Miscellaneous Etats-Unis
Di Fiore v. Lyndhurst
[Cite as Di Fiore v. Lyndhurst,
2026-Ohio-4290
.]
COURT OF APPEALS OF OHIO
EIGHTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
COUNTY OF CUYAHOGA
GOFFREDO J. DI FIORE, :
Requester-Appellant, :
No. 116623
v. :
CITY OF LYNDHURST, :
Respondent-Appellee. :
JOURNAL ENTRY AND OPINION
JUDGMENT: DISMISSED
RELEASED AND JOURNALIZED: October 29, 2026
Administrative Appeal from the Court of Claims of Ohio
Case No. 2026-00145PQ
Appearances:
Goffredo J. Di Fiore, pro se.
Henderson, Schmidlin & McGarry Co., LPA and Raymond
J. Schmidlin, Jr.; and John P. Luskin, for appellee.
EILEEN A. GALLAGHER, J.:
Appellant Goffredo J. Di Fiore (“Di Fiore”) appeals the Court of
Claims’ judgment entry dismissing his public-records request complaint against the
City of Lyndhurst (“Lyndhurst” or “the city”) without prejudice. For the reasons that
follow, we dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction.
Facts and Procedural History
On November 26, 2025, Di Fiore emailed a public-records request to
Lyndhurst’s assistant law director regarding records concerning a “notice to stop
work” order for the property known as Georgetown of Lyndhurst. On December 4,
2025, the assistant law director responded to the request informing Di Fiore that
Lyndhurst had no responsive documents besides the attached stop work order. On
December 5, 2025, Di Fiore made another public records request concerning the
property requesting additional items not contained in his original request. The
assistant law director responded to this request the same day and attached
additional documents not originally requested.
On December 8, 2025, Di Fiore made a third public records request
concerning the property requesting more items not originally requested. On
December 9, 2025, the assistant law director responded to Di Fiore stating
Lyndhurst had no further responsive documents. On December 9, 2025, Di Fiore
sent a fourth request asking for clarification and more information regarding the
city’s last response. The assistant law director clarified that the city did not have any
responsive documents other than those already produced to Di Fiore.
On January 2, 2026, Di Fiore hand delivered a prefiling complaint to
Lyndhurst giving the city three days to cure the failure alleged in his complaint
pursuant to R.C. 149.43(C)(1).
On February 19, 2026, Di Fiore filed a public record request
complaint in the Court of Claims against Lyndhurst and the assistant law director.
Di Fiore alleged that Lyndhurst violated R.C. 149.43(B) by denying him access to
public records.
On April 17, 2026, Lyndhurst filed a motion to dismiss Di Fiore’s
complaint pursuant to R.C. 149.43(C)(2) alleging, relevant to this appeal, that
Di Fiore failed to comply with the service requirements of R.C. 149.43(C)(1).
On May 12, 2026, a special master issued a report and
recommendation (“R&R”) where the special master recommended granting
Lyndhurst’s motion to dismiss pursuant to R.C. 149.43(C)(2) because Di Fiore failed
to comply with the statute’s service requirements for the preliminary complaint
because hand delivery was not permitted by R.C. 149.43(C)(1). On May 22, 2026,
Di Fiore filed six objections to the R&R. On June 1, 2026, the trial court overruled
Di Fiore’s objections, adopted the special master’s R&R and dismissed Di Fiore’s
complaint without prejudice.
Di Fiore now appeals, raising the following five assignments of error
for our review:
Assignment of Error No. 1
The trial court erred in importing Civ.R. 4 into R.C. 149.43(C)(1) to
mandate strict, clerk driven service for a pre-suit administrative notice,
violating R.C. 2743.03(D) and creating an operational impossibility.
(June 1, 2026 Decision and Entry, at 6-9.)
Assignment of Error No. 2
The trial court erred as a matter of law in construing the permissive
verb “may” in R.C. 149.43(C)(1) as mandatory. (Decision and Entry at
6.)
Assignment of Error No. 3
The trial court erred in failing to recognize that hand delivery with
acknowledged receipt satisfies R.C. 149.43(C)(2)’s “properly
transmitted” functional standard. (Decision and Entry at 6-9.)
Assignment of Error No. 4
The trial court erred in expanding R.C. 149.43(C)(2)’s dismissal trigger
beyond its express terms. (Decision and Entry at 9.)
Assignment of Error No. 5
The trial court erred in rejecting waiver under Akron-Canton Regional
Airport Auth. V. Swinehart and Civ.R. 12(H)(1). (Decision and Entry at
9.)
Law and Analysis
The city alleges in its brief that this court does not have jurisdiction to
hear this appeal because the Court of Claims’ journal entry dismissed Di Fiore’s
complaint without prejudice and, as such, it is not a final appealable order. Before
reviewing the merits of Di Fiore’s assignments of error “we must first determine
whether we have jurisdiction to do so.” G&E HC Reit II Parkway Med. Ctr., L.L.C.
v. Drs. Ford & Soud, Inc.,
(8th Dist.).
“An appellate court has jurisdiction to review, affirm, modify, set
aside, or reverse judgments or final orders.” Id.; Ohio Const., art. IV, § 3(B)(2); R.C.
2505.03. “If an order is not final and appealable, then an appellate court has no
jurisdiction to review the matter and it must be dismissed.” Id.
‘“Ordinarily a dismissal of a complaint “without prejudice” is not a
final, appealable order because it is not an adjudication on the merits and does not
prevent the party from refiling.”’ Grace v. Racino,
(8th Dist.), quoting Martin v. Ohio Univ.,
2023-Ohio-2511
, ¶ 20 (4th Dist.), citing State ex rel. DeDonno v. Mason,
; see also Glavic v. Weltman, 2024-Ohio- 6029, ¶ 10 (8th Dist.) (‘“[A] trial court’s dismissal of a matter without prejudice is not a final, appealable order.’”), quoting Lakeview Holding (OH), L.L.C. v. Farmer,
(8th Dist.), citing Natl. City Commercial Capital Corp. v. AAAA at Your Serv., Inc.,
2007-Ohio-2942
.
Here, the Court of Claims dismissed Di Fiore’s complaint “without
prejudice” because he failed to comply with the procedural requirement of R.C.
149.43(C)(1) and did not serve the prefiling complaint as mandated by the statute.
The Court of Claims’ judgment dismissing his complaint “without prejudice” did not
adjudicate or rule on any of the allegations raised in Di Fiore’s complaint against
Lyndhurst. Furthermore, nothing, besides alleged inconvenience, prevents Di Fiore
from refiling his complaint after serving the prefiling complaint in compliance with
R.C. 149.43(C)(1). Because there was no adjudication of the merits of Di Fiore’s
claims and he is able to refile his complaint, the dismissal of his complaint “without
prejudice” is not a final, appealable order.
Di Fiore argues that this court has jurisdiction pursuant to R.C.
2743.75(G)(1) because this is an appeal from “a final order of the court of claims[.]”
However, as discussed above the order here is not final because it is not an
adjudication on the merits and Di Fiore is not prevented from refiling his complaint.
Di Fiore also argues that a dismissal without prejudice is supposed to leave a party
in the same position they were in prior to the filing and, because the Court of Claims
awarded Lyndhurst costs, he is not left in the same position. This argument,
however, is unpersuasive. The award of costs does not change the fact that the Court
of Claims’ judgment did not adjudicate his claims on their merits and he is still able
to refile his complaint. Di Fiore cites no case law to support his argument that the
award of costs somehow changes the disposition of the dismissal to a final
appealable order.
Accordingly, the Court of Claims’ dismissal was not a final,
appealable order and we lack jurisdiction to hear this appeal. See Shutway v. Ohio
Dept. of Rehab. & Corr.,
(10th Dist.) (holding that a complaint
dismissed “without prejudice” by Court of Claims is not a final appealable order, the
court lacked jurisdiction to hear the appeal and the appeal was properly dismissed).
Appeal dismissed.
It is ordered that appellee recover from appellant costs herein taxed.
A certified copy of this entry shall constitute the mandate pursuant to Rule 27
of the Rules of Appellate Procedure.
__________________________
EILEEN A. GALLAGHER, JUDGE
EILEEN T. GALLAGHER, P.J., and
KATHLEEN ANN KEOUGH, J., CONCUR
Official sources: view the source page