Tax European Court of Human Rights
TSELINSKIY AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
THIRD SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 7061/06
Eduard Vladimirovich TSELINSKIY against Russia
and 25 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Third Section), sitting on 5 January 2017 as a Committee composed of:
Branko Lubarda, President,
Pere Pastor Vilanova,
Georgios A. Serghides, judges,
and Fatoş Aracı, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the dates set out in the appendix,
Having regard to the decision to apply the pilot-judgment procedure taken in the case of Gerasimov and Others v. Russia (nos. 29920/05 and 10 others, § 218, 1 July 2014),
Having regard to the declarations submitted by the Government and the applicants’ acceptance of their terms,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
FACTS AND PROCEDURE
The applicants are Russian nationals whose names and dates of birth are set out in the appendix.
The Russian Government (“the Government”) were represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights.
The applicants complained, among other matters, about the delayed enforcement of the judgments in their favour imposing various obligations in kind on domestic authorities and the lack of the effective remedies in respect of the non-enforcement complaint. Dates of the judgments, their entry into force and their full enforcement are set out in the appendix.
In the wake of the pilot judgment, on various dates in late 2014 the applications were communicated to the Government (see Gerasimov and Others, cited above, §§ 230-31, and point 13 of the operative part).
On the dates specified in the appendix the Government submitted unilateral declarations with a view to resolving the issues raised by the applications.
In their declarations they acknowledged, in each case, the lengthy enforcement of the judgment in the applicant’s favour. The unilateral declarations further contained, in each case, the dates of the judgment at issue, its entry into force and its full enforcement, as well as an overall enforcement delay.
The authorities stated their readiness to pay to the applicants the sums listed in the appendix as just satisfaction. The payments were to cover any pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage as well as costs and expenses, and would be free of any taxes that may be applicable. They would be payable within three months from the date of notification of the decision taken by the Court. In the event of failure to pay the sums within the said period, the Government undertook to pay simple interest on them, from expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points. The payments would constitute the final resolution of the cases.
In their letters received on the dates indicated in the appendix, the applicants informed the Court that they agreed to the terms of the Government’s declarations.
THE LAW
Having regard to the similarity of the main issues under the Convention in the above cases, the Court decides to join the applications and examine them in a single decision.
The Court attaches particular weight to the applicants’ express agreement to the terms of the declarations made by the Government. It finds that such agreement shall be considered as a friendly settlement between the parties (see Cēsnieks v. Latvia (dec.), no. 9278/06, § 34, 6 March 2012, and Bakal and Others v. Turkey (dec.), no. 8243/08, 5 June 2012).
The Court therefore takes formal note of the friendly settlement reached between the parties. The Court further considers that the settlement is based on respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols (Article 37 § 1 in fine of the Convention and Rule 62 § 3 of the Rules of Court).
In any event the Committee of Ministers remains competent to supervise the execution of the terms of the friendly settlement as set out in the present decision (Article 39 § 4 of the Convention and Rule 43 § 3 of the Rules of Court). Further, in any event the Court’s present ruling is without prejudice to any decision it might take to restore, pursuant to Article 37 § 2 of the Convention, the present applications to its list of cases.
In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the cases out of the list in accordance with Article 39 of the Convention.
The Court considers that the amounts proposed by the Government should be converted into the currency of the respondent State at the rate applicable on the date of payment.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Decides, having regard to the terms of the Government’s declarations, and the arrangements for ensuring compliance with the undertakings referred to therein, and the applicants’ acceptance of the terms of the declarations, to strike the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 39 of the Convention.
Done in English and notified in writing on 26 January 2017.
Fatoş Aracı Branko Lubarda
Deputy Registrar President
APPENDIX
|
No. |
Application no. Lodged on |
Applicant Date of birth Place of residence |
Representative |
Date of judgment Final on |
Enforcement date Enforcement delay as specified in the unilateral declaration |
Date of unilateral declaration Remedial offer (euros) |
Date of applicant’s letter in reply |
|
|
7061/06 27/01/2006
|
Eduard Vladimirovich TSELINSKIY 29/01/1966 Klin
|
|
09/07/2007 27/07/2007
|
29/06/2011 3 years 11 months |
25/07/2016
3,850 |
22/09/2016 |
|
|
11765/06 09/02/2006
|
Raisa Mikhaylovna VASETSKAYA 17/08/1948 Milovidovo
|
|
13/03/2002 25/03/2002
|
27/04/2007 5 years 1 month |
01/06/2016
3,210 |
27/09/2016 |
|
|
25026/06 26/05/2006
|
Andrey Mikhaylovich SHASHKOV 07/11/1967 Yekaterinburg
|
|
13/12/2005 30/12/2005
|
11/08/2008 2 years 7 months 12 days |
01/06/2016
2,560 |
18/08/2016 |
|
|
44076/07 11/09/2007
|
Aleksandr Borisovich TELKOV 26/09/1957 St Petersburg
Galina Nikolayevna TELKOVA 30/03/1962 St Petersburg
|
|
05/03/1999 05/04/1999 |
29/10/2008 9 years 6 months 24 days |
26/09/2016
6,500 |
07/11/2016 |
|
|
15446/09 16/05/2008
|
Nina Aleksandrovna YEZHOVA 10/11/1949 Chelyabinsk
|
|
06/05/2004 24/05/2004
|
20/11/2007 3 years 5 months 27 days |
07/07/2016
3,420 |
09/08/2016 |
|
|
22514/09 18/02/2009
|
Zelimkhan Abadiyevich GUTIYEV 01/01/1942 Alkhanchurt
|
Aleksandr Yuryevich DZILIKHOV |
01/03/2005 19/04/2005
|
03/06/2013 8 years 1 month 15 days |
07/07/2016
6,500 |
19/09/2016 |
|
|
37610/09 03/06/2009
|
Igor Aleksandrovich PATERIKIN 30/09/1961 Svetlyy
|
|
31/03/2008 02/07/2008
|
23/12/2010 2 years 5 months 21 days |
07/07/2016
2,420 |
14/10/2016 |
|
|
40999/09 13/05/2009
|
Lyudmila Sergeyevna TYULKINA 02/06/1949 Armavir
|
|
07/07/2005 19/07/2005
|
24/06/2013 7 years 11 months 5 days |
07/07/2016
6,500 |
09/08/2016 |
|
|
2656/10 22/12/2009
|
Aleksandr Mikhaylovich KADUSHKIN 04/04/1947 Sochi
Tatyana Ivanovna KADUSHKINA 31/10/1953 Sochi
|
|
10/10/2006 23/11/2006
|
22/10/2009 2 years 11 months |
07/07/2016
2,850 (jointly) |
16/08/2016 |
|
|
4526/10 29/12/2009
|
Galina Ilyinichna TEPLYAKOVA 01/01/1952 Shenkursk
|
|
24/11/2008 05/12/2008
|
02/12/2011 2 years 11 months 27 days |
07/07/2016
2,930 |
11/08/2016 |
|
|
6269/10 30/11/2009
|
Sergey Vladimirovich VOROTNIKOV 07/01/1966 Pushkino
|
|
21/05/2009 02/06/2009
|
11/07/2013 4 years 1 month 9 days |
07/07/2016
4,030 |
09/08/2016 |
|
|
19910/10 09/03/2010
|
Yelena Alekseyevna SERDYUKOVA 05/06/1961 Belgorod
|
|
15/05/2009 02/07/2009
|
20/05/2015 5 years 10 months 18 days |
13/07/2016
5,760 |
19/09/2016 |
|
|
28858/10 04/05/2010
|
Mikhail Aleksandrovich BULATOV 04/08/1976 Moscow
|
|
13/08/2009 25/08/2009
|
27/12/2012 3 years 4 months 2 days |
13/07/2016
3,270 |
03/10/2016 |
|
|
28859/10 04/05/2010
|
Nikolay Vladimirovich YAKOVLEV 15/01/1976 Moscow
|
|
13/08/2009 25/08/2009
|
05/09/2013 4 years 10 days |
18/04/2016
3,950 |
13/06/2016 |
|
|
32272/10 30/04/2010
|
Aleksandr Semenovich SHEVELEV 14/01/1973 Syktyvkar
|
Ernest Aleksandrovich MEZAK |
21/05/2008 28/06/2008
|
06/05/2014 5 years 10 months 8 days |
13/07/2016
5,000 |
29/09/2016 |
|
|
42962/10 07/07/2010
|
Pavel Yakovlevich KOMARNITSKIY 08/05/1966 Rostov-na-Donu
|
|
27/08/2008 09/09/2008
|
26/06/2012 3 years 9 months 17 days |
18/04/2016
3,720 |
08/06/2016 |
|
|
44376/10 08/06/2010
|
Nikolay Refatovich ABDULIN 06/04/1961 Rostov-na-Donu
|
|
17/07/2008 04/08/2008
|
07/03/2013 4 years 7 months 3 days |
18/04/2016
4,500 |
02/06/2016 |
|
|
45597/10 18/06/2010
|
Yuriy Vladimirovich YAKOVLEV 12/05/1963 Krasnyy Krym
|
|
04/07/2008 15/07/2008
|
21/08/2012 4 years 1 month 6 days |
18/04/2016
4,020 |
02/06/2016 |
|
|
48887/10 30/07/2010
|
Murat Khasanbiyevich KAKIYEV 23/01/1979 Argudan
|
|
10/04/2009 06/05/2009
|
19/06/2012 3 years 1 month 13 days |
13/07/2016
3,060 |
08/09/2016 |
|
|
61885/10 30/09/2010
|
Valeriy Sergeyevich MAKAROV 01/07/1953 Moscow
|
|
07/02/2008 23/02/2008
17/05/2010 02/09/2010
|
31/05/2013
12/01/2016 7 years 10 months 17 days |
13/07/2016
6,500 |
10/10/2016 |
|
|
71229/10 29/11/2010
|
Andrey Olegovich OSTROVERKHIY 13/01/1980 Moscow
|
|
16/10/2009 03/11/2009
|
30/01/2013 3 years 2 months 27 days |
18/04/2016
3,180 |
17/05/2016 |
|
|
71329/10 12/11/2010
|
Sergey Nikolayevich AKSENOV 03/09/1962 Balashikha
|
|
14/08/2008 01/09/2008
|
02/11/2011 3 years 2 months 1 day |
13/07/2016
3,100 |
03/10/2016 |
|
|
36858/11 31/05/2011
|
Oleg Vladimirovich STROGIN 16/07/1984 Cheboksary
|
|
06/10/2010 19/10/2010
|
23/04/2012 1 year 6 months 4 days |
01/07/2016
1,480 |
09/08/2016 |
|
|
45657/11 04/06/2011
|
Andrey Leonidovich KOMAROV 15/04/1972 Arkhangelsk
Aleksandr Leonidovich KOMAROV 26/05/1977 Arkhangelsk
Lyudmila Dmitriyevna KOMAROVA 12/10/1941 Arkhangelsk
|
Igor Yuryevich TELYATYEV |
14/11/2006 24/11/2006
|
27/12/2010 4 years 1 month 5 days |
01/07/2016
4,010 (jointly) |
08/08/2016 |
|
|
57402/11 16/08/2011
|
Vladimir Mikhaylovich NEMCHENKO 19/04/1966 Moscow
|
|
24/10/2007 09/11/2007
|
14/06/2013 5 years 7 months 10 days |
01/07/2016
5,490
|
18/08/2016 |
|
|
70759/11 24/10/2011
|
Valentina Stepanovna DENISKO 19/03/1930 Yakutsk
|
|
21/10/1999 31/10/1999
|
30/10/2012 13 years 4 days |
01/07/2016
6,500
|
18/08/2016 |
Official sources: view the source page · Official PDF
HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.