Administrative United Kingdom
Brian Joseph Haw v Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors
NCN: [2026] UKFTT 01469 (GRC)
Case Reference: FT/D//2026/0519
First-tier Tribunal
(General Regulatory Chamber)
Transport
Heard on: 12 October 2026
Decision given on: 27 October 2026
Before
Judge Simon Bird KC
Between:
BRIAN JOSEPH HAW
Appellant
and
Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors
Respondent
DECISION
Representation
For the Appellant: In person
For the Respondent: Mr Andrew Heard
Decision : The appeal is allowed.
REASONS
Introduction
1. This is an appeal against a decision of the Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors (’the Registrar’) made on 18 March 2026 to remove the Appellant’s name from the Register of Approved Driving Instructors (the “Register”). The decision was taken on the grounds that the Appellant had failed to pass the test of continued ability and fitness to give instruction to continue as an Approved Driving Instructor (“ADI”).
2. The proceedings were held by video (CVP). The Tribunal heard submissions from the Appellant and on behalf of the Respondent and had before it a bundle of 41 pages which has been taken into account.
Legal Framework
3. Entry of a person’s name in the Register is subject to the conditions set out in section 125(5) of the Road Traffic Act 1988 (” the Act “). Under section 128 of the Act the Registrar may remove the name of a person from the Register if satisfied that they do not fulfil the relevant conditions. One of those conditions, at section 128(2)(d) , is that they have failed to pass a test of continued ability and fitness to give instruction (often referred to as a “standards check”). Under section 125(5)(a)(i), a person whose name is in the Register must submit to a test of continued ability and fitness to give instruction in the driving of motor cars, if required at any time to do so by the Registrar.
4. The powers of the Tribunal in determining this appeal are set out in section 131 of the Act. The Tribunal may make such order as it thinks fit ( section 131(3) ). The Tribunal stands in the shoes of the Registrar and takes a fresh decision on the evidence available to it, giving appropriate weight to the Registrar’s decision as the person tasked by Parliament with making such decisions (in accordance with R. (Hope and Glory Public House Ltd) v City of Westminster Magistrates Court & Ors [2011] EWCA Civ 31 ).
Appeal to the Tribunal
5. The Appellant’s grounds of appeal are, in summary:
(i) In the period leading up to his most recent standards check on 7 January 2026, he experienced a series of significant personal and medical difficulties which adversely affected his concentration and performance;
(ii) He accepts that he did not inform the DVSA of the full extent of these matters before the standards check and acknowledges that he should have been more open, but says that embarrassment and pride prevented him from discussing his difficulties at the time;
(iii) While accepting that he failed the January 2026 standards check, he argues that the combination of bereavement, stress, illness and family difficulties meant that his performance on that occasion was unrepresentative of his normal instructional standards. He attributes the failure to the exceptional pressure he was experiencing at the time; and
(iv) He seeks a further opportunity to undertake a standards check as one last chance to prove himself.
6. In response to the Appellant’s appeal the Registrar argues:
(i) The decision to remove the Appellant from the Register was justified under sections 125 and 128 of the Road Traffic Act 1988, because the Appellant failed the statutory test of continued ability and fitness to give instruction on three occasions: 5 March 2020, 19 July 2023 and 7 January 2026. On the first test, not only did the Appellant fail to achieve the overall minimum required score, but he had also failed to achieve the minimum required score within the competence of Risk Management. These failures demonstrate that hecan no longer be satisfied that the Appellant's instructional ability is of a satisfactory standard;
(ii) The Appellant has been afforded ample opportunity to demonstrate competence. Since qualifying in 2014, the Appellant has not passed a standards check, has cancelled 13 booked tests, failed to attend 5 booked tests, and has had 6 tests cancelled by the DVSA. The Registrar maintains that ADIs cannot be given unlimited opportunities to reschedule or avoid assessment and that the Appellant has already been given a reasonable opportunity to demonstrate the required standard;
(iii) The Appellant has produced no evidence of professional development or remedial training to address the deficiencies identified in the failed assessments;
(iv) Whilst acknowledging and expressing sympathy for the Appellant's personal and medical difficulties, these matters were not disclosed before the standards check on 7 January 2026. Instead, the rescheduling request made on 29 December 2025 referred only to a pupil's driving test and a period of absence later in January. Those circumstances do not undermine the decision to remove the Appellant from the Register; and
(v) As the official responsible for maintaining the Register in the interests of road safety and consumer protection, removal was necessary because the Appellant had failed to satisfy the Registrar that his ability to provide paid driving instruction remained of a satisfactory standard.
Submissions
Respondent
7. The Registrar decided to remove the Appellant’s name from the register as he had failed to pass the standards check for the reasons set out in his Statement of Case. Section 125(5)(a)(i) of the Act requires only one test opportunity although it is the Registrar’s normal practice to allow up to three tests to enable the ADI to undertake further professional development in order to pass. The Appellant had failed three tests on 5 March 2020, 19 July 2020 and 7 January 2026. The Registrar had considered the Appellant’s representations and was sympathetic to the Appellant’s personal circumstances, but could not ignore the three failures. The Appellant’s test record showed that there had also been 13 booked tests cancelled and five failures to attend. These were not relied upon as reasons to remove the Appellant’s name from the Register but formed part of the context for the decision demonstrating the reasonable opportunity which the Appellant had been afforded to pass the test.
8. The Appellant had not passed a test since he qualified in April 2014 and there was no reference in his representations to having undertaken any personal development to address the causes of the test failures. He had been provided with a reasonable number of opportunities to pass the standards check, but failed to do so. Confidence in Register would be undermined if the Appellant’s name were allowed to remain on it and, in the interests of road safety, the Registrar’s decision was correct.
9. In answer to the Tribunal’s questions, the Registrar explained that there have been some instances where those ADI’s who have failed three tests have been allowed to remain on the Register, but the circumstances have been exceptional. The Respondent’s representative at the hearing also stated that, whilst he could not speak for the Registrar, it is likely that had the Appellant been frank about the reasons for his request to defer the test fixed for 7 January 2026, it is likely the request would have been granted.
Appellant
10. The Appellant stated that he had been an ADI providing instruction for in excess of 14 years and had good students who had achieved good passes. His first test in 2020 had been shortly after the death of his father in law and it had not gone well. He had been over-confident for his second test and had misjudged it. As for the third, this took place during what he described as his personal annus horribilis during which everything which could go wrong, had gone wrong.
11. He considers that he is a genuinely good instructor and that, if granted one more opportunity he would improve himself and has already lined up extra training with an audit trainer for that purpose. He had not undertaken that training to date, as he did not want to incur the cost of doing so until the result of his appeal was known. After his first failure, he had undertaken 4-5 hours with a trainer, but repeat that after failing his second test.
12. In answer to the Tribunal he said that he had continued to provide training in the Autumn of 2025 and into 2026, but this has not been at full capacity.
13. In response to questions from the Registrar as to why he had not explained to the Registrar the full reasons why he wanted the test fixed for 7 January 2026 to be moved, the Appellant stated that he had been embarrassed and that he was “a typical bloke” in relation to such personal matters. He now realised that one should be frank about such matters and, with hindsight, he would have been truthful about them.
Conclusions
14. There is no material dispute of fact in this case. Whilst the Appellant did not believe that he had failed to attend a number of tests as the Respondent claimed, he accepted that he had no evidence to dispute the Respondent’s evidence
15. The Respondent’s records show that the Appellant has been provided with numerous opportunities to pass the required test and I have some sympathy for the Registrar’s decision that following a third test failure, he could no longer be satisfied that the Appellant’s ability to give driving instruction was of a satisfactory standard. However, in my view, it is highly material that at the date that the Appellant took that third test his personal circumstances were such that he was unable to concentrate properly on it and that, had he been frank about those personal circumstances, the test would have been likely to have been cancelled and a further date offered.
16. The decision in this appeal is a finely balanced one. There is a need to ensure that public confidence in the Register is maintained and requiring ADI’s to pass the test is an essential element part of the statutory scheme to satisfy that objective. The Appellant, despite the numerous opportunities offered, has failed to pass the test meaning that his last demonstration of suitable ability was when his name was first entered on the Register in 2014. Further, the fact that he was compelled to take the test on 7 January 2026 was a result of his absence of frankness as to his personal circumstances at that time. Had he made full disclosure of those circumstances, it is likely that he would have been provided with an opportunity to take the standards check at a time when he was in a better state to undertake it. I also bear in mind that, despite his personal circumstances, the Appellant continued to provide tuition over the relevant period albeit at a reduced level.
17. However, the evidence produced in support of the Appellant’s personal circumstances is both comprehensive and convincing. It is very clear to see why his head would not have been in the right place to undertake the test on 7 January 2026 to the extent that this cannot be said to have been a fair opportunity to take the test. Whilst there was no statutory obligation on the Respondent to provide as many opportunities as he did to the Appellant to pass the test, the fact remains that it was the failure of this third test which triggered the removal of the Appellant’s name from the Register and, by reason of the circumstances affecting the Appellant, this cannot be described as a reasonable or fair opportunity to pass the test.
18. In my view, given the need to protect public confidence in the Register, it should only be in exceptional circumstances that the name of an ADI who has failed to pass a standards check on three occasions should be retained on the Register. I am satisfied on the facts here that such exceptional circumstances have been made out by the Appellant. The combination of circumstances which impaired his ability to take the standards check on 7 January 2026 can fairly be described as exceptional and these coupled with his commitment to undertake training justify allowing his name to remain on the register to allow him one final opportunity to pass the standards check. I should add that I have also taken into account that in his most recent test he passed the Risk Management element of the standards check indicating that pupil safety is an issue which he has addressed. I have also taken into account that greater frankness on the part of the Appellant would likely have led to an effective opportunity to pass the test, but this is counterbalanced by his frankness in explaining why he had not been more honest.
19. Whilst it is not open to me to set a deadline by which the Appellant must re-take the test, I make it clear that I would not expect the Registrar to be tolerant of any further cancellations or failures to attend a final booked test.
20. In all the circumstances, the Tribunal whilst giving appropriate deference to the Registrar’s decision to remove the Appellant’s name from the register concludes that it was wrong in the light of the evidence now available. Accordingly this appeal is allowed.
Signed:
Tribunal Judge Simon Bird
Date:13 October 2026
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).