Administrative United Kingdom

Tung Foods Limited v The Pensions Regulator

Official source

NCN: [2026] UKFTT 01467 (GRC)

Case Reference: FT/PEN/2026/0022

First-tier Tribunal

(General Regulatory Chamber)

Pensions

Decided without a hearing

Heard on: 16 October 2026

Decision given on: 27 October 2026

Before

JUDGE SIMON BIRD KC

Between

tung foods limited

Appellant

and

THE PENSIONS REGULATOR

Respondent

Decision: The reference is dismissed and the Fixed Penalty Notice and Escalating Penalty Notice confirmed. The matter is remitted to the Respondent. No further directions are required.

REASONS

1. This is the Appellant’s appeal by way of reference in respect of a fixed penalty notice (FPN) with reference 2501257-002021 issued on 3 October 2025 under section 40 of the Pensions Act 2008 (PA 2008). The Notice was issued because the Respondent was of the opinion that the Appellant had failed to comply with a Compliance Notice (CN) issued under section 35 of the PA 2008 on 11 August 2025 with a deadline date of 23 September 2025. The Appellant also appeals against an escalating penalty notice (“EPN”) issued under section 41 on the PA 2008 with reference 2501257-002159 issued on 4 November 2025 in respect of continued non-compliance with the CN.

The Legal Framework

2. The Pensions Act 2008 and the Employer’s Duties (Registration and Compliance) Regulations 2010 impose a number of legal obligations on employers in relation to the automatic enrolment of certain employees into occupational or workplace personal pension schemes. The Respondent has statutory responsibility for securing compliance with these obligations and may exercise certain enforcement powers.

3. This appeal relates to the duty of the employer to pay relevant contributions to an occupational or personal pension scheme and the duty to provide the Respondent with the information prescribed under section 11 of the PA 2008. The information to be provided to the Respondent is prescribed in the Employers’ Duties (Registration and Compliance) Regulations 2010 (‘the 2010 Regulations’). It includes information about the number of workers automatically enrolled into a pension scheme, those already in a pension scheme, and those not in either category, as well as details of the pension provider and scheme (if any). Regulation 3(1) of the 2010 Regulations sets the deadline for providing the information, which is five months starting from employer’s staging date (the date when the automatic enrolment legislation first applies to the employer). Regulation 4(1) of the 2010 Regulations also sets the deadline for providing re-enrolment information, which is within five months beginning with the third anniversary of the employer’s staging

4. In this case the Respondent issued the CN requiring the Appellant to do the following:

– Work out which staff had to be put into a pension scheme and which could to be put into its scheme (opt in or join).

– Put relevant staff into a scheme, including those who ask.

– Write to all staff to give them information explaining how automatic enrolment affected them, what their individual entitlements were from the Appellant’s staging date or duties start date, and the option to pay any unpaid staff contributions (which may be paid in instalments).

– Calculate and pay unpaid employer contributions from its staging date or duties start date, by the deadline out in the CN.

– Complete or correct the declaration of compliance to inform The Pensions Regulator that it had complied with its employer duties.

5. The Respondent has the power to issue a CN requiring amongst other matters, an employer to pay unpaid pension contributions into a pension scheme and to provide evidence that it has done so (ss.35 and 38 of the PA 2008). In the event of the employer failing to comply with a CN, the Respondent has the power under section 40 of the PA 2008 to issue a FPN in the sum of £400 and, where there is a continuing failure to comply with a CN, an EPN at a prescribed daily rate not exceeding £10,000.

Background

6. The Respondent contends that the Appellant failed to comply with a CN issued on 11 August 2025, which required the specified steps outlined above to be taken by 23 September 2025.

7. The Appellant’s registered office is Block A, Victoria Docks, Balaclava Road, Caernarfon, Gwynedd LL55 1TH. The Respondent states that all statutory notices were sent to that registered office address. It also states that it made a number of attempts by e-mail (using the address provided to it by the Respondent when completing its Declaration of Compliance) and by telephone to alert the Appellant of the requirements of the CN and the need to comply with it. No contact was established.

8. On 3 October 2025, as the Appellant had not responded to the CN, the Appellant issued the FPN which, the Appellant states was posted to the Respondent’s registered office. It was explained in the FPN that an EPN might be issued in the event that there was continued no compliance with the CN. The Respondent states that it sought to contact the Appellant by e-mail on 22 October 2025 as the date for compliance set by the FPN was approaching.

9. On 3 November 2025, the Respondent received a report from NEST, the Appellant’s chosen provider, which showed that none of its employees had been enrolled on the pension scheme since 2023.

10. On 4 November 2025, as the Appellant had still not complied with the CN, the EPN was issued which stated that the penalty would accrue at the rate of £500 per day in the event that the Appellant failed to comply by the deadline. The Respondent subsequently e-mailed the Appellant on two occasions to remind it of the need to comply. Once the escalating penalty was accruing, the Respondent sent the Appellant two further e-mails reminding of its need to take steps to comply with the CN. On 31 December 2026, the Respondent e-mailed the Appellant to state that the accrued penalty then amounted to £14,400.

11. The Appellant’s first contact with the Respondent in respect of the notices was on 13 January 2026 in a telephone call. During this call, the Appellant’s representative stated that none of its employees wished to enrol into a pension scheme and, as a result the Appellant had not enrolled them. It was also stated that the Appellant had difficulty accessing the e-mail address which had been used by the Respondent to contact it and it challenged the claim by the Respondent that it had correctly issued and posted the notices.

12. On 14 January 2026, the Appellant e-mailed to the Respondent confirming that it had submitted its Declaration of Compliance confirming that Automatic Enrolment duties did not apply. On the same day, it also emailed the Respondent to confirm that four of its employees were enrolled into the NEST scheme. NEST confirmed on 20 January 2026, that the four employees had been enrolled on 14 January 2026.

13. The Appellant sought a review of the Respondent’s EPN on 20 January 2026. The Respondent’s upheld the penalty notices and communicated this to the Appellant by letter dated 11 February 2026. The Appellant appealed to the Tribunal on 12 February 2026.

The Appellant’s Grounds of Appeal

14. The Appellant contends that the breach resulted from administrative and human error rather than any deliberate failure to comply with automatic enrolment obligations. It says there was a misunderstanding of the interaction between Sage payroll software and NEST, incorrect reference numbers were used when declaring duties, and there was confusion about the process for employees opting in or out of a pension scheme. The Appellant maintains there was no intention to mislead the Respondent or neglect its duties.

15. The Appellant says it never received the Compliance Notice that the Respondent alleges was sent by post and did not receive any telephone calls from the Appellant on its main business number. It argues that, had it been aware of the notice, it would have addressed the matter much sooner.

16. The Appellant states that the Respondent was communicating with an e-mail account which had not been accessed or used by it since 2023. As a result, the Appellant did not see the email communications sent by the Respondent. The Appellant says it has since regained access to that account and now monitors it regularly.

17. The Appellant's case is that it first became aware of the Fixed Penalty Notice and Escalating Penalty Notice during a telephone conversation with the Respondent on 13 January 2026. It says that, once informed, it investigated the position immediately and responded to Respondent within 24 hours.

18. The Appellant states that it took immediate corrective action after learning of the problem. It enrolled employees into the NEST pension scheme, paid the missed pension contributions (said to amount to approximately £309.60), submitted the necessary exception schedule, and provided evidence of compliance to the Respondent.

19. The Appellant argues that the underlying issue involved an overlooked contribution and administrative mistake, rather than a conscious decision not to comply with pension legislation. It submits that its conduct after January 2026 demonstrates a willingness to comply.

20. The Appellant contends that Respondent did not use its principal business landline and that the correct contact details could readily have been found had they been looked for. It argues that a simple search would have enabled direct contact and earlier resolution of the issue.

21. The principal remedy sought is the cancelation of the Escalating Penalty Notice. The Appellant argues that a penalty of approximately £14,000is wholly disproportionate in circumstances where the underlying missed contributions amounted to about£309.60, there was no deliberate wrongdoing, and compliance was achieved promptly once it became aware of the issue.

22. The Appellant asks the Tribunal to revoke the Escalating Penalty Notice on the basis of reasonable excuse, non-receipt of communications, prompt remediation, absence of deliberate non-compliance, and the alleged disproportionality of the penalty.

The Respondent’s Response to the Appeal

23. In response to the Appellant’s grounds of appeal, the Respondent contends that the Compliance Notice, Fixed Penalty Notice and Escalating Penalty Notice were sent to the company's registered office. The registered office address was the address for the Appellant recorded at Companies House. Service by post is expressly permitted by the legislation. The registered office exists precisely so that official and legal correspondence can be served upon a company. Accordingly, the Respondent argues that all relevant notices were validly served.

24. The Respondent relies on the statutory presumption that documents properly addressed and posted are deemed to have been delivered. It submits that the Appellant's assertion that it did not receive the notices is unsupported by evidence and amounts to nothing more than a "bare assertion" of non-receipt. It relies on the decision of the Upper Tribunal in London Borough of Southwark v Akhter [2017] UKUT 150, where it was held that a mere assertion of non-receipt is insufficient to displace the statutory presumption of service and Keith's Rubbish Clearance Ltd v The Pensions Regulator (PEN/2020/0203), where the Tribunal reached a similar conclusion in the pensions context. The Respondent therefore contends that the Tribunal should find that the notices were received.

25. The Respondent also relies on the fact that it sent multiple emails between July and December 2025, attempted telephone contact on more than one occasion, emailed copies of the Compliance Notice, Fixed Penalty Notice and Escalating Penalty Notice to the Appellant and continued trying to alert the Appellant even after penalties had begun accruing. It argues that it took reasonable and repeated steps to bring the compliance issues to the Appellant's attention.

26. The Respondent rejects the suggestion that the penalties should be cancelled because the company did not access its email account. It states that the email address used was the address supplied by the Appellant, the registered office was the address recorded by the company at Companies House and it is the Appellant's responsibility to maintain and monitor its own official contact details. Any failure to receive communications because an email account was not being monitored is therefore the Appellant's responsibility.

27. The Respondent accepts that the Appellant eventually enrolled employees into a pension scheme in January 2026 and thereafter achieved compliance. However, the Respondent argues that subsequent compliance does justify the cancellation of the penalties that were correctly imposed when the Appellant was in breach. The relevant question is whether the notices were properly issued at the time, not whether compliance was later achieved.

28. As to the quantum of the penalty and the Appellant’s claim that it was disproportionate, when compared with the underlying contribution shortfall of about £309.60, The Appellant states that the escalating penalty accrued because the company did not comply for an extended period, the amount was generated by the statutory penalty regime, and the proper focus for the Tribunal should be on whether the statutory conditions for issuing the notices were met. The fact that the missed pension contributions were relatively modest does not, in the Respondent’s submission, undermine the validity of the escalating penalty.

Conclusions

29. The Tribunal’s jurisdiction is derived from section 44 of the PA 2008. Where a person to whom a relevant has been issued under under the PA 2008 has first made an application for review of the FPN, they may then make a reference to the Tribunal. The role of the Tribunal is to make its own decision on the appropriate action for the Regulator to take, considering all the evidence before it. The Tribunal may confirm, vary or revoke a Fixed Penalty Notice and when it reaches a decision, it must remit the matter to the Regulator with such directions (if any) required to give effect to the decision.

30. The issues in this appeal are:

Whether the Compliance Notice, Fixed Penalty Notice and Escalating Penalty Notice were served and received by the Appellant?

Whether there was a reasonable excuse for the failure to comply with the CN?

Whether the penalties set by the FPN and EPN were disproportionate having regard to the Appellant’s breach?

Service and Receipt of the Notices

31. Section 303 of the Pensions Act 2004, applied by section 144A of the PA 2008 to notices issued under its provisions, provides that:

“…

(2) The notification of document may be given to the person in question –

(a) by delivering it to him;

(b) by leaving it at his proper address, or

(c) by sending it by post to at that address.

….

(6) For the purposes of this section and section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978 (c.30)(service of documents by post) in its application to this section, the proper address of a person is –

(a) in the case of a body corporate, the address of the registered or principal office of the body,

….”

32. The Appellant is a body corporate and, therefore, section 303(6)(a) of the 2004 Act applies to the instant reference.

33. Section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978, referred to in section 303(6), provides that:

“Where an Act authorises or requires any document to be served by post (whether the expression “serve” or the expression “give” or “send” or any other expression is used) the, unless the contrary intention appears, the service is deemed effected by properly addressing, pre-paying and posting a letter containing the document and, unless the contrary is proved, to have been effected at the time at which the letter would be delivered in the ordinary course of post”.

34. Section 7 therefore provides for a rebuttable presumption that a notice which is contained in a letter which is properly addressed, pre-paid and posted is to be deemed served at the time the letter would be delivered in the ordinary post.

35. The Respondent is also able to rely on a second set of rebuttable presumptions as to the issue and service of notices under the PA 2008 contained in regulation 15 of the Employer’s Duties (Registration and Compliance” Regulations 2010 (the 2010 Regs). Regulation 15 provides:

“(3) The presumptions in paragraph (4) apply where notices to which section 43 applies are issued…..

(4) For the purposes of this regulation, it is presumed that –

(a) where a notice is given a date by the Regulator, it was posted or otherwise sent on that day;

(b) if a notice is posted or otherwise sent to a person’s last known or notified address, it was issued on the day on which that notice was posted or otherwise sent; and

(c) a notice was received by the person to whom it was addressed.”

36. In essence, once the Respondent has discharged the evidential burden of establishing that the relevant notice was issued and properly addressed, if an Appellant claims not to have received the relevant notice, they bear the onus of rebutting the regulation 15(4)(c) presumption that it was received by them. The presumptions have been described as strong statutory presumptions (Keith’s Rubbish Clearance Limited v The Pensions Regulator PEN/2020/0203).

37. In London Borough of Southwark v Akhtar [2017] UKUT 150 (LC) the Tribunal explained the effect of the presumption of receipt in the following terms:

“82. A legal presumption like the one in s.7 has the effect of reversing the burden of proof. Once the landlord has proved that the notice was properly addressed, pre-[aid and posted, it has nothing further to do – unless the contrary is proved. If the contrary is provide, then the landlord must, as it were, go the long way round and actually prove service without the help of the presumption and must therefore convince the tribunal on the balance of probabilities that the notice was actually received. But it is only required to do that if the contrary is proved and not if the contrary is merely asserted”.

38. In Keith’s Rubbish Clearance Limited, the Tribunal further emphasised that a bare denial or receipt of the relevant notice was insufficient to discharge the presumption of service.

Finding on Service and receipt

39. I am satisfied from the evidence provided by the Respondent’s case officer as to the manual process involved in the service of each of the CN, the FPN and the EPN that, as a matter of fact the Respondent has shown that it is more likely than not that they were issued by it by post to the registered office of the Appellant. That is sufficient to engage the presumption of service contained in section 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978 and that contained in Regulation 15(4)(c) that the notices were received by the Appellant.

40. Other than a bare assertion from the Appellant that it did not receive the notices, the Appellant advances no reason why notices issued and posted by the Respondent might not have come to its attention. The notices were correctly addressed to the Appellant’s registered office and it has not suggested that there was any issue with post sent to that address coming to its attention. Even if there were, as is clear from section 86 of the Companies Act 2006, it is for the Appellant to ensure that its registered address is one which can be used to serve documents which need to come to the attention to those in control of the Appellant’s affairs.

41. I agree following, London Borough of Southwark v Akhter, that a bare denial is insufficient to rebut the statutory presumptions of service and that they are strong presumptions. There is nothing by way of evidence before the Tribunal on which it could conclude that the presumptions of service and receipt have been rebutted.

42. I therefore find both as a matter of fact and law that the CN, the FPN and the EPN were served on and received by the Appellant. The absence of knowledge of the notices cannot, therefore, be attributed to their non-receipt.

“System Failure”

43. Whilst the Appellant has sought to rely on “system failure” in reality this appears to have been a failure on its part to understand the interface between their SAGE payroll and NEST rather than any failure of the systems. There was also some obvious internal misunderstanding of the correct process for Automatic Enrolment and what it required of the Appellant. There was an obligation on it to enrol the relevant employees and then for those employees to decide whether or not to opt out. Further, as is clear from the evidence and contrary to the Appellant’s initial contention to the Respondent, it did have employees who wished to be enrolled and were enrolled as NEST confirmed in January 2026.

44. It was the Appellant’s responsibility to apprise itself of its relevant obligations under the PA 2008 and to ensure that it understood those requirements. The Compliance Notice gave what, in my view, were clear steps which would have enabled the Appellant to comply and to avoid the FPN and EPN. However, it was not for the Respondent to explain the obligations to the Appellant. As a responsible employer it should been aware of and complied with its obligations without any need for the Respondent to try to make contact by e-mail and telephone to alert it to potential breaches.

45. The fact that the Respondent’s e-mails did not come to the notice of anyone at the Appellant cannot be a matter laid at the Respondent’s feet. It used an e-mail address it had been provided with by the Appellant when completing its declaration of compliance and it was an e-mail adderess which the Appellant could, if had tried, have secured access, as events show. The fact that the Appellant’s director might have been locked out of an e-mail address in 2023 which had it had chosen to use in important communications with a statutory regulator, does not explain why it had not taken steps to secure access to that e-mail inbox much earlier and at a time which would could have ensured that it avoided breaching is obligations under the PA 2008.

46. Whilst I accept that the Appellant’s failings were not deliberate and that, when it ultimately appreciated what they were, it took immediate steps to remedy the position, overall, I see no reasonable excuse for its non-compliance with the CN having regard to the matters raised and it is this which gave rise to the FPN and the EPN. I therefore conclude that those notices must be confirmed.

47. Whilst the Appellant contends that the level of overall penalty is disproportionate to the breach, taking into account the level of unpaid pension contribution, the level of penalty is prescribed by regulations 12 and 13 of the Employers’ Duties (Registration and Compliance) Regulations 2010 (“the 2010 Regulations). Neither the Tribunal nor the Respondent has any discretion as to the amounts to be imposed by way of civil penalty. I am satisfied that the amount of the penalties is in accordance with the 2010 Regulations.

48. In the event that this level of penalty causes financial hardship to the Appellant, as the Respondent has pointed out, that is a matter which should be raised directly with the Respondent.

49. I therefore conclude that the Respondent has failed to show a reasonable excuse for its failure to comply with the CN which it received and that the level of penalty accords with that prescribed by the 2010 Regulations. I therefore dismiss the reference and confirm the FPN and EPN. There is no need for any further directions.

Signed Judge Simon Bird KC Date: 16 October 2026


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.