suspended sentence given non-compliance with the existing one. The same view was taken of a request that sentence be deferred.
15. Twenty-seven months was imposed, concurrent on each offence. No action was taken in relation to the suspended sentence. The offences did not breach that, given they pre-dated its imposition. The Recorder wondered whether he had the power to revoke the order in the interests of justice, though opted not to do so.
DISCUSSION AND FINDINGS
16. I will begin with the OASys report (29th December, 2025.) Whilst the entirety of the report has been taken into account, given its length I will set out only certain sections.
17. Reference was made to the offences from December 2022. Beyond the drugs found, there was also mention in the report of a knife being recovered (paragraph 2.1.) Nothing shows, even if a knife was found, it resulted in a charge or conviction on that occasion. A caution – for possession of drugs and a bladed article – was noted from 2020. The author of the report expressed concern about some history of possessing weapons (R10.1) Similar worry was raised about a possible history of drugs supply, given the matters from December 2022.
18. I take care not to place much weight on either element. Whilst the Probation Service was entitled to take into account matters for which the Appellant was not convicted, it would in my view be unfair to do so in any significant sense within these proceedings. Even though there was a conviction for possession of drugs arising from what happened in December 2022, that was not for supply. There appears from the information available to have been a caution and one later conviction for possession of a knife. Nether instance related to the offences dealt with at the Crown Court. Taking things back a step, whilst other convictions can be taken into account beyond those sentenced at the Crown Court they must be the primary focus. It was that conviction which led to the deportation order.
19. Discussing background, the Appellant said he was introduced to a drug dealer by a friend. He was tempted by the lure of earning money. There had been regular cannabis use at the time, though the Appellant did not perceive that to be an addiction (2.8.) Funding the habit was difficult without work, the friend offering a solution through selling drugs. Full responsibility was taken, remorse expressed (2.11.) The Appellant said he had since ended negative associations, recognised his immaturity at the time. Efforts were made to seek qualifications and an apprenticeship after the offences were committed. The author of the report suggested that demonstrated a more positive path being taken.
20. Something of a work history existed, for example at Amazon (4.10.) It was leaving that and becoming unemployed which led to money problems. The Appellant failed to attend the job centre, causing a loss of benefits (5.6.) There remained a need to support the cannabis habit. Such events were deemed to show poor decision-making skills. Later attempts to secure work and achieve qualifications whilst the index offences were pending appeared, the report writer suggested, to show the Appellant learnt from his mistakes. Greater risk was suggested to apply if education or work was not maintained on release (R10.5.) A medium risk of harm to the public was found to exist. All other risk criteria were set at a low level (R10.6.)
21. A number of documents are served in support of the Appellant’s case. From page 85 of his bundle are several certificates from the prison estate. They appear to show rehabilitative work being done. Example include course called ‘New Lifestyle’ and ‘Change as a Process.’ That demonstrates some efforts made to address offending behaviour in the comparatively short time spent in custody.
22. Similar material is found at page 98 of the Respondent’s bundle. That consists of certificates from roughly 2016-8, whereby academic qualifications were attained on leaving school. Earlier transcripts are also submitted A CV is page 116. Therein, the Appellant expressed a hope to work in the automotive industry.
23. At page 146 is a letter confirming the Appellant’s national insurance number. There is also an HMRC document from September 2018 that refers to re-payment of income tax. No dispute has been raised the Appellant worked for some of his adult life.
24. The Appellant’s mother (TB) submits both a letter (page 76 Respondent’s bundle) and formal statement (page 7 Appellant’s bundle, dated 29th July, 2026.) Both contain much the same content. In summary, TB talks of entering the UK with her four children when the Appellant was three. He had been born in France[1], never visited the DRC. Two uncles live in the UK (albeit in London,) some aunts in France. TB and her children lived together throughout. They currently reside in the Manchester area.
25. TB describes the Appellant having gone to what she calls ‘the wrong side,’ was influenced by the wrong people. She blames herself for that. The Appellant is described as playing an important role within the family unit. Emotional support is provided to both TB and the other children in the house (who are now roughly twenty-four, eighteen and ten.) TB works as a care assistant, has long hours so relies on the Appellant for childcare. That extends to the school run, preparing meals and helping with homework. Support had previously been given to a now-late maternal grandmother when they lived in the address. He is, TB says, not perfect but has a sense of responsibility for his family – especially siblings. Any life established which exists is in the UK. No relatives remain in the DRC.
26. Similar letters (and in the case of the eldest sibling, JB, a corresponding statement) are produced from the Appellant’s siblings. The material is found at pages 80, 84 and 87 of the Respondent’s bundle and for JB’s statement – 29th July, 2026 – page 12 of the Appellant’s bundle. They largely repeat what is said by TB. JB (the eldest) refers to regular phone contact from prison. The Appellant expresses his remorse, talks about a desire to find work on release. SB (the middle sibling) recalls the Appellant as a guiding presence from a young age. As with their mother, SB accepts her brother is not perfect. He has not, however, exhibited any negative behaviour towards family members. The Appellant’s presence is argued to provide stability to the household. GB, the youngest, says she is afraid of losing her brother. He goes on walks with her after school, helps with homework.
27. A cousin to the Appellant, EK, has produced a letter (page 89 Respondent’s bundle.) There is no corresponding statement nor ID, though the Respondent has not expressed concern about that. EK describes the Appellant as an important figure in the lives of his siblings but also his own. Emotional and financial help has always been provided by the Appellant. That mirrors 4.10 of the OASys report, in which the Appellant said when in work he contributed towards the household where possible.
28. A series of family photographs are at page 92. They are no doubt intended to depict the family unit at various stages of life. Only so much weight can be applied to such material, though it does bolster the depiction of a happy, mutually caring family unit.
29. The Appellant was interviewed, presumably around the time of arrival to custody by the Immigration Prison Team. Notes of the conversation are at page 30 of the Respondent’s bundle. He confirmed therein much the same family circumstances as set out in the statements discussed above. The Appellant said was not taking any medication (question 6.2) or suffereing from mental health problems (6.5.) He noted having never been to the DRC.
30. In his statement (page 1 Appellant’s bundle, dated 21st July, 2026) the Appellant does not minimise his offending. He also acknowledges words are not enough. A desire to move away from negative influences is expressed. As is an ambition to qualify as a barber. It is argued even if, as the refusal contends, some form of short-term help might be available from the DRC state, it cannot replace the Appellant’s life in the UK.
31. The Appellant adopted his statement in court. He was released from custody in September, now lives as before with his mother and siblings. When asked by Mr.Scholes, the Appellant initially suggested he began selling drugs in 2024. Via a clarifying question from myself, he confirmed not being sure about dates. It was, the Appellant said, some time ago. The sole instance of drug supply had occurred through in January 2022, resulting in the custodial term served. Mr.Scholes did not invite any finding that drugs supply occured beyond that reflected in the criminal convictions.
32. In terms of drug use, the Appellant said he was not taking them. Mr.Scholes asked when that stopped, to which the reply was (from my note) “I don’t.” During closing submissions, Mr.Scholes suggested inconsistency might thereby arise. Contrast was drawn between that said in court and contrasting comment in the OASys report (discussed earlier in this section.) Mr.Timson in response argued the Appellant’s answers could be interpreted to mean there is no current use. He referred to what was characterised as a frank account in the report around the taking of drugs. I accept given there was no further exploration of the topic in court the replies given could be viewed in different ways. It would for that reason be unfair to find a discrepancy exists.
33. As to his offending, the Appellant accepted he was given a police caution in 2020. Both that, the further offences thereafter and a choice to begin selling drugs was put down to lack of maturity. He had, the Appellant said, not taken life seriously. His mother was aware of police involvement from the caution onwards. TB in her evidence confirmed that was right, having taken the Appellant to the police station after they called at the family home.
34. The Appellant reported he is unable to obtain work or employment at present. That is due to lack of ID. A previous biometric card, which the Appellant believed would no longer be valid in any event, had expired. His mother is a British citizen, having achieved that (per her evidence) in 2016. The Appellant suggested he did not do so at the same time because his biometric card needed to be updated. TB gave a different account, explaining the Appellant failed to take a required citizenship test.
35. Prior to the custodial term, the Appellant worked. He described a series of warehouse jobs in court. The last period of paid employment was left about a year prior to custody being imposed. The Appellant explained that ended due to having weekly reporting conditions as part of bail and being required to attend unpaid work via the suspended sentence. He chose to cease work rather than being sacked or made redundant.
36. Any financial support currently comes from TB and the Appellant’s younger brother, JB. The latter is now employed. There was also reference to borrowing from close friends. Living at the family home had been approved by the Appellant’s probation officer. They recently reduced appointments to every two weeks, said to be due to good progress.
37. In response to questions from myself, the Appellant confirmed he is subject to a ‘tagged’ curfew. There are no conditions preventing entry to certain areas or association with particular individuals. The Appellant asserted his previous, negative ties are severed completely. When asked his response to concern in the OASys report that risk of re-offending was greater without education or work, the Appellant relied on those cut ties as a sign he would not be in trouble again. His probation officer has referred the Appellant to an organisation called Achieve. He is attending a training course run by them, with a view to obtaining work skills.
38. Given reference in the OASys report to a knife being recovered during the December 2022 arrested (for which the Crown Court sentencing remarks refer only to offences of failing to provide and obstructing a police officer,) I asked for clarity. The Appellant told me he was in trouble twice for a knife – the caution in 2020 and (as mentioned in the remarks) via the suspended sentence imposed August 2024. I see no reason to disbelieve that, given the lack of further conviction for weapons.
39. As to that suspended sentence, there had been no formal breach proceedings. The Appellant could not recall if it was imposed by a Magistrates or Crown Court. Any missed appointments – something the Recorder noted – was due to health issues. I do not take too much from the point but that does not fit with what is said in the sentencing remarks. Whilst detail given therein was limited, mention is made of unauthorised absences rather than acceptable misses.
40. Life in the DRC, the Appellant said, would be a struggle. No family remain there. Separation from relatives in the UK would be detrimental to everyone. A family discussion had taken place about what would happen if the Appellant were deported. There was, he suggested, no guarantees of survival. Having never been to that country, the Appellant had no idea of the environment or conditions there. On that topic, I note there is some suggestion in the papers the Appellant was born in France (said for example at the end of the interview with the prison immigration team.) TB explained during the hearing that was something his grandmother had (incorrectly) told the Appellant in the past. In fairness, his statement confirms the DRC as the place of birth.
41. The Appellant confirmed being able to speak French and Lingala as well as English. He clarified on re-examination that not to the level of fluency. TB agreed, suggesting any proficiency was limited to a few words. None of the Appellant’s siblings can understand Lingala. No external information is presented by either party as to the use of French in the DRC.
42. TB’s live evidence was largely consistent with that of the Appellant. She spoke of her son as a changed person since release from custody. Her belief was he realised the error of his previous behaviour. Small amounts of money are provided to the Appellant. TB denied that would be of any real use to him in the DRC. The sums provided are typically £10 or so as pocket money. JB (the Appellant’s younger brother) sometimes gives him money. Any help provided from him is typically spent on travel for probation and immigration (reporting) appointments.
43. TB did not think warehouse jobs, the Appellant’s previous work, existed in the DRC. She confirmed having no family left there. Although the topic had been discussed, it was not thought feasible to support the Appellant if deported. TB told me in reply to a clarifying question she had claimed asylum here due to risk faced in the DRC. She would not go back there, even for a visit.
44. TB said she struggles to make ends meet, having been forced to take part-time hours during the Appellant’s prison term. That was due to a need to care for her other children – particularly the youngest. When TB did work, she left her youngest daughter with neighbours. There was no money for a childminder. The Appellant is now able to help with that again, as (per TB’s statement and those of his siblings) he had done before. When asked, TB said she intended to return to full-time when possible. A request had been made, though her workplace is currently over-subscribed.
Exception One
45. There is no dispute the Appellant has been in this country for most of his life. He arrived at a very young age.
46. The question of integration within UK society is in my view finely-balanced. The offences for which custody was imposed are clearly very serious. Without re-litigating the Crown Court case, drugs have a significant impact on the community. The start point was one of four and a half years on the guidelines – a substantial period. Though the Appellant only had a caution at the time, while pending the index offences he went on to commit further offences. One set of those led to a suspended sentence, for which compliance appears comparatively limited. It might be argued having been given chance to show adherence to what was – via the rehabilitation days imposed – a constructive form of punishment the Appellant showed little willingness to do so. It was for that reason the Recorder felt unable to consider a suspended sentence or period of deferment. Without placing too much emphasis on the point, the Appellant’s antecedence has a recurring theme of either drug use or supply.
47. From the OASys report, the Crown Court offences were committed for money. That was used to fund a cannabis habit, in preference to paid work or benefits. Though not entirely clear (meaning less weight is given,) the implication from the OASys report is the Appellant simply failed to attend job centre appointments rather than there being extenuating circumstances behind sanction of benefits. An element of choice was therefore arguably involved.
48. Reliance is placed on the presence of supportive family members, principally the Appellant’s mother. Although something to which I will return, TB in her statement talks of having been unable to prevent offending from taking place. She describes bringing the Appellant to a police station. Despite being held for forty-eight hours, the offences continued. Some force exists in the argument that notwithstanding the presence of relatives with a negative view of the Appellant’s behaviour he persisted with it. That reduces what weight can be given to the suggestion family will act as a protective measure in future.
49. There are some balancing factors. The index offences at least are of some age. Though noting the Appellant chose to exercise his right to remain silent in police interview, the Judge recognised a considerable delay followed before charges were brought. No blame was apportioned to the Appellant for that. It can be said no further instances of drug supply took place thereafter. To that extent, there is no pattern of behaviour shown. However, any positive weight applied is reduced by the fact more criminal offences occurred. The Appellant was not deterred from such behaviour despite pending serious criminal matters.
50. In terms of the index offences themselves, the Recorder acknowledged the Appellant was young at the time of their commission. He was deemed immature for his years. That is echoed in the OASys report. Though placing the offences in category 3 (hence the four and a half year start point,) the Appellant was found to be at the very bottom of any supply chain. He pleaded guilty at what seems a fairly early opportunity, the Recorder accepting enquiries by the Single Competent Authority were legitimately pursued. Even allowing for the 25% discount said to have been applied for early pleas, the sentence imposed was substantially lower. That indicates the Crown Court placed some weight on other mitigating elements as set out. They did not, however, feel able to do other than impose immediate custody.
51. I do not ignore the police caution mentioned in the OASys report, though that must I find carry less weight than a substantive conviction. It is nonetheless a source of some concern, given as it contains as with other matters a drug element. Possession of a knife is not trivial, though tempered by the method of disposal chosen by the police. Beyond that caution, the Appellant did not trouble the police or courts until 2022. He had been in the UK for many years by then, including both his childhood and some time as a young adult. Then again, as Mr.Scholes observed much of the Appellant’s adult life has been spent offending. That carries significant weight in my view.
52. The OASys report is mixed in my view. Concern must I find stem from assessment of the Appellant as a medium risk to the public. That conclusion was formed notwithstanding the more positive elements within the report. It is a relatively recent document. Nothing is presented to suggest risk levels have been re-assessed downwards by Probation since. Reference is made to drug use, albeit as discussed the Appellant said in court that is in his past. Though linked to the offences committed (meaning I am careful not to unduly ‘double-count’ the feature,) drug use nevertheless amounts to activity outside the norms of society. The report author found risk could be greater were the Appellant to either engage with negative peers or find himself out of work or education. Each of those aspects was considered key to the offending behaviour which occurred. It is of note the Appellant currently falls such category, though in fairness has not offended as a result.
53. Set against that is evidence the time spent in custody was used productively. The certificates produced, of which there are several, suggest courses taken designed to tackle offending. It cannot be said the Appellant has not sought rehabilitative programmes within the prison estate. The OASys report suggested any expressions of remorse and determination to avoid re-offending were genuine. Regard was had to aspects such as immaturity. The report author found the Appellant had potential in the right circumstances.
54. The Appellant is now back in the community, albeit only for around two months. Though strictly speaking not adduced into evidence, Mr.Scholes in his closing explained he had seen the Appellant’s PNC print. No other criminal cases are pending against him or have been since release. I take that into account, though it can carry only quite limited weight. It may be lack of further offending supports what the Appellant and his mother say about a new attitude towards life. However, by staying out of trouble he has done no more than behave as would be expected of anyone. The brief span of time involved is also relevant. There has been limited opportunity for the Appellant to prove himself.
55. Perhaps more positively, there is no suggestion of breached licence conditions. There was no challenge made in court to claims probation appointments are now fortnightly due to progress made. The same can be said of engagement with Achieve. I see no reason to doubt what the Appellant says about being unable to access work or education until the question of ID is resolved. Something of a contrast might be drawn between that and someone simply choosing not to access either.
56. I recognise the support voiced by TB in court for her son. It is clear she is determined he now lives a law-abiding life. As do the various siblings (and cousin) who have given statements or letters of support. I limit the weight given to that, however, simply because any wish the Appellant remain crime-free likely existed prior to and during his span of offending. Regard has been given to Mr.Scholes’ argument that in returning home the Appellant is in very similar circumstances as he was before going to prison. In saying that, I appreciate the reply would be the Appellant has not committed further offences nor engaged with his previous associates. Given the potential for that (due to him being back where he was before,) the point similarly has some value.
57. Mr.Scholes placed emphasis on a failure by the Appellant to secure British citizenship alongside his mother. Each gave different reasons why in court. TB’s belief was her son had not undergone the process due to lack of motivation to take a required test. By contrast, the Appellant’s version was he could not do so due to further ID problems. It is difficult absent more information to resolve the tension, though that said by TB implies an absence of effort more than anything else. What does seem clear is at least some opportunity to adopt British citizenship existed and was not taken. I make plain that far from determines the appeal. It could nevertheless be said taking on such citizenship might have weighed in favour of demonstrating integration.
58. I note the Appellant speaks English, seems for at least some of his adult life to have been self-sufficient via paid employment. That is balanced to an extent by mention of later claiming benefits, something which seems to have occurred by choice. There is no self-sufficiency at present, though I acknowledge if ID is a barrier that may be beyond the Appellant’s control.
59. Some, albeit comparatively limited, evidence of paid employment has been provided. As has certificates showing educational achievements beyond those obtained at school (prior to going into custody.) The Appellant’s CV suggests someone with ambitions, though as yet they appear unrealised. He gave evidence in court about work at various warehouses. No dispute was raised by Mr.Scholes about ongoing attendance at Achieve. The OASys report suggested potential exists to live a law-abiding, positive life. Care has been taken not to over-emphasise that, however. A medium risk was found to exist despite more positive aspects existing.
60. Mr.Timson invites the conclusion that things have moved on. He cites the courses taken in prison (which post-date the OASys report,) positive engagement since release as signs any potential might yet be realised. Reliance is placed on the Appellant being on licence until 2028. I do not ignore that. It may constitute a protective measure, though arguably so too did the suspended sentence previously imposed. Though it is not suggested further offending occurred during the currency of that order (the index offences here pre-dating by some time,) nor can the Appellant claim to have fully complied. Given the absence of a court finding, I apply less weight but at the same time there was discussion at the Crown Court of failed appointments.
61. Even if, as was said in court before me, the Appellant was unable to attend appointments as part of the suspended sentence due to ill-health, the sentencing remarks refer to unjustified breaches. Mr.Scholes relied on that in his closing, arguing the Appellant failed to take previous chances to mend his ways. As with other aspects of the appeal, I remind myself the focus must be the matters for which custody was imposed. Prior compliance with court orders can nonetheless be relevant when assessing the question of integration.
62. There was brief mention in the Appellant’s live evidence of having suffered trauma in the past. Without speculating unduly, that may link to the National Referral Mechanism briefly mentioned by the sentencing Recorder. I can, however, give no weight to the issue. Very little was said about it. Assuming momentarily it does relate to the Single Competent Authority, a reasonable negative grounds decision was reached. Mr.Timson via his closing accepted there was no reliance on the point.
63. The question of integration is finely-balanced. Without unnecessarily repeating that already discussed above, the length of time in this country must I find carry significant weight. As does the Appellant having lived a blameless life for much of that period. He attended school, achieved qualifications thereafter and has some history of work. Close family members have been present throughout. All of those factors show integration with the norms of UK society.
64. Set against that is the serious nature of the index offences along with other convictions which post-date their commission. Each arose despite the positive features set out above. The Appellant made what seems to be relatively limited (positive) use of the suspended sentence, though it is right to say he did not re-offend after its imposition. I bear in mind the offences which led to immediate custody are now approaching five years ago.
65. If the above elements fully reflected the Appellant’s circumstances, I would not have found integration within UK society. The seriousness of the index offences along with other criminality carries substantial weight. As Mr.Scholes rightly reminds me, the more grave the offence the greater the public interest in removal. Whilst not perhaps the longest of sentences, that imposed was of some duration. There is force in the argument that rehabilitative chances offered to the Appellant prior to its imposition were squandered – especially in terms of the suspended sentence.
66. What just about tips matters in the Appellant’s favour is events since the sentence began. Notwithstanding his being designated a medium risk in the OASys report (something to which substantial weight is given,) I bear in mind that was written some relative time ago. As a broad point, I accept things can move on. In this instance, almost a year has elapsed. The Appellant has shown some commitment to rehabilitative work. That comes via the courses taken in custody and since release via his probation officer. No challenge was made in court to claims drug use has ceased or that negative peers no longer form part of the Appellant’s life. Though less of a factor given they were unable to prevent offending before, he remains with close family. They are supportive.
67. I am careful not to apply too much weight given the duration involved but no further offending has taken place following release. That has at least some relevance, given the Respondent’s characterisation of the Appellant as a person whose offending escalated over a comparatively short time. Regard must also be had to the fact the index offences date back to January 2022, the most recent criminality – resulting in the suspended sentence – must logically have been before its imposition in August 2024. Between then and October 2025 (and since release in September this year) no further offending occurred. Not the most central of points but nevertheless one which weighs to an extent in the Appellant’s favour.
68. It may be what the author of the report says – that work or education are key – is correct. Whilst not formally involved in either, the Appellant’s engagement with the Achieve course is partly analogous to having a job or attending educational programmes. The point is the Appellant’s time is being used positively. He behaved similarly through the courses taken in prison. That could demonstrate a willingness and capacity for change.
69. I am therefore, though not without some hesitation, persuaded the Appellant is integrated within society.
70. Within exception one, that leaves the question of very significant obstacles to re-integration. The Appellant’s case on this topic is straightforward. He has not been to the DRC since early childhood, has no family there or knowledge of the country. Reliance is also placed on the evidence of TB, who suggested in court her giving the Appellant a few pounds in ‘pocket money’ was unlikely to be enough to support him if removed from this country.
71. Mr.Scholes accepted in his closing re-integration would be ‘tough.’ He nevertheless asserted the required threshold had not been met. The Respondent points to the Appellant’s relative youth, good health, work history as signs he might be able to re-establish a life in the DRC. The refusal notes a lack of any apparent enquiry as to what life on return might look like. Neither party submits external information on the topic, albeit I bear in mind the Respondent bears no burden here. It was suggested during closing arguments that having lived in a household with his mother means some familiarity with DRC culture may exist. Mr.Scholes noted comment from the Appellant about his ability to speak at least some Lingala. He argued if family in the UK are willing to support the Appellant here, they might also do so from overseas.
72. The Appellant’s skeleton argument contends that re-integration is not just about health or potential ability to find work. Emphasis was placed in court on the absence of any ties in the DRC and length of time spent in the UK.
73. Without engaging in undue speculation, the Appellant could be in a better position than some to find work. That comes via his employment history and qualifications amassed. No health barriers exist nor concern around age. As was said in court, the Appellant is able to speak Lingala to an extent. I do not overstate that, however, given comment from both he and TB that any familiarity with the language is comparatively limited. On the other hand, nor can I be said communication on return would be impossible – even from the point of arrival. Weight is also applied to the Appellant having lived with TB throughout his life. While arguably not the same as going through childhood and beyond within the DRC, it could be what is portrayed as a close relationship between the Appellant and his mother means some knowledge of society there has been passed on.
74. Set against that is the Appellant having arrived to the UK at the age of three. I accept he would likely have no substantive memory of his home country. Nothing is identified which causes me to doubt claims there is an absence of family in the DRC. While equally persuaded any support currently provided would likely continue on removal, at least in financial terms that is quite limited. I make no assumptions about the cost of living in the DRC but as TB per rightly commented ad hoc payments of £10 will only go so far. No clear idea was given in court about the extent of monetary help given by the Appellant’s younger brother. I can, that said, have regard to it being described as sufficient only to cover the cost of getting to probation and immigration appointments. Some limits would therefore seem to exist.
75. I recognise support is not necessarily just about money. Nothing suggests contact with family in the UK would be lost if the Appellant did depart. Quite how much that would assist with re-integration is debatable, however. TB made clear in court she will not return to the DRC. Whether that also applies to the Appellant’s siblings is unknown, though I bear in mind his two sisters at least are either a child or a very young adult. Visiting might therefore be difficult without a parent willing to accompany them. TB described in court struggling to pay her bills. Travel could in any event therefore be out of reach for now.
76. Though length of time away from the DRC is a relevant consideration, it does not have to follow that someone away for a long period faces sufficient obstacles to re-integration. There are a number of factors – health, work history, education – which lend weight to the argument such barriers have not been established. I also give consideration to at least some understanding of Lingala and having grown in a household containing someone who lived in the DRC for what seems likely much of their lives.
77. The last two elements can only carry so much weight. Whilst a partial substitute for lived experience, having a few words of a language and having been told by a parent of a place can only count for so much. Even if better placed than some to find work, other aspects must also be taken into account. As someone who left at the age of three and has been gone for twenty-five years it is difficult to see how the Appellant could be considered to have any substantive insider knowledge of DRC society. That has relevance, given a need to re-establish himself without any direct support. The extent of help from family in the UK would be limited – be it due to financial constraints or simply the distance involved.
78. Taken together, that is enough to satisfy me very significant obstacles to re-integration would arise on return. Exception one is therefore met.
Very Compelling Circumstances
79. Many of the competing factors discussed above are relied on by each party. The refusal cited seriousness of offending, lack of compliance with the suspended sentence. An apparent inability of family to prevent offences from taking place was also noted. Doubt was expressed about claims made of strong community ties. Nothing showed the Appellant’s family are dependent on him. While acknowledging some impact would flow from removal, the refusal argued it was outweighed by the public interest. Ties could be maintained from the DRC.
80. Though the issue was not abandoned by Mr.Timson in court, his primary focus during closing was whether the first exception to deportation could be met. The Appellant’s skeleton concedes a strong public interest exists. It is nevertheless argued the best interests of his siblings lies in the Appellant remaining in the UK. I bear in mind one remains under the age of eighteen, the oldest sister having turned eighteen since the decision letter. My assessment bears in mind that significant, though not determinative, weight should be given to the best interests of a child.
81. It is clear a close relationship exists between the Appellant, his brother and two sisters. As discussed earlier in the determination, each has provided either a letter or statement in support. Mr.Scholes made nothing of the brother’s absence from court nor the two younger siblings. That view may be informed, at least in relation to the sisters, from their being children at the time letters were prepared. Mention is made of the Appellant acting in tandem with TB, helping with school pick-up, homework and meals whilst their mother was at work. That is said to remain the case for the youngest child. Per TB’s evidence in court, the older sister is now at university. That does not have to mean ties with the Appellant have entirely faded. It is nevertheless the case that the sister is to an extent living a life away from her brother. Childcare is no longer needed in that sense.
82. TB spoke in court of having to reduce her working hours while the Appellant was in custody. There was no-one present to help with childcare. There was mention of struggling to pay bills as a result. The Appellant’s younger brother has just started work. It is not suggested he has moved out of the family home. That may indicate greater ability to cover household costs. On the other hand, if the brother is employed and the older sister at university that leaves less scope for the youngest child to be cared for outside of school hours. TB noted she had to leave the child with neighbours in the Appellant’s absence. Not perhaps an ideal situation, though nor does that mean any risk arises as a result. It was not claimed the neighbour is about to withdraw their help. TB said she had asked to return to full-time hours. Without assuming anything, that may mean family finances are about to improve further. At least some childcare provision exists.
83. The Appellant’s father was said via the OASys report to be in another country. No contact takes place. That has not been disputed. The picture painted is one whereby TB and her children came to the UK as a result of adversity in the DRC. What that involved has not been explained, though as TB observed in court she will not return to her country of origin. It is possible those events created a stronger bond between the Appellant and his immediate family. That has some value. TB and each of the siblings attest to that in their respective statements and letters.
84. It is nonetheless correct to note one of the siblings was an adult at the time of the decision letter. As now is the oldest sister. In terms of them and TB, something beyond normal emotional ties between an adult and their mother, brother or sister would have to be shown. Things in that sense are mixed in my view. I recognise that shared hardship (coming to the UK for protection) could lead to a closer than normal bond to exist. There was no real exploration in court around the level of contact maintained whilst the Appellant was in custody, though the statements and letters talk about calls taking place. I recognise even though he was absent for some months, a difference exists between being in prison within the same country as family for a limited time and removal on a long-term basis to the DRC. That perhaps reduces the strength of any argument about communication from overseas as a substitute for absence (though I accept the point retains some force.) I recognise from TB’s comments in court she will not travel to the DRC. That was not challenged.
85. TB and each sibling speak well of the Appellant. That is perhaps to be expected in any positive family environment. I accept upset would flow from deportation. It does relatively little to establish the existence of very compelling circumstances, however. Emotional damage is an inevitable part of many removals. Balanced against that is a suggestion the Appellant played and, again, now plays an important role for his siblings. TB in her statement describes him as her other hand. There may be some value in that, given reference to filling gaps TB found more difficult to due to her work commitments. Mention is made of other family members in the UK. Per TB’s account in court, her brother lives in Manchester though not close-by. Other relatives are in London. Those factors may mean less ability to assist, be it in terms of emotional support or otherwise if the Appellant departed. It cannot, however, be said that TB and her other children would be alone in the Appellant’s absence. Any reliance on him would likely be less, given two siblings are now adults.
86. The best interests of the Appellant’s sister clearly lie in her remaining at home with TB. There is no suggestion his leaving the UK would change that – be it in terms of school, accommodation or any other factor. The youngest child will be with close family as before, in what appears a safe and stable environment. It could be said the Appellant plays an important part in that. Even so, equally apparent is the family were able to maintain themselves during the sentence served.
87. Nothing suggests the family are financially dependent on the Appellant, though that is only one factor among several. As set out above, given TB and the younger brother are in work it could be any struggles previously faced in that sense are now reduced. TB may be about to return to full-time work, though I do not assume that will be the case. Notwithstanding challenges TB faced in paying bills due to reduced hours, there is no claim without the Appellant she and her other children faced destitution while the Appellant was in custody. Even before then, given what seems a relatively limited work history and periods of either benefits or no income at all any financial contribution to the family unit would likely have been constrained.
88. I remind myself for the high threshold required to be met, something beyond that contained within either exception must be shown to arise. Relying only on the elements found to constitute exception two would not be enough. The Appellant is not currently in work. Removal would not lead to loss of employment.
89. What remains is impact on the Appellant’s family. I accept the Appellant is well-loved by TB and his siblings. Given their history together and the help he provided to TB in caring for his brother and sisters, the depth of emotional ties may have gone further than that typical. No reason is presented to reject claims the Appellant played a part whereby TB’s ability to work became greater. The overall family unit benefitted as a result. By way of balance, even by the time of the decision letter, things had moved on ; more so by the present. One sibling is in work, another at university. Both are adults. The youngest had what seems adequate care from a neighbour. Household finances may be more positive ; they are not dependent on the Appellant’s presence.
90. All of that means whilst no doubt the Appellant’s absence would be felt – perhaps more keenly in comparison to some family units – it does not reach the high level very compelling circumstances requires. The balancing public interest is substantial. Any positive features whilst taken into account are not enough.
91. The appeal is nevertheless allowed on the basis of exception one.
NOTICE OF DECISION
The appeal is allowed, to the extent set out.
TO THE RESPONDENT
FEE AWARD
Given what might be considered a mixed outcome, no fee award is made. The appeal was
arguable on both sides.
Signed Date 8th November, 2026
FTTJ JEPSON
First-tier Tribunal Judge Jepson
Notes
[1] Though, as discussed later in the determination that part of the account was recanted in court.
Our immigration lawyer in Paris assists clients in matters of this kind.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).