Administrative United Kingdom

MM v The Secretary of State for the Home Department

Official source

First-tier Tribunal
(Immigration and Asylum Chamber)

Appeal Number: PA/61613/2025

THE IMMIGRATION ACTS

Heard at Hatton Cross
On 27 October 2026

Before

FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL JUDGE Farmer

Between

M.M.
(ANONYMITY ORDER MADE)

Appellant

and

THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT

Respondent

Representation:

For the Appellant: Ms J Weatherall, counsel – instructed by Ata & Co Solicitors

For the Respondent: Mr S Grewal, Home Office Presenting Officer

DECISION AND REASONS

1. This is the decision of the Tribunal in the appeal of the appellant against the decision of the respondent made on 20 March 2025.

Anonymity

2. In making this decision I have considered that justice being administered openly and in public is a fundamental tenet of the justice system but it may be qualified by the interests of the parties and family members. I have decided to make an anonymity direction because the importance of facilitating the discharge of the obligations of the United Kingdom under the Refugee Convention in the circumstances of this case outweighs the principle of open justice.

Background

3. The appellant is an Afghan national, who arrived in the United Kingdom on 5 October 2024 and claimed asylum on the same day. The appellant claims to be at risk on return from the Taliban. Following his father’s death in 2021, the appellant, together with his mother, three sisters, and younger brother went to live with his uncle. His uncle was a Mullah and taught Islam religiously. He was connected to the Taleban and taught their children the Quran. The Taliban would visit his uncle at his home and proposed on multiple occasions that the appellant’s three sisters married local Taliban members. His uncle supported the marriage but the appellant’s family refused the proposals and following a visit in August 2024 the Taliban attacked the appellant and his younger brother. The appellant was hit in the face one of his teeth was broken. His younger brother was shot and killed, he was 15 years old. Following this, the appellant stabbed one of the men with a fruit knife. He escaped with his three sisters and mother using the back door and then travelled to Nimrooz by car with the help of a neighbour. They stayed there at his aunt’s house for a week until he left with the help of a smuggler in August 2024. He was separated from his mother and sisters in Greece and does not know their whereabouts although he has attempted to trace them through the Red Cross. He fears that if returned to Afghanistan he would be put in prison or killed by the Taliban because he injured one of the Taliban members and he opposes the Taliban.

4. The respondent accept the appellant’s identity and nationality. It is accepted that his opposition of the Taliban engages the Convention on the grounds of political opinion. The refusal letter states that opposing the marriage of his sisters is not a Convention reason. The respondent accept the treatment he fears would amount persecution as the appellant fears death. The respondent accepted no material facts of his claim but did accept that if he established his fear of the Taleban and the core of his claim there will be no sufficiency of protection and internal relocation would not be an option. The respondent made adverse credibility findings in the refusal letter which were extended and added to in the respondent’s review.

The Hearing

5. The hearing took place face to face. It was recorded using the Cloud Video Platform. That recording is the record of proceedings and should be consulted in the event of any dispute about what was said at the hearing. Counsel for the appellant attended the hearing remotely by CVP link, all the remaining parties to the hearing attended the hearing centre.

Issues

6. As a preliminary issue I was invited to treat the appellant as a vulnerable. I have his medical records and he has been suffering with low mood for a considerable time. He is on sertraline at 100 mg which has been prescribed for depression, he attends talking therapy and is on the waiting list for further support. His diagnosis brings him within the definition of a vulnerable adult. Applying SB (vulnerable adult: credibility) Ghana [2019] UKUT 00398 (IAC), so as to ensure the best practicable conditions for the appellant to give evidence, I treated the appellant as a vulnerable witness, but I reserved my findings on the relationship between the vulnerability and the evidence adduced. I took into consideration [13] of the Senior President of the Tribunal’s Practice Direction of the FtTIAC, 1 November 2024, and had regard to the latest version of the Equal Treatment Bench Book. In these circumstances I directed that any questions put to him be short and simple, and any change in the subject matter of questioning should also be signposted. He was told he could take a break at any time during the hearing. Although I observed he was slightly distressed during the translation of the respondent’s submissions, he was able to give oral evidence without needing a break.

7. The parties agreed that the issues the Tribunal must decide are:

(a) On the balance of probabilities, taking the appellant's claim at its highest, is there a Convention reason?

(b) On the balance of probabilities does the appellant fear persecution for that Convention reason?

(c) Is it reasonably likely that the appellant would be persecuted for that Convention reason?

(d) Is it reasonably likely there would not be sufficient protection available?

(e) Is it reasonably likely that the appellant could not internally relocate?

Evidence

8. All the documents I was referred to were uploaded onto myHMCTS. I had a consolidated bundle [CB] of 447 pdf pages which contained the appellant’s bundle, and skeleton argument, respondent’s bundle and review as well as background evidence and the CPINs. I heard oral evidence from the appellant with the assistance of an interpreter in the language Dari. The appellant confirmed that he understood the interpreter at the commencement of the hearing and no issues with translation arose.

Legal Framework

9. To succeed in an appeal on asylum grounds, the appellant must show a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason (race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, political opinion). The burden of proof rests on the appellant. As the asylum claim was made on or after 28 June 2022, pursuant to s32 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022, in considering whether the appellant qualifies as a refugee, I must apply a two-stage test. As per the guidance from DS (NABA s. 32(2)(a); (JCK amended) Afghanistan [2026] UKUT 00413 I must first determine the following matters on the balance of probabilities:

(a) Whether, on the balance of probabilities, the appellant has a characteristic which could cause them to fear persecution for one of the five reasons set out in the Refugee Convention. This calls for a specific finding of fact.

(b) Whether, on the balance of probabilities, the appellant does in fact fear persecution for that convention reason? This requires an assessment of the appellant’s credibility and may be informed by findings about the probable likelihood of the truth of their account of their past experiences; the likelihood of the truth of their account of their present circumstances and any section 8 considerations.

10. If so, I must go on to determine whether it is reasonably likely (i.e. to the lower standard of proof) that:

(a) The appellant would be persecuted for that Convention reason;

(b) There would not be sufficient protection available; and

(c) The appellant could not internally relocate.

11. My approach to assessing credibility comes from KB & AH (credibility-structured approach) Pakistan [2017] UKUT 491 (IAC) where the Upper Tribunal commended consideration of sufficiency of detail, internal consistency, external consistency and plausibility. I consider any documents along with all the evidence in the round. I am also conscious that just because a person has lied about one thing does not mean he has lied about another.

12. Section 8 Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants etc) Act 2004 means that behaviour designed or likely to conceal information, mislead, obstruct or delay consideration of a claim, and claims made after a negative decision has been made or after there was an opportunity to make a claim in a safe country are damaging to credibility.

Facts

13. The respondent made a number of adverse credibility findings in both the reason for refusal letter and the review document.

14. The respondent found a number of aspects of the account to be implausible and inconsistent with external information. Two credibility points were raised in the Refusal letter and in the respondent’s review these points were added to. I raise this at the outset as the appellant was criticised for not dealing with the adverse credibility points. However very few issues were raised against him in the Refusal and he has dealt with these in his witness statement. The review, which was completed after the appellant’s evidence was filed, goes into considerable more detail in respect of the appellant’s claim and I therefore make no adverse finding that this was not dealt with in his written evidence as many new credibility or implausibility points were raised. To the extent that the appellant was cross examined about these points I have made findings on his credibility when considering all the evidence in the round.

15. The first point taken by Mr Grewal was that the appellant has been inconsistent about how the Taliban knew that he had younger sisters who they then wanted to marry. The appellant initially said they learned about them as his uncle told them about his sisters. However in his witness statement he says they learned about them on their visits to the house. Mr Grewel sought to distinguish between a deliberate imparting of information as opposed to indirectly finding out about them. I find that this reads far too much into the words used by the appellant and I do not agree that these accounts are mutually inconsistent. I find that the appellant gave a clear and consistent answer when questioned. The Taliban learned about his sisters on their visits to the house during which time his uncle told them about his sisters in an attempt to ingratiate himself with them. I make no adverse credibility finding against the appellant in respect of this and find there is no internal inconsistency in his evidence.

16. A further inconsistency was raised, namely that the appellant said that the Taliban had approached his family five or six times in order to propose marriage, he then later said that he had no previous interaction with them prior to the August 2024 incident. The appellant was asked about this in his evidence and explained that they were visiting his uncles and not visiting the appellant. Again, I find his answers are entirely consistent. His uncle was aligned to the Taliban and taught their children. The appellant was ideologically opposed to them and when they visited the home had nothing to do with them. It is clear that the uncle supported the marriage and therefore the proposals came through him. There is nothing inconsistent in the account and I make no adverse credibility finding against the appellant.

17. As a general point the respondent criticises the appellant for failing to give sufficient detail in his screening interview, or that by amplifying and expanding upon his account in his substantive interviews, this undermines the core of his claim. He is criticised for then giving further detail in his witness statement. As a general point I accept the principle that the appellant should be able to summarise his claim in his screening interview and any failure to mention core elements of his claim at his screening interview may result in an adverse credibility finding. However, I find the appellant did summarise the core of his claim. In his screening interview he stated that Taliban members wished to marry his three younger sisters and he was opposed to this. He mentions that his brother was killed in an altercation and that they fled the country. This is his case in summary and I make no adverse finding that he did not provide more detail when he specifically told to summarise his case. He has not added any new elements to the core of his claim but has, quite rightly, added further detail when asked and given the opportunity to do so.

18. The appellant was specifically criticised in cross examination and in submissions for not raising in his interviews how his brother was killed. In his witness statement he states that he was shot three or four times in the chest but does not mention this in his interview. However, the appellant has been clear since he entered the United Kingdom that his brother was killed. I have given anxious scrutiny to the screening interview and the substantive interviews and at no point is he asked about how his brother was killed. He has remained consistent about his brother’s death and had he been specifically asked how he was killed and given a different answer that might be a point taken against him. However he was never asked the question and nor was it put to him in his interviews that he had not given sufficient detail about the way his brother was killed. In the screening interview the appellant does say that his brother was taken away and killed. When he was asked about that in cross examination he said that he thought the interpreter may have made a mistake as he is clear that his brother was always killed inside the house.

19. The respondent made an adverse credibility finding that the appellant has developed his account over time. In his first asylum interview he says that the Taliban attacked him and killed his brother and he subsequently stabbed a Taliban member before escaping. In the second interview he added to this that his uncle and four cousins became involved in the fight with the Taliban which enabled him to escape. The respondent found this was a significant detail which was absent from his earlier account and appears to have been introduced in response to concerns regarding the plausibility of his escape. The respondent also found the account of his claimed escape to be implausible. The respondent did not find it plausible that he would starve a Taliban member in the stomach and still be able to escape through a door gather together his mother and three sisters lock the door behind him and leave without being apprehended. The respondent found that given his brother had been shot three or four times in the chest and the Taliban members were clearly armed one of their members he would have been unlikely to escape in the manner he claims.

20. The appellant was cross examined about these issues but has remained consistent in his account. I find the fact that he has given further detail as he has been asked further questions does not undermine the core of his claim.

21. The appellant claimed to have stabbed a member of the Taliban on the night they visited his home before escaping with his mother and three sisters with the help of the neighbour. The respondent found this account be implausible because he has failed to demonstrate how he did this. In addition it was found to be implausible that his neighbour would decide to help them knowing the risk that he was putting himself in. The appellant was cross examined about these issues. He said that the neighbour had heard a noise and come out of his house. In his oral and written evidence he refers to his neighbour hearing gunshots and having witnessed the appellant running out of the house with his mother and sisters. Hearing a noise, an altercation or a gunshot are not inconsistent with each other. He did not explain to the neighbour that he had stabbed a member of the Taliban and cannot explain why he decided to help them other than it is common to help your neighbour in Afghanistan and it was an act of humanity. It is not incredible that a neighbour would help in the circumstances and I put this evidence in the balance when considering all the evidence in the round.

22. The appellant was asked why locking an internal door would have prevented the Taliban from pursuing him. It is not suggested that this meant that they were all locked within the home and could not leave but rather it delayed their pursuit and in any event the altercation was continuing in his absence. It is entirely credible that having seen his brother being shot and having seen blood coming out of his chest he would not stop and check to see if his brother was dead. When he was asked in cross-examination about this he said that he was just frightened for himself and wanted to get out. I find he has given a consistent and credible account of his actions on this night.

23. The respondent found it was implausible that the appellant was able to remain in Afghanistan for one week after stabbing a member of the Taliban. However, the appellant and his family remained in hiding at his aunt’s home whilst arrangements were made for them to leave the country and I find there is nothing inherently implausible about this. They were some 3 hours away by car and did not remain in the local area.

24. Mr Grewel submitted that various different accounts were given about who paid for the agent. The appellant has said his maternal aunt paid and his maternal aunt’s husband. He has also said that his mother contributed her jewellery to assist in the cost. He was pushed in his interview on what the cost was and he said, “say 9,000 euros”. He accepts this is an estimate that he does not know the actual cost. I do not find the fact that he guessed what the cost is does not undermine his claim. Nor do his answers about who funded the agent because it is clear that the money was raised by his maternal aunt and her husband with his mother contributing what she could.

25. The appellant was cross examined about the journey to Nimrooz. In his oral evidence he said they used the mountains or the smugglers path and not the main road. No inconsistency was put to him with his previous evidence and he was not invited to explain whether or not the neighbour also used a bypass. The difference in time between 2 to 3 hours for the journey and 3 to 4 hours is not a material difference which adversely affects his credibility.

26. The appellant has attempted to trace his mother and sisters via the Red Cross tracing system. I accept the submission of the respondent that this does not materially assist the core of his claim and is a neutral factor.

27. The appellant relies on the psychological report of Joanne Lackenby dated 13 March 2026 which records symptoms of anxiety, depression and PTSD. The respondent accepts that the appellant may experience mental health difficulties but notes that the report does not independently verify the claimed events in Afghanistan. The appellant has not claimed either in his evidence, or in the submissions on his behalf, that the psychological report supports his core account. Clearly, the separation from his family and all the journey of itself may have caused his current mental health symptoms as well as his claim to have witnessed his brother being shot. The report is therefore relevant to his mental health but is otherwise a neutral factor.

28. I bear in mind when assessing the evidence, as set out in Karanakaran v SSHD [2000] EWCA Civ 11 that I am not required to decide whether each alleged material fact has been established. I must evaluate all the evidence in the round, taking all of the evidence into account and giving it whatever weight it is due. I have therefore not looked at the credibility findings in isolation but taken a holistic view of the evidence.

29. The appellant did not claim asylum in either Greece or France. In Greece he claims to have been under the supervision of an agent. In France, he clearly had more freedom because a group of Afghan men offered to assist him getting to the United Kingdom. I therefore find that section 8 factors do apply however I bear in mind this is not determinative of his claim and is only one factor that I take into account when considering all the evidence in the round.

Determination of the Issues

30. It is agreed that credibility is central to this appeal. In SB (Sri Lanka) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2019] EWCA Civ 160, the Court of Appeal stated that where the credibility of the appellant is in issue, courts should adopt a variety of different evaluative techniques to assess the evidence. The court will for instance consider: (i) the consistency (or otherwise) of accounts given to investigators at different points in time; (ii) the consistency (or otherwise) of an appellant's narrative case for asylum with his actual conduct at earlier stages and periods in time; (iii) whether, on the facts found or agreed which are incontrovertible, the appellant is a person who can be categorised as a risk if returned, and, if so, as to the nature and extent of that risk (taking account of applicable Country Guidance); (iv) the adequacy (or by contrast paucity) of evidence on relevant issues that, logically, the appellant should be able to adduce in order to support his or her case ; and (v), the overall plausibility of an appellant's account. This checklist is not intended to be exhaustive, nor does every part of it have to be satisfied. Everything depends on all the circumstances of each individual case.

31. I have given anxious scrutiny to all the adverse credibility points taken in the refusal letter, the review document, and in cross-examination and submissions in the hearing before me. It is accepted by the respondent that credibility is central to the appeal. I have found for all the reasons set out above, that the appellant has given an internally consistent detailed and credible account.

32. I am satisfied on the balance of probabilities that he genuinely fears the Taliban on return because he stabbed a Taliban member and refused to allow them to marry his underage sisters. I am satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that this engages the Convention on the grounds of political opinion. I am further satisfied that the treatment he fears on return amounts to persecution. I have made positive credibility findings and taken into account and taken into account all the evidence in the round. I find on the balance of probabilities that the appellant does fear the Taliban on return due to the events of August 2024.

33. Having resolved the first two limbs of the test in the appellant’s favour, I also find to the lower standard that he is at risk on return of persecution from the Taliban and that there would be no sufficiency of protection and internal relocation would not be a realistic option, the latter two issues having being conceded by the respondent the appellant can establish the core of his claim.

34. No freestanding article 8 claim was raised by the appellant.

Notice of Decision

35. The appeal is allowed on protection grounds and the appellant is at risk on return to Afghanistan for a Convention reason namely political opinion.

ANONYMITY ORDER

36. Unless and until the Tribunal, the Upper Tribunal, or, a Court orders otherwise, pursuant To rule 13(1)(b) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Rules 2014, the appellant [and/or any member of his family, expert, witness or other person the Tribunal considers should not be identified], is granted anonymity. No-one shall publish or reveal either directly or indirectly any information, including their names or their addresses, that is likely to lead members of the public to identify them. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.

To the Respondent – Fee Award

37. As I have allowed the appeal I have considered whether or not to make a fee award. I have decided to make a fee award for any fee which has been paid or is payable because there is no reason for the fee award not to follow the outcome of the appeal.

Signature

Signed Date 28 October 2026

S L Farmer

First-tier Tribunal Judge Farmer

If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our immigration lawyer in Paris.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.