Miscellaneous Etats-Unis

Mississippi Alcoholic Beverage Control and Mississippi Department of Revenue v. Green Cross of MS, LLC and Karen Crumpler

Official source
                  IN THE SUPREME COURT OF MISSISSIPPI

                              NO. 2024-SA-01021-SCT

MISSISSIPPI ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
CONTROL AND MISSISSIPPI DEPARTMENT OF
REVENUE

v.

GREEN CROSS OF MS, LLC, AND KAREN
CRUMPLER


DATE OF JUDGMENT:                       07/26/2024
TRIAL JUDGE:                            HON. SMITH MURPHEY
TRIAL COURT ATTORNEYS:                  JOHN THOMAS LAMAR, III
                                        TAYLOR ALLISON HECK
                                        MATTHEW TIMMONS HENRY
                                        DAVID J. CALDWELL
                                        JESSICA LEIGH LONG
COURT FROM WHICH APPEALED:              PANOLA COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT
ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLANT:                JESSICA LEIGH LONG
                                        MATTHEW TIMMONS HENRY
                                        DREW DOUGLAS GUYTON
ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEE:                 JOHN THOMAS LAMAR, III
                                        TAYLOR ALLISON HECK
NATURE OF THE CASE:                     CIVIL - STATE BOARDS AND AGENCIES
DISPOSITION:                            ON DIRECT APPEAL: REVERSED; ON
                                        CROSS-APPEAL: AFFIRMED - 10/29/2026
MOTION FOR REHEARING FILED:

      EN BANC.

      BRANNING, JUSTICE, FOR THE COURT:

¶1.   As a case of first impression, we are called upon to interpret provisions of the

Mississippi Medical Cannabis Act (the Act) regarding the location of medical-cannabis

dispensaries in proximity to churches and refundability of certain fees. The Alcoholic
Beverage Control (ABC), a division of the Mississippi Department of Revenue (MDOR),

denied Green Cross of MS LLC’s application for a medical-cannabis-dispensary license

based on its proximity to a church. While MDOR refunded the $25,000 annual license fee,

it did not refund Green Cross’s $15,000 application fee. On appeal, the circuit court affirmed

the denial of the license application but ordered ABC to refund the $15,000 application fee.

ABC now appeals, and Green Cross cross-appeals.

¶2.    Based on the plain language of the Act, we affirm the circuit court’s decision to

uphold ABC’s denial of the medical-cannabis-dispensary license. But we reverse the circuit

court’s decision ordering ABC to refund the $15,000 application fee.

                        FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

¶3.    Enacted in 2022, the Act authorizes MDOR to oversee and license medical-cannabis

dispensaries doing business in the state of Mississippi. Specific to today’s case, the Act

provides that dispensaries are not authorized to locate within one thousand feet of schools,

churches, or childcare facilities, with waivers available only for those locating more than five

hundred feet of a school, church, or childcare facility. 

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137-35

(16)

(Rev. 2023). In addition, the Act provides that the application and license fees are

nonrefundable except when a dispensary applies for a location within fifteen hundred feet

of another dispensary. 

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137-37

(5) (Supp. 2026).

¶4.    On July 30, 2022, Green Cross submitted an application for a medical-cannabis

dispensary to be located at 311 Heritage Drive, Oxford, Mississippi. As part of its due




                                               2
diligence, Green Cross obtained a survey to verify that the proposed dispensary location

would not run afoul of the Act’s prohibition against being:

       within one thousand (1,000) feet of the nearest property boundary line of a
       school, church or child care facility which exists or has acquired necessary real
       property for the operation of such facility before the date of the medical
       cannabis establishment application unless the entity has received approval
       from the school, church or child care facility and received the applicable
       waiver from their licensing agency, provided that the main point of entry of the
       cannabis establishment is not located within five hundred (500) feet of the
       nearest property boundary line of any school, church or child care facility

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137-35

(16)(a)(ii) (Rev. 2023).

¶5.    The July 18, 2022, survey depicted the proposed dispensary as being within one

thousand feet, but not less than five hundred feet, of a childcare facility. Green Cross,

therefore, obtained a waiver from the affected childcare facility as allowed by the Act. At

that same time, the surveyor certified that no properties owned by a church fell within the

boundaries of the prohibited area. Additionally, Green Cross’s investigation included a

search of the Mississippi secretary of state’s website, which indicated that Next Gear

Solutions LLC/Next Gear Solutions Inc. was the occupier of 304 Heritage Drive, Suite 2.

Next Gear was not an entity with distance restrictions under the Act.

¶6.    Through its investigation, however, ABC discovered that a church was operating

within one thousand feet of the proposed dispensary address. More specifically, on July 15,

2022, Wellspring Church began holding church services within a strip mall located at 304

Heritage Drive. It is undisputed that Wellspring Church did not own this property.

¶7.    On August 5, 2022, ABC formally denied Green Cross’s application due to the

proposed dispensary’s being less than one thousand feet from Wellspring Church. As a

                                              3
result, ABC refunded Green Cross’s $25,000 annual license fee but did not refund the

$15,000 application fee.

¶8.    On August 8, 2022, Green Cross appealed this decision to the Panola County Circuit

Court,1 arguing that because the church “had no property interest in the property,” it was not

a “church” under the Act. The circuit court affirmed the license denial but ordered ABC to

refund the $15,000 application fee “in this unique set of facts” as being “arbitrary.” ABC

appealed the order requiring the refund, and Green Cross cross-appealed the order affirming

the denial of the license.

                               STANDARD OF REVIEW

¶9.    We acknowledge the standard of review for decisions from administrative agencies

requires a determination of whether the decision “(1) [w]as supported by substantial

evidence; or (2) [w]as arbitrary or capricious; or (3) [w]as beyond the power of the lower

authority to make; or (4) [v]iolated some statutory or constitutional right of the complaining

party. ” Hill Bros. Constr. & Eng’g Co., Inc. v. Miss. Transp. Comm’n, 

909 So. 2d 58, 64


(Miss. 2005) (alterations in original) (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting Landmark

Structures, Inc. v. City Council for Meridian, 

826 So. 2d 746, 749

 (Miss. 2002)). Because

the parties only raise questions of law, however, we will review this matter de novo. Miss.

Ethics Comm’n v. Grisham, 

957 So. 2d 997, 1000

 (Miss. 2007) (quoting 32 Pit Bulldogs

v. Cnty. of Prentiss, 

808 So. 2d 971, 973

 (Miss. 2002)).



       1
       Even though the dispensary was to be located in Lafayette County, Mississippi Code
Section 41-137-59(2)(a) (Rev. 2023) conveys jurisdiction on the circuit court of the county
in which the appellant resides, which is Panola County.

                                              4
                                       DISCUSSION

¶10.   Green Cross’s sole issue on cross-appeal is whether ABC had the authority to deny

the application based on the plain language of the statute. Likewise, ABC’s sole issue on

appeal is whether the circuit court correctly interpreted the Act in ordering the refund of the

application fee. And on direct appeal, Green Cross argues that it would be “den[ied]

substantial justice” if this Court chose to reverse the circuit court’s decision to require ABC

to refund the application fee.

¶11.   Chief Justice Randolph writes that Green Cross “was never offered constitutional due

process.” Randolph Diss. Op. ¶ 35. While it should be noted that Green Cross raises no

procedural or due-process concerns, the record reflects that the parties followed the statutory

procedure for appeals under the Act that was in place at that time.

¶12.   This Court has held that “[a] complainant must exhaust the administrative remedies

available to him before resorting to the courts for resolution of his dispute.” State v. Beebe,

687 So. 2d 702, 704

 (Miss. 1996) (emphasis added) (citing NCAA v. Gillard, 

352 So. 2d

1072, 1082-83

 (Miss 1977); Everitt v. Lovitt, 

192 So. 2d 422, 426

 (Miss. 1966); Davis v.

Barr, 

250 Miss. 54

, 

157 So. 2d 505

 (1963)). But “where no adequate remedy is provided,

the exhaustion doctrine is not applicable.” Miss. Dep’t of Corr. v. McClure, 

386 So. 3d 372

,

377 (Miss. 2024) (internal quotation marks omitted) (citing Tiger Prod. Co., LLC v. Pace

353 So. 3d 429

, 433 (Miss. 2022)).

¶13.   Green Cross appealed the decision of MDOR in August 2022. At that time,

Mississippi Code Section 41-137-47 (Supp. 2022) only provided an administrative appeal



                                              5
process for fines, suspensions, and revocations of licenses. It was not until March 2023 that

House Bill 1158 became effective, thereby creating an administrative appeal for denials of

license applications. H.B. 1158, Reg. Sess., 2023 Miss. Laws ch. 436, § 6. Therefore, it is

undisputed that at the time Green Cross filed its appeal to the circuit court, no other

administrative remedies were available under the Act.

¶14.   Justice Sullivan writes that “ABC’s decision to deny Green Cross’s license application

is not based on substantial evidence and thus constitutes an arbitrary and capricious

decision.” Sullivan Diss. Op. ¶ 41. But Green Cross clearly states in its brief:

       As stated above, the circuit [court] found that ABC’s denial was supported by
       substantial evidence. . . . Respectfully, though, that was not and is not Green
       Cross’s argument. Rather, Green Cross argued below and argues here that
       ABC did not have the authority to deny its application, based on the plain
       language of the relevant statutes.

¶15.   On appeal, Green Cross does not identify assignments of error related to due process,

the sufficiency of evidence presented by ABC, or the appellate process with the circuit court.

In fact, in their joint supplemental brief filed with this Court, the parties acknowledge that

“Green Cross properly appealed the denial of its application to the Panola County Circuit

Court in August of 2022.” Therefore, because the issues on appeal relate solely to the

interpretation of the Act, we limit our review to these specific questions of law.

       I.     Denial of the Medical-Cannabis License Based on Proximity to a
              Church

¶16.   When applicants seek to open medical-cannabis dispensaries in Mississippi, the Act

requires certain criteria to be met in order to receive approval to operate. With regard to the

physical-location requirements, the Act provides that such dispensaries:


                                              6
       shall not be within one thousand (1,000) feet of the nearest property boundary
       line of a school, church or child care facility which exists or has acquired
       necessary real property for the operation of such facility before the date of the
       medical cannabis establishment application unless the entity has received
       approval from the school, church or child care facility and received the
       applicable waiver from their licensing agency, provided that the main point of
       entry of the cannabis establishment is not located within five hundred (500)
       feet of the nearest property boundary line of any school, church or child care
       facility[.]

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137-35

(16)(a)(ii) (Rev. 2023). In the present case, ABC denied the

application due to the proposed dispensary’s location being merely ninety-nine feet from

Wellspring Church, citing Section 41-137-35(16)(a)(ii) in its denial notice.

¶17.   Throughout the appeal, Green Cross’s position has been that Wellspring Church did

not qualify as a “church” under the Act due to its lack of a “property interest in the property”

located at 304 Heritage Drive, Suite 2. Specifically, Green Cross states in its brief:

       [T]o the extent that ABC seeks to reiterate its argument before the circuit court
       that Wellspring is indeed a “church,” Green Cross must clarify that it does not
       and has never argued that Wellspring is not a “church” under the standard
       definition. . . . Rather, Green Cross’s argument is that the Legislature’s
       decision to make the decisive factor the property boundary line of a church
       must actually have real property interests in order to prohibit a medical
       cannabis dispensary within 1,000 feet.

(Emphasis added.)

¶18.   But the Legislature chose only to stipulate that a church either be in “exist[ence] or

ha[ve] acquired necessary real property for the operation of such facility[.]” § 41-137-

35(16)(a)(ii). We do not find the Act’s reference to the “property boundary line of a church”

as a requirement of fee-simple ownership to qualify as a church. And neither party here




                                               7
disputes that Wellspring Church existed within ninety-nine feet of the proposed dispensary

prior to Green Cross’s application.

¶19.   As explained by the circuit court:

       The Record is clear that investigations were conducted by both Appellants and
       Appellee; however, there is substantial evidence Appellee’s investigation
       showed that a church did exist within the boundary limitations set forth in
       

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137-35

(16), and that the church existed before the
       dispensary application was submitted, albeit unknown to appellant despite their
       due diligence. Furthermore, as the church was within five hundred (500) feet
       of the proposed dispensary, a waiver was not a legal option. 

Miss. Code Ann.
§ 41-137-35

(16). While Appellants urge that Wellspring Church had no
       legally cognizable property interest in 304 Heritage Drive, the [c]ourt finds
       that is not accurate. While the statute does not require a church to own land for
       the church to exist, Wellspring Church had paid a fee in order to occupy the
       property, thus it did have an interest in the property. As Wellspring Church
       ‘sprung up’ at 304 Heritage Drive, Oxford, MS, thirteen (13) days prior to
       [Green Cross] submitting the application, [the ABC’s] denial of the application
       did not violate Rule 5.03 of the URCCC.

We agree.

¶20.   Accordingly, we find that the circuit court correctly affirmed the decision of ABC in

its denial of Green Cross’s license application based on the plain language of the Act.

       II.    The Application and License Fees

¶21.   With regard to the application and license fees, the Act clearly provides that “[a]

medical-cannabis dispensary shall be subject to a one-time non-refundable license application

fee for Fifteen Thousand Dollars ($15,000.00). The annual license fee shall be a non-

refundable fee of Twenty-five Thousand Dollars ($25,000.00).” 

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137

-

35(4) (Rev. 2023).

¶22.   Additionally, Mississippi Code Section 41-137-37(5) goes on to explain:



                                              8
              No medical cannabis dispensary may be located within a
       one-thousand-five-hundred-feet radius from the main point of entry of the
       dispensary to the main point of entry of another medical cannabis dispensary.
       If the sole basis of denial by the licensing agency in refusing to issue the
       medical cannabis dispensary a license to operate is that the dispensary fails the
       distance requirement of this subsection (5), then the licensing agency may
       refund all or part of the license application fee in Section 41-137-35(5) to the
       applicant.

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137-37

(5) (Supp. 2026) (emphasis added).

¶23.   While the Act does provide a refund exception for an applicant locating within fifteen

hundred feet of another dispensary, ABC argues that the Green Cross application did not fall

under this exception so it was statutorily barred from refunding the application fee based on

the plain reading of the Act. We agree.

¶24.   Green Cross acknowledged this specific nonrefundable language in the Act. But it

argued that not refunding the application fee in this instance would be “unconscionable”

based on its “due diligence investigation,” that it was “not a frivolous application,” and that

Green Cross detrimentally relied on public information.

¶25.   In its analysis, the circuit court found that Green Cross conducted a good-faith

investigation in determining if their location would comply with the Act’s statutory

requirements. The circuit court noted Green Cross’s use of an engineer/survey expert to

measure the distance between property boundaries and the fact that Green Cross diligently

searched public records, including the tax assessor’s records and the secretary of state’s

records.

¶26.   Additionally, the circuit court noted that Green Cross’s investigation revealed that a

childcare facility was the only entity within the distance restrictions contained in Section 41-

                                               9
137-35(16) and that Green Cross had obtained the appropriate waiver as required by the Act.

The circuit court further noted the exception for proximity to other dispensaries as found in

Section 41-137-37 and reasoned the “one-time non-refundable application fee” language

contained in Section 41-137-35(4) was purposed to prevent frivolous applications, although

any reference to the prevention of frivolous applications is nowhere in the Act.

¶27.   The circuit court further held that because Green Cross proceeded on the validity of

public information, it should not have been penalized for doing so. The circuit court

reasoned that “as this new law unfolds, there will be times when facts dictate a more

conscionable resolution with further exceptions” and concluded that “not to refund the

$15,000 application fee in this unique set of facts is arbitrary.” We disagree.

¶28.   The Mississippi Constitution is clear that each branch of government is designed to

perform separate functions, pointing out that “[n]o person or collection of persons, being one

or belonging to one of these departments, shall exercise any power properly belonging to

either of the others.” Miss. Const. art 1, § 2. It is not the proper role of the Court to “decide

what a statute should provide, but to determine what it does provide.” Lawson v. Honeywell

Int’l, Inc., 

75 So. 3d 1024, 1027

 (Miss. 2011) (emphasis added) (citing Russell v. State, 

231

Miss. 176

, 

94 So. 2d 916, 917

 (1957)).

¶29.   And “courts cannot restrict or enlarge the meaning of an unambiguous statute[.]”

Green v. Cleary Water, Sewer & Fire Dist., 

910 So. 2d 1022, 1027

 (Miss. 2005) (internal

quotation marks omitted) (quoting Marx v. Broom, 

632 So. 2d 1315, 1318

 (Miss. 1994)).

When a statute is not ambiguous, “the court should simply apply the statute according to its



                                               10
plain meaning . . . .” Miss. Dep’t of Transp. v. Allred, 

928 So. 2d 152, 154

 (Miss. 2006)

(quoting City of Natchez v. Sullivan, 

612 So. 2d 1087, 1089

 (Miss. 1992)).

¶30.   The Act is clear that the only exception to the refundability of the application fee is

when an applicant chooses a location within fifteen hundred feet of an existing dispensary.

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137-37

(5). The Legislature did not provide an exception for a refund

when an application is denied based on proximity to a church, and it is certainly not within

the constitutional powers of this Court to create one. Miss. Const. art. 1, §§ 1-2.

¶31.   Further, “[i]t is not this Court’s duty to change statutory language where it sees fit, but

only to interpret the language provided by the Legislature.” City of Jackson v. City of Pearl,

358 So. 3d 621

, 626 (Miss. 2023) (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting Chandler v.

McKee, 

202 So. 3d 1269, 1274

 (Miss. 2016)). Neither the circuit court nor this Court has

the authority to place such a requirement upon ABC when the statute expressly does not.

¶32.   Green Cross argues that ABC’s return of the license fee was the exercise of discretion

when no refund exception existed in the Act. Thus, Green Cross argues that similar

discretion should be exercised for the return of the application fee. ABC returned the license

fee to Green Cross, however, because “no license [was] created and therefore there [was]

nothing for the remitted annual license fee to be applied to.” We agree. The return of the

license fee based on the denial of the application does not conflict with the plain language

of Act, but the return of the application fee for reasons other than those expressly permitted

in Section 41-137-37(5) does. As a result, Green Cross’s argument is without merit.




                                               11
                                      CONCLUSION

¶33.   On direct appeal, we reverse the circuit court’s judgment ordering ABC to refund

Green Cross’s $15,000 application fee. On cross-appeal, we affirm the circuit court’s

judgment affirming the denial of Green Cross’s medical-cannabis-dispensary license.

¶34.   ON DIRECT APPEAL: REVERSED; ON CROSS-APPEAL: AFFIRMED.

    COLEMAN, P.J., GRIFFIS, WILSON AND TOLLISON, JJ., CONCUR.
RANDOLPH, C.J., DISSENTS WITH SEPARATE WRITTEN OPINION.
SULLIVAN, J., DISSENTS WITH SEPARATE WRITTEN OPINION JOINED BY
KING, P.J., AND ISHEE, J.

       RANDOLPH, CHIEF JUSTICE, DISSENTING:

¶35.   Green Cross was never offered constitutional due process. The majority attempts to

brush aside this constitutional violation by asserting “Green Cross raises no procedural or due

process concerns,” Maj. Op. ¶ 11, but Green Cross did brief a due process violation. In

stating the standard of review to this Court, Green Cross wrote:

       “In reviewing the decisions of administrative agencies, [appellate courts] will
       entertain the appeal only to determine: whether or not the order of the
       administrative agency . . . violated some statutory or constitutional right of the
       complaining party.” Shird v. Miss. State Dept. of Mental Health, 

785 So. 2d
275, 278

 (Miss. 2001) (citation omitted).

Green Cross also argued that the trial court erred by excluding its evidence, which it deemed

“patently unfair.” Green Cross was clearly arguing that its rights were violated by not being

allowed to introduce evidence.

¶36.   “This Court has held that ‘an administrative [agency] must afford minimum

procedural due process under the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution

and under Art. 3, § 14 of the Mississippi Constitution consisting of (1) notice and (2)


                                              12
opportunity to be heard.’” Molden v. Miss. State Dep’t of Health, 

730 So. 2d 29, 35

 (Miss.

1998) (alteration in original) (quoting Booth v. Miss. Emp. Sec. Comm’n, 

588 So. 2d 422,

428

 (Miss. 1991)). This requires “notice reasonably calculated, under all the circumstances,

to apprise interested parties of the pendency of the action and to afford them an opportunity

to present their” case. Miss. Bd. of Veterinary Med. v. Geotes, 

770 So. 2d 940, 943

 (Miss.

2000) (internal quotation mark omitted) (quoting City of Tupelo v. Miss. Emp. Sec.

Comm’n, 

748 So. 2d 151, 153

 (Miss. 1999)). “[D]ue process is flexible and calls for such

procedural protections as the particular situation demands.” Tippah Cnty. v. LeRose, 

283 So.

3d 149

, 151 (Miss. 2019) (internal quotation mark omitted) (quoting Daricek Living Tr. v.

Hancock Cnty. ex rel. Bd. of Supervisors, 

34 So. 3d 587, 597

 (Miss. 2010)).

¶37.   This Court has also held that

       even in the absence of a statutory provision therefor, notice and hearing may
       often be necessary to comply with the constitutional requirement [of due
       process]; but the necessity must depend somewhat on the nature of the right
       affected by the . . . action, the nature of the power exercised, the existence of
       factors other than the requisite of a hearing which operate to safeguard the
       rights of individuals and to prevent arbitrary action on the part of officials, and
       the urgency of public need requiring prompt action without the delay
       necessitated by notice and hearing.

Id.

 (alterations in original) (quoting Oliphant v. Carthage Bank, 

224 Miss. 386, 411

, 

80 So.

2d 63, 73

 (1955)).

¶38.   When the legislature initially passed the Mississippi Medical Cannabis Act on

February 2, 2022, the legislature required direct appeal of license application denials to

circuit courts rather than requiring an administrative appeal. 

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137

-

35(21) (Supp. 2022); 

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137-59

 (Supp. 2022). The Alcoholic Beverage

                                               13
Control (“ABC”) denied Green Cross’s license application without a hearing on August 5,

2022, and instructed the then-pro se Green Cross to appeal to a circuit court. Green Cross did

so on August 8, 2022. On March 27, 2023, the legislature amended the statute to provide for

an administrative appeals process. 

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137-47

(1) (Rev. 2023); 

Miss. Code

Ann. § 41-137-59

 (Rev. 2023). On May 15, 2023 the parties had already begun briefing the

appellate court, but Green Cross was in the appellate court absent ever having a hearing

before the agency or having an opportunity to submit evidence for an appellate record. In the

appellate record, however, an email was included although it was dated a month and a half

after the agency had denied the application. Green Cross was denied an “opportunity to be

heard,” a violation of due process under the United States and Mississippi Constitutions.

Molden, 

730 So. 2d at 35

; Geotes, 

770 So. 2d at 943

.

¶39.     Preventing a party from presenting any evidence is a violation of due process that

amounts to plain error. Because Green Cross was offered no fair opportunity to be heard, I

would reverse the judgment of the Circuit Court of Panola County and would remand this

case with instructions for the circuit court to enter an order remanding this case to ABC for

a full and complete administrative appeal.

         SULLIVAN, JUSTICE, DISSENTING:

¶40.     Respectfully, I dissent. I agree with the circuit court’s ruling that Green Cross’s

application fee should be refunded but for different reasons than those cited by the circuit

court.




                                             14
¶41.   Mississippi Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) prosecutes this appeal from the circuit

court’s order that ABC refund Green Cross’s $15,000 application fee.2 But as the record

submitted by ABC to the circuit court clearly illustrates, ABC’s decision to deny Green

Cross’s license application is not based on substantial evidence and thus constitutes an

arbitrary and capricious decision. Pub. Emps.’ Ret. Sys. v. Marquez, 

774 So. 2d 421, 430


(Miss. 2000) (“If an administrative agency’s decision is not based on substantial evidence,

it necessarily follows that the decision is arbitrary and capricious.” (citing Miss. State Dep’t

of Health v. Natchez Cmty. Hosp., 

743 So. 2d 973, 976

 (Miss. 1999)). ABC’s determination

that a distance restriction existed under the Mississippi Medical Cannabis Act (the Act) is

supported by nothing other than uncorroborated hearsay within hearsay. While hearsay may

be admissible in an administrative proceeding, “uncorroborated hearsay [by itself] is not

substantial evidence[.]” Williams v. Miss. Emp. Sec. Comm’n, 

395 So. 2d 964, 966

 (Miss.

1981); see Noxubee Cnty. Bd. of Educ. v. Givens, 

481 So. 2d 816, 820

 (Miss. 1985).

¶42.   Further, when Green Cross sought to supplement the record on appeal to the circuit

court with documentation necessary for a determination as to whether an actual-distance

restriction existed under the Act, ABC successfully moved to quash it. Now on appeal to this

Court, ABC renews its objection to these documents and asks that they be excluded from

consideration by this Court, while reminding us that a court exceeds its authority if it allows

evidence to be entered that is outside the record. Bd. of Law Enf’t Officers Standards &

Training v. Butler, 

672 So. 2d 1196, 1199

 (Miss. 1996).

       2
         ABC and the Mississippi Department of Revenue (the DOR), not Green Cross, filed
the notice of appeal challenging the circuit court’s order that the application fee be refunded.

                                              15
¶43.   Both the United States and Mississippi Constitutions guarantee due process of law

before an administrative agency. McFadden v. Miss. State Bd. of Med. Licensure, 

735 So.

2d 145, 158

 (Miss. 1999) (citing U.S. Const. amend. XIV; Miss. Const. art. 3, § 14).

Administrative actions must be “conducted in a fair and impartial manner, free from any just

suspicion of prejudice, unfairness, fraud or oppression.” Miss. State Bd. of Health v.

Johnson, 

197 Miss. 417

, 

19 So. 2d 445, 447

 (1944) (internal quotation mark omitted)

(quoting State ex rel.Williams v. Whitman, 

156 So. 705, 710

 (Fla. 1934)). “Due process

always stands as a constitutionally grounded procedural safety net in administrative

proceedings.” McGowan v. Miss. State Oil & Gas Bd., 

604 So. 2d 312, 318

 (Miss. 1992),

cert. denied, 

506 U.S. 1052

, 

113 S. Ct. 976

, 

122 L. Ed. 2d 130

 (1993). Notwithstanding this

Court’s “policy of according great weight and deference” to agencies discharging their

responsibilities, agencies “do not have carte blanche authority to do as they please,” and they

“no less than others are subject to the rule of law the ultimate guardian of which in this state

is this Court.” Givens, 

481 So. 2d at 819

. When an agency “has acted in a manner which

is arbitrary and capricious and where its actions are not supported by substantial evidence,

[our courts] and ultimately this Court have the responsibility to intervene.” 

Id.

 at 820 (citing

Madison Cnty. Bd. of Educ. v. Miles, 

252 Miss. 711

, 

173 So. 2d 425

 (1965)).

¶44.   When ABC denied Green Cross’s license application on August 5, 2022, no

administrative-hearing process was available for license applicants under the Act, which had

just been enacted earlier that year. The Act’s administrative-hearing process was available

only to licensees aggrieved by a licensing agency’s decision. For aggrieved applicants such



                                              16
as Green Cross, their only recourse was judicial review in the circuit court sitting as an

appellate court. Cf. Miss. Ann. Code § 67-1-72 (Rev. 2026) (providing an administrative-

hearing process for applicants denied an alcohol permit under Mississippi’s Local Option

Alcoholic Beverage Control Law).

¶45.   The Legislature changed this in its 2023 session by amending Mississippi Code

Section 41-137-47 (Rev. 2023) to make the hearing process available to license applicants

as well.

¶46.   The Legislature also amended Mississippi Code Section 41-137-59 to provide that

judicial review “by the circuit court shall be based on the record made before the agency.”

Miss. Code Ann. § 41-137-59

(2)(b) (Rev. 2023). No such provision was contained in the

original 2022 Act.

¶47.   Yet ABC relied on the amended provision in its briefing to the circuit court when

objecting to Green Cross’s request to supplement the record with documents favorable to

Green Cross’s case. ABC contended that it did not use these documents when determining

whether Green Cross was eligible for a medical-cannabis-dispensary license. The circuit

court agreed with ABC and rejected Green Cross’s request.

¶48.   The record ABC submitted to the circuit court in support of its decision consisted of

three emails sent by ABC Enforcement Agent Jacob Abel to ABC Chief Enforcement Agent

Pat Daily and an affidavit by Agent Daily attesting that he had “reviewed the attached

printouts of electronic mail[.]” The circuit court based its decision on what was contained

in these emails—two generated on August 2, 2022, and one generated on September 21,



                                            17
2022, after Green Cross had already filed its petition in the circuit court on August 8, 2022.

ABC submitted no other documentation.

¶49.   In the first August 2 email, Agent Abel said he recalled a conversation he had with

the planning commissioner for the city of Oxford who told him about a possible conflict with

a proposed cannabis dispensary and a church operating in a strip mall located next to the

dispensary’s proposed location.3 Agent Abel said he then spoke by telephone with an

employee for the owner of the strip mall who said a church was using a building in the strip

mall to hold church services, but she did not know the church’s name. The employee called

Agent Abel back and told him the church’s name is Wellspring Church, and it currently has

a contract to purchase the entire building. Agent Abel said he attempted to contact the

church but was unsuccessful and would “attempt to get further conformation on the possible

real estate contract and compare it to Green Cross’s . . . application date.”

¶50.   In the second August 2 email, Agent Abel said he drove by the location and saw a

realtor’s sign in front of the strip mall. He contacted the realtor who told him the strip mall

was under contract with a church and was scheduled to close in ninety days. The realtor said

the church could begin holding church services before closing for a fee, which had been paid.

The realtor said the church had been occupying the building since July 15.

¶51.   Based on these two emails, ABC informed Green Cross in an email on August 5,

2022, that its license application had been denied based on a distance restriction under the

Act. The email did not inform Green Cross why there was a distance restriction; it simply



       3
           The proposed dispensary location was not a part of the strip mall.

                                              18
told Green Cross that if it wished to appeal the denial it must file a petition in the circuit

court within twenty days of this decision. ABC refunded Green Cross the $25,000

nonrefundable annual license fee, but it did not refund the $15,000 application fee.

¶52.   Karen Crumpler, on behalf of Green Cross and proceeding pro se, filed a petition in

the circuit court on August 8, 2022. Counsel for Green Cross entered an appearance in the

case on September 21, 2022. That same day, after ABC already had issued its final decision

on August 8, Agent Abel sent a third email to Agent Daily of the DOR legal division saying

he had spoken with the pastor for Wellspring Church, who had said the church was still

planning on “closing/buying” the building. Agent Abel said he accessed the church’s

Facebook page and observed a church service recorded on July 17 in which the pastor said

the service was the Church’s first service in the building. Agent Abel concluded the email

by saying he would provide further documentation once he received another email from the

church’s pastor.

¶53.   That ABC was able to have the September 21 email included in the record submitted

to the circuit court, while having documentation submitted by Green Cross excluded, shows

just how unfair the process was for Green Cross.

¶54.   Our review of this case should end here. These emails and an affidavit attesting to

them is all that comprises the record ABC submitted to the circuit court in support of its

decision to deny Green Cross’s license application. This is not substantial evidence, and

ABC knew or should have known that further documentation was necessary for review in the

circuit court—particularly in this instance when no administrative-hearing process was



                                             19
available to license applicants such as Green Cross. But ABC hastily made its decision

without any supporting documentation and later (through the DOR’s legal division) told the

circuit court that such documentation was immaterial or unnecessary for its decision. I think

not.

¶55.   Even though the Act did not provide an administrative-hearing process for license

applicants when ABC denied Green Cross’s license application, it did provide for judicial

review of ABC’s decision. Thus, Rule 5.03 of the Uniform Civil Rules of Circuit and

County Court Practice, which governs the scope of appeals from administrative agencies,

applies. The rule provides:

             On appeals from administrative agencies the court will only entertain
       an appeal to determine if the order or judgment of the lower authority:

              1.     Was supported by substantial evidence; or

              2.     Was arbitrary or capricious; or

              3.     Was beyond the power of the lower authority to make; or

              4.     Violated some statutory or constitutional right of the
                     complaining party.

UCRCCC 5.03. The Act provided the same standards requirement for the administrative-

hearing process available only to aggrieved licensees when ABC made its decision in this

case. S.B. 2095, Reg. Sess., 2022 Miss. Laws, ch. 303, § 24.

¶56.   This Court has been clear: an administrative decision that is not supported by

substantial evidence constitutes an arbitrary and capricious decision and will not stand on

appeal. Givens, 

481 So. 2d at 820

 (affirming chancery court’s order requiring a school board



                                             20
to reinstate a teacher because board’s decision to discharge the teacher was based on

uncorroborated hearsay and not substantial evidence); Marquez, 

774 So. 2d at 430

 (affirming

circuit court’s order to reverse agency’s decision and grant state-employee-disability benefits

because the agency’s decision to deny benefits was not supported by substantial evidence);

Natchez Cmty. Hosp., 

743 So. 2d at 976

 (affirming chancery court’s order to vacate and set

aside Mississippi Department of Health’s grant of a certificate of need for lack of substantial

evidence); Freeman v. Pub. Emps.’ Ret. Sys., 

822 So. 2d 274, 282

 (Miss. 2002) (reversing

circuit court’s ruling to affirm agency decision to terminate employee’s disability benefits

when the decision was not supported by substantial evidence and remanding to circuit court

with instructions to remand to the agency for reinstatement of employee’s disability status

along with back pay); Pub. Emps.’ Ret. Sys. v. Shurden, 

822 So. 2d 258, 264

 (Miss. 2002)

(affirming circuit court’s reversal of agency decision to deny disability benefits because

decision was not supported by substantial evidence and was thus arbitrary and capricious);

Miles, 

173 So. 2d at 427

 (affirming chancery court’s order that principal be reinstated when

his removal by the board was not based on substantial evidence).

¶57. That counsel for Green Cross says in its brief on appeal that the “substantial evidence”

standard is not their argument is of no moment. This comment strikes merely as inadvertent

given Green Cross’s claim throughout that “there is no proof at all that Wellspring ever had

any legally cognizable interest whatsoever in the property prior to Green Cross’s application

on July 30, 2022.” The comment runs counter to Green Cross’s claim that ABC duplicitously

told the circuit court that there was an “uncontroverted contractual relationship,” then asked



                                              21
the court to exclude that contract from the record. And it runs completely counter to Green

Cross’s attempt to supplement the record with necessary documentation.

¶58.   Moreover, it was ABC, not Green Cross, that filed a notice of appeal claiming the

circuit court erred by ordering a refund. ABC tells this Court that “[t]he Department does

not have the authority to refund the application fee and to do so would violate the plain

language of the statutes.”4 ABC instructs us that the Legislature’s reason for making the

application fee nonrefundable “makes logical sense, as the Department of Revenue and

Department of Health expend considerable time and resources investigating the applicants,

the documents, and the proposed property locations as part of the process.”

¶59.   That does make logical sense. But as the scant record before us impresses, that was

not done in this case—illustrated further by ABC’s disclosure to the circuit court that any

information other than what Agent Abel was told by third parties was immaterial to its

decision.

¶60.   Furthermore, ABC claims that by ordering a refund of the application fee, the circuit

court erred as a matter of law. But whether an agency’s decision is supported by substantial

evidence also concerns a matter of law. Miss. Div. of Medicaid v. All. Health Ctr., 

174 So.

3d 254, 261

 (Miss. 2015) (“reviewing an agency’s decision for the support of substantial

evidence is an inquiry into the sufficiency of the evidence, which presents a question of law,

Rogers v. State, 

599 So. 2d 930, 932

 (Miss. 1992)[.]”). Even in cases in which judicial

review is limited by a writ of certiorari, and courts are confined to the examination of

       4
         Yet ABC found discretion to refund the nonrefundable license fee—for which the
Act also makes no express provision.

                                             22
questions of law arising or appearing on the face of the record, a decision not supported by

substantial evidence runs contrary to the law and will not stand. See, e.g., Gill v. Miss. Dep’t

of Wildlife Conservation, 

574 So. 2d 586, 591

 (Miss. 1990) (addressing Mississippi Code

Section 11-51-95 (Rev. 2019), which provides certiorari review of decisions by inferior

tribunals).

¶61.   Although Agent Abel alluded to the necessity of supporting documentation in the first

August 2 email, ABC simply went with what Agent Abel said he was told by others and

issued a final decision denying Green Cross’s license application on August 5. Then, after

Green Cross filed an appeal in circuit court, ABC buttressed its August 5 final decision with

yet another email from Agent Abel reporting what he was told by a third party and

mentioning once again that further documentation would be forthcoming.

¶62.   ABC’s course of action in this particular case evinces arbitrary and capricious

conduct. This Court has said that “[a]n administrative act is ‘arbitrary’ when it is not done

according to reason or judgment, but depending on the will alone.” Bay St. Louis Cmty.

Ass’n v. Comm’n on Marine Res., 

808 So. 2d 885, 890

 (Miss. 2001) (citing Burks v. Amite

Cnty. Sch. Dist., 

708 So. 2d 1366, 1370

 (Miss. 1998)). “An administrative act is capricious

when done without reason, in a whimsical manner, implying either lack of understanding or

a disregard for the surrounding facts and settled controlling principles.” 

Id.

 (citing Burks,

708 So. 2d at 1370

).

¶63.   By mere happenstance, ABC heard that a church might be operating near Green

Cross’s proposed location. ABC then summarily concluded that a distance restriction existed



                                              23
under the Act based solely on what ABC was told by third persons. While slight inquiry by

an investigative body charged with such duties may suffice in circumstances in which the

existence of an entity listed by Section 41-137-35(16) is factually obvious and indisputable

so that no reasonable person could contest, that was not the case here.

¶64.   These circumstances presented a factual question as to whether a church “exists or has

acquired necessary real property for the operation of such facility” as contemplated by

Section 41-137-35(16) so as to preclude Green Cross from receiving a license to operate at

its proposed location. ABC thus had the duty and responsibility to shore up its investigation

into this matter with documentation necessary for adequate appellate review of its final

decision. ABC, however, doubled down on its course of action with the contention that

supporting documentation was unnecessary for its decision and that such documentation was

outside the record, thus precluding any consideration of it by a reviewing court.

¶65.   Karen Crumpler, on behalf of Green Cross, did everything that reasonably could be

expected of her to do under the circumstances to comply with the Act. ABC, by its own

admission, did not. ABC then utilized to its end the lack of adequate process available to

Crumpler at the time. And rather than leave well enough alone with the circuit court’s order

that ABC issue Green Cross a refund, ABC now comes to this Court claiming that its

decision to deny the license application was based on substantial evidence and that we must

reverse the circuit court’s order.

¶66.   As shown, ABC’s decision was not based on substantial evidence, and it should have

been reversed as a matter of law. Givens, 

481 So. 2d at 820

. The majority, however, accedes



                                             24
to ABC, finding as fact from unsubstantiated hearsay that a church was in “existence” prior

to Green Cross’s submitting its application.

¶67.   First, this Court should not be determining the scope and applicablity of Section 41-

137-35(16) on the evidence of this case, which is no evidence at all under this Court’s

precedent. Williams, 

395 So. 2d at 966

; Givens, 

481 So. 2d at 820

. Second, as matter of

common sense, the term exists means more than mere existence as evinced by the

conjunction “or” before the language “has acquired necessary real property for the operation

of such facility.” Were it not to, then any entity (no matter its temporary status) conducting

church services would fall within the purview of Section 41-137-35(16), leaving its

applicability to the whims of a licensing agency interpreting the section as it sees fit.

¶68.   While I disagree with the circuit court’s holding that ABC’s August 5 final decision

was based on substantial evidence, I agree with the court’s order that ABC refund Green

Cross’s $15,000 application fee. Given the length of time that has passed since this case

began, as well as the procedural posture of it, refund of the application fee is the proper

remedy.

¶69.   Thus, I would reverse the circuit court’s order affirming ABC’s denial of Green

Cross’s application, and I would affirm the circuit court’s order that ABC refund Green

Cross’s application fee.

       KING, P.J., AND ISHEE, J., JOIN THIS OPINION.




                                               25

Our administrative lawyer in Paris assists clients in matters of this kind.


Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.