Miscellaneous Mauritius
Supreme Court of Mauritius, 12 May 2026, 2026 PMP 5 – Deorat Baichoo
Deorat Baichoo
2026 PMP 5
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF PAMPLEMOUSSES CN: 8659/24 In the matter of:- Police v Deorat Baichoo JUGMENT
A. Introduction
1. The Accused stands charged with an offence of Committing an act of Domestic Violence against his spouse in breach of Sections 2 and 13(1)(a) of the Protection from Domestic Violence Act as amended.
2. The information avers that on or about the 13th day of May 2022 at Royal Road 8eme Mile, Triolet, the Accused did wilfully and unlawfully commit an act of domestic violence by ill-treating his spouse one Pushpa Devi Baichoo.
3. The Accused pleaded not guilty to the charge and was represented by counsel throughout the trial.
4. The case for the prosecution was conducted by police prosecutor.
B. The case for the prosecution
5. Witness no.1 produced the defence statement of the Accused, marked as DOC A.
6. In cross-examination, witness no.1 confirmed having conducted an enquiry before recording the defence statement of the Accused. He had ascertained whether the parties were divorced. According to the judgment of the Supreme Court, the declarant was supposed to leave the house on 20.03.22. The Accused was a senior advisor at the Ministry of Labour and is of clean record. The declarant gave a withdrawal statement at Triolet police station on 16.05.22. The witness could not confirm whether her withdrawal statement was recorded by a WPC Kausmally. It was then put to him what the declarant had stated: “mo pas envi alle la cour, mo pas envi tarnir aine relation, personne pas fine force moi, mo p dire sa volontairement”. He could not confirm as he did not see the statement. The witness confirmed that the declarant was asked on 13.05.22 whether she wanted to be medically examined and she refused. The declarant did not bear any mark of violence. The gist of her complaint was that the Accused allegedly put his hand near her forehead. There are no recording of the alleged incident and no witnesses. The declarant did not sustain any injuries.
7. Witness no.2 confirmed having giving a declarant on 13.05.22 at 12:13hrs at Triolet police station against the Accused for domestic violence. On 13.05.22 at about 09:30hrs, she was at home at Residences Triolet, her conjugal home at the time. She was going through a divorce process and hence was packing her belongings. She was going to move the weekend of the 14th/15th. She was in her room and was collecting her belongings from one room to another. Her ex-husband then came; he was getting ready to go to work whilst she continued packing. At some point, the latter followed her and stated to her: “bane bijoux la coter, qui pou faire ek bane bijoux”. She explained that it was her wedding jewelleries and told him that the jewelleries were hers and that she could do whatever she wants with them, and continued packing. Then suddenly, she felt him behind her and he put his fist on her forehead and stated to her: “mo p alle met aine case vol contre toi, mové pitin, mo pou faire toi aller vini la cour, mo faire to lavie amer”. He insulted her at the same time. She was shocked, so shocked that she began to tremble. She took a moment and then left in her car. She stated that he left first and went to make a larceny declaration. She went afterwards. At the station, she met with a police officer, one Vencatasawmy, who stated to him that he could not report a larceny against his wife. She stated that at time of the incident, she was upstairs. Her children were at school and her parents were downstairs. There were only her and her ex-husband upstairs. She was not injured but she was traumatised, shaken and scared. She went to the Family Protection Unit to make her complaint. She did not seek treatment immediately. She went back to pack her belongings and left the next day. She positively identified her ex-husband as being the Accused in the dock. She had been living in the conjugal home since 01.09.14.
8. In cross-examination, she confirmed that her in-laws were at home. There was no fight, just talking. She did not know whether her in-laws overheard or if they heard and did not react, she would not know. They would not have heard if they were far. She maintained that the Accused had stated to her: “mo pou faire to lavie vine amer”. She stated to the police that she was traumatised and explained that the police saw her in that state and she was crying. When it was put to her that the police who recorded the statement did not make mention of her state or that she was shaken, she replied that she would not know and maintained that she was traumatised. It was then put to her that she never made mention of this in her statement. She maintained that she was traumatised, felt diminished and hurt. Upon being confronted to the fact that she had to leave the conjugal roof on 20.03.22, she replied that she stated that would leave on finding a place to stay. Her divorce was pronounced in August 2022. It was then put to her that she had a delay to leave the house and she replied that she stated that she would upon finding a place to stay. She stated that she was in the process of divorce when she made her declaration. She confirmed that she signed an agreement on 21.12.21 and that the said agreement was filed in court on 18.05.22 at the Supreme Court; there was mutual consent. She confirmed the clause in the agreement which stated: “the wife petitioner undertakes to leave the conjugal roof at Royal Road Triolet within a delay of 3 months as from the signature of the agreement”. Hence, as per the agreement, she had to leave on 21.03.22; she confirmed and agreed that she overstayed for more than one year. During that year, everything went well. She was staying downstairs and the Accused was upstairs. They were not communicating during the 15 months period. When it was put to her that she had jewelleries belonging to the Baichoo family, she replied that they were wedding jewelleries and the Accused did not specify which jewelleries. The Baichoo jewelleries always remained with her mother-in-law and there was no reason for the Accused to ask her for same. The Accused had asked her for the wedding jewelleries. She confirmed having refused medical examination and that there were no traces of violence on her. She denied having made her declaration in a moment of anger and explained that he told her that he was going to make a declaration against her. He threatened her and stated to her: “mo pou montrer roi qui apel moi, movai SDF, illegal dans mo lakaz, mo pou faire toi galoup la cour, mo pou faire to lavie amer”. It was then put to her that she went to the police station because she saw him go first. She denied same and stated that she was traumatised. She stated she went to report because he saw him do so and his allegations were false. She confirmed that she still stayed on 13.05.22 and only left the next day. She agreed that despite being traumatised, she still stayed there. She first went to the police station on 13.05.22. She left the conjugal roof on 14.05.22. She went back to the police station on
16.05.22 to inform the police that she had left the conjugal roof. She confirmed having went back to the police station to withdraw the case. She confirmed having stated: “mo aussi ena pou dire qui personne pas fine force moi, menace moi ou blackmail moi pou tir case sa”. She denied having levelled a false allegation. She agreed not having stated in her statement that the Accused threatened her. She denied that she reported the case because the Accused told her that he would report her for larceny of the jewelleries.
C. The case for the defence
9. Under oath, the Accused confirmed that whatever he averred in his defence statement was the truth. He confirmed that witness no.2 stayed for a period of 15 months after the agreement was signed and during that period, it was peaceful. He did not force her to withdraw the case; she went voluntarily. He denied the charge and explained that they only had a conversation on the material date.
D. Analysis
10. I have carefully assessed the evidence on record.
11. The prosecution bears a heavy burden in the present matter for its whole case hinges on the evidence of witness no.2. Having listened to the latter’s testimony and having also taken cognisance of her complaint as gauged in DOC A, I have doubts as to her credibility and truthfulness.
11.1. On the date of the alleged incident, witness no.2 stated that she was traumatised and scared of the Accused. Yet, in spite of her alleged trauma, she still went back to the conjugal roof on the same date. Her complaint also makes no mention of her being scared or traumatised or shaken by the Accused following the incident or even of her crying to the police officer. There is also no mention of her going to the Family Protection Unit.
11.2. Witness no.2 conceded in cross-examination that she went to the station and reported the incident as she thought that the Accused would report her for theft. She also confirmed that she went back to withdraw her case two days later. I am in
the dark as to why she decided to withdraw the case since the police prosecutor did not ask for any clarifications during re-examination.
11.3. It is undisputed that the Accused and witness no.2 are ex-spouses and even after their divorce pronouncement, witness no.2 was still living under the conjugal roof. The alleged incident occurred during this period, when she overstayed her welcome. She stated herself that during the 15 months of her still living there, everything was peaceful, until the alleged incident. Basically, witness no.2 wants this court to believe that after those 15 months, the Accused would suddenly ill-treat her on the day she was packing to move out. Bearing para 11.1 and 11.2 in mind, I am very doubtful of her genuineness.
12. At this stage, in view of the above, and given the ease with which a charge of this nature may be laid, I find that I cannot safely rely on witness no.2’s testimony and the Accused should therefore be given the benefit of a doubt.
E. Conclusion
13. For all reasons as stated, I find that the prosecution has failed to prove the case against the Accused beyond reasonable doubt and accordingly dismiss the charge against him.
Mrs. M. D. Chung Kow Cheong District Magistrate 11.05.26
Our criminal law attorney in Paris assists clients in matters of this kind.
Official sources: view the source page · Official PDF
Supreme Court of Mauritius.