Tax United Kingdom
Rachel Maddock v The Commissioners for HMRC
Neutral Citation: [2026] UKFTT 01477 (TC)
Case Number: TC10065
FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL
TAX CHAMBER
By remote video
Appeal reference: TC/2025/03056
VAT DIY HOUSEBUILDERS’ SCHEME – s35 VATA 1994 – substantial redevelopment of existing bungalow – whether construction of a building – Notes 16 and 18 Group 5 Schedule 8 VATA – whether existing building ceased to exist – retention of more than a single façade – alternative case of corner site and double façade – planning permission – reconstruction or alteration of existing building – appeal dismissed
Heard on: 6 October 2026
Judgment date: 23 October 2026
Before
TRIBUNAL JUDGE ROSA PETTIFER
MR SIMON GILLESPIE-KHAN
Between
RACHEL MADDOCK
Appellant
and
THE COMMISSIONERS FOR HIS MAJESTY’S REVENUE AND CUSTOMS
Respondents
Representation:
For the Appellant: The Appellant represented herself
For the Respondents: Ms Lorissa Tulloch-Mignott litigator of HM Revenue and Customs’ Solicitor’s Office
DECISION
Introduction
1. The Appellant applied to HMRC on 20 September 2024 under the DIY housebuilders scheme for a refund of £63,779.50 paid in respect of VAT on goods acquired by her (the “Claim”).
2. The Claim related to works done at a site on Park Road in Colchester CO3 which before the works had a small detached bungalow on it and after the works had a large house on it (the “Site”, the “Works”, the “Bungalow” and the “Large House”).
3. HMRC rejected the Claim on 9 April 2025 and upheld that rejection on review on 20 June 2025 (the “Rejection”).
4. The Appellant now appeals against the Rejection.
5. For the reasons explained in this Decision, we have concluded that the Works did not amount to the “construction of a building” for the purposes of s 35(1A)(a) VATA 1994 because the Bungalow did not cease to be an “existing building” and the Works constituted the reconstruction or alteration of an existing building. Therefore the appeal is dismissed.
preliminary points
Documents and evidence
6. For the hearing we were provided with an updated hearing bundle of 248 pages and an authorities bundle of 76 pages.
7. The Tribunal heard oral evidence from the Appellant whose evidence was unchallenged. We found the Appellant to be honest and credible.
8. The majority of our findings of fact are set out in 'The Facts' part of our decision. A significant proportion of our findings of fact are from the documents supplied or the largely unchallenged evidence of the Appellant. Consequently, most of them require no discussion as they were not in dispute. Where they were in dispute or require further discussion, we provide the reasons for our findings below. Therefore, generally we incorporate the relevant evidence in our findings rather than setting it out separately.
Parties’ submissions
9. We are grateful to the Appellant and Ms Tulloch-Mignott for their submissions, willingness to engage with our questions and to the Appellant for her evidence. We set out below our summary of those submissions on the law and the facts. The parties should, however, be assured that when preparing this decision our notes of the hearing were reviewed. Because we do not deal specifically with any point it does not mean that it was not considered in the round when reaching our decision.
Late appeal
10. In her Notice of Appeal the Appellant stated that she believed the appeal had been made in time although it was 10 days late. In all the circumstances, including the short delay, HMRC's lack of objection and having considered the three-stage test in Martland v HMRC [2018] UKUT 178 (TCC), we grant permission for this late appeal to be brought.
the issue, the burden of proof and the standard of proof
11. The issue between the parties is whether the Claim satisfies the requirements of s35 Value Added Tax Act 1994 (“VATA”), in summary whether the Works were the construction of a building.
12. The burden of proof is on the Appellant on the balance of probabilities.
the law
Legislation
13. Section 35 of VATA 1994 relevantly provides:
35 Refund of VAT to persons constructing certain buildings
(1) Where –
(a) a person carries out works to which this section applies,
(b) his carrying out of the works is lawful and otherwise than in the course or furtherance of any business, and
(c) VAT is chargeable on the supply or importation of any goods used by him for the purposes of the works,
subject to subsections (2) to (2C), the Commissioners shall, on a claim made in that behalf, refund to that person the amount of VAT so chargeable.
(1A) The works to which this section applies are—
(a) the construction of a building designed as a dwelling or number of dwellings;
(b) the construction of a building for use solely for a relevant residential purpose or relevant charitable purpose; and
(c) a residential conversion.
(2) The Commissioners shall not be required to entertain a claim for a refund of VAT under this section unless the claim—
(a) is made within such time and in such form and manner, and
(b) contains such information, and
(c) is accompanied by such documents, whether by way of evidence or otherwise,
as may be specified by regulations or by the Commissioners in accordance with regulations.
……
(4) The notes to Group 5 of Schedule 8 shall apply for construing this section as they apply for construing that Group but this is subject to [non-relevant exception].
14. Section 96(9) VATA provides that Schedule 8 VATA must be interpreted in accordance with its notes. Section 35(4) provides that the notes to Group 5 (Construction of buildings etc) of Schedule 8 apply for construing s35 as they apply for construing that Group. Notes 2, 16 and 18 to Group 5 of Schedule 8 VATA are as follows:
(2) A building is designed as a dwelling or a number of dwellings where in relation to each dwelling the following conditions are satisfied—
(a) the dwelling consists of self-contained living accommodation;
(b) there is no provision for direct internal access from the dwelling to any other dwelling or part of a dwelling;
(c) the separate use, or disposal of the dwelling is not prohibited by the term of any covenant, statutory planning consent or similar provision; and
(d) statutory planning consent has been granted in respect of that dwelling and its construction or conversion has been carried out in accordance with that consent.
……
(16) For the purpose of this Group, the construction of a building does not include—
(a) the conversion, reconstruction or alteration of an existing building; or
(b) any enlargement of, or extension to, an existing building except to the extent the enlargement or extension creates an additional dwelling or dwellings; or
(c) subject [non-relevant exception] below, the construction of an annexe to an existing building
……
(18) A building only ceases to be an existing building when:
(a) demolished completely to ground level; or
(b) the part remaining above ground level consists of no more than a single facade or where a corner site, a double facade, the retention of which is a condition or requirement of statutory planning consent or similar permission.
We refer to these as “Notes” in the rest of this decision.
the facts
15. The Appellant was granted planning permission on 24 September 2021 for the Works (the “Planning Permission”). The Large House has two storeys and double the square footage of the Bungalow.
16. Paragraph 2 of the Planning Permission relevantly provides:
The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the details shown on the submitted Drawing Numbers: 3512-PA-LOC, PA-10B, PA-11B, PA-12A……
17. The drawings are as follows:
(1) 3512-PA-LOC is an aerial map/plan labelled proposed extensions and alterations location plan. It shows the footprint of Large House on the Site and also that the Site is in a row of plots which have detached buildings on them.
(2) PA-12A is a more detailed aerial map/plan labelled extensions and alterations proposed site plan;
(3) PA-11B is labelled extensions and alterations proposed elevations;
(4) PA-10B is labelled the extensions and alterations proposed floor plans. We have included this drawing in the Appendix to this decision.
18. The Works were completed in accordance with the drawings referred to in the Planning Permission (and listed above) on 9 September 2024. Therefore, the Large House encompasses various of the Bungalow’s walls or parts of. These are shown fully in the plans in the Appendix to this decision (see where the existing construction is marked retained), but can be summarised as:
(1) The four walls of the sitting room, parts of which were internal walls in the Bungalow and smaller parts of which remain internal walls in the Large House, the remainder becoming or remaining external walls. Part of one of the internal walls also forms part of the entrance hall, one adjoins the study and a small part of one of the external walls extends to the external wall of the study.
(2) Two complete walls of the study, both of which were internal walls in the Bungalow and remain internal walls in the Large House. One adjoins the cloakroom and one adjoins the sitting room.
(3) Two walls of the games room, one of which was an external wall of the Bungalow, extending alongside the kitchen/dining area, and the other of which was an internal wall of the Bungalow. Those walls retain their respective characters as external and internal walls in the Large House. The internal wall forms part of the entrance hall.
(4) Two walls of the kitchen/dining area, the wall facing the terrace and the wall on the left-hand of the image that extends to the games room, both of which were external walls of the Bungalow and remain external walls of the Large House;
(5) Two shorter sections of the wall to the kitchen/dining area, both of which were external walls of the Bungalow and remain external walls of the Large House;
(6) Two short sections of the wall to the utility/boot room, both of which were external walls of the Bungalow and which become predominantly internal walls of the Large House.
19. Following completion of the Works the Appellant made the Claim. Following correspondence between the parties where HMRC sought and the Appellant provided further information in relation to the Claim HMRC rejected the Claim and the Appellant appealed the Rejection to the Tribunal.
discussion
The parties’ arguments
The Appellant
20. The substance of the Appellant’s case is that the conditions of the DIY housebuilders’ scheme were satisfied because:
(1) The Works were carried out in accordance with the drawings referred to in and therefore in accordance with the Planning Permission. The Planning Permission provided for the demolition of the existing walls to ground level, save for: the retention of the front façade; or at a corner site of the building a double facade; and
(2) In light of the above it does not matter that the Planning Permission is expressed in terms of an extension or alteration.
HMRC
21. The main points of HMRC’s case were that the Claim did not satisfy the requirements of the DIY housebuilders’ scheme because:
(1) The Works were an extension or alteration of an existing building. The Bungalow had not ceased to be an existing building for the purposes of Note 18 because substantially more than a single façade, or a double façade on a corner site, remained above ground level following the Works; and
(2) The retention of a single or double façade was not a condition or requirement of the Planning Permission.
22. Accordingly, HMRC submitted that the Works fell within Note 16 and were not the construction of a building for the purposes of s35 VATA. HMRC made a number of other points, which we address below, which were not central to its case.
Application of the law to the facts
23. Section 35 VATA provides that HMRC shall make a refund where a person carries out works comprising the construction of a building designed as a dwelling and their carrying out of the works is lawful and otherwise than in the course or furtherance of any business.
24. The crux of the issue between the parties was whether there was a “construction of a building”. There was no issue between the parties as to any other statutory requirements, subject to the points we address below.
Note 18
25. The Upper Tribunal in HMRC v J3 Building Solutions Ltd [2017] UKUT 0253 (TCC)said at [23] – [25]:
23. There is little difficulty about Items 2 and 4. The works involved in this case were clearly works of construction. What has to be considered is whether or not the works were the conversion, reconstruction or alteration of an existing building for the purposes of Note 16. It is those emphasised words which were not given proper effect by the FTT.
24. The words “existing building” are defined in Note 18. On the facts of this case there remained an existing building at all times. The pre-works building stood, and it was not demolished completely to ground floor level. What remained did not fall within Note 18(b), so there was an existing building at all times.
25. So it then becomes necessary to consider whether what was done amounted to conversion, reconstruction or alteration of that existing building. Those words cover a lot of metaphorical ground.
This is binding guidance as to the approach to Note 18 and Note 16 which we have considered and will apply: if the Works do not fall within Note 18 there will remain an existing building at all times. We turn to Note 18.
26. It is clear that the Bungalow was not demolished completely (and it did not form part of the Appellant’s case that it was). Therefore, Note 18(a) does not apply and we consider Note 18(b). That requires some consideration of the meaning of the word façade. HMRC said that a single façade was an exterior wall element facing a road. The Appellant said that it was a road facing wall.
27. In Northchurch Homes Limited v HMRC [2022] UKFTT 201 (TC) the First-tier Tribunal set out at [39]:
According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the principal meaning of facade is "The face or front of a building towards a street or other open place, especially the principal front."
We proceed using this definition.
Single façade
28. The Appellant’s primary case was that there was a single façade remaining after the Works. The Appellant identified that façade as the section of the sitting room wall which includes the window and runs parallel to, and below, the words “SITTING ROOM” in drawing PA-10B (in the Appendix to this decision). It appears that this part of the Bungalow meets the dictionary definition of a façade. However, in our view, the Appellant’s argument does not give effect to the words “no more” in Note 18(b). Those words impose a limit on the extent of the pre-existing building which may remain: no more than a single façade may be retained. If other parts of the pre-existing building could be retained without limit, provided only that no more than one of them was characterised as a façade, there would in principle be nothing to prevent the whole of the pre-existing building from being retained and falling within Note 18(b). That cannot, in our view, be what Note 18(b) means. We have found as a fact, and described above, the numerous other parts of the Bungalow which remained following the Works. They are parts of the pre-existing building which were retained in addition to (as they clearly do not form part of) the identified façade. On any view, therefore, more of the Bungalow remained than the single façade permitted by Note 18(b).
Double facade
29. The Appellant also advanced an alternative argument that, if the single façade requirement was not met, the Bungalow was a corner site on which a double façade had been retained. HMRC submitted that the reference to a “corner site” in Note 18(b) is to the nature of the plot, for example an end-of-terrace property with two elevations facing adjoining streets. The Appellant submitted that “corner site” referred instead to the corner of a building. On that basis, the Appellant identified the double façade as comprising the wall relied upon for the purposes of her single façade argument and the wall perpendicular to it, running approximately parallel with the boundary on the right-hand side of drawing PA-10B (in the Appendix to this decision). We do not need to resolve the parties’ differing interpretations of “corner site”, because the Appellant’s double façade argument encounters the same difficulty as her single façade argument. Even if we assume in the Appellant’s favour both that the double façade she identified was a corner site within the meaning of Note 18(b) and that the two walls identified by the Appellant constituted a double façade, the part of the Bungalow remaining above ground level did not consist of no more than that double façade. As we have found above, numerous other parts of the Bungalow remained following the Works. Accordingly, the requirements of Note 18(b) are not satisfied on the Appellant’s alternative case either.
Requirement of planning permission
30. HMRC also submitted that Note 18(b) could not be satisfied because the Planning Permission did not expressly require the retention of a single façade or double façade. HMRC relied on the decision of the Upper Tribunal in Boxmoor Construction Limited v HMRC [2016] UKUT 0091 (TCC) (“Boxmoor”) at [38]:
We consider that, in order for Note 18(b) to be satisfied, the planning consent must require, rather than merely permit, the retention of the façade. Mere inference is not enough. Where planning consent is granted subject to the condition that the work will be carried out in accordance with the plans then, where those plans show that a façade is to be retained, the retention of that façade is a condition or requirement of the consent. That is not the situation in this case. It is clear that nothing in the terms of the planning consent or the plans required the retention of the projecting bay. Indeed, it appears to us that the planning consent and plans envisaged the retention of rather more than the projecting bay although the FTT made no finding on that point and it is not part of our decision.
[Our emphasis.]
31. Although, in light of our conclusions above, it is not necessary for us to decide this point, we do not accept HMRC’s submission. We do not understand the Upper Tribunal in Boxmoor to have held that a planning permission must expressly use the words “single façade” or “double façade”. The requirement is that the retention of the relevant façade or double façade must be a condition or requirement of the planning consent. As Boxmoor makes clear, that requirement may be satisfied where the planning permission requires the development to be carried out in accordance with plans which themselves require a single façade or a double façade to be retained.
32. In this case, paragraph 2 of the Planning Permission required the Works to be carried out in accordance with the specified plans. We are therefore satisfied that the retention of the existing parts of the Bungalow shown on those plans formed a condition or requirement of the Planning Permission. That conclusion does not, however, assist the Appellant. As we have found above, the plans required the retention of considerably more of the Bungalow than the single façade, or alternatively the double façade, upon which the Appellant relies. The development shown on the approved plans therefore does not satisfy Note 18(b).
Note 16
33. Given our conclusions in relation to Note 18, the Bungalow had not ceased to be an “existing building”. As the Upper Tribunal explained in J3 at 24, Note 18 supplants any conceptual inquiry as to whether so little of the original building remains that it can sensibly be said to have ceased to exist. It therefore remained necessary to consider whether the Works amounted to the conversion, reconstruction or alteration of that existing building. The Upper Tribunal in J3 at [25] held that those words, taken together, are of very broad scope, with “alteration” in particular being capable of a wide meaning. In our view, the extensive Works carried out to the Bungalow plainly fall within the reconstruction or alteration of that existing building. Note 16 therefore applies.
Conversion
34. HMRC also addressed us briefly on whether the Works could constitute a residential conversion for the purposes of s35(1A)(c) VATA, by reference to Note 7A. However, the Appellant confirmed at the hearing that this formed no part of her case. It is therefore unnecessary for us to determine whether the statutory requirements for a residential conversion were met. However, we note that there was no evidence before us which suggested that they were.
Conclusion on s35 VATA eligibility
35. The Works are therefore outside s35(1)(a) VATA 1994 and are not eligible for a refund.
HMRC’s reservation of right to check invoices supplied
36. HMRC’s Statement of Case requested that if we found that the Works were eligible for a refund pursuant to s35(1A) VATA that HMRC were given an opportunity to examine the individual invoices in order to check the Claim. In light of our conclusion above we do not need to consider this point but we are doubtful that this avenue is open to HMRC for the reasons given at [61] to [63] in Smithers v HMRC [2020] UKFTT 380 (TC).
Conclusion
37. For the reasons given above the appeal is dismissed.
right to apply for permission to appeal
38. This document contains full findings of fact and reasons for the decision. Any party dissatisfied with this decision has a right to apply for permission to appeal against it pursuant to Rule 39 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009. The application must be received by this Tribunal not later than 56 days after this decision is sent to that party. The parties are referred to “Guidance to accompany a Decision from the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber)” which accompanies and forms part of this decision notice.
Release date: 23rd OCTOBER 2026
appendix
If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our tax lawyer.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).