Administrative United Kingdom

Ian Brown v Registrar for Approved Driving Instructors

Official source

NCN: [2026] UKFTT 01504 (GRC)

Case Reference: FT/D/2026/0213

First-tier Tribunal

(General Regulatory Chamber)

Transport

Heard by Cloud Video Platform

Heard on: 29 October 2026

Decision given on: 02 November 2026

Before

JUDGE PERI MORNINGTON

TRIBUNAL MEMBER ROANTREE

TRIBUNAL MEMBER FRY

Between

Ian brown

Appellant

and

REGISTRAR FOR APPROVED DRIVING INSTRUCTORS

Respondent

Representation:

For the Appellant: In Person

For the Respondent: Mr Heard

Decision: The appeal is Dismissed. The Registrar’s decision of 27 January 2026 is upheld.

REASONS

1. This appeal concerns a decision of the Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors (“the Registrar”) made on 27 January 2026 to remove the Appellant’s name from the Register of Approved Driving Instructors (the “Register”) on the grounds that the Appellant had ceased to be a fit and proper person to be an Approved Driving Instructor (“ADI”).

2. The proceedings were held by video (CVP). All parties joined remotely. The Tribunal was satisfied that it was fair and just to conduct the hearing in this way.

Background to Appeal

3. The Appellant’s name was first entered in the Register of Approved Driving Instructors (“the Register”) in August 2022. He provided driving tuition to his pupil, the Complainant between approximately August 2024 and July 2025. The Complainant was 17 years old when the tuition began.

4. In August 2025, the Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency (“DVSA”) received a complaint concerning the Appellant’s conduct during that period of tuition. The initial complaint was made by the Complainant’s mother on her behalf. The Complainant subsequently provided a detailed statement describing what she considered to be an increasingly over-familiar and inappropriate relationship between herself and the Appellant.

5. The complaint alleged that the Appellant had hugged the Complainant from the beginning of the instructional relationship and that physical contact continued throughout the period of tuition. The Complainant described the hugs as taking place at the beginning or end of lessons and stated that the contact made her feel awkward and uncomfortable. Her mother stated that both she and the Complainant’s father had witnessed the Appellant hugging their daughter.

6. The Complainant also alleged that the Appellant regularly engaged her in conversations about personal matters unrelated to driving instruction, including her relationships and other aspects of her private life. She said that he referred to her as his favourite pupil, told her that she was special, and asked whether she had missed him between lessons. According to the Complainant, the Appellant’s comments became increasingly intrusive over time. She said that she did not know how to challenge the conduct and generally attempted to ignore it and move on.

7. A further aspect of the complaint concerned visits to McDonald’s, cafés and other food outlets during paid lessons. The Complainant said that only part of some lessons was spent driving because time was used to stop for food, eat and have conversations unrelated to tuition. She also said that the Appellant offered food as a reward for her performance during lessons.

8. The complaint followed a mock driving test on 22 July 2025. The Complainant’s account was that the mock test went poorly, that she became distressed and that the Appellant concluded that she was not ready to take her practical test. The Appellant took over the driving and drove her home. He then cancelled her remaining lesson and withdrew the use of his vehicle for her practical test. The Complainant did not return to the Appellant for any further tuition.

9. The complaint also included an allegation concerning the Appellant’s driving on the journey following the mock test. The Complainant alleged that the Appellant proceeded against a red traffic signal and brought the vehicle into conflict with other traffic. The Appellant denied that this incident occurred. Although that allegation formed part of the material placed before the Registrar, the central regulatory concern related to the Appellant’s maintenance of professional boundaries with a pupil over the course of their instructional relationship.

10. DVSA investigated the complaint. As part of that investigation, the Complainant provided a formal statement and the Appellant was interviewed by a DVSA investigator at Southampton Maybush Driving Test Centre on 10 December 2025. DVSA also sent enquiries to five former pupils of the Appellant, using the contact and instructor details provided when those pupils took their driving tests. One former pupil responded and provided an account supportive of the Appellant. No responses had been received from the other four former pupils by the time the investigation report was prepared.

11. On 29 December 2025, having considered the complaint and the material obtained during the investigation, the Registrar wrote to the Appellant giving notice that consideration was being given to the removal of his name from the Register under section 128(2)(e) of the Road Traffic Act 1988 on the basis that he might no longer be a fit and proper person. The letter summarised the concerns arising from the complaint, referred to the relevant professional standards and invited the Appellant to provide written representations within 28 days before a final decision was made.

12. The Appellant provided written representations dated 13 January 2026. He referred to his professional experience and previous positions of responsibility and maintained that he had always sought to act professionally and in accordance with safeguarding principles. He denied any inappropriate intention and said that his overriding concern had been the Complainant’s safety, emotional state and progress as a learner driver. He also provided testimonials concerning his conduct towards other pupils.

13. In those representations, the Appellant accepted that some physical contact had occurred by way of an arm around the Complainant’s shoulder but described it as minimal, non-intrusive and intended solely as reassurance. He accepted that stops had been made at McDonald’s, explaining that he needed access to toilet facilities because of his medical condition and that the Complainant liked chips. He also accepted that the Complainant had spoken about her relationship, but maintained that he allowed such conversations only because they appeared to reduce her anxiety and improve her concentration. He denied that any suggestive or otherwise inappropriate discussions had taken place.

14. Having considered the complaint, the investigation report and the Appellant’s representations, the Registrar decided that the Appellant had ceased to be a fit and proper person to have his name entered in the Register. Formal notice of that decision was given on 27 January 2026. The letter stated that the decision had been reached because of the Complainant’s complaint, as outlined in the Registrar’s earlier letter of 29 December 2025. The decision was not to take immediate effect, thereby preserving the Appellant’s right of appeal.

15. In the Registrar’s subsequent response to the appeal, the concerns were explained in greater detail. The Registrar considered that the complaint disclosed a pattern of conduct over a substantial period rather than an isolated lapse of judgment. The Registrar relied upon the cumulative effect of the physical contact, personal conversations, expressions of favouritism and social interactions during paid lessons. The Registrar considered that those matters had progressively blurred the distinction between a professional instructional relationship and a personal relationship.

16. The Registrar attached particular significance to the Complainant’s age when the tuition began, the position of trust occupied by an ADI, and her account that she had not known how to challenge behaviour which made her uncomfortable. The Registrar’s position was that the responsibility for maintaining clear professional boundaries rested with the instructor and that a pupil should not be required to identify or challenge inappropriate conduct.

17. The Registrar did not determine that the Appellant had committed a criminal offence or that he had acted with a sexual or other improper purpose. The Registrar’s concern was that, whatever his subjective intentions, the Appellant had repeatedly failed to exercise the professional judgment and boundary awareness expected of an ADI instructing a pupil. The Registrar was also concerned that the Appellant’s representations principally sought to explain or justify the conduct rather than demonstrate sufficient recognition of the safeguarding concerns arising from it.

18. The Appellant appealed against the Registrar’s decision. He maintained that he remained a fit and proper person, had acted with integrity, had prioritised pupil safety and had maintained appropriate professional standards. He disputed the complainant’s characterisation of his conduct and relied upon his experience, previous good record and testimonials from other pupils.

19. By the date of the hearing, the Appellant’s period of registration had expired on 31 August 2026, and he had not made an application for further registration. At the hearing, he told the Tribunal that he had retired in March 2026 and did not intend to return to the Register. He explained that he nevertheless pursued the appeal because he wished to clear his name and establish that he remained a fit and proper person.

The Appeal

20. The Appellant’s grounds of appeal may be summarised as follows:

(a) The Appellant maintains that he remains a fit and proper person to be entered in the Register of Approved Driving Instructors.

(b) He contends that, throughout his professional career, he has acted with integrity, maintained appropriate professional boundaries and complied with safeguarding principles.

(c) He states that he understands the duty of care owed to pupils and the degree of trust placed in an Approved Driving Instructor, and that pupils’ safety, wellbeing and best interests have been his primary considerations.

(d) He submits that his approach to driving tuition has been structured, learner-centred and risk-managed, with lessons adapted to pupils’ emotional readiness, confidence and driving competence.

(e) He maintains that he has conducted himself professionally both during and outside lessons and has exercised the personal integrity and sound judgment expected of a DVSA-registered instructor.

(f) He relies upon his commitment to continuing professional development and reflective practice, including reviewing his instructional methods and professional conduct to ensure compliance with DVSA standards.

(g) He relies upon his professional history and conduct and contends that he has maintained high instructional standards.

(h) Accordingly, he submits that the Registrar’s decision was unjustified and that his name should remain on the Register as a fit and proper person to continue as an Approved Driving Instructor.

21. The Registrar’s Statement of Case dated 22 June 2026 resists the appeal. The Registrar maintains that the Appellant overstepped the professional boundary between a pupil and instructor, that he has ceased to be a fit and proper person, and that the Appellant’s name should be removed from the Register.

The relevant law

22. Conditions for entry and retention on the Register require the applicant to be and continue to be a “fit and proper person” to have his name on the Register – see sections 125(3) and 127(3)(e) of the Road Traffic Act 1988 (the “Act”).

23. The Registrar can remove a person’s name from the Register if they have ceased to be a fit and proper person to have their name on the Register (section 128(2)(e) of the Act). The Registrar may take the view that a person no longer meets this requirement where there has been a change in circumstances. The Registrar has the burden of showing that a person does not meet the statutory requirement to be a fit and proper person, and the standard of proof is the balance of probabilities.

24. The powers of the Tribunal in determining this appeal are set out in section 131 of the Act. The Tribunal may make such order as it thinks fit (section 131(3)). The Tribunal exercises a full merits jurisdiction and takes a fresh decision on the evidence available to it, giving appropriate weight to the Registrar’s decision as the person tasked by Parliament with making such decisions (in accordance with R. (Hope and Glory Public House Ltd) v City of Westminster Magistrates Court & Ors [2011] EWCA Civ 31).

25. In Harris v Registrar of Approved Driving Instructors [2010] EWCA Civ 808, the Court of Appeal described the “fit and proper person” condition as follows: “..the condition is not simply that the applicant is a fit and proper person to be a driving instructor, it is that he is a fit and proper person to have his name entered in the register. Registration carries with it an official seal of approval…It seems to me that the maintenance of public confidence in the register is important. For that purpose, the Registrar must be in a position to carry out his function of scrutiny effectively, including consideration of the implications of any convictions of an applicant or a registered ADI. This is why there are stringent disclosure requirements.” (paragraph 30).

26. The expression “fit and proper person” is not exhaustively defined in the Act. It calls for a broad assessment of the person’s character, conduct, integrity and judgment in the context of the responsibilities of an Approved Driving Instructor and the position of trust which registration entails. The assessment is concerned with present suitability, the protection of pupils and the maintenance of public confidence in the Register. It does not require proof of criminal conduct or an improper motive.

27. In making that assessment, the Tribunal may have regard to the standards contained in the ADI Register Guide and the ADI Code of Practice. Those documents do not create independent statutory grounds for removal, but they provide relevant evidence of the professional standards reasonably expected of a registered instructor. Those standards include maintaining appropriate professional boundaries, avoiding inappropriate physical contact, refraining from becoming improperly involved in a pupil’s personal affairs and avoiding circumstances which might reasonably be perceived as inappropriate.

28. The evidence must be assessed cumulatively and in its proper context. Individual incidents which might be capable of an innocent explanation when considered separately may nevertheless demonstrate poor professional judgment or a failure to maintain appropriate boundaries when considered as part of a pattern of conduct. The absence of an improper motive and the presence of good intentions are relevant to that assessment, but they are not determinative.

The evidence

29. The Tribunal has considered a bundle of evidence. This includes evidence of the original submissions provided to the Registrar by the Appellant. The Tribunal heard submissions from the Appellant and the representative for the Registrar.

The Appellant's Evidence and Submissions

30. The Appellant denied acting inappropriately or with any improper intention. He disputed a number of the specific allegations made by the Complainant but accepted that there had been some physical contact, by way of placing a reassuring arm around her shoulders; that he had taken her to McDonald’s and other food outlets during lessons; and that they had discussed aspects of her personal life. He maintained that each of those matters had an innocent explanation and arose from his attempts to reassure and support a pupil whom he considered to be particularly anxious and nervous about driving.

31. In relation to physical contact, the Appellant denied giving the Complainant the form of frontal embrace which she described. He accepted that he had placed an arm around her shoulders, but said that this was a brief gesture of reassurance, usually made outside her home or on the driveway at the conclusion of a lesson. He maintained that the contact took place openly and that he regularly spoke to the Complainant’s parents when collecting or returning her. He submitted that, had her parents considered his conduct inappropriate, they had opportunities to raise the matter with him but had not done so.

32. The Appellant explained that the Complainant was extremely anxious during lessons and would at times remain physically shaking after driving. He said that his own granddaughter had experienced mental-health difficulties and that this experience had assisted him in recognising and responding to the Complainant’s anxiety. He regarded his conduct as comparable to the reassurance a grandparent might provide to a grandchild. He maintained that he had been attempting to support the Complainant and had not intended to establish an inappropriate or overly personal relationship with her.

33. In relation to the stops at food outlets, the Appellant said that he had type 2 diabetes and sometimes needed to use toilet facilities during lessons. He said that he commonly took pupils to coffee shops or food outlets and that any instructional time lost as a result was made up later. He maintained that the visits took place in public and were intended to provide an anxious pupil with a brief opportunity to relax away from the vehicle. He accepted that he had bought the Complainant chips and that, on an early occasion, he had offered to buy her an ice cream. He denied that the provision of food was intended to reward or influence her. The Appellant confirmed that he maintained this practice with other students up until his retirement.

34. The Appellant accepted that he and the Complainant had discussed her boyfriend and other aspects of her personal life. He said that the Complainant liked to talk and that allowing her to do so helped to reduce her anxiety and maintain a calm learning environment. He denied initiating inappropriate conversations and denied making a number of the more personal comments attributed to him. His position was that he listened and responded to matters raised by the Complainant as part of his efforts to put her at ease.

35. In respect of the mock test, the Appellant said that the Complainant had been crying and shaking, had failed to make adequate observations and had concentrated upon the steering wheel rather than her surroundings. He described an incident in which she suddenly mounted a kerb, requiring him to use the dual controls to prevent the vehicle from continuing towards a hedge. He concluded that it was unsafe for her to continue driving and that she could not be made ready for her practical test within the remaining period. He advised her to cancel the test within the applicable period so that she could obtain a refund. He then drove her home and advised her to take a break before returning to tuition. He denied the allegation concerning his own driving on that journey.

36. The Appellant told the Tribunal that, although he had undertaken his training and qualified as an Approved Driving Instructor in 2022, he had not previously seen or read the ADI Code of Conduct. He accepted that he had signed the documentation required for entry onto the Register without reading the Code and said, in substance, that he had signed what was required in order to progress his application. Having now read the Code, he accepted that its provisions required an instructor to avoid inappropriate physical contact, becoming involved in a pupil’s personal affairs and conduct which might be perceived as inappropriate.

37. When those provisions were put to him during the hearing, the Appellant accepted that, viewed against the standards set out in the Code, he could understand the Registrar’s concerns and why the Registrar had taken action. He ultimately accepted that the Registrar had been right to regard his conduct as crossing professional boundaries. However, he continued to maintain that he had acted with good intentions, without any improper motive, and in what he believed at the time to be the Complainant’s best interests.

38. The Appellant relied upon his previous professional experience, his history as an instructor and the positive testimonials provided by other pupils. He submitted that the complaint was not representative of his conduct towards pupils generally. He maintained that he had always sought to prioritise safety and that there had been no previous complaint of a similar nature.

39. The Appellant told the Tribunal that he had retired from driving instruction and did not intend to seek re-entry onto the Register. He nevertheless wished to pursue the appeal because he considered it important to clear his name and establish that he remained a fit and proper person. He asked the Tribunal to take account of his intentions, his previous good record and his acceptance at the hearing that, having now read the Code, he understood why his conduct had caused regulatory concern.

The Respondent's Submissions

40. On behalf of the Respondent, Mr Heard submitted that the appeal should be dismissed and the Registrar’s decision upheld. He submitted that the issue was not whether the Appellant had acted with a sexual or otherwise improper motive, but whether his conduct demonstrated the professional judgment and maintenance of boundaries required of an Approved Driving Instructor. The Respondent did not invite the Tribunal to find that the Appellant had committed a criminal offence or had deliberately sought to exploit the Complainant.

41. Mr Heard submitted that Approved Driving Instructors occupy a position of trust and may provide tuition to young or otherwise vulnerable pupils in circumstances where the instructor and pupil are alone together for extended periods. The responsibility for establishing and maintaining clear professional boundaries rested with the Appellant as the registered professional. It was not incumbent upon the Complainant, who was 17 years old when the tuition began, to identify the conduct as inappropriate or to challenge it at the time.

42. The Respondent relied upon the Complainant’s account that the Appellant’s conduct had become increasingly over-familiar during the course of the instructional relationship. That account included allegations of repeated physical contact, conversations concerning her private life and relationships, expressions of favouritism, and visits to McDonald’s and other food outlets during paid lessons. Mr Heard submitted that those matters should be considered cumulatively and in the context of an instructional relationship continuing over a substantial period.

43. Mr Heard acknowledged that the Appellant disputed a number of the Complainant’s specific allegations. However, he submitted that the Tribunal did not need to resolve every disputed detail in order to determine the appeal. Even on the Appellant’s own account, he had placed an arm around the shoulders of a teenage pupil, discussed her boyfriend and personal life, provided emotional support which he compared to that of a grandparent, and taken her to food outlets during lessons. The Respondent submitted that those admissions were sufficient to establish that the relationship had moved beyond the appropriate boundaries of professional driving instruction.

44. In relation to the physical contact, Mr Heard submitted that it was not an acceptable response for the Appellant to say that it had occurred openly, outside the Complainant’s home or in circumstances where her parents might have observed it. Nor did the absence of an earlier complaint establish that the contact was appropriate. The relevant issue was whether a registered instructor should have initiated or engaged in such contact with a pupil, having regard to the professional standards applicable to Approved Driving Instructors.

45. The Respondent did not dispute that the Appellant may have intended to reassure the Complainant or that she experienced anxiety during driving lessons. Mr Heard submitted, however, that an instructor’s good intentions did not remove the need to maintain professional boundaries.

46. In respect of the stops at McDonald’s and other food outlets, the Respondent’s concern arose from the frequency and nature of the stops, the purchase of food for the Complainant and the extent to which the visits formed part of the more personal relationship that had developed. The visits were therefore relevant not merely as a question of lost lesson time but as part of the wider pattern of over-familiarity.

47. Similarly, the Respondent accepted that ordinary conversation between an instructor and pupil was both inevitable and capable of assisting a nervous learner. Mr Heard submitted, however, that the Appellant had gone beyond general conversation intended to establish rapport. By engaging with the Complainant about her boyfriend and other aspects of her personal life, and by assuming a wider supportive role, the Appellant had become involved in matters outside the proper scope of the professional relationship.

48. Mr Heard relied upon the ADI Code of Conduct as setting out the standards reasonably expected of a registered instructor. In particular, he referred to the requirements concerning appropriate physical contact, involvement in clients’ personal affairs and the avoidance of situations or conduct which might reasonably be perceived as inappropriate. He submitted that the Code was directly relevant to the assessment of whether the Appellant remained a fit and proper person to have his name entered in the Register.

49. The Respondent highlighted that the Appellant continued principally to explain and justify his conduct by reference to the Complainant’s anxiety, his good intentions, his medical needs and the absence of any objection from her parents. The Respondent submitted that the Appellant had not fully recognised that maintaining appropriate boundaries was his responsibility, irrespective of his intentions or whether the Complainant or her parents complained at the time.

50. Mr Heard submitted that the testimonials from other pupils and the absence of previous complaints were relevant but not determinative. Positive experiences reported by other pupils did not disprove the Complainant’s account or render the conduct admitted by the Appellant appropriate. The statutory question concerned the Appellant’s present fitness and propriety in light of all the evidence, rather than whether similar concerns had previously been raised.

51. Taking the evidence in the round, the Respondent submitted that the Appellant’s conduct demonstrated an insufficient appreciation of the professional boundaries required of an Approved Driving Instructor. Registration carried an official assurance of suitability and trustworthiness. The cumulative conduct, together with the Appellant’s limited insight into its inappropriateness, justified the Registrar’s conclusion that he had ceased to be a fit and proper person to remain on the Register. The Respondent accordingly invited the Tribunal to dismiss the appeal.

Conclusions

52. If an ADI’s name is allowed to remain on the Register when the ADI has demonstrated conduct relevant to fitness and propriety, this is liable to diminish the standing of the Register and undermine public confidence in it. This includes conduct concerning the maintenance of appropriate professional boundaries with pupils.

53. ADIs are held to a high standard of personal and professional conduct. The public is entitled to expect that those whose names appear on the Register will maintain a properly professional instructor-pupil relationship, particularly where the pupil is young or otherwise vulnerable. The Approved Driving Instructor Code of Practice provides that driver trainers will be professional, comply with the law, keep clients safe and treat them with respect. It also requires instructors to avoid inappropriate physical contact, avoid becoming involved in a client’s personal affairs and avoid circumstances and situations which are, or could be perceived to be, of an inappropriate nature.

54. Teaching people of all ages to drive safely, carefully and competently is a professional vocation requiring a significant degree of responsibility. Driving instruction commonly takes place in a confined environment, with the instructor and pupil alone together for extended periods. It should therefore be entrusted only to those who demonstrate high personal and professional standards, sound judgment and a proper understanding of the boundaries required by the instructor-pupil relationship.

55. The Registrar has the duty of ensuring that only those of appropriate standing remain on the Register and that registered instructors understand and comply with their professional responsibilities. It is not sufficient for an instructor merely to possess the necessary instructional competence. The instructor must also demonstrate the integrity, judgment and awareness of professional boundaries required of a person whose registration carries an official assurance of suitability.

56. We have considered the entirety of the evidence and the parties’ submissions. We do not consider it necessary to resolve every disputed detail of the Complainant’s account. In particular, we make no finding that the Appellant acted with a sexual or otherwise improper motive. We accept that he believed he was attempting to reassure and support a pupil whom he regarded as particularly anxious. However, the absence of an improper motive does not determine whether he remained a fit and proper person to have his name entered in the Register.

57. Much of the material conduct was admitted by the Appellant. He accepted that he had placed an arm around the Complainant’s shoulders as a gesture of reassurance; that he had taken her to McDonald’s and other food outlets during lessons; that he had bought food for her; and that he had discussed her boyfriend and aspects of her personal life. He also accepted that he had assumed a wider supportive role, which he compared to the reassurance a grandparent might provide to a grandchild.

58. We have considered each aspect of the Appellant’s conduct both separately and cumulatively. We accept that ordinary social conversation is a natural part of driving tuition and may assist an anxious pupil. We also accept that an instructor may need to stop during a lesson for legitimate reasons and that a brief stop at a public place is not, of itself, improper. Similarly, not every instance of physical contact will necessarily establish that an instructor is not fit and proper. The concern in this appeal arises from the cumulative effect of the conduct and the extent to which the Appellant allowed the relationship to move beyond the proper limits of driving instruction.

59. In our judgment, the Appellant became too familiar with the Complainant and involved himself in her personal affairs to an inappropriate extent. His role was to teach the Complainant to drive safely and competently. It was not his role to act as her counsellor, confidant or substitute grandparent. If he considered that the Complainant’s anxiety required support beyond the reassurance ordinarily appropriate during a driving lesson, he could have raised the matter with her parents or encouraged her to seek support from an appropriate source. His good intentions did not relieve him of the responsibility to maintain clear professional boundaries.

60. The Appellant relied upon the fact that the physical contact took place openly, sometimes outside the Complainant’s home, and that her parents had not raised any concern with him at the time. We do not consider those matters to answer the regulatory concern. The responsibility for recognising and maintaining appropriate boundaries rested with the Appellant as the registered professional. It was not for the Complainant or her parents to define those boundaries for him. Nor does an absence of objection at the time establish that the conduct was appropriate.

61. We have also considered the Complainant’s age. She was 17 when the period of tuition began. Instructors may teach young people who are inexperienced, anxious and dependent upon the instructor’s professional judgment. It is therefore particularly important that an instructor avoids conduct which may blur the nature of the professional relationship or place a young pupil in a position in which the pupil may be uncertain how to respond.

62. The Code of Practice makes clear the standards of behaviour required. The Appellant’s admitted conduct was inconsistent with the provisions requiring instructors to avoid inappropriate physical contact, refrain from becoming involved in clients’ personal affairs, and avoid circumstances which are or could reasonably be perceived as inappropriate. Although the Code does not provide a freestanding statutory ground for removal, it is important evidence of the professional standards reasonably expected of an ADI.

63. Of particular concern is the Appellant’s evidence that, despite having undertaken his training and qualified as an ADI in 2022, he had not previously seen or read the Code of Practice. He accepted that he had signed the documentation required for registration without familiarising himself with the Code. An ADI is responsible for understanding the standards governing the profession. The Appellant’s failure to read the Code does not excuse his conduct. Rather, it demonstrates an inadequate appreciation of the responsibilities associated with registration.

64. We acknowledge that, having read the Code by the date of the hearing, the Appellant accepted that the Registrar was right to identify his conduct as crossing professional boundaries and to take action. That represented some development in his understanding and we have taken it into account. We also accept that the Appellant had begun to reflect upon matters by the time he gave evidence before us.

65. Nevertheless, we find that his insight remained limited. The Appellant continued to explain his conduct principally by reference to his good intentions, the Complainant’s anxiety, his wish to support her, his medical need to use toilet facilities and the fact that the Complainant’s parents had not objected. Those explanations did not adequately recognise that it was his responsibility to maintain the boundary, regardless of his intentions and regardless of whether the Complainant or her parents complained at the time.

66. We have considered the allegation concerning the Appellant’s driving after the mock test and his account of the circumstances in which he concluded that the Complainant was not ready to take her practical test. It is unnecessary for us to resolve the disputed allegation concerning the traffic signal. Even if that allegation is left out of account, the admitted conduct and the conclusions we have reached about professional boundaries provide a sufficient basis upon which to determine the appeal.

67. We have also considered the testimonials concerning the Appellant, his previous professional experience and the absence of any earlier complaint of a similar nature. Those matters are relevant and we have given them appropriate weight. However, positive experiences reported by other pupils do not establish that the conduct in issue was appropriate. Nor do they outweigh the cumulative significance of the boundary failures established in this case.

68. We do not find that the Appellant deliberately sought to exploit the Complainant or intended to cause her harm. However, the fit and proper person test is not confined to cases involving dishonesty, criminality, sexual motivation or deliberate misconduct. The test also encompasses professional judgment, safeguarding awareness, respect for appropriate boundaries and an instructor’s appreciation of the responsibilities associated with registration.

69. We find that public confidence in the Register would be undermined if an instructor who had behaved in this manner, and who demonstrated only limited insight into why the conduct was inappropriate, were regarded as continuing to satisfy the statutory requirement. The Appellant’s conduct was incompatible with the standards reasonably expected of an Approved Driving Instructor.

70. The fact that the Appellant has now retired from driving instruction and does not presently intend to seek re-entry onto the Register does not determine this appeal. The Tribunal must decide whether, on the evidence available at the date of the hearing, the Appellant satisfies the statutory requirement to be a fit and proper person to have his name entered in the Register. His stated future intentions do not remove the need to determine that question.

71. We have considered all of the arguments advanced by the Appellant, including his good intentions, his previous record, his professional experience, the testimonials submitted on his behalf and the developing insight demonstrated at the hearing. We do not consider that those matters are sufficient to outweigh the seriousness and cumulative effect of his failure to maintain appropriate professional boundaries.

72. We therefore find, on the balance of probabilities, that the Appellant does not currently meet the statutory requirement to be a fit and proper person to have his name entered in the Register. In all the circumstances, we conclude that the Registrar’s decision to remove the Appellant’s name from the Register was correct. The appeal is dismissed.

Signed: Judge Peri Mornington Dated: 29 October 2026

At Kohen Avocats, our administrative lawyer in Paris can review your situation.


Open Justice Licence (The National Archives).

Neighbouring decisions

Preliminary case review

Send your documents. Receive an analysis.

Send us the documents in your case. Hassan KOHEN reviews them personally and sends you a first written analysis of your situation within 24 working hours.

  • Written analysis by the lawyer, €80 incl. VAT
  • Personal reply within 24 working hours
  • 100% confidential, legal professional privilege guaranteed
  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
80 €incl. VAT

Preliminary review of your case. Review of your documents and a first written analysis by Hassan KOHEN within 24 working hours. Payment is made online after this form is submitted.

  • Up to 1 GB of documents in total, folders and sub-folders accepted
  • Secure payment, no card details stored
  • Terms and fee agreement

Click or drag your files here
All formats accepted (PDF, Word, images, etc.)

Sending...

Payment constitutes a request for immediate performance of your analysis. Your data is used solely to process your request.
Terms · Privacy policy.

IA juridique gratuite

Une question de droit ? Demandez à Judith.

Judith cherche dans les codes, la Constitution, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme et les décisions des juges, puis vous montre les textes et les passages d’arrêts qui pourraient répondre à votre question, avec leur source officielle. Gratuite, sans compte, elle ne rédige rien à votre place. Découvrir Judith, l’IA juridique gratuite du cabinet.

Trois recherches par jour, sans compte. Votre question est enregistrée et relue par le cabinet pour améliorer l’outil : n’y mettez ni nom ni information sensible.