Administrative United Kingdom
NB v The Secretary of State for the Home Department
First-tier Tribunal
(Immigration and Asylum Chamber)
Appeal Number: HU/60473/2025
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
Heard at Newport
On 29 October 2026
Before
FIRST-TIER TRIBUNAL JUDGE L Salkeld
Between
NB
(ANONYMITY ORDER MADE)
Appellant
and
THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent
Representation:
For the Appellant: Ms King, Counsel
For the Respondent: Ms Dutton, Home Office Presenting Officer
DECISION AND REASONS
1. This is the decision of the Tribunal in the appeal of the Appellant against the decision of the Respondent made on 9 July 2025.
Anonymity
2. In making this decision I have considered that justice being administered openly and in public is a fundamental tenet of the justice system but it may be qualified by the interests of the parties and family members. I have decided to make an anonymity direction because the importance of facilitating the discharge of the obligations of the United Kingdom under the Refugee Convention outweighs the principles of open justice.
Background
3. The background to the appeal is contained in the documentation on MyHMCTS.
4. A is a national of Bangladesh. She entered the United Kingdom on 11 July 2024 with her husband, H. A entered with leave as a Skilled Worker and H as her dependant.
5. A subsequently claimed asylum. She claims that she cannot safely return to Bangladesh because of H’s actual or perceived political opinion.
6. H claims that he was involved with the student wing of the Awami League during his college years and later became General Secretary of a local Jubo League committee.
7. A and H say that, following the fall of the Awami League government, H was named in two criminal cases, one of which concerns an allegation of murder. They maintain that the allegations against him are false and politically motivated. They also say that members of H’s family have been threatened and that the family property was vandalised. A claims that, as H’s wife, she would be at risk from those interested in him.
8. A initially also relied upon loans obtained from banks in Bangladesh and the consequences of the couple’s inability to make the required repayments. In submissions, however, Ms King accepted that the bank debts did not engage a Refugee Convention reason and did not provide a basis for humanitarian protection.
The Hearing
9. The hearing took place face to face. It was recorded using the Cloud Video Platform. That recording is the record of proceedings and should be consulted in the event of any dispute about what was said at the hearing.
Agreed and Disputed Issues
10. A’s identity and Bangladeshi nationality are accepted.
11. The issues the Tribunal must decide are:
(a) whether A has given a credible account of the material matters relied upon in support of her protection claim;
(b) whether A would face a real risk of persecution or serious harm on return to Bangladesh because of her actual or imputed political opinion arising from H’s claimed political activities and adverse interest in him;
(c) whether A would have access to sufficient protection;
(d) whether A could reasonably relocate within Bangladesh; and
(e) whether A’s removal would breach Article 8 ECHR.
Evidence
12. A and H gave evidence with the assistance of a Bangladeshi Sylheti interpreter. They both adopted their witness statements and were cross-examined. I heard submissions from the representatives and reserved my decision.
Legal Framework
13. To succeed in an appeal on asylum grounds, the Appellant must show a well-founded fear of persecution for a Refugee Convention reason (race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, or political opinion). The burden of proof rests on the appellant. As the asylum claim was made on or after 28 June 2022, section 32 of the 2022 Act applies.
14. Following the guidance in DS (NABA s.32(2)(a); JCK amended) Afghanistan [2026] UKUT 413 (IAC), I must first determine, on the balance of probabilities:
(a) whether the Appellant has a characteristic which could cause her to fear persecution for a Convention reason (or such a characteristic is attributed to her by an actor of persecution); and
(b) whether the Appellant does in fact fear such persecution.
15. If those questions are answered in the affirmative, I must then determine whether there is a reasonable likelihood that:
(a) the Appellant would be persecuted for that Convention reason;
(b) she would not receive sufficient protection; and
(c) she could not safely and reasonably relocate within her country of origin.
16. When answering each of those questions, the evidence must be considered in the round. Section 32 does not require the Tribunal to determine whether each alleged material fact is established on the balance of probabilities.
17. To succeed on an appeal on humanitarian protection grounds the Appellant must not be a refugee; she must show substantial grounds for believing that she would face a real risk of suffering serious harm in her country of origin. The burden of proof rests on the Appellant.
18. In so far as she relies on Article 8 outside the Rules it is for the Appellant to show that Article 8(1) of the ECHR is engaged and if so, it is for the Respondent to show that the decision was in accordance with the law, made in pursuance of a legitimate aim and that it was proportionate to the legitimate aim. The standard of proof is the balance of probabilities. Sections 117A to 117D of the 2002 Act are relevant to any assessment under Article 8 of the ECHR outside the Rules.
19. My approach to assessing credibility comes from KB & AH (credibility-structured approach) Pakistan [2017] UKUT 491 (IAC) where the Upper Tribunal commended consideration of sufficiency of detail, internal consistency, external consistency and plausibility. I consider any documents along with all the evidence in the round. I am also conscious that just because a person has lied about one thing does not mean they have lied about another.
20. Section 8 Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants etc) Act 2004 means that behaviour designed or likely to conceal information, mislead, obstruct or delay consideration of a claim, and claims made after a negative decision has been made or after there was an opportunity to make a claim in a safe country are damaging to credibility.
Findings and Reasons
21. I have considered all the oral and documentary evidence in the round. I refer only to those matters necessary to explain my findings.
Development of the claim
22. At screening, A was asked briefly to explain all the reasons why she could not return to Bangladesh. She referred to money borrowed from banks and local villagers, her inability to repay it, the possibility of proceedings being brought against her, and her fear of arrest. The screening record does not contain any reference to H’s political activity, threats from political opponents, vandalism of the family property or criminal proceedings against H.
23. When asked at her substantive interview why she had not mentioned her political fears at screening, A said that the interpreter had joined the screening interview late. She then said that she had mentioned the political matters but had been told that the interviewer wanted to hear about her own issues and would discuss H’s problems with him.
24. I have considered that explanation. The screening record identifies a telephone interpreter and records the language of the interview as Bangla. It also records the interpreter as present from the stated commencement time. At the substantive interview, A confirmed that the information she had provided at screening was accurate.
25. I bear in mind the guidance in YL (Rely on SEF) China [2004] UKIAT 00145 that a screening interview is intended to establish the general nature of the claim and is not the occasion upon which a claimant is expected to provide a detailed account. I also take account of A’s explanation at her substantive asylum interview that the interpreter joined the screening interview late and that she understood she should concentrate upon matters affecting her personally, while H’s circumstances would be addressed separately with him. I therefore do not treat the omission as determinative.
26. Nevertheless, A was expressly asked to identify all the reasons why she could not return. Her answer identified only the debts and their anticipated consequences. Her explanation at substantive interview does not fully account for the absence of any reference to political risk, particularly as her case is now that she personally fears harm because of H’s political circumstances. The omission is a relevant factor to be considered with the evidence as a whole.
H being a dependant rather than the principal claimant
27. The Respondent considered it adverse that H, rather than A, was said to be the principal target but had not made an independent protection claim. I attach little weight to that matter. H was included as A’s dependant, and A’s evidence was that she acted as the principal applicant because she had entered as the Skilled Worker and H as her dependant. The procedural manner in which the claim was made does not materially assist in determining whether the underlying account is true.
A’s evidence
28. A’s knowledge of H’s political activities was limited. She did not know precisely how he obtained the claimed position, how long he held it or the full extent of his responsibilities. She was also unable to provide detailed evidence about the criminal proceedings.
29. I do not regard this as inherently adverse to A’s credibility. A was not involved in politics, and some of H’s claimed activities predated their marriage. She is not accused in the criminal proceedings.
30. Nor would I expect A to know the evidential basis of a murder allegation which she says is false and in which H maintains he was added as an accused person after they left Bangladesh.
31. A’s limited knowledge nevertheless means that her evidence provides little independent support for H’s political profile or the nature and present status of the proceedings. Those matters depend principally upon H’s evidence and the documents produced.
H’s political involvement
32. H did not claim that he had experienced material adverse interest before he and A left Bangladesh on 11 July 2024. His evidence was that there had previously been political differences, but no significant problems with the authorities or opposition-party members. He said that the political situation appeared to be deteriorating in June or July 2024 and that others advised them to leave because they anticipated danger. The alleged vandalism and material threats occurred after departure. H’s evidence was that the murder case commenced in 2022but that he was added as an accused person after he left Bangladesh.
33. H said that he was involved with the student wing of the Awami League during his college years and subsequently became General Secretary of a local Jubo League committee.
34. H said that local and sub-district leaders consulted members of the community before deciding who would hold the position. He did not describe a formal election. His evidence was that the relevant leaders held a meeting, consulted local people and then appointed him.
35. H said that meetings took place approximately once a month. When asked about his responsibilities, he said that he attended political activities and meetings at which local community matters were discussed. He referred to helping to organise events marking significant dates for the party, offering advice and ideas about how such events should be arranged and seeking to ensure that activities remained within party rules and did not cause conflict or result in unjust conduct towards others.
36. H did not say that he gave speeches, chaired or led meetings, recruited members, made decisions on behalf of the party or exercised authority over others. Although his account was capable of describing participation in local political activity, it remained general. He gave no particular example of an event he had organised, a community matter he had helped to resolve, a decision for which he had been responsible or an occasion on which he had exercised the responsibilities of General Secretary.
37. I take account of Ms King’s submission that H did not claim to be a national, parliamentary or prominent district-level figure. His evidence must be assessed in the context of the modest local role which he claimed. I would not expect a person holding such a position to demonstrate national prominence or provide evidence of sophisticated political responsibilities.
38. Nevertheless, the position claimed was that of General Secretary, rather than simply a party supporter or participant. It was reasonable to expect H to provide a reasonably clear account of the functions he performed in that capacity. His evidence did not adequately distinguish his activities from those of an ordinary local member or supporter.
39. H produced a document which purports to confirm that he held the position claimed. The document is dated 11 July 2021.
40. H said that his brother obtained the document from the local party office and sent it to him as a PDF through WhatsApp. He said that the telephone on which he received it was subsequently damaged and that he changed his telephone number.
41. I accept that this provides a plausible explanation for the absence of the original communication. I also take account of Ms King’s submission that A and H may not have been asked to produce evidence showing how the document was transmitted.
42. However, A and H said that they remain in regular, usually daily, contact with family members in Bangladesh and that H’s brother assisted in obtaining documents for the appeal. It would therefore have been reasonably open to H to obtain evidence from his brother explaining which office he approached, from whom he obtained the document and in what circumstances it was issued.
43. No evidence has been provided from H’s brother, the local Jubo League office or a person who served with H on the committee. Such evidence was reasonably available and would have addressed the disputed position. I take its absence into account in accordance with TK (Burundi) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2009] EWCA Civ 40. I do not treat corroboration as a formal requirement or the absence of such evidence as determinative.
44. I have considered the committee document together with H’s oral evidence and the evidence concerning how it was obtained. Applying Tanveer Ahmed [2002] UKIAT 00439, the question is whether the document may be relied upon when considered in the context of the evidence as a whole. The document provides some support for H’s account. However, its provenance has not been adequately establishedand H did not provide a sufficiently detailed account of the responsibilities he exercised in the position recorded in it.
45. I have also considered the Country Information Note, Bangladesh: Documentation, version 4.0, November 2024. It records the availability of both forged documents and genuine documents containing false information. I do not infer from that general evidence that this document is false. It does, however, reinforce the need to assess the document in the context of its provenance and the other evidence rather than by its appearance alone.
46. Taking the evidence in the round, I accept that H supported the Awami League and participated in political activities at a local level. I am not satisfied that he held the claimed position of General Secretary of the local Jubo League committee. I find that his established profile was that of a local member or supporter, rather than an office-holder or person exercising significant political influence.
The criminal proceedings and supporting documents
47. A relies upon documents said to relate to two criminal cases. The first is identified as GR Case No. 199/22 and concerns an allegation of murder. The documents identify H as accused number 7. The second is identified as GR Case No. 149/24 and identifies him as accused number 19.
48. A also relies upon two reports dated 27 January 2026, said to have been prepared by a lawyer in Bangladesh, concerning those proceedings.
49. H’s evidence was that the murder case commenced in 2022, when the Awami League remained in power, but that he was not originally named as an accused person. He says that his name was added after he and A left Bangladesh and following the fall of the Awami League government.
50. I do not regard H’s limited knowledge of the events underlying the original murder allegation as materially adverse. His case is that he had no involvement in the offence and was later added to existing proceedings for political reasons. In those circumstances, he might reasonably have limited knowledge of the original complaint. I place still less significance upon A’s inability to explain it, as she is not accused in the proceedings.
51. The Country Information Note, Bangladesh: Documentation, version 4.0, November 2024, confirms in Annex A that, following the police investigation, the persons listed in a charge sheet may differ from those identified in the original First Information Report. H’s claim that he was added to existing proceedings at a later stage is therefore not inherently inconsistent with Bangladeshi criminal procedure.
52. I have also considered the December 2024 Country Policy and Information Note, Bangladesh: Political situation, and the substantial body of objective evidence relied on by A. That material records the use of mass criminal complaints following the fall of the Awami League government and concerns that some persons named in proceedings had little or no connection with the alleged offences.
53. The country evidence therefore provides some general support for the plausibility of an Awami League member or supporter being added to criminal proceedings for political reasons. It does not establish that H was added to these particular proceedings for such a reason. That must be determined from the individual evidence.
54. Ms King submitted that the Respondent had not identified any feature on the face of the documents demonstrating that they were false. She relied upon their appearance, layout, stamps and signatures.
55. I accept that the documents have not been shown to be forged. Applying Tanveer Ahmed [2002] UKIAT 00439, however, the relevant question is whether A has established that they can be relied upon when considered in the context of the evidence as a whole.
56. H said that the documents were obtained after his brother attended court and consulted a lawyer. They were subsequently transmitted to H in PDF form.
57. I have already addressed the loss of the original WhatsApp communications, the continuing contact with H’s relatives and absence of evidence from H’s brother. I take those matters into account when assessing the provenance of the criminal case documents and do not repeat the analysis.
58. H said that the lawyer was paid through his brother and that he transferred money to his brother. I place no material adverse weight upon the absence of receipts or transfer records. As Ms King submitted, A and H had not previously been asked to prove those payments and could not reasonably have been expected to anticipate that particular line of questioning.
59. The lawyer’s reports provide some support for H’s account. They identify the proceedings and refer to the potential consequences he may face.
60. However, the reports do not explain clearly:
(a) whether the writer personally inspected the original court files;
(b) how the copies produced in the appeal were obtained;
(c) what checks were undertaken against the relevant court records; or
(d) the present procedural position in each case.
61. I accept that there may be limited substantive action a lawyer can take where the client remains outside Bangladesh. The absence of a bail application, appeal or substantive defence is therefore not adverse to H. It would nevertheless have been reasonable for the lawyer to explain more clearly how the documents were obtained and what steps were taken to establish their present status.
62. The documents were produced with A’s appeal bundle rather than before the refusal decision. The explanation was that H’s brother was young and inexperienced, H’s parents were not continuously residing at the family home and it took time to obtain the material.
63. I accept that those matters may have caused delay. However, the evidence did not provide a clear chronology identifying when H first learned of each case, when his brother was asked to obtain the documents, when the lawyer became involved or when the documents were received.
64. The late production does not establish that the documents are unreliable. It is nevertheless relevant to the weight they carry where their provenance and present status have not been fully explained.
65. Considering the documents cumulatively with the oral evidence and country material, I attach some weight to them. They provide some support for H’s assertion that his name appears in criminal proceedings in Bangladesh.
66. I am not, however, satisfied that the evidence establishes:
(a) the current procedural status of either case;
(b) that an enforceable arrest warrant remains outstanding against H;
(c) that the alleged searches by the authorities amounted to a continuing or nationwide search for H; or
(d) that he was named in either of the criminal proceedings because of his actual or perceived political opinion.
Threats, vandalism and the circumstances of H’s family
67. A and H said that the family property was vandalised in approximately the middle of August 2024. A did not witness the incident and relied upon information provided by H’s relatives. H said that two of those involved were identified as persons associated with opposition parties. A said that the incident had not been reported to the police, whereas H said that it had been reported but that no action was taken. I accept that A may not have known whether a report was made and attach limited weight to that difference in their evidence.
68. No statement has been provided by anyone who witnessed the vandalism, identified those responsible or received the subsequent threats. A and H remain in daily or frequent contact with their relatives and relied upon them to obtain documents for this appeal. Evidence from those relatives was therefore reasonably available and would have addressed matters central to this part of the claim. I take its absence into account in accordance with TK (Burundi), although I do not regard corroboration as a formal requirement.
69. I accept that there may have been an incident affecting the family property during the unrest following August 2024 and that relatives may subsequently have received hostile remarks or threats concerning H. H named two individuals whom he said had been seen by those present and whom he understood to be associated with the BNP, although he did not witness the incident himself and no evidence was provided by those who identified them. I am not satisfied that the evidence establishes the political affiliation of those responsible or the reason why the property was targeted. Nor does it establish a continuing and organised campaign against H’s family.
70. H’s parents continue to use and stay at the family home, although it was said that they sometimes stay with relatives and limit their movements because they are fearful. I recognise that continued residence does not necessarily establish an absence of risk. Nevertheless, they have not experienced any further physical attack, repeated vandalism, arrest or other physical mistreatment since August 2024.
71. A said during her asylum interview that H had also received threatening telephone calls and that messages concerning those calls might be available. No such messages were subsequently produced. That aspect of the account was not developed with any clarity in H’s witness statement or oral evidence. There was limited evidence about when the calls occurred, who made them, what was said or how those responsible were identified. I therefore attach limited weight to the allegation that H received direct telephone threats.
72. A and H also referred to later verbal threats made to H’s father or brother. Those threats concerned what would happen to H if he returned, including a threat said to have been made to H’s brother approximately one month before the hearing. The evidence did not establish that A had herself been sought or named, or that any threat had been directed towards harming her personally.
Bank loans
73. A and H said that they had borrowed money from several banks and that a substantial proportion remained outstanding.
74. Ms King accepted that the debts did not engage a Refugee Convention reason and were not relied upon as giving rise to humanitarian protection. I therefore make no detailed findings about the amount borrowed, the repayments made or the sum outstanding.
75. At its highest, the evidence indicates that the banks may pursue ordinary legal or commercial procedures to recover the debts. Such action would not amount to persecution for a Convention reason or serious harm for the purposes of humanitarian protection.
Section 8
76. The Respondent also relied upon section 8 of the Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc.) Act 2004 because A did not claim asylum immediately upon arrival in the United Kingdom. I attach limited weight to that matter. A and H entered lawfully for the purpose of employment. A’s case is that the political situation materially deteriorated following the fall of the Awami League government in August 2024 and that H was subsequently named in criminal proceedings. A claimed asylum on 10 April 2025, before the date on which the curtailment of her leave was to take effect, although after she had been notified of the proposed curtailment. The timing is a matter I take into account, but it does not materially affect my assessment of the central evidence.
Overall findings concerning H
77. I accept that H supported the Awami League and participated in political activities at a local level. I am not satisfied that he held the claimed position of General Secretary of the local Jubo League committee. His established profile was that of a local member or supporter rather than an office-holder or person exercising significant political influence.
78. I attach some weight to the documents concerning the two criminal cases. They provide some support for H’s assertion that his name appears in criminal proceedings in Bangladesh. I do not find that the documents have been shown to be false.
79. However, for the reasons given, I am not satisfied that the evidence establishes the present status of either case, that H remains subject to an enforceable arrest warrant or nationwide search, or that he was named in either proceeding because of his actual or perceived political opinion.
80. H is not the appellant in this appeal and did not make an independent protection claim. It is unnecessary for me to reach a concluded finding as to whether he would himself face a real risk on return. A must establish that she personally faces a real risk of persecution or serious harm. I address that question below.
Determination of the Issues
Question 1: Does A have a characteristic which could cause her to fear persecution for a Convention reason, or is such a characteristic attributed to her by an actor of persecution?
81. A relies upon imputed political opinion arising from her marriage to H and his association with the Awami League. If she were targeted because of H’s actual or perceived political opinion, the harm feared would be for a Convention reason.
82. I am satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that A’s relationship with H is capable of giving rise to a fear of persecution for reasons of imputed political opinion. I answer the first question affirmatively.
Question 2: Does A in fact fear persecution for that Convention reason?
83. Notwithstanding my reservations about the development of A’s account, which I have addressed above, I accept on the balance of probabilities that she genuinely fears harm arising from H’s actual or perceived political opinion. I answer the second question affirmatively.
Question 3: Is there a reasonable likelihood that A would be persecuted for that Convention reason?
84. In assessing present risk, I have considered the country evidence relied upon by both parties. A relied upon the Country Policy and Information Note, Bangladesh: Political situation, version 1.0, December 2024, together with extensive additional objective evidence, including material published in 2026. The Respondent relied at the hearing upon the more recent Country Policy and Information Note, version 2.0, October 2026, and the report of the June 2026 fact-finding mission. I have considered all of that material, attaching particular weight to the most recent evidence when assessing current risk.
85. It is unnecessary for me to determine whether H would himself face a real risk on return. Even if the matters relied upon established a real risk to H, A must separately establish that any such risk would extend to her.
86. The country evidence records attacks upon homes and property associated with Awami League figures and isolated incidents in which relatives or households were affected. It does not, however, establish a general pattern of non-political spouses or other relatives being persecuted merely because of their relationship with an Awami League member.
87. The individual evidence does not establish that any risk to H would extend to A. She has no political profile of her own, is not named in either criminal proceeding and has not independently attracted adverse interest. H’s parents and brother remain in Bangladesh. Although verbal threats concerning H were allegedly communicated to his father or brother, the evidence does not establish that the relatives were themselves being sought or targeted for physical harm and there has been no further physical attack or vandalism against the family since August 2024.
88. I recognise that A’s position as H’s wife is not identical to that of his parents or brother. Their continuing circumstances are nevertheless relevant to the nature and extent of any continuing adverse interest in H’s family.
89. Having considered the individual and country evidence cumulatively and applying the lower standard of proof, I am not satisfied that A faces a real risk of persecution for reasons of actual or imputed political opinion. I answer the third question negatively.
90. As A has not established a real risk of persecution in her home area, the questions of sufficient protection and internal relocation do not arise.
Humanitarian protection and Articles 2 and 3 ECHR
91. A has not established substantial grounds for believing that she would face a real risk of death or serious harm on return to Bangladesh. She does not qualify for humanitarian protection. For the same reasons, her removal would not breach Articles 2 or 3 ECHR.
Article 8 ECHR
92. The Article 8 claim relies upon the same underlying circumstances as the protection claim. It is also said that A would face very significant obstacles to her integration in Bangladesh.
93. I first consider whether A has established very significant obstacles to her integration for the purposes of Appendix Private Life.
94. I have not accepted that H held the claimed position of General Secretary. Although I attach some weight to the documents concerning the criminal proceedings, their present status, any continuing official interest in H and whether they are politically motivated remain unclear. My finding is that H supported the Awami League and participated in political activity at a local level. The evidence does not establish that he is unable to return to Bangladesh.
95. H has not established an independent entitlement to remain in the United Kingdom. The case was not advanced on the basis that A and H intended to separate. I therefore assess Article 8 on the basis that they would return to Bangladesh together.
96. A lived in Bangladesh until July 2024 and spent her childhood, formative years and early adulthood there. She speaks Bengali, is familiar with the culture and social norms of the country and remains in regular contact with family members there. Her parents, two brothers and sister remain in Bangladesh. H also spent the substantial majority of his life there, and his parents, brother and other relatives remain in the country.
97. A is educated. She studied English to the second year of an honours degree at Moulvibazar Government Women’s College. She also said that she had previously worked for ASA before and after the Covid-19 restrictions. Those matters demonstrate that she has previously participated in education and employment in Bangladesh.
98. A and H remain in regular contact with their families, who have assisted them in obtaining documents for this appeal. H’s parents continue to use the family home. I do not assume that any relative would be obliged to accommodate or maintain them. However, the evidence does not establish that temporary accommodation or practical family assistance would be unavailable while they re-established themselves.
99. I accept that A and H may return with limited financial resources, outstanding debts and no immediate employment. They may experience financial hardship and a lower standard of living than they presently enjoy. However, the evidence does not establish that A would be incapable of seeking employment or that H could provide her with no practical support, that they would be without all family assistance or accommodation, or that A would be unable to participate in life in Bangladesh. Any lawful debt-recovery action would not prevent her integration.
100. Considering those circumstances cumulatively, I am not satisfied that A would face very significant obstacles to her integration in Bangladesh.
101. I have considered Article 8 outside the Immigration Rules. A and H enjoy family life together, but A’s removal would not result in their separation, as I have assessed the case on the basis that they would return together. Their family life can continue in Bangladesh. A’s private life in the United Kingdom was established while her immigration status was precarious. There are no children whose interests require separate consideration.
102. I have regard to section 117B of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002. The maintenance of effective immigration control is in the public interest.No positive weight arises under section 117B from any ability A may have to speak English. The evidence does not establish that she is financially independent.
103. On A’s side of the balance, I take account of her relationship with H, the private life they have established in the United Kingdom, the likely disruption caused by removal, their limited immediate resources and the difficulties they may face in securing employment and meeting their debts. Against those matters, the evidence does not establish that they would be unable to return together, have spent most of their lives in Bangladesh, retain family and cultural ties, and have not established any protection-related or other substantial obstacle to resuming their lives there.
104. The difficulties identified do not outweigh the public interest in immigration control. A’s removal is proportionate and would not breach Article 8 ECHR.
Notice of the Decision
105. The appeal is dismissed on asylum grounds.
106. The appeal is dismissed on humanitarian protection grounds.
107. The appeal is dismissed on human rights grounds.
ANONYMITY ORDER
108. Unless and until the Tribunal, the Upper Tribunal, or, a court orders otherwise, pursuant to rule 13(1)(b) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) Rules 2014, the Appellant and her husband are granted anonymity. No-one shall publish or reveal either directly or indirectly any information, including their names or their addresses, that is likely to lead members of the public to identify them. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.
To the Respondent – Fee Award
I have dismissed the appeal and therefore there can be no fee award.
Signature
Signed Date 2 November 2026
L Salkeld
First-tier Tribunal Judge L Salkeld
Our immigration lawyer assists clients in matters of this kind.
Official sources: view the source page
Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).