Tax United Kingdom
Michael Cohen v The Commissioners for HMRC
Neutral Citation: [2026] UKFTT 01486 (TC)
Case Number: TC10070
FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL
TAX CHAMBER
By remote video/telephone hearing
Appeal reference: TC/2024/01403
Closure notice – director’s loan account – written-off balance chargeable to income tax – careless or deliberate penalty
Heard on: 23 April 2026
Judgment date: 26 October 2026
Before
TRIBUNAL JUDGE SUSAN TURNER
JAMES ROBERTSON
Between
MICHAEL COHEN
Appellant
and
THE COMMISSIONERS FOR HIS MAJESTY’S REVENUE AND CUSTOMS
Respondents
Representation:
For the Appellant: Michael Cohen in person
For the Respondents: Nathaniel Campbell, litigator of HM Revenue and Customs’ Solicitor’s Office
A summary decision was issued to the parties on 14 May 2026. A request for a full decision was subsequently received from the Appellant. This is our full decision in this appeal.
DECISION
Introduction
1. Mr Cohen appealed against the conclusion of a closure notice dated 8 August 2023 (the Closure Notice) issued by HMRC under s 28A(1B) and (2) Taxes Management Act 1970 (TMA 1970) in respect of the 2020/21 tax year which increased Mr Cohen’s self-assessed income tax due by an amount of £138,047.73 (the Amendment).
2. The Amendment was made by HMRC in respect of a balance of £362,830 (the DLA Balance) credited to Mr Cohen’s director’s loan account (DLA) with Bellagio Europe Limited (BEL) and written off as described at [9] below.
3. Mr Cohen also appealed against a penalty imposed by HMRC on 28 December 2023 under sch 24 Finance Act 2007 (FA 2007) in respect of the 2020/21 tax year in the sum of £53,148.37 (the Penalty). The Penalty was imposed for the failure of Mr Cohen to include the DLA Balance on his self-assessment tax return (SATR).
4. The form of the hearing was V (video) and all parties attended remotely using Microsoft Teams. We were referred to a documents bundle of 636 pages. A skeleton argument was also provided on behalf of each party. Mr Cohen’s skeleton argument attached several exhibits.
5. At the hearing, we heard evidence from Mr Cohen and from Alan Spraggs, HMRC Compliance Officer.
6. Prior notice of the hearing had been published on the gov.uk website, with information about how representatives of the media or members of the public could apply to join the hearing remotely in order to observe the proceedings. As such, the hearing was held in public.
Background and Facts
7. BEL was incorporated in 2004 and Mr Cohen was appointed director on 1 November 2005.
8. On 11 July 2019, Gareth Howarth of Path Business Recovery Limited (the Liquidator) was appointed liquidator of BEL in a creditors’ voluntary liquidation.
9. By letter dated 9 November 2020 (the Liquidator’s Letter), the Liquidator wrote to Mr Cohen writing off Mr Cohen’s overdrawn DLA with an outstanding balance of £362,830. The Liquidator’s Letter noted that, pursuant to a settlement agreement dated 16 December 2019 (the Settlement Agreement), Mr Cohen was now released from all claims / rights that BEL had in relation to the DLA.
10. By letter dated 16 November 2020 (the Notification Letter), HMRC contacted Mr Cohen to notify him that the written-off DLA had become chargeable to income tax and that the DLA Balance should be included in Mr Cohen’s SATR for 2020/21, which was due by 31 January 2022.
11. BEL was dissolved on 23 June 2021.
12. Mr Cohen’s SATR was submitted on 18 March 2022 but did not include the DLA Balance.
13. By way of notice dated 31 May 2022 (the Notice), Mr Cohen was informed that an enquiry was opened into his 2020/21 SATR under s 9A TMA 1970.
14. In each of the Notification Letter and the Notice, HMRC erroneously referred to “the balance of your loan to” BEL rather than “from” BEL, though both made clear that the sum was chargeable to tax. In the Notification Letter, reference was made to Mr Cohen’s release from his obligations.
15. On 14 July 2022, HMRC wrote to Mr Cohen informing him that HMRC were aware that the DLA had been written off and therefore the DLA Balance should be included on his SATR for 2020/21. They asked for an explanation of its omission and informed Mr Cohen that inaccuracy penalties may be considered.
16. In response, by letter dated 9 August 2022, Mr Cohen noted that he was unaware that the DLA Balance should be included on his SATR and that he believed the £38,380 he had paid in respect of the DLA under the Settlement Agreement was full and final settlement with HMRC.
17. By letter dated 31 August 2022, HMRC explained the nature of the DLA to Mr Cohen and that the Settlement Agreement did not relate to settling any debt to HMRC. They noted the amount paid had been reduced to £36,170 by variation of the Settlement Agreement.
18. On 27 September 2022, Mr Cohen wrote to HMRC reiterating that he thought the £36,170 paid in respect of the DLA had been in full and final settlement. He also said he had had no benefit from the DLA. In this letter, Mr Cohen asserted that the DLA represented rental payments, not payments to himself. Mr Cohen expressed confusion regarding the DLA Balance and said he was never advised the amount should be included in his SATR, the amounts being for rent and not a loan to him personally. He said this had all arisen from listening to advice from his accountants and was not deliberate. He said he ceased using the accountants in mid-2021 because of errors in the company accounts.
19. By letter dated 3 November 2022, HMRC informed Mr Cohen that the chargeability arose under s 415(1) Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005 (ITTOIA 2005) and noted that he had been alerted of the need to include the amount on his SATR in the Notification Letter.
20. On 10 January 2023, HMRC wrote to Mr Cohen to tell him that they intended to issue a closure notice and explaining the findings of their enquiry, though the body of the letter referred to raising an assessment.
21. Further correspondence relating to HMRC’s enquiry followed between Mr Cohen and HMRC between January 2023 and September 2023. To the extent Mr Cohen’s correspondence raised complaints, these were referred to HMRC’s complaints department.
22. In a letter dated 1 February 2023, Mr Cohen disputed HMRC’s findings. In this letter, he refers to the inaccuracy and misunderstanding caused by his accountants, though acknowledges responsibility lies with him. He says again that this has all arisen by listening to his accountants and is not deliberate.
23. By letter dated 18 April 2023, HMRC sent a notice of assessment to Mr Cohen under s 29 TMA 1970 in the amount of £138,047.73 relating to tax year 2020/21 and Mr Cohen appealed the assessment.
24. HMRC provided a view of the matter and offered an independent review of the assessment, which Mr Cohen accepted.
25. On 10 July 2023, HMRC contacted Mr Cohen explaining that they intended to impose a behavioural penalty and asking for relevant information.
26. On 20 July 2023, Mr Cohen wrote to HMRC to dispute the penalty explanation letter, saying that the figures were calculated based on disputed figures and reiterating information provided in earlier correspondence.
27. HMRC identified that a closure notice rather than a tax assessment should have been issued and communicated to Mr Cohen by letter dated 26 July 2023 that the assessment was invalid, though the enquiry had been opened and therefore a closure notice would be required to charge any additional tax.
28. The Closure Notice was issued on 8 August 2023 as noted at [1] above and Mr Cohen appealed on 24 August 2023.
29. On 4 September 2023, HMRC issued their view of the matter in respect of the Closure Notice, upholding their decision and offering an independent review, which Mr Cohen accepted.
30. HMRC’s review conclusion letter dated 28 November 2023 upheld the decision communicated in the Closure Notice.
31. On 28 December 2023, HMRC issued the penalty notice referred to at [3] above.
32. On 25 January 2024, HMRC re-issued the review conclusion letter as Mr Cohen said he had not received it.
33. On 5 February 2024, Mr Cohen notified his appeal against both the Closure Notice and the Penalty to this Tribunal.
34. On 26 April 2024, HMRC wrote to the Tribunal and to Mr Cohen requesting that Mr Cohen appeal the Penalty to HMRC first.
35. On 8 May 2024, Mr Cohen emailed HMRC and the Tribunal enclosing appeal documents and a letter disputing the Penalty dated 25 March 2024. Following consideration, HMRC accepted the earlier letter as an appeal by Mr Cohen in respect of both the Penalty and the Closure Notice and confirmed they did not object to the late appeal of the Closure Notice.
The Issues
36. The Tribunal was asked to determine the following issues:
(1) Whether the DLA Balance was chargeable to income tax during the 2020/21 tax year under sections 415-416 ITTOIA 2005.
(2) Whether the Closure Notice was correctly issued.
(3) Whether Mr Cohen has been overcharged by the Amendment.
(4) Whether the conditions for the imposition of the Penalty under sch 24 FA 2007 are met.
(5) If the conditions for imposing the Penalty are met, whether the Penalty has been correctly categorised and calculated in the correct amount.
37. The burden of proof rests with HMRC to demonstrate that the Closure Notice was validly issued and with Mr Cohen to show that he was overcharged by the Amendment.
38. The burden of proof rests with HMRC to demonstrate that the conditions for the imposition of the Penalty are met and that it has been correctly categorised and calculated.
39. The standard of proof in each case is the balance of probabilities.
Mr Cohen’s Grounds of Appeal
40. Mr Cohen’s grounds of appeal raised the following issues:
(1) That he had never had the benefit of the funds the tax is being claimed on.
(2) That the DLA figures were recorded incorrectly by his accountants.
(3) That he had never been advised to include the DLA on a self-assessment tax return.
(4) That the appeal had lasted a number of years and caused financial hardship.
(5) That he did not have the funds to pay.
(6) That he believed that HMRC had withdrawn their assessment.
(7) That he believed the DLA Balance had been written off and a settlement had been paid to the Liquidator during 2020 which would include amounts owing to HMRC.
(8) That he has not at any time tried to mislead anyone or acted in bad faith.
(9) That he was dyslexic and lacked understanding of company accounts.
The Law
The Amendment made by the Closure Notice
41. Under s 415(1) ITTOIA 2005, where a company which is or was chargeable to tax under section 455 Corporation Tax Act 2010 (CTA 2010) in respect of a loan or advance, and that company releases or writes off the whole or part of the debt in respect of the loan or advance, income tax is chargeable.
42. According to s 416(1) ITTOIA 2005, tax is charged on the amount of the debt released or written off in the tax year.
43. Section 455 CTA 2010 creates a charge to tax on loans by a “close company” to a “participator” in that company.
44. In this case, there is no dispute that BEL was a close company of which Mr Cohen was a participator and s 455 CTA 2010 applies. Therefore, if there was a release or write-off of the DLA Balance, income tax becomes chargeable on the amount of the debt released or written off.
The Penalty
45. Paragraph 1, sch 24 FA 2007 states that:
“(1) A penalty is payable by a person (P) where—
(a) P gives HMRC a document of a kind listed in the Table below, and
(b) Conditions 1 and 2 are satisfied.
(2) Condition 1 is that the document contains an inaccuracy which amounts to, or leads to—
(a) an understatement of a liability to tax,
(b) a false or inflated statement of a loss, or
(c) a false or inflated claim to repayment of tax.
(3) Condition 2 is that the inaccuracy was careless (within the meaning of paragraph 3) or deliberate on P’s part.
(4) Where a document contains more than one inaccuracy, a penalty is payable for each inaccuracy.”
46. Paragraph 3(1), sch 24 FA 2007 provides that:
“(1) For the purposes of a penalty under paragraph 1, inaccuracy in a document given by P to HMRC is—
(a) “careless” if the inaccuracy is due to failure by P to take reasonable care,
(b) “deliberate but not concealed” if the inaccuracy is deliberate on P's part but P does not make arrangements to conceal it, and
(c) “deliberate and concealed” if the inaccuracy is deliberate and P makes arrangements to conceal it (for example, by submitting false evidence in support of an inaccurate figure).”
47. A self-assessment tax return under s 8 TMA 1970 is included in the Table referred to at para 1(1), sch 24 FA 2007. Therefore, if Mr Cohen’s SATR for tax year 2020/21 contained an inaccuracy which amounts to an understatement of a liability to tax (Condition 1) and that inaccuracy was careless or deliberate on Mr Cohen’s part (Condition 2), a penalty is payable.
Discussion
The Amendment made by the Closure Notice
48. First, Mr Cohen contended that HMRC’s assessment had been withdrawn as invalid and therefore could not be pursued. As noted at [27] above, HMRC did issue a tax assessment dated 18 April 2023, which they subsequently informed Mr Cohen was invalid. Although some unfortunate confusion had been caused by HMRC’s error, the Closure Notice was then validly issued within the required timeframe.
49. During the hearing, we heard from Mr Cohen that he disputed the existence of the DLA and the DLA Balance. Mr Cohen told us that he had relied upon accountants for advice in respect of accountancy matters for BEL and himself, in relation to which he was no expert. It was clear that Mr Cohen felt that errors had been made by the accountants in the past and he told the Tribunal that the amounts recorded in the DLA represented rental payments made on behalf of BEL and that they had been incorrectly recorded.
50. Mr Cohen told the Tribunal that he had not received the amounts recorded in the DLA. He also said that he believed that the payment made to the Liquidator under the Settlement Agreement had been in full and final settlement and included sums owing to HMRC.
51. At the hearing, HMRC drew our attention to the financial statements of BEL for the year ended 30 November 2017, which were signed by Mr Cohen as director and showed the DLA. They referred us to the Liquidator’s Letter, dated 9 November 2020, which informed Mr Cohen that the DLA Balance had been formally written off pursuant to the Settlement Agreement under which Mr Cohen had paid £36,170. HMRC also referred us to the Liquidator’s statement of affairs, signed by Mr Cohen, which included details of an overdrawn DLA and the settlement payment.
52. We accept that Mr Cohen had relied upon accountants relating to the accounts of BEL and his personal tax affairs until they parted company in mid-2021. We also accept that he was no expert when it came to accounting matters and believed that his accountants had made several errors.
53. However, based on the evidence before us, including the Liquidator’s Letter, the Liquidator’s statement of affairs, and the Settlement Agreement, we find that Mr Cohen did have a DLA with BEL and that the DLA Balance was written off during the 2020/21 tax year.
54. It follows, by operation of s 415(1) and s 416(1) ITTOIA 2005, that the DLA Balance becomes chargeable to income tax and should have been included in Mr Cohen’s SATR for the 2020/21 tax year.
55. As the Amendment was correct and the Closure Notice was validly issued, Mr Cohen’s appeal against the conclusion of the Closure Notice is dismissed.
The Penalty
56. The Penalty was issued under sch 24 FA 2007 in respect of the inaccuracy caused by Mr Cohen’s failure to include the written-off DLA Balance in his 2020/21 SATR.
57. HMRC raised the Penalty on the basis that the inaccuracy giving rise to the understatement of Mr Cohen’s liability to tax was made deliberately but had not been concealed.
58. Mr Campbell submitted for HMRC that the inaccuracy was a consequence of deliberate behaviour because Mr Cohen had been advised by the Notification Letter that the DLA Balance which had been written off was chargeable to income tax. As such, he knowingly submitted a return that omitted an amount which was taxable and did so with the intention that HMRC would rely on the return as accurate. Mr Campbell reminded the Tribunal that a finding of deliberate behaviour does not require proof of dishonesty, relying on HMRC v Tooth [2021] UKSC 17 and CF Booth Ltd v HMRC [2022] UKUT 217 (TCC).
59. In the alternative, HMRC contended that Mr Cohen’s behaviour was careless and following the language used in David Collis v HMRC [2011] FTT 588, extended beyond simple errors of omission or mere oversights, noting that Mr Cohen had himself referred to his error as “careless” in correspondence. Mr Campbell noted that Mr Cohen had ceased working with his accountants before the SATR was submitted and that he did not check the tax consequences related to the DLA write-off.
60. We heard from Mr Cohen that he did not dispute the inaccuracy in his SATR, but he told the Tribunal that he had not received HMRC’s Notification Letter. He did acknowledge that he had received much other correspondence from HMRC in connection with the matters under appeal and that his dyslexia presented him with challenges of dealing with all of the documentation relating to the appeal.
61. Officer Spraggs’ evidence was that the Notification Letter had been sent and had not been returned to HMRC, while every other letter sent by HMRC had been received by Mr Cohen.
62. Mr Cohen repeatedly told the Tribunal that he did not believe he had received the amounts represented by the DLA. He said that he had instructed accountants in connection with the affairs of BEL and his personal tax up until mid-2021. At this time, Mr Cohen stopped instructing the accountants because of errors in the accounts of BEL.
63. After parting with his accountants, he told the Tribunal that a woman working locally, a retired bookkeeper, had helped him for a time with his personal tax affairs, though he said he prepared and filed his own tax return and helped his wife with hers. When asked in cross-examination what additional steps he had taken in 2022 to ensure his SATR was accurate, Mr Cohen says that he worked through his bank statements to see what he had received. He took advice from the local bookkeeper and spoke to a family member and focused on money he had received. He said he could not afford to pay for advice at that time.
64. Under cross-examination, Mr Cohen said he had spoken to several people and they had said that amounts should not be in his SATR if he had not received the funds. Mr Cohen told the Tribunal that he did not include the DLA Balance on his SATR because he had not received the funds. Following the experience of the liquidation of BEL, he did not trust accountants.
65. When asked if he had asked HMRC for help with his tax return, Mr Cohen said he thought he may have done so because he was scared and sought any free advice available. He said he had spoken to HMRC about many things and that he was getting letters saying that his tax return was late. He said that HMRC’s notes, which did not record any calls from this time, were not comprehensive and he could not recall when contact had been made. He also suggested that his former accountants had told him not to talk to HMRC.
66. Mr Cohen’s evidence relating to the submission of his SATR for the 2020/21 tax year was therefore somewhat confused.
67. We find that, on the balance of probabilities, HMRC’s Notification Letter was sent and received by Mr Cohen. However, we accept that Mr Cohen’s dyslexia and confusion surrounding the nature of the DLA Balance and the Settlement Agreement may have prevented his understanding that HMRC had told him that the DLA Balance should be included on his SATR. We also accept that Mr Cohen was not an expert in accounting matters, whether related to the accounts of BEL or his personal affairs.
68. Having lost trust in his former accountants, Mr Cohen sought assistance from a local accountant and family on an informal basis about the completion of his SATR for the 2020/21 tax year. Following several discussions, Mr Cohen believed that only amounts actually received by him would be taxable and should be included and this led him to not include the DLA Balance.
69. However, in circumstances where BEL had been liquidated and he knew that the significant sum of the DLA Balance had been written off, it would have been prudent for Mr Cohen to instruct accountants specifically to advise him whether or not the written-off DLA Balance should be included on his SATR rather than interpreting earlier advice from a firm of accountants that he no longer instructed or relying on informal advice or his belief that he had not received the amounts represented by the DLA and they therefore did not need to be included on his SATR. The inaccuracy in this case was not made with the intention to mislead but was the result of more than a simple error of omission or oversight and represented a failure by Mr Cohen to take reasonable care.
70. We are therefore satisfied that Mr Cohen’s failure to include the DLA Balance in his self-assessment tax return for the 2020/21 tax year was a consequence of careless rather than deliberate behaviour.
71. It follows that we allow Mr Cohen’s appeal against the Penalty in part. Mr Cohen’s SATR for tax year 2020/21 contained an inaccuracy which amounts to an understatement of a liability to tax (Condition 1) and that inaccuracy was careless on Mr Cohen’s part (Condition 2). The penalty imposed should be re-categorised as careless and recalculated and charged on that basis. We find that the mitigations allowed for helping, telling and giving are appropriate and equivalent reductions should apply.
The Decision
72. The Tribunal decided that the appeals should be ALLOWED IN PART.
73. The appeal against the amendment to Mr Cohen’s SATR for the 2020/21 tax year in the amount of £138,047.73 is dismissed.
74. The appeal against the penalty in the sum of £53,148.37 is allowed in part and the penalty should be re-categorised and recalculated as a careless penalty as noted at [71] above.
Right to apply for permission to appeal
75. This document contains full findings of fact and reasons for the decision. Any party dissatisfied with this decision has a right to apply for permission to appeal against it pursuant to Rule 39 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009. The application must be received by this Tribunal not later than 56 days after this decision is sent to that party. The parties are referred to “Guidance to accompany a Decision from the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber)” which accompanies and forms part of this decision notice.
Release date: 26th OCTOBER 2026
Our tax lawyer assists clients in matters of this kind.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).