Civil European Court of Human Rights
YÖYLER AND OTHERS v. TURKEY
SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 10783/07
Ziri YÖYLER and others against Turkey
and 46 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 16 December 2014 as a Chamber composed of:
Guido Raimondi, President,
Işıl Karakaş,
Nebojša Vučinić,
Helen Keller,
Paul Lemmens,
Egidijus Kūris,
Robert Spano, judges,
and Stanley Naismith, Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications, listed in the appendix,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.
A. The circumstances of the case
2. The facts of the case, as submitted by the applicants, may be summarised as follows.
3. On various dates, the applicants initiated actions before various civil courts or civil proceedings were brought against them before the civil courts. Certain procedures lasted several years, and some are still pending before the domestic courts.
B. Relevant domestic law
4. A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in Turgut and Others v. Turkey ((dec.), no. 4860/09, §§ 19-26, 26 March 2013).
COMPLAINTS
5. The applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time.
6. Some of the applicants alleged that there had been a violation of Article 13 of the Convention in that there was no effective remedy under Turkish law.
7. All the applicants raised additional complaints with reference to various Articles of the Convention and its Protocols.
THE LAW
A. Alleged violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention
8. The applicants complained that the length of the proceedings had been incompatible with the “reasonable time” requirement, laid down in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention, which reads as follows:
“In the determination of his civil rights and obligations …, everyone is entitled to a … hearing within a reasonable time by a … tribunal…”
9. The Court observes that the applicants asserted that the length of the proceedings had been incompatible with the principle of “reasonable time” requirement in accordance with Article 6 § 1 of the Convention. The Court found in Turgut and Others (cited above, §§ 8 and 60) that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384, insofar as it is a priori accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 § 1 of the Convention. Accordingly, the applicants should avail themselves of the new remedy offered by Law no. 6384 (see also Haçikoğlu and others v. Turkey ((dec.) no. 21786/04, 8 April 2014).
10. It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
B. Alleged violation of Article 13 of the Convention
11. Some of the applicants complained that there was no effective remedy under Turkish law. They relied, in this regard, on Article 13 of the Convention, which provides:
“Everyone whose rights and freedoms as set forth in this Convention are violated shall have an effective remedy before a national authority notwithstanding that the violation has been committed by persons acting in an official capacity.”
12. The Court recalls that it has also held that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384 provides for an effective remedy within the meaning of Article 13 of the Convention for applicants to complain about the length of proceedings for the purposes of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention relating to all applications pending before the Court, not yet communicated to the respondent Government, submitted before 23 September 2012 (Turgut and Others (cited above, § 59)).
13. It follows that this part of the application is manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.
C. Other alleged violations of various Articles of the Convention and its Protocols
14. The applicants invoked various articles of the Convention and its Protocols.
15. The Court considers that it is not at this stage able to determine whether these complaints should be communicated to the Government in accordance with Rule 54 § 2 (b) of the Rules of Court, and adjourns their examination.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Declares the complaints concerning the length of the proceedings and the lack of an effective remedy for undue length of proceedings inadmissible;
Decides to adjourn the examination of the remainder of the application.
Stanley Naismith Guido Raimondi
Registrar President
Appendix
|
No |
Application No |
Lodged on |
Applicant Date of birth Place of residence |
Represented by |
|
|
10783/07 |
02/03/2007 |
Ziri YÖYLER 02/04/1946 Muş
Nazlı DERE 01/04/1954 Kocaeli
Refika GÜVEN 27/05/1950 Muş
Hazime DAŞ 02/01/1956 Muş
|
Kerim YILDIZ |
|
|
13378/07 |
22/03/2007 |
Muhsin GÖLBAŞ Bursa
|
Nalan BENER |
|
|
19535/07 |
03/05/2007 |
Mustafa Volkan LÜLÜ 02/01/1957 Antalya
Ali Noyan LÜLÜ 12/12/1953
Yonca Rahime GİRİTLİ 21/06/1956
Demet DOLZ 01/01/1959
Hatice Ayten LÜLÜ 14/05/1928
|
Salih EFE |
|
|
51508/08 |
22/09/2008 |
Fatih TAŞ 07/05/1979 İstanbul
|
İnan AKMEŞE |
|
|
51512/08 |
24/09/2008 |
Fatih TAŞ 07/05/1979 İstanbul
|
İnan AKMEŞE |
|
|
6810/09 |
|
Fatih TAŞ 07/05/1979 İstanbul
|
İnan AKMEŞE |
|
|
24067/09 |
24/03/2009 |
Bedi YAŞAR 01/01/1936 Mersin
Müzeyyen YILMAZ 04/01/1963 Mersin
Mithat YAŞAR 01/06/1964 Mersin
Melahat ÇELİK 13/10/1966 Mersin
Kayhan YAŞAR 02/09/1970 Mersin
Belkıs YAŞAR 05/10/1967 Mersin Metin YAŞAR 02/10/1960 Mersin
|
Ferda İRİŞİK |
|
|
31884/09 |
23/05/2009 |
Şemsi KAYA 01/01/1939 İstanbul
|
Murat HAZİNEDAR |
|
|
32586/09 |
10/06/2009 |
Mihriye CANTÜRK 17/12/1954 Ürgüp / Nevşehir
|
Ferda İRİŞİK |
|
|
32594/09 |
10/06/2009 |
Metin GÜLER 15/02/1969 Mersin
|
Ferda İRİŞİK |
|
|
33495/09 |
29/05/2009 |
Fatih TAŞ 07/05/1979 İstanbul
|
İnan AKMEŞE |
|
|
33748/09 |
11/06/2009 |
Hüseyin ATAY 01/04/1965 Mardin
Nihad ATAY 08/08/1968
Hidayet ATAY 10/06/1975
Fatma ATAY 01/01/1955 Mardin
Abdullah ATAY 01/09/1975 Mardin
Nurullah ATAY 01/09/1980 Mardin
Emrullah ATAY 01/09/1980 Mardin
Muazzez ÖZDEMİR 01/10/1982 Mardin
Medine ATAY 01/01/1985 Mardin
Mehmet ATAY 01/03/1987 Mardin
Feride ATAY 20/02/1989 Mardin |
Şeyhmus TAŞKIN |
|
|
67385/09 |
16/12/2009 |
Cemile KAYA 28/02/1957 Tunceli Akın KAYA 10/03/1981 Tunceli
İbrahim KAYA 10/11/1982 Tunceli
Cemal KAYA 05/11/1986 Tunceli
Deniz KAYA 15/02/1975 Elazığ
|
Barış YILDIRIM |
|
|
3801/10 |
25/12/2009 |
Güler ÇELİK 01/01/1972 Bingöl
|
Fırat AYDINKAYA |
|
|
7417/10 |
20/01/2010 |
İbrahim OĞUZ 01/01/1929 Gaziantep
|
Mustafa TÜRKMEN |
|
|
10797/10 |
08/02/2010 |
Işıl SARIKAMIŞ 04/03/1986 İstanbul
|
Mehmet ERBİL |
|
|
10985/10 |
10/02/2010 |
Recep TOKUÇ 17/07/1976 Kütahya
|
|
|
|
13874/10 |
17/02/2010 |
Vahit SEVİM 11/01/1970 İstanbul
Mehmet Hanifi ÖNCEL 01/01/1974 İstanbul
|
İnan AKMEŞE |
|
|
13992/10 |
29/01/2010 |
Ülger YAŞAR 02/03/1943 Gaziantep
|
Mustafa TÜRKMEN |
|
|
17867/10 |
14/12/2009 |
Mustafa ERSİN 26/09/1925 İstanbul
Mehmet Basri ERSİN 06/05/1929 Tekirdağ
Ziya GÜLBARAN 22/08/1956 İstanbul
Murat GÜLBARAN 19/05/1962 İstanbul
Deniz GÜLBARAN 15/08/1958 İstanbul
Ahmet Hayri UĞUR 22/02/1946 İstanbul
|
Turgan GÜRMEN |
|
|
23702/10 |
05/04/2010 |
Mehmet Ali VARIŞ 10/01/1979 İstanbul
|
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER |
|
|
30511/10 |
03/05/2010 |
Sefer BOZACI 09/02/1979 Bartın
|
|
|
|
33528/10 |
01/06/2010 |
Fatih TAŞ 07/05/1979 İstanbul
|
İnan AKMEŞE |
|
|
39389/10 |
17/05/2010 |
Erdal ÇERİ 10/01/1974 İstanbul |
Haluk KÖKSOY |
|
|
41764/10 |
07/08/2010 |
Fatma DEMİR 01/01/1949 Osmaniye
|
Adil AKTAY |
|
|
47010/10 |
12/07/2010 |
Turabi KARTAL 01/01/1978 İstanbul
|
Metin FİLORİNALI |
|
|
70258/10 |
24/09/2010 |
TEMKAŞ YERLİ ÜRÜNLER İTHALAT İHRACAT SANAYİ VE TİCARET A. Ş. İstanbul
|
Melahat ERDAL |
|
|
31812/11 |
18/02/2011 |
MLG REKLAM PRODÜKSİYON ORGANİZASYON MÜŞAVİRLİK VE DIŞ TİCARET LİMİTED ŞİRKETİ Ankara
|
Emrah GENÇ |
|
|
32043/11 |
23/09/2009 |
Ramazan ORAL 11/03/1985 Mersin
İbrahim Halil YAHLİ 08/03/1984 İstanbul
Enver TEKİN 01/01/1983 Bursa
|
İnan AKMEŞE |
|
|
32445/11 |
03/03/2011 |
Zeynep ERGÜN SÖZEN 01/03/1939 Samsun
|
Erhan BORA |
|
|
32446/11 |
03/03/2011 |
Emine KUŞ SÖZEN 16/04/1949 Samsun
|
Erhan BORA |
|
|
49851/11 |
13/06/2011 |
Doğan ERDOĞAN 21/07/1986 Amasya
|
Yasin YILDIZ |
|
|
77839/11 |
28/11/2011 |
Kadir KORKUT 01/01/1973 Antalya
İsa Emre KORKUT 14/07/2001 Antalya
Özlem KORKUT 01/12/1974 Antalya
|
Nurullah AKSARI |
|
|
78510/11 |
11/11/2011 |
Yasemin OKUYUCU 04/02/1972 İstanbul
|
Sevgi EPÇELİ ARSLAN |
|
|
78807/11 |
10/11/2011 |
Faruk MENEKŞE 01/03/1973 Diyarbakır
|
Serkan AKBAŞ |
|
|
1320/12 |
05/12/2011 |
Adem ORAN 12/10/1979 İstanbul Fatma ÖZCAN 10/06/1977 İstanbul
Emre ORAN 25/04/1985 İstanbul
İsmail ORAN 08/09/1956 İstanbul
|
Mustafa BOSTANOĞLU |
|
|
22537/12 |
01/03/2012 |
Sadi ÇİFTÇİ 01/01/1974 İstanbul
Mufide ÇİFTÇİ 01/01/1980 İstanbul
|
Fırat AYDINKAYA |
|
|
27300/12 |
16/04/2012 |
Kenan TANDOĞAN 03/01/1976 İstanbul
|
Mehmet UZUNCAOK |
|
|
47232/12 |
06/04/2012 |
Ali GÜRBÜZ 01/01/1971 Köln
Hasan BAYAR 01/01/1982 Bern
|
İnan AKMEŞE |
|
|
59884/12 |
09/07/2012 |
Ali ÇANAKÇI 01/01/1984 Edirne
|
Fırat AYDINKAYA |
|
|
61984/12 |
24/07/2012 |
Fatma YAĞLI 10/08/1959 Ordu
İsa YAĞLI 10/06/1977 Ordu
Musa YAĞLI 10/06/1979 Antalya
Eyüp YAĞLI 01/01/1990 Ordu
|
Fatma ŞÜKÜROĞLU |
|
|
72778/12 |
03/09/2012 |
Bayram BAYRAKÇI 01/07/1934 Ankara
Ekrem BAYRAKÇI 10/01/1950 Ankara
Mustafa BAYRAKÇI 25/03/1969 Ankara
|
Okan YILMAZYURT |
|
|
77747/12 |
08/09/2012 |
Nesim YILMAZ 28/04/1947 Van
İbrahim YILMAZ 01/01/1978 Van
Mevlüde YILMAZ 01/01/1987 Van
Hüsna YILMAZ 01/01/1948 Van
Doğan YILMAZ 01/01/1991 Van
Halil YILMAZ 01/01/1990 Van
|
Murat TİMUR |
|
|
3009/13 |
15/11/2012 |
Zeki AYTİMUR 12/04/1952 Kocaeli
Feryat AYTİMUR 01/04/1974 Istanbul
Şengül AYTİMUR 26/04/1958 Kocaeli
Gönül AYTİMUR 02/09/1968 Kocaeli
Hatice AYTİMUR 01/01/1977 Kocaeli
Ali AYTİMUR 20/08/1978 Kocaeli
Abdülkadir AYTİMUR 01/07/1982 Kocaeli
Huriye AYTİMUR 10/10/1985 Kocaeli
Ayşegül AYTİMUR 10/10/1987 Kocaeli
Hakan AYTİMUR 01/06/1989 Kocaeli
Yadigar AYTİMUR 01/06/1991 Kocaeli
|
Fatih YEMEN |
|
|
7277/13 |
05/12/2012 |
Nizamettin KARAALANLI 01/06/1935 İzmir
|
|
|
|
13351/13 |
11/01/2013 |
Muzaffer DOĞAN 01/01/1970 Antalya
|
|
|
|
17133/13 |
21/09/2012 |
Hatice DİLEK 15/11/1990 İstanbul
|
Fırat AYDINKAYA |
Official sources: view the source page · Official PDF
HUDOC, Council of Europe / European Court of Human Rights.