Property United Kingdom
Lucy Formela-Osborne (Valuation Officer) v Tungsten West Plc
Neutral Citation Number: [2026] UKUT425 (LC)
LC-2025-191
IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL (LANDS CHAMBER)
ON APPEAL FROM THE VALUATION TRIBUNAL FOR ENGLAND
Royal Courts of Justice, Strand,
London WC2A 2LL
4 November 2026
TRIBUNALS, COURTS AND ENFORCEMENT ACT 2007
RATING – HEREDITAMENT – tungsten mine – proposals to delete from 2017 rating list – disclaimer of Environment Agency permits – disconnection of power supply – capability of beneficial occupation – repair assumption – whether defective non-rateable plant relevant to rateability – para 2, Sch 6, Local Government Finance Act 1988 – appeal allowed, cross appeal dismissed
BETWEEN:
LUCY FORMELA-OSBORNE
(VaLUATION OFFICER)
Appellant
-and-
TUNGSTEN WEST PLC
Respondent
Hemerdon Mine,
Hemerdon, Plymouth
Martin Rodger KC, Deputy Chamber President
and Mr Mark Higgin FRICS FIRRV
25 – 26 August 2026
Mr Paul Reynolds, instructed by HMRC Legal Group, for the appellant
Mr Luke Wilcox, on licensed access, for the respondent
© CROWN COPYRIGHT 2026
The following cases are referred to in this decision:
Arbuckle Smith & Co Ltd v Greenock Corporation [1960] AC 813
BNPPDS(J) Ltd & Anor v Hitchings (VO) [2025] UKUT 104 (LC)
British Telecommunications v Kennet District Council [1982] RA 161
Carey Group PLC v Ricketts (VO) [2024] UKUT 356 (LC)
Dawkins v Ash Bros and Heaton Ltd [1969] 2 AC 366
Jackson (VO) v Canary Wharf Ltd [2019] UKUT 136 (LC)
John Laing & Son Ltd v Kingswood Assessment Committee [1949] 1 KB 344
Porter (VO) v Trustees of Gladman SIPPS [2011] UKUT 204 (LC), [2011] RA 337
Post Officev Nottingham CC [1976] 1 WLR 624
R v Makro Properties Ltd v Nuneaton & Bedworth Borough Council [2012] EWHC 2250 (Admin), [2012] RA 285
Ravenseft Pties Ltd v Newham LBC [1975] RA 410
Ricketts (VO) v Cyxtera Technology UK Limited [2021] UKUT 265 (LC)
Sainsbury's Supermarkets Ltd v Sykes (VO) [2017] UKUT 138 (LC)
Sunderland City Council v Stirling Investment Pties LLP [2013] EWHC 1413, [2013] RA 411
Williams (VO) v Scottish & Newcastle Retail Ltd [2001] EWCA Civ 185, [2001] RA 41
Introduction
1. When Environment Agency permits for the operation of an open cast tungsten mine were disclaimed and the electricity supply necessary for the mine’s operation was disconnected did the mine become incapable of beneficial occupation and liable to be deleted from the rating list? The Valuation Tribunal for England (‘the VTE’) answered that question affirmatively in a decision handed down on 1 May 2025. Consequently, the VTE directed that the Hemerdon Mine near Plymouth (‘the Mine’), which had appeared in the 2017 rating list with a rateable value of £477,000, should be deleted from the list between 17 July 2019 and 30 November 2022.
2. The issue in this appeal by the valuation officer (‘the VO’) and cross-appeal by the ratepayer, Tungsten West plc, is whether the VTE’s conclusion that the Mine had ceased to be rateable and had remained so only for the period specified was correct.
3. The VO challenges the VTE’s conclusion on two grounds. Her primary case is that the Mine was beneficially occupied throughout the period the VTE directed it to be deleted from the list.
4. The VO’s alternative case, to which the bulk of the argument was directed, is that neither the absence of mains electricity nor the lack of a mineral processing permit rendered the Mine incapable of beneficial occupation so as to justify its deletion from the list.
5. Although Tungsten West succeeded below, it also challenges the VTE’s decision on two grounds. First, it says that the VTE was wrong to limit the deletion of the Mine and to reinstate it after 30 November 2022 when power was restored. It argues that the power which was available to the Mine from 1 December 2022 was not sufficient to enable it to be beneficially occupied for its intended purpose (as opposed to being used for acts preparatory to that purpose).
6. Secondly, Tungsten West argues that the Mine was in any event incapable of beneficial occupation from 22 March 2019, because no operator could have acquired the environmental permit necessary for the lawful operation of the Mine in its physical condition at that time.
7. At the hearing the VO was represented by Mr Paul Reynolds. Tungsten West was represented by Mr Luke Wilcox who called Mr Damian Andrews, Acting Plant Manager at the Mine as a witness of fact. We are grateful to them all.
The Mine
8. The Mine is about 0.6 miles north of the small village of Hemerdon, and 5.5 miles north-east of Plymouth city centre. It is an open cast operation covering an area of about 250 hectares (618 acres) comprising an open pit, a mineral processing facility (or ‘MPF’), offices, open storage areas for product and waste materials, and ponds to collect and process tailings arising from the MPF. An annotated aerial photograph of the mine in its current configuration follows.
9. The mineral processing facility is housed in a large building to which the newly mined ore is transported in 750 mm square blocks. There it is fed through primary, secondary and tertiary crushers and separated into two fractions by processes which Mr Andrews described as similar to panning for gold. A fine ore fraction (comprising particles of less than 0.8 mm) is mixed with water to form a slurry, which is processed through a series of spirals, shaking tables, and centrifugal concentrators to separate mineral particles containing tungsten and tin from lighter waste material. A coarse ore fraction (greater than 0.8 mm) is mixed with magnetite or ferrosilicon and processed in a similar way. In both cases waste material is pumped to the tailings storage facility while the concentrated minerals are collected for further processing to remove impurities such as arsenic, iron and silica and to separate the magnetic tungsten concentrate from the non-magnetic tin materials. The resulting tungsten and tin concentrates are collected, drummed, and sold. Some of the waste produced is also capable of being sold as aggregate for use in road building and the like.
10. The deposit at Hemerdon is the only tungsten mine in the United Kingdom and the third largest tungsten deposit globally. It was discovered in 1915, and the Mine was briefly operated in the inter war period when domestic tungsten production was regarded as a strategic national interest. Investigations into the viability of restarting tungsten mining began in the late 1970’s and a feasibility study carried out at that time indicated an ore reserve of 20 million tonnes. Planning permission was granted in 1986 but a global collapse in metal prices prevented viable extraction.
11. In 2007 Wolf Minerals (‘Wolf’) acquired the rights to mine tungsten and tin at the Mine. A positive feasibility study eventually enabled it to obtain finance to start construction of the necessary facilities. In March 2014 the Mine was energised with mains electrical power at a capacity of 6.5 megavolt amperes (‘MVA’) and in June 2015 Wolf started extraction and processing.
12. Wolf’s operations suffered a series of technical difficulties largely related to the design of the mineral processing facility. In his evidence Mr Andrews explained that Wolf’s design was based on analysis of granite samples taken at a depth of approximately 70 metres below the surface of the Mine. These samples were from fresh hard granite which was not representative of the well weathered material which comprises the top 40 metres of the ore deposit available for open cast extraction. Wolf’s analysis of the deposit relied on these unrepresentative samples and consequently the MPF was poorly designed, and its roller crushers reduced the tungsten bearing minerals to a size that led to low recovery rates. Design issues also afflicted the substantial screens used for sizing finely crushed stone, the largest ever made by the manufacturer, and these would often crack when operating under load. Frequent breakdowns and damage necessitated repairs and replacement of significant parts and led to extended periods when the MPF could not operate. The plant achieved a run time of approximately 50% compared to the design target of 90%.
13. Coupled with commercial issues, these design deficiencies contributed to Wolf’s operations becoming unviable and on 10 October 2018 the company entered voluntary administration followed a week later by compulsory liquidation. The former mining contractor, Hargreaves Services plc (‘Hargreaves’), then bought the assets of the company out of receivership on the understanding that it would endeavour to sell them on to a mine operator with the consent of the secured lenders. On 19 March 2019 certain of Wolf’s assets (including the Mine) were transferred to a new company, Drakelands Restoration Ltd (‘Drakelands’), ownership of which remained with Hargreaves. These were then acquired by Tungsten West on 29 November 2019.
Environmental licensing
14. Part of Tungsten West’s case is that the mineral processing facility, which it regards as essential to the beneficial occupation of the Mine, cannot lawfully be operated in its existing condition, and that very substantial expenditure would be required before processing could resume.
15. A number of activities necessary for the operation of a tungsten mine are regulated by the Environment Agency (‘EA’). These include the abstraction of water, the management of waste material and the operation of the mineral processing facility. Mr Andrews explained that the necessary permits imposed legal and reporting obligations which were regarded as onerous when the Mine was not functioning. On 22 March 2019 the Official Receiver, acting as liquidator of Wolf, disclaimed six environmental permits including those for the waste facility and the MPF, and surrendered water abstraction licences.
16. In December 2017, following an investigation prompted by concerns raised by local residents about significant low frequency noise created by Wolf’s operations, the EA concluded that noise abatement measures were necessary to address breaches of the mineral processing permit. The source of the problem was eventually traced to the large screens used to grade and separate the ore which functioned at frequencies in the range 15-16 Hz. Interference between these screens generated a ‘beating’ effect which adversely impacted local communities.
17. When Tungsten West acquired the Mine it did not recommence mineral processing. It was warned by the Environment Agency that further measures needed to be implemented at the mineral processing facility to reduce the emission of low frequency noise. Wolf had initially proposed cladding the MPF building and this approach had been endorsed by the Environment Agency but was later rejected by Tungsten West as unlikely to be effective. Tungsten West’s preferred solution is to mitigate the noise at or close to its source as part of substantial alterations to the process plant. A number of techniques are proposed, including replacing some of the screens and sheltering others in acoustic enclosures. None of these modifications has yet been implemented, pending the securing of the funds required to restart mining operations.
18. Tungsten West applied to the Environment Agency for the necessary licences to operate the mineral processing facility in August 2021 and on 10 June 2024 a new permit was granted. The permit is conditional on the implementation of Tungsten West’s noise mitigation proposals. For the time being therefore minerals cannot lawfully be processed at the Mine, as has been the case since at least 22 March 2019 when the previous permits were surrendered.
Electricity supply
19. The operation of the Mine requires a supply of mains electricity. Two features of that supply are relevant to the appeal.
20. First, the operation of the mineral processing facility requires a high voltage mains supply. That supply is controlled through a substation in the separate occupation of the power supply company, Western Power Distribution. Although the substation is within the boundaries of the Mine, by reason of its separate occupation, it is not part of the same hereditament.
21. Secondly, the water essential to the mineral processing operation is pumped to the Mine from two sources located beyond its boundaries at Tory Pond and Loughtor Mill. The low voltage electricity required to power the pumps is obtained from the local network through cables. None of the water sources, the pumps or the cables form part of the hereditament. An additional waste seepage pump at Lee Moor is required to operate the mineral waste facility which is part of the hereditament.
22. While Wolf controlled the Mine it had access to a supply of 6.5MVA although it typically operated at 4 to 4.5 MVA. After production ceased, Drakelands asked Western Power to disconnect the main power supply to the site. Western Power duly obliged on 17 July 2019 by tripping breakers in the primary substation and locking them in the off position. This supply appears not immediately to have been reallocated to other customers, but the evidence suggests it was taken by November 2019. While the mains supply to the Mine remained disconnected, the mineral processing facility could not operate.
23. The low voltage supply to the water pumps was also disconnected in July 2019, although the precise date is not known. The supplies to the mineral waste facility, and at Tory Pond and Loughtor Mill, were severed by physically cutting the cables at the pump houses. These connections provided raw water to the processing plant and controlled the flow of wastewater. Without a raw water supply the mineral processing facility could not operate.
24. In April 2020 Tungsten West applied to Western Power to restore mains electrical power to the Mine with a maximum capacity of 2.5MVA. It expected this requirement to increase and in October 2020 Western Power confirmed that a 6.5MVA connection was reserved for the use of Tungsten West although the supply was initially limited to 2.5MVA. The connection agreement signed by Tungsen West in November 2020 Tungsten West provided for the first stage only and three months later, in March 2021, Western Power reconnected and energised the Mine to a mains power capacity of 2.5MVA. A variation of this agreement, signed in June 2022 increased the supply to 6.5MVA with effect from 1 December 2022.
Operations by Tungsten West at the Mine
25. The VO’s primary case is that the Mine was in beneficial occupation throughout the currency of the 2017 rating list. The evidence shows that after Tungsten West acquired control of the Mine through its acquisition of Drakelands in November 2019 it was in occupation and engaged in activities related to the resumption of mining. Whether those activities amounted in law to the beneficial occupation of the Mine for rating purposes is in dispute.
26. It is clear that at a relatively early stage Tungsten West began to dispose of a stockpile of aggregates which was present on the site. It established a wholly owned subsidiary, Aggregates West Ltd (‘AWL’), for the disposal of aggregates produced as a byproduct of tungsten mining. In July 2021 it notified the VO that AWL had been formed to develop, produce and sell products from mining waste. AWL undertook certification for various aggregate products during December 2020 and started selling small quantities of aggregates from January 2021, disposing of 14,243 tonnes by 30 June 2021. This represented only a small portion of the total stockpiled at the Mine, which in September 2021 was said to comprise 700,000 tonnes of aggregates. Stockpiles of graded aggregate considered to be ‘ready for sale’ were also observed by Mr Teagle of the VOA during an inspection in November 2022. In a review of the aggregates market prepared by Tungsten West in July 2023 it recorded that between February 2021 and September 2022 AWL had sold 102,000 tonnes of a wide variety of materials derived from the Mine with peak sales in November and December 2021.
27. During his November 2022 inspection Mr Teagle also noted stockpiles of already-won tungsten in approximately 200 white bulk bags (similar to those used by builders to deposit sand on a building site) which he understood contained ammonium paratungstate ore produced by the previous operator. The white bags of ore had gone by the time Mr Teagle made a later inspection on 25 March 2025.
28. At the time of his first inspection Mr Teagle also noted the presence of a security building, an office building, a laboratory and a car park. Mr Andrews confirmed to us that at the material days the laboratory was in the occupation of a third party under contract to Tungsten West as part of its effort to better understand the potential of the Mine and prove its commercial viability.
29. It is also clear from the evidence that active mining and processing of minerals did not resume after Wolf ceased operations and with limited exceptions the Mine entered what was referred to as a care and maintenance phase. It is impractical to transport unprocessed ore over significant distances and until the required modifications to the mineral processing facility are undertaken processing on site is not permissible within the current licence. Those modifications will be expensive, an estimated cost of $93 million was mentioned as the cost of reopening the Mine for production, and Tungsten West’s current activities are mainly directed towards securing the required funds. To attract investors it has sought to demonstrate the viability and potential of the Mine through research and the marketing of material left over from Wolf’s period of occupation.
The proposals
30. The appeal arises from two proposals submitted on 21 April 2023 and 26 September 2023, both of which proposed deletion of the Mine from the 2017 rating list (or reduction of the assessment from £477,500 to a nominal figure of £1). The earlier proposal relied on the termination of the high voltage power supply to the Mine, which occurred on 17 July 2019, and the severance of the low voltage power supply to the auxiliary pumps which supplied water to the Mine, which was said to have occurred by the end of July 2019. The later proposal also sought deletion and relied additionally on the disclaimer by the Official Receiver of the permits required to operate the Mine on 22 March 2019. The effective date suggested in both proposals was 30 November 2019, the day after Tungsten West acquired its interest in the Mine.
31. The VTE was satisfied that the Mine had been incapable of beneficial occupation from 17 July 2019 to 30 November 2022 and determined that its entry should be deleted from the list between those dates. The period of deletion commenced with the termination of the high voltage power supply and resumed when the supply was fully restored. The VTE did not think that the absence of Environment Agency permits was a relevant consideration, nor did it think that the reconnection of a limited power supply in March 2022 was sufficient to enable the Mine to be beneficially occupied.
The legal framework
32. Section 41 of the Local Government Finance Act 1988 (‘the 1988 Act”) requires the Valuation Officer for a billing authority to compile and maintain a local non-domestic rating list for the authority’s area. The units of assessment shown in the list are referred to as hereditaments, and by section 42 the rating list must show each relevant non-domestic hereditament.
33. Non-domestic rates are payable by the person who is in occupation of all or part of a hereditament (section 43(1), 1988 Act). Whether a hereditament is occupied, and who is the occupier, is determined by applying principles developed before the passing of the General Rate Act 1967 (section 65(2), 1988 Act).
34. The ingredients of rateable occupation were identified by Tucker LJ in John Laing & Son Ltd v Kingswood Assessment Committee [1949] 1 KB 344, 350 :
“there are four necessary ingredients in rateable occupation … First, there must be actual occupation; secondly, that it must be exclusive for the particular purposes of the possessor; thirdly, that the possession must be of some value or benefit to the possessor; and, fourthly, the possession must not be for too transient a period.”
35. In this case the parties agree that on the material days (22 March 2019 and 17 July 2019) and thereafter three of these ingredients were present: there was actual occupation by Wolf and then by Drakelands and Tungsten West; that occupation was exclusive; and it was not too transient. The parties frame the critical issue in the appeal as whether the possession was, or was capable of being, of value or benefit to the possessor. There is some overlap between the concepts of actual occupation and possession which is of value or benefit and the authorities do not always divide the issue of rateable occupation into neat compartments. The question might be framed in more general terms as whether on the material days the Mine was in rateable occupation.
36. We were referred to a number of authorities on what amounted to beneficial occupation, or the capacity for beneficial occupation.
37. For the VO, Mr Reynolds cited cases which supported the proposition that provided there is actual occupation of the hereditament, and that occupation is exclusive, it does not matter that the hereditament may not be used by the occupier to the full. Thus, in R v Makro Properties Ltd v Nuneaton & Bedworth Borough Council [2012] RA 285 the tenant of a retail warehouse made no use of it other than for the storage of 60 pallets of business paperwork, which it was required by law to retain. This was found to constitute beneficial occupation. Similarly, in Sunderland City Council v Stirling Investment Pties LLP [2013] EWHC 1413 Wilkie J found that the placing of a small blue tooth transmitter in a warehouse and its use to transmit advertising messages amounted to beneficial occupation. The use was beneficial to the occupier although only a small physical presence was necessary due to the nature of its business. It was said not to be relevant that the nature of the use to which the occupier put the hereditament was different from the mode or category of occupation described in the rating list.
38. For Tungsten West, Mr Wilcox did not dispute the principle that slight beneficial occupation could be sufficient, but he pointed out that the cases which illustrated that principle were concerned with liability to pay the rate, and not with the prior question whether the hereditament was properly included in the rating list at all. In none of the minimal occupation cases was there any doubt about the condition of the premises themselves or their capacity for occupation for their intended purpose.
39. Mr Wilcox relied on other cases to demonstrate that unless premises are capable of beneficial occupation, they are not a hereditament. In Porter (VO) v GladmanSIPPS [2011] UKUT (LC) 204 premises which were intended for use as offices but which were not yet complete (lacking small power, partitioning, air conditioning and tenant’s fitting out) were entered in the list without previous service of a completion notice. The VO accepted, at [20], that the relevant question was whether the building was practically complete and ready for occupation for the purpose for which it was intended; if it was not, it could not be described as a hereditament and could not be entered in the rating list. Applying that test, the VO considered that the premises were complete. This Tribunal (George Bartlett QC, President and NJ Rose FRICS) agreed with the VO’s formulation of the question but not with his answer. At [66], the Tribunal summarised the effect of the relevant authorities including, in particular the decision of the Court of Appeal in Ravenseft Pties Ltd v Newham LBC [1975] RA 410:
“A building is only a hereditament if it is ready for occupation, and whether it is ready for occupation is to be assessed in the light of the purpose for which it is designed to be occupied. If the building lacks features which will have to be provided before it can be occupied for that purpose and when provided will form part of the occupied hereditament and form the basis of its valuation it does not constitute a hereditament and so does not fall to be shown in the rating list.”
40. An important distinction is drawn in this context between completion of the building and the installation of equipment and furniture required for the purpose for which it is intended. In Arbuckle Smith & Co Ltd v Greenock Corpn [1960] AC 813, the appellant acquired premises intending to use them as a bonded warehouse. The approval of Customs and Excise was required for that use and was available only on condition that certain alterations should be carried out to the premises to render them secure (such as bricking up window openings and installing bars). The House of Lords held that the appellant had not been in rateable occupation while the works were being undertaken and that occupation for the purpose of improving the premises did not amount to actual use. At page 824, when considering the meaning of rateable occupation Lord Reid said:
“But I can see a clear distinction between maintaining, repairing or improving a fabric, on the one hand, and enjoying the accommodation which it provides, on the other. And I think that it would accord with the ordinary use of language to say that the owner who in some way enjoys the accommodation is occupying the premises, but that the owner who merely maintains, repairs or improves his premises is not thereby occupying them: he is preparing for future occupation by himself, his tenant or his disponee.”
41. Post Office v Nottingham City Council [1976] 1 WLR 624 was a case on the same side of the line which concerned a purpose-built telephone exchange. The Court of Appeal found that it was not yet capable of beneficial occupation because it lacked electrical wiring and a transformer. The absence of a ventilation system would also have prevented beneficial occupation for its intended purpose, but the absence of kitchen equipment and of the telephone equipment itself did not. Browne LJ regarded the distinction as a matter of fact and degree and commended a broad and common sense approach. Cairns LJ added at 636G-H: “If the building is, in the ordinary sense, complete so that it is ready to be equipped for the intended purpose by introducing some equipment which is not part of the building, then, in my opinion the building is ready for occupation for that purpose.”
42. The principle in these cases was applied by the Tribunal (Judge Elizabeth Cooke and Mark Higgin FRICS) in Ricketts (VO) v Cyxtera Technology UK Ltd[2021] UKUT 265 (LC). That case concerned “white space” in a data hall (space not yet adapted for use by customers), and whether it was capable of beneficial occupation and should be included in the rating list, other than under the completion notice procedure. The parties agreed that the passage we have quoted above from the Tribunal’s decision in Gladman was a correct statement of the law. The Tribunal decided that the empty data hall was beneficially occupied by the operator, which was actively managing it, even though no customers had yet located there. It put the question to be determined in this way, at [46]:
“So we have to decide whether white space is capable of beneficial occupation for the purpose for which the building was intended. It does not have to be capable of immediate use, provided that what is lacking is – in common sense terms, as a matter of fact and degree – furniture or equipment rather than part of the building itself.”
43. In BNPPDS(J) Ltd v Hitchings (VO) [2025] RA 177 we applied the same approach to a warehouse building which was already in the list but which was undergoing a scheme of refurbishment to make it usable as a “dark kitchen”. At [49] we said:
“The Tribunal's decisions in Porter and Aviva were not concerned with completion notices. They support the proposition that a building which, for reasons other than disrepair, lacks attributes and features that are a prerequisite for beneficial occupation is not a hereditament. We do not see why a building which has never been in the list should be treated more favourably than one which has, when both are in substantially the same condition.”
We might qualify that statement by reminding ourselves that once a hereditament has been entered in the list it will remain there unless it is shown that circumstances exist which justify its deletion. The onus of demonstrating those circumstances falls on the person seeking deletion, and if they are unable to do so there is no need for the VO to justify the continuation of the entry.
44. Finally, in Newbigin (VO) v Monk [2017] 1 WLR 851, the Supreme Court considered whether the statutory assumptions found in Schedule 6 to the 1988 Act which dictate the condition of a hereditament for the purposes of valuation, apply equally to the prior question of whether a hereditament capable of beneficial occupation exists, and concluded that they do not. The appeal concerned a building undergoing redevelopment which the Court of Appeal had considered should be valued as if in a state of reasonable repair, applying the repair assumption in paragraph 2(1)(b) of Schedule 6. Lord Hodge concluded that a different approach, described at [22], was required where a building was undergoing redevelopment. Before applying the statutory assumption that the hereditament is in a state of repair, it was necessary first to consider whether the property was capable of rateable occupation at all and thus whether it was a hereditament, and then to determine its mode or category of occupation. Both of those preliminary stages involved the application of the reality principle, which Lord Hodge had explained, at [14], by reference to the decision of the Court of Appeal in Scottish & Newcastle Retail Ltd v Williams (VO) [2001] 1 EGLR 157:
“[T]he reality principle meant that it was assumed that a hereditament was in the same physical state as upon the material day, save for minor alterations, and could be occupied only for a purpose within the same mode or category of purpose as that for which it was occupied on the material day.”
45. The assumptions and instructions found in Schedule 6 to the 1988 Act therefore govern valuation rather than inclusion in the rating list. Of relevance to this appeal is the assumption in paragraph 2(1) that the hereditament is in a state of reasonable repair. Additionally, where a rateable value is be determined with a view to making an alteration to a list which has been compiled (as Tungsten West’s proposals sought in this case) paragraph 2(6) directs that certain matters “shall be taken to be as they are assumed to be on the material day.” Those matters are listed in paragraph 2(7) and include the mode or category of occupation of the hereditament, matters affecting the physical state or enjoyment of the hereditament, and matters affecting the physical state of the locality in which the hereditament is situated.
Summary of the parties’ positions
46. The primary case advanced on behalf of the VO by Mr Reynolds was that on both material days, and throughout the 2017 list the Mine was not only capable of beneficial occupation but was beneficially occupied in fact. Acts amounting to rateable occupation included the storage of valuable stockpiles of aggregate and quantities of tungsten ore which were intentionally stored for future sale, and some of which were sold by Tungsten West during the life of the 2017 list. They also included the activities undertaken in the office building and the laboratory which the evidence confirms were being used at both material days.
47. The VO’s secondary case, if evidence of limited acts of beneficial occupation was not enough, challenged the VTE’s conclusion that the Mine was incapable of beneficial occupation because it lacked a mains electricity supply. The evidence showed that the 6.5MVA supply disconnected on 17 July 2019 was not reallocated until some months later and would have been available for the Mine. Tungsten West could have had access to 6.5MVA power considerably earlier than 1 December 2022 but delayed requesting an increase. Meanwhile, diesel generators were used to supply power to the office and the laboratory. Nor did the absence of environmental permits prevent the Mine from being beneficially occupied, as these would be available to a new occupier. As for the condition of the mineral processing facility itself, either the statutory repair assumption required that a solution must be taken to have been found to the issue of low frequency noise which had caused Wolf to breach the conditions of its permits, or the condition of the facility was irrelevant because it was non-rateable.
48. On behalf of Tungsten West Mr Wilcox submitted that the purpose of a mine was the winning and processing of minerals and that the Mine could not be retained in the rating list as “mine and premises – Tungsten”, for so long as the Mine was incapable of producing tungsten. Occupation of parts of the Mine for minor or ancillary or preparatory activities might justify the inclusion in the list of a different, smaller hereditament, but it did not justify the entry of the whole Mine as a mine.
49. Mr Wilcox accepted that the absence of the environmental permit required to operate the mineral processing facility did not render the Mine incapable of beneficial occupation; the permit was not an essential feature of the Mine, it was issued to a particular operator and was, as he put it, “accidental” to the notional letting of the hereditament which would form the basis of its valuation (applying the distinction explained by Lord Pearce in Dawkins v Ash Bros and Heaton Ltd [1969] 2 AC 366, 382 B-C). Nevertheless, he submitted, the design of the processing facility meant that it could not operate without generating unacceptable levels of low frequency noise and could not comply with the conditions attached to the previous permits. Without significant mitigation measures there was no possibility of an occupier securing a new environmental permit for the operation of the processing plant at the Mine. The reality principle precluded any assumption that the necessary mitigations were in place at the material days.
50. Tungsten West’s alternative case depended on the supply of electricity. On the second material day, the Mine’s primary power supply was switched off by the tripping of breakers and the application of safety locks in the substation outside the hereditament. Additionally, power supplies were severed to the water pumps on which mineral processing depended. The pumps were in the locality of the hereditament, which must be taken to be in its actual physical state at the second material day. Without power the Mine could not function for its intended purpose.
51. Finally, Mr Wilcox submitted that the VTE had been wrong to attribute the significance it did to the reinstatement of the 6.5MVA supply on 1 December 2022. 6.5MVA had been adequate for Wolf’s unsuccessful and non-compliant operation but was not sufficient to run the upgraded mineral processing facility proposed by Tungsten West. We understood this part of the argument not to have been pursued.
52. It will be convenient to consider first, and in chronological order, whether the changes on which Tungsten West relies had the effect of rendering the Mine incapable of beneficial occupation. The first change, which occurred on 22 March 2019, was the Official Receiver’s disclaimer of the Environment Agency permits which governed the operation of the mineral processing facility.
Issue 1 – The disclaimer of Environment Agency permits
53. There is no doubt that the Mine was occupied beneficially at least until the first material day. The mineral processing facility had run since June 2015 intermittently but with some measure of success, achieving operational rates of up to 75%. Whether Wolf’s business was profitable or not is not a relevant consideration.
54. Tungsten West relies on what it suggests was the impossibility of any operator securing an Environment Agency permit to process minerals following the disclaimer of the existing permit on 22 March 2019. Unlike the permit itself, the permitting regime is part of the general law which would apply to any occupier of the Mine. The deficiencies in the original design of the processing facility had not been appreciated when the permit was first granted but they were apparent from at least 20 December 2017 when the Environment Agency published an assessment confirming that the facility produced unacceptable levels of noise pollution. Mr Wilcox submitted that the availability of the necessary permit to operate the mineral processing facility was therefore a precondition of beneficial occupation of the Mine since without it, it would be unlawful to produce tungsten in powder form. He suggested that the condition of the facility was such that in order to obtain a permit for its operation it would have to be altered to a significant degree and submitted that those alterations could not be assumed to have occurred without violating the reality principle.
55. We accept that prior to the material day the Mine was under threat of the permit being withdrawn. Mr Andrews’ evidence was that once the permit was given up, the Environment Agency would not have authorised recommencement of mineral processing until works to mitigate the low frequency noise emissions were completed.That proposition was not challenged by the VO and it is supported by consideration of the difficulty Tungsten West had in obtaining the replacement permit for which it applied in August 2021 but which was not granted until June 2024. The new permit is conditional on the noise mitigation measures proposed by Tungsten West. Those measures are more extensive than the modifications originally proposed by Wolf, which were never implemented and whose effectiveness was never tested.
56. The intended purpose of the Mine is the winning and working of tungsten to make it marketable. The absence of a permit for processing did not prevent the removal of the rock from the ground, but we accept Mr Andrews’ evidence that it would be impractical to transport the mined rock containing the tungsten ore elsewhere for processing. It follows that without a functioning processing facility the Mine could not be used to its fullest intended extent.
57. The VO did not challenge the proposition that in reality a new permit would not have been available without a solution first being found to the noise pollution problem but advanced two arguments. In her statement of case and written argument, and for much of the hearing itself, the VO suggested that the noise problem was a repair issue which could be assumed away. As the case developed in oral argument, and in written submissions provided after the close of the hearing, the VO focussed on the distinction between rateable and non-rateable plant and machinery and invited us to approach the capacity of the Mine for beneficial occupation without having regard to the presence or condition of non-rateable elements.
58. We will begin with the VO’s argument based on the repair assumption.
59. According to Tungsten West’s own 2021 feasibility study, the source of the noise seems to be the large number of vibrating screens used in the separation of tungsten particles from waste material. The screens are prone to cracking, but Mr Reynolds submitted that they should be assumed to be in a reasonable state of repair, and that the work of repair should also be taken to be sufficient to solve the noise problem. In support of that submission he relied on our own decision in Carey Group PLC v Ricketts (VO) [2024] UKUT 356 (LC), at [71] where we pointed out that repair is not limited to addressing deterioration solely by “returning a damaged element to its former condition… It may include eradicating an inherent defect …”
60. The VO’s case on the issue of repair relied on two factual propositions. First, that work of repair to the vibrating screens would have successfully dealt with the problem of low frequency noise; and second, that once the work of repair had been completed a mineral processing permit could have been obtained. As these propositions were relied on by the VO, it fell to her to prove them.
61. The VO called no evidence of her own and relied instead on sporadic references to the feasibility report prepared by Tungsten West, a document of more than 900 pages none of which directly addressed the assumptions on which the VO’s repair argument depended.
62. The feasibility report identified a series of problems under the heading of process and engineering design, including excessive generation of low frequency noise by the large number of screens in the main plant building. Cracking on the two most troublesome screens was attributed to a design issue and these were to be removed and replaced by screens manufactured to a new design which had not yet been settled on. It is clear that the original screens were poorly designed and frequently broke down, but there was no suggestion that simply repairing them would be enough. On the contrary, a range of additional measures was proposed specifically to achieve noise mitigation after the screens had been replaced. These measures included the use of active noise cancellation speakers mounted above the screens, the use of motor synchronisation methods to adjust the constructive or destructive wave interactions between individual noise generating sources resulting in reduction of the “beating” effect, the installation of soundproof enclosures around the screens, and the cladding of the entire building.
63. The report did note that all of the screens would benefit from a complete refurbishment but, while we have no difficulty in accepting that that would be work of repair, it was clearly incidental to a much more substantial piece of work. It is also apparent from the report that Wolf had already gone to great lengths to reduce noise emissions, commissioning numerous technical studies and undertaking engineering works to reinforce the structure, all to no avail (“no reductions were ever reported by the regulator or the local community”).
64. On the basis of this evidence we are unable to accept the VO’s submission that the repair assumption, if it is applicable, allows the capacity of the Mine for beneficial occupation to be assessed on the basis that the problem of noise pollution had been resolved. Simply remedying defective screens, even by their replacement, would not have addressed the issue. We have no clear description of the mitigation measures which the VO suggests should be assumed to have been installed and we are satisfied that those identified as possible solutions in the feasibility study go significantly beyond what is comprehended in the concept of repair. They would involve a substantial redesign of the screens and the introduction of entirely new prophylactic apparatus and might require the addition of substantial new building components.
65. For these reasons we do not accept that the repair assumption has a relevant role to play in answering the question raised by the first issue. In any event, the VO’s reliance on the repair assumption (which is a valuation assumption) in order to determine whether the Mine is in rateable occupation is inconsistent with the approach endorsed by the Supreme Court in Monk.
66. The capacity of the Mine for beneficial occupation must therefore be judged on the assumption that screens were not cracked and that nuts and bolts were not loose, but otherwise on the facts as they were on 22 March 2019. No permit for the operation of the mineral processing facility existed, and none could be obtained without undertaking substantial works to redesign important parts of the facility.
67. Mr Reynolds’ alternative submission was that the Tribunal’s focus should be on whether the buildings alone were capable of beneficial occupation. When asking that question no regard should be had to the equipment, plant and machinery within the building, whatever its condition and whether it was rateable or non-rateable for the purposes of valuation. In support of this submission Mr Reynold relied on two cases concerning telephone exchanges, Post Office v Nottingham City Council to which we have already referred and the decision of the House of Lords in British Telecommunications v Kennet District Council [1982] RA 161. In the former case the building was found to be capable of beneficial occupation before the telephone exchange equipment was installed, and Browne LJ, at 636B, emphasised the distinction between “the time when the building is ready for occupation as a building, and the subsequent installation in it of equipment or furniture which is necessary for its use for the purpose for which it is intended”. The same distinction was made by the Tribunal in Ricketts v Cyxtera.
68. The Court of Appeal’s decision in Post Office v Nottingham City Council may be distinguishable, as Mr Wilcox suggested, on the grounds that it concerned the completion notice regime and the meaning of the words “the erection of the building can reasonably be expected to be completed” in paragraph 8 of Schedule 1 to the General Rate Act 1967. Where a completion notice is given and not challenged the building is to be treated as completed, whatever its actual condition or capability of beneficial occupation.
69. The same distinction cannot be made in the case of British Telecommunications v Kennet, which addressed the question whether BT was in rateable occupation of two new buildings which it was fitting out for use as telephone exchanges. The periods under consideration began on the date each building was completed as a building and ended on the date the premises were ready for service as an operational telephone exchange. In the intervening period the necessary telephone exchange equipment was installed. It was common ground that the telephone exchange equipment within the building was not rateable and that the direction in section 21(1) of the General Rate Act 1967 applied so that “for the purpose of the valuation … no account shall be taken of [its] value”. But Lord Keith, with whom the other members of the House of Lords agreed, considered that the same direction had wider consequences, as he explained at page 46:
“The subsection provides that it is for purposes of valuation that plant and machinery within para (b) is to be left out of account, but it must, I think, follow that it is impossible to treat such plant and machinery as part of the hereditament for any rating purpose, even though it be so fixed or attached that it would have fallen to be valued as part of the hereditament under the law prevailing before the statutory ancestor of s 21 was enacted in the form of s 24 of the Rating and Valuation Act 1925. Nothing can be rated which is not capable of being valued for the purposes of rating, and nothing which is not so capable can be the subject of rateable occupation. So it was rightly conceded by counsel for the respondents that the hereditament in issue here was land with the bare shell of the building on it, excluding all of the equipment therein. Counsel for the appellants, for his part, was prepared to accept that if the equipment had fallen within para (a) of s 21(1) the hereditament would not have been complete until it had been installed, and that until that event there could have been no rateable occupation.”
70. The importance of the distinction between rateable and non-rateable plant and machinery which appears from Lord Keith’s speech also finds expression in the Tribunal’s statement of principle in Porter v Gladman: “If the building lacks features which will have to be provided before it can be occupied for that purpose and when provided will form part of the occupied hereditament and form the basis of its valuation it does not constitute a hereditament.”
71. Perhaps heretically, in Sainsbury's Supermarkets Ltd v Sykes (VO) [2017] UKUT 138 (LC), at [126], the Tribunal considered that the presence of a non-rateable ATM should not be ignored when determining whether the space delineated only by the footprint of the machine was a separate hereditament. Be that as it may, in this case Mr Wilcox accepted in written submissions received after the conclusion of the hearing that non-rateable plant was irrelevant for the purpose of assessing whether or not it would be possible for an occupier to obtain an environmental permit for the operation of the mineral processing facility.
72. Mr Reynolds’ late reliance on the decision of the House of Lords in Kennet (which had not featured in his original argument) led the parties belatedly to consider the extent to which the machinery in the mineral processing facility was rateable or non-rateable. After the conclusion of the hearing the parties provided us with an agreed statement and further argument. It was agreed that screens that cause the low frequency noise generation are not in themselves rateable but that the steelwork which supports the screens is and any additional steelwork introduced to support mitigation measures such as acoustic enclosures around the screens would also be rateable. On the material day the steel work was configured to support the original screens.
73. Mr Wilcox submitted that any screen which could be installed and attached to the supporting steelwork as it existed on the material day would give rise to the same noise issues as the existing screens. We were referred to no evidence in support of that submission but were invited to infer from the fact that the screens themselves were bespoke installations that the only screens which could be supported on the existing steelwork would have been incapable of operating without generating the same unacceptable noise pollution.
74. The Environment Agency permit granted to Tungsten West in June 2024 refers to an approved noise and vibration management plan, which may describe the changes required, but we were not shown that document. Nor have we been able to identify for ourselves from the feasibility study exactly what modifications were under consideration. The document shows that a number of different approaches have been considered with some being rejected and others identified as worthy of further investigation, but it was not written with Mr Wilcox’s proposition in mind. The evidence of Mr Andrews includes a schematic representation of the changes now proposed by Tungsten West, but this does not show how replacement or additional components would be supported.
75. We agree with Mr Reynolds’ submission that it was for Tungsten West to make good the suggestion that the mineral processing facility could not have been made compliant with the conditions which would be attached to an Environment Agency permit without altering the rateable parts of the Mine. That proposition required evidence, not assertion, and nothing which we have seen addresses it. We are therefore unable to accept it.
76. For these reasons we accept Mr Reynolds’ alternative submission and conclude that the Mine did not become incapable of beneficial occupation on 22 March 2019 when the Official Receiver disclaimed the Environment Agency permits required for the operation of the mineral processing facility.
77. We would add that we do not think Tungsten West’s case is assisted by reliance on Arbuckle Smith v Greenock Corporation on which Mr Wilcox based an argument that acts undertaken to prepare a building for beneficial occupation should not be treated as evidence of beneficial occupation in their own right. Arbuckle Smith concerned preparatory works to the fabric of the building, without which it could not be occupied for its intended purpose, and it can be distinguished from the facts proven in this appeal because it has not been established that the alterations required before a permit could be obtained went beyond changes to non-rateable machinery.
Issue 2 – The disconnection of the high voltage electricity supply to the Mine
78. The high voltage 6.5MVA electricity supply to the Mine was suspended on 17 July 2019 when Western Power switched off the connection to the grid by tripping breakers and applying safety locks within its own substation. The substation is agreed not to be part of the same hereditament. The evidence suggests that the supply was not reallocated to other customers until November 2019.
79. Mr Reynolds submitted that availability of the 6.5MVA supply is not relevant to the question of whether the Mine was capable of beneficial occupation. Alternatively, it was available to the occupier on the material day and for some time thereafter. Mr Wilcox submitted that the status of the Mine must be considered on the assumption that the supply had been disconnected and the switches locked off because those were aspects of the physical state of the locality at the material day and must be taken as found. He submitted that the ease with which the supply could have been restored is nothing to the point, and that a future possibility of change in the locality cannot be considered in deciding whether a hereditament exists.
80. We agree with Mr Wilcox that the capacity of the Mine for beneficial occupation should be assessed on the basis of the facts as they were when the mains supply was disconnected. But it cannot seriously be suggested that, at least while the supply remained available and had not been reallocated, the disconnection of the supply made any difference to the capacity of the Mine for beneficial occupation. Processing could not resume until the steps taken on 17 July 2019 were reversed, but that reversal would involve no physical change to the Mine itself and would be easily accomplished.
81. The reality principle does not preclude the possibility of minor changes to the facts as they existed at the material day. For the purpose of valuation that proposition is clearly established by the decision of the Court of Appeal in Williams (VO) v Scottish & Newcastle Retail Ltd [2001] EWCA Civ 185 [2001] RA 41, at [74], where Robert Walker LJ allowed for “the possibility of minor alterations in the hereditament on the occasion of its hypothetical letting” and referred to “the absurdity of any other view”. In Dawkins v Ash, at 386A, Lord Wilberforce said, of foreseeable changes: “it would surely be unreasonable to suppose that the hypothetical tenant is so inescapably imprisoned in the present that no anticipation is permitted of what is to come.” In Post Office v Nottingham Council, which was not concerned with valuation but with the question whether a hereditament had yet come into being, Cairns LJ, at page 636H, refused to accept that to be “ready for occupation” a building must be ready for “immediate use”: “If the building is, in the ordinary sense, complete, so that it is ready to be equipped for the intended purpose by introducing some equipment which is not to be part of the building, then, in my opinion, the building is ready for occupation for that purpose.”
82. Mr Wilcox’s argument depended on disapplying the Scottish & Newcastle minor alterations doctrine because the switches were located outside the boundaries of the hereditament and therefore, he suggested, were required by paragraph 2(6) of Schedule 6 to the 1988 Act to be assumed to be as they had been at the material day. We do not accept that argument, as Schedule 6 is concerned with valuation and not with the prior question of whether the premises are capable of beneficial occupation, as Lord Hodge explained in Newbigin v Monk, at [20]. In any event, we do not accept that the taking of an easily reversible step such as moving a switch position means that a hereditament ceases to be capable of beneficial occupation. We can see no reason why the same flexible application of the reality principle should not be possible in the immediate locality, admitting the possibility of minor alterations to avoid being inescapably imprisoned in what was only ever a temporary condition.We do not think it matters whether the switch forms part of the hereditament or is elsewhere in the locality, or whether it is in the ‘off’ or ‘on’ position.
83. We would add that the evidence about the availability of the mains supply after disconnection was exiguous. No relevant facts were agreed and no witness with direct knowledge of Western Power’s operation was called to give evidence. Reliance was placed instead on emails sent at the request of Tungsten West several years after the material day. That evidence suggests that power was not reallocated to other customers of Western Power until November 2019. As no proposal was made to delete the Mine from the list from any date other than 17 July 2019 we make no findings of fact about the availability of power after that date.
Issue 3 – The disconnection of the low voltage electricity supply to the water pumps
84. The low voltage power supplies to the pumps which provided water to the Mine were interrupted when the cables were physically severed close to the pumps themselves. The cables were in the locality of the Mine but neither they nor the pumps formed part of the hereditament.
85. There is uncertainty over the date on which the cables were severed and no witness was called who could give relevant evidence.
86. Mr Reynolds submitted that the cables had not been touched on the material day (which for this purpose is 17 July 2019, as that was the date identified in the proposal). Like Mr Wilcox, he relied on an e-mail from Mr Gary Beasley of the National Grid written in August 2022. Mr Beasley had been personally involved in switching off the high voltage power supply and was able to give a precise account of what had occurred. He had not been involved in severing the supply to the water pumps and he reported only that this had been completed “by the end of July 2019”. Mr Wilcox suggested that severing the cables had been the first of two phases to which Mr Beasley referred and that it could be inferred that it had occurred before 17 July. No such inference is possible. The email suggests to us that Mr Beasley did not know exactly when the work had been done and that the most he could say from the records he had consulted was that the water pump supply was severed some time in July. We note also that Tungsten West’s interpretation of the available information when its statement of case was settled by Mr Wilcox was that the low voltage supply was disconnected after 17 July (“at some point over the two weeks thereafter and by 31 July 2019 at the latest”).
87. Given the limited evidence and the case pleaded on behalf of Tungsten West we conclude that the low voltage supply to the water pumps had not been interrupted by the material day and that the availability of water from the pumps was not a limiting factor on the capacity of the Mine for beneficial occupation at that time.
88. Had we taken the opposite view, we would have found that the need to restore the severed cables did not render the Mine incapable of beneficial occupation for the same reasons as applied to the high voltage supply. The work took little time to arrange and carry out (a week in total, but the work itself could have been completed at each location within a day) and was exactly the sort of minor change which any intending occupier of the Mine would anticipate.
Conclusion
89. Having decided that none of the events relied on by Tungsten West had the effect of rendering the Mine incapable of beneficial occupation, it is unnecessary for us to consider the VO’s primary argument that the limited beneficial use which was being made of the Mine, for the storage and sale of modest quantities of aggregates and processed tungsten, and for research and office functions, amounted to rateable occupation.
90. For these reasons we allow the VO’s appeal and dismiss Tungsten West’s cross appeal.
Martin Rodger KC, Mark Higgin FRICS FIRRV,
Deputy Chamber President Member
4 November 2026
Right of appeal
Any party has a right of appeal to the Court of Appeal on any point of law arising from this decision. The right of appeal may be exercised only with permission. An application for permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal must be sent or delivered to the Tribunal so that it is received within 1 month after the date on which this decision is sent to the parties (unless an application for costs is made within 14 days of the decision being sent to the parties, in which case an application for permission to appeal must be made within 1 month of the date on which the Tribunal’s decision on costs is sent to the parties). An application for permission to appeal must identify the decision of the Tribunal to which it relates, identify the alleged error or errors of law in the decision, and state the result the party making the application is seeking. If the Tribunal refuses permission to appeal a further application may then be made to the Court of Appeal for permission.
Our tax lawyer in Paris assists clients in matters of this kind.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).