Administrative United Kingdom
Muhammed Ishaq v The Secretary of State for the Home Department
First-tier Tribunal
(Immigration and Asylum Chamber)
Appeal Number: HU/59863/2024
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
Heard at Birmingham
On 13 October 2026
Before
FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL JUDGE Elliott
Between
MUHAMMED ISHAQ
Appellant
and
THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent
Representation:
For the Appellant: Mr M. Brooks, Counsel
For the Respondent: Mr R. Lack, Home Office Presenting Officer
DECISION AND REASONS
1. This is the decision of the Tribunal in the appeal of the Appellant against the decision of the Respondent made on 30 July 2024.
BACKGROUND
2. The appellant is a citizen of Pakistan. He appeals against the respondent’s decision to refuse his human rights claim.
3. The appellant claims that he entered the United Kingdom on 16th November 2003 as a visitor but that he has remained continuously here ever since. He asserts that he has now accrued over twenty years continuous residence and that he therefore satisfies the requirements of Appendix Private Life.
4. The respondent accepts that there is evidence to demonstrate the appellant’s presence in the United Kingdom from December 2010 onwards, but does not accept that he has established his continuous residence before then. The principal issue in dispute is therefore whether the appellant has demonstrated, on the balance of probabilities, that he has been continuously resident in the United Kingdom since November 2003.
THE HEARING
5. The hearing took place face to face. It was recorded and that recording is the record of proceedings and should be consulted in the event of any dispute about what was said at the hearing.
6. I had before me a stitched bundle of evidence consisting of 596 pages (albeit with some duplication) which appears on the myHMCTS portal. I confirmed with the representatives that they both had access to the same documents.
7. I heard oral evidence from the appellant and two of his witnesses, Zahid Awan and Muhammad Riaz. They were assisted where necessary by a Mirpuri-speaking interpreter. I was satisfied that there were no apparent problems with the interpretation process. The appellant adopted the contents of his witness statement dated 28th February 2025 as his evidence in chief, and Mr Awan and Mr Riaz in turn adopted the contents of their supporting letters contained in the stitched bundle as their evidence in chief. The appellant and his witnesses were each, in turn, cross examined by Mr Lack. There was some re-examination from Mr Brooks and I asked some questions of each witness by way of clarification.
8. I then heard submissions from each of the representatives following which I reserved my decision, which is set out below. In arriving at my decision I have taken account of all the evidence, both written and oral, before me, whether or not I specifically referred to in my reasoning.
ISSUES
9. The parties agreed that the issues the Tribunal must decide are:
(a) Whether the appellant has established that, by the date of hearing, he had accrued at least twenty years' continuous residence in the United Kingdom for the purposes of Appendix Private Life.
(b) If I find that he has demonstrated twenty years continuous residence, it follows that he satisfies the requirements of Appendix Private Life.
(c) If the appellant has not established twenty years' continuous residence, it will be necessary for me to determine whether he meets any alternative requirements of the Immigration Rules, including whether there would be very significant obstacles to his integration into Pakistan.
(d) If the appellant does not satisfy the Immigration Rules, I must then determine whether the refusal of his human rights claim amounts to a disproportionate interference with his right to respect for private life under Article 8 ECHR having regard to all relevant circumstances, including the public interest considerations set out in Part 5A of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002
LEGAL FRAMEWORK
10. The relevant provisions of the Immigration Rules in this appeal are contained in Paragraph PL 5.1 of Appendix Private Life to the Immigration Rules, which provide as follows:
PL 5.1. Where the applicant is aged 18 or over on the date of application:
(a) (a) the applicant must have been continuously resident in the UK for more than 20 years; or
(b) (b) where the applicant has not been continuously resident in the UK for more than 20 years, the decision maker must be satisfied there would be very significant obstacles to the applicant’s integration into the country where they would have to live if required to leave the UK.
11. In so far as he relies on Article 8 outside the Rules, it is for the appellant to show that Article 8(1) of the ECHR is engaged and if so, it is for the respondent to show that the decision was in accordance with the law, made in pursuance of a legitimate aim and that it was proportionate to the legitimate aim. The standard of proof is the balance of probabilities. Sections 117A to 117D of the 2002 Act are relevant to any assessment under article 8 of the ECHR outside the Rules.
FINDINGS
12. I remind myself that the burden of proving that he meets the requirements of the Immigration Rules rests upon the appellant and the relevant standard is the balance of probabilities.
13. The central issue in this appeal is whether the appellant has established his continuous residence in the United Kingdom from the date of his claimed entry to the UK in November 2003 until the present day.
14. I accept that there is limited contemporaneous documentary evidence covering the period between the date of the appellant’s claimed arrival in November 2003 and the start of the documentary evidence in December 2010. The absence of documentary evidence weighs in the respondent’s favour and I have taken that factor into account.
15. However, I remind myself that there is no legal requirement that residence may only be established through documentary evidence. The question is whether, considering the evidence before me in the round, the appellant has established the facts he relies on, on the balance of probabilities.
16. In considering the appellant’s evidence, I have taken account of the contents of his witness statement, which he had adopted as his evidence in chief. I accept that in his oral evidence there were some inaccuracies and uncertainty in his recollection of date of his arrival in the UK, and his age at the date of his arrival. However I find that those are not surprising given the passage of time and the appellant’s age. He is eighty-three years old. I do not regard the discrepancies as materially undermining of the core of the appellant’s claim. They were, I find, reasonably explained in cross-examination and re-examination in answering my questions seeking clarification.
17. The appellant’s evidence has consistently been that he entered the United Kingdom in November 2003 with a visitor visa and that he has remained here ever since. I accept that the appellant's ability to demonstrate his residence through documentary evidence is limited. Following the expiry of his visa, his presence in the United Kingdom was unlawful. He would not be able to work lawfully or be able to open a bank account. I accept therefore that his ability to provide a paper trail of his presence is rather limited.
18. I found the evidence of Zahid Awan to be credible and reliable. He gave a detailed account of knowing the appellant in Pakistan, prior to his arrival in the United Kingdom, of the appellant’s arrival in the United Kingdom and of his residence at Sherwood Road in Luton over a significant period of time following his arrival. I find that his oral evidence appeared to be genuine recollection of past events rather than a fabrication.
19. I also found the evidence of Muhammad Riaz to be broadly credible. While he was not entirely precise regarding dates, I found his evidence consistent with the appellant’s account and that of Mr Awan.
20. I recognise that both witnesses are known to the appellant and are not independent. I have therefore treated their evidence with appropriate caution. I accept that there were some inconsistencies concerning dates and the precise duration of acquaintanceships. Having considered those matters carefully, I regard them as minor and attributable to the passage of time rather than indicators of unreliability. Having heard both of them give evidence and having considered their answers under cross-examination, I am satisfied that both witnesses appeared to be doing their best to assist the Tribunal honestly.
21. I attach significance to the evidence regarding the appellant’s residence at Sherwood Road. The appellant and Mr Awan both gave evidence that the appellant lived at that address following his arrival in the United Kingdom. It was a property that Mr Awan owned, and next door to the property in which he resided. Mr Awan’s evidence was that he saw the appellant regularly whilst living at Sherwood Road, at least weekly, and that he would have known if the appellant had left the country. The GP records show that the appellant was living at that address when he registered with the surgery in December 2010. Whilst that evidence does not in itself establish residence from 2003, it is consistent with the account given by the appellant and his witnesses and provides some separate support for it.
22. I also accept that both witnesses have provided accommodation to the appellant free of charge, and that from time to time have supported him financially and provided him with food. I accept therefore that would contribute to the lack of formal documentation available to enable the appellant to evidence his continuous residence between 2003 and 2010.
23. I also attach weight to the appellant’s evidence concerning his passport. His evidence was that he entered this country using a visitor visa, which was inserted into his passport, which later was retained by the respondent. He said that his passport expired in 2008 and he has not renewed it. The appellant explained that he was unable to produce the document because it remains in the respondent’s possession. That evidence was not challenged by the respondent either in submissions or by the production of any further documentary evidence.
24. I accept the appellant's evidence that the passport upon which he travelled expired in 2008 and remains in the respondent's possession. Whilst this does not establish continuous residence, it is a factor capable of lending support to the appellant's account that he had been present in the United Kingdom for a significant period before the commencement of the documentary evidence in 2010. It is also consistent with his claim that he remained in the United Kingdom following the expiry of that passport. No evidence has been produced by the respondent which is inconsistent with that account
25. I also take into account that the respondent has not provided any positive evidence to contradict the appellant’s account of arriving with a visa, and later residence in the UK. The respondent’s challenge is, in essence, based upon the absence of documentary evidence prior to 2010 rather than the existence of evidence suggesting that the appellant was not in the UK at some stage after 2003 or that he arrived at a later date. The appellant referred to his visa in his witness statement and that would have alerted the respondent to manner in which the appellant claimed to have arrived here in 2003. He also referred to his passport having expired in 2008. I bear in mind that the burden rests upon the appellant. However, I also take account of the fact that the appellant's account of entry with a visitor visa and his evidence regarding the expiry of his passport in 2008 were matters clearly identified in his evidence. No evidence was produced by the respondent which was inconsistent with that account.
26. Drawing the evidence together, I find that the appellant’s account of arriving in the United Kingdom in November 2003 has remained materially consistent. It is supported by the oral evidence of two witnesses who I found to be broadly credible and reliable. It is also consistent with the limited documentary evidence that is available. Whilst I accept that there is a substantial gap in the documentary evidence before December 2010, I do not find that sufficient, considering all the circumstances, to outweigh the credible oral evidence.
27. Having considered all the evidence in the round, I am satisfied on the balance of probabilities, that the appellant entered the United Kingdom in November 2003 and has remained here continuously since that date. I find therefore that he has established more than twenty years continuous residence in the United Kingdom.
28. I am therefore satisfied that the appellant has established that he meets the requirements of the Immigration Rules contained in Appendix Private Life. Having found that the appellant satisfies the requirements of Appendix Private Life, it follows that the refusal of his human rights claim is disproportionate under Article 8 ECHR.
NOTICE OF DECISION
29. The appeal is allowed on human rights grounds.
TO THE RESPONDENT – FEE AWARD
30. As I have allowed the appeal I have considered whether to make a fee award. I have decided not to do so as I have allowed the appeal based, to a significant extent, on the oral evidence which necessarily had to be tested in cross-examination.
Signature
Signed Date 9th November 2026
D.J.R. Elliott
First-tier Tribunal Judge Elliott
At Kohen Avocats, our immigration lawyer in Paris can review your situation.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).