Administrative United Kingdom
NR v The Secretary of State for the Home Department
First-tier Tribunal
(Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Appeal Number: PA/58489/2025
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
Heard at Manchester
On 26 October 2026
Before
JUDGE OF THE FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL C R COLE
Between
NR
(anonymity direction made)
Appellant
and
the secretary of state for the home department
Respondent
Representation:
For the Appellant: Ms S Khan, Counsel instructed by Amicus Solicitors
For the Respondent: Mr F Delacruz, Home Office Presenting Officer
DECISION AND REASONS
Anonymity Direction
1. I have decided to make an anonymity direction because in this specific case the importance of facilitating the discharge of the United Kingdom’s obligations under the Refugee Convention and the ECHR in the circumstances of this case outweighs the principle of open justice
Introduction
2. The appellant was born in 1993. He is a national of Afghanistan.
3. The appellant arrived in the UK on 29 August 2024 and claimed asylum.
4. By decision dated 25 February 2025 the respondent refused the appellant’s Protection Claim and Human Rights Claim.
5. The appellant appeals against the respondent’s decision pursuant to section 82(1) of the Nationality, Immigration & Asylum Act 2002.
Issues
6. At the outset of the hearing, I clarified with the parties the issues to be resolved in this appeal.
7. The respondent does not accept any of the material facts of the appellant’s account.
8. The respondent accepts that “There would not be sufficient protection from persecution in Afghanistan (Section 34 NABA) and you could not relocate within your home country (Section 35 NABA) if the key material facts of your claim were accepted.”
9. In the Review it was confirmed that the respondent is now satisfied that the appellant falls within a Particular Social Group (PSG). It stated that this is consistent with the Country Policy and Information Note: Fear of the Taliban, Afghanistan, February 2026 which recognises as a PSG those who transgress religious, moral, or societal norms, including individuals involved in extramarital relationships, as they are considered to have breached the Taliban’s moral code.
10. Thus, it was agreed that the credibility of the appellant’s account is the sole issue for resolution.
Documents
11. The respondent provided a bundle of 84 pages with Annexes A to F, including Screening Interview (SI), Asylum Interview Records (AIR1 and AIR2), supporting documents, and the Reasons for Refusal Letter (RFRL) dated 25 February 2025. The respondent also provided a Review.
12. The appellant provided a bundle of 21 pages which included the appellant’s witness statement, skeleton argument, country information, and case law. The appellant later provided further supporting evidence including videos and transcripts and a Taliban warning letter.
The Hearing
13. The appellant adopted his witness statement and gave evidence in Pashto.
14. The full details of the evidence and the submissions are contained in the Record of Proceedings which is within the court file. I have taken them into consideration in determining this matter. Consequently, I will not rehearse the evidence and submissions except where it is relevant to my findings.
15. After hearing the evidence and submissions, I reserved my decision.
Findings and Reasons
16. I have considered all the evidence, paying regard to the matters to which I was specifically referred, but only summarised those matters that have been of most assistance to me and which relate to the issues for me to determine.
17. The credibility of the appellant’s account is the key issue for me to determine.
18. The appellant’s asylum claim was made after the coming into force of sections 30 to 38 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022. Thus, section 32 applies to the assessment of the relevant factual matters relied upon by the appellant. Those matters fall to be determined on the balance of probabilities. However, the assessment of future risk remains subject to the lower standard of proof. It must be noted that the lower standard of proof still applies to any Humanitarian Protection/Article 3 claim.
19. I have chosen to initially reach my conclusions regarding the credibility of the appellant’s account applying the lower standard of proof. If the appellant cannot prove his case to the lower standard, then he cannot succeed under the Refugee Convention or under Humanitarian Protection/Article 3.
20. Under section 8 of the Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc.) Act 2004 I am obliged to consider certain behaviour as affecting an appellant’s credibility. I accept that the appellant travelled via France and Italy. The appellant did not claim asylum in either of these countries. The appellant’s account for not claiming asylum in these countries is not objectively reasonable. He did have the opportunity to claim asylum in a safe country.
21. Thus, this matter does undermine the appellant’s credibility to a limited extent. However, I must still assess the merits of the appellant’s protection claim considering all the evidence and applying the relevant standard of proof, whilst having regard to the appellant’s reduced credibility.
22. I have considered the appellant’s evidence with anxious scrutiny, taking account of the lower standard of proof. Nonetheless, for the reasons that follow, I do not find the appellant to be a credible or reliable witness.
23. The appellant's account is that he conducted a clandestine romantic relationship with his partner over a period of around four months whilst he was a married man living in a rural Afghan community. He claims that they communicated regularly by telephone, that she visited his house, that he visited her house, and that they travelled together to markets and other locations.
24. However, I find that the appellant was unable to provide a coherent or sufficiently detailed explanation as to how such a relationship was able to continue in secret.
25. The appellant's evidence was that his partner would visit his house and that, on occasion, his wife would be present. He maintained that his wife never questioned why his partner was there notwithstanding the frequency of the visits. He also claimed that his partner was able to leave her home secretly at night to meet him and accompany him to public places.
26. When asked how this was possible, his explanations were vague and lacked detail. He repeatedly asserted that meetings occurred “secretly” but provided very little evidence as to the practical means by which the relationship was concealed from family members and others in the community despite its alleged duration and frequency. I find that this is a significant deficiency in the evidence.
27. I also find the appellant's account of the relationship being discovered to be unclear and lacking in detail. The appellant ultimately stated that his partner had refused a proposed marriage offer and declared that she wished to only marry the appellant. He claims that this led to her brothers killing her and subsequently seeking to kill him.
28. However, the evidence does not provide a clear and coherent account of how the family came to conclude that an illicit relationship existed. On the appellant's own case, neither he nor his partner were discovered together. There is no satisfactory explanation as to how the family acquired the information which allegedly led to such extreme consequences. The absence of a coherent account of this pivotal event materially undermines the reliability of the claim.
29. I have carefully considered the video recordings and transcripts. At their highest, the recordings appear to show a discussion involving individuals seeking the appellant and making threats. However, the videos are undated. There is no independent evidence as to when they were recorded, who recorded them, or the identities of those appearing within them. The appellant relies entirely upon his own assertions regarding these matters.
30. Furthermore, I note that the content of the videos sits uneasily with other aspects of the appellant's account. In his evidence he stated that members of his partner’s family attended his home and opened fire, killing his brothers. The videos instead depict what appears to be a discussion and negotiation concerning the appellant's whereabouts rather than the aftermath of a violent attack that had already resulted in the deaths of two of his brothers. I accept that these events are not necessarily mutually exclusive. However, the differing nature of the accounts does little to enhance the reliability of the narrative advanced by the appellant.
31. In any event, the recordings do not specifically refer to an illicit relationship with his partner. Even if accepted as genuine recordings, they do not establish the central factual basis of the appellant's protection claim.
32. I have also considered the warning letter said to emanate from the Taliban. I attach little weight to this document. It is undated and there is no reliable evidence regarding its provenance or how it was obtained. The document contains no meaningful detail regarding the underlying allegations against the appellant and does not explain why he is sought. I bear in mind the guidance in Tanveer Ahmed and assess the document in the context of the evidence as a whole. In my judgment, assessed in the round and in light of my concerns regarding the credibility of the core account, the letter does not provide independent corroboration capable of materially advancing the appellant's case.
33. Drawing these matters together, I find that the appellant's account contains significant gaps, lacks coherent detail concerning the operation and discovery of the alleged relationship, and is not materially supported by the documentary evidence upon which he relies.
34. I have carefully considered Ms Khan's submissions that the appellant gave his evidence in a broadly consistent manner, that the video recordings provide support for his account, and that caution should be exercised before rejecting an account solely on the basis that aspects of it appear unusual or unexpected. I have borne those submissions firmly in mind.
35. However, my concerns do not arise simply because the account is unusual. Rather, they arise from the appellant's inability to provide a coherent and sufficiently detailed explanation of key aspects of his claim, the lack of a satisfactory account as to how the alleged relationship was discovered, and the limited evidential weight that I am able to attach to the documentary and video evidence for the reasons set out above.
36. I accept that the background evidence demonstrates that persons involved in actual or perceived extramarital relationships may face very serious consequences in Afghanistan. However, the issue in this appeal is not whether such consequences can occur. The issue is whether the appellant has established, even to the lower standard of proof, that the events he describes actually occurred and that he is a person of adverse interest for the reasons claimed. For the reasons already given, I am not satisfied that he has done so.
37. Having considered all of the evidence in the round and applying the lower standard of proof, I am not satisfied that the appellant has established that his claimed relationship with his partner, her alleged killing, or the subsequent interest of her family and the Taliban are reasonably likely to have occurred as claimed. Accordingly, I reject the core of the appellant's account.
38. Therefore, I find that the appellant has failed to prove that he would be at real risk of serious harm on return to Afghanistan.
Notice of Decision
The appeal is dismissed on all grounds.
Order regarding anonymity
Unless and until the Tribunal, the Upper Tribunal, or, a Court orders otherwise, pursuant to rule 13(1)(b) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Rules 2014, the appellant is granted anonymity.
No-one shall publish or reveal either directly or indirectly any information, including his name or address, that is likely to lead members of the public to identify him. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.
Signed C R Cole Date 27 October 2026
Judge C R Cole
Judge of the First-tier Tribunal
TO THE RESPONDENT
FEE AWARD
The appeal has been dismissed and so there can be no fee award.
Signed C R Cole Date 27 October 2026
Judge C R Cole
Judge of the First-tier Tribunal
If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our immigration lawyer in Paris.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).