Property United Kingdom

Albemarle Ealing No.1 Limited v Tawfeek Fahim & Ors

Official source

Neutral Citation Number: [2026] UKUT 408 (LC)

Case No: LC-2025-692

IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL (LANDS CHAMBER)

AN APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL PROPERTY CHAMBER

Ref: LON/00AJ/LSC/2023/0470

23 October 2026

TRIBUNALS, COURTS AND ENFORCEMENT ACT 2007

LANDLORD AND TENANT – SERVICE CHARGES – application not fully determined by the FTT – the distinction between costs incurred and future estimated costs – sufficiency of reasons

BETWEEN:

ALBEMARLE EALING NO.1 LIMITED

Appellant

-and-

TAWFEEK FAHIM AND VARIOUS OTHER LEASEHOLDERS

Respondents

Greystoke Court,

Hanger Lane,

London, W5 1EN

Upper Tribunal Judge Elizabeth Cooke

29 September 2026

Mr Tom Morris for the appellant, instructed by Mills Chody LLP

Ms Nicola Muir for the respondents, instructed by Comptons Solicitors LLP

© CROWN COPYRIGHT 2026

The following case was referred to in this decision:

Jarowicki v Freehold Managers (Nominees) Limited [2016] UKUT 435 (LC)

Introduction

1. This is an appeal from a decision of the First-tier Tribunal about service charges in its jurisdiction under section 27A of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. The appellant is the freeholder of Greystoke Court, which comprises three blocks of flats, and the respondents are the leaseholders of 38 of the 47 flats. I refer to them as “the landlord” and “the leaseholders”, for the avoidance of confusion since the landlord was the respondent in the FTT.

2. The landlord was represented by Mr Tom Morris and the leaseholders by Ms Nicola Muir; I am grateful to them both for their helpful arguments at an interesting hearing. Mr Morris was hampered by the fact that he had not appeared before the FTT, had not drafted the grounds of appeal, and had not been made aware by his client, at the time when he prepared his skeleton argument, of some very important facts.

3. The appeal was concerned with the following charges:

i. Major works: £1,487,349.48 demanded in advance on 8 August 2024

ii. Fire Doors: £146,533

iii. Lift repair/replacement: £102,660 and £60,884

iv. Emergency work on the lifts: £30,384

v. A charge disallowed in relation to insurance; neither party was able to tell me the amount in question.

The legal background

4. The FTT has jurisdiction under section 27A of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 to decide whether service charges are payable; section 19 of the 1985 Act makes provision about whether charges are payable. Some of the argument in this appeal rested upon the precise wording of those two sections so I set them out as far as relevant:

5. Section 27A says this:

“(1) An application may be made to [the FTT] for a determination whether a service charge is payable and, if it is, as to—

(a) the person by whom it is payable,

(b) the person to whom it is payable,

(c) the amount which is payable,

(d) the date at or by which it is payable, and

(e) the manner in which it is payable.

(2) Subsection (1) applies whether or not any payment has been made.

(3) An application may also be made to [the FTT] for a determination whether, if costs were incurred for services, repairs, maintenance, improvements, insurance or management of any specified description, a service charge would be payable for the costs and, if it would, as to—

(a) the person by whom it would be payable,

(b) the person to whom it would be payable,

(c) the amount which would be payable,

(d) the date at or by which it would be payable, and

(e) the manner in which it would be payable.”

6. Section 19 sets out circumstances in which a service charge will and will not be payable:

“(1) Relevant costs shall be taken into account in determining the amount of a service charge payable for a period—

(a) only to the extent that they are reasonably incurred, and

(b) where they are incurred on the provision of services or the carrying out of works, only if the services or works are of a reasonable standard;

and the amount payable shall be limited accordingly.

(2) Where a service charge is payable before the relevant costs are incurred, no greater amount than is reasonable is so payable, and after the relevant costs have been incurred any necessary adjustment shall be made by repayment, reduction or subsequent charges or otherwise.”

7. The different provisions in section 19(1) and 19(2) draw attention to the fact that the FTT may be asked to make a decision about a charge imposed in respect of a cost that the landlord has already incurred, or about an estimated charge demanded in advance of the cost being incurred. It is important that the FTT in making its determination distinguishes these two different types of charge and makes clear which type of charge is in question and which determination is being made; some confusion has arisen in the present case because the FTT did not do that.

8. Section 27A makes provision for the FTT to decide whether a service charge would be payable in respect of costs if they were to be incurred in the future.

9. Section 20 of the 1985 Act makes important provisions about consultation; its effect is that if works are going to cost leaseholders more than £250 each, the landlord must follow the consultation requirements specified in regulations. If it does not do so, no more than £250 can be charged to each leaseholder. Section 20ZA enables a landlord to apply to the FTT for dispensation from the consultation requirements:

“(1) Where an application is made to [the FTT] for a determination to dispense with all or any of the consultation requirements in relation to any qualifying works or qualifying long term agreement, the tribunal may make the determination if satisfied that it is reasonable to dispense with the requirements.”

10. At the time when the FTT heard the application in relation to the service charges in question, the landlord had applied for dispensations under section 20ZA in relation to charges for the lifts, the fire doors and the major works. The FTT had decided not to hear the section 27A application and the dispensation applications together because not all the leaseholders were party to the section 27A application. As a result, the FTT was asked to make determinations about whether service charges were reasonable and payable at a point when consultation had not been carried out and no dispensation was in place; at that point, therefore, a maximum of £250 per leaseholder was payable in respect of the lifts, the fire doors and the major works irrespective of whether the charges in question were payable pursuant to section 19 of the 1985 Act. Furthermore, some of the charges were not payable at all because the demands issued by the landlord were invalid, as is now admitted. Nevertheless the landlord wanted a determination that the service charges in question would be payable if properly demanded, so that it could charge the whole amount if it got a dispensation.

11. The FTT’s decision in the section 27A application was not entirely favourable to the landlord and is now appealed with the FTT’s permission. Meanwhile, on 16 June 2026 the FTT has granted conditional dispensations in relation to the lifts, the fire doors and the major works. There is a dispute between the parties as to whether the conditions imposed upon those three dispensations have been complied with. Moreover the FTT’s grants of dispensation have been appealed, with permission of the FTT, to this Tribunal; the Notice of Appeal was filed on 17 September 2026 and the appeal has not yet been listed for hearing.

The factual background and the proceedings in the FTT

12. The leases of the flats in the three blocks of Greystoke Court make unsurprising provision for service charges; the landlord is obliged to maintain the building, and the leaseholders have to meet the cost of its complying with its obligations. There is provision for estimated charges to be demanded in advance at set times (but not for ad hoc charges) and for balancing payments and reimbursements at the end of the year.

13. The landlord acquired the freehold in August 2023. It has planning permission to build 4 new flats in the eaves of Block 1 and to build nine new flats above Blocks 2 & 3. In December 2023 the landlord sent to the leaseholders a Notice of Intention (pursuant to the statutory consultation requirements) to carry out major works. A revised notice was sent in March 2024. I do not need to go into the detail of the consultation exercise because it is common ground now that it was not carried out properly, which is why a dispensation was sought. Whilst the failed consultation was in progress the leaseholders expressed grave concerns about the planned works as described in the notice. They took the view that much of what was set out did not fall within their service charge obligations, and that essentially they were being required to fund the landlord’s development plans.

14. Three contractors provided tenders in the course of the consultation exercise, and as a result a contract was awarded to Glanmire Design and Build Ltd whose estimate was for £1,489,174.59.

15. Service charge demands, by way of payment in advance for the major works, were sent out on 8 August 2024; they did not specify a date for payment and did not comply with the timing provisions for the demand of service charges in the lease. The amounts demanded varied, the maximum being over £55,000, and the total charged to the leaseholders was £1,487,349.48. Three weeks later the landlord sent letters before action to all the leaseholders and their mortgagees demanding payment in full and costs.

16. Such letters are the daily bread of the litigator, and it is worth remembering how terrifying they are to people who have not seen one before. Three leaseholders paid the charges demanded in response to those letters, in total £88,000. It is not now in dispute that the demands were invalid, and it is very troubling that that sum has not been reimbursed to those leaseholders.

17. Later in 2024 the leaseholders applied to the FTT for a determination as to whether the £1,487,349.48 demanded for the major works was payable. At the same time they challenged service charges demanded by the previous freeholder in relation to work to be done on the fire doors and the lifts, as well as other charges that are not the subject of this appeal. The scale of the material that was before the FTT can be gauged from the fact that the Scott Schedule extended to nearly 100 pages. 76 items within the schedule were components of the charge for the major works, broken down into the items for which Glanmire had quoted on the basis of the landlord’s specification.

18. The FTT conducted a four-day hearing; it made a number of determinations, not all of which are in issue in this appeal. I explain what was decided in the context of each ground of appeal.

Ground 1: the major works

The FTT’s decision

19. Counsel for the landlord before the FTT (not Mr Morris) in his skeleton argument acknowledged that unless and until a dispensation from consultation was granted the FTT could not make a final decision about the charges demanded in August 2024 for the major works, by way of payment in advance. But he sought a determination under section 27A in any event. His skeleton argument does not say precisely what the FTT was asked to decide, but I take it that the parties and the FTT wanted a decision under section 27A(3) as to whether or not the service charges demanded in August 2024, for the work specified at that date, would be payable if validly demanded and if the consultation requirements were dispensed with. The service charges demanded were estimated sums, and so the test as to whether they would be payable is set out in section 19(2) – although the FTT did not say so – which bears repetition:

“ (2) Where a service charge is payable before the relevant costs are incurred, no greater amount than is reasonable is so payable, and after the relevant costs have been incurred any necessary adjustment shall be made by repayment, reduction or subsequent charges or otherwise.”

20. The leaseholders challenged the charges on the basis that items within it were either part of the landlord’s construction works for the new flats, or were rendered obsolete by the construction works (a conspicuous example being a new roof for Blocks 2 and 3, when the roof was going to be removed so that two new floors could be built), or were not within the leaseholders’ service charge liability (for example, the proposed works to the windows of the flats, which were demised and therefore not part of the landlord’s obligation). They challenged the decision to demand the whole sum at once, rather than phasing the works over 10 years. Their expert witness gave evidence that much of the work was unnecessary or superfluous, and expressed serious concerns about the imprecision of the specification the contractor was working from:

“He said that the specification was of a poor standard and this would cause problems in analysing tenders. Too much was left to the contractor to speculate on and this would mean that there would be lack of consistency across the contractors’ tenders. He said he would start again and do a detailed description of the works required, with a better specification and schedules so that the contractors were clear about what they were pricing for.”

21. The FTT heard from Mr Butler, the director of the landlord. In the course of cross-examination he accepted that there were a number of items within the charge for the major works for which the leaseholders could not be liable, for example the roof of Blocks 2 and 3, and the wrap-around scaffolding. Of Mr Butler’s evidence the FTT said:

“51 … He was asked about the plans for the development works. He said the plans in the bundle were out of date. He said that the work was a moveable feast. He said the roofscape was changing and further planning permission may be required.”

22. The FTT’s conclusion about the charges for the major works was as follows:

“63. … It was patently clear that [Mr Butler’s] principal concern was getting his project completed for a profit. He gave the Tribunal very little reassurances that he appreciated the responsibilities of being a freeholder. He was unable to give straight answers about what was planned for the development, how it would affect leaseholders or indeed what the major works (which we were principally concerned with) would actually entail. The specification that had apparently been sent out to tenderers was woefully inadequate. This was described perhaps too politely by the Second Applicant’s expert, it did not contain proper quantities, it left too much for the contractors to speculate on and he would have scrapped it and started again. Mr Butler said the contractors were invited on site and it was a process of dialogue. This is inadequate. … More immediately we as a Tribunal are left in an impossible position speculating on major works costs without a proper specification. We refuse to do this and this is the reason why we make no determination in relation to the payability and reasonableness of the major works. We simply don’t have the correct information to do so.”

23. At the end of its decision in summarising its finding the FTT said:

“Major works – £1,487,349.48

97. For the reasons given above we make no determination on this issue. The

specification prevented any proper analysis of costs predicted. This does not

mean that the sums are due. The Respondent will need to address the issue of

the specification before any determination can be made. In any event there is

dispensation application to be considered.”

The arguments in the appeal

24. The grounds of appeal, drafted of course soon after the hearing and before the dispensation application had been determined, said that the parties were entitled to a decision about the major works. It was suggested that:

“12. In the instant case, notwithstanding its findings at paragraph [97] that the

specification was deficient, the Tribunal had a range of options available to it

including:

a. Finding on the basis of the defects of the specification that the disputed

charges were recoverable in principle under the leases, but only on

presentation of better evidence and compliant consultation.

b. Exercising its case management powers to adjourn this part of the

proceedings to enable further evidence to be obtained or pending the

outcome of the dispensation applications.

c. Exercising its case management power to issue further directions

inviting written submissions on this issue (as the Tribunal had done in

relation to the insurance premium for 2024/2025).”

13. The Tribunal’s failure to make a determination on this issue notwithstanding the substantial evidence before it prejudices all parties given it risks further disputes and additional costs being incurred. The Tribunal is accordingly invited to make a determination as to the payability and reasonableness of the Major Works.”

25. In response, the FTT granted permission to appeal and said:

“The Tribunal should have made a determination in relation to major works. In actual fact, we should have found that none of the major works were recoverable as the evidence before us prevented us deciding anything else as it was so poor or adjourned for further information. The latter would have been unfair to the leaseholders who wanted to achieve a final determination and had worked towards this.”

26. Mr Morris argued that the Tribunal should not follow that indication. In his skeleton argument he asserted that dispensation had now been granted so that that particular bar to payability has been removed. He pointed to authority as to the necessity for the FTT to reach a decision and set out the sum due (rather than leaving it to the parties to work it out: Jarowicki v Freehold Managers (Nominees) Limited [2016] UKUT 435 (LC)). He argued that the matter should now be remitted to the FTT:

“Now that a dispensation has been granted, it ought to be possible for the FTT to make a determination of [the reasonableness of the costs of the major works] on the basis of the specification relied upon and any evidence and submissions that the Respondents wish to make.”

27. If a dispensation had been granted in respect of precisely the works comprised in the service charge demand on 8 August 2024 then it would be appropriate for the FTT then to consider whether those charges were reasonable. Mr Morris wrote his skeleton argument not knowing that the dispensation had been granted only conditionally, and that the condition upon the dispensation made it clear that the scope of the works was no more clear at the dispensation stage than it had been at the time when the FTT made the decision now appealed. The decision of the FTT granting dispensation said this:

“96. The tribunal grants dispensation in respect of the works consulted upon between December 2023 and August 2024 and the contract awarded to Glanmire on the following conditions:

(a) The Applicant will serve on the leaseholders a revised scope of works setting out what works it intends to undertake which it considers are recoverable via the leaseholders’ service charges, with associated costs, including revised preliminaries appropriate to the revised scope of works.

(b) Once condition (a) has been complied with, should there be any dispute as to whether any of the proposed works form part of the Development Works, that question shall be referred to an independent surveyor nominated by the Respondents and the reasonable costs of that independent surveyor shall be paid by the Applicant.”

28. Ms Muir, referring to the grounds of appeal, pointed out that it was not for the FTT to give directions for the landlord to provide more evidence about the work it intended to do; and in any event no adjournment had been applied for. She pointed out that during the hearing before the FTT the landlord conceded that numerous items in the specification did not fall within the lessees’ service charge obligations; and it was not simply a matter of removing those items, because their removal would have a knock-on effect in terms of preliminaries, insurance, professional fees and scaffolding. It was not for the FTT to correct, or to supply missing quantities in, the landlord’s specification. It was for the landlord to persuade the FTT that its charges were fair and reasonable.

Determination

29. When looking at estimated charges demanded in advance the exercise the FTT has to carry out is necessarily imprecise because it has to decide whether the landlord has made a reasonable estimate. But even so, it needs to know what is going to be done and the sort of cost likely to be incurred. At the heart of the problem was that the specification provided by the landlord for the major works was imprecise, without proper quantities, which meant that inevitably what the contractor was going to do was unknown. In any event it was going to be affected by the landlord’s development works, which as Mr Butler himself said were “a moveable feast” and a process of dialogue with the contractor with a possibility that further planning permission might be needed. As a result the landlord was unable to show that the charges for the proposed major works would be reasonable and payable when properly demanded and following consultation or dispensation.

30. The suggestions made in the appeal (paragraph 24 above) are unrealistic. The idea that the FTT should have found that the disputed charges were “recoverable in principle … but only on presentation of better evidence” is incomprehensible; I do not see how the FTT could have found that the charges might be reasonable, or might be within the service charges in the lease, if the landlord were to provide evidence that they were. And it was certainly not for the FTT on its own initiative to adjourn and direct the landlord to provide fresh evidence or make further submissions, and the landlord did not ask it to do so. It was for the leaseholders to raise a prima facie case that the charges were not reasonable, as indeed they did, and for the landlord then to prove that they were. It did not do so. It could not show that the estimated charges for the work were reasonable, because it could not even show what the works were going to be.

31. As the FTT said in granting permission to appeal, the inescapable implication of what the FTT said was that the proposed service charges would not be payable. I set aside the FTT’s conclusion that it could not make a decision, and I substitute the Tribunal’s decision under sections 19(2) and 27A(3) of the 1985 Act that the charges for the major works as demanded on 8 August 2024 would not be payable if properly demanded, because they were not reasonable in amount as section 19(2) requires.

Consequences for the dispensation

32. At the end of its decision the FTT said this:

“The parties will need to reflect on this decision and the way it affects the other applications for dispensation before the Tribunal. When Mr Butler was being questioned, he accepted that it would make more sense for the development works to be carried out before the major works. This would allow the Respondent more time to properly prepare the specification of works for the major works and consult on the works in accordance with the Act. It is of course up to the Respondent whether they pursue this course.”

33. Despite that very sensible concession on Mr Butler’s part, the landlord maintained its application for a dispensation from consultation in respect of the charges for the major works as set out in the Glanmire contract, with the result that we have seen above (paragraph 27): dispensation was granted on 16 June 2026 by the FTT, “in respect of the works consulted upon between December 2023 and August 2024 and the contract awarded to Glanmire”, on the condition that the landlord tell the leaseholders exactly what were the works which it proposed to do and considered were recoverable via the service charge.

34. I have decided that the charges demanded in 2024 in respect of works to be done by Glanmire were not reasonable in amount and are therefore not payable. Where charges are not reasonable and not payable, neither consultation nor dispensation can enable the landlord to recover those charges. The Tribunal will invite the parties, in the dispensation appeal, to make submissions about the implication of the conclusion in this appeal both for the dispensation granted by the FTT in respect of the major works and for the appeal.

Ground 2: the fire doors

The FTT’s decision

35. Another item challenged by the leaseholders was the sum of £146,533 charged by the landlord’s predecessor in respect of 36 new fire doors. The charge was demanded in two instalments of £54,000 in the service charge year 2021-22 and £92,559 in 2022-23. The leaseholders’ position was that they had paid this charge in full but that only six fire doors had been installed – despite the fact that the replacement of the fire doors was required by the London Fire Brigade and was the subject of an Enforcement Notice served in August 2021 with which the landlord had still not complied. They also said that there would be no point replacing the fire doors because that work would be rendered redundant by the landlord’s development. The landlord’s response was that the doors had not been replaced because the leaseholders had not paid the service charge, and that the work would not be redundant.

36. The FTT said this about the fire doors:

“Fire doors – £54,000

69. The evidence about the fire doors becoming redundant was inconclusive. It is however disingenuous for the Respondent to blame service charge arrears. The work had only partially been completed accordingly we consider that only the amount completed should be charged. This represents 1/6 of the total sum namely £9,180. This is the sum due. Part of the fire doors cost has been subject to a dispensation application. It’s hard to glean from the application exactly what is included. It may be the case that the unit sum payable is only £250 until dispensation is granted.

…

Fire doors – £92559

72. The arguments on this item were a mirror image of the previous year. We allow £15725. Again, this might be affected by the dispensation application.”

37. The landlord sought permission to appeal on the ground that the FTT had failed to make a proper determination. It ought to have considered whether the works consulted upon were required and therefore reasonable, and whether the demanded sums were reasonably incurred or were reasonable in amount. As it was, the FTT appears to have found that the fire doors needed to be installed but had denied the landlord the ability to recover the cost of doing so, and it failed to give proper weight to the impact of the service charge arrears. The FTT granted permission to appeal on the basis that “we were required to assess the reasonableness and payability of these works notwithstanding that they had not been completed.”

38. The charges for the fire doors were the subject of a consultation in 2022 and 2023 by the landlord’s predecessor, but an application was made by the present landlord in April 2025 for dispensation from the consultation requirements, apparently on the basis that a different contractor was now being used. The application was determined by the FTT on 16 June 2026 and is one of the dispensations challenged in the dispensation appeal alongside those relating to the major works and (as will be seen below) the lifts. Dispensation was granted conditionally as follows:

“65. The tribunal grants dispensation in respect of the fire doors works consulted on between April 2022 and August 2023 and the contract ultimately awarded to On-Course Property Limited on the following conditions:

Within 30 days of this decision, the Applicant is to serve on the leaseholders confirmation of what works remain outstanding in the scope of works being undertaken by On-Course, which of these works it still intends to do and when.”

39. The parties disagree as to whether that condition has been complied with.

The arguments in the appeal

40. Again Mr Morris had not been placed in possession of all the facts, and initially argued that the charges for the fire doors all represented incurred costs, but after a short adjournment during the hearing for him to take instructions he explained that only the cost of the doors that have been replaced has been incurred; the rest of the charge remains an estimated charge for future work. He suggested that the FTT made a decision under section 19(1) of the 1985 Act about the costs incurred, and should have made a decision under section 19(2) about the five-sixths not yet incurred.

41. In his skeleton argument Mr Morris pointed out that the FTT did not find that the cost of the fire doors was not payable in principle, nor that they were not reasonably incurred. Instead, it allowed a proportion of the full cost on the basis of the proportion of the work that had been completed. That, he said, was an error of law. The FTT could only disallow the charge if the cost was not reasonable in amount or if the work had not been carried out to a reasonable standard (section 19 of the 1985 Act).

42. Furthermore, the FTT had not made any finding that the landlord did not intend to do the work.

43. As to the arrears, Mr Morris said it was open to the landlord to choose the work to which it applied money paid by way of service charge; there was a shortfall, and the landlord could not afford to do the work. The landlord sought to adduce fresh evidence about the service charge arrears and the resulting cash flow problem.

44. Ms Muir said that the leaseholders’ case was simple. They had paid £146,559 by way of service charges for the replacement of 36 fire doors between April 2021 and March 2023. Only 6 doors had been replaced by the date of the FTT hearing (one has been replaced since then). Therefore the FTT found that only the cost of 6 doors had been reasonably incurred. It is implicit in the FTT’s finding either that the rest of the cost was not reasonably incurred or that the rest of the cost falls to be re-credited to the leaseholders as section 19(2) anticipates.

45. The leaseholders say that the landlord has no intention of replacing the remaining doors. 30 remain to be done, five years after the Enforcement Notice. The plans shown to them by the landlord would render the installation of fire doors redundant because there were going to be new fire lobbies in different locations.

46. As to the landlord’s assertion that it cannot do the work because service charges have not been paid, the leaseholders say that that is disingenuous because they paid the charges demanded in 2021 and 2022 for the doors. The landlord’s accountant’s letter dated 6 May 2025 indicated that service charges for the estate were only £5,950 as at 31 March 2024. The new figures now produced are said to be incorrect and to include the amounts claimed in the invalid demands.

Determination

47. It is, I think, not controversial that the charges for the fire doors were, when demanded, for advance payments for costs not yet incurred. Four years on, the FTT allowed that proportion of the charges that actually reflected incurred costs. I read the FTT’s decision at its paragraphs 69 and 72 (set out at paragraph 36 above) as a determination under section 19(1) that one sixth of the costs charged were payable on the basis that they had been reasonably incurred.

48. That leaves the parties without a decision so far as the remaining five-sixths of the cost is concerned, as the FTT acknowledged in giving permission to appeal. The charge was, when demanded in its two instalments, a charge for future expenditure and fell to be examined under section 19(2) of the 1985 Act. The leaseholders raised a prima facie case that it was not a reasonable charge on the basis that the replacement of the fire doors would be pointless in light of the development works – as is evidenced by the fact that the remaining doors have not yet been replaced.

49. It was for the landlord to answer that case and to prove on the balance of probabilities that the remaining five-sixths of the charge was a reasonable advance charge to have demanded. Inevitably it had to address the fact that, in the event, the work had not been done, which certainly makes it look as if it did not intend to do the work – and its intentions remained in doubt at the later hearing of the dispensation application (paragraph 38 above). Mr Morris stressed that the FTT did not find that the landlord did not intend to do the work; but the leaseholders did not have to prove that. It was for the landlord to prove that this was a reasonable charge for work that it intended to do, and it failed to do that.

50. As Ms Muir said, another way of looking at this was to say that even if the whole of the advance charge was payable when demanded, now that the costs had been incurred and only one sixth of the money has been spent the rest is to be reimbursed. Either way the outcome is the same. I proceed on the basis that the FTT was deciding whether the charge was reasonable when demanded.

51. The landlord’s argument about arrears was most unconvincing. As the leaseholders said, its accountant’s letter of 6 May 2025, apparently commissioned by the landlord to show the state of its service charge account particularly in relation to the lifts and the fire doors, states that the amounts charged in respect of both had been paid, retained by the landlord, borrowed on occasions for other expenditure and then refunded to the service charge account, and finally incurred in doing part of the works. Evidence of later arrears is inadmissible and irrelevant.

52. Once the red herring about arrears is cleared out of the way it can be seen that the position as regards the remaining five-sixths of the charge for the fire doors is exactly as it was for the major works. The landlord failed to show that five-sixths of the charge was a reasonable charge to demand in advance, and therefore five-sixths of the charge was not payable. I set aside the FTT’s conclusion that one sixth of the charge was payable (amounting to £24,426), and I substitute the Tribunal’s decision that one sixth of the charge, in the sum of £24,426, was payable and the rest was not.

53. The dispensation granted by the FTT in respect of the charges for the fire doors (whether or not the condition has been complied with) no longer avails the landlord so far as five-sixths of the charge is concerned, since that five-sixths is not now payable whether or not a dispensation is in place. Again I will invite the parties to make submissions about the implications of that for the dispensation appeal.

Ground 3: the lifts

54. There are three lifts at Greystoke Court, one in each block. A large number of items in the Scott Schedule related to the lifts but only three are in issue in the appeal. The grounds for two items are different from the ground in relation to the third and so I have to separate ground 3 into two sections.

Ground 3(a): £102,660 and £60,884

55. Two of the sums in issue relating to the lifts were demanded in the 2023-24 service charge year. One is a charge of £102,660 for the modernisation of the lift in Block 1, said by the leaseholders not to be payable because the lift was going to be removed and replaced as part of the landlord’s development works which were going to include the provision of a new lift going to the new top floor. The second item in question is a charge of £60,884 described in the Schedule as “Section 20 money spent on lifts”; the leaseholders in the Scott Schedule said that they did not know to what it related.

56. At the hearing the leaseholders told the FTT that the landlord had served a Notice of Intention in 2023 so as to commence a consultation process in relation to “Repairs and/or replacement where necessary of the 3X communal lifts”. The leaseholders had objected to the works proposed in Blocks 2 and 3. A contract had been awarded to Empire Lifts, but the work to the lifts in Blocks 2 and 3 had been put on hold. The consultation process was not properly carried out, and a dispensation was applied for. Charges imposed for the work to the lift in Block 1 had been paid, but the work had not been completed.

57. The landlord’s position in the FTT was that “that money for the lifts paid by the leaseholders had been absorbed by other financial pressures” and that was why only one lift had been replaced (Mr Butler’s evidence, recorded at the FTT’s paragraph 54).

58. The FTT heard evidence from the director of Empire Lifts who explained that only one-third of the work required for the lift in Block 1 had been done:

“50. … The only reliable witness on the Respondent’s side in our view was the lift engineer, Mr Davies. He gave honest answers. His firm had not been kept in funds and that was why the lift improvement work had ceased.”

59. The FTT concluded:

“Block 1 Lift Modernisation – £102660

81. This sum is subject to a dispensation application. At present £250 per unit is the sum payable. We were asked to comment on the reasonableness of the sum nonetheless. The facts are that the work had been demanded and paid for by the leaseholders but the work has not been completed. In fact, Mr Davies estimated that only 1/3 of the work had been carried out. We allow 1/3 of the total sum which is £34,220.

…

Section 20 money spent on lifts – £60884

83. For the same reason given above we allow a 1/3 of the sum- £20295. This is of course contingent on dispensation being granted.”

60. In the dispensation proceedings the FTT granted a conditional dispensation in relation to charges for work on the lifts, and that is the third of the three dispensations that are the subject of the dispensation appeal in this Tribunal.

61. Reverting to the present appeal, the ground of appeal in relation to the FTT’s determinations in its paragraphs 81 and 83 is exactly the same as for the fire doors, and the FTT granted permission on the same basis, namely that it should have made a decision about the whole of the sum charged. Mr Morris in his skeleton argument dealt with these sums briefly and said that for the same reasons as those given under ground 2 this decision should be set aside and the sums claimed allowed in full.

62. Ms Muir argued that where costs are incurred, those costs are recoverable only insofar as they were reasonably incurred and insofar as the works were of a reasonable standard. Insofar as the lift works have not been done at all they cannot be said to have been of a reasonable standard.

63. Inevitably my determination is the same as for the fire doors; the landlord failed to show to the FTT that any more than one third of the charges of £102,660 and £60,884 were payable, and therefore I substitute for the FTT’s decision the Tribunal’s decision that the sums of £34,220 and £20,295 were payable and the rest was not.

Ground 3(b): £30,384 for emergency work on the lifts

64. One of the items in the Scott Schedule was a charge of £30,384 for emergency work on the lifts. The FTT said:

“Emergency Lift works – £30384

95. This appears to be a duplicate charge in relation to the lift charges above. If it is a duplicate it is not payable. If it is not a duplicate it’s unclear what it relates to.”

65. There is no other discussion about this sum in the decision. In the grounds of appeal it is said that the FTT made an error of fact because the charge was not a duplicate but was incurred for maintenance works, and moreover that the leaseholders conceded before the FTT that it was payable.

66. Ms Muir said that no such concession was made. She provided a copy of the landlord’s counsel’s closing note before the FTT in which various concessions were recorded, and this figure was not among them; the paragraph that refers to it (paragraph 5.4), treats it as being still in issue.

67. In the Scott Schedule the leaseholders’ comments are said to be set out in paragraph 28 of the statement of case, and I see from that document that they raised several issues about this sum. Various elements of it were said to be duplicated, to be inconsistent with invoices, unreasonable or incorrect.

68. In light of that, the FTT’s decision simply reflects the fact that the landlord had not shown that the charge for the emergency works, whatever they were, was reasonably incurred in the face of the leaseholders’ challenge. The leaseholders did their part in raising a prima facie case and the FTT was not persuaded that this charge was reasonable. The appeal fails on this point.

Ground 3 and the dispensation appeal

69. The dispensation from consultation in relation to the lift works related to the incurred and proposed charges in respect of all three lifts, and therefore the Tribunal’s decision on ground 3(a) will have implications for the dispensation appeal. I cannot say exactly what those implications will be because the dispensation decision is not entirely clear about the amounts involved. The Tribunal will invite the parties in the dispensation appeal to say what they think are the implications of the Tribunal’s decision in this appeal.

Ground 4: a deduction from insurance charges

70. This is the only ground of appeal where permission was given by the Tribunal and not by the FTT.

71. Insurance premiums were among the sums disputed before the FTT. The premiums themselves are not in issue in the appeal. However, in relation to the service charge year 2021-22 the FTT said this:

“Insurance costs – £56295

67. This was a recurrent item. … [there followed a discussion of the parties’ cases on the insurance premiums] We consider that this charge was reasonable and recoverable. There is however one aspect we were not happy with. This was the extra cost for the payment by instalments by the Respondent. This sum ought to be met by the Respondent as it is entirely for their benefit. The extra sum will need to be deducted from the total.”

72. Neither party could tell me what that sum was although Ms Muir thought it might have been £4,000.

73. Ground 4 is that the FTT should not have raised this cost on its own initiative; it was not complained of by the leaseholders. Mr Morris said the deduction of this item was irrational and that the decision was procedurally unfair. He said it was inexplicable because the cost was incurred every year but was deducted only for the year 2021-22. Furthermore the FTT did not explain whether this cost was disallowed because it was unreasonable or because it was not recoverable under the lease.

74. Ms Muir argued that the FTT was entitled to raise a new point if it fell within the broad scope of the application provided the parties were given the opportunity to address the issue. The parties were invited to make submission about insurance generally and did so. She asserted that the FTT deducted this cost in every year.

75. The FTT’s decision records a determination about insurance every year. Paragraph 67 was about 2021-22. For the insurance cost in 2022-23 the FTT said this:

“Insurance costs – £62005

71. The arguments on this item were a mirror image of the previous year. For the same reasons we allow the sum in full.”

76. The same was said for the insurance costs in the following years. Ms Muir said that it was implicit in those decisions that the extra cost for the payment by instalments by the landlord was to be deducted. I am afraid I do not see that. “We allow the sum in full” is unambiguous.

77. It appears to me that the FTT determination in the last three sentences of its paragraph 67, about the cost for payment in instalments, has to be set aside because at best it is unexplained. In light of the amount in issue I see no purpose in remitting the matter to the FTT for the determination of that issue. I substitute the Tribunal’s decision that the cost of insurance in 2021-22 was payable in full.

Conclusion

78. On grounds 1, 2 and 3, although the landlord has persuaded the Tribunal that the FTT failed to determine the whole question before it, the appeal fails insofar as I have decided that the sums in question were not payable. The landlord has succeeded on ground 4.

79. The leaseholders have applied for an order under section 20C of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 in respect of the costs of the appeal. If the landlord wishes to say that such an order should not be made it may do so within 14 days of the date of this decision.

Judge Elizabeth Cooke

23 October 2026

Right of appeal

Any party has a right of appeal to the Court of Appeal on any point of law arising from this decision. The right of appeal may be exercised only with permission. An application for permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal must be sent or delivered to the Tribunal so that it is received within 1 month after the date on which this decision is sent to the parties (unless an application for costs is made within 14 days of the decision being sent to the parties, in which case an application for permission to appeal must be made within 1 month of the date on which the Tribunal’s decision on costs is sent to the parties). An application for permission to appeal must identify the decision of the Tribunal to which it relates, identify the alleged error or errors of law in the decision, and state the result the party making the application is seeking. If the Tribunal refuses permission to appeal a further application may then be made to the Court of Appeal for permission.

ANNEX

LIST OF RESPONDENTS

TAWFEEK FAHIM (2)

MIRADEL INVESTMENTS CO LTD (3)

HANAN AL TAHAN AL TAHAN (4)

GARY SILVER (5)

GLORIA PUGH (6)

LOUISE EMMA BEN-NATHAN (7)

M DARUWALLA AND A YEO (8)

ST MAT INVESTMENTS LTD (9)

DANIELLE LYNDA ALMARY (10)

ARMEN KHATCHATRIAN (11)

PRAKASH AND CHRISTINE NANDWANI (12)

PAOLO BOSCHI (13)

PLR REAL ESTATE LIMITED (14)

HISHAM MAHMOUD (15)

MOHAMMED BAHA AL-MOUSAWI (16)

JOSEPH AND CHRISTINE FARREN (17)

GERMAINE KEMPLAY AMOW (18)

DENISE MICHELLE MURPHY AND TIMMY PATRICK O’KEEFFE (19)

HINA RAUF (20)

ROYE AND MS WILLIAMS (21)

MOHINDRA AND ARUNA DHALL (22)

HAMID REZA SHARIATMADARI-BAFGHI (23)

RICHARD OLADIPO (24)

SHARAM PARASPOUR MOGHADAM AND JOSEPHINE ANN CUNNINGHAM (25)

RAIMOND OHANIAN (26)

VUK BULATOVIC (27)

AKHTAR DADBAKHSH (28)

BIJAN KIMIACHI (29)

TRADE FINANCE CONSULTANTS CO LTD (30)

LINDA MURRAY (31)

AMIR NOUREAI (32)

AVISHA CHEHRAZI-RAD (33)

JAMES AND LUZ BUCHANAN (34)

SORAYA MALAK KHANOOM SADRI (35)

YASMIN SYED (36)

HARALAMBOS KASTELLIS (37)

ELIZABETH AITKEN (38)

MOHAMMED IBRAHIM (39)

AUDAY AL SAFFAR AND LUBNA AUDAY AL SAFFAR (40)

WB ESTATES DEVELOPMENT LTD (41)

For advice on a matter of this kind in France, contact our real estate lawyer in Paris.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.