Tax United Kingdom
Complete Electrical Services (NW) Limited v The Commissioners for HMRC
Neutral Citation Number [2026] UKUT 00416 (TCC)
UPPER TRIBUNAL
TAX AND CHANCERY CHAMBER
| Applicant: Complete Electrical Services (NW) Limited | Tribunal Ref: UT-2026-000070 |
| Respondents: The Commissioners for His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs |
RECONSIDERATION OF APPLICATION FOR PERMISSION TO APPEAL
DECISION NOTICE
JUDGE JEANETTE ZAMAN
1. The applicant, Complete Electrical Services (NW) Limited (“CESL”), applies to the Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber) for permission to appeal against the decision (the “FTT Decision”) of the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) (“FTT”) released on 16 January 2026 (TC/2022/14173). CESL applied to the FTT for permission to appeal against the FTT Decision and, in a decision notice released on 21 April 2026, the FTT refused permission on all grounds. On 21 May 2026 CESL applied to the Upper Tribunal for permission to appeal (the “Application”) and I refused that application on the papers in a decision released on 25 August 2026 (the “UT Papers Decision”).
2. CESL applied for that decision to be re-considered at a hearing. The hearing took place on 21 October 2026. I heard from Glyn Willmott and Alan Fielding for CESL and Ope Abolude for HMRC.
3. References below in the form FTT[x] are to paragraphs of the FTT Decision.
When does an appeal lie to the Upper Tribunal?
4. Pursuant to s11(1) Tribunals Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 an appeal to the Upper Tribunal may only be made on a point of law. An application for permission to appeal must demonstrate that it is arguable that the FTT made an error of law in reaching its decision which was material to that decision. “Arguable” means an argument that carries a realistic as opposed to fanciful prospect of success.
FTT Decision
5. The FTT dismissed CESL’s appeal against HMRC’s decision to issue a VAT assessment for the periods 10/15 to 01/19 for a total of £46,791 (as amended).
6. The FTT decided that the VAT assessment was made to the best of HMRC’s judgment, considering information provided by CESL, using an appropriate methodology and the information available at the time. The FTT found that CESL had not met the burden of proving, on the balance of probabilities, that the VAT assessment was incorrect.
Application for PTA
7. The Application, the letter applying for an oral renewal, Mr Fielding’s skeleton argument and the submissions by Mr Willmott and Mr Fielding at the renewal hearing were framed by reference to three grounds of appeal:
(1) Ground 1 – Procedural unfairness during remote hearing – Technical difficulties during the hearing affected CESL’s representative, Mr Mohammed, and he was disconnected and unable to re-join the hearing. The FTT erred in law by proceeding without ensuring effective participation or considering adjournment. The FTT did issue directions providing for written submissions to be made within 14 days, but this did not cure the prejudice to CESL, particularly given that the FTT then refused to admit the documentation that was provided on 18 August 2025.
(2) Ground 2 – Exclusion of Relevant Evidence – CESL provided further documentation on 18 August 2025, which included contemporaneous accounting records and VAT schedules (the “additional documentation”) capable of addressing the assumptions and calculations underlying the VAT assessment. This material was relevant to the correctness of the VAT assessment. The FTT’s decision to exclude this evidence was unfair to CESL.
(3) Ground 3 – Material effect on the substantive decision – The additional documentation, which was excluded by the FTT, was potentially capable of addressing the FTT’s conclusion that CESL had failed to demonstrate that the VAT assessment was incorrect. The exclusion of this evidence was therefore potentially material to the outcome.
8. There was some overlap between the reasons relied upon in support of Grounds 1 and 2. Whilst I have dealt with each ground of appeal separately, I have taken account of all of the submissions made for all of the grounds when making my decision.
Ground 1
9. This ground of appeal arises from the technical difficulties which arose during the FTT hearing and which resulted in CESL’s representative being disconnected and unable to rejoin the hearing.
10. Rule 2 of The Tribunal Procedure First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) Rules 2008 (the “FTT Rules”) requires that the FTT deal with cases fairly and justly. This includes seeking flexibility in the proceedings, ensuring (so far as practicable) that the parties are able to participate fully in the proceedings and avoiding delay, so far as compatible with proper consideration of the issues.
11. When deciding to refuse permission on this ground on the papers, I set out the following in the UT Papers Decision:
“13. I have considered whether it is arguable that there was procedural unfairness such that the FTT Decision should not be permitted to stand. It is important for this purpose to identify what happened. My understanding from the FTT Decision, the FTT PTA Decision and the Application is that the situation was as follows:
(1) The hearing was conducted remotely by video on 4 August 2025.
(2) It was attended by a representative for each party, Yusuf Mohammed for CESL and Ope Abolude for HMRC, and Officer Winnet Chamapiwa attended as a witness for HMRC.
(3) The technical difficulties arose during Ms Abolude’s submissions, from around 11.25am. By this time, I infer that Mr Mohammed had presented his oral submissions, and it is clear that Officer Chamapiwa had given evidence (which I infer would have included any cross-examination Mr Mohammed wished to conduct). Ms Abolude had been making her submissions for HMRC.
(4) Technical difficulties meant that Mr Mohammed was disconnected from the hearing. From this point, he could not hear what was being said and the FTT and HMRC could not hear him. The FTT was aware this had happened and there were attempts to resolve these technical difficulties to enable Mr Mohammed to re-join the hearing. This was unsuccessful.
(5) The hearing platform being used to conduct the hearing was still operational, in that the FTT and Ms Abolude were both connected. Ms Abolude confirmed to the FTT (in the absence of Mr Mohammed) that she had no further submissions to make beyond those set out in HMRC’s statement of case.
(6) The oral hearing was ended.
(7) The FTT issued directions that CESL may provide any final written submissions for consideration by the FTT in writing and by 18 August 2025.
(8) Mr Fielding of JML provided correspondence attaching further documentation on 18 August 2025.”
12. At that time the above was my understanding of what had happened based on the papers which were before me. Having since received Mr Fielding’s skeleton (which states at [12] that the technical difficulties “deprived the Applicant of the normal opportunity to make oral closing submissions in response to HMRC’s case”) and having heard from not only Mr Willmott and Mr Fielding but also Ms Abolude (who, as is clear from the above, had attended the FTT hearing) I am satisfied that this is an accurate summary of what happened.
13. I have considered carefully whether it is arguable that Mr Mohammed’s disconnection and inability to rejoin the hearing and the direction that any final submissions be provided instead in writing were procedurally unfair. Mr Fielding and Mr Willmott submitted that there was unfairness and that the subsequent directions permitting CESL to make written submissions did not adequately cure the inability to make oral submissions in response to HMRC’s case.
14. An assessment of the fairness of a hearing is a cumulative exercise, looking at its overall fairness – in Hima v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2024] EWCA Civ 680, which concerned the fairness of a FTT hearing, the Court of Appeal said (at [53]) that “what has to be considered is the overall fairness of the hearing”.
15. Having reconsidered the position in the light of the submissions made at the renewal hearing, I do not consider that it is arguable that there was procedural unfairness as a result of the technical difficulties and the FTT’s decision to direct that final submissions be provided in writing.
16. Mr Mohammed had, during the remote hearing, orally presented CESL’s case, heard Ms Abolude’s submissions for HMRC and cross-examined Officer Chamapiwa. There were no further oral submissions made by HMRC following the technical difficulties, ie the hearing did not continue in his absence. If the technical difficulties had not arisen, it would typically have been expected that Mr Mohammed would then have made oral submissions in reply to HMRC’s case (whether responding to HMRC’s oral submissions or the witness evidence which had been given at the hearing). This would have been done almost immediately after hearing from HMRC (potentially after a very short adjournment of, say, 10 minutes to enable him to review his notes). Instead, he was directed to provide written submissions within 14 days. This not only gave Mr Mohammed an opportunity to respond, but also enabled him more time to prepare his submissions.
17. I have concluded that the decision made by the FTT to end the hearing and give CESL the opportunity to make written submissions was pragmatic and entirely in accordance with the overriding objective in the FTT Rules. I am not persuaded that it is arguable that there was any procedural unfairness or that this case management decision of the FTT involved the making of an error of law.
18. I refuse permission to appeal on this ground.
Ground 2
19. This ground of appeal arises from the FTT’s decision not to admit the additional documentation which was provided by CESL on 18 August 2025.
20. The additional documentation is outlined at FTT[9], and the FTT’s decision not to admit this documentation is explained at FTT[10] to [12]. The additional documentation was provided to the Upper Tribunal with the Application and CESL also provided a further document, a VAT reconciliation, before the renewal hearing.
21. In the UT Papers Decision I accepted that the additional documentation was clearly potentially relevant to the matters under appeal. The VAT assessment was for the periods 10/15 to 01/19 inclusive, and the additional documentation included Excel spreadsheets of CESL’s bank account control transactions for the period 1 February 2016 to 31 October 2018 and its VAT transactions for the same period. However, it is important to identify that the FTT did not conclude that this material was not relevant. Instead, the FTT stated that the additional documentation was new evidence (FTT[10]), and had not been provided to HMRC for review and consideration at or before the hearing, referring to the fact that the hearing had already been postponed many times (FTT[11]).
22. I am not satisfied that it is arguable that the FTT made an error of law in excluding the additional documentation.
23. In Ladd v Marshall, Denning LJ set out three conditions that should be fulfilled to justify the admission of new evidence when he said (at page 1491):
“…first, it must be shown that the evidence could not have been obtained with reasonable diligence for use at the trial; secondly, the evidence must be such that, if given, it would probably have an important influence on the result of the case, though it need not be decisive; thirdly, the evidence must be such as is presumably to be believed, or in other words, it must be apparently credible, though it need not be incontrovertible.”
24. In Bramley Ferry Supplies v HMRC [2017] UKUT 214 (TCC) the Upper Tribunal said it should not apply the criteria in Ladd v Marshall as strict rules as the overriding objective requires the Upper Tribunal to take into account all of the circumstances of the case; but the Ladd v Marshall criteria are not irrelevant. These criteria are “persuasive authority as to how to give effect to the overriding objective” ([23]).
25. Here, it cannot be said that the evidence could not have been obtained with reasonable diligence for use at the trial.
26. CESL had plenty of time to produce this documentation, whether during HMRC’s investigation between 2019 and 2022 or following notification of the appeal to the FTT (noting that in CESL’s notice of appeal to the FTT they stated that working papers would be provided within 14 days (FTT[30]) but nothing was provided).
27. In the UT Papers Decision, I stated that no explanation has been provided as to why the additional documentation had not previously been provided. Mr Fielding has now explained (in a witness statement and at the renewal hearing) that he had prepared this documentation during the period from March to June 2025 in preparation for the FTT hearing. The reason it had not been provided to the FTT and HMRC before the hearing “was simply an oversight resulting from my then ill-health, other family concerns, and a heavy workload arising from post covid pressures of additional work and lack of experienced staff capable of the level of expertise necessary to assist with various matters” (according to his witness statement).
28. CESL thus accepts that the additional documentation existed and was available to be produced before the hearing. Permission may still have been needed at that time; but in any event it is not fair or just that the consequences of this oversight on behalf of CESL are borne by HMRC.
29. As to the second and third conditions, I have said that the material is relevant. However, they are schedules produced by or on behalf of CESL after the VAT periods in issue, apparently using other documentation (whether bank account statements (one of the Excel spreadsheets states it is a list of bank account transactions) or other material) but that other documentation has not itself been produced. I would expect that, if the additional documentation were to be admitted, there would be questions to be addressed as to the reliability of these schedules given the absence of the underlying documentation; they may not therefore have an important influence on the outcome.
30. I have also considered the circumstances in which the additional documentation was eventually produced to the FTT, including Mr Mohammed being unable to rejoin the hearing and the FTT issuing directions providing for written submissions. Mr Fielding stated that his understanding of the FTT’s directions permitting further submissions was to allow this material to be considered by both HMRC and the FTT, and these documents were intended to demonstrate that HMRC’s calculations were overstated in the amount of £22,673. He recognised that HMRC would need to have an opportunity to examine and respond to the documents.
31. This is wholly unrealistic. It has been repeatedly emphasised that the hearing itself is not a dress rehearsal, but is itself the first and last night of the show. The directions provided for written submissions to be made, and were not an open-ended invitation to CESL to check and see if there was further evidence it wished to submit, which had not only not been provided to the FTT and to HMRC before the hearing but which had not been raised by Mr Mohammed at the hearing. Admitting the additional documentation would potentially prejudice HMRC and is not in accordance with the overriding objective; and it is no answer to this to say that HMRC could be given an opportunity to address this evidence as that time has passed.
32. I am not persuaded that it is arguable that the FTT made an error of law in refusing to admit the additional documentation.
33. Permission to appeal is refused on this ground.
Ground 3
34. The third ground of appeal is essentially that any arguable error of law identified by the first two grounds was material to the FTT Decision.
35. This ground of appeal is not a free-standing or separate challenge, and on the basis of my conclusions in relation to Grounds 1 and 2, this ground does not identify an arguable error of law.
36. I refused permission to appeal on this ground.
Decision
37. Permission to appeal is REFUSED.
| Signed: Jeanette Zaman |
| Issued to the parties on: 27 October 2026 |
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).