Administrative United Kingdom
KA v The Secretary of State for the Home Department
First-tier Tribunal
(Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Appeal Number: PA/81998/2025
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
Heard at Manchester
On 4 November 2026
Before
JUDGE OF THE FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL C R COLE
Between
KA
(anonymity direction made)
Appellant
and
the secretary of state for the home department
Respondent
Representation:
For the appellant: Mr A Islam, Counsel instructed by Burton & Burton Solicitors
For the respondent: Ms N Keegan, Home Office Presenting Officer
DECISION AND REASONS
Anonymity Direction
1. I have decided to make an anonymity direction because in this specific case the importance of facilitating the discharge of the obligations of the United Kingdom under the Refugee Convention in the circumstances of this case outweighs the principle of open justice.
Introduction
2. The appellant was born in 2004. He is a national of Somalia.
3. The appellant arrived in the UK on 16 April 2025 and claimed asylum.
4. By decision dated 11 July 2025 the respondent refused the appellant’s Protection Claim and Human Rights Claim.
5. The appellant appeals against the respondent’s decision pursuant to section 82(1) of the Nationality, Immigration & Asylum Act 2002.
Issues
6. At the outset of the hearing, I clarified with the parties the issues to be resolved in this appeal.
7. None of the appellant’s account is accepted. Thus, the credibility of the appellant’s account is the key material issue for resolution.
8. The respondent stated that “There would not be sufficient protection from persecution in Somalia (Section 34 NABA) and you could not relocate within your home country (Section 35 NABA) if the key material facts of your claim were accepted…”
9. Thus, it was agreed that the sole issue for resolution is whether the appellant’s account of events in Somalia is credible.
Documents
10. The respondent provided a bundle of 64 pages with Annexes A to D, including Screening Interview (SI), Asylum Interview Record (AIR), and the Reasons for Refusal Letter (RFRL) dated 11 July 2025. The respondent also provided a Review.
11. The appellant provided a bundle of 19 pages which included the appellant’s witness statement, and Country Information Evidence Schedule. The appellant also provided an Appeal Skeleton Argument (ASA).
The Hearing
12. The appellant adopted his witness statement and gave evidence in Somali.
13. The full details of the evidence and the submissions are contained in the Record of Proceedings which is within the court file. I have taken them into consideration in determining this matter. Consequently, I will not rehearse the evidence and submissions except where it is relevant to my findings.
14. After hearing the evidence and submissions, I reserved my decision.
Findings and Reasons
15. I have considered all the evidence, paying regard to the matters to which I was specifically referred, but only summarised those matters that have been of most assistance to me and which relate to the issues for me to determine.
16. The credibility of the appellant’s account is the key issue for me to determine.
17. The appellant’s asylum claim was made after the coming into force of sections 30 to 38 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022. Thus, section 32 applies to the assessment of the relevant factual matters relied upon by the appellant. Those matters fall to be determined on the balance of probabilities. However, the assessment of future risk remains subject to the applicable lower standard. It must be noted that the lower standard of proof still applies to any Humanitarian Protection/Article 3 claim.
18. Under section 8 of the Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc.) Act 2004 I am obliged to consider certain behaviour as affecting an appellant’s credibility. I accept that the appellant travelled via France. The appellant did not claim asylum in France. The appellant’s account for not claiming asylum in France is not objectively reasonable. He did have the opportunity to claim asylum in a safe country.
19. Thus, this matter does undermine the appellant’s credibility to a limited extent. However, I must still assess the merits of the appellant’s protection claim considering all the evidence and applying the relevant standard of proof, whilst having regard to the appellant’s reduced credibility.
20. I have carefully considered the appellant’s account as provided across the SI, AIR, witness statement and oral evidence. In my judgment the appellant has provided sufficiently consistent and detailed evidence regarding the core facts of his account. I find that the core of appellant’s account can be accepted to the civil standard of proof.
21. The appellant’s account is that he is from Sabiid in Lower Shabelle and that he is a member of the Digil clan. The appellant was approached by Al Shabab members in April 2022. He was warned not to work as a barber and then he was told that he would have to join Al Shabab as a fighter. He was told that he must join them or they would kill him. The appellant was scared and so his mother arranged for him to go to Mogadishu to live with his uncle.
22. In Mogadishu the appellant lived with his uncle and worked at his uncle’s tailor shop. Whilst working at the shop, he met and started a relationship with a female customer. They fell in love and married in July 2022. The appellant’s wife became pregnant, and she then told her mother about the marriage.
23. The appellant’s wife’s family were from the Hawiye clan. They did not approve of the relationship. Toward the end of September 2022, the appellant was attacked in the tailor shop by his wife’s brothers. The appellant then went into hiding and then left Somalia at the beginning of November 2022.
24. The appellant eventually got to Belgium where he stayed for over two years pursuing an asylum claim that was refused. He then travelled to the UK.
25. I have carefully considered the credibility issues raised in the RFRL, Review and by Ms Keegan in her submissions. I find that the matters raised are not sufficient to fundamentally undermine the core of the appellant’s account.
26. As internal relocation within Somalia is conceded by the respondent not to be safe or reasonable, then the key aspect of the appellant’s account is events in the appellant’s home area. I find that the appellant’s claim to have been targeted by Al Shabab in his hometown is sufficiently detailed and consistent. I also find that his account is supported by the country information.
27. The respondent relied upon her Country Policy and Information Note, Somalia – Mogadishu: Al Shabab and the security situation, Version: 2.0, June 2025 (CPIN). This has a specific section on recruitment. This confirms that forced recruitment by Al Shabab does occur, often involving young men recruited as fighters.
28. In my judgment this supports the appellant’s account of being approached by Al Shabab in his hometown and then being threatened with forced recruitment.
29. Whilst the background evidence is incapable of establishing that these events happened to this particular appellant, it is capable of demonstrating that his account is consistent with known conditions in Somalia. I therefore treat the country evidence as supporting the plausibility of the appellant's account, whilst recognising that the ultimate issue remains whether his own evidence is credible.
30. The only challenge to this aspect of the account in the RFRL lacks substance. The respondent stated that it was inconsistent when the appellant stated that he knew the men who approached him were from Al Shabab as he lived in a small town where everyone knew each other. The respondent’s submission is that Lower Shabelle has a population of 1.3 million implying that the appellant could not know everyone. This ignores the fact that the appellant was clearly referring to his town of Sabiid, and not to the whole region of Lower Shabelle.
31. Furthermore, the appellant in the AIR stated that the men who approached him actually told him that they were from Al Shabab; the small town so everyone knew everyone point was only his secondary reason for knowing the men were from Al Shabab.
32. In the Review the respondent submits that the appellant’s account of the threat of forcible recruitment should be rejected as the appellant “completely failed to mention this within his screening interview.”
33. In the SI the appellant’s initial assertion is that “The Al-Shabab want to kill me.” The recorded account then moves to the appellant’s problems with the family of his wife. There is some conflation of the issues as Al Shabab get referenced in the brief reference to getting his wife pregnant and this seems to add confusion. I note that there is no reference to the threat of forced recruitment.
34. However, the SI is a short interview conducted in detention shortly after arrival in the UK. Its purpose is to gather basic identity and travel details and a brief overview of the asylum claim. The appellant referred to Al Shabab wanting to kill him. He provided full details in the AIR.
35. Overall, I do not accept that the failure to specifically refer to forced recruitment in the SI is a matter which significantly undermines the appellant’s overall account.
36. Ms Keegan relied mainly on the argument that it was not plausible that the appellant would be targeted by Al Shabab and relied on up the CPIN. As detailed above, I find that the CPIN supports rather than undermines the appellant’s account of being at risk of forced recruitment by Al Shabab.
37. Therefore, I find that, on balance, the appellant was subjected to threats of forced recruitment by Al Shabab in his hometown of Sabiid.
38. The appellant then fled to Mogadishu where the second phase of his account takes place.
39. I acknowledge that there was some confusion and potential inconsistency regarding the appellant’s evidence about being in hiding with his uncle in Mogadishu, working at his uncle’s shop, and meeting his wife. However, in my judgment the appellant has provided a full and detailed explanation of all the various aspects of his account.
40. The appellant detailed how his uncle’s shop was effectively attached to his uncle’s house and so there was no travelling around. He detailed how he mainly worked in the back of the shop and not in the front with the customers. I find that this is a reasonable explanation of the appellant’s claim to have been in hiding.
41. The appellant has explained how his wife was a customer of his uncle’s shop and how he was able to see her from his section in the back of the shop. He explained how if someone from Al Shabab came into the shop, they would not see him in the back room straight away and this meant he could escape. I find that this is a reasonable account with sufficient detail of the situation.
42. The appellant’s account of how the relationship developed into a secret marriage so swiftly does lack detail. However, the appellant was never really pressed on this point and never asked to provide more detail.
43. I note that there are inconsistent answers recorded about when the appellant met his wife, but these were swiftly corrected with the appellant explaining that the July 2022 date was when they married. I do not find this is a matter which undermines the appellant’s credibility.
44. The respondent disputes that the appellant’s wife’s family would disapprove of the marriage as their clan (Hawiye) and the appellant’s clan (Digil) are major clans in Somalia.
45. The appellant has provided a detailed explanation about his wife’s family viewing his clan as lesser and about them viewing his job as beneath them. I find this a plausible and reasonable explanation.
46. The evidence provided by the respondent via a footnote to the RFRL details that the Digil “are found primarily in the Lower Jubba Valley of central Somalia, between the Shabeelle and Jubba Rivers and south of the Jubba River.” The Digil make up just 3% of Somali population.
47. The Hawiye are the largest clan in Somalia and make up 25% of the population. The evidence provided details that “Major Hawiye cities include the capital of Somalia, Mogadishu…”
48. Thus, I find that the evidence supports the appellant’s contention that his wife’s family would view the appellant as from a lesser clan and undertaking work that was beneath them. I accept his evidence that his wife’s family rejected the marriage and wished to kill the appellant because of his marriage.
49. The respondent then submitted that it was implausible that the appellant could remain in Mogadishu for two months and leave on his own passport if his wife’s family had the power and influence claimed.
50. It is possible that the appellant’s claim about his wife’s father being a high-ranking police officer and her brother being in the intelligence service is mere embellishment in an attempt to bolster his claim. However, even if this were the situation, this does not necessarily undermine the credibility of the rest of his account.
51. I also note that members of the security forces should not be assumed to be able and willing to abuse their professional position to further personal aims.
52. Thus, considering this matter holistically, I find that the appellant was able to hide for around two months and then leave Somalia on his own passport. There are various possible reasons for this as detailed above, but I do not accept that these matters undermine the overall credibility of the appellant’s claim.
53. I have also considered whether the various discrepancies and concerns identified by the respondent, when viewed cumulatively rather than individually, are sufficient to undermine the credibility of the claim. Having done so, I conclude that they are not. Whilst there are imperfections within the appellant's evidence, I do not find them sufficient to outweigh the generally detailed and consistent nature of his account regarding the core events relied upon.
54. Drawing all the threads together and considering all the evidence in the round, I find that the appellant has been able to demonstrate to the balance of probabilities that his account of events in Somalia is correct. I find that the appellant has provided a sufficiently detailed and consistent account which is supported by the background evidence. I find that the appellant has provided reasonable responses to the issues raised by the respondent.
55. The respondent expressly accepted within the RFRL that if the material facts relied upon by the appellant were accepted, neither sufficiency of protection nor internal relocation would be available. Having accepted those material facts, there is no remaining dispute on those issues.
56. Therefore, I find that the appellant has demonstrated that the core of his account of events in Somalia is true to the civil standard of proof.
57. Thus, I conclude that the appellant does have a well-founded fear of persecution in Somalia for a Refugee Convention reason.
58. Having accepted the appellant's account on the balance of probabilities, I am necessarily satisfied that the same facts meet the lower standard applicable to future risk. I find there is at least a reasonable degree of likelihood that the appellant would again come to the attention of both Al Shabab and his wife's family were he returned to Somalia.
59. Thus, I also find that his removal to Somalia would give rise to a real risk of treatment contrary to Article 3 ECHR.
Notice of Decision
The appeal is allowed on asylum and human rights grounds.
Order regarding anonymity
Unless and until the Tribunal, the Upper Tribunal, or, a Court orders otherwise, pursuant to rule 13(1)(b) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Rules 2014, the appellant is granted anonymity.
No-one shall publish or reveal either directly or indirectly any information, including his name or address, that is likely to lead members of the public to identify him. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.
Signed C R Cole Date 9 November 2026
Judge C R Cole
Judge of the First-tier Tribunal
TO THE RESPONDENT
FEE AWARD
No fee is paid or payable and therefore there can be no fee award.
Signed C R Cole Date 9 November 2026
Judge C R Cole
Judge of the First-tier Tribunal
At Kohen Avocats, our immigration lawyer in Paris can review your situation.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).