Miscellaneous Etats-Unis

Portage Township of St. Joseph County, Indiana v. City of South Bend

Official source
       Pursuant to Ind. Appellate Rule 65(E), the trial court and parties shall not take any
                     action in reliance upon this Opinion until it is certified.



                                                                                          FILED
                                                                                     Oct 29 2026, 9:12 am

                                                                                          CLERK
                                                                                      Indiana Supreme Court
                                                                                         Court of Appeals
                                                                                           and Tax Court




                                             IN THE

            Court of Appeals of Indiana
           Portage Township of St. Joseph County, Indiana, and 350
                          Columbia Street, LLC,
                                 Appellants-Intervenor Defendants

                                                    v.

                                       City of South Bend,
                                           Appellee-Plaintiff


                                           October 29, 2026
                                     Court of Appeals Case No.
                                            26A-PL-711
                             Appeal from the Marshall Circuit Court
                             The Honorable Janette E. Surrisi, Judge
                                        Trial Court Cause No.
                                          50C01-2501-PL-4




Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-711 | October 29, 2026                       Page 1 of 8
                                   Opinion by Judge Vaidik
                                      Judge May concurs.
                   Chief Judge Tavitas concurs in result with separate opinion.



      Vaidik, Judge.


      Case Summary
[1]   Indiana law grants units of local government—counties, municipalities, and

      townships—broad eminent-domain power. Indiana Code section 36-7-14-20

      addresses the use of this power in “redevelopment project areas.” Specifically,

      the statute provides that if a unit’s legislative body (e.g., a city council)

      considers it necessary to use eminent domain to acquire real property in a

      redevelopment project area, it must adopt a resolution setting forth that

      determination and directing its attorney to file suit. The issue we must decide in

      this appeal is whether this statute gives a unit’s legislative body exclusive

      authority to exercise the power of eminent domain in a redevelopment project

      area, thereby precluding other unit officials from doing so. We hold that it does.

      Here, the trial court allowed a city to bring an eminent-domain action for

      property in a redevelopment project area without authorization from the city’s

      legislative body, so we reverse.


      Facts and Procedural History
[2]   In October 2024, the City of South Bend, acting at the direction of its mayor,

      filed a Complaint for Condemnation as to real property owned by Argos 316,


      Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-711 | October 29, 2026             Page 2 of 8
      LLC. The property is in a redevelopment project area established by the South

      Bend Redevelopment Commission. Portage Township of St. Joseph County

      had previously contracted to buy the property and completed the purchase

      shortly after the City filed its complaint. The Township, along with 350

      Columbia Street, LLC, which held easements on the property, intervened in the

      case and filed objections to the condemnation. As relevant here, Portage

      Township and 350 Columbia Street (“Objectors”) objected under Indiana Code

      section 36-7-14-20(a), which provides:


              If the legislative body of the unit that established the department
              of redevelopment considers it necessary to acquire real property
              in a redevelopment project area by the exercise of the power of
              eminent domain, the legislative body shall adopt a resolution
              setting out its determination to exercise that power and directing
              its attorney to file a petition in the name of the unit on behalf of
              the department of redevelopment, in the circuit or superior court
              of the county in which the property is situated.


      Objectors claimed that the City’s condemnation action is illegal because it was

      not authorized by the South Bend Common Council—the City’s legislative

      body—as contemplated by this statute. After briefing and oral argument, the

      trial court overruled this objection and the others. The court concluded that

      Common Council authorization under Section 36-7-14-20 is just one way, not

      the only way, for the City to use eminent domain to acquire real property in a

      redevelopment project area.


[3]   Objectors now appeal.



      Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-711 | October 29, 2026            Page 3 of 8
      Discussion and Decision
[4]   Objectors contend that the trial court erred by overruling their objection under

      Section 36-7-14-20. 1 The trial court’s decision turned on the interpretation of

      that statute, which is a pure question of law, so our review is de novo. See

      Anderson v. Gaudin, 

42 N.E.3d 82, 85

 (Ind. 2015). When a statute is clear and

      unambiguous, no interpretation is necessary; we simply “apply the words and

      phrases in their plain, ordinary, and usual sense.” 

Id.

 But when a statute is

      susceptible to more than one interpretation, it is ambiguous and thus open to

      judicial construction. 

Id.

 In construing an ambiguous statute, our goal is to

      determine, give effect to, and implement the intent of the Legislature. 

Id.



[5]   Objectors argue that only the legislative body of a unit of local government can

      exercise the power of eminent domain in a redevelopment project area. They do

      not dispute that units have broad eminent-domain power or that this power can

      generally be exercised by officials other than the unit’s legislative body. See 

Ind.

Code § 36-1-4-5

(a) (“A unit may acquire by eminent domain or other means,

      and own interests in real and personal property.”). But they assert that Section

      36-7-14-20(a) unambiguously limits the use of eminent domain in the context of

      redevelopment project areas. As noted above, the statute provides that “[i]f the

      legislative body of the unit that established the department of redevelopment

      considers it necessary to acquire real property in a redevelopment project area




      1
       Objectors also challenge the overruling of their other objections. Because we reverse based on Section 36-7-
      14-20, we need not address those arguments.

      Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-711 | October 29, 2026                               Page 4 of 8
      by the exercise of the power of eminent domain,” it must adopt a resolution

      setting forth that determination and directing its attorney to file suit. According

      to Objectors, the clear implication of the statute’s language—establishing a

      procedure for a unit’s legislative body to exercise the power of eminent domain

      in a redevelopment project area, but not establishing a procedure for other unit

      officials to exercise that power—is that other officials do not have the power.


[6]   The City also argues that Section 36-7-14-20(a) is unambiguous, but in a much

      different way. The City contends that the statute does nothing to limit who can

      exercise a unit’s power of eminent domain in a redevelopment project area; it

      simply establishes the procedure to be employed “if” it is the unit’s legislative

      body that wants to exercise that power. According to the City, because the

      statute doesn’t expressly state that only a unit’s legislative body can exercise the

      power of eminent domain in a redevelopment project area, or that other unit

      officials cannot exercise such power, the statute has no impact on the broad

      eminent-domain powers of other officials under Indiana Code section 36-1-4-

      5(a). In sum, the City maintains that Section 36-7-14-20(a) is merely a

      procedural statute applicable to a unit’s legislative body, not a substantive

      statute establishing who does or does not have the power of eminent domain in

      a redevelopment project area.


[7]   When the statute is read in isolation, both interpretations are reasonable.

      Therefore, the statute is ambiguous, and we must look beyond its plain text to

      discern its meaning. See Anderson, 

42 N.E.3d at 85

. Having done so, we

      conclude that Objectors offer the correct interpretation.

      Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-711 | October 29, 2026        Page 5 of 8
[8]    Section 36-7-14-20 is part of Indiana Code chapter 36-7-14, which establishes a

       comprehensive scheme for units of local government (except townships) to (1)

       create redevelopment project areas and (2) acquire real property in such areas.

       A unit may establish a department of redevelopment, to be controlled by a

       redevelopment commission. I.C. § 36-7-14-3. In turn, a redevelopment

       commission can establish a redevelopment project area for an “area needing

       redevelopment” (with the approval of the unit’s plan commission and legislative

       body). I.C. §§ 36-7-14-15, -16, -17. Once a redevelopment commission

       establishes such an area, it must identify the real property that needs to be

       acquired for the redevelopment project and then attempt to negotiate the

       purchase of that property. I.C. § 36-7-14-19; see also I.C. § 36-7-14-19.5.


[9]    Of course, a redevelopment commission won’t always be able to negotiate an

       amicable purchase of property. And that is when eminent domain becomes

       necessary and Section 36-7-14-20 comes into play. The statute sets forth how

       the power of eminent domain can be exercised in a redevelopment project

       area—through a vote of the unit’s legislative body. While other unit officials

       generally have broad eminent-domain power, and Section 36-7-14-20 doesn’t

       expressly bar them from exercising that power in a redevelopment project area,

       the redevelopment statutory scheme as a whole makes clear that the power lies

       with the unit’s legislative body. Since the property at issue here is in a

       redevelopment project area, and the City’s legislative body didn’t authorize the

       condemnation action, the trial court erred by overruling the objection.


[10]   Reversed.

       Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-711 | October 29, 2026           Page 6 of 8
May, J., concurs.

Tavitas, C.J., concurs in result with separate opinion.


ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANTS
James A. Masters
Nemeth, Feeney, Masters & Campiti, P.C.
South Bend, Indiana


ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEE
Jenny R. Buchheit
Andrew J. Miroff
John D. French
Abby V. DeMare
Ice Miller LLP
Indianapolis, Indiana




Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-711 | October 29, 2026   Page 7 of 8
       Tavitas, Chief Judge, concurring in result.


[11]   I concur in result. The majority concludes that Indiana Code Section 36-7-14-

       20(a) is ambiguous, but it nevertheless concludes that the authority to exercise

       the power of eminent domain in a redevelopment project area lies with the

       unit’s legislative body.


[12]   Neither party argues that the statute is ambiguous. I am, therefore, hesitant to

       conclude that the statute is ambiguous sua sponte. But because the City’s

       legislative body did not authorize the condemnation action, I agree that the trial

       court erred by overruling the objection.




       Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-711 | October 29, 2026      Page 8 of 8

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.