Miscellaneous Etats-Unis

Aita, M. v. NCB Mgmt. Ser., Aplt.

Official source
                                   [J-16-2026]
                    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
                                MIDDLE DISTRICT

TODD, C.J., DONOHUE, DOUGHERTY, WECHT, MUNDY, BROBSON, McCAFFERY, JJ.


  MARCELO AITA,                                    :   No. 25 MAP 2025
                                                   :
                      Appellee                     :   Appeal from the Order of Superior
                                                   :   Court at Nos. 510 EDA 2022 and
                                                   :   615 EDA 2022, dated September
               v.                                  :   26, 2024, Affirming the order of
                                                   :   the Bucks County Court of
                                                   :   Common Pleas, Civil Division, at
  NCB MANAGEMENT SERVICES, INC.,                   :   No. 2019-00981 dated January
                                                   :   21, 2022
                      Appellant                    :
                                                   :   ARGUED: March 12, 2026


                                        OPINION


 JUSTICE MUNDY                                          DECIDED: October 29, 2026
       We granted allowance of appeal to consider whether Pennsylvania’s Wage

 Payment and Collection Law 1 (WPCL) authorizes an employee to initiate a cause of

 action for liquidated damages after the employer fully pays all owed wages and statutory

 interest. Because we find that it does not, we reverse the order of the Superior Court.

          I. PERTINENT WAGE PAYMENT AND COLLECTION LAW PROVISIONS

       “The Wage Payment and Collection Law provides employees a statutory remedy

 to recover wages and other benefits that are contractually due to them.” Oberneder v.

 Link Comput. Corp., 

696 A.2d 148, 150

 (Pa. 1997) (citing Killian v. McCulloch, 

850

F.Supp. 1239, 1255

 (E.D. Pa. 1994)). We accepted this appeal to determine whether the

 WPCL’s text limits relief to employees who were owed wages at the time they filed suit.

 1 Act of July 14, 19161, P.L. 637, as amended, 43 P.S. §§ 261.1 – 260.45.
The resolution of this issue turns primarily on the interpretation of two consecutive WPCL

provisions, Sections 260.9a and 260.10, which we set forth in full:

                        § 260.9a. Civil remedies and penalties

             (a) Any employe or group of employes, labor organization or
             party to whom any type of wages is payable may institute
             actions provided under this act.

             (b) Actions by an employe, labor organization, or party to
             whom any type of wages is payable to recover unpaid wages
             and liquidated damages may be maintained in any court of
             competent jurisdiction, by such labor organization, party to
             whom any type of wages is payable or any one or more
             employes for and in behalf of himself or themselves and other
             employes similarly situated, or such employe or employes
             may designate an agent or representative to maintain such
             action or on behalf of all employes similarly situated. Any
             such employe, labor organization, party, or his representative
             shall have the power to settle or adjust his claim for unpaid
             wages.

             (c) The employe or group of employes, labor organization or
             party to whom any type of wages is payable may, in the
             alternative, inform the secretary of the wage claim against an
             employer or former employer, and the secretary shall, unless
             the claim appears to be frivolous, immediately notify the
             employer or former employer of such claim by certified mail.
             If the employer or former employer fails to pay the claim or
             make satisfactory explanation to the secretary of his failure to
             do so within ten days after receipt of such certified notification,
             thereafter, the employer or former employer shall be liable for
             a penalty of ten percent (10%) of that portion of the claim
             found to be justly due. A good faith dispute or contest as to
             the amount of wages due or the good faith assertion of a right
             of set-off or counter-claim shall be deemed a satisfactory
             explanation for nonpayment of such amount in dispute or
             claimed as a set-off or counter-claim. The secretary shall
             have a cause of action against the employer or former
             employer for recovery of such penalty and the same may be
             included in any subsequent action by the secretary on said



                                      [J-16-2026] - 2
             wage claim or may be exercised separately after adjustment
             of such wage claim without court action.

             (d) In any civil action brought under the provisions of this act,
             the Secretary of Labor and Industry may require the employer
             to post bond or security to secure payment of the entire claim
             of the employe with credit in the amount of any good faith
             assertion of a right of set-off or counter-claim. Such bond or
             security shall be posted in the court where the civil action is
             brought. The request for bond or security shall be signed by
             the secretary and shall provide that such bond or security in
             the amount stated shall be posted within 30 days of service
             thereof on the employer. If such bond or security is not posted
             within the 30-day period, the employer will be deemed to have
             admitted his liability and execution may immediately ensue.

             (e) If the secretary determines that wages due have not been
             paid and that such unpaid wages constitute an enforceable
             claim, the secretary shall, upon the request of the employe,
             labor organization or party to whom any type of wages is
             payable, take an assignment in trust, from the requesting
             party of such claim for wages without being bound by any of
             the technical rules respecting the validity of any such
             assignments and may bring any legal action necessary to
             collect such claim, subject to the right by the employer to set-
             off or counter-claim against the assigning party. Upon any
             such assignment, the secretary shall have the power to settle
             and adjust any such claim to the same extent as might the
             assigning party.

             (f) The court in any action brought under this section shall, in
             addition to any judgment awarded to the plaintiff or plaintiffs,
             allow costs for reasonable attorneys' fees of any nature to be
             paid by the defendant.

             (g) No administrative proceedings or legal action shall be
             instituted under the provisions of this act for the collection of
             unpaid wages or liquidated damages more than three years
             after the day on which such wages were due and payable as
             provided in sections 3 and 5[, 43 P.S. §§ 260.3 and 260.5].
43 P.S. § 260.9a.




                                     [J-16-2026] - 3
                               § 260.10. Liquidated damages

                Where wages remain unpaid for thirty days beyond the
                regularly scheduled payday, or, in the case where no regularly
                scheduled payday is applicable, for sixty days beyond the
                filing by the employe of a proper claim or for sixty days beyond
                the date of the agreement, award or other act making wages
                payable, or where shortages in the wage payments made
                exceed five percent (5%) of the gross wages payable on any
                two regularly scheduled paydays in the same calendar
                quarter, and no good faith contest or dispute of any wage
                claim including the good faith assertion of a right of set-off or
                counter-claim exists accounting for such non-payment, the
                employe shall be entitled to claim, in addition, as liquidated
                damages an amount equal to twenty-five percent (25%) of the
                total amount of wages due, or five hundred dollars ($500),
                whichever is greater.
43 P.S. § 260.10. 2

       With these provisions in mind, we turn to the straightforward and undisputed facts

of this case.

                         II. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

       NCB employed Aita as its Chief Executive Officer (CEO) from June 9, 2008 until

Aita resigned on July 18, 2017. Compl., 2/13/19, at 1 ¶ 3 (R.R. at 6a). On December 29,

2014, Aita and NCB entered into a Private Sale Bonus Agreement (Bonus Agreement).

Id. at 2 ¶ 5 (R.R. at 7a). Per the terms of the Bonus Agreement, NCB agreed to pay Aita

$1,080,000.00 in 18 monthly retention bonus installments of $60,000.00 per month

beginning in January 2015, contingent on Aita remaining with NCB in the month prior to

each bonus installment. Id. at 2 ¶ 6 (R.R. at 7a). Aita qualified for all 18 bonus payments.

From January 2015 to July 2015, NCB timely paid the first six installments, but it failed to


2 To maintain consistency with the Superior Court’s opinion and for ease of discussion

and reference, we will refer to the sections of the WPCL by their Purdon’s Pennsylvania
Statutes’ citations.


                                        [J-16-2026] - 4
timely remit the remaining installments due to cash flow issues. Id. at 2 ¶ 7-8 (R.R. at

7a). Nonetheless, in July 2017, NCB paid Aita in a lump sum of $660,000.00 for all but

one of the remaining unpaid installments plus 6% interest, which is the legal rate of

interest set forth in 41 P.S. § 202. Id. at 2 ¶ 9 (R.R. at 7a). Then, in October 2017, NCB

paid Aita the final bonus installment of $60,000.00 plus 6% interest. Id. at 2 ¶ 10 (R.R. at

7a).

       In February 2019, Aita filed a complaint against NCB for breach of contract and a

violation of the WPCL, seeking compensatory damages, liquidated damages, and

attorneys’ fees. Aita’s WPCL claim alleged that “NCB has now paid the unpaid bonus,

and interest due thereon, but remains liable for liquidated damages due under the WPCL

and attorneys’ fees incurred by [Aita].” Id. at 3 ¶ 18 (R.R. at 8a). NCB filed preliminary

objections, which the trial court sustained as to the breach of contract claim and overruled

as to the WPCL claim. Thereafter, NCB filed a motion for summary judgment, asserting

Aita could not recover under the WPCL because NCB ultimately made all payments due

under the Bonus Agreement before Aita filed suit, and, thus, Aita no longer had “payable”

wages at the time he filed suit. Aita also filed a cross-motion for summary judgment,

seeking $180,000.00 in liquidated damages under the WPCL, which was 25% of the

$720,000.00 in untimely bonus payments NCB had remitted to Aita in July 2017 and

October 2017.

       On January 21, 2022, the trial court denied NCB’s motion for summary judgment

and granted Aita’s cross-motion. The trial court awarded Aita liquidated damages of

$60,000.00, which represented 25% of the $240,000.00 total bonus payments for March

2016 through June 2016. Tr. Ct. Order, 1/21/22, at 1. The trial court explained that Aita

could not recover liquidated damages for the remaining late bonus payments due to the




                                      [J-16-2026] - 5
WPCL’s three-year statute of limitations in 43 P.S. § 260.9a(g). NCB timely filed a notice

of appeal to the Superior Court, and Aita filed a cross-appeal.

       In a 5-4 published opinion, an en banc majority of the Superior Court affirmed the

trial court. Aita v. NCB Mgmt. Servs., Inc., 

324 A.3d 611

, 623 (Pa. Super. 2024) (en

banc). Addressing NCB’s argument that the WPCL’s text unambiguously limits a cause

of action to aggrieved parties who are owed wages and does not provide a means for

parties to recover liquidated damages absent a claim of wage loss, the Superior Court

initially recounted that the legislative purpose of the WPCL was “to provide an employee

with a statutory remedy for an employer’s breach of its contractual obligation to remit

wages.” Id. at 616 (quoting Laborers Combined Funds of W. Pa. v. Mattei, 

518 A.2d

1296, 1298

 (Pa. Super. 1986)) (emphasis omitted). The court explained that the WPCL

fulfills this purpose by “provid[ing] a statutory remedy to ensure that employees are paid

on their regular payday and, if not timely paid, make them whole by penalizing employers

who fail to pay regular wages without good cause.” 

Id.

 Accordingly, the court viewed the

WPCL’s civil provisions as remedial and stated they must be liberally construed to

effectuate their legislative purpose and to “promote justice.” 

Id.

 at 617 (quoting 1 Pa.C.S.

§ 1928(c)).

       The Superior Court then identified five WPCL provisions that reinforced the law’s

purpose. First, the court noted that Section 260.3(a) requires employers to pay all wages

on an employee’s regular payday. 3 Id. Second, the court observed that Section 260.10

3 Section 260.3(a) provides:


            (a) Wages other than fringe benefits and wage supplements.
            Every employer shall pay all wages, other than fringe benefits
            and wage supplements, due to his employes on regular
            paydays designated in advance by the employer. Overtime
            wages may be considered as wages earned and payable in
            the next succeeding pay period. All wages, other than fringe
            benefits and wage supplements, earned in any pay period
(continued…)

                                      [J-16-2026] - 6
provides for liquidated damages when an employer fails to timely pay wages, which is

intended to discourage and penalize an employer’s bad faith withholding of wages. Id.

The court opined that the liquidated damages provision “applies regardless of whether

the employer ultimately pays the wages owed to the employee, because the liquidated

damages are statutorily imposed once wages remain unpaid for thirty days beyond the

scheduled payday, and no good faith dispute exists over the claim.” Id. Third, the court

pointed out that Section 260.11a provides for the imposition of a criminal penalty on an

employer that fails to timely pay an employee. 4 Id. at 618. Fourth, the court noted that


              shall be due and payable within the number of days after the
              expiration of said pay period as provided in a written contract
              of employment or, if not so specified, within the standard time
              lapse customary in the trade or within 15 days from the end of
              such pay period. The wages shall be paid in lawful money of
              the United States or check, except that deductions provided
              by law, or as authorized by regulation of the Department of
              Labor and Industry for the convenience of the employe, may
              be made including deductions of contributions to employe
              benefit plans which are subject to the Employee Retirement
              Income Security Act of 1974, 

29 U.S.C. § 1001

 et seq.
43 P.S. § 260.3(a).
4 Section 260.11a, titled “criminal penalties,” provides:


              (a) The secretary or any employe, group of employes, labor
              organization or party to whom any type of wages is payable
              may institute prosecutions under this act.
            (b) In addition to any other penalty or punishment otherwise
            prescribed by law, any employer who violates any provisions
            of this act shall be guilty of a summary offense and, upon
            conviction thereof, shall be punished by a fine of not more
            than three hundred dollars ($300), or by imprisonment up to
            90 days, or by both, for each offense. The good faith contest
            or dispute by any employer of any wage claim or the good
            faith assertion of a right of set-off or counter-claim shall not be
            considered a violation of this act: Provided, That the employer
            has paid all wages due in excess of the amount in dispute or
            asserted to be subject to a right of set-off or counter-claim.
(continued…)

                                      [J-16-2026] - 7
Section 260.9a(f) mandates the award of reasonable attorneys’ fees to prevailing

employees. Id. Fifth, the court observed that Section 260.9a(a) specifies WPCL actions

may be commenced by “[a]n employe[e] or group of employe[e]s, labor organization or

party to whom any type of wages is payable[.]” Id. (quoting 43 P.S. § 260.9a(a)) (brackets

in original). The Superior Court then summarized these provisions:

             the WPCL requires that an employer pay wages on an
             employee’s regular payday, subjects an employer who fails to
             pay on that date to criminal penalties, and if not paid within
             the grace period provided by statute absent a good-faith
             defense, imposes liquidated damages against the employer
             as well as reasonable attorneys’ fees expended in pursuing
             the claim.
Id.

      The Superior Court agreed with the trial court’s rationale for denying NCB’s motion

for summary judgment, which was that Aita had a claim for unpaid wages after the

expiration of the WPCL’s grace period. Id. at 619. The court highlighted that Section

260.9a(a) provides an employee “to whom any type of wages is payable may institute” a

WPCL action. Id. (quoting 43 P.S. § 260.9a(a)). The court defined “payable” as “when a

monetary obligation becomes due or is required to be paid.” Id. (noting the WPCL does

not define “payable” and relying on the definition in Black’s Law Dictionary). Using this

definition of payable, the Superior Court interpreted Section 260.9a(a)’s phrase “to whom


             Nonpayment of wages to, on account of, or for the benefit of
             each individual employe shall constitute a separate offense.
             (c) Where such employer is a corporation, the president,
             secretary, treasurer or officers exercising corresponding
             functions shall each be guilty of such summary offense.
             (d) All fines or penalties collected under this act shall be paid
             into the State Treasury through the Department of Revenue
             to the credit of the General Fund.
43 P.S. § 260.11a.


                                     [J-16-2026] - 8
any type of wages is payable” as meaning “that an employee is payable on his or her

regular payday, i.e., once the grace period has expired, and an action can be maintained

for liquidated damages thereafter.”    Id.   In the court’s view, this interpretation was

consistent with the legislature’s intent to set a deadline for an employer to pay wages and

to penalize employers for untimely payments. Id. Accordingly, the court concluded “the

WPCL provides for liquidated damages even if the wages are paid outside the grace

period to further the statutory objective of ensuring that employees are paid on their

regular payday.” Id.

       Continuing on, the Superior Court rejected NCB’s argument that an employee does

not have a WPCL claim for liquidated damages when the employer pays the wages owed

at any time before the employee files suit.      Id.    The court reasoned that such an

interpretation of the WPCL would render the statutory grace period “a mere suggestion

rather than a fixed date by which liquidated damages can be imposed.” Id. Moreover,

the court characterized NCB’s position as an amendment of the grace period by extending

the length of the grace period to the instant before an employee files suit. Id. The court

found such an interpretation contravened the WPCL’s purpose of protecting employees

because “an employer could drag its feet for months and escape liability for liquidated

damages by finally paying the employee’s due and payable wages just before the

employee files suit.” Id.

       Additionally, the court concluded that Section 260.9a(g) permits a claim for

liquidated damages independent of a claim for unpaid wages. Id. 619-20. That section

provides “[n]o administrative proceedings or legal action shall be instituted under the

provisions of this act for the collection of unpaid wages or liquidated damages more than

three years after the day on which such wages were due and payable as provided in [43

P.S. §§ 260.3 and 260.5].” 43 P.S. § 260.9a(g). Focusing on the word “or” in the phrase




                                      [J-16-2026] - 9
“unpaid wages or liquidated damages,” the Superior Court interpreted “or” as having its

“ordinary disjunctive meaning, indicating that an employee may bring a claim for

liquidated damages without seeking unpaid wages.” Aita, 324 A.3d at 620. In support,

the Superior Court cited two federal district court decisions that permitted standalone

claims for liquidated damages to proceed to trial, Bair v. Purcell, No. 1:04-CV-1357, 

2010

WL 3282653

 (M.D.Pa. Aug. 17, 2010) (memorandum), and to survive a motion to dismiss,

Endo Pharmaceuticals Inc. v. Fryer, No. 17-2245, 

2020 WL 4748296

 (E.D. Pa. Aug. 17,

2020) (memorandum). Accordingly, the Superior Court held “an employee can bring an

action for liquidated damages under the WPCL regardless of whether the employer has

paid all outstanding wages by the time the legal action is commenced.” Aita, 324 A.3d at

620.

       Judge Bowes filed a dissenting opinion, 5 in which she concluded the plain

language of the WPCL dictated that “a plaintiff must be due wages at the time of filing a

suit pursuant to the WPCL in order to sustain an action seeking either unpaid wages or

unpaid wages plus liquidated damages.” Aita, 324 A.3d at 623 (Bowes, J., dissenting).

The dissent’s analysis initially focused on the WPCL’s plain language, observing the plain

language is the best indication of legislative intent, as opposed to the majority’s approach

of beginning with the WPCL’s purpose and then construing the statutory text “through that

lens.” Id. at 625 n.2 (quoting the Third Circuit’s statement in Barnhart v. Compugraphic

Corp., 

936 F.2d 131

, 134 n.5 (3d Cir. 1991), indicating “[t]his court has also attempted to

review the legislative history of the [WPCL] to further determine the purposes underlying

the law. Unfortunately, there are no substantive remarks included in the history of this

law which would instruct this court.”). Like the majority, the dissent noted that Section

260.9a(a) permits an employee “to whom any type of wages is payable” to file a WPCL


5 Judges Stabile, Dubow, and Sullivan joined Judge Bowes’ dissenting opinion.




                                     [J-16-2026] - 10
action, and the dissent also used the Black’s Law Dictionary definition of “payable” as “[o]f

a sum of money or a negotiable instrument) that is to be paid.” 

Id.

 at 625 (quoting 43 P.S.

260.9a(a) and Black’s Law Dictionary (11th ed. 2019)).

       In the dissent’s view, it was significant that the legislature wrote Section 260.9a in

the present tense (“is payable”), which combined with the rest of the WPCL, led the

dissent to conclude “that actions may be brought only when wages remain unpaid, as

demonstrated by the following pertinent subsections [of Section 260.9a.]” 

Id.

 The dissent

then explained that liquidated damages are the subject of Section 260.10, which provides

that when wages remain unpaid for more than 30 days beyond the regularly scheduled

payday, or more than 60 days beyond when they become payable if no regularly

scheduled payday is applicable, and there is no good faith dispute of the claim, then “the

employee shall be entitled to claim, in addition, as liquidated damages an amount equal

to twenty-five percent (25%) of the total amount of wages due, or five hundred dollars

($500), whichever is greater.” 

Id.

 at 626 (quoting 43 P.S. § 260.10). Addressing the

apparent tension between Section 260.10’s statement that liquidated damages are “in

addition” to a claim for unpaid wages and Section 260.9a(g)’s three-year limitation for

actions seeking “unpaid wages or liquidated damages,” the dissent opined that the

disjunctive “or” in Section 260.9a(g) did not create a liquidated damages cause of action

that is independent from an unpaid wages claim because “the text of § 260.10 clearly

provides that a claim for liquidated damages is to be additive.” Id. at 627 (quoting

Andrews v. Cross Atl. Cap. Partners, Inc., 

158 A.3d 123, 136

 (Pa. Super. 2017), and

Thomas Jefferson Univ. v. Wapner, 

903 A.2d 565, 574

 (Pa. Super. 2006), which

explained liquidated damages are available to prevailing plaintiffs who prove the employer

has no good faith defense to an unpaid wages claim). Accordingly, the dissent found the

combination of Sections 260.9a(g) and 260.10 provided:




                                      [J-16-2026] - 11
              First, no proceedings pursuant to the WPCL shall be instituted
              beyond the statute of limitations period provided. Second,
              there are two potential causes of action. A plaintiff may file
              suit for (1) unpaid wages withheld in good faith, or for (2)
              unpaid wages withheld in the absence of good faith. If a
              plaintiff pursues the second cause of action, he may also seek
              ancillary liquidated damages, in an amount of at least five
              hundred dollars. As such, the WPCL does not support a
              separate cause of action solely for liquidated damgaes.
              Indeed, based upon the text of the statute and this [c]ourt’s
              interpretation thereof, to be entitled to the additional remedy
              of liquidated damages, unpaid wages must first be
              recoverable.

Id. at 628

 (emphasis in original); see also 

id.

 at 628 n.5 (noting its interpretation is

consistent with the Department of Labor and Industry’s view that a plaintiff with unpaid

wages “may take legal action to recover wages due plus liquidated damages” (quoting

Summary       of     the    WPCL,       Department       of     Labor     and     Industry,

https://www.dli.pa.gov/Individuals/Labor-Management-Relations/llc/Documents/llc-2.pdf)

(emphasis in original)). In further support of its interpretation of the WPCL, the dissent

noted that in the nearly 50 years since the WPCL was amended in 1977, there have been

no reported cases in which a plaintiff successfully maintained a WPCL action after the

employer paid all outstanding late wages, which “suggests the WPCL was not intended

to operate in this fashion and need not do so in order to accomplish its goals.” 

Id. at 628

.

       The dissent then addressed three unreported federal court cases that permitted

an independent liquidated damages claim to proceed “without explanation or citation to

Pennsylvania authority” and concluded they were not helpful to the analysis in this case.

First, in Bair, the district court noted “[d]efendants had fully paid the claimed back wages

by the time this case was filed, leaving only the propriety of liquidated damages at issue,”

but it did not analyze the propriety of pursuing a standalone liquidated damages claim

under the WPCL. Bair, 

2010 WL 3282653

, at *7. As such, the dissent found Bair

contained “no pertinent analysis, sound or otherwise, to guide this [c]ourt on the issue



                                     [J-16-2026] - 12
presently before us.” Aita, 324 A.3d at 629 (Bowes, J., dissenting). Second, in Endo

Pharmaceuticals, the district court denied the defendant’s motion to dismiss, which was

based on the defendant’s argument that it fully paid the plaintiff’s accrued paid time off

plus interest, because the district court found the fact that the defendant paid it 19 months

late may still entitle the plaintiff to liquidated damages. Endo, 

2020 WL 4748296

, at *4.

However, as the district court’s analysis was limited to two conclusory sentences, the

dissent did not detect “any guidance from the Endo court’s cursory conclusion.” Aita, 324

A.3d at 629 (Bowes, J., dissenting). Third, in Viancourt v. Paragon Wholesale Foods

Corp., No. CV 20-628, 

2023 WL 2726705

 (W.D. Pa. Mar. 31, 2023) (memorandum), the

district court permitted the plaintiff’s amended complaint, which alleged he was owed

salary continuation payments after the defendant had paid his back wages, to survive

summary judgment because the plaintiff was still owed wages and accordingly could

pursue liquidated damages under Section 260.9a. Viancourt, 

2023 WL 2726705

, at *22.

The dissent asserted, “[i]nsofar as Viancourt holds any persuasive value for this [c]ourt,

it aligns with my interpretation that unpaid wages must be recoverable under the WPCL

before a plaintiff may add on a claim to seek liquidated damages.” Aita, 324 A.3d at 629

(Bowes, J., dissenting).

       Addressing the majority’s accusation that its interpretation renders the WPCL

grace period a mere suggestion and would permit an employer to delay paying wages but

escape liability for liquidated damages by paying just before the employee files suit, the

dissent responded “that may only be the case where an employee chooses to sit on his

rights. The WPCL was not written to protect dilatory enforcement, and this [c]ourt cannot

read more into the statute than what is plainly provided for on its face.” Id. at 631.

Accordingly, the dissent concluded the trial court erred in granting Aita’s motion for

summary judgment because it was undisputed that Aita did not have a claim for unpaid




                                      [J-16-2026] - 13
wages at the time he filed suit, so he could not pursue a standalone liquidated damages

claim as a matter of law. Id.

      Separately, Judge Sullivan, who joined Judge Bowes’ dissenting opinion, also filed

a dissenting opinion, 6 expressing her concern that under Judge Bowes’ interpretation, “an

employer could, without good reason make a practice of paying its employees one-to-two

weeks late, with interest, which would make it practically impossible for the employees to

have wages ‘payable’ for a sufficient period to allow them to file suit under the WPCL and,

if unpaid for more than 30 days, seek liquidated damages,” which would have deleterious

consequences for all employees living paycheck to paycheck. Aita, 324 A.3d at 632

(Sullivan, J., dissenting). Despite this concern, Judge Sullivan maintained the court was

bound to follow the WPCL’s plain language and reminded that the legislature “is charged

with the authority to make any changes in the WPCL it deems necessary to protect

employees against the hypothetical employer practice described above.” Id.

                       III. ISSUE AND STANDARD OF REVIEW

      This Court granted NCB’s petition for allowance of appeal on the following issue,

which we rephrased for clarity:

             Whether the text of the Pennsylvania Wage Payment and
             Collection Law (WPCL) plainly limits relief under the WPCL to
             employees who were owed wages at the time they filed suit?
Aita v. NCB Mgmt. Servs., Inc., 

337 A.3d 959

 (Pa. 2025) (per curiam). 7

      As this issue arises in the context of the trial court granting summary judgment in

favor of Aita and against NCB, we note that “[s]ummary judgment may be entered only

when, even after examining the record in the light most favorable to the non-moving party


6 Judge Dubow joined Judge Sullivan’s dissenting opinion.

7 This Court also denied Aita’s petition for allowance of appeal in the same order.   Aita,
337 A.3d at 959.


                                     [J-16-2026] - 14
and resolving of all doubts as to the existence of a genuine issue of material fact against

the moving party, the moving party is clearly entitled to judgment as a matter of law.”

Pyeritz v. Commonwealth, 

32 A.3d 687, 692

 (Pa. 2011). This Court’s “scope of review of

a trial court’s order granting or denying summary judgment is plenary, and our standard

of review is clear: the trial court’s order will be reversed only where it is established that

the court committed an error of law or abused its discretion.” Daley v. A.W. Chesterton,

Inc., 

37 A.3d 1175, 1179

 (Pa. 2012) (quoting Pappas v. Asbel, 

768 A.2d 1089, 1095

 (Pa.

2001)).

    IV. STANDALONE CLAIM FOR LIQUIDATED DAMAGES UNDER THE WPCL

A. PARTIES’ ARGUMENTS

       NCB argues that the plain language of the WPCL clearly provides an employee

must have unpaid wages at the time he or she files suit, and an employee cannot sue for

liquidated damages in the absence of a claim for unpaid wages. NCB emphasizes

Section 260.9a(a) uses the present tense in delineating the parties who may file WPCL

actions, which means only parties who are “presently owed wages” may bring WPCL

claims. NCB’s Br. at 17. Further, NCB notes that Section 260.9a(b) likewise uses the

present tense to define the scope of a WPCL action and “makes clear that only those

employees who are presently owed wages may maintain an action under the WPCL in

the [c]ourt of [c]ommon [p]leas.” 

Id.

 Similarly, NCB highlights Sections 260.9(c) and

260.9(e) permit aggrieved parties to inform the Secretary of Labor and Industry “of the

wage claim against an employer or former employer,” 43 P.S. § 260.9a(c), and the

secretary may pursue legal action on behalf of the employee “if the secretary determines

that wages have not been paid and that such unpaid wages constitute an enforceable

claim.” 43 P.S. § 260.9(e). Id. at 18. According to NCB, the subsections permitting an




                                      [J-16-2026] - 15
employee to resort to the Secretary of Labor and Industry further illustrate that relief is

limited to “employees to whom wages are currently due and owing.” Id.

       In additional support of its position, NCB notes that Section 260.10 provides that

an award of liquidated damages is calculated as 25% of “the total amount of wages due,”

which clarifies that unpaid wages must be recoverable to receive the additional remedy

of liquidated damages. Id. at 19-20. NCB asserts that Section 260.10 “is not intended to

penalize employers who have already rectified payment delays.” Id. at 20. Instead, NCB

reads Section 260.10 as permitting liquidated damages only when an employee has a

claim for unpaid wages, meaning liquidated damages are additive to unpaid wages. Id.

Based on this reading of Section 260.10, NCB maintains that it is not meant to penalize

employers who have rectified payment delays before an employee files suit.                Id.

Additionally, NCB notes liquidated damages are reserved for a subset of plaintiffs who

can show an employer has no good faith defense to failing to timely pay wages, meaning

Section 260.10 penalizes employers who withhold wages in bad faith. Id. at 21.

       NCB contends that the Superior Court erred in expanding the scope of the WPCL

to allow Aita to bring a cause of action for solely liquidated damages. NCB argues the

WPCL’s text does not support the Superior Court’s conclusion, which “is little more than

an aspirational interpretation of the law in an effort to effectuate its understanding of the

WPCL’s remedial purpose.” Id. at 22.         NCB argues “the Superior Court’s decision

elevated the spirit of law over its plain language in contravention of the Statutory

Construction Act.” Id. Here, because it is undisputed that NCB paid Aita’s outstanding

wages before he filed suit, NCB maintains Aita had no unpaid wages when he

commenced his WPCL action and asks us to reverse the Superior Court’s decision based

on the plain language of the WPCL.




                                      [J-16-2026] - 16
       In contrast, Aita argues the plain language of the WPCL does not enable an

employer to avoid liquidated damages by paying overdue wages at any time before an

aggrieved party files suit. Aita reiterates that NCB violated the WPCL by failing to pay

Aita’s bonus installments from August 2015 to July 2016, totaling $720,000.00. Aita’s Br.

at 7 (“There is no dispute that NCB did not pay the bonuses on the dates they were due

pursuant to the terms of the Agreement, and thus violated [43 P.S. §] 260.3(a).”).

Moreover, Aita notes NCB conceded it had no good faith reason to withhold the bonus

installments, and the bonus payments were more than 60 days overdue, which entitles

Aita to liquidated damages under Section 260.10. Id. at 8. Aita argues NCB’s sole

defense, which is that it made its untimely payment before Aita filed suit, relies on a flawed

construction of the WPCL. Id.

       Aita asserts the WPCL’s plain language entitles an employee to liquidated

damages when the violation of the WPCL occurs, regardless of whether it is later rectified.

Id.   Aita reads Section 260.9a(a) as enabling aggrieved parties to institute actions

“provided under this act.” Id. at 11 (quoting 43 P.S. § 260.9a(a)). The actions, in Aita’s

view, are provided in Section 260.3, which requires timely payment of wages, and Section

260.10, which permits a claim for liquidated damages when wages are not paid within 60

days without a good faith basis. Id.

       Aita disagrees with NCB’s argument that the phrase “to whom any type of wages

is payable” in Section 260.9a(a) limits actions to those in which wages remain unpaid on

the date the complaint is filed. Id. at 12. Aita contends the purpose of Section 260.9a(a)

is to identify the plaintiffs who can institute WPCL actions, which are: (1) an employee;

(2) a group of employees; (3) a labor organization; or (4) a “party to whom any type of

wages is payable.” Id. (quoting 43 P.S. § 260.9a(a)). Aita argues the phrase “to whom

any type of wages is payable” modifies only “party,” and it does not apply to the three




                                       [J-16-2026] - 17
other enumerated classes of plaintiffs. Id. In support of this interpretation, Aita raises the

“last antecedent” rule of statutory construction, which presumes a modifier applies only

to the immediately preceding provision or clause. Id. at 12-13 (citing Pa. Dept. of Banking

v. NCAS of Del. LLC, 

948 A.2d 752, 760-61

 (Pa. 2008)). Because “party” is the last

antecedent, Aita maintains the phrase “to whom wages is payable” modifies only the word

“party.” Id. at 13. In Aita’s view, the legislature intended “party to whom wages is payable”

to operate as a catchall provision to include an aggrieved party who is not an employee,

a group of employees, or a labor organization. Id. In further support of this reading, Aita

highlights that the next subsection, 43 P.S. § 260.9a(b), lists the four classes of plaintiffs

identified in Section 260.9a(a) in a different order, with the modifier “to whom wages is

payable” linked to party but not to employee:

              Actions by an employe, labor organization, or party to whom
              any type of wages is payable to recover unpaid wages and
              liquidated damages may be maintained in any court of
              competent jurisdiction, by such labor organization, party to
              whom any type of wages is payable or any one or more
              employes for and in behalf of himself or themselves and
              other employes similarly situated, or such employe or
              employes may designate an agent or representative to
              maintain such action or on behalf of all employes
              similarly situated. Any such employe, labor organization,
              party, or his representative shall have the power to settle or
              adjust his claim for unpaid wages.
Id. at 13-14 (quoting 43 P.S. § 260.9a(b) (emphasis in Aita’s brief)). For these reasons,

Aita concludes the phrase “to whom any type of wages is payable” does not act as a time

limitation on WPCL actions; instead, it simply defines one class of aggrieved parties who

may initiate a WPCL action. Id. at 14.

       Alternatively, Aita posits that if this Court reads “to whom any type of wages is

payable” to modify the word “employe,” then we should define “payable” as “the date upon

which wages must be paid.” Id. at 15. Aita highlights the WPCL uses “payable” in this



                                      [J-16-2026] - 18
manner in four other provisions: (1) 43 P.S. § 260.3(a) provides overtime wages are

“payable” in the next pay period; (2) 43 P.S. § 260.3(a) also states that all other wages

are “payable” as set forth in a written agreement or within 15 days after the close of the

pay period; (3) 43 P.S. § 260.9a(g) specifies that the three-year statute of limitations

begins on the date that wages are “payable;” and (4) 43 P.S. § 260.10 provides a 60-day

grace period to avoid liquidated damages that begins on the date wages were “payable”

under an agreement, award, or other act. Id. Consequently, Aita maintains the WPCL

“renders wages payable on the date they were due, such that, if an employer fails to pay

the wages on the date they are ‘payable,’ there is a violation of the statute, and the

employee can file suit under Section 260.9a(a).” Id. at 16.

      Moreover, Aita argues his interpretation is consistent with Section 260.9a(g), which

he interprets as providing a separate action for liquidated damages independent of a

claim for unpaid wages. Id. Aita argues the only prerequisite to a claim for liquidated

damages is the expiration of the grace period because a violation of the WPCL occurs

when an employer fails to timely pay wages. Id. at 17. Aita maintains liquidated damages

are available in this case because NCB delayed its payment of the bonus installments by

two years, which is the type of untimely payment that the WPCL’s liquidated damages

provision is directed at remedying. Id. In Aita’s view, “[t]he status of whether or not

[earned] wages were eventually paid is not relevant – instead, the violation of the WPCL

occurs when the earned wages are not paid. In such an instance, the employee is entitled

to liquidated damages under Section 260.10.” Id. at 20. 8 Accordingly, Aita asks us to

8 Amicus Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry filed a brief

in which it agrees with the Superior Court and Aita that the plain language of the WPCL
permits liquidated damages when earned wages are not paid in full or on time or within
the statutory grace period. According to Amicus, “Section 9a(a) authorizes an action
when an employer violates the Act, regardless of whether the employer subsequently
makes payment, because the cause of action became ripe when the employer failed to
pay due wages in violation of the statutory requirements.” Amicus Br. at 6.


                                    [J-16-2026] - 19
affirm the Superior Court’s conclusion that he is entitled to pursue liquidated damages

under the WPCL. Id. at 21.

       In its reply brief, NCB first disagrees with Aita’s construction of the phrase “to whom

any type of wages is payable” as modifying only the term “party.” NCB argues that phrase

clearly applies to all four categories of potential plaintiffs listed in 260.9a(a) because

“[w]hen several words are followed by a modifying phrase which is applicable as much to

the first and other words as to the last, the natural construction of the language demands

that the modifying phrase be read as applicable to all.” NCB’s Reply Br. at 3 (quoting

Penn Psychiatric Ctr., Inc. v. U.S. Liability, 

257 A.3d 1241, 1251

 (Pa. Super. 2021)).

Accordingly, NCB contends Aita’s construction relying on the “last antecedent” principle

is misplaced. Second, NCB maintains that defining “payable” as “due and owing” is

consistent with the various sections of the WPCL Aita cited. Id. at 4-5. Third, NCB argues

that Aita’s interpretation of Section 260.9a(g) as enabling a plaintiff to assert an

independent claim for liquidated damages is inconsistent with Section 260.10, which

clearly states that liquidated damages are additive to a claim for wages presently due or

payable. Id. at 5-6. Additionally, NCB reiterates that liquidated damages are available to

only the subset of prevailing plaintiffs whose employers have no good faith basis for

withholding the payment of wages, and they are not available when employers have a

good faith basis. Id. at 6. Fourth, NCB dismisses Aita’s concern that employers could

delay payment and avoid liquidated damages by tendering the payment upon the threat

of litigation by asserting that an employee who is owed wages controls when to initiate

proceedings, and we should not interpret the WPCL to protect dilatory enforcement. Id.

at 8 (citing Aita, 324 A.3d at 631 (Bowes, J., dissenting)).




                                      [J-16-2026] - 20
B. ANALYSIS

       As the issue before this Court is a question of statutory interpretation, our analysis

is guided by the Statutory Construction Act, which directs us to give effect to the

legislature’s intent and all the statute’s provisions. 1 Pa.C.S. § 1921(a). A statute’s plain

language is the best indication of the legislature’s intent. Crown Castle NG E. LLC v. Pa.

Pub. Util. Comm’n, 

234 A.3d 665

, 674 (Pa. 2020). In determining a statute’s plain

meaning, we analyze its operative language in context and interpret words and phrases

according to their common and approved usage. 

Id.

 We must give effect to a clear and

unambiguous statute, and we cannot disregard a statute’s plain meaning to implement its

perceived objectives. 

Id.

 “Only if the statute is ambiguous, and not explicit, do we resort

to other means of discerning legislative intent.” Matter of Private Sale of Prop. by

Millcreek Twp. Sch. Dist., 

185 A.3d 282, 291

 (Pa. 2018); see also 1 Pa.C.S. § 1921(c)

(listing factors to consider when “the words of a statute are not explicit”). Additionally,

“[s]tatutory interpretation is a question of law, as to which our standard of review is de

novo and our scope of review is plenary.” Commonwealth v. Crosby, 

329 A.3d 1141

,

1148-49 (Pa. 2025).

       To determine whether the WPCL provides a cause of action for liquidated

damages alone, we begin with Section 260.9a(a), which provides “[a]ny employe or group

of employes, labor organization or party to whom any type of wages is payable may

institute actions provided under this act.” 43 P.S. § 260.9a(a). This subsection lists the

four categories of aggrieved parties that “may institute actions provided under this act:”

(1) any employee; (2) any group of employees; (3) a labor organization; or (4) a party to

whom any type of wages is payable. Contrary to the Superior Court majority and NCB,

we do not interpret the phrase “to whom any type of wages is payable” to apply to all four

classes of potential plaintiffs; instead, that phrase modifies only “party.” This is confirmed




                                      [J-16-2026] - 21
by Section 260.9a(b), which lists the four categories of aggrieved parties in a different

order with the phrase “to whom any type of wages is payable” linked to “party” and not to

any of the other three classes. Specifically, Section 260.9a(b) provides that WPCL

actions may be maintained “by such labor organization, party to whom any type of wages

is payable or any one or more employes for and in behalf of himself or themselves and

other employes similarly situated . . . .” 43 P.S. § 260.9a(b). Reading this in pari materia,

it is evident that the legislature intended the phrase “to whom any type of wages is

payable” to modify “party,” essentially creating and limiting a catchall class of aggrieved

parties who may institute WPCL actions.

       Further, any suggestion that “to whom any type of wages is payable” modifies

employee, group of employees, or labor organization is dispelled by applying the last

antecedent cannon of statutory construction. The last antecedent rule recognizes that in

a list ending with a limiting clause or phrase, the limiting language ordinarily modifies only

the immediately preceding noun or phrase and “do[es] not extend to or include other

words, phrases, or clauses more remote, unless such extension or inclusion is clearly

required by the intent or meaning of the context or disclosed by an examination of the

entire act.” Commonwealth v. Packer, 

798 A.2d 192, 198

 (Pa. 2002) (quoting John

Hancock Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co. v. Commonwealth, Ins. Dept., 

554 A.2d 618, 622

 (Pa.

Cmwlth. 1989)) (citing 1 Pa.C.S. § 1903). Here, Section 260.9a(a) provides a list of four

categories of potential WPCL plaintiffs with the last category, “party,” qualified by the

phrase “to whom any type of wages is payable.” Pursuant to the last antecedent rule, the

qualifying language modifies only “party” unless extending it to the three preceding

classes is required by the context of Section 260.9a(a) or an examination of the WPCL.

As explained above, the legislature’s reordering of the four categories in Section

260.9a(b) shows that it intended the qualifying language to apply to only “party.”




                                      [J-16-2026] - 22
Moreover, applying the last antecedent rule gives a natural reading to Section 260.9a as

there is no indication “to whom any type of wages is payable” applies to the three more

remote classes, and it does not make sense to apply it to labor organization because

wages cannot be payable to a labor organization. Accordingly, we agree with Aita’s

position that Section 260.9a(a) identifies the four categories of aggrieved parties who may

institute WPCL actions, one of which is any “party to whom any type of wages is payable.”

However, this conclusion ultimately does not resolve the issue before us because Section

260.9a(a) does not define the scope of a WPCL action or specifically indicate whether an

employee can initiate a WPCL action seeking only liquidated damages when the

employee is not owed wages at the time he or she files the WPCL action.

       To resolve that question, we begin by looking to Section 260.9a(b), which states:

“Actions by an employe, labor organization, or party to whom any type of wages is payable

to recover unpaid wages and liquidated damages may be maintained in any court of

competent jurisdiction[.]” 43 P.S. § 260.9a(b). This section, which defines the scope of

WPCL actions, clearly authorizes an action “to recover unpaid wages and liquidated

damages.” Id. Giving “recover” its common meaning of “[t]o get back or regain in full or

in equivalence . . . [t]o obtain (relief) by judgment or other legal process” shows that the

legislature authorized a WPCL action to regain or obtain unpaid wages and liquidated

damages. Recover, BLACK’S LAW DICTIONARY (12th ed. 2024). Moreover, “unpaid” wages

are wages that are “not yet paid” or “outstanding.” Unpaid, COLLINS ENGLISH DICTIONARY

(digital ed. 2012). Consequently, Section 260.9a(b) plainly authorizes an action to get

back, regain, or obtain wages that are not yet paid or outstanding and liquidated damages.

By extension, the WPCL does not authorize an action to recover “untimely paid” wages.

See Commonwealth v. Wright, 

14 A.3d 798, 814

 (Pa. 2011) (“As a matter of statutory




                                     [J-16-2026] - 23
interpretation, although one is admonished to listen attentively to what a statute says; one

must also listen attentively to what it does not say.”) (internal brackets omitted).

       Sections 260.9a(c)-(e), which provide an alternative remedy for aggrieved parties

in the form of enlisting the Secretary of Labor and Industry to pursue the “wage claim”

against an employer or former employer, confirms that WPCL actions must be based on

unpaid wages. 43 P.S. § 260.9a(c). Under Section 260.9a(c), an aggrieved party may

inform the secretary of the wage claim, and the secretary, after determining the claim is

not frivolous, then notifies the employer of the claim. Id. If the employer “fails to pay the

claim or make satisfactory explanation” within 10 days, then the employer is liable for a

penalty of 10% of the claim “justly due.” Id. “The secretary shall have a cause of action

against the employer or former employer for recovery of such penalty and the same may

be included in any subsequent action by the secretary on said wage claim or may be

exercised separately after adjustment of such wage claim without court action.” Id.

Additionally, Section 260.9a(e) permits the secretary to “take an assignment in trust” from

the aggrieved party “[i]f the secretary determines that wages due have not been paid and

that such unpaid wages constitute an enforceable claim,” and the secretary may bring an

action to collect the claim. 43 P.S. § 260.9a(e). These sections reinforce the conclusion

that a WPCL claim must be for wages that the employer has not yet paid at the time the

WPCL action is commenced, whether by a private plaintiff or the Secretary of Labor and

Industry. See 43 P.S. §§ 260.9a(b), (e).

       In addition to Section 260.9a’s unambiguous provision of a cause of action “to

recover unpaid wages and liquidated damages,” Section 260.10 clearly provides that

liquidated damages are an additional remedy available when there is no good faith

dispute of the plaintiff’s wage claim. Section 260.10, as set forth above, provides an

employee is entitled to pursue liquidated damages as follows:




                                      [J-16-2026] - 24
              Where wages remain unpaid for thirty days beyond the
              regularly scheduled payday, or, in the case where no regularly
              scheduled payday is applicable, for sixty days beyond the
              filing by the employe of a proper claim or for sixty days beyond
              the date of the agreement, award or other act making wages
              payable, or where shortages in the wage payments made
              exceed five percent (5%) of the gross wages payable on any
              two regularly scheduled paydays in the same calendar
              quarter, and no good faith contest or dispute of any wage
              claim including the good faith assertion of a right of set-off or
              counter-claim exists accounting for such non-payment, the
              employe shall be entitled to claim, in addition, as liquidated
              damages an amount equal to twenty-five percent (25%) of the
              total amount of wages due, or five hundred dollars ($500),
              whichever is greater.
43 P.S. § 260.10. Under the plain language of Section 260.10, an employee is entitled

to claim liquidated damages when wages remain unpaid beyond set time periods and

there is no good faith dispute of the “wage claim.” Id. Consistent with Section 260.09a(e),

which also uses the term “wage claim,” a “wage claim” is a claim for unpaid wages. See

43 P.S. § 260.09a(e). Section 260.10 continues that when there is no good faith dispute

of the wage claim, the employee can claim “in addition” liquidated damages in the amount

of 25% of the total amount of wages due or $500.00, whichever is greater. 43 P.S.

§ 260.10. This clearly means that liquidated damages are additive to the claim for unpaid

wages and calculated in reference to “the total amount of wages due.” See id. Section

260.10 does not authorize a standalone claim for liquidated damages when the employee

does not have a claim for unpaid wages. Further, the legislature based the formula for

calculating the amount of liquidated damages on the “total amount of wages due,” not the

amount of “untimely paid wages.” See id. Moreover, it is clear from Section 260.09a(c),

which gives the Secretary of Labor and Industry a cause of action for the 10% penalty

imposed on an employer who receives notice of a wage claim from the secretary and fails

to pay the claim or offer a satisfactory explanation within 10 days, that the legislature was




                                      [J-16-2026] - 25
aware of how to create an independent cause of action for a penalty, but the legislature

did not enact a similar provision for liquidated damages. See 43 P.S. § 260.9a(c).

Accordingly, we conclude that the WPCL does not permit an employee to bring a claim

for liquidated damages based on untimely paid wages.

       Additionally, we disagree with the Superior Court’s conclusion that Section

260.9(g)’s use of “or” creates a claim for liquidated damages independent of a claim for

unpaid wages. Section 260.9a(g) is plainly a statute of limitations provision, and it does

not alter the cause of action that the legislature established in Section 260.9a(b). Section

260.9a(g) states “[n]o administrative proceedings or legal action shall be instituted under

the provisions of this act for the collection of unpaid wages or liquidated damages more

than three years after the day on which such wages were due and payable[.]” 43 P.S.

§ 260.9a(g). We cannot read this procedural bar as substantively modifying the scope of

the WPCL action that the legislature authorized in the preceding sections, which is an

action “to recover unpaid wages and liquidated damages.” 43 P.S. § 260.9a(b); see, e.g.,

Westinghouse Elec. Corp./CBS v. W.C.A.B. (Korach), 

883 A.2d 579

, 588 n.11 (Pa. 2005)

(noting a statute of limitations is a procedural bar to a remedy, and it does not extinguish

or alter the cause of action it governs). Additionally, the two unreported memoranda

decisions from federal district courts cited by the Superior Court in support of its

construction of Section 260.9a(g) as permitting an independent claim for liquidated

damages did not discuss or analyze the provisions of Section 260.9a, so we do not find

they are persuasive for our present purposes. See Endo, 

2020 WL 4748296

, at *4

(denying defendant’s motion to dismiss and concluding summarily that the plaintiff "may

still be entitled to liquidated damages” because the defendant did not pay plaintiff her

accrued paid time off for 19 months); Bair, 

2010 WL 3282653

, at *2 (stating, without

discussion, a jury found defendant failed to timely pay plaintiff’s earned wages, and




                                     [J-16-2026] - 26
defendant did not have a good faith dispute of the wage claim, which entitled plaintiff to

liquidated damages); but see Stilp v. Commonwealth, 

905 A.2d 918

, 977 n.44 (Pa. 2006)

(“[O]f course, decisions of the lower Federal courts do not bind this Court, and particularly

where the question is one of state law.”).

       Here, there is no dispute that NCB failed to timely pay Aita 12 of his earned monthly

retention bonuses. There is also no dispute that NCB did eventually pay those bonuses,

plus 6% interest, in July and October 2017, before Aita filed his WPCL claim in February

2019, seeking only liquidated damages and attorneys’ fees. See Compl., 2/13/19 at 3

¶ 18 (“NCB has now paid the unpaid bonus, and interest due thereon, but remains liable

for liquidated damages due under the WPCL and attorneys’ fees incurred by Plaintiff.”).

Therefore, at the time Aita filed his WPCL action, he had no claim for unpaid wages. As

Section 260.9a(b) authorizes actions “to recover unpaid wages and liquidated damages,”

and does not contain any provisions entitling a plaintiff to pursue liquidated damages in

the absence of a claim for unpaid wages, we hold Aita’s standalone claim for liquidated

damages was not permitted as a matter of law.

                                    V. CONCLUSION

       Based on the foregoing, we conclude the Superior Court erred in affirming the trial

court’s denial of NCB’s motion for summary judgment and grant of Aita’s cross-motion for

summary judgment. Accordingly, we reverse the order of the Superior Court.

       Chief Justice Todd and Justices Donohue, Dougherty, Brobson and McCaffery join

the opinion.

       Justice Wecht files a dissenting opinion.




                                      [J-16-2026] - 27

Dissenting opinion

                            [J-16-2026] [MO: Mundy, J.]
                    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
                                 MIDDLE DISTRICT


    MARCELO AITA,                                  :   No. 25 MAP 2025
                                                   :
                      Appellee                     :   Appeal from the Order of Superior
                                                   :   Court at Nos. 510 EDA 2022 and
                                                   :   615 EDA 2022, dated September
               v.                                  :   26, 2024, Affirming the order of
                                                   :   the Bucks County Court of
                                                   :   Common Pleas, Civil Division, at
    NCB MANAGEMENT SERVICES, INC.,                 :   No. 2019-00981 dated January
                                                   :   21, 2022
                      Appellant                    :
                                                   :   ARGUED: March 12, 2026


                                  DISSENTING OPINION


JUSTICE WECHT                                           DECIDED: October 29, 2026

        The Wage Payment and Collection Law (“the WPCL” or “the Law”) requires that

employers promptly pay all wages owed to employees. The Law instructs employers to

“designat[e] in advance” certain “regular paydays,” creating distinct pay periods. 1

Employers are required to pay each employee all wages that the employee earns in a

given pay period “within the number of days after the expiration of said pay period as [is]

provided in [the employee’s] written contract of employment.”2 If no written contract

exists—or if it exists but is silent regarding the duration of the payroll period—then the




1       43 P.S. § 260.3(a).
2       Id.
employer must remit the employee’s wages either “within the standard time lapse [that is]

customary in the trade” or “within 15 days” after the pay period ends. 3

       The WPCL gives employees whose employers violate these prompt-payment rules

a private right of action to recover any unpaid wages. 4 An employee who does not wish

to litigate his or her claim in court “may, in the alternative,” seek administrative resolution

of that wage claim through the Department of Labor and Industry. 5

       Employers that violate the WPCL by failing to pay wages within the required time

frame may be liable for liquidated damages of $500 or “twenty-five percent (25%) of the

total amount of wages due,” whichever is greater. 6 The Law limits the availability of

liquidated damages: “the employe[e] shall be entitled to claim” liquidated damages only

“[w]here wages remain unpaid for thirty days beyond the regularly scheduled payday.”7

If no regularly scheduled payday applies, an employee can claim liquidated damages

when wages remain unpaid for “sixty days beyond the date of the agreement, award[,] or

other act making wages payable.” 8 A claim for liquidated damages will succeed only



3      Id.
4      Id. § 260.9a(a) (“Any employe or group of employes, labor organization or party to
whom any type of wages is payable may institute actions provided under this act.”); id.
§ 260.9a(b) (“Actions by an employe, labor organization, or party to whom any type of
wages is payable to recover unpaid wages and liquidated damages may be maintained
in any court of competent jurisdiction[.]”).
5     Id. § 260.9a(c) (“The employe or group of employes, labor organization or party to
whom any type of wages is payable may, in the alternative, inform the secretary of the
wage claim against an employer or former employer[.]”).
6      Id. § 260.10.
7      Id.
8      Id.


                              [J-16-2026] [MO: Mundy, J.] - 2
when the employer lacks a “good faith contest or dispute” of the wage claim, “including

the good faith assertion of a right of set-off or counter-claim.”9

       As the Majority explains, this appeal concerns whether an employee can pursue a

stand-alone claim for liquidated damages under the WPCL against an employer who

belatedly paid the employee all arrearages prior to the suit being filed. The employee in

this case, Marcelo Aita, was the CEO of debt collection agency NCB Management

Services (“NCB”). In late 2014, NCB promised in writing to pay Aita a retention bonus of

$60,000 per month for seventeen months. NCB initially paid Aita the monthly installments

as agreed, but then stopped paying the bonus in the summer of 2015, thus breaching the

written agreement and violating the WPCL. In 2017, NCB paid Aita all of the past-due

bonus installments (plus interest).     Nevertheless, Aita sued NCB under the WPCL,

seeking liquidated damages for NCB’s statutory violations.

       NCB unsuccessfully argued in the lower courts that an employee cannot sue his

employer under the WPCL unless he is still owed outstanding wages when he files the

lawsuit. NCB’s argument that the WPCL does not permit stand-alone claims for liquidated

damages in the absence of a claim for unpaid wages is based upon Subsection 260.9a(a)

of the Law. That provision states that “[a]ny employe[e] or group of employe[e]s, labor

organization or party to whom any type of wages is payable may institute actions provided

under this act.”10 NCB believes that the phrase “to whom any type of wages is payable”

modifies each of the categories that precede it. The company therefore concludes that




9      Id.
10     Id. § 260.9a(a).


                              [J-16-2026] [MO: Mundy, J.] - 3
Subsection 260.9a(a) makes “a claim for unpaid wages [a] prerequisite for filing a claim

under WPCL.” 11

      As the Majority explains, NCB’s interpretation of Subsection 260.9a(a) is incorrect.

Applying the last antecedent rule, the phrase “to whom any type of wages is payable”

should be read to modify only “party” (the final listed category) and not “employe[e],”

“group of employe[e]s,” or “labor organization.” Subsection 260.9a(a) therefore gives

employees like Aita the right to sue under the WPCL without qualification. As the Majority

also notes, NCB’s proposed interpretation makes no sense, because “wages” would

never be “payable” to a labor organization. Any lingering doubts about whether the last

antecedent rule should apply are alleviated by Subsection 260.9a(b), in which the General

Assembly listed the same categories of permissible plaintiffs in a different order, and a

“party to whom any type of wages is payable” no longer appears at the end of the list. 12

      Despite correctly rejecting NCB’s flawed interpretation of Subsection 260.9a(b),

the Majority nevertheless agrees with the company that workers whose employers pay

wages delinquently (in violation of the WPCL) cannot pursue stand-alone claims for

liquidated damages whenever the employer has repaid all delinquent wages prior to the

filing of suit. The Majority bases this conclusion principally upon Subsection 260.9a(b).

But Subsection 260.9a(b) does not say what the Majority claims. Subsection 260.9a(b)

merely instructs that “[a]ctions by an employe[e] . . . to recover unpaid wages and




11    Brief for NCB at 17.
12     43 P.S. § 260.9a(b) (referring to actions “by such labor organization, party to whom
any type of wages is payable[,] or any one or more employes for and in behalf of himself
or themselves and other employes similarly situated” (emphasis added)).


                             [J-16-2026] [MO: Mundy, J.] - 4
liquidated damages may be maintained in any court of competent jurisdiction[.]” 13 From

this unremarkable text, the Majority intuits that employees whose employers violate the

WPCL have no claim for statutory damages unless their wages remain unpaid up until

the filing of the lawsuit. 14

        The Majority’s analysis of Subsection 260.9a(b) is spare. The Majority states only

that:

        [Subsection 260.9a(b)], which defines the scope of WPCL actions, clearly
        authorizes an action “to recover unpaid wages and liquidated damages.”
        Giving “recover” its common meaning of “[t]o get back or regain in full or in
        equivalence . . . [t]o obtain (relief) by judgment or other legal process” shows
        that the legislature authorized a WPCL action to regain or obtain unpaid
        wages and liquidated damages. Recover, BLACK’S LAW DICTIONARY (12th
        ed. 2024). Moreover, “unpaid” wages are wages that are “not yet paid” or
        “outstanding.” Unpaid, COLLINS ENGLISH DICTIONARY (digital ed. 2012).
        Consequently, Section 260.9a(b) plainly authorizes an action to get back,
        regain, or obtain wages that are not yet paid or outstanding and liquidated
        damages. By extension, the WPCL does not authorize an action to recover
        “untimely paid” wages. 15

        I struggle to grasp the Majority’s point. After defining the words “recover” and

“unpaid”—terms which are not materially in dispute here—the Majority suggests that

workers cannot file stand-alone claims for liquidated damages because the WPCL “does

not authorize an action to recover ‘untimely paid’ wages.” 16 But that’s an obvious non

sequitur. Aita is not pursuing a claim for “untimely paid” wages. His claim is one for




13      Id. § 260.9a(b).
14    Majority Opinion at 24 (stating that “a WPCL claim must be for wages that the
employer has not yet paid at the time the WPCL action is commenced”).
15      Id. at 23 (citation to the WPCL omitted).
16      Id.


                                [J-16-2026] [MO: Mundy, J.] - 5
liquidated damages under the WPCL, which the Majority properly understands and

correctly articulates in other sections of today’s decision. 17

       In other words, Aita’s claim is for liquidated damages, and Subsection 260.9a(b)

authorizes actions to obtain liquidated damages. The Majority has failed to supply a

coherent rationale for interpreting Subsection 260.9a(b) in a manner that forecloses

stand-alone liquidated damages claims.

       I suppose there is an argument to be made that the word “and” in Subsection

260.9a(b) should be given its usual conjunctive meaning. In such a case, the provision

would only permit actions seeking to obtain both unpaid wages and liquidated damages.

The Majority does not embrace that theory in today’s decision. Accepting it would prevent

stand-alone claims for unpaid wages too. I do not think anyone believes the General

Assembly intended that. 18 Moreover, any argument that Subsection 260.9a(b) authorizes

only actions for both unpaid wages and liquidated damages would run headfirst into

Subsection 260.9a(e). There, the legislature created a three-year statute of limitations

for the cause of action described in Subsection 260.9a(b). That limitations provision

describes the action as one “for the collection of unpaid wages or liquidated damages.” 19



17      Id. at 25 (“Section 260.10 does not authorize a standalone claim for liquidated
damages when the employee does not have a claim for unpaid wages.”); id. at 27 (“[W]e
hold Aita’s standalone claim for liquidated damages was not permitted as a matter of
law.”).
18     See Brief for NCB at 21 (“It must also be emphasized that the statute’s liquidated
damages provision is available only to a subset of plaintiffs in cases where an employer
has no good faith defense to withholding the payment of wages for a set amount of time
under the statute.”).
19     43 P.S. § 260.9a(g) (emphasis added) (“No administrative proceedings or legal
action shall be instituted under the provisions of this act for the collection of unpaid wages
(continued…)

                              [J-16-2026] [MO: Mundy, J.] - 6
       The Majority attempts to bootstrap its misinterpretation of Subsection 260.9a(b) by

referencing adjacent WPCL provisions. The Majority’s arguments in this regard are

unpersuasive.    The Majority cites Subsections 260.9a(c) and (e), which detail the

alternative administrative review procedures available to employees.           Subsection

260.9a(c), for example, states that employees “may, in the alternative, inform the

secretary of the wage claim against an employer or former employer.” 20 Citing this

language—and citing similar references to “unpaid wages” in Subsection 260.9a(e)—the

Majority somehow concludes that these provisions elaborating on distinct administrative

remedies somehow “confir[m] that WPCL actions must be based on unpaid wages.” 21

They do not. These provisions in no way speak to the scope of the (judicial) cause of

action afforded to employees under Subsection 260.9a(b). Whether outstanding unpaid

wages are required for an employee to seek administrative relief is neither here nor there.

       Put simply, today’s decision hollows out the WPCL’s primary mechanism for

ensuring that employers pay their workers on time. It does so based on a strained

interpretation of Subsection 260.9a(b) that, despite the Majority’s best efforts, finds no

support in the WPCL’s statutory text. I respectfully dissent.




or liquidated damages more than three years after the day on which such wages were
due and payable as provided in sections 3 and 5.”).
20     Id. § 260.9a(c).
21      Majority Opinion at 24 (emphasis added) (“Sections 260.9a(c)-(e), which provide
an alternative remedy for aggrieved parties in the form of enlisting the Secretary of Labor
and Industry to pursue the ‘wage claim’ against an employer or former employer, confirms
[sic] that WPCL actions must be based on unpaid wages.”).


                             [J-16-2026] [MO: Mundy, J.] - 7

If you are facing a similar issue in France, you may contact our employment lawyer in Paris.


Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.